Characterization of branched ultrahigh molar mass polymers by asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation and size exclusion chromatography

The molar mass distribution (MMD) of synthetic polymers is frequently analyzed by size exclusion chromatography (SEC) coupled to multi angle light scattering (MALS) detection. For ultrahigh molar mass (UHM) or branched polymers this method is not sufficient, because shear degradation and abnormal elution effects falsify the calculated molar mass distribution and information on branching. High temperatures above 130 °C have to be applied for dissolution and separation of semi-crystalline materials like polyolefins which requires special hardware setups. Asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AF4) offers the possibility to overcome some of the main problems of SEC due to the absence of an obstructing porous stationary phase. The SEC-separation mainly depends on the pore size distribution of the used column set. The analyte molecules can enter the pores of the stationary phase in dependence on their hydrodynamic volume. The archived separation is a result of the retention time of the analyte species inside SEC-column which depends on the accessibility of the pores, the residence time inside the pores and the diffusion ability of the analyte molecules. The elution order in SEC is typically from low to high hydrodynamic volume. On the contrary AF4 separates according to the diffusion coefficient of the analyte molecules as long as the chosen conditions support the normal FFF-separation mechanism. The separation takes place in an empty channel and is caused by a cross-flow field perpendicular to the solvent flow. The analyte molecules will arrange in different channel heights depending on the diffusion coefficients. The parabolic-shaped flow profile inside the channel leads to different elution velocities. The species with low hydrodynamic volume will elute first while the species with high hydrodynamic volume elute later. The AF4 can be performed at ambient or high temperature (AT-/HT-AF4). We have analyzed one low molar mass polyethylene sample and a number of narrow distributed polystyrene standards as reference materials with known structure by AT/HT-SEC and AT/HT-AF4. Low density polyethylenes as well as polypropylene and polybutadiene, containing high degrees of branching and high molar masses, have been analyzed with both methods. As in SEC the relationship between the radius of gyration (R(g)) or the molar mass and the elution volume is curved up towards high elution volumes, a correct calculation of the MMD and the molar mass average or branching ratio is not possible using the data from the SEC measurements. In contrast to SEC, AF4 allows the precise determination of the MMD, the molar mass averages as well as the degree of branching because the molar mass vs. elution volume curve and the conformation plot is not falsified in this technique. In addition, higher molar masses can be detected using HT-AF4 due to the absence of significant shear degradation in the channel. As a result the average molar masses obtained from AF4 are higher compared to SEC. The analysis time in AF4 is comparable to that of SEC but the adjustable cross-flow program allows the user to influence the separation efficiency which is not possible in SEC without a costly change of the whole column combination.     

Size exclusion chromatography with dual-beam refractive index gradient detection of polystyrene samples

Non-aqueous size exclusion chromatography (SEC) of polystyrenes (as model analytes) is examined using the microscale molar mass sensor (μ-MMS) for detection. The μ-MMS is combined with SEC to demonstrate this simultaneously universal and molar mass selective detection method for polymer characterization. The μ-MMS is based on measuring the refractive index gradient (RIG) at two positions (upstream and downstream) within a T-shaped microfluidic channel. The RIG is produced from a sample stream (eluting analytes in the mobile phase) merging with a mobile phase stream (mobile phase only). The magnitude of the RIG is measured as a probe beam deflection angle and is related to analyte diffusion coefficient, the time allowed for analyte diffusion from the sample stream toward the mobile phase stream, and the bulk phase analyte refractive index difference relative to the mobile phase. Thus, two deflection angles are measured simultaneously, the upstream angle and the downstream angle. An angle ratio is calculated by dividing the downstream angle by the upstream angle. The μ-MMS was found to extend the useful molar mass calibration range of the SEC system (nominally limited by the total exclusion and total permeation regions from ∼100,000 g/mol to ∼800 g/mol), to a range of 3,114,000-162 g/mol. The injected concentration LOD (based on 3 s statistics) was 2 ppm for the upstream detection position. The point-by-point time-dependent ratio, termed a ‘ratiogram’, is demonstrated for resolved and overlapped peaks. Within detector band broadening produces some anomalies in the ratiogram shapes, but with highly overlapped distributions of peaks this problem is diminished. Ratiogram plots are converted to molar mass as a function of time, demonstrating the utility of SEC/μ-MMS to examine a complex polymer mixture.     

