Investigation on elemental and isotopic fractionation during 196 nm femtosecond laser ablation multiple collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

Despite the large number of successful applications of laser ablation, elemental and isotopic fractionation coupled to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) remain as the main limitations for many applications of this technique in the fields of analytical chemistry and Earth Sciences. A substantial effort has been made to control such fractionations, which are well-established features of nanosecond laser ablation systems. Technological advancements made over the past decade now allow the ablation of solids by femtosecond laser pulses in the deep ultraviolet (UV) region at wavelengths less than 200 nm. Here the use of femtosecond laser ablation and its effects on elemental and isotopic fractionation is investigated. The Pb/U system is used to illustrate elemental fractionation and stable Fe isotopes are used to illustrate isotopic fractionation. No elemental fractionation is observed beyond the precision of the multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (MC-ICP-MS) measurements. Without a matrix match between standard and sample, elemental fractionation is absent even when using different laser ablation protocols for standardization and samples (spot versus raster). Furthermore, we found that laser ablation-induced isotope ratio drifts, commonly observed during nanosecond laser ablation, are undetectable during ultraviolet femtosecond laser ablation. So far the precision obtained for Fe isotope ratio determinations is 0.1‰ (2 standard deviation) for the ⁵⁶Fe/⁵⁴Fe ratio. This is close to that obtainable by solution multiple-collector inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. The accuracy of the results appears to be independent of the matrix used for standardization. The resulting smaller particle sizes reduce fractionation processes. Femtosecond laser ablation carries the potential to solve some of the difficulties encountered during the two prior decades since the introduction of laser ablation.     

Characterizing ablation and aerosol generation during elemental fractionation on absorption modified lithium tetraborate glasses using LA-ICP-MS

The influence of sample matrix composition, absorption behavior and laser aerosol particle size distribution on elemental fractionation in laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry was studied for nanosecond laser ablation at a wavelength of 266 nm. To this end, lithium tetraborate glass samples with different iron oxide contents and trace amounts of a group of 11 elements were prepared synthetically. The samples were characterized in terms of optical absorbance, melting points, trace element concentrations and homogeneity. UV/VIS spectra showed that sample absorption rises with increasing Fe₂O₃ content. Crater depths and time-dependent particle size distributions were measured, and ablated and transported sample volumes were estimated. Furthermore, the laser aerosol was filtered using a particle separation device and transient ICP-MS signals were acquired with and without filtering the aerosol. The results demonstrate that the amount of ablated sample is related to the absorption coefficient of the sample and therefore to the optical penetration depth of the laser beam into the sample. The higher energy densities resulting from the shorter penetration depths result in smaller average particle sizes for highly absorbing samples, which allows more efficient transport to and atomization and excitation of the ablated material within the ICP. The particle size distribution changes continuously with ablation time, and larger particle fractions occur mainly at the beginning of the ablation, which leads to particle-related fractionation processes at the beginning of the transient signal. Exceeding a critical depth to diameter ratio, laser-related elemental fractionation processes occur. Changes in the volatile to non-volatile element intensity ratio after the aerosol is filtered indicate that particle size-related enrichment processes contribute to elemental fractionation.     

Laser ablation in analytical chemistry-a review

Laser ablation is becoming a dominant technology for direct solid sampling in analytical chemistry. Laser ablation refers to the process in which an intense burst of energy delivered by a short laser pulse is used to sample (remove a portion of) a material. The advantages of laser ablation chemical analysis include direct characterization of solids, no chemical procedures for dissolution, reduced risk of contamination or sample loss, analysis of very small samples not separable for solution analysis, and determination of spatial distributions of elemental composition. This review describes recent research to understand and utilize laser ablation for direct solid sampling, with emphasis on sample introduction to an inductively coupled plasma (ICP). Current research related to contemporary experimental systems, calibration and optimization, and fractionation is discussed, with a summary of applications in several areas.     

