Deviations from linearity in statistical evaluation of linearity in assay validation

Linearity and linear range are the key evaluations of the accuracy in assay validation. The average deviation from linearity (ADL) and the sum of squares of deviations from linearity (SSDL) have been proposed for assessment of the linearity. However, both ADL and SSDL do no consider the variability of the assay for evaluation of linearity. Therefore, we proposed the coefficient of variation of deviations from linearity (CVDL) as an alternative measure for the linearity assessment. For the inference of evaluation of linearity, we proposed testing procedures based on generalized pivotal quantities (GPQ) of ADL and CVDL for evaluation of linearity. The simulation studies were conducted to empirically investigate the size and power between the three methods. The simulation results show that all three methods adequately control size. However, the ADL method is uniformly more powerful than the other two methods. A numeric example illustrates the proposed methods. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Practical uses of proficiency testing as valuable tools for validation and performance assessment in environmental analysis

Besides their role as an external quality control tool, PT results or samples could be used as an alternative to fulfil some of the quality assurance requirements such as analytical precision, uncertainty assessment, and internal quality control. This additional use of proficiency testing could help laboratories to reduce the financial impact of their quality assurance process. The purpose of this paper is to highlight some practical uses of PT results or samples in the environmental analytical field, which have been implemented at ISSeP (Institut Scientifique de Service Public), either for method validation or for internal quality control.Presented at the Eurachem PT Workshop September 2005, Portorož, Slovenia     

Method validation for assay determination of cannabidiol isolates

The speed at which regulations have changed in the cannabis marketplace has increased the pressure for accurate, easy, and efficient analytical methodology. Purified isolates are used to formulate a variety of consumer products such as topicals, edibles, and beverages. Accuracy of the quantitative cannabinoid content of the isolates used in preparation of these products is directly dependent upon the reliability of the analytical methodology used for characterization. An inaccurate quantitative assay value does not only pose health, safety, and ethical concerns for consumers, it can generate a potential financial loss for manufacturers marketing isolates based upon purity. The aim of this work is to describe the validation of a rapid and reliable reversed-phase liquid chromatographic method coupled with UV detection for quantitative determination of Cannabidiol (CBD) purified isolate. Accuracy, precision, specificity, linearity, robustness and range of the analytical method were determined according to assay method requirements specified in the International Conference for Harmonization (ICH) Q2(R1), “Validation of Analytical Procedures: Test and Methodology” for quantitative evaluation of the active moiety in samples of drug substance by liquid chromatography. Additionally, the feasibility of manufacturer prepared DEA-exempt CBD reference standard solutions formulated at 1.0?mg/mL was explored for the quantification of CBD isolate.     

Accelerated ratcheting testing of polycarbonate using the time-temperature-stress equivalence method

The long-term performance of polymers under cyclic loading is important for safety assessments in engineering applications. The deformation process under the cyclic loading can be accelerated through use of temperature and stress. As for asymmetric cyclic loading, so called ratcheting, a time-temperature-stress (TTS) equivalence method in which all the parameters have clear physical meanings and can be determined experimentally, was proposed to predict the long-term cyclic loading behavior for polycarbonate using short-term data. Taking into consideration the effects of both the mean stress and the stress amplitude, the ratcheting compliance was defined and its evolution function was also provided. Next, the TTS equivalence method was validated using the long-term ratcheting test results for the polycarbonate. Time, temperature, and stress do show equivalent effects on long-term ratcheting of polycarbonate. Using the proposed method, time and cost can be dramatically saved for the assessment of the long-term cyclic loading performance of polycarbonate.     

Developmental validation of the AGCU 21+1 STR kit: A novel multiplex assay for forensic application

In this study, we describe the developmental validation assay performed on a novel designed STR multiplex system, AGCU 21+1 STR kit. This kit contains a sex‐determining locus amelogenin and 21 noncombined DNA index system STR loci, that are, D6S474, D12ATA63, D22S1045, D10S1248, D1S1677, D11S4463, D1S1627, D3S4529, D2S441, D6S1017, D4S2408, D19S433, D17S1301, D1GATA113, D18S853, D20S482, D14S1434, D9S1122, D2S1776, D10S1435, and D5S2500. The 21+1 kit was validated by a series of tests including optimized PCR conditions, sensitivity, precision and accuracy, stutter ratio, DNA mixture, inhibitors, and species specificity according to the revised validation guidelines issued by the Scientific Working Group on DNA Analysis Methods (SWGDAM). Our results in this study show that the kit is a useful tool for forensic application.     