Studies on high-performance size-exclusion chromatography of synthetic polymers. I. Volume of silica gel column packing pores reduced by retained macromolecules

Macromolecules, which stay adsorbed within the active size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) column packings may strongly reduce effective volume of the separation pores. This brings about a decrease of retention volumes of the non-retained polymer samples and results in the increased apparent molar mass values. The phenomenon has been demonstrated with a series of poly(methyl methacrylate)s (PMMA) and a polyethylenoxide (PEO) fully retained by adsorption within macroporous silica gel SEC column from toluene or tetrahydrofuran, respectively. The non-retained probes were polystyrenes (PS) in toluene and both PS and PMMA in THF eluents. The errors in the peak molar mass values determined for the non-retained polymer species using a column saturated with adsorbed macromolecules and considering calibration curves monitored for the original "bare" column packing assumed up to several hundreds of percent. Errors may appear also in the weight and number averages of molar masses calculated from calibration dependences obtained with columns saturated with adsorbed macromolecules. Moreover, the SEC peaks of species eluted from the polymer saturated columns were broadened and in some cases even split. These results demonstrate a necessity not only to periodically re-calibrate the SEC columns but also to remove macromolecules adsorbed within packing in the course of analyses.     

Separation of statistical poly[(N-vinyl pyrrolidone)-co-(vinyl acetate)]s by reversed-phase gradient liquid chromatography

Although size exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been used successfully to determine the molecular weight distribution (MWD) of statistical poly[(N-vinyl pyrrolidone)-co-(vinyl acetate)]s [PVPVAs], SEC cannot separate the copolymers according to their chemical composition. In this article, the separation of commercial PVPVAs with varying chemical compositions is reported, by aqueous reversed-phase gradient liquid chromatography (RPLC) using polystyrene-divinylbenzene-based wide pore columns. RPLC-SEC cross-fractionation indicates the presence of molar mass dependant effects during RPLC separation due to broad MWD for the copolymer studied; therefore the width of the RPLC peak could not be associated entirely with chemical composition distribution of the copolymer. Coupling of RPLC with online FTIR spectroscopy reveals the increase of VA content with increasing THF gradient, an indication of interaction mechanism between VA repeating units and the stationary phase for water soluble PVPVAs. Separation of water insoluble PVPVAs and PVAs by the RPLC are possibly based on both interaction and precipitation/redissolution mechanisms.     

Preferential solvation of poly(methyl methacrylate) and a bisphenol A diglycidyl ether by size-exclusion chromatography

The preferential adsorption coefficient, lambda, of poly(methyl methacrylate), PMMA, in solutions formed by an epoxy resin in tetrahydrofuran (THF), was studied by size-exclusion chromatography (SEC). Only PMMA of lowest molar mass was preferentially solvated by epoxy but at low concentrations of epoxy in the mixture. At higher epoxy content PMMA was preferentially solvated by THF. A simultaneous and competitive solvation between the specific interactions PMMA-epoxy and the self association of epoxy at high concentrations would be the responsible of this inversion point. The more compacted coil of PMMA of higher molecular weights in solution could explain the lack of interaction of these polymers with epoxy. The results also indicated that lambda decreased with the molar mass. This variation has been attributed to the influence of the coil segment density on preferential adsorption.     

