Photodynamic Therapy for Cancer: What's Past is Prologue

Thomas J Dougherty from Roswell Park Cancer Center played a major role in the progress of photodynamic therapy (PDT) from a laboratory science into a real-world clinical therapy to treat patients with cancer. Nevertheless over the succeeding 45 years, it is fair to say that the overall progress of clinical PDT for cancer has been somewhat disappointing. The goal of this perspective article is to summarize some of the clinical trials run by various companies using photosensitizers with different structures that have been conducted for different types of cancer. While some have been successful, others have failed, and several are now ongoing. I will attempt to touch on some factors, which have influenced this checkered history and look forward to the future of clinical PDT for cancer.     

Scavenger-receptor targeted photodynamic therapy

Covalent conjugation of a photosensitizer to a ligand that specifically recognized and internalized by a cell-surface receptor may be a way of improving the selectivity of photodynamic therapy (PDT). The class A Type-I scavenger receptor of macrophages, which among other ligands recognizes maleylated serum albumin and has a high capacity is a good candidate for testing this approach. Chlorin(e6) was covalently attached to bovine serum albumin to give conjugates with molar substitution ratios of 1:1 and 3:1 (dye to protein), and these conjugates could then be further modified by maleylation. A novel way of purifying the conjugates by acetone precipitation was developed in order to remove traces of unbound dye that could not be accomplished by size-exclusion chromatography. Conjugates were characterized by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and thin-layer chromatography. Photosensitizer uptake was measured by target J774 murine macrophage-like cells and nontarget OVCAR-5 human ovarian cancer cells, and phototoxicity was examined after illumination by a 660 nm diode laser by a tetrazolium assay. All of the purified conjugates were taken up by and after illumination killed J774 cells while there was only small uptake and no phototoxicity toward OVCAR-5 cells. The higher dye:protein ratio and maleylation of the conjugates both produced higher uptakes and lower survival ratios in J774 cells. The uptake and phototoxicity by J774 cells were decreased after incubation at 4 degrees C demonstrating internalization, and confocal microscopy with organelle-specific green fluorescent probes showed largely lysosomal localization. Uptake and phototoxicity by J774 cells could both be competed by addition of the scavenger receptor ligand maleylated albumin. These data show that scavenger receptor-targeted PDT gives a high degree of specificity toward macrophages and may have applications in the treatment of tumors and atherosclerosis.     

Supramolecular circular helicates formed by destabilisation of supramolecular dimers

The effect of changes in the angles at the connection points of linear/circular helicates is explored as a route to control the nuclearity and architecture of metallo-supramolecular arrays. This effect is probed by changing the geometry of the metal centre used to assemble bis-pyridylimine ligands that contain a 1,3-bis(aminomethyl) benzene spacer group. Tetrahedral metal ions favour linear dimers, whereas octahedral nickel(II) predominantly gives a triangular circular helicate. Five-coordinate copper(II) falls in the middle of these extremes and results in the formation of solvent-dependent mixtures of dimer and trimer. The trinuclear, triangular, circular helicate structures, which result from coordination to copper(II) and nickel(II), are structurally characterised by X-ray crystallography and reveal that the units can aggregate into hexagonal arrays that contain anion-filled tube-like channels in the solid state.     

Antimicrobial photodynamic therapy and photodynamic inactivation, or killing bugs with dyes and light--a symposium-in-print

In antimicrobial photodynamic therapy, the photosensitizer (PS) in its ground singlet state absorbs light to give the excited singlet state that can transition to the long-lived triplet state. This PS triplet may undergo energy transfer (Type 2) or electron transfer (Type 1) to oxygen to form reactive oxygen species (singlet oxygen and/or hydroxyl radicals) that can kill both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria and fungi. Infections in animal models can also be treated.     

Solvable Groups Satisfying the Two-Prime Hypothesis II

In this paper, we consider solvable groups that satisfy the two-prime hypothesis. We prove that if G is such a group and G has no nonabelian nilpotent quotients, then |cd G|?≤?462,515. Combining this result with the result from part I, we deduce that if G is any such group, then the same bound holds.     

The Photosensitizing Efficacy of Micelles Containing a Porphyrinic Photosensitizer and KI against Resistant Melanoma Cells

Photodynamic therapy (PDT) is a promising alternative to overcome the resistance of melanoma to conventional therapies. Currently applied photosensitizers (PS) are often based on tetrapyrrolic macrocycles like porphyrins. Unfortunately, in some cases the use of this type of derivative is limited due to their poor solubility in the biological environment. Feasible approaches to surpass this drawback are based on lipid formulations. Besides that, and inspired in the efficacy of potassium iodide (KI) for antimicrobial photodynamic therapy (aPDT), the combined effect of singlet oxygen (¹O₂) with KI was assessed in this work, as an alternative strategy to potentiate the effect of PDT against resistant melanoma cells.