Strong dissimilarities between the gas-phase acidities of saturated and alpha,beta-unsaturated boranes and the corresponding alanes and gallanes

The effect that unsaturation has on the intrinsic acidity of boranes, alanes, and gallanes, was analyzed by B3 LYP and CCSD(T)/6-311+G(3df,2p) calculations on methyl-, ethyl-, vinyl-, and ethynylboranes, -alanes and -gallanes, and on the corresponding hydrides XH3. Quite unexpectedly, methylborane, which behaves as a carbon acid, is predicted to have an intrinsic acidity almost 200 kJ mol(-1) stronger than BH3, reflecting the large reinforcement of the C--B bond, which upon deprotonation becomes a double bond through the donation of the lone pair created on the carbon atom into the empty p orbital of the boron. Also unexpectedly, and for the same reason, the saturated and alpha,beta-unsaturated boranes are much stronger acids than the corresponding hydrocarbons, in spite of being carbon acids as well. The Al derivatives also behave as carbon acids, but in this case the most favorable deprotonation process occurs at C beta, leading to the formation of rather stable three-membered rings, again through the donation of the C beta lone pair into the empty p orbital of Al. For Ga-containing compounds the deprotonation of the GaH2 group is the most favorable process. Therefore only Ga derivatives behave similarly to the analogues of Groups 14, 15, and 16 of the periodic table, and the saturated derivatives exhibit a weaker acidity than the unsaturated ones. Within Group 13, boranes are stronger acids than alanes and gallanes. For ethyl and vinyl derivatives, alanes are stronger acids than gallanes. We have shown, for the first time, that acidity enhancement for primary heterocompounds is not only dictated by the position of the heteroatom in the periodic table and the nature of the substituent, but also by the bonding rearrangements triggered by the deprotonation of the neutral acid.     

Cyclization Triggered by Deprotonation: The Gas‐Phase Acidity of 1,8‐Chalcogen‐Bridged Naphthalenes

High‐level density functional theory computations have been used to estimate the gas‐phase (intrinsic) acidities of the complete series of 1,8‐chalcogen‐bridged naphthalene derivatives. The existence of a chalcogen? chalcogen bond in chalcogen‐bridged naphthalene derivatives plays a crucial role in the intrinsic acidity of the system. For 1,8‐naphthalenediylbis(oxy), where this bond does not exist, the para C? H group is the most acidic site, whereas for the remaining compounds, deprotonation of the ortho CH groups is the most favorable process. Deprotonation of the aromatic rings has a large effect on the strength of the bonds of the five‐membered ring. These effects depend on the nature of the heteroatoms forming the X? Y bridge, and modulate the acidity of the molecule. Also importantly, when one of the heteroatoms is oxygen, ortho and para deprotonation lead to cleavage of the X? Y bridge. This bond fission favors the formation of a CYC (Y=S, Se, Te) three‐membered ring that enhances the stability of the anion and, therefore, increases the acidity of these compounds. We have shown that, whereas this cyclization process is energetically favorable for oxygen‐containing compounds, it is not favorable for the remaining derivatives.     

Why Are Selenouracils as Basic as but Stronger Acids than Uracil in the Gas Phase?

The gas‐phase basicity and acidity of 2‐selenouracil ( 2SU ), 4‐selenouracil ( 4SU ), and 2,4‐diselenouracil ( 24SU ) have been calculated at the B3LYP/6‐311+G(3df,2p) level of theory. Our results showed that all these compounds behave as bases of moderate strength in the gas phase. As was found for uracil and for the thiouracil analogues, the most basic site is the heteroatom at position 4, and only for 2SU is there a certain ambiguity in assigning the basic site. More importantly, with the only exception of 2SU , selenouracils are as basic as or slightly less basic than uracil, because the replacement of the oxygen atom at position 2 by a selenium atom leads to an increase of the electron delocalization inside the six‐membered ring, which decreases the intrinsic basicity of the heteroatom at position 4. As already reported for uracil and thiouracils, for selenouracils N1 is the most acidic site. However, selenouracils are predicted to be stronger acids than uracil. This acidity enhancement is essentially due to a specific stabilization of the anion when O is replaced by Se. Two factors are responsible for this stabilization: a significant aromatization of the ring upon deprotonation and a better dispersion of the excess electron density when the system contains third‐row atoms.     