Laser sampling in inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry in the inorganic analysis of solid samples: Elemental fractionation as the main source of errors

The review is devoted to one of currently most often used methods for the study of the elemental composition of samples differing by origin and matrix, laser sampling (LS), in combination with inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry. The method ensures the analysis of samples without their transfer into solution and with high spatial resolution, up to several micrometers. The main restriction of laser sampling is due to elemental and isotopic fractionation, proceeding in the interaction of laser irradiance with the sample surface, on which photoelectronic and thermal processes, resulting in the formation of sample aerosols of different nature, can occur depending on the characteristics of laser irradiance. The paper covers works on the study of the effect of the laser wavelength, pulse duration, pulse fluence, plasma screening, explosive boiling, and the crater geometry on elemental fractionation and works in which fractionation coefficients were calculated on the basis of experimental data.     

激光剥蚀电感耦合等离子体质谱法中生物样品的元素分馏效应研究

采用213 nm-纳秒激光剥蚀系统对生物基体样品的剥蚀颗粒进行研究,优化了激光剥蚀条件.在剥蚀能量为25%,束斑直径为200 μm,剥蚀速率为20 μm/s,频率为20 Hz,载气为700 mL He + 700 mL Ar时,信号强度及稳定性最佳.以31P为内标元素,最佳剥蚀条件下,考察了56个元素的相对分馏因子.结果表明,生物基体的剥蚀颗粒相较于NIST 610 玻璃标样更大,达到3 μm;生物基体中元素分馏效应相较于玻璃基体小,大多数元素的相对分馏因子达到1.0 ±0.1.探讨了生物基体中元素分馏机理,分析了生物基体相较于玻璃基体剥蚀颗粒大,而相对分馏因子未明显增大的原因.一方面可能是粒径3 μm的颗粒进入电感耦合等离子体后能原子化;另一方面,大的剥蚀颗粒的富集效应相对较小.进一步对分馏效应的影响因素进行研究,发现分馏效应与激光剥蚀能量、激光频率和扫描速率相关,并且与元素的氧化物沸点负相关,与氧化物键能和电离能正相关.     

Analyte response in laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

The dependence of analyte sensitivity and vaporization efficiency on the operating parameters of an inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICPMS) was investigated for a wide range of elements in aerosols, produced by laser ablation of silicate glass. The ion signals were recorded for different carrier gas flow rates at different plasma power for two different laser ablation systems and carrier gases. Differences in atomization efficiency and analyte sensitivity are significant for the two gases and the particle size distribution of the aerosol. Vaporization of the aerosol is enhanced when helium is used, which is attributed to a better energy-transfer from the plasma to the central channel of the ICP and a higher diffusion rate of the vaporized material. This minimizes elemental fractionation caused by sequential evaporation and reduces diffusion losses in the ICP. The sensitivity change with carrier gas flow variation is dependent on m/z of the analyte ion and the chemical properties of the element. Elements with high vaporization temperatures reach a maximum at lower gas flow rates than easily vaporized elements. The sensitivity change is furthermore dependent on m/z of the analyte ion, due to the mass dependence of the ion kinetic energies. The mass response curve of the ICPMS is thus not only a result of space charge effects in the ion optics but is also affected by radial diffusion of analyte ions and the mismatch between their kinetic energy after expansion in the vacuum interface and the ion optic settings.     

Laser defocusing effects on laser ablation inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometry: different ablation interactions between the laser and low-alloy steel, Fe pellets, and a pond sediment pellet.

