Field-flow fractionation in microfluidic channels of low aspect ratio

The shape of the steady-state three-dimensional flow velocity profile established in carrier liquid flowing inside the rectangular cross-sectional channel for field-flow fractionation should be taken into account to optimize the separation. The central parts of this profile in the planes parallel to the main channel walls are flat with almost identical flow velocities which drop down to zero at the side walls. The separated species transported by the flow in the close-to-side walls regions move with lower average velocities compared to the species transported in the central part of the channel and are undesirably broadened. The hydrodynamic splitting of the carrier liquid at the entry of the channel where the sample is injected only into the central part of the channel eliminates the excessive zone broadening. The aspect ratio of the breadth to the thickness of the channel ratio can thus be reduced. The effect of various aspect ratios on the shape of the flow velocity profile is calculated and the results are used to optimize the aspect ratio of microfluidic channels. The experiments carried out by microthermal field-flow fractionation confirmed that the aspect ratio cannot be reduced to a value of 1, proposed by other authors.     

Field-flow fractionation in bioanalysis: A review of recent trends

Field-flow fractionation (FFF) is a mature technique in bioanalysis, and the number of applications to proteins and protein complexes, viruses, derivatized nano- and micronsized beads, sub-cellular units, and whole cell separation is constantly increasing. This can be ascribed to the non-invasivity of FFF when directly applied to biosamples. FFF is carried out in an open-channel structure by a flow stream of a mobile phase of any composition, and it is solely based on the interaction of the analytes with a perpendicularly applied field. For these reasons, fractionation is developed without surface interaction of the analyte with packing or gel media and without using degrading mobile phases. The fractionation device can be also easily sterilized, and analytes can be maintained under a bio-friendly environment. This allows to maintain native conditions of the sample in solution.In this review, FFF principles are briefly described, and some pioneering developments and applications in the bioanalytical field are tabled before detailed report of most recent FFF applications obtained also with the hyphenation of FFF with highly specific, sensitive characterization methods. Special focus is finally given to the emerging use of FFF as a pre-analytical step for mass-based identification and characterization of proteins and protein complexes in proteomics.     

Experimental study on the retention of silica particles in gravitational field-flow fractionation effects of the mobile phase composition

Effects of mobile phase composition can play an effective role in modulating the retention of particles in gravitational field-flow fractionation (GFFF), the simplest and cheapest among field-flow fractionation (FFF) techniques. In the framework of an optimized procedure for the GFFF characterization of particulate systems, an experimental approach to the effects of the mobile phase composition on the retention of silica particles retention is presented. The role of the ionic strength and the presence of surfactant are emphasized, with special regards to the shape of the particles. Moreover, the first experimental evidence of potential-barrier GFFF is reported.     

On the retention mechanisms and secondary effects in microthermal field-flow fractionation of particles

The behavior of nanometer or micrometer-sized particles, dispersed in liquid phase and exposed to temperature gradient, is a complex and not yet well understood phenomenon. Thermal field-flow fractionation (TFFF), using conventional-size channels, played an important role in the studies of this phenomenon. In addition to thermal diffusion (thermophoresis) and molecular diffusion or Brownian movement, several secondary effects such as particle–particle and/or particle–wall interactions, chemical equilibria with the components of the carrier liquid, buoyant and lift forces, etc., may contribute to the retention and complicate the understanding of the relations between the thermal diffusion and the characteristics of the retained particles. Microthermal FFF is a new high-performance technique allowing much easier manipulation and control of the operational parameters within an extended range of experimental conditions in comparison with conventional TFFF. Consequently, in combination with various other methods, it is well suited for a detailed investigation of the mentioned effects. In this work, some contradictory published results concerning the thermal diffusion of the colloidal particles, studied by TFFF but also by other methods, are analyzed and compared with our experimental findings.     

Newly designed flow field-flow fractionation channel for macromolecules and particles in the submicrometer and micrometer range

The flow field-flow fractionation (FIFFF) technique is a promising method for separating and analysing particles and large size macromolecules from a few nanometers to approximately 50 μm. A new fractionation channel is described featuring well defined flow conditions even for low channel heights with convenient assembling and operations features. The application of the new flow field-flow fractionation channel is proved by the analysis of pigments and other small particles of technical interest in the submicrometer range. The experimental results including multimodal size distributions are presented and discussed.     

Potential barrier field-flow fractionation for the separation and characterization of colloidal particles

Summary The reversibility of adsorption of colloidal particles on the channel wall in Sedimentation Field-Flow Fractionation (SFFF), which is based on the variation of the ionic strength of the carrier solution, suggests a new method, for the separation and characterization of colloidal materials. This new method has been called Potential Barrier Field Flow Fractionation (PBFFF).     