Development and validation of a sequential-injection method with chemiluminescence detection for the high throughput assay of the total antioxidant capacity of wines

This work reports a sequential-injection analysis (SIA) method with chemiluminescence (CL) detection for the rapid assay of the total antioxidant capacity (TAC) in wines. The method exploited the Co(II)-catalysed CL reaction of luminol with hydrogen peroxide in alkaline medium. Zones of sample, hydrogen peroxide, catalyst (Co(II) solution) and alkaline luminol were sequentially aspirated into the holding coil of the SIA manifold. Then, the flow was reversed and the stacked zones were directed to the CL detector. As the zones overlapped, antioxidants in the samples scavenged a portion of hydrogen peroxide and the decrease in the CL intensity was monitored and related to the TAC. The chemical and geometric conditions were studied and the method was validated in terms of linearity, accuracy (trueness and precision), matrix effects, signal additivity and robustness. The reproducibility of the method (expressed as the between-days % relative standard deviation) was between 2.5 and 3.4% and the trueness (expressed as the % recovery in wines spiked with gallic acid) was in the range 96.7-97.3%. The sampling frequency was 60 samples h⁻¹. The proposed SIA-CL method was compared with the DPPH method and the Folin-Ciocalteau (FC) method for the analysis of 25 wine samples.     

Optimisation and validation of a generic method for the LC assay of six corticosteroids and salicylic acid in dermopharmaceutical forms

Summary A generic method was developed for the liquid chromatographic (LC) assay of six corticosteraids and salicylic acid in different dermatological formulations containing methylparaben and propylparaben or sorbic acid as preservatives. An adequate separation was obtained using octadecylsilica as stationary phase and a mixture of acetonitrile (MeCN) and 25 mM phosphate buffer of pH 3.5 as mobile phase. Segmented gradient elution was applied from 30 to 45% of MeCN in 9.9 minutes, then from 45 to 96% in 19.0 minutes. UV detection was performed at 240 nm. The method was validated. Very good results were obtained with respect to linearity, selectivity, precision and accuracy.     

Method comparison on confidence interval construction for the slope in a linear measurement model with heteroscedastic errors

In analytical chemistry, the evaluation on performance accuracy of an analytical method is an important issue. When an adjusted or new method (test method) is developed, the linear measurement error model is commonly used to compare it with another reference method. For this routine practice, the measurements on the reference method can be placed on the x‐axis, whereas those of the test method on the y‐axis, then the slope of this linear relationship indicates the agreement between them and also the performance of the test method. Under the assumption that both variables are subject to heteroscedastic measurement errors, a novel approach based on the concepts of a generalized pivotal quantity (GPQ) is proposed to construct confidence intervals for the slope. Its performance is compared with two maximum likelihood estimation (MLE)‐based approaches through simulation studies. It is shown that the proposed GPQ‐based approach is capable of maintaining the empirical coverage probabilities close to the nominal level and yielding reasonable expected lengths. The GPQ‐based approach can be recommended in practical use because of its easy implementation and better performance than the MLE‐based approaches in most simulation scenarios. Two real datasets are given to illustrate the approaches. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Design and validation of a vacuum assisted anchorage for the uniaxial tensile testing of soft materials

Current commercial tensile testing systems use spring-loaded or other compression-based grips to clamp materials in place posing a problem for very soft or delicate materials that cannot withstand this mechanical clamping force. In order to perform uniaxial tensile tests on soft tissues or materials, we have created a novel vacuum-assisted anchor (VAA). Fibrin gels were subjected to uniaxial extension, and the testing data was used to determine material mechanical properties. Utilizing the VAA, we achieved successful tensile breaks of soft fibrin gels while finding statistically significant differences between the mechanical properties of gels fabricated at two different fibrinogen concentrations.     

Experimental parameters affecting sensitivity and specificity of a yeast assay for estrogenic compounds: results of an interlaboratory validation exercise

In vitro assays are considered as the first step in a tiered approach to compound screening for hormonal activity. Although many new assays have been developed in recent years, little attention has been paid towards assay validation. Our objective was to identify critical experimental parameters in a yeast estrogen screen (YES) that affect its sensitivity and specificity. We investigated the role of incubation time, solvent type, yeast inoculum growth stage and concentration on the outcome of the YES. Compounds tested included new and established agonists, antagonists and negative controls, and results were evaluated according to prefixed statistical criteria. In addition, we assessed the assay’s performance in a blind interlaboratory validation exercise (IVE). An incubation time of five days was necessary to positively identify the estrogenic properties of all agonists tested, when dissolved in DMSO. Longer incubation times were required when using an ethanol protocol. Similar estrogenic activity was reported for benzyl butyl phthalate, bisphenol-A, methoxychlor, permethrin and genistein in the IVE. One out of the three laboratories did not classify α,β-endosulfan, dissolved in DMSO, as an estrogen. The same was true for 4,4′-DDE and lindane, dissolved in ethanol, a result that might be attributable to an inappropriate yeast start concentration and/or growth stage. These validation experiments show that under appropriate experimental conditions the YES yields sensitive, specific and reliable results. Therefore it fulfills the requirements as a first step screening assay to evaluate the capacity of chemicals to interact with the estrogen receptor.     

