Prediction of the effects of methanol and competing ion concentration on retention in the ion chromatographic separation of anionic and cationic pharmaceutically related compounds

The mixed-mode separation of a selection of anionic and cationic pharmaceutically related compounds is studied using ion-exchange columns and eluents consisting of ionic salts (potassium hydroxide or methanesulfonic acid) and an organic modifier (methanol). All separations were performed using commercially available ion-exchange columns and an ion chromatography instrument modified to allow introduction of methanol into the eluent without introducing compatibility problems with the eluent generation system. Isocratic retention prediction was undertaken over the two-dimensional space defined by the concentration of the competing ion and the percentage of organic modifier in the eluent. Various empirical models describing the observed relationships between analyte retention and both the competing ion concentration and the percentage of methanol were evaluated, with the resultant model being capable of describing the separation, including peak width, over the entire experimental space based on six initial experiments. Average errors in retention time and peak width were less than 6% and 27%, respectively, for runs taken from both inside and outside of the experimental space. Separations performed under methanol gradient conditions (while holding the competing ion concentration constant) were also modelled. The observed effect on retention of varying the methanol composition differed between analytes with several analytes exhibiting increased retention with increased percentage methanol in the eluent. An empirical model was derived based on integration of the observed t_R vs. %methanol plot for each analyte. A combination of the isocratic and gradient models allowed for the prediction of retention time using multi-step methanol gradient profiles with average errors in predicted retention times being less than 4% over 30 different 2- and 3-step gradient profiles for anions and less than 6% over 14 different 2- and 3-step gradient profiles for cations. A modified peak compression model was used to estimate peak widths under these conditions. This provided adequate width prediction with the average error between observed and predicted peak widths being less than 15% for 40 1-, 2- and 3-step gradients for anions and less than 13% over 14 1-, 2- and 3-step gradients for cations.     

Retention profiles and mechanism of anion separation on latex-based pellicular ion exchanger in ion chromatography

A retention model based on stoichiometric approach has been developed in order to describe analyte retention of anions on latex-based pellicular ion exchanger. The chromatographic process entails two stepwise and complex equilibria, first is ion-pair forming of analyte or eluent ion with ion-exchange sites under the effect of electrostatic forces due to the sulfonic layer behind the aminated functional groups of stationary phase. Second component is the ion-exchange between the analyte and eluent ions. As a new parameter of the fractional electrostatic coefficient of the ion exchange capacity was introduced to develop retention profiles of anions. Analysis of the dependence of the capacity factors on the eluent concentrations at different values of fractional coefficient shed light on the possible complex mechanism. Extensive experimental retention data were obtained for 14 anions (formate, acetate, propionate, pyruvate, lactate, chloride, nitrate, oxalate, malonate, succinate, tartarate, fumarate, maleate, sulphate) using hydroxide eluents of varying concentration. The ion-pair formation and ion-exchange selectivity constants for analyte and eluent species are determined using derived retention equation from experimental data by nonlinear iterative calculation. The model was utilized to predict retention data under elution conditions of practical importance. The predicted and obtained retention factors are in good agreement, which confirms the predictive power of the model.     

Two-dimensional ion chromatography using tandem ion-exchange columns with gradient-pulse column switching

A two-dimensional ion chromatography (2D-IC) approach has been developed which provides greater resolution of complex samples than is possible currently using a single column. Two columns containing different stationary phases are connected via a tee-piece, which enables an additional eluent flow and independent control of eluent concentration on each column. The resultant mixed eluent flow at the tee-piece can be varied to produce a different eluent concentration on the second column. This allows analytes strongly retained on the first column to be separated rapidly on the second column, whilst maintaining a highly efficient, well resolved separation of analytes retained weakly on the first column. A group of 18 inorganic anions has been separated to demonstrate the utility of this approach and the proposed 2D-IC method provided separation of this mixture with resolution of all analytes greater than 1.3. Careful optimisation of the eluent profiles on both columns resulted in run times of less than 28 min, including re-equilibration. Separations were performed using isocratic or gradient elution on the first column, with an isocratic separation being used on the second column. Switching of the analytes onto the second column was performed using a gradient pulse of concentrated eluent to quickly elute strongly retained analytes from the first column onto the second column. The separations were highly repeatable (RSD of 0.01–0.12% for retention times and 0.08–2.9% for peak areas) and efficient (typically 8000–260,000 plates). Detection limits were 3–80 ppb.     