Probing the aromaticity of bis(diazolo)pyrazine radical anions

The aromaticity of a series of heterocyclic radical anions of bis(diazolo)pyrazine type, X(CN)₂N₂(CN)₂Y (X, Y = O, S, Se, Te) was explored by the methods of electron density of delocalized bonds (EDDB) and gauge-included magnetically induced currents (GIMIC). The existence of T-aromaticity that encloses the entire molecule, which was due to delocalization of seven β-electrons, was shown. The degree of aromaticity depends on the nature of the X(Y) heteroatom and varies in the series S > O > Se > Te.     

α,β‐Unsaturated and Saturated Derivatives of Be,Mg, and Ca: Are They Carbon or Metal Acids in the Gas Phase?

The gas-phase acidity of R--XH (R=H, CH(3), CH(2)CH(3), CH==CH(2), C[triple chemical bond]CH; X=Be, Mg, Ca) alkaline-earth-metal derivatives has been investigated through the use of high-level CCSD(T) calculations by using a 6-311+G(3df,2p) basis set. BeH(2) is a stronger acid than BH(3) and CH(4) for two concomitant reasons: 1) the dissociation energy of the Be--H bond is smaller than the dissociation energies of the B--H and C--H bonds, and 2) the electron affinity of BeH(.) is larger in absolute value than those of BH(2) (.) and CH(3) (.). The acidity also increases on going from BeH(2) to MgH(2) due to these two same factors. Quite importantly, despite the fact that the X--H bonds in the R--XH (X=Mg, Ca) derivatives exhibit the expected X(delta+)--H(delta-) polarity, they behave as metal acids in the gas phase and only Be derivatives behave as carbon acids in the gas phase. The ethylberyllium hydride exhibits an unexpected high acidity compared with the methyl derivative because deprotonation of the system is accompanied by a cyclization that stabilizes the anion. Similarly to that found for derivatives that contain heteroatoms from groups 14, 15, and 16, the unsaturated compounds are stronger acids than the saturated counterparts, with the only exception of the Ca-vinyl derivative. Most importantly, among ethyl, vinyl, and ethynyl derivatives containing a heteroatom of the main group of the Periodic Table, those containing Be, Mg, and Ca are among the strongest gas-phase acids.     

The role of chalcogen-chalcogen interactions in the intrinsic basicity acidity of beta-chalcogenovinyl(thio)aldehydes HC([double bond]X)[bond]CH[double bond]CH[bond]CYH

The intrinsic acidity and basicity of a series of beta-chalcogenovinyl(thio)aldehydes HC([double bond]X)[bond]CH[double bond]CH[bond]CYH (X=O, S; Y=Se, Te) were investigated by B3LYP/6-311+G(3df,2p) density functional and G2(MP2) calculations on geometries optimized at the B3LYP/6-31G(d) level for neutral molecules and at the B3LYP/6-31+G(d) level for anions. The results showed that selenovinylaldehyde and selenovinylthioaldehyde should behave as Se bases in the gas phase, because the most stable neutral conformer is stabilized by an X[bond]H...Se (X=O, S) intramolecular hydrogen bond (IHB). In contrast the Te-containing analogues behave as oxygen or sulfur bases, because the most stable conformer is stabilized by typical X...Y[bond]H chalcogen-chalcogen interactions. These compounds have a lower basicity than expected because either chalcogen-chalcogen interactions or IHBs become weaker upon protonation. Similarly, they are also weaker acids than expected because deprotonation results in a significantly destabilized anion. Loss of the proton from the X[bond]H or Y[bond]H groups is a much more favorable than from the C[bond]H groups. Therefore, for Se compounds the deprotonation process results in loss of the X[bond]H...Se (X=O, S) IHBs present in the most stable neutral conformer, while for Te-containing compounds the stabilizing X...Y[bond]H chalcogen-chalcogen interaction present in the most stable neutral conformer becomes repulsive in the corresponding anion.     

