Use of isopycnic plots in designing operations of supercritical fluid chromatography: II. The isopycnic plots and the selection of the operating pressure-temperature zone in supercritical fluid chromatography

In SFC, the key chromatographic parameters, the retention factors and the column efficiency, strongly depend on the density of the mobile phase. This indicates that the isodensity or isopycnic plots, drawn on the pressure-temperature plane, can provide an effective tool to help analyzing how the chromatograms obtained in SFC evolve, when the experimental conditions, the inlet and outlet pressures and the column temperature, are changed. In a companion paper, we analyzed the role of density in controlling the physical properties of the mobile phase, which in turn controls solute retentions and column efficiencies. In this report, we analyze the operating conditions in SFC with reference to the isopycnic plots of carbon dioxide. This analysis clarifies the differences and similarities between the operating conditions selected in the subcritical zone and those located in the supercritical zone. It also sets out an operational map illustrating how retention factors vary with respect to the operating temperatures and pressures. This study is focused on the use of pure carbon dioxide as the mobile phase, but the same method of investigation is also applicable when the mobile phase contains a modifier.     

Isocratic networks in supercritical fluid chromatography

For chromatography with supercritical fluids (SFC), the dependence of the capacity ratios k′ and of the mean resolution R_m on temperature and pressure is presented as a three-dimensional diagram. A sufficient number of test chromatograms were run for the diagram to lead to an isocratic network in form of a curved surface. The isocratic network possesses a characteristic shape and contains all information about the temperature and pressure dependence of k′ and R_m for a given volume flow rate and chromatographic system. The specific system studied comprised pentane as the mobile phase, unmodified silica as the stationary phase, and a set of four polycyclic hydrocarbons as the test mixture. The isocratic net of this system allows interpolation of k′ and R_m for any temperature and pressure. Together with similar experimental data from other systems, this allows qualitative forecasts about the isocratic nets of other systems.     

A unified classification of stationary phases for packed column supercritical fluid chromatography

The use of supercritical fluids as chromatographic mobile phases allows to obtain rapid separations with high efficiency on packed columns, which could favour the replacement of numerous HPLC methods by supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) ones. Moreover, despite some unexpected chromatographic behaviours, general retention rules are now well understood, and mainly depend on the nature of the stationary phase. The use of polar stationary phases improves the retention of polar compounds, when C18-bonded silica favours the retention of hydrocarbonaceous compounds. In this sense, reversed-phase and normal-phase chromatography can be achieved in SFC, as in HPLC. However, these two domains are clearly separated in HPLC due to the opposite polarity of the mobile phases used for each method. In SFC, the same mobile phase can be used with both polar and non-polar stationary phases. Consequently, the need for a novel classification of stationary phases in SFC appears, allowing a unification of the classical reversed- and normal-phase domains. In this objective, the paper presents the development of a five-dimensional classification based on retention data for 94-111 solutes, using 28 commercially available columns representative of three major types of stationary phases. This classification diagram is based on a linear solvation energy relationship, on the use of solvation vectors and the calculation of similarity factors between the different chromatographic systems. This classification will be of great help in the choice of the well-suited stationary phase, either in regards of a particular separation or to improve the coupling of columns with complementary properties.     

Numerical modeling of the elution peak profiles of retained solutes in supercritical fluid chromatography

In supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), the significant expansion of the mobile phase along the column causes the formation of axial and radial gradients of temperature. Due to these gradients, the mobile phase density, its viscosity, its velocity, its diffusion coefficients, etc. are not constant throughout the column. This results in a nonuniform flow velocity distribution, itself causing a loss of column efficiency in certain cases, even at low flow rates, as they do in HPLC. At high flow rates, an important deformation of the elution profiles of the sample components may occur. The model previously used to account satisfactorily for the retention of an unsorbed solute in SFC is applied to the modeling of the elution peak profiles of retained compounds. The numerical solution of the combined heat and mass balance equations provides the temperature and the pressure profiles inside the column and values of the retention time and the band profiles of retained compounds that are in excellent agreement with independent experimental data for large value of mobile phase reduced density. At low reduced densities, the band profiles can strongly depend on the column axial distribution of porosity.     