Methodology for porting retention prediction data from old to new columns and from conventional-scale to miniaturised ion chromatography systems

Several procedures are available for simulating and optimising separations in ion chromatography (IC), based on the application of retention models to an extensive database of analyte retention times on a wide range of columns. These procedures are subject to errors arising from batch-to-batch variability in the synthesis of stationary phases, or when using a column having a different diameter to that used when the database was acquired originally. Approaches are described in which the retention database can be recalibrated to accommodate changes in the stationary phase (ion-exchange selectivity coefficient and ion-exchange capacity) or in the column diameter which lead to changes in phase ratio. The entire database can be recalibrated for all analytes on a particular column by performing three isocratic separations with two analyte ions. The retention data so obtained are then used to derive a "porting" equation which is employed to generate the required simulated separation. Accurate prediction of retention times is demonstrated for both anions and cations on 2mm and 0.4mm diameter columns under elution conditions which consist of up to five sequential isocratic or linear gradient elution steps. The proposed approach gives average errors in retention time prediction of less than 3% and the correlation coefficient was 0.9849 between predicted and observed retention times for 344 data points comprising 33 anionic or cationic analytes, 5 column internal diameters and 8 complex elution profiles.     

Modelling gradient elution of bioactive multicomponent systems in non-linear ion-exchange chromatography

A theoretical framework for the ion-exchange behaviour of bioactive substances in non-linear ion-exchange chromatogaphy is described. The aim of the study was the creation of a model basis to support a process design for production-scale ion-exchange chromatography. The theory can be applied to a whole variety of biological substances, such as amino acids, polysaccharides, peptides and proteins and either isocratic or gradient elution can be carried out. The influence of the eluent concentration on the ion-exchange as well as on the characteristic charge was considered. Experimental measurements showed a strong non-linear ion-exchange equilibrium with a transition from a Langmuir-type to a sigmoidal isotherm at higher eluent concentrations. Hereby, the compound binds to the surface though it is not ionic. Therefore, the model considered the possibility of ion-exchange as well as adsorption. A simplified distribution of the counter-ions based on the Gouy-Chapman theory with a discrete distribution of the counter-ions was used. The theory was extended by a selectivity in the double layer to allow specific adsorption. Calculations of adsorption-elution cycles showed, in agreement with the experimental observations, the development of non-linear elution profiles with a desorption fronting. As a result, the column loading and the eluent concentration were varied. The effect of contaminants, in this case sodium ions, was investigated and included in the model. Finally, the model was extended to multicomponent systems to investigate the effect of side components on the retention behaviour. The development of the characteristic elution profiles and the effect of the column loading on the separation are discussed. Calculated concentration profiles along the column at discrete time steps were used to reveal the influence of side components and the underlying separation mechanism. The simulations provided a new insight into the phenomena involved in biochromatography and make convenient design concepts at least doubtful as the separation is in this case mainly determined by the loading step and not by the choice of the elution gradient.     

Determination of anions in landfill leachates by ion chromatography

Ion chromatography has been used to determine inorganic and organic anions within landfill leachates. Two procedures are operated on split samples which have multiple dilutions and vary in sample treatment: gradient ion-exchange chromatography for inorganic anions and isocratic ion-exclusion chromatography for organic anions. Interference between carbonate and organic acid anions using ion-exclusion chromatography is avoided by treatment with octanesulphonic acid eluent. Using ion-exchange chromatography, the presence of valerate, hexanoate and heptanoate is checked (but not quantified) for a subsample which has been treated to remove chloride; these species are then determined by ion-exclusion chromatography. Analysis of certified standards (10 mg/1 certified VFA standard; Supelco, Bellefonte, PA, USA; 20–150 mg/l inorganic anions, ICMIX1-100, Glen Spectra Reference Materials, Middlesex, UK) gives good agreement (within 5% for organic anions except formate, and within 1% for inorganic anions), with R.S.D. values for all anionic species varying from 0.44–2.23.     