Newly designed flow field-flow fractionation channel for macromolecules and particles in the submicrometer and micrometer range

The flow field-flow fractionation (FIFFF) technique is a promising method for separating and analysing particles and large size macromolecules from a few nanometers to approximately 50 μm. A new fractionation channel is described featuring well defined flow conditions even for low channel heights with convenient assembling and operations features. The application of the new flow field-flow fractionation channel is proved by the analysis of pigments and other small particles of technical interest in the submicrometer range. The experimental results including multimodal size distributions are presented and discussed.     

Separation and characterization of nanoparticles in complex food and environmental samples by field-flow fractionation

The thorough analysis of natural nanoparticles (NPs) and engineered NPs involves the sequence of detection, identification, quantification and, if possible, detailed characterization. In a complex or heterogeneous sample, each step of this sequence is an individual challenge, and, given suitable sample preparation, field-flow fractionation (FFF) is one of the most promising techniques to achieve relevant characterization.The objective of this review is to present the current status of FFF as an analytical separation technique for the study of NPs in complex food and environmental samples. FFF has been applied for separation of various types of NP (e.g., organic macromolecules, and carbonaceous or inorganic NPs) in different types of media (e.g., natural waters, soil extracts or food samples).FFF can be coupled to different types of detectors that offer additional information and specificity, and the determination of size-dependent properties typically inaccessible to other techniques. The separation conditions need to be carefully adapted to account for specific particle properties, so quantitative analysis of heterogeneous or complex samples is difficult as soon as matrix constituents in the samples require contradictory separation conditions. The potential of FFF analysis should always be evaluated bearing in mind the impact of the necessary sample preparation, the information that can be retrieved from the chosen detection systems and the influence of the chosen separation conditions on all types of NP in the sample. A holistic methodological approach is preferable to a technique-focused one.     

Gravitational field-flow fractionation in combination with flow injection analysis or electrothermal AAS for size based iron speciation of particles

A simple gravitational field-flow fractionation (GrFFF) system was used for size separation of micron sized silica particles coated with hydrous iron oxide (geothite). The amount of iron on the particles was monitored either on-line by reverse-flow injection analysis (r-FIA) with chemiluminescence detection using luminol or off-line by electrothermal atomic absorption spectrophotometry (ETAAS). The combination of GrFFF with reverse FIA or with ETAAS has been demonstrated to be a cost-effective tool for size based iron speciation of particles.     

Field-flow fractionation: An efficient approach for matrix removal of soil extract for inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry

An on-line coupling between a continuous-flow sequential extraction (CFSE) unit and flow field-flow fractionation with cross flow matrix removal (FlFFF/CFM) with ICP-OES detection was developed for determination of metal leachability from soil. The use of high concentration of Mg(NO₃)₂ in exchangeable phase can cause undesirable matrix effects by shifting ionization equilibrium in the plasma, etc., resulting in a clear need for matrix removal. Therefore, the capability of FlFFF/CFM to remove Mg matrix ion from soil extract was evaluated. Poly(ethylene imine) (PEI) having molecular weight of 25,000 Da was added to form complexes with analyte elements (Cu, Mn, Pb, and Zn) but not the matrix element (Mg). The free Mg matrix ions were then removed by filtering off through the ultrafiltration membrane, having a 1000-Da molecular weight cut-off, inside the FlFFF channel. With the use of FlFFF/CFM, matrix removal efficiency was approximately 83.5%, which was equivalent to approximately 6-fold dilution of the matrix ion. The proposed hyphenated system of CFSE and FlFFF/CFM with ICP-OES detection was examined for its reliability by checking with SRM 2710 (a highly contaminated soil from Montana). The metal contents determined by the proposed method were not significantly different (at 95% confidence) from the certified values.     

Combination of gravitational SPLITT fractionation and field-flow fractionation for size-sorting and characterization of sea sediment

A combination of gravitational split-flow thin (SPLITT) fractionation and sedimentation/steric field-flow fractionation (Sd/StFFF) has been used for continuous size-sorting of a sediment sample and for size analysis of the collected fractions. An IAEA (International Atomic Energy Agency) sediment material was separated into four size fractions (with theoretical size ranges <1.0, 1.0–3.0, 3.0–5.0, and >5.0 m in diameter) by means of a three-step gravitational SPLITT fractionation (GSF) for which the same GSF channel was used throughout. The GSF fractions were collected and examined by optical microscopy (OM) and by Sd/St FFF. The mean diameters of the GSF fractions measured by OM were within the size interval predicted by GSF theory, despite the theory assuming that all particles are spherical, which is not true for the sediment particles. The Sd/St FFF results showed that retention shifted toward shorter elution time (or larger size) than expected, probably because of the shape effect. The results from GSF, OM, and Sd/StFFF are discussed in detail.     