Hexafluoroisopropanol as size exclusion chromatography mobile phase for polyamide 6

The present study deals with the use of hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP) as size exclusion chromatography (SEC) mobile phase for polyamide 6 (PA6). Contradictory conclusions relating to the use of HFIP as SEC mobile phase for polyamides are found in the literature. By using a multi-detector SEC apparatus equipped with on-line viscometer and multi-angle light scattering we have studied the chromatographic artifacts and the validity of the universal calibration (UC) in HFIP for different PA6 samples (hydrolytic and anionic, monofunctional or bifunctional activator). Appropriate SEC columns and optimized experimental conditions allow most of the chromatographic artifacts to be avoided, even in neat HFIP. The use of a salt in the mobile phase, namely 0.01 M tetraethylammonium nitrate (TEAN), slightly increases the elution volume for both PA6 and PMMA polymers. Under the right conditions, the UC substantially holds for PA6. The validity of the UC is not linked to the presence of TEAN in the mobile phase. With some PA6 samples, namely those anionically synthesized using a bifunctional activator, aggregation becomes a problem and the molar mass in neat HFIP is overestimated. Addition of TEAN prevents any aggregation of the above anionically synthesized PA6. In contrast, the use of a different salt, namely potassium trifluoroacetate, increases the extent of aggregation.     

Investigation of copolymers of styrene and ethyl methacrylate by size exclusion chromatography and gradient HPLC

Summary Copolymers of styrene and ethyl methacrylate have been separated according to composition by gradient HPLC on silica columns or CN bonded phase columns. This mode of separation according to composition was applied to fractions obtained by size exclusion chromatography (SEC). From viscosity and molecular mass data of copolymers with a styrene content ranging from 7.5 to 95.3 mass-% it can be concluded that SEC separates mainly by molecular mass even in this copolymer system. Thus, chromatographic cross-fractionation is possible by prefractionation by SEC and subsequent separation according to composition by gradient HPLC.

---

Untersuchung von Copolymeren von Styrol und Ethylmethacrylat durch Ausschluß-Chromatographie und Gradienten-HPLC

     

Association behaviour of lignins and lignin model compounds studied by multidetector size-exclusion chromatography

SEC elution curves of spruce milled wood lignin (MWL) and guaiacyl lignin polymer models (G-DHPs) in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) exhibited a bimodal elution profile. Light scattering measurements indicated that these elution profiles were due to association effects between the molecules. This became apparent from the determination of high molar masses in the range 10(5)-10(8) g/mol. To study this effect, MWL and DHP were fractionated by precipitation in tetrahydrofuran (THF). The THF-insoluble fractions were found to be the fractions corresponding to the apparent high molar mass part of the DMF elution profiles. The THF-soluble fractions proved to be the less-associated fractions, with lower apparent molecular mass. The individual fractions proved to be rather stable in DMF. Accordingly, the bimodal elution profiles of the starting materials were not the result of an equilibrium between associated and molecular dispersed molecules but of different structures exhibiting a specific and stable association pattern. The different fractions were further characterised by SEC in THF after acetylation to determine molar masses in molecular disperse solutions.     

Characterization of EO-PO Block Copolymers by Liquid Chromatography Under Critical Conditions

Summary: Block copolymers of ethylene oxide (EO) and propylene oxide (PO) are characterized by liquid chromatography under critical conditions (LCCC) for EO. At the critical adsorption point (CAP) for one structural unit, the non-critical block can elute in size exclusion (SEC) or adsorption (LAC) mode. Depending on the molar mass and architecture of the polymers, different strategies are applied. For samples with a higher molar mass, the SEC separation is the method of choice, while lower molar masses also allow a LAC separation. Examples for both situations are given, which show, that these approaches yield different information. In the SEC mode, homopolymers and diblocks can be separated from the triblocks. In LAC mode, a baseline resolution of individual oligomers can be achieved, in which homopolymers, diblocks and triblocks with the same number of repeat units of the non-critical block have the same elution volume.     

