Performance limits of monolithic and packed capillary columns in high-performance liquid chromatography and capillary electrochromatography

A method is proposed for the comprehensive characterization and comparison of columns in the high-performance liquid chromatographic (HPLC) and capillary electrochromatographic (CEC) modes. Using this approach, column parameters such as the number of plates, the eddy-diffusion and mass-transfer contributions to peak broadening, the permeability, and the analysis time are incorporated in a single graph and a comparison in terms of efficiency and speed is obtained. The chromatographic performance of silica-based and polymer-based monolithic capillary columns is discussed and a comparison is made with the performance of packed columns. Also, the potential of ultra-high-pressure liquid chromatography is discussed in this context. In the HPLC mode, the best results were obtained with silica monoliths; in the CEC mode, the low-density methacrylate-ester-based monoliths showed the best performance.     

Performance of new prototype packed columns for very high pressure liquid chromatography

The reduced heights equivalent to a theoretical plate (HETP) of naphtho[2,3-a]pyrene were measured at room temperature on two sets of new prototype columns designed to be used in very high pressure liquid chromatography (VHPLC). The mobile phase used was pure acetonitrile. The columns are 50, 100, and 150 mm long. Those of the first set are 2.1 mm I.D., those of the second set, 3.0 mm I.D. The performance of these new columns were compared to those of the first generation of VHPLC columns, commercially available in 2.1 mm I.D. The prototype and commercial columns behave similarly at low reduced linear velocities (ν<5$\nu <5$), when the heat effects are negligible. At high flow rates, the shorter prototype columns have a twice better efficiency and less steep C-branches than the commercial columns. In contrast, the C-branch of the 150 mm long prototype columns are slightly steeper than those of the commercial columns. The important contribution to the reduced HETP that is due to the heat effects at high flow rates can in part be accounted for by a band broadening model governed by a flow mechanism with the shortest prototype columns. The sole heat effects cannot, however, explain the mediocre reduced HETPs of the 2.1 and 3.0 I.D. 150 mm long prototype columns. It seems that radial heterogeneity of the flow rate of the long prototype columns is significantly larger than that of the short columns. The contribution of the packing heterogeneity adds up to that of the heat effects to yield a poor column efficiency when sub-2μm$\text{sub-}2\mu \text{m}$ are packed into thin, long column tubes.     

Evaluation of packed capillary liquid chromatography columns and comparison with conventional-size columns

Apart from extracolumn effects peak dispersion in liquid chromatographic columns is caused by the column inlet, the packed bed, and the column outlet. A strategy applicable for independent evaluation of the individual sources of column band broadening was developed on the basis of the linear extrapolation method (LEM). This method was applied to compare the performance of packed capillary LC columns from various commercial suppliers with conventional-size columns. The columns differed widely in their performance with respect to peak shapes and widths for standard substances. The capillary columns were found well packed, but in some cases overall performance would benefit from improving the design of the area between the packed bed and the connecting capillaries, containing frits as well as dead volumes.     

Polyethylenimine-modified metal oxides for fabrication of packed capillary columns for capillary electrochromatography and capillary liquid chromatography

The need for novel packing materials in both capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and capillary liquid chromatography (CLC) is apparent and the development towards more selective, application-oriented chromatographic phases is under progress world-wide. In this study we have synthesized new polyethyleneimine (PEI) functionalized Mn(2)O(3), SiO(2), SnO(2), and ZrO(2) particles for the fabrication of packed capillary columns for CEC and CLC. The nanocasting approach was successful for the preparation of functionalized metal oxide materials with a controlled porosity and morphology. PEI functionalization was done using ethyleneimine monomers to create particles which are positively charged in aqueous solution below pH 9. This functionalization allowed the possibility to have both hydrophobic (due to its alkyl chain) and ionic interactions (due to positively charged amino groups) with selected compounds. For comparison aminopropyl-functionalized silica was also synthesized and tested. Both slurry pressure and electrokinetic packing procedures used gave similar results, but fast sedimentation of the material caused some problems during the packing. The high stability and wide pH range of PEI-functionalized SiO(2) material, with potential for hydrophobic and electrostatic interactions, proved to be useful for the CEC and CLC separation of some model acidic and neutral compounds.     