Fast ion chromatography using short anion exchange columns

A fast ion chromatographic system is described which uses shorter column lengths and compares various eluent profiles in order to maximise the performance without sacrificing the chromatographic resolution. Both isocratic and gradient elution profiles were considered to find the most efficient mode of separation. The separation and determination of seven target anions (chloride, chlorate, nitrate, chromate, sulfate, thiocyanate and perchlorate) was achieved using a short (4 mm ID, 50 mm long) column packed with Dionex AS20 high-capacity anion exchange material. A hydroxide eluent was used at an initial concentration of 25 mM (at a flow-rate of 1.0 mL/min) and two performance maxima were found. The maximum efficiency occurred at a normalised gradient ramp rate of 5 mM/t₀, resulting in a peak capacity of 16, while the fastest separation (<3 min) occurred at a normalised ramp rate of 30 mM/t₀. The retention time, peak width and resolution using the different eluent profiles on varying column lengths is also compared. Further investigations in this study determined that the highest peak capacity separation under gradient conditions could be approximated using an isocratic separation. The advantage of using this novel approach to approximate the maximum efficiency separation removes the need for column re-equilibration that is required for gradient elution resulting in faster analyses and enhanced sample throughput, with benefits in particular for multidimensional chromatography.     

In-line respeciation: an ion-exchange ion chromatographic method applied to the separation of degradation products of chemical warfare nerve agents in soil

The natural background of anions encountered when analyzing soil samples by ion chromatography (IC) present significant problems in the separation, detection and quantification of isopropyl methylphosphonic acid (IMPA) and methylphosphonic acid (MPA), the degradation products of sarin, a chemical warfare nerve agent. Using chemically-suppressed IC with conductivity detection, a commercially available ion-exchange column, and an isocratic binary eluent system, IMPA and MPA were determined in aqueous extracts of soil at sub-ppm (μg/g) concentrations without the need for gradient elution or organic solvent eluent modifiers. Common soil anions such as chloride, nitrate, sulfate and phosphate do not interfere with the analysis method due to the composition of the binary eluent allowing for greater mobilization of multivalent anions (e.g., MPA, carbonate, and sulfate) while monovalent anions (e.g., IMPA and nitrate) are relatively unaffected. Carbonate is selectively removed by in-line respeciation to bicarbonate.     

Interconversion of gradient and isocratic retention data in reversed-phase liquid chromatography: Effect of the uptake of eluent modifier on the retention of analytes

The experimental technique of mass spectrometric tracer pulse chromatography was used to study the effect of the sorption of eluent components by a C₁₈-bonded silica RPLC packing on the retention of a series of test analytes during isocratic and gradient elution experiments. The analytes of interest were a substituted phenol, a substituted nitroaniline, an anti-malaria drug, tetrahydrofuran, and methanol. The eluent used was a mixture of acetonitrile and water. The solutes and isotopically labeled eluent components were injected at fixed time intervals during each gradient run. The mass specific detector allowed the assignment of individual analyte peaks even when there was overlap in the chromatograms from successive injections. Thus, the retention time of each analyte could be determined as a function of gradient slope and initial eluent composition at the time of each injection. Experimental gradient retention time data were then compared with the calculated results from two theoretical models. The first model assumed the velocity of the mobile phase and eluent were equal. The second and most realistic model assumed the velocity of the eluent was less than the velocity of the mobile phase due to the uptake of eluent by the stationary phase. Gradient retention times predicted by the two models were reasonably accurate with the sorption model giving slightly more accurate values. Inverse calculations, i.e., calculation of isocratic retention factors from gradient elution data were also carried out with very similar results. That is, the model allowing for the uptake of eluent was slightly more accurate than the model assuming no eluent-stationary phase interaction.     

Evaluation of separation in gradient elution ion chromatography by combining several retention models and objective functions

In this work, three different methods for modeling of gradient retention were combined with several optimization objective functions in order to find the most appropriate combination to be applied in ion chromatography method development. The system studied was a set of seven inorganic anions (fluoride, chloride, nitrite, sulfate, bromide, nitrate, and phosphate) with a KOH eluent. The retention modeling methods tested were multilayer perceptron artificial neural network (MLP-ANN), radial-basis function artificial neural network (RBF-ANN), and retention model based on transfer of data from isocratic to gradient elution mode. It was shown that MLP retention model in combination with the objective function based on normalized retention difference product was the most adequate tool for optimization purposes.     

Characteristics of a column suitable for capacity gradient chromatography with a borate eluent

In capacity gradient elution, the gradient separation of ionic species is achieved by decreasing the ion-exchange capacity of a column during the course of the separation. Diol-type hydroxy groups on the resin surface form anionic complexes with borate as an eluting reagent. Thus, a chemically bonded anion-exchange column enriched with residual hydroxy groups allows the creation of a capacity gradient. An increase in the amount of the complex formed gradually brings about a decrease in the ion-exchange capacity of the column, and strongly bound analyte ions are eluted. We investigated the characteristics of a column suitable for this eluent system. The concentration of borate eluent required to remove the ion-exchange capacity depended inversely on the ratio of the residual hydroxy groups to functional groups. On a column in which this ratio was approximately 100, the ion-exchange capacity could easily be adjusted by using a low concentration of mannitol as a competing reagent. Use of this column led to very small baseline shifts during the borate-mannitol gradients, and to the simultaneous determination of anions with widely varying retention times.     

