The interpretation and use of stability data in the certification of reference materials

 Stability tests are carried out on candidate reference materials in order to ascertain that the certification values continue to be valid a reasonable time after completion of the certification analysis. These tests are also used for recommending storage conditions, as well as the duration of storage before certification values need be rechecked. BCR (Community Bureau of Reference) reference materials do not normally have an expiry date, but rely on stability monitoring throughout the lifetime of the certified material. The 1997 version of the BCR Guidelines for the production and certification of reference materials does, however, take into account the necessity of limiting the validity of a certification, when degradation of the material during storage cannot be ignored. This paper discusses an example of significant degradation taking place between the time of completion of the certification analysis and the issue of a formal certificate. Various options are presented together with an account of their influence on the certified values and their uncertainties. Received: 3 October 1997 · Accepted: 3 November 1997     

Lifetime of the traceability chain in chemical measurement

Since the uncertainty of each link in the traceability chain (measuring analytical instrument, reference material or other measurement standard) changes over the course of time, the chain lifetime is limited. The lifetime in chemical analysis is dependent on the calibration intervals of the measuring equipment and the shelf-life of the certified reference materials (CRMs) used for the calibration of the equipment. It is shown that the ordinary least squares technique, used for treatment of the calibration data, is correct only when uncertainties in the certified values of the measurement standards or CRMs are negligible. If these uncertainties increase (for example, close to the end of the calibration interval or shelf-life), they are able to influence significantly the calibration and measurement results. In such cases regression analysis of the calibration data should take into account that not only the response values are subjects to errors, but also the certified values. As an end-point criterion of the traceability chain destruction, the requirement that the uncertainty of a measurement standard should be a source of less then one-third of the uncertainty in the measurement result is applicable. An example from analytical practice based on the data of interlaboratory comparisons of ethanol determination in beer is discussed. Received: 5 October 2000 Accepted: 3 December 2000     

Influence of buffer quality on pH measurement uncertainty: prediction and experimental evaluation

Dependence of the uncertainty of a pH measurement result on the quality of buffers (i.e. the uncertainty of their certified pH values) at different levels of instrumental uncertainty (pH-meter, etc.) was simulated using the Monte Carlo method and regression analysis. The contribution of the instrumental standard uncertainty (in the studied range from 0.1 to 1 mV) to the uncertainty of the pH measurement result is negligible, if the standard uncertainties of the pH buffers exceed 0.04 pH (e. g. for in-house buffers). It is shown how the choice of pH-meter and buffers should be correlated in order to meet the required uncertainty of a pH measurement result in a sample under analysis. The results of the simulation were compared with experimental data obtained from calibrations of a pH/ion-meter with a hydrogen working electrode (Radiometer PHM-240) and with a glass electrode (Metrohm 744). Buffers of different quality (National Institute for Standards and Technology standard reference materials, certified Radiometer buffers and Merck CertiPUR buffers) were used for the calibrations. The uncertainties of the experimental results are close to the predicted ones obtained by the simulation. Received: 16 June 2002 Accepted: 19 July 2002 Presented at the 14^th International Conference of the Israel Society for Quality, 18–21 November 2002, Jerusalem, Israel Correspondence to I. Kuselman     

Certification for trace elements and methyl mercury mass fractions in IAEA-452 scallop (Pecten Maximus) sample

A marine certified reference material (CRM), IAEA-452, prepared with scallop (Pecten maximus) sample was recently produced by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and certified for trace elements and methyl mercury (MeHg). The Scallop (Pecten maximus) sample is commonly found and consumed seafood and is also used as bio-indicators for trace metal contamination in marine pollution studies. This paper presents the sample preparation methodology, material homogeneity and stability studies, evaluation of certification campaign results, the assignment of property values and their associated uncertainty. The reference values and associated expanded uncertainty for 9 trace elements (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Hg, Mn, Pb and Zn) and MeHg in scallop sample are established. The informative value for one more element (Ni) is also given. The new CRM can be used for the development and validation of analytical methods for determination of trace elements and methyl mercury in seafood and also for quality assurance/quality control purposes.     

Uncertainty calculations in the certification of reference materials

To serve as a measurement standard, a (certified) reference material must be stable. For this purpose, the material should undergo stability testing after it has been prepared. This paper looks at the statistical aspects of stability testing. Essentially, these studies can be described with analysis of variance statistics, including variant regression analysis. The latter is used in practice for both trend analysis and for the development of expressions for extrapolations. Extrapolation of stability data is briefly touched upon, as far as the combined standard uncertainty of the reference material is concerned. There are different options to validate the extrapolations made from initial stability studies, and some of them might influence the uncertainty of the reference material and/or the shelf-life. The latter is the more commonly observed consequence of what is called ’stability monitoring’. Received: 6 October 2000 Accepted: 4 December 2000     

Definitive method certification of clinical analytes in lyophilized human serum: NIST Standard Reference Material (SRM) 909b