Hydrodynamic impact of particle shape in slurry packed liquid chromatography columns

We report on a series of flow velocity and efficiency profiles, which were measured across the cross section of preparative chromatographic columns packed with different stationary phase materials using computed tomography. It is shown that this non-invasive technique is very useful for visualization of the inner part of a packed column and measurement of the spatial resolved column packing properties. For evaluation of the influence of the particle shape on the velocity distribution and column performance, irregular and spherical reversed phases were studied in detail. The results showed a decreasing velocity towards the column wall most certainly due to a lower permeability. This effect was much less pronounced in the case of spherical particles, indicating a more homogenous packing structure. The influence of the column packing pressure, as a possible measure for improvement of the packing homogeneity was also studied. It was shown that under the same packing conditions spherical particles always lead to a more homogeneous packing. The overall results of this work contribute to the origin of the fact that spherical material is superior to irregular one from the hydrodynamic point of view.     

Gas chromatography of hydrocarbons using packed liquid chromatographic capillary columns

Capillary columns of 0.3-0.5 mm i.d. packed with 3- to 30-μm silica-based stationary phases for liquid chromatography were used for gas chromatographic separation of hydrocarbons. Column efficiencies were evaluated for various commercially available packing material. The best column efficiency was achieved with 5-μm octadecyl group bonded silica gel, the surface of which was coated with a poly (dimethylsiloxane) film. The 30-cm column produced 11,000 theoretical plates.     

Surfactant-bound monolithic columns for separation of proteins in capillary high performance liquid chromatography

A surfactant-bound monolithic stationary phase based on the co-polymerization of 11-acrylamino-undecanoic acid (AAUA) is designed for capillary high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). Using D-optimal design, the effect of the polymerization mixture (concentrations of monomer, crosslinker and porogens) on the chromatographic performance (resolution and analysis time) of the AAUA–EDMA monolithic column was evaluated. The polymerization mixture was optimized using three proteins as model test solutes. The D-optimal design indicates a strong dependence of chromatographic parameters on the concentration of porogens (1,4-butanediol and water) in the polymerization mixture. Optimized solutions for fast separation and high resolution separation, respectively, were obtained using the proposed multivariate optimization. Differences less than 6.8% between the predicted and the experimental values in terms of resolution and retention time indeed confirmed that the proposed approach is practical. Using the optimized column, fast separation of proteins could be obtained in 2.5 min, and a tryptic digest of myoglobin was successfully separated on the high resolution column. The physical properties (i.e., morphology, porosity and permeability) of the optimized monolithic column were thoroughly investigated. It appears that this surfactant-bound monolith may have a great potential as a new generation of capillary HPLC stationary phase.     

A miniature gradient elution system for liquid chromatography with packed capillary columns

A miniaturized continuous gradient elution system was designed for work with packed capillary columns. The retention reproducibility achieved is adequate for many practical applications.     

Packed capillary columns for liquid chromatography

Summary Fused silica capillaries, ≈ 130 × 0.32mm have been packed with small reversed phase spherical silica particles, 3 or 2μm, in order to achieve LC-systems giving high plate numbers at relatively low pressure drop in short analysis times. At optimal conditions, columns packed with 3μm particles showed reduced plate heights, h, around 2.5, and the column flow resistance, ϕ, was 335–625. With 2μm particles, a reduced plate height of only 3.7 was achieved, which reflects the difficulty in the packing of such small particles.     

Porous ceramic bed supports for fused silica packed capillary columns used in liquid chromatography

Porous ceramic bed supports for fused silica packed capillary columns utilized in liquid chromatography were prepared by polymerizing solutions containing potassium silicate in-situ within a column to create a mechanically stable, rugged, and easily constructed termination. The effect of the bed support length on efficiency, and comparisons to glass wool bed supports, were considered in terms of column efficiencies and hydrodynamic variables. Results obtained indicate better performance for the ceramic bed support.     

Towards high peak capacity separations in normal pressure nanoflow liquid chromatography using meter long packed capillary columns

Single shot proteomics is a promising approach to high throughput proteomics analysis. In this strategy, long capillary columns are needed to perform long and shallow gradients to achieve high peak capacity and good peak width for informative mass spectrometric detection. Herein, we report that meter long capillary columns, packed with 5 μm particulate material, can be facilely fabricated based on single particle fritting technology. The long columns could reliably generate high peak capacities of 800 in 10 h long gradients for protein digest separations. The operation was within the pressure range (40 MPa) of the most widely used normal pressure nanoLC systems. Due to the excellent life time (>100 injections) and inter-column performance consistency, the meter long capillary columns reported here should be of practical usefulness in single shot proteomics without the need for ultra-high pressure instrumentation.     