Development and validation of a forensic six-dye multiplex assay with 29 STR loci

This paper describes the development and validation of a novel 31-locus, six-dye STR multiplex system, which is designed to meet the needs of the rapidly growing Chinese forensic database. This new assay combines 20 extended-CODIS core loci (D3S1358, D5S818, TPOX, CSF1PO, TH01, vWA, D7S820, D21S11, D8S1179, D18S51, D16S539, D13S317, FGA, D1S1656, D2S441, D2S1338, D10S1248, D12S391, D19S433, and D22S1045), nine highly polymorphic loci in Chinese Han population (D3S3045, D6S1043, D6S477, D8S1132, D10S1435, D15S659, D19S253, Penta D, and Penta E), and two gender determining markers, amelogenin and Y-Indel, which could amplify DNA from extracts, as well as direct amplification from substrates. To demonstrate the suitability for forensic applications, this system was validated by precision and accuracy evaluation, concordance tests, case sample tests, sensitivity, species specificity, stability, stutter calculation, and DNA mixtures, according to the guidelines described by the Scientific Working Group on DNA Analysis Methods (SWGDAM) and regulations published by the China Ministry of Public Security. The validation results indicate the robustness and reliability of this new system, and it could be a potentially helpful tool for human identification and paternity testing in the Chinese population, as well as facilitating global forensic DNA data sharing.     

Bioanalytical assay validation parameters re‐visited: perspectives on stability studies

Bioanalytical assay validation for plethora of parameters is considered vital for the reliable and accurate generation of raw analytical data used for pharmacokinetic characterization of analytes. Although the validation parameters have been widely accepted, the intent of this communication is to provide some perspectives on the commonly followed approaches for stability studies (i.e. freeze–thaw and long‐term freezer stability studies). The proposed discussion is intended to stimulate the thinking process to cut down on the extra work and/or maximize the efficiency in the bioanalytical work. Additionally, the availability of new emerging technological know‐hows and latest nuances in the field should provide the necessary impetus to innovate and articulate strategies for smart assay development/validation work for analytes. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The evaluation of measurement uncertainty from method validation studies

 A protocol has been developed illustrating the link between validation experiments, such as precision, trueness and ruggedness testing, and measurement uncertainty evaluation. By planning validation experiments with uncertainty estimation in mind, uncertainty budgets can be obtained from validation data with little additional effort. The main stages in the uncertainty estimation process are described, and the use of trueness and ruggedness studies is discussed in detail. The practical application of the protocol will be illustrated in Part 2, with reference to a method for the determination of three markers (CI solvent red 24, quinizarin and CI solvent yellow 124) in fuel oil samples. Received: 10 April 1999 / Accepted: 24 September 1999     

Ultra‐thin SiO2 on Si VIII. Accuracy of method,linearity and attenuation lengths for XPS

In the study of ultra‐thin films (<10‐nm thick), there is a range of methods that can provide accurate measurements of differences in thickness. However, in a pilot study under the auspices of the Consultative Committee for Amount of Substance (CCQM), results for the archetypal system of SiO₂ on Si show that the methods have different offsets such that, at all thicknesses, positive or negative amounts in the range up to 1 nm may be observed between methods. All the methods studied give thicknesses that are greater than those measured by X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) by amounts between 0.2 nm and approximately 1 nm. Significant parts of these offsets, of other methods with respect to XPS, may be attributed to contaminations which increase the apparent thickness but that do not affect XPS. However, not all of these offsets can yet be explained at the 0.2 nm level. The remaining part of the offsets could be thought to have arisen either from the XPS or from the other methods. In this study, by measuring SiO₂ deposited in situ on amorphous Si by XPS it is shown that the XPS linearity is consistent with the previous estimate of ± 0.025 nm, down to fractions of a monolayer, with no significant offset and that, therefore, it is the offsets seen using other methods that need further study. Recent calculations of the film thickness dependence of the attenuation lengths (ALs) for this system, using NIST SESSA software, are not consistent with these data although earlier calculations are. This work shows that XPS, with the AL calibrated by one or more other methods that are valid for differences in thickness, can provide a traceable measurement of thickness in all laboratories. © Crown Copyright 2007. Reproduced with the permission of Her Majesty's Stationery Office. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Development and validation of a forensic multiplex InDel assay: The AGCU InDel 60 kit