Synthetic and characterization aspects of dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate reversible addition fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization

2‐cyanoprop‐2‐yl dithiobenzoate (CPDB) mediated RAFT polymerization of dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate (DMAEMA) was carried out in dioxane at 90 °C. The influence of several parameters, such as the monomer to CPDB molar ratio (100 to 500), the monomer concentration (2 mol·L^?1 to 5.9 mol·L^?1), and CPDB to initiator molar ratio (1 to 10), was evaluated with regards to conversion and polymerization duration, as well as control of molar mass and molar mass distributions. Number average molar masses from 10,000 to 70,000 g·mol^?1 can be targeted. The determination of the molar masses has been carried out by size exclusion chromatography (SEC) with a refractometer detector with poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) standards. The experimental values were lower than the expected ones. Then, SEC in aqueous medium with an online laser light scattering detector was used both to get absolute molar masses and to recalibrate the SEC column in THF. Characterization of well‐controlled PDMAEMA samples has been performed by proton NMR spectroscopy and matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight mass spectrometry. Finally, a chain extension experiment was evaluated with regard to living features. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 43: 3551–3565, 2005     

Turbidimetric titration and gradient high-performance liquid chromatography of polystyrene samples

Summary Polystyrene samples of narrow molecular-weight distribution have been eluted according to their molecular weight from columns packed with bare silica Si50, phenyl, or C18 bonded phase by gradients of methanol and tetrahydrofuran (THF) or ofiso-octane and THF. Among the six combinations investigated,iso-octane/THF with a silica column formed a proper normal-phase system whereas methanol/THF with a C18 column formed a proper reversed-phase system. The combinations of C18 column andiso-octane/THF or of Si50 column and methanol/THF gradient did not correspond to the approved polarity rules in high-performance liquid chromatography but were nevertheless effective in separating polystyrene mixtures by molecular weight. Methanol andiso-octane are nonsolvents for polystyrene whereas THF is a solvent. The solubility of polystyrene as a function of molecular weight and concentration was determined by means of turbidimetric titration of solutions in THF with the nonsolvents used in the gradients. The solubility and elution characteristics were almost identical on C18 columns or in methanol/THF combinations. The elution from phenyl bonded phase and Si50 columns usingiso-octane/THF gradients required more THF than the solubility experiments. Information is also given on the occurrence of multimodal elution patterns.     

Characterisation of poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) by asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation, dynamic light scattering, and size exclusion chromatography

Asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation (AsFIFFF) was used to determine the hydrodynamic particle sizes, molar masses, and phase transition behaviour of various poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAM) samples synthesised by reversible addition--fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) and conventional free radical polymerisation processes. The results were compared with corresponding data obtained by dynamic light scattering (DLS) and size exclusion chromatography (SEC). Agreement between the three methods was good except at higher molar masses, where the molar mass averages obtained by SEC were much lower than those obtained by AsFIFFF and light scattering. The aggregation of the polymers, which are thermally sensitive, was studied by DLS and AsFIFFF at various temperatures. In deionised water there was an abrupt change in the particle size due to phase separation at approximately equal to 32-35 degrees C. The critical temperatures determined by AsFIFFF were 3-5 degrees C higher than those obtained by DLS.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography for the characterization of functional acrylate polymers

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography-size-exclusion chromatography (LC x SEC) was investigated as a tool for the characterization of functional poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) polymers. Ultraviolet-absorbance and evaporative light-scattering detection (ELSD) were used. A simple method to quantify ELSD data is presented. Each data point from the ELSD chromatogram can be converted into a mass concentration using experimental calibration curves. The qualitative and quantitative information obtained on two representative samples is used to demonstrate the applicability of LC x SEC for determining the mutually dependent molar-mass distributions (MMD) and functionality-type distributions (FTD) of functional polymers. The influence of the molar mass on the retention behavior in LC was investigated using LC x SEC for hydroxyl-functional PMMA polymers. The critical conditions, at which retention is--by definition--independent of molar mass, were not exactly the same for PMMA series with different end-groups. Our observations are in close agreement with theoretical curves reported in the literature. However, for practical applications of LC x SEC it is not strictly necessary to work at the exact critical solvent composition. Near-critical conditions are often sufficient to determine the mutually dependent distributions (MMD and FTD) of functional polymers.     