Retention mechanisms in super/subcritical fluid chromatography on packed columns

Whereas the retention rules of achiral compounds are well defined in high-performance liquid chromatography, on the basis of the nature of the stationary phase, some difficulties appear in super/subcritical fluid chromatography on packed columns. This is mainly due to the supposed effect of volatility on retention behaviours in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) and to the nature of carbon dioxide, which is not polar, thus SFC is classified as a normal-phase separation technique. Moreover, additional effects are not well known and described. They are mainly related to density changes of the mobile phase or to adsorption of fluid on the stationary phase causing a modification of its surface. It is admitted that pressure or temperature modifications induce variation in the eluotropic strength of the mobile phase, but effects of flow rate or column length on retention factor changes are more surprising. Nevertheless, the retention behaviour in SFC first depends on the stationary phase nature. Working with polar stationary phases induces normal-phase retention behaviour, whereas using non-polar bonded phases induces reversed-phase retention behaviour. These rules are verified for most carbon dioxide-based mobile phases in common use (CO(2)/MeOH, CO(2)/acetonitrile or CO(2)/EtOH). Moreover, the absence of water in the mobile phase favours the interactions between the compounds and the stationary phase, compared to what occurs in hydro-organic liquids. Other stationary phases such as aromatic phases and polymers display intermediate behaviours. In this paper, all these behaviours are discussed, mainly by using log k-log k plots, which allow a simple comparison of stationary phase properties. Some examples are presented to illustrate these retention properties.     

Fundamental challenges and opportunities for preparative supercritical fluid chromatography

The use of supercritical fluids as mobile phases in chromatography was suggested nearly fifty years ago. In spite of some major potential advantages, this mode of chromatography, generally known as SFC, is only now beginning to be considered by the mainstream community but it still does not yet enjoy a popularity comparable to those of gas or liquid chromatography. This seems to be largely due to a combination of (1) the serious instrumental difficulties that took many years to solve; (2) the complexity of the behavior of supercritical fluids in chromatographic systems when their temperature, pressure, or composition changes; (3) the long-lasting absence of any substantial incentive to use more complex systems, when the simpler and more robust approaches provided by HPLC are available. This situation, however, has begun to significantly change during recent years. The incentive of employing green, sustainable technologies in industrial processes as well as in analyses is increasing. Because mobile phases generally used in SFC tend to be less environmentally harmful and less expensive than those used in HPLC, SFC presents strong economical and regulatory advantages over the latter technique. Added to that, steady advancements in LC techniques in the last three decades has solved many instrumental difficulties related to SFC, which is now taking full advantages of many of these advances. One factor, however, has remained mostly unresolved. A clearer understanding of the physico-chemical behavior of supercritical fluids in preparative chromatographic columns under nonlinear conditions is still needed. This seems to be the main obstacle to the establishment of SFC as a sustainable separation tool. One aim of this review is to highlight these issues in more detail through a survey of the state-of-the-art techniques available for the design and operation of SFC. Another aim is to outline a possible series of investigations, which are necessary to develop a better physical understanding of SFC.     

Use of isopycnic plots in designing operations of supercritical fluid chromatography. III: reason for the low column efficiency in the critical region

This paper discusses the origins of efficiency loss in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) when analyses are carried out in the low pressure supercritical region of carbon-dioxide, close to its critical point. Recent publications have shown strong evidence of radial thermal heterogeneity inside an SFC column and suggested that it leads to peak-shape distortion and greatly reduces the column efficiency. We demonstrate that the physico-chemical properties of CO(2) close to the critical point are such that formation of thermal heterogeneity inside the column is highly probable and could cause the observed efficiency loss. Consideration of isopycnic plots of CO(2) permits clear identification of the problematic region and explains why these properties of CO(2) are primarily responsible for the often perplexing efficiency losses taking place during the SFC operations.     

Retention in capillary supercritical fluid chromatography

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) sometimes exhibits GC-like behavior and sometimes LC-like behavior, depending on conditions. However, it is not always clear whether one of these types of behavior, or a combination, operates for a particular set of conditions for every solute in a mixture. For example, some components may be partitioned mostly by their vapor pressures, while others, in the same mixture, are partitioned predominantly by solvent-like properties of the mobile phase. Plots of retetion (as log of the capacity factor) vs. reciprocal temperature at constant pressure reveal a clear change in the character of the separation of well-behaved solutes. A thermodynamic explanation of the observed behavior is given, based on the assumption that partitioning is controlled by the heats of solution of solute in the mobile and stationary phases. A model of SFC retention as it deviates from pure-GC behavior on the same column is presented.     