The ablation interaction between a laser and solid samples, which affects the analytical performance for laser ablation inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry (LA-ICP-AES), was studied. The emission intensities of elements observed by LA-ICP-AES (LA-ICP-AES element signal intensities) for different solid samples were measured under different laser defocusing conditions with a fixed laser output energy. It was found that the optimum laser defocusing conditions were dependent on the different solid samples with different sample characteristics, and also on the different elements with different elemental characteristics in each solid sample. A low-alloy steel, pellets containing different Fe concentrations (0 - 100% Fe pellet), and a pond sediment pellet were used as different solid samples. The variations of the LA-ICP-AES Fe signal intensities observed under different laser defocus conditions were completely different between the low-alloy steel and the pond sediment pellet. The changes in the LA-ICP-AES Fe signal intensities for 90 and 100% Fe pellets were similar to that of the low-alloy steel. However, pellets with lower Fe concentrations (less than 70%) showed different trends and the defocusing behavior became closer to that of the pond sediment pellet. The LA-ICP-AES signal intensities of other elements were also evaluated, and were compared for different solid samples and different defocusing behavior. It was observed that the changes in the LA-ICP-AES signal intensities of almost all elements in the pond sediment pellet showed a similar trend to those of Fe for different laser defocus positions; that is, the elemental fractionation for these elements in the pond sediment pellet seemed to be relatively small. On the contrary, it was found that the LA-ICP-AES Si, Ti, and Zr signal intensities for low-alloy steel showed different trends compared to those of other elements, including Fe, under different defocusing conditions; that is, the elemental fractionation observed for the low-alloy steel was larger than that of the pond sediment pellet. From these results, different ablation interactions between the laser and the different solid samples were considered, and attributed to the sample characteristics, such as the matrix, hardness, and conductivity. Elemental fractionation was attempted to be explained by using elemental characteristics, such as the melting point and ionization energy of the elements.     

Phenomenological studies on structure and elemental composition of nanosecond and femtosecond laser-generated aerosols with implications on laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

In laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICPMS), the properties of laser-generated aerosols, such as size and composition, are crucial for matrix-independent quantification. In this study, the aerosol particle morphology and elemental composition generated by two state-of-the-art laser systems (ArF excimer nanosecond-UV laser and Ti:sapphire femtosecond-IR laser) were investigated by electron microscopic techniques. Electrostatic sampling of the aerosols directly onto transmission electron microscopy (TEM) grids allowed us to study the morphology and elemental composition of the aerosols using TEM and TEM–EDX (energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy) analyses, respectively. The results of the electron microscopic studies were finally compared to the LA-ICPMS signals of the main matrix components. The investigations were carried out for non-conducting materials (glass and zircon), metallic samples (steel and brass) and semiconductors (sulfides). The studies confirm that ns-LA-generated aerosols dominantly consist of nanoparticle agglomerates while conducting samples additionally contain larger spherical particles (diameter typically 50 to 500 nm). In contrast to ns-laser ablation, fs-LA-generated aerosols consist of a mixture of spherical particles and nanoparticle agglomerates for all investigated samples. Surprisingly, the differences in elemental composition between nanoparticle agglomerates and spherical particles produced with fs-LA were much more pronounced than in the case of ns-LA, especially for zircon (Si/Zr fractionation) and brass (Cu/Zn fractionation). These observations indicate different ablation and particle formation mechanisms for ns- and fs-LA. The particle growth mechanism for ns-LA is most likely a gas-to-particle conversion followed by agglomeration and additional hydrodynamic sputtering for conducting samples. On the other hand, phase explosion is assumed to be responsible for the mixture of large spherical particles and nanoparticle agglomerates as found for fs-LA-generated aerosols. Based on these mechanisms, the overall temporal elemental fractionation effects in ns-LA-ICPMS seem to occur mainly during the ablation. This effect was not observed for fs-LA-ICPMS despite the element separation into different particle fractions, which, on the other hand, could induce severe ICP-induced fractionation.     

硫化物矿物LA-ICP-MS激光剥蚀元素信号响应

采用193 nm ArF准分子激光剥蚀电感耦合等离子体质谱(LA-ICP-MS)对5种天然硫化物矿物进行激光剥蚀分析, 基于不同硫化物矿物的剥蚀形貌特征和元素瞬时信号响应, 考察了硫化物矿物的元素分馏效应及激光频率、能量和激光斑径对硫化物矿物激光剥蚀行为的影响. 结果表明, 不同硫化物矿物的激光剥蚀形貌和元素分馏效应存在明显差异, 其中黄铁矿、辉钼矿和闪锌矿的剥蚀晕约为剥蚀斑径的10倍, 而黄铜矿和磁黄铁矿的剥蚀晕约为剥蚀斑径的14倍; 黄铜矿、磁黄铁矿和闪锌矿元素分馏因子(EFI)约为1.0, 其元素分馏效应可以忽略, 而黄铁矿和辉钼矿存在明显的元素分馏效应. 在对硫化物矿物的LA-ICP-MS分析中, 选择较大的激光剥蚀斑径、较小的激光剥蚀频率与激光能量可获得理想的信号强度和准确的分析结果.     