Analysis of polyamides by size exclusion chromatography and laser light scattering

The molar mass analysis of polyamides is complicated due to the fact that only a limited range of solvents can be used and association and aggregation phenomena have to be screened by adding electrolytes to the mobile phase. Optimum SEC behaviour is obtained when hexafluoroisopropanol + 0.05 mol/L potassium trifluoroacetate is used as the mobile phase. The calibration of the SEC system can be conducted in different ways. While a calibration with narrow disperse polymethyl methacrylate standards does not yield accurate molar mass information, the quantification can be done using an “artificial” calibration curve. This calibration curve is obtained by correcting the PMMA calibration curve with polyamide molar mass data from light scattering. The resulting molar mass distributions for different types of polyamides are compared with molar masses that are determined by size exclusion chromatography with a light scattering detector and an excellent correlation is obtained.     

Gradient elution chromatography of polymers on reversed-phase columns with tetrahydrofuran as an eluent component

Summary The chromatographic separation of poly(styrene-co-acrylonitrile) samples (SAN) with an elution gradient iso-octane/tetrahydrofuran is solubility governed. This has been proven by the correspondence between the volume fraction of precipitant as estimated from elution data and as measured by turbidimetric titration, by the molar mass dependence of retention, and by the temperature effect on retention. In addition to these arguments data are presented which have been obtained on columns with different packing materials ranging from bare silica through CN bonded phase material to hydrocarbonaceous stationary phases. The eluent composition at peak position is nearly independent of the stationary phase used. Presented at the 15th International Symposium on Chromatography, Nürnberg, October 1984     

Study of the abnormal late co-elution phenomenon of low density polyethylene in size exclusion chromatography using high temperature size exclusion chromatography and high temperature asymmetrical flow field-flow fractionation

The elution behaviour of linear and branched polyethylene samples in SEC was studied. For the branched samples an abnormal late co-elution of large and small macromolecules manifests itself as an abnormal re-increase of the molar mass and the radius of gyration values detected with multi angle light scattering at high elution volumes in SEC. The late co-elution of small and large macromolecules cannot be explained by the SEC mechanism alone. The influence of several experimental parameters on the late co-elution was studied. It was found that the type of SEC column and the flow rate have a significant influence. The late eluting part of the sample was fractionated and separated by HT-SEC- and HT-AF4-MALS. The different results of both methods have been discussed with the aim to find possible explanations for the late elution. The experiments indicate that especially large branched structures show an increased tendency for the phenomenon.     

Liquid chromatography of polymers under limiting conditions of desorption II. Tandem injection and quantitative molar mass determination

Liquid chromatography under limiting conditions of desorption (LC LCD) is a method which allows molar mass independent elution of various synthetic polymers. A narrow, slowly moving zone of small molecules, which promotes full adsorption of one kind of polymer species within column (an adsorli) acts as an impermeable barrier for the fast moving macromolecules. The latter accumulate on the barrier edge and elute nearly in total volume of liquid within column. At the same time, transport of less adsorptive macromolecules is not hampered so that these are eluted in the size exclusion (SEC) mode. As result, polymers differing in their polarity and adsorptivity can be easily separated without molar mass interference. Three methods of barrier creation are discussed and compared. It is shown that a fraction of sample may elute unretained if the adsorli sample solvent is used as a barrier in connection with a narrow-pore column packing. One part of excluded macromolecules likely breaks-out from the adsorli zone and this results in partial loss of sample and distortion of the LC LCD peaks. This problem can be avoided if the adsorli zone is injected immediately before sample solution. Applicability of the LC LCD method for polymer separation has been demonstrated with a model mixture of poly(methyl methacrylate) (adsorbing polymer) and polystyrene (non adsorbing polymer) using bare silica gel as a column packing with a combination of tetrahydrofuran (a desorption promoting liquid -a desorli) and toluene (adsorli). It has been shown that the LC LCD procedure with tandem injection allows simple and fast discrimination of polymer blend components with good repeatability and high sample recovery. For quantitative determination of molar masses of both LC LCD and SEC eluted polymers, an additional size exclusion chromatographic column can be applied either in a conventional way or in combination with a multi-angle light scattering detector. A single eluent is used in the latter column, which separates the mixed mobile phase, system peaks and the desorli zone from the polymer peaks so that measurements are free from disturbances caused by the changing eluent composition. The resulting LC LCD x SEC procedure has been successfully applied to poly(methyl methacrylate) samples.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography and hyphenated liquid chromatography to study the degradation of poly(bisphenol A)carbonate