Different methods for the fractionation of magnetic fluids

 Magnetic fluids are used in many fields of application, such as material separation and biomedicine. Magnetic fluids consist of magnetic nanoparticles, which commonly display a broad distribution of magnetic and nonmagnetic parameters. Therefore, upon application only a small number of particles contribute to the desired magnetic effect. In order to optimize magnetic fluids for applications preference is given to methods that separate magnetic nanoparticles according to their magnetic properties. Hence, a magnetic method was developed for the fractionation of magnetic fluids. Familiar size-exclusion chromatography of two different magnetic fluids was carried out for comparison. The fractions obtained and the original samples were also magnetically characterized by magnetic resonance and magnetorelaxometry, two biomedical applications. The size-exclusion fractions are similar to those of magnetic fractionation, despite the different separation mechanisms. In this respect, magnetic fractionation has several advantages in practical use over size-exclusion chromatography: the magnetic method is faster and has a higher capacity. The fractions obtained by both methods show distinctly different magnetic properties compared to the original samples and are therefore especially suited for applications such as magnetorelaxometry. Received: 12 July 1999/Accepted in revised form: 9 November 1999     

Improved theory of cyclical electrical field flow fractionation

Previously reported theories for cyclical electrical field flow fractionation (CyElFFF) are severely limited in that they do not account for diffusion, steric, or electric double layer effects. Experiments have shown that these theories overpredict the retention of particles in CyElFFF. In this work, we present a model for prediction of steric, diffusion, and electrical effects. The electrical double layer effects are treated using a lumped electrical circuit model that accounts for the field shielding by the electrical double layer formed at the electrode-carrier interface. The electrical effects are shown to dominate retention times and outweigh the contributions of diffusion and particle size. Detailed results from the simulations are presented in this work, and a comparison between the theoretical and experimental results obtained from the retentions of polystyrene particle standards is presented in this paper. The models are shown to correctly predict the retention of the polystyrene standards in CyElFFF with a reasonable error, while existing models are shown to have significant failings.     

Optimization of cyclical electrical field flow fractionation

Cyclical electrical field flow fractionation (CyElFFF) is a variation on electrical field flow fractionation (ElFFF) where cyclical electrical fields are used instead of steady DC fields to increase the effective field experienced by particles in the flow channel. Even though the effective field increases more than 20-fold compared to normal ElFFF, the retention and resolution in CyElFFF has not been shown to be better than in ElFFF. In this paper we report how one can optimize operational parameters in CyElFFF to obtain good retention and resolution in CyElFFF. The effects of offset voltage, frequency, flowrate, concentration of particles and sample size on retention, resolution and retained peak/void peak ratio have been observed. The results obtained from these experiments were analyzed and suggestions have been made to improve both retention and resolution. A 4-fold improvement in retention without a significant increase in band broadening is reported.     

Hollow-fiber flow/hyperlayer field-flow fractionation for the size characterization of airborne particle fractions obtained by SPLITT fractionation

Hollow-fiber flow field-flow fractionation (HF FlFFF) was applied for the separation and size characterization of airborne particles which were collected in a municipal area and prefractionated into four different-diameter intervals >5.0, 2.5-5.0, 1.5-2.5, <1.5 microm) by continuous split-flow thin (SPLIIT) fractionation. Experiments demonstrated the possibility of utilizing a hollow-fiber module for the high-performance separation of supramicron-sized airborne particles at steric/hyperlayer operating mode of HF FlFFF. Eluting particles during HF FlFFF separation were collected at short time intervals (approximately 10 s) for the microscopic examination. It showed that particle size and size distributions of all SPLITT fractions of airborne particles can be readily obtained using a calibration and that HF FlFFF can be utilized for the size confirmation of the sorted particle fraction during SPLITT fractionation.     

A quantitative approach to the analysis of supermicron dispersions by field-flow fractionation with UV-vis detectors. The application of an absolute method

Summary Quantitative analysis in field-flow fractionation is becoming a necessary requirement for routine applications, instrumental optimization and scale-up to preparative separations. The use of detection systems which show complex dependence on sample characteristics (i.e. UV spectrometry) has hindered the application of quantitative methods of analysis in field-flow fractionation. A standardless model, shown valid in flow-through, homogeneous systems, is applied here to a heterogeneous system (dispersed supermicron particles) in field-flow fractionation by single peak area measurements. Absolute analysis in the fractionation of spherical silica particles for high-performance liquid chromatography column packing by gravitational field-flow fractionation with UV-Vis detectors is presented. It has been shown that for such samples extinction coefficients are independent of sample concentration and are determined by the size and density of the particles. The accuracy of such an approach to absolute analysis is discussed. In memory of J. C. Giddings Presented at FFF'95-Fifth International Symposium on Field-Flow Fractionation, Park City, UT, USA, July 10–12 1995.     

Electrochemical response and separation in cyclic electric field-flow fractionation

Electric field-flow fractionation (EFFF) is a separation technique that couples a lateral electric field with axial Poiseuille flow to separate particles on the basis of size and/or mobility. In unidirectional EFFF, the field rapidly decreases in time due to charging of the double layer. The field strength could be increased by performing EFFF with cyclic electric fields. In cyclic electric field-flow fractionation (CEFFF), a periodic voltage, which can be either sinusoidal or square-wave, is applied in the lateral direction. In this paper, we measure the electrochemical response of CEFFF, i.e., the current-time response for a given time-dependent voltage and then utilize this electrochemical response in a transport model to predict separation. The CEFFF device studied here comprises two gold-coated glass plates separated by a spacer. The transient current profiles are measured for a step change and cyclic square-shaped voltage. The current profile is compared with the equivalent circuit model, and is fitted to a sum of two decaying exponentials. The dependence of the electrochemical response on voltage, frequency, channel thickness, and salt concentration is studied. Next, the electrochemical data are utilized in the convection-diffusion equation to develop a model for separation by CEFFF. The equations are solved by using a combination of analytical and numerical techniques to determine the mean velocity and the dispersion coefficient of molecules, and to determine the effect of various parameters on the separation efficiency of the EFFF device. Also, the model predictions are compared with experimental data available in the literature.     

Impact of non‐ideal analyte behavior on the separation of protein aggregates by asymmetric flow field‐flow fractionation

Asymmetric flow field‐flow fractionation is a valuable tool for the characterization of protein aggregates in biotechnology owing to its broad size range and unique separation principle. However, in practice asymmetric flow field‐flow fractionation is non‐trivial to use due to the major deviations from theory and the influence on separation by various factors that are not fully understood. Here, we report methods to assess the non‐ideal effects that influence asymmetric flow field‐flow fractionation separation and for the first time identify experimentally the main factors that impact it. Furthermore, we propose new approaches to minimize such non‐ideal behavior, showing that by adjusting the mobile phase composition (pH and ionic strength) the resolution of asymmetric flow field‐flow fractionation separation can be drastically improved. Additionally, we propose a best practice method for new proteins.     

Theoretical analysis of the local orientation effect and the lift‐hyperlayer mode of rodlike particles in field‐flow fractionation

We investigated theoretically the effects of the cross‐stream migration and the local average orientation of rodlike particles on the shape‐based separation using field‐flow fractionation. The separation behavior was analyzed by comparing the retention ratios of spheres and rods. The retention ratio of a rod was evaluated through the derivation of its cross‐sectional concentration profile by considering the rod migration and the local average orientation. Our study in various flow conditions showed that the rod migration, caused by the hydrodynamic interaction with a wall, can affect the separation behavior as a lift‐hyperlayer mode. We also demonstrated that the local average orientation, which is a function of a local shear rate and a rotational diffusivity, results in the transverse diffusivity that is different from its perpendicular diffusivity. These results suggest that the experimental separation behaviors of rods in field‐flow fractionation may not be fully explained by the current theory based on the normal mode and the steric mode. We also characterized each condition where one of the normal mode, the steric mode of spheres, and the lift‐hyperlayer mode of rods is dominant.     

Poisson's effects in electrical field flow fractionation

Recent and earlier models of electrical field flow fractionation (ELFFF) have assumed that the electric field within the fluid domain is governed by Laplace's equation. This assumption results in a linear potential and a spatially constant field across the channel and is generally true for very dilute systems and relatively high effective potentials. Experimental studies show, however, that the effective potential within the channel may be less than 1% of the applied potential; this is apparently due to double layer formation and charge buildup at the poles. In such cases, local analyte concentrations can, nonetheless, be orders of magnitude higher than the bulk mean and the local potential small, both of which can lead to a nonlinear spatial distribution of the field strength. In such cases Poisson's equation must be used rather than Laplace's equation. Steady-state ELFFF simulations were performed using a Poisson's equation-based model. The domain in which Laplace's equation is valid was identified and the effects of concentration and effective field strength on device performance were explored.