Ablative and transport fractionation of trace elements during laser sampling of glass and copper

The fractionation of trace elements due to ablation and transport processes was quantified during Q-switched infrared laser sampling of glass and copper reference materials. Filter-trapping of the ablated product at different points in the sample introduction system showed ablation and transport sometimes caused opposing fractionation effects, leading to a confounded measure of overall (ablative + transport) fractionation. An unexpected result was the greater ablative fractionation of some elements (Au, Ag, Bi, Te in glass and Au, Be, Bi, Ni, Te in copper) at a higher laser fluence of 1.35 × 10⁴W cm⁻² than at 0.62 × 10⁴W cm⁻², which contradicted predictions from modelling studies of ablation processes. With glass, there was an inverse logarithmic relationship between the extent of ablative and overall fractionation and element oxide melting point (OMPs), with elements with OMPs < 1000°C exhibiting overall concentration increases of 20–1340%. Fractionation during transport was quantitatively important for most certified elements in copper, and for the most volatile elements (Au, Ag, Bi, Te) in glass. Elements common to both matrices showed 50–100% higher ablative fractionation in copper, possibly because of greater heat conductance away from the ablation site causing increased element volatilisation or zone refinement. These differences between matrices indicate that non-matrix-matched standardisation is likely to provide inaccurate calibration of laser ablation inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry analyses of at least some elements.     

Characterization of laser-irradiated YNi 2 B 2 C surfaces by Auger electron spectroscopy

The suitability of laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS) for precise analysis of YNi(2)B(2)C has been investigated. The intensity ratios B/Y and Ni/Y were found to vary during ablation as a function of the ablation conditions. This could be because of fractionation, owing to incongruent ablation or transport and plasma effects. The bottoms and surroundings of the craters were investigated by scanning Auger electron spectrometry. The bottoms of the craters produced by ablation are covered with a thin oxide comparable with that on the polished crystal surface.The craters are surrounded by an oxide layer the dimensions and thickness of which depend on the laser conditions. The formation of this oxide can be assumed to be a result of partial oxidation of sample material during the ablation process; the oxide is then redeposited around the laser crater.     

Development and fundamental investigation of Laser Ablation Glow Discharge Time-Of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LA-GD-TOFMS)

Glow Discharge (GD) spectroscopy is a well known and accepted technique for the bulk and surface composition analysis, while laser ablation (LA) provides analysis with high spatial-resolution analysis in LIBS (laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy) or when coupled to inductively coupled plasma spectrometry (ICP-OES or ICP-MS). This work concerns the construction of a Laser Ablation Glow Discharge Time-Of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LA-GD-TOFMS) instrument to study the analytical capabilities resulting from the interaction of a laser-generated sample plume with a pulsed glow discharge. Two ablation configurations were studied in detail. In a first approach, the laser-generated plume was introduced directly into the GD, while the second approach generated the plume inside the GD. The ablated material was introduced at different times with respect to the discharge pulse in order to exploit the efficient ionization in the GD plasma. For both LA-GD configurations, direct ablation into the afterglow of the pulsed glow discharge leads to an ion signal enhancement of up to a factor of 7, as compared to the ablation process alone under the same experimental conditions. The LA-GD enhancement was found to occur exclusively in the GD afterglow, with a maximum ablation S/N occurring in a few hundred microseconds after the termination of the glow discharge. The duration of the enhanced signal is about two milliseconds. Both the laser pulse energy and the position of the ablation plume (with respect to the sampling orifice) were found to affect the amount of mass entering the afterglow region and consequently, the enhancement factor of ionization.     

Development of an on-line low gas pressure cell for laser ablation-ICP-mass spectrometry.