Size exclusion chromatography (SEC), gradient polymer elution chromatography (GPEC) and liquid chromatography at critical conditions (LC-CC) have been developed and applied to observe chemical changes in poly(bisphenol A)carbonate (PC) due to hydrolytic degradation. Especially LC-CC appeared to be very successful to observe differences in functionality of PC as result of hydrolytic degradation. Observed differences due to degradation could be identified by (semi) on-line coupling to matrix assisted laser desorption-ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS). The differences in functionality could be attributed to the formation of different end-groups, i.e. OH end-groups. In addition, comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2D-LC) has been applied successfully to study the hydrolytic degradation of PC. LC-CC x SEC showed that the formation of PC with different end-groups occurred over the whole molecular mass range. This information could not be obtained with the separate liquid chromatographic techniques, thereby illustrating the added value of 2D-LC.     

Quasielastic light scattering as a method for determining the distribution of relaxation times in a polymer system

Amongst other techniques, dynamic light scattering may be used to obtain molar mass distributions. The first step in this process consists in the Laplace inversion of the time correlation function that was measured by dynamic light scattering. This inversion gives a distribution of diffusion coefficients. In order to convert this distribution into the corresponding molar mass distribution, a relationship between diffusion coefficient and molar mass of monodisperse fractions has to be known. Such a relationship can be derived for linear and star-branched macromolecules from measurements of polydisperse systems, since the polydispersity of the distributions does not change with the molar mass. The problem is more involved with randomly branched materials, since in these cases the polydispersity increases strongly as the point of gelation is approached. A procedure is suggested for deriving the diffusion-molar mass dependence of monodisperse samples from polydisperse systems. After an outline of this background the method is applied to the three selected systems (i) radically polymerized linear PMMA, (ii) a star-branched microgel where monodisperse arms are attached to a microgel center and (iii) a randomly branched poly(dicyanate) sample based on bisphenol A. The results are compared with the combined column chromatography SEC/LALLS/VISC. Good agreement was found up to molar masses of about 10 millions g/mol, but systematic deviations occured in the high molar mass region. These differences result from the limitations of size permeation chromatography. Finally it is shown that the size distribution can be determind by this method, even for associates.     

Liquid chromatography of polymer mixtures applying a combination of exclusion and full adsorption mechanisms. 5. Six-component blends of chemically similar polymers

The separation of six-component blends of chemically similar homopolymers utilising the full adsorption-desorption (FAD) process is presented. The main advantage of the FAD approach over other methods represents the successive and independent size- exclusion chromatography (SEC) characterisation of all blend components. The method is based on the full adsorption and retention of all n or n−1 components of the polymer blend from an adsorption promoting liquid (ADSORLI) in a small FAD column. Nonadsorbed macromolecules are forwarded directly into SEC for molecular characterisation. Next, appropriate displacers are successively applied to the FAD column to selectively release preadsorbed blend constituents into the on-line SEC column. Dynamic integral desorption isotherms for single constituents, as well as for polymer blends to be analysed, allow identification of optimal displacer compositions to release just one kind of macromolecule. Model polymer blends containing polystyrene (PS), poly(lauryl methacrylate), poly(butyl methacrylate), poly(ethyl methacrylate), poly(methyl methacrylate) and poly(ethylene oxide) (PEO) or, alternatively, PS, poly(2-ethylhexyl acrylate), poly(butyl acrylate), poly(ethyl acrylate), poly(methyl acrylate) and PEO of similar molar masses can be separated and characterised in one multistep run using nonporous silica FAD packing, toluene as an ADSORLI and its mixtures with a desorption promoting liquid such as ethyl acetate, tetrahydrofuran or dimetylformamide to form displacers with appropriate desorption strength. Received: 9 September 1998 Accepted in revised form: 16 November 1998