Ab initio and density functional theory studies of the structure,gas-phase acidity and aromaticity of tetraselenosquaric acid

Results of ab initio self-consistent-field (SCF) and density functional theory (DFT) calculations of the gas-phase structure,acidity (free energy of deprotonation,G0) and aro-maticity of tetraselenosquaric acid (3,4-diselenyl-3-cy-dobutene-1,2-diselenone,H2C4Se4) are reported.The global minimum found on the potential energy surface of tetraselenosquaric acid presents a planar conformation.The ZZ iso-mer was found to have the lowest energy among the three planar conformers and the ZZ and ZE isomers are very dose in energy.The optimized geometric parameters exhibit a bond length equalization relative to reference compounds,cyclobu-tanediselenone,and cydobutenediselenol.The computed aromatic stabilization energy (ASE) by homodesmotic reaction is -77.4 (MP2(fu)/6 - 311 G //RHF/6 - 311 G) and - 54.8 kJ/mol (B3LYP/6 - 311 G //B3LYP/6 -311 G).The aromaticity of tetraselenosquaric add is indicated by the calculated diamagnetic susceptibility exaltation (A) - 19.13 (CSGT(IGAEM) - RHF/6 - 311 G// RHF/6-     

Alkaline Earth Metallocenes Coordinated with Ester Pendants: Synthesis,Structural Characterization,and Application in Metathesis Reactions

A variety of ester‐substituted cyclopentadiene derivatives have been synthesized by one‐pot reactions of 1,4‐dilithio‐1,3‐butadienes, CO, and acid chlorides. Direct deprotonation of the ester‐substituted cyclopentadienes with Ae[N(SiMe₃)₂]₂ (Ae=Ca, Sr, Ba) efficiently generated members of a new class of heavier alkaline earth (Ca, Sr, Ba) metallocenes in good to excellent yields. Single‐crystal X‐ray structural analysis demonstrated that these heavier alkaline earth metallocenes incorporated two intramolecularly coordinated ester pendants and multiply‐substituted cyclopentadienyl ligands. The corresponding transition metal metallocenes, such as ferrocene derivatives and half‐sandwich cyclopentadienyl tricarbonylrhenium complexes, could be generated highly efficiently by metathesis reactions. The multiply‐substituted cyclopentadiene ligands bearing an ester pendant, and the corresponding heavier alkaline earth and transition‐metal metallocenes, may have further applications in coordination chemistry, organometallic chemistry, and organic synthesis.     

Acidity trends in alpha,beta-unsaturated sulfur, selenium, and tellurium derivatives: comparison with C-, Si-, Ge-, Sn-, N-, P-, As-, and Sb-containing analogues

The gas-phase acidity of CH3-CH2XH (X=S, Se, Te), CH2=CHXH (X=S, Se, Te) and PhXH (X=S, Se) compounds was measured by means of Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry. To analyze the role that unsaturation plays on the intrinsic acidity of these systems, a parallel theoretical study, in the framework of the G2 and the G2(MP2) theories, was carried out for all ethyl, ethenyl (vinyl), ethynyl, and phenyl O-, S-, Se-, and Te-containing derivatives. Unsaturated compounds are stronger acids than their saturated analogues, because of the strong pi-electron donor ability of the heteroatoms that contributes to a large stabilization of the unsaturated anions. Ethynyl derivatives are stronger acids than vinyl compounds, while phenyl derivatives have an intrinsic acidity intermediate between that of the corresponding vinyl and ethynyl analogues. The CH2=CHXH vinyl compounds (enol-like) behave systematically as slightly stronger acids than their CH3-C(H)X (keto-like) tautomers. Vinyl derivatives are stronger acids than ethyl compounds, because the anion stabilization attributable to unsaturation is greater than that undergone in the neutral compounds. Conversely, the enhanced acidity of the ethynyl derivatives with respect to the vinyl compounds is due to two concomitant effects, the stabilization of the anion and the destabilization of the neutral compound. The acidities of ethyl, vinyl, and ethynyl derivatives containing heteroatoms of Groups 14, 15, and 16 of the periodic table are closely related, and reflect the differences in electronegativity of the CH3CH2-, CH2=CH-, and CH[triple chemical bond]C- groups.     

Can Substituted Cyclopentadiene Become Aromatic or Antiaromatic?

Cyclopentadiene derivatives with electronegative (F, Cl) or electropositive (H(3)Si, Me(3)Si) bis-5,5-substituents were studied at the B3LYP/6-311G* level of theory. It was found that there is no special stabilization or destabilization for any of the derivatives; the energetic effects that were previously attributed to aromatic stabilization or antiaromatic destabilization are the result of interactions in the reference systems. A nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS) scan study at the HF-GIAO/6-311+G* theoretical level of these and similar derivatives suggest that they all show different magnitudes of diamagnetic ring current. None of the derivatives shows a paramagnetic ring current. Thus, cyclopentadienes are neither aromatic nor antiaromatic. It is also concluded that a diamagnetic ring current is perhaps necessary but certainly not a sufficient condition for aromaticity. The NICS scan procedure describes the type of ring current in the system, whereas a single isotropic NICS value (i.e., NICS(1)) may wrongly assign the type of ring current. It is shown that neither NICS(1) nor the NICS scan procedure can be used as a single aromaticity criterion.     