The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) has developed several Standard Reference Materials (SRMs) based on human serum. NIST SRM 909b, Human Serum, is a lyophilized human serum material with concentrations for seven organic and six inorganic analytes at two levels certified solely by definitive methods (DMs). This material provides the vehicle by which high precision, high accuracy measurements made with DMs at NIST can be transferred through the measurement hierarchy to other laboratories. Isotope dilution gas chromatographic-mass spectrometric (GC-IDMS) methods were applied to measure cholesterol, creatinine, glucose, urea, uric acid, triglycerides, and total glycerides. Thermal ionization isotope dilution mass spectrometry (TI-IDMS) was used for determination of lithium, magnesium, potassium, calcium, and chloride. In addition, chloride was determined by coulometry, providing a comparison between two DMs. Sodium, which lacks a stable isotope that would permit isotope dilution mass spectrometric (IDMS) measurement, was determined by gravimetry. SRM 909b includes certified values for total glycerides and triglycerides, which were not certified in the previous lot of this material (SRM 909a). Improvement in uniformity of vial fill weight in the production of SRM 909b resulted in smaller certified uncertainties over previous freeze-dried serum SRMs. Uncertainties at the 99% level of confidence for relative expanded uncertainty (%) for certification of the organic analytes on a mmol/L/g basis ranged from 0.44% for urea (level II) to 5.04% for glucose (level II). (In-house studies have shown glucose to be a relatively unstable analyte in similar lyophilized serum materials, degrading at about 1% per year.) Relative expanded uncertainties (99% C.I.) for certification of inorganic analytes on a mmol/L/g basis ranged from 0.25% for chloride (level I) to 0.49% for magnesium (level II). Received: 30 July 1997 / Revised: 24 October 1997 / Accepted: 31 October 1997     

Certification of 22 elements in a pure copper (99.5%) sample for spark emission and X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (CRM BAM-376)

 The element contents of Ag, Al, As, Be, Bi, Cd, Co, Cr, Fe, Mg, Mn, Ni, P, Pb, S, Sb, Se, Sn, Te, Ti, Zn and Zr in a pure copper (99.5%) sample (CRM BAM-376) for use in spark emission and X-ray fluorescence spectrometry were certified and the certified values are given. For Si, the certification has not yet been completed, the content of this element will be certified later. The sample was produced and certified in collaboration with the Committee of Chemists of the GDMB Gesellschaft für Bergbau, Metallurgie, Rohstoff- und Umwelttechnik. Data of the homogeneity testing and the certification campaign with 14 participating laboratories using different analytical methods are reported. Received: 3 February 1997/Revised: 21 February 1997/Accepted: 5 March 1997     

k0-NAA, a valuable tool for reference-material producers.

The main concern of producers of certified reference materials (CRM) is the preparation of high-quality products with demonstrated homogeneity and stability, combined with a well established set of certified characteristics. CRM producers must, furthermore, comply with other constraints imposed by the ISO Guide 34: production processes, production control, and certification analyses should be performed by expert laboratories, using validated protocols documented in their respective quality assurance manuals; laboratory mean values and the corresponding "expanded" uncertainties, must be used for the determination of the certified values, as recommended by the ISO Guide to the Expression of Uncertainties in Measurements (GUM); and when possible, traceability of the certified value to the SI units, using appropriately validated and/or primary methods, must be ensured. k0-NAA, i.e. neutron activation analysis with k0 standardization, is one of the analytical techniques implemented at the Reference Material Unit of IRMM; it meets the first two requirements.     

Influence of storage time and temperature of air-dried soils on pH and extractable nutrients using 0.01 mol/L CaCl2

The stability of pH and certified amounts of nitrate, ammonia, total soluble nitrogen, total soluble organic carbon, magnesium, sodium, potassium and phosphorus obtained by extraction from air-dried (40 °C) soil samples by 0.01 mol/L CaCl₂ solution during storage at –18 °C, 4 °C, ambient temperature, 40 °C and 70 °C was investigated in one calcareous soil and one acid sandy soil. Even at storage times of 45 and 90 days, extractable amounts changed. Extractable amounts of P, NH₄-N, total soluble N and soluble organic C increased even at a storage temperature of 40 °C. The pH was lower for samples stored at a temperature of 70 °C and also the Mg concentration became lower at elevated storage temperatures after 45 days in both soils. It is suggested that reference materials certified for values using unbuffered extractants should be stored at a temperature not higher than 4 °C. Received: 13 May 1997 / Revised: 16 July 1997 / Accepted: 18 July 1997     

Results of the ASTM Nuclear Methods intercomparison on NIST apple and peack leaves standard reference materials

The ASTM Task Group on Nuclear Methods of Chemical Analysis (E10.05.12) has conducted a trace element intercomparison among some of its members over the past two years. Eight non-NIST laboratories submitted data using nuclear techniques, with a total of 111 values for the apple leaves and 116 values for the peach leaves, on 46 and 50 elements, respectively. This intercomparison provided a unique opportunity for the analytical laboratories, because the analytical values submitted could be later compared to the NIST certified values. For the seven elements which were certified by NIST and had three or more intercomparison values, the results showed that: 1) 61% of all 56 intercomparison values submitted had results whose stated uncertainty overlapped the uncertainty limits of the NIST certified values, and 2) less than 6% of the intercomparison values had means which fell outside ±20% of the NIST values. In general, the intercomparison values submitted showed excellent agreement with the NIST values. However, many reported uncertainties accompanying intercomparison values appeared overly optimistic.     

k0-NAA, a valuable tool for reference-material producers

The main concern of producers of certified reference materials (CRM) is the preparation of high-quality products with demonstrated homogeneity and stability, combined with a well established set of certified characteristics. CRM producers must, furthermore, comply with other constraints imposed by the ISO Guide 34: ·*production processes, production control, and certification analyses should be performed by expert laboratories, using validated protocols documented in their respective quality assurance manuals; ·*laboratory mean values and the corresponding “expanded” uncertainties, must be used for the determination of the certified values, as recommended by the ISO Guide