Marker sets based on insertion/deletion polymorphisms (InDels) combine the characteristics of both short tandem repeats (STRs) and single nucleotide polymorphisms and have served as effective complementary or stand-alone systems for human identification in forensics. We developed a novel multiplex amplification detection system, designated the AGCU InDel 60 kit, containing 57 autosomal InDels, 2 Y-chromosomal InDels, and the amelogenin locus and validated the kit in a series of studies, which included tests of the PCR conditions; tests for sensitivity, species specificity, reproducibility, stability, and mock case samples; degradation studies; and a population study. The results indicated that the AGCU InDel 60 kit was accurate, specific, reproducible, stable, and robust. Complete DNA profiles were obtained even with 125 pg of human DNA. In tests of artificially degraded samples, we found that the number of alleles detected by the validated kit was considerably greater than that detected by the STR-based AGCU 21+1 kit, even as the degree of degradation increased. Additionally, 564 unrelated individuals from three Han groups were investigated using this novel system, and the values of combined power of discrimination and combined power of exclusion were not less than 1–4.9026 × 10⁻²⁴ and 1–3.1123 × 10⁻⁵, respectively. Thus, the results indicated that the novel kit was more powerful than the previous version of the InDel kit (the AGCU InDel 50 kit). Our results suggest that the AGCU InDel 60 kit can serve as an efficient tool for human forensics and a supplementary kit for population genetics research.     

一种可用于直接检测空气中异氰酸酯的比率型荧光探针

异氰酸酯是一类广泛使用的化工原料，但容易挥发到空气中对人体健康造成危害.因此，建立一种快速、方便检测空气中异氰酸酯的方法具有重要的意义.合成了一种荧光探针（N-正丁基-4-羟基-1，8萘二酰亚胺），能与异氰酸酯快速反应，从而使探针的荧光颜色由黄绿色转变为蓝色，实现对异氰酸酯的比率型荧光检测.同时，该探针对异氰酸酯的响应具有灵敏性和选择性.反应机理研究表明，探针萘环4位上的羟基与异氰酸酯基（-NCO）反应生成了氨基甲酸酯基团.为了直接检测空气中的异氰酸酯，制备了一种基于该探针的检测试纸，实现对空气中异氰酸酯高灵敏性、高选择性的检测.该方法对空气中异氰酸酯的检测具有实际意义，同时也为挥发性有机物的检测提供了参考.     

Development and validation of a hydrophilic interaction chromatography-mass spectrometry assay for taurine and methionine in matrices rich in carbohydrates

A new procedure based on hydrophilic interaction chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry (ionisation process by pneumatically assisted electrospray in negative ion mode), is developed and validated for the simultaneous determination of underivatised taurine and methionine in beverages rich in carbohydrates such as energy drinks. No initial clean-up procedure and no sample derivatisation are required. Satisfactory analysis was obtained on an Astec apHera NH2 (150 mm x 4.6 mm; 5 microm) column with methanol-water (60/40) as mobile phase. The method was validated in terms of specificity, detection limits, linearity, accuracy, precision and stability, using threonine as internal standard. The potential effects of matrix and endogenous amino acid content were also examined. The limits of detection in the beverage varied from 20 microg L(-1) for taurine to 50 micro L(-1) for methionine.     

Perspectives on updates,clarifications and controversies in chromatographic assay guidance for bioanalytical method validation from major regulatory agencies and organizations

Bioanalysis, a key supporting function for generating data for pre‐clinical and clinical studies in drug development, is under the regulation of local agencies as well as global organizations to ensure the data integrity and quality in submission. As major regulatory agencies and organizations, the US Food and Drug Administration, the European Medicines Agency and the International Council for Harmonization of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use have been updating their industry guidance for bioanalytical method validation, to keep up with the development new modalities, technologies and regulations. This article summarizes the recent updates and any clarifications and controversies triggered by those updates. Perspectives and recommendations are given based on our own experience as well as commonly accepted practice in the bioanalytical community.     

On the use of the correlation coefficient r for testing the linearity of calibration functions

This paper criticises the use of the correlation coefficient r for testing the linearity of calibration functions and recommends better methods.