Comprehensive DFT calculations on organic sulfuric acid derivatives to design of powerful neutral organic superacids

In order to examine the acidity of organic sulfuric acid derivatives in gas phase, comprehensive density functional theory (DFT) calculations at B3LYP/6-31++G(d,p) level have been undertaken. In the title compounds, one of the oxygen atoms is substituted by an 1,3-cyclopentadiene group. The focus of this paper is on DFT studies of two classes of sulfuric acid derivatives: dithionic and peroxydisulfuric acids. Tautomers of proposed organic sulfuric acids are also investigated. DFT calculations indicate that the acidity of the proposed acids without any electron withdrawing groups on the ring was more than sulfuric acid.

     

Gas-phase protonation and deprotonation of acrylonitrile derivatives N[triple chemical bond]C--CH==CH--X (X=CH(3), NH(2), PH(2), SiH(3))

A combined experimental and theoretical study on the gas-phase basicity and acidity of a series of cyanovinyl derivatives is presented. The gas-phase basicities and acidities of (N[triple chemical bond]C--CH==CH--X, X=CH(3), NH(2)) were obtained by means of Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FT-ICR) mass spectrometry techniques. The corresponding calculated values were obtained at the G3B3 level of theory. The effects of exchanging CH(3) for SiH(3), and NH(2) for PH(2), were analyzed at the same level of theory. For the neutral molecules, the Z isomer is always the dominant species under standard gas-phase conditions at 298 K. The loss of the proton from the substituent X was found systematically to be much more favorable than deprotonation of the HC==CH linking group. The corresponding isomeric E ion is much more stable than the Z ion, so that only the former should be found in the gas phase. The most significant structural changes upon deprotonation occur for the methyl and amino derivatives because, in both cases, deprotonation of X leads to a significant charge delocalization in the corresponding anion. Protonation takes place systematically at the cyano group, whereby the isomeric E ion is again more stable than the Z ion. Push-pull effects explain the preference of aminoacrylonitrile to be protonated at the cyano group, which also explains the high basicity of this derivative relative to other members of the analyzed series that present rather similar gas-phase basicities, GB approximately 780 kJ mol(-1), indicating that the different nature of the substituents has only a weak effect on the intrinsic basicity of the cyano group. The cyanovinyl derivatives have a significantly stronger gas-phase acidity than that of the corresponding vinyl compounds CH(2)==CH--X. This acidity-strengthening effect of the cyano group is attributed to the greater stabilization of the anion with respect to the corresponding neutral compound.     

Aromaticity and Stability of Azaborines

The influence of the relative boron and nitrogen positions on aromaticity of the three isomeric 1,2‐, 1,3‐, and 1,4‐azaborines has been investigated by computing the extra cyclic resonance energy, NICS(0)_πzz index and by visualizing the π‐electron (de)shielding pattern as a response of the π system to a perpendicular magnetic field. The origin of the known stability trend, in which the 1,2‐/1,3‐isomer is the most/least stable, was examined by using an isomerization energy decomposition analysis. The 1,3‐arrangement of B and N atoms creates a charge separation in the π‐electron system, which was found to be responsible for the lowest stability of 1,3‐azaborine. This charge separation can, in turn, be considered as a driving force for the strongest cyclic π‐electron delocalization, making this same isomer the most aromatic. Despite the well‐known fact that the B?N bond attenuates electron delocalization due to large electronegativity difference between the atoms, the 1,4‐B,N relationship reduces aromaticity to a greater extent by making the π‐electron delocalization more one‐directional (from N to B) than cyclic. Thus, 1,4‐azaborine was found to be the least aromatic. Its lower stability with respect to the 1,2‐isomer was explained by the larger exchange repulsion.     