Retention of some glucosinolates in anion exchange chromatography. Part I: Qualitative study on a silica-trialkylammonium exchanger

Summary The retention and separation of glucosinolates, as organic anions, were studied on a silica-based strong anion exchanger under isocratic elution conditions. All glucosinolates carry the same functional ionic group (-OSO ₃ ^– ), however they do not have the same retention in anion exchange chromatography. The plots of capacity factors of organic anions versus the reciprocal of eluent ion concentration show good linearity. From the slope and y-intercept data the major retention mechanisms are interpreted as ion exchange and reversed-phase interactions. The effects of nature and concentration of the eluent ion and the influence of organic modifier addition to the aqueous buffered mobile phase are also investigated. Direct and indirect UV detection were used.Our results open the way for the development of new systems for intact glucosinolate analysis which are easier to use than the present ion-pairing chromatographic method.     

Relationship between isocratic and gradient retention times in the high-performance ion-exchange chromatography of proteins. Theory and experiment

Using isocratic retention parameters, the gradient elution retention time for several proteins has been calculated. The gradient retention time calculation is based on fitting the isocratic retention data to an equation of the form: log k' = m log (1/[Ca2+]) + log K and on applying well-established principles of gradient elution. A good correlation between the observed and calculated retention times for several test proteins was obtained at various total gradient times and column flow-rates. Conversely, isocratic retention parameters characterizing protein retention can be calculated from gradient elution retention data. However, even with retention data of high quality, small errors are amplified by the log-log nature of the ion-exchange isocratic retention model employed. Based on the close correlation between predicted and observed gradient retention times, no evidence for protein denaturation resulting from immobilization of the protein at high initial k' values at or near the column inlet was observed.     

Isocratic and gradient elution chromatography: a comparison in terms of speed, retention reproducibility and quantitation

Chromatographers are cautioned to avoid gradient elution when isocratic elution will do. In this work, we compared the analytical properties of gradient and isocratic separations of a sample which can be done quite readily under isocratic conditions. We found that gradient elution gave a shorter overall analysis with similar resolution of the critical pair compared to isocratic elution without sacrificing repeatability in retention time, peak area and peak height or linearity of the calibration curve. We also obtained acceptable repeatability in peak area/height and linearity of calibrations curves for a sample that required gradient elution using a practical baseline subtraction technique. Based on these results and related work which show that columns can be reequilibrated by flushing with less than two column volumes of the initial eluent, we conclude that many of the reasons given to avoid gradient elution deserve serious reconsideration, especially for those samples which are easily separated isocratically. However, we believe isocratic elution will remain preferable when: (1) the sample contains less than 10 weakly retained components (i.e. the last peak elutes with k' < 5) or (2) the gradient baseline impedes trace analysis.     

Vitamin U-bonded stationary phase in capillary ion chromatography

A vitamin U-bonded stationary phase was prepared and the retention behavior of inorganic anions was examined using ion chromatography. Inorganic anions were retained on the vitamin U-bonded stationary phase under acidic as well as neutral eluent conditions in the ion-exchange mode. The elution order of the examined anions under neutral eluent conditions was nearly the same as that observed in common ion exchange mode, while the elution order observed under acidic eluent conditions was completely different from that observed in common ion exchange mode. The retention of the analyte anions under the neutral eluent conditions was due to the sulfonium groups of the vitamin U, while protonated primary amino groups caused retention of the analyte anions with different selectivity under acidic conditions. The retention factor of the analyte anions increased with decreasing eluent concentration under both eluent conditions. The present system was applied to the determination of bromide and nitrate contained in seawater.     

Optimization of stepwise gradient elution in columns chromatography

Summary A general equation for the final retention of a solute chromatographed under conditions of stepwise gradient elution has been derived. The elution process and the distances travelled by solutes as a function of eluent volume were simulated by computer for the optimization of stepwise gradient prorams from isocratic HPLC data. The validity of the equations was experimentally veritied.     

