Rational principles of compound selection for combinatorial library design

It is practically impossible in a short period of time to synthesize and test all compounds in any large exhaustive chemical library. We discuss rational approaches to selecting representative subsets of virtual libraries that help direct experimental synthetic efforts for both targeted and diverse library design. For targeted library design, we consider principles based on the similarity to lead molecules. In the case of diverse library design, we discuss algorithms aimed at the selection of both diverse and representative subsets of the entire chemical library space. We illustrate methodologies with several practical examples.     

A novel approach to combinatorial library design

We address the problem of designing a general-purpose combinatorial library to screen for pharmaceutical leads. Conventional approaches focus on diversity as the primary factor in designing such libraries. We suggest making screening libraries out of a set of pharmaceutically relevant scaffolds, with multiple analogs per scaffold. The rationale for this rests on the fact that even though the hit-rate in active series is much higher than in the database as a whole, often a large fraction of the compounds in active series are inactive. This is especially true when the series has not been optimized for the target under study. We introduce the concept of hit-rate within a series and use historic screening data to arrive at a crude estimate for it. We then use simple probability arguments to show that 50-100 compounds are required in each series in order to be nearly certain of finding at least one active compound in each true active series for any given target.     

CombiDOCK: Structure-based combinatorial docking and library design

We have developed a strategy for efficiently docking a large combinatorial library into a target receptor. For each scaffold orientation, all potential fragments are attached to the scaffold, their interactions with the receptor are individually scored and factorial combinations of fragments are constructed. To test its effectiveness, this approach is compared to two simple control algorithms. Our method is more efficient than the controls at selecting best scoring molecules and at selecting fragments for the construction of an exhaustive combinatorial library. We also carried out a retrospective analysis of the experimental results of a 10×10×10 exhaustive combinatorial library. An enrichment factor of approximately 4 was found for identifying the compounds in the library that are active at 330 nM.     

A scalable approach to combinatorial library design for drug discovery

In this paper, we propose an algorithm for the design of lead generation libraries required in combinatorial drug discovery. This algorithm addresses simultaneously the two key criteria of diversity and representativeness of compounds in the resulting library and is computationally efficient when applied to a large class of lead generation design problems. At the same time, additional constraints on experimental resources are also incorporated in the framework presented in this paper. A computationally efficient scalable algorithm is developed, where the ability of the deterministic annealing algorithm to identify clusters is exploited to truncate computations over the entire data set to computations over individual clusters. An analysis of this algorithm quantifies the tradeoff between the error due to truncation and computational effort. Results applied on test data sets corroborate the analysis and show improvement by factors as large as 10 or more, depending on the data sets.     

Sensitivity analysis and other improvements to tailored combinatorial library design

"Tailoring" combinatorial libraries was developed several years ago as a very general and intuitive method to design diverse compound collections while controlling the profile of other pharmaceutically relevant properties. The candidate substituents were assigned to "categorical bins" according to their properties, and successive steps of D-optimal design were performed to generate diverse substituent sets consistent with required membership quotas from each bin. This serial algorithm was expedient to implement from existing D-optimal design codes, but was order-dependent and did not generally locate the very best possible design. A new "parallel" Fedorov search algorithm has now been implemented that can find the most diverse property-tailored design. An ambiguous mass penalty has been added, whereby most duplicate masses can be eliminated with little loss of library diversity. Sensitivity analysis has also been added to quantitatively explore the diversity trade-offs due to increasing or decreasing each specific kind of bias.     

Scaffold diversity of natural products: inspiration for combinatorial library design

Natural products contain scaffold structures that can be systematically exploited for the design of combinatorial compound libraries with druglike properties. We review approaches for scaffold identification, and compare properties and pharmacophoric features of drugs and natural products. In particular, an application of the self-organizing map technique is presented for natural product-derived compound and library design.     

Computational methods and software in computer-aided combinatorial library design

Recent trends in the computer-aided design of diverse and focussed combinatorial libraries are surveyed. First, chemical data input, storage and retrieval including chemical database management and virtual chemical structure enumeration are outlined as background. Then, the optimization of ADMET parameters, diversity maximization, molecular similarity search, QSAR-based virtual screening, pharmacophore search and molecular docking are discussed.     

Reagent Selector: using Synthon Analysis to visualize reagent properties and assist in combinatorial library design

Reagent Selector is an intranet-based tool that aids in the selection of reagents for use in combinatorial library construction. The user selects an appropriate reagent group as a query, for example, primary amines, and further refines it on the basis of various physicochemical properties, resulting in a list of potential reagents. The results of this selection process are, in turn, converted into synthons: the fragments or R-groups that are to be incorporated into the combinatorial library. The Synthon Analysis interface graphically depicts the chemical properties for each synthon as a function of the topological bond distance from the scaffold attachment point. Displayed in this fashion, the user is able to visualize the property space for the universe of synthons as well as that of the synthons selected. Ultimately, the reagent list that embodies the selected synthons is made available to the user for reagent procurement. Application of the approach to a sample reagent list for a G-protein coupled receptor targeted library is described.     

Diversity space and its application to library selection and design

To promote more productive combinatorial endeavors, the Diversity Space methodology introduced here enables similarity comparisons at the library level. Particularly at an early screening stage, when little or no information is available regarding the pharmacophoric entities necessary for binding, it is more efficient to select or discard an entire ensemble of molecules at once, rather than focus on individual compounds. Also described are applications of the methodology to a form of scaffold hopping, herein categorized as "soft" scaffold hopping, and to a newly introduced approach called surrogate synthesis, both of which are furthered by library-level information that is absent in more traditional molecular similarity calculations.     

Structure-based combinatorial library design: discovery of non-peptidic inhibitors of caspases 3 and 8

Structure-based design of a combinatorial array was carried out in order to identify non-peptidic thiomethylketone inhibitors of caspases 3 and 8. Five compounds from the designed array were active against caspase 3, and two were active against caspase 8. A 2.5-Å resolution co-crystal structure of caspase 3 and a thiomethylketone array member is reported. The structure-based design strategy has proved useful for identifying caspase inhibitors.     

Application of self-organizing maps in compounds pattern recognition and combinatorial library design

In the computer-aided drug design, in order to find some new leads from a large library of compounds, the pattern recognition study of the diversity and similarity assessment of the chemical compounds is required; meanwhile in the combinatorial library design, more attention is given to design target focusing library along with diversity and drug-likeness criteria. This review presents the current state-of-art applications of Kohonen self-organizing maps (SOM) for studying the compounds pattern recognition, comparing the property of molecular surfaces, distinguishing drug-like and nondrug-like molecules, splitting a dataset into the proper training and test sets before constructing a QSAR (Quantitative Structural-Activity Relationship) model, and also for the combinatorial libraries comparison and the combinatorial library design. The Kohonen self-organizing map will continue to play an important role in drug discovery and library design.     

Target-induced selection of ligands from a dynamic combinatorial library of mono- and bi-conjugated oligonucleotides

A dynamic library of 15 mono- and bi-conjugated oligonucleotides was generated from a pool of three aldehydes and an oligonucleotide bearing two reactive amino groups. Addition of complementary target to the equilibrating mixture of imines resulted in selective amplification of one conjugate. UV-melting experiments confirmed that it was the best ligand among those that were tested. This study emphasizes that dynamic combinatorial chemistry can be used to simultaneously identify the type and the location of appended residues for stabilizing oligonucleotide complexes.