Long-distance structural consequences of H-bonding. How H-bonding affects aromaticity of the ring in variously substituted aniline/anilinium/anilide complexes with bases and acids

The aromaticity of the ring in variously substituted aniline/anilinium/anilide derivatives in their H-bonded complexes with various Broensted acids and bases was a subject of an analysis based on 332 experimental geometries retrieved from the Cambridge Structural Database and geometries optimized at the B3LYP/6-311+G** and MP2/aug-cc-pVDZ levels of theory. Ab initio modeling was applied to the para-substituted aniline, anilinium cation, and anilide anion derivatives (X = NO, NO2, CN, CHO, H, CH3, OCH3, and OH) and their H-bonded complexes (only for X = NO, NO2, CHO, H, and OH) with B (B = F- and CN-) or HB (HB = HF and HCN). In both cases, the harmonic oscillator model of aromaticity index (HOMA) was used, whereas for computational geometries, additionally, the magnetism-based indices NICS, NICS(1), and NICS(1)zz were also applied (NICS = nucleus-independent chemical shift). There is an equivalent prediction of aromaticity by NICSs and HOMA and approximate monotonic dependences of HOMA and NICS on the C-N bond length. The strongest changes in aromaticity estimated by HOMA and NICSs were found for aniline derivatives with NH2...B and anilide derivatives without and with NH-...HB interactions. The changes observed for two other kinds of interactions, NH2...HB and NH3+...base (for anilinium cations), are much smaller. For all four kinds of interactions, the relationships between ipso-bond angle, mean ipso-ortho bond length, and C-N bond length follow the Bent-Walsh rule.     

3,4-二硒方酸芳香性和气相酸性的理论研究

在ＲＨＦ／６－３１１Ｇ水平优化得到３,４－二硒方酸（３,４－二氢硒基－３－环丁烯－１,２－二酮）３ 种平面构象异构体的平衡几何构型。进一步用ＭＰ２（ｆｕｌｌ）／６－３１１Ｇ／／ＲＨＦ／／６－３１１Ｇ方法计算单点能量,发现ＺＺ型异构体是能量最低构象,且ＺＺ和ＺＥ型能量非常接近。用优化的最稳定构象ＺＺ型异构体在ＲＨＦ／６－３１１Ｇ／／ＲＨＦ／６－３１１Ｇ、ＲＨＦ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ／／ＲＨＦ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ、ＭＰ２（ｆｕｌｌ）／６－３１１＋ Ｇ／／ＲＨＦ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ 和Ｂ３ＬＹＰ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ／／Ｂ３ＬＹＰ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ水平计算其气相酸性（ΔＧ°）和同键反应芳香性稳定化能（ＨＡＳＥ）。用基团加和法（ｇｒｏｕｐ ｉｎｃｒｅｍ ｅｎｔ ａｐ－ｐｒｏａｃｈ ） 在 ＲＨＦ／６－３１１ ＋ Ｇ／／ＲＨＦ／６－３１１ ＋ Ｇ 和 Ｂ３ＬＹＰ／６－３１１ ＋ Ｇ／／Ｂ３ＬＹＰ／６－３１１＋ Ｇ水平计算其磁化率增量（Λ）。计算结果指出标题化合物的同键反应芳香性稳定化能和磁化率增量均为负值,表明它具有芳香性,实现了标题化合物芳香性的几何、能量和磁性的判定。     

1, 2-二硒方酸气相酸性和芳香性的理论研究

在RHF/6-311G^*^*水平优化得到1,2-二硒方酸(3,4-二羟基-3-环丁烯-1,2-二硒酮)三种平面构象异构体的平衡几何构型。进一步用MP2(full)/6-311G^*//RHF/6-311G^*^*方法计算三种异构体的单点能量,发现ZZ型异构体是能量最低构象,且ZZ和ZE型能量非常接近。用优化的最稳定构象ZZ型异构体在RHF/6-311G^*^*//RHF/6-311G^*^*,RHF/6-311+G^*^*//RHF/6-311+G^*^*,MP2(full)/6-311+G^*^*//RHF/6-311+G^*^*和B3LYP/6-311+G^*^*//B3LYP/6-311+G^*^*水平计算其气相酸性[ΔGⅲ~(~2~9~8~K~)]和同键反应芳香性稳定化能(HASE)。用基团加和法(groupincrementapproach)在RHF/6-311+G^*^*//RHF/6-311+G^*^*和B3LYP/6-311+G^*^*//B3LYP/6-311+G^*^*水平计算其磁化率增量(Λ)。计算结果指出标题化合物的键长发生了平均化,同键反应芳香性稳定化能和磁化率增量均为负值,表明它具有芳香性,实现了标题化合物芳香性的几何、能量和磁性的判定。     