An on-line low gas pressure cell device has been developed for elemental analysis using laser ablation-ICP-mass spectrometry (LA-ICPMS). Ambient gas in the sample cell was evacuated by a constant-flow diaphragm pump, and the pressure of the sample cell was controlled by changing the flow rate of He-inlet gas. The degree of sample re-deposition around the ablation pit could be reduced when the pressure of the ambient gas was lower than 50 kPa. Produced sample aerosol was drawn and taken from the outlet of the diaphragm pump, and directly introduced into the ICP ion source. The flow rate of He gas controls not only the gas pressure in the sample cell, but also the transport efficiency of the sample particles from the cell to the ICP, and the gas flow rate must be optimized to maximize the signal intensity of the analytes. The flow rates of the He carrier and Ar makeup gas were tuned to maximize the signal intensity of the analytes, and in the case of (238)U from the NIST SRM610 glass material, the signal intensity could be maximized with gas flow rates of 0.4 L/min for He and 1.2 L/min for Ar. The resulting gas pressure in the cell was 30 - 35 kPa. Using the low gas pressure cell device, the stability in the signal intensities and the resulting precision in isotopic ratio measurements were evaluated. The signal intensity profile of (63)Cu obtained by laser ablation from a metallic sample (NIST SRM976) demonstrated that typical spikes in the transient signal, which can become a large source of analytical error, were no longer found. The resulting precision in the (65)Cu/(63)Cu ratio measurements was 2 - 3% (n = 10, 2SD), which was half of the level obtained by laser ablation under atmospheric pressure (6 - 10%). The newly developed low-pressure cell device provides easier optimization of the operational conditions, together with smaller degrees of sample re-deposition and better stability in the signal intensity, even from a metallic sample.     

Plasma chemistry in laser ablation processes

Based on the results of quantitative spectroscopic diagnostics (LIF in combination with time resolved emission spectroscopy) chemical dynamics in laser-produced plasmas of metallic (Ti, Al,), and graphite samples have been examined. The Nd-YAG (1064 nm, 10 ns, 100 mJ) and excimer XeCl (308 nm, 10 ns, 10 mJ) lasers were employed for ablation. The main attention was focused on the elucidation of a role of oxide and dimer formation in controlling spatio-temporal distributions of different species in the ablation plume. The results of the spatial and temporal analysis of a laser-produced plasma in air indicates the existence of diatomic oxides in the ablation plume both in the ground and excited states, which are formed from reactions between ablated metal atoms and oxygen. The efficiency of the oxidation reaction depends on the intensity and spot diameter of the ablation laser beam. The maximal concentration of TiO molecules are estimated to be of 1×10¹⁴ cm⁻³ at the time of 10 μs after the start of the ablation pulse. A comparison of spatial–temporal distributions of Ti atoms and excited TiO molecules allow us to find a correlation in their change, which proves that electronically excited Ti oxides are most probably formed from oxidation of atoms in the ground and low lying metastable states. The spectroscopic characterization of pulsed laser ablation carbon plasma has also been performed. The time–space distributions as well as the high vibrational temperature of C₂ molecules indicate that the dominant mechanism for production of C₂ is the atomic carbon recombination.     

Emission and electron/ion analysis of the ablated plume from LiYF4 crystals doped with Tm3+ or Nd3+ ions

We performed temporal as well as frequency-resolved emission spectroscopy of the plasma plume generated in vacuum by 355 nm pulsed laser ablation of a LiYF₄:Tm³⁺ crystal (1% Tm³⁺ concentration) and a LiYF₄:Nd³⁺ crystal (1.5% Nd³⁺ concentration). The plume emission spectrum is very rich in features and shows the elemental lines belonging to all the components of the host lattice, either neutral or ionized. The time-resolved analysis of some emission features is discussed and some stream velocities are derived. A possible model for the time evolution of the plume components is reported. The electronic detection technique was used to detect the onset of the plasma plume and to measure the ablation laser fluence threshold.     