Retention behaviour of imidazolium ionic liquid cations on 1.7 μm ethylene bridged hybrid silica column using acetonitrile-rich and water-rich mobile phases

The potential of 1.7 μm ethylene bridged hybrid silica phase was investigated for the separation of twelve imidazolium-based ionic liquid cations. U-shaped retention profile was observed for all solutes with an increase in retention at both low and high acetonitrile content. Chromatographic behaviour of imidazolium cations in both hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) and per aqueous liquid chromatography (PALC) modes was studied by varying key parameters such as buffer concentration and pH, acid additive, organic modifier and column temperature. Experimental data provided some evidences that under PALC conditions cationic solutes are retained predominantly by mixed hydrophobic/ion-exchange interactions. In the HILIC mode, both partitioning and ion-exchange interactions are responsible for the retention of solutes. Compared to PALC, HILIC provided significantly higher efficiencies with less or even no peak tailing, better separation selectivity and greater resistance to overload. In PALC mode gradient elution was required to achieve adequate retentivity of all solutes but selectivity was not sufficient to distinguish between solutes with very similar hydrophobicity. In contrast, under HILIC conditions twelve solutes were almost completely resolved in less than 4 min by using isocratic elution. Summarizing, it could be concluded that ethylene bridged hybrid silica column providing a dual retention mechanism offers the possibility of selecting between the two retention modes with opposite separation selectivity, just by changing the composition of the mobile phase.     

Capacity gradient anion chromatography with a borate complex as eluent

Complex formation between borate compounds and vicinal diols is well recognized. Generally, in a chemically bonded anion-exchange resin, many hydroxyl groups are introduced on the surface of the resin in order to make the resin hydrophilic. The borate as an eluting reagent also reacts to these hydroxyl groups, and this complex formation decreases the apparent ion-exchange capacity of the column by being dissociated to the anion depending on the eluent pH. In the present work a method is described for the simultaneous determination of anions based on the capacity gradient for suppressed ion chromatography. A Tosoh IC-Anion-PW column and dihydroxyphenylborane–mannitol eluent system were used. To maintain baseline stability, it was helpful to keep the borate concentration constant during a gradient of 16 to 0 mM mannitol as a modifier to prevent the complex formation with the hydroxyl on the resin. The chemical composition of the eluents and gradient profiles are discussed and the application to the analysis of the condensed phosphates with widely varying retention times as food additives in a cheese sample is presented.     

Error analysis and performance of different retention models in the transference of data from/to isocratic/gradient elution

The transferability of retention data among isocratic and gradient RPLC elution modes is studied. For this purpose, 16 beta-blockers were chromatographed under both isocratic and gradient elution with acetonitrile-water mobile phases. Taking into account the elution mode where the experimental data come from, and the mode where the retention should be predicted, the following combinations are possible: isocratic predictions from (i) isocratic or (ii) gradient experimental designs; and gradient predictions from (iii) isocratic or (iv) gradient data. Each of these possibilities was checked using three retention models that relate the logarithm of the retention factor: (a) linearly and (b) quadratically with the volume fraction of organic solvent, and (c) linearly with a normalised mobile phase polarity parameter. The study was carried out under two different perspectives: a straightforward examination of the prediction errors and the analysis of the uncertainties derived from the variance-covariance matrix of the fitted models. The best combinations of prediction mode and model were: (i)-(b), (ii)-(c), (iii)-(b), and (iv)-(a) or (c).     

Double gradient ion chromatography using short monolithic columns modified with a long chained zwitterionic carboxybetaine surfactant

The rapid separation of inorganic anions on short monolithic columns permanently coated with a long chained zwitterionic carboxybetaine-type surfactant is shown. The surfactant, N-dodecyl-N,N-(dimethylammonio)undecanoate (DDMAU), was used to coat 2.5, 5.0 and 10 cm long reversed-phase silica monoliths, resulting in a permanent zwitterionic exchange surface when used with aqueous based eluents. The unique structure of the surfactant results in a charge double layer structure on the surface of the stationary phase, with strong internal anionic and weak external cationic exchange groups. The dissociation of the weak external carboxylic acid group acts to shield the inner anionic exchange site, resulting in substantial effective capacity changes with eluent pH. Utilising this effect with the application of an eluent pH gradient, simultaneously combined with eluent flow-rate gradients, very rapid simultaneous separations of both weakly retained anions and strongly retained polarisable anions was possible, with up to 10-fold decreases in overall run times. Coating stability and retention times under isocratic and isofluentic eluent conditions were shown to be reproducible over >450 repeat injections, with peak efficiency values averaging 29,000 N/m for the 2.5 cm column and 42,000 N/m for the 10 cm monolithic column, again under isocratic elution conditions.