Quantum chemical study of the reactivity of C60HR and C60(CHR) derivatives

In the present work a quantum chemical study of a series of substituted hydrofullerenes, C(60)HR, and a series of methanofullerenes, C(60)(CHR), is presented. Their reactivity and geometrical, energetic, electronic, and magnetic properties, as well as the influence of the substituent, are discussed. As a probe of the reactivity, the acidic properties of these fullerene derivatives were predicted, based on the calculated deprotonation energies, with a previously set up scheme. The electronic delocalization upon deprotonation was described, and the global (magnetizabilities) and local aromaticity (nucleus-independent chemical shifts) was analyzed and compared with respect to the group properties for the series of functional groups. The geometries of both acidic and basic forms were fully optimized at the AM1 level, and all property calculations were performed at the HF/3-21G and the B3LYP/6-31G* level of theory.     

Criteria for the elucidation of the pseudopericyclic character of the cyclization of (Z)-1,2,4,6-heptatetraene and its heterosubstituted analogues: magnetic properties and natural bond orbital analysis

The electrocyclization of heterosubstituted derivatives of (Z)-1,2,4,6-heptatetraene, (2Z)-2,4,5-hexatrien-1-imine and (2Z)-2,4,5-hexatrienal exhibit some features which suggest a pseudopericyclic mechanism. In order to examine this, a comprehensive study including the determination of magnetic properties to estimate aromaticity and an NBO analysis throughout the reaction path was conducted. The cyclization of 5oxo-2,4-pentadienal, a process of unequivocal pseudopericyclic nature, was studied for comparison. The results suggest that, although the lone electron pair on the heteroatom in the heptatetraene derivatives seemingly plays a crucial role in the reaction mechanism, it does not suffice to deprive the reaction from the essential features of a pericyclic disrotatory electrocyclization.     

3,4-二硫方酸芳香性和气相酸性的理论研究

在RHF/6-311G^**,RHF/6-311+G^**和B3LYP/6-311+G^**水平优化得到3,4-二硫方酸(3,4-二巯基-3-环丁烯-1,2-二酮)三种平面构象异构体的平衡几何构型.用MP2(Full)/6-311G^**//RHF/6-311G^**方法计算单点能量,发现ZZ型异构体是能量最低构象,且ZZ和ZE型能量非常接近.用优化的最稳定构象ZZ型异构体在RHF/6-311G^**//RHF/6-311G^**,RHF/6-311G^**//RHF/6-311G^**,MP2(Full)/6-311G^**//RHF/6-311G^**和B3LYP/6-311G^**//B3LYP/6-311G^**水平计算其气相酸性(ΔG⁰)和同键反应芳香性稳定化能(HASE).用基团加和法(Group Increment Approach)在RHF/6-311G^**//RHF/6-311G^**和B3LYP/6-311G^**//B3LYP/6-311G^**水平计算其磁化率增量(Λ).计算结果表明,标题化合物的同键反应芳香性稳定化能和磁化率增量均为负值,表明它具有芳香性,实现了标题化合物芳香性的几何、能量和磁性的判定.     

Reactions that generate aromatic molecules: is aromatic stabilization less or more advanced than bond changes at the transition state? Kinetic and thermodynamic acidities of rhenium carbene complexes

A kinetic study of the reversible deprotonation of the rhenium carbene complexes 1H(+)(O), 1H(+)(S) and 2H(+)(O) by carboxylate ions, primary aliphatic and secondary alicyclic amines, water and OH(-) in 50% MeCN-50% water (v/v) at 25 degrees C is reported. These carbene complexes are of special interest because in their deprotonated form they represent derivatives of the aromatic heterocycles furan, thiophene and benzofuran. Intrinsic rate constants (k(o) for Delta G degrees = 0) determined from appropriate Br?nsted plots for these rhenium carbene complexes and for the corresponding selenophene (1H(+)(Se)) and benzothiophene (2H(+)(S)) derivatives investigated earlier follow the orders furan < selenophene < thiophene and benzofuran less, similar benzothiophene. These orders indicate that an increase in aromaticity leads to an increase in the intrinsic rate constant or a decrease in the intrinsic barrier. This is an unexpected result; it implies that, in contrast to common resonance effects, the development of aromaticity at the transition state is ahead of proton transfer, i.e., the percentage development of the aromatic stabilization energy at the transition state is higher than the percentage of proton transfer.