Novel multichannel plasma-source mass spectrometer

A novel mass spectrometer system for elemental analysis is described. The instrument combines an inductively coupled plasma (ICP) ion source with a Mattauch-Herzog mass spectrometer and multichannel ion detector. Ion detection is simultaneous and an elemental mass spectrum (20–230 μ) can be acquired in <10 ms. The instrument can be used with either Ar or He plasma sources. The speed of the system makes it well suited for acquisition of fast (10–100-ms duration) transient signals, such as those generated by pulsed laser ablation sample introduction. Preliminary system performance characteristics, which include detection limits, stability, and measurement accuracy, obtained with an Ar ICP are presented. The application of the instrument to the analysis of solid samples by laser ablation is discussed.     

基于大气压下介质阻挡放电抑制LA-ICP-MS分析中元素分馏效应研究

采用自制的大气压下介质阻挡放电装置串联在激光剥蚀池与ICP炬管之间, 对激光剥蚀产生的气溶胶进行预电离. 结果表明, 元素瞬时信号轮廓的平滑度得以改善, 元素分析信号精密度(RSD, n=3)可提高2.55％. 在ArF准分子激光(193 nm)和Nd∶YAG 固体激光(213 nm)两种不同波长的激光剥蚀系统中, 元素分馏因子均比常规模式下更接近于1, 表明采用介质阻挡放电对气溶胶预电离后元素分馏效应得以有效抑制. 相比两种不同波长的激光剥蚀系统, 介质阻挡放电对213 nm固体激光的元素分馏效应改善作用明显.     

Influence of laser wavelength on LIBS diagnostics applied to the analysis of ancient bronzes

In this work the influence of laser wavelength upon the analytical results obtained from applying LIBS diagnostics to bronzes was investigated theoretically and experimentally at 1,064 nm and 355 nm. The laser ablation process was modeled for a set of reference samples of quaternary Cu/Sn/Pb/Zn alloys and the difference between plume composition and known target stoichiometry was estimated for both of the wavelengths considered. LIBS measurements were performed on the same set of reference samples and under the same experimental conditions to validate the model at different wavelengths. Results from the application of the model to calculate sample optical properties during laser irradiation, absorption in the plasma and plasma temperature are also presented.     

Detection efficiencies in nano- and femtosecond laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry

Detection efficiencies of laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS), defined as the ratio of ions reaching the detector and atoms released by LA were measured. For this purpose, LA of silicate glasses, zircon, and pure silicon was performed using nanosecond (ns) as well as femtosecond (fs) LA. For instance, ns-LA of silicate glass using helium as in-cell carrier gas resulted in detection efficiencies between approximately 1E-7 for low and 3E-5 for high mass range elements which were, in addition, almost independent on the laser wavelength and pulse duration chosen. In contrast, the application of argon as carrier gas was found to suppress the detection efficiencies systematically by a factor of up to 5 mainly due to a less efficient aerosol-to-ion conversion and ion transmission inside the ICP-MS.     

Experimental study of laser-induced plasma: Influence of laser fluence and pulse duration

Influence of laser fluence and pulse duration on the morphology and the internal structure of plasma induced by infrared nanosecond laser pulse on an aluminum target placed in an argon ambient gas of one atmosphere pressure was experimentally studied. Dual-wavelength differential spectroscopic imaging was used in the experiment, which allowed observing the detailed structure inside of the ablation plume with distributions of species evaporated from the target as well as contributed by the ambient gas. Different regimes of post-ablation interaction were investigated using different laser fluences and pulse durations. We demonstrate in particular that plasma shielding due to various species localized in different zones inside of the plume leads to different morphologies and internal structures of the plasma. At moderate fluence, the plasma shielding due to the ablation vapor localized in the central part of the plume leads to its nearly spherical expansion with a layered structure of the distribution of different species. At higher fluence, the plasma shielding becomes strongly contributed by ionized ambient gas localized in the propagation front of the plume. An elongated morphology of the plume is observed with a zone of mixing between different species evaporated from the target or contributed by the ambient gas. Finally with extremely strong plasma shielding by ionized ambient gas in the case of a long duration pulse at high fluence, a delayed evaporation from the target is observed due to the ejection of melted material by splashing.