On-line multidimensional chromatography using packed capillary liquid chromatography and capillary gas chromatography

The introduction of selected fractions from a liquid chromatograph into a gas chromatograph has been described; however, analyses were performed by off-line experiments requiring collection and reinjection of the separate fractions or by on-line procedures where disadvantageously, only a fraction of the separated peak or a well resolved component in a mixture could be introduced into a gas chromatograph. This disadvantage is overcome by the apparatus and method described in this paper, which utilizes a multidimensional chromatography system employing a high efficiency, packed capillary LC column coupled on-line to a capillary gas chromatograph. The liquid chromatograph (so designed) can act as a highly efficient clean-up or chemical class fractionation step prior to introduction into the gas chromatograph, significantly reducing sample preparation times in many applications. Thus minor components in a complex matrix can be determined without prior sample clean-up, an example of which is the determination of polychlorinated biphenyls in a complex hydrocarbon matrix.     

Polymethacrylate monolithic columns for capillary liquid chromatography

In recent years, continuous separation media have attracted considerable attention because of the advantages they offer over packed columns. This research resulted in two useful monolithic material types, the first based on modified silica gel and the second on organic polymers. This work attempts to review advances in the development, characterization, and applications of monolithic columns based on synthetic polymers in capillary chromatography, with the main focus on monolithic beds prepared from methacrylate-ester based monomers. The polymerization conditions used in the production of polymethacrylate monolithic capillary columns are surveyed, with attention being paid to the concentrations of monomers, porogen solvents, and polymerization initiators as the system variables used to control the porous and hydrodynamic properties of the monolithic media. The simplicity of their preparation as well as the possibilities of controlling of their porous properties and surface chemistries are the main benefits of the polymer monolithic capillary columns in comparison to capillary columns packed with particulate materials. The application areas considered in this review concern mainly separations in reversed-phase chromatography, ion-exchange chromatography, hydrophobic and hydrophilic interaction modes; enzyme immobilization and sample preparation in the capillary chromatography format are also addressed.     

Standardization of test conditions for high performance liquid chromatography columns

Summary Comparisons of columns, column packings and column packing methods are made difficult and sometimes invalidated by differences and inadequacies in the test procedures used and the experimental data recorded. This paper reviews test procedures and recommends standards for a) the experimental and test parameters which must be recorded in order to enable comparisons to be made from laboratory to laboratory, b) the group of chromatographic parameters which best represent column performance for comparative purposes, with methods for their calculation, c) test solutes and eluents for some different types of packing materials. A computer program in BASIC is given which converts the experimental parameters into relevant chromatographic parameters.     

An electroosmotic pump for packed capillary liquid chromatography

An electroosmotic pump (EOP) capable of generating pressure above 3 MPa and μl/min flow rate with reverse phase mobile phases of HPLC was constructed and evaluated. The pump consisted of three parallel connected fused silica capillary columns (25 cm×320 μm I.D.) packed with 2 μm silica materials, hollow electrodes, a high voltage DC power supply, and a liquid pressure transducer. The EOP was applied in a capillary liquid chromatographic system for mobile phase delivery instead of a mechanical pump. Standard samples containing thiourea, naphthalene, anthracene, phenanthrene and acetonitrile were separated on a 15 cm×320 μm I.D. 5 μm Chromasil C₁₈ packed capillary column with acetonitrile/water as mobile phase.     

Divinylbenzene-based monolithic capillary columns in capillary liquid chromatography

The effect of the conditions of synthesis of divinylbenzene-based monolithic capillary columns on their chromatographic characteristics was studied. It was demonstrated that the porosity and permeability of the column change significantly even at small deviations from the optimum conditions of polymerization of the monolith in the column. By contrast, the minimum value of HETP proved to be only slightly sensitive to the conditions of synthesis, ranging within ～10–20 μm. The conditions of polymerization of the monolith were found to produce more pronounced effect on the slope of the right branch of the van Deemter curve (parameter C), with the flattest curve being observed for columns prepared under optimum conditions. The minimum value of HETP for polymer monolithic capillary columns was found to be similar to that for silica gel monolithic capillary columns, but the latter are characterized by C values approximately an order of magnitude lower.