Modifier effects on packed and capillary columns in supercritical fluid chromatography

Summary The separation of polar thermally labile solutes is one of the potentially most rewarding fields of SFC application. A presupposition for such applications is, however, mobile phases having relatively high solvent strengths. A promising approach to achieve this is the use of mobile phases consisting of carbon dioxide with a polar additive. In this work, the chromatographic effects of different concentrations of an additive, isopropanol, in carbon dioxide have been studied on capillary and packed columns. A series of antibiotics was used as test substances. Best results were obtained with carbon dioxide/8% isopropanol as mobile phase on a capillary column coated with a cyanopropyl-substituted polysiloxane stationary phase.     

Numerical modeling of elution peak profiles in supercritical fluid chromatography. Part I—Elution of an unretained tracer

When chromatography is carried out with high-density carbon dioxide as the main component of the mobile phase (a method generally known as “supercritical fluid chromatography” or SFC), the required pressure gradient along the column is moderate. However, this mobile phase is highly compressible and, under certain experimental conditions, its density may decrease significantly along the column. Such an expansion absorbs heat, cooling the column, which absorbs heat from the outside. The resulting heat transfer causes the formation of axial and radial gradients of temperature that may become large under certain conditions. Due to these gradients, the mobile phase velocity and most physico-chemical parameters of the system (viscosity, diffusion coefficients, etc.) are no longer constant throughout the column, resulting in a loss of column efficiency, even at low flow rates. At high flow rates and in serious cases, systematic variations of the retention factors and the separation factors with increasing flow rates and important deformations of the elution profiles of all sample components may occur. The model previously used to account satisfactorily for the effects of the viscous friction heating of the mobile phase in HPLC is adapted here to account for the expansion cooling of the mobile phase in SFC and is applied to the modeling of the elution peak profiles of an unretained compound in SFC. The numerical solution of the combined heat and mass balance equations provides temperature and pressure profiles inside the column, and values of the retention time and efficiency for elution of this unretained compound that are in excellent agreement with independent experimental data.     

Clinical and pharmaceutical applications of packed-column supercritical fluid chromatography

Packed-column supercritical fluid chromatography (pSFC) is a fast separation technique that combines the properties of HPLC and GC. pSFC with carbon dioxide as the mobile phase and packed silica column as the stationary phase possesses the properties of normal phase mechanism; however, the addition of modifiers to the mobile phase allows the separation of relatively polar compounds. In spite of its many positive attributes, pSFC has not been widely used in areas such as proteomics, where methods such as HPLC dominate. Packed column SFC has been extensively used in clinical and pharmaceutical laboratories, especially for separation of nonpolar and chiral drugs. This review will discuss recently published applications of pSFC, with a specific focus on its advantages and limitations for the analysis of pharmaceuticals with varying chemical properties.     

Sampling considerations in supercritical fluid chromatography

Summary Packed column supercritical fluid chromatography, like HPLC, utilizes a sample loop to introduce materials onto the column for analysis. Unlike HPLC the mobile phase in SFC cannot be used to dissolve the sample. In practice, this causes a solvent peak, which can create a problem in the chromatographic interpretation. This paper describes one approach to solving this problem. A valving scheme is used to extract materials with the supercritical CO₂ mobile phase and introduce them onto the column with no external handling. The viability of this method is demonstrated and separations of the CO₂ extracts for several materials are shown on various columns. Comparisons are made for coal and coffee extracts using this on-line method and conventional off-line CH₂Cl₂ extracts. Advantages of the on-line procedure as they apply to chromatography and high information detectors are also discussed.     

Rapid analysis using capillary supercritical fluid chromatography

Capillary supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) is proving to be a viable and useful separation method for thermally labile and nonvolatile materials. As with other capillary chromatographic techniques, very fast separations can be accomplished by sacrificing total efficiency and optimizing the conditions for rapid analysis. This is achieved using short, small-bore capillary columns, increased mobile phase linear velocities and very fast pressure programming rates. These principles are demonstrated for the rapid separation of selected component systems.     

Supercritical fluid chromatography: Retention, resolution, and gradient methods

Summary For applying gradient methods in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), the dependence of retention and resolution on the physical parameters, temperature, pressure/density, linear velocity, and mobile phase composition, is of particular relevance. This stems from the finding that the dependence of retention and resolution on physical parameters is more varied for SFC than for either gas or liquid chromatography. Thus, both retention and resolution tend to form maxima with temperature at constant pressure. In this communication, the dependence of capacity ratio k and resolution R on temperature and pressure is shown as three-dimensional plots. From these plots the general requirements for single and multiple gradients are discussed. In addition, equations are given which relate the contributions of vapor pressure and solvation to the measured capacity ratio k and selectivity .

---

Chromatographie mit überkritischen fluiden Phasen: Retention, Auflösung und Gradientenmethoden

     

Electrospray mass spectrometry and supercritical fluid chromatography of methylated beta-cyclodextrins.

Five commercial dimethylated beta-cyclodextrin (DM-beta-CD) samples were analysed by electrospray (or ionspray) mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) with evaporative light scattering detection. A silica and a nitro-bonded silica were selected using CO2-methanol-acetonitrile-water and CO2-methanol as mobile phase, respectively. An extensive optimisation scheme was performed for mobile phase selection. Both SFC systems were used for analyses of complex DM-beta-CD samples. Peak identifications were made using off-line ESI-MS. Commercial DM-beta-CDs are impure mixtures of homologues and isomers and analysis reveals that every manufacturer produces a different mixture.     

High-resolution analysis of polyprenols by supercritical fluid chromatography

A high-resolution analysis of polyprenol mixtures was achieved by supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). The separation of polyprenols was examined on an octadecylsilane-packed column with liquid carbon dioxide as the mobile phase and ethanol as modifier. Using this chromatography system, the resolution of separation (Rs) between octadecaprenol (prenol 18) and nonadecaprenol (prenol 19) was two times higher than that using conventional reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography. Our SFC technique allows the advantage of baseline separation of polyprenol samples containing hydrophobic components such as terpenes or fatty acids that are unfavorable for good separation. This method is very useful for the analysis of structurally close polyprenol analogues of rubber plant metabolites.     

Capillary supercritical fluid chromatography of limonoids

Capillary supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) with carbon dioxide as the mobile phase has been used to separate a mixture of limonoid standards. Chromatographic conditions were optimized to enable analysis of plant extracts. The seed of Aphanamixis polystacha (Meliaceae) and the stem bark of Harpephyllum caffrum (Anacardiaceae) were extracted with hexane and the extracts were analyzed by SFC to demonstrate the potential of the technique as a screening tool. SFC analysis indicated the presence of limonoids in the hexane extract of the bark of Entandrophragma delevoyii (Meliaceae). One limonoid and two protolimonoids isolated from the extract were separated by SFC.     

Synthetic ceramic clay material as stationary phase in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography

Summary A novel inorganic synthetic clay material (SC) has been evaluated as the stationary phase in packed-column, supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). The molecular recognition capability of the SC stationary phase in SFC for polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons has been evaluated using carbon dioxide and carbon dioxide modified with methanol as the mobile phase. This recognition derives from the layer structure of the SC material which acts as a slit to distinguish non-planar solutes from the molecular-molecular interaction between solute and stationary phase and leads to smaller retention for non-planar solutes. The recognition capability is also dependent on the SFC conditions such as column pressure and column temperature.     

Current technological challenges in capillary supercritical fluid chromatography

In cases where high efficiency is required to resolve complex mixtures of either thermally labile or nonvolatile organic compounds, capillary supercritical fluid chromatography may be the most desirable analytical method. While great strides in this new technology have been made over the last few years, several problem areas are requiring increased attention. These include sample introduction systems, pressure reduction at the end of the column, column stability in various supercritical mobile phases, and migration of polar solute molecules. This paper describes the state-of-the-art in capillary SFC with emphasis on the progress made and future needs in the solutions to these specific problems.     

Possibility of predicting separations in supercritical fluid chromatography with the solvation parameter model

In order to obtain a selection of optimal chromatographic columns for the separation of chlorotriazine pesticides in packed column supercritical fluid chromatography (pSFC), a multi-criteria approach is applied. For this purpose, prediction of the separations is carried out, based on quantitative structure–retention relationships, then Derringer's desirability function is proposed to determine the stationary phase that will result in the most desirable separation. The best SFC separation obtained was then optimized using a mobile phase gradient. Besides, the accuracy of the solvation parameter model as SFC retention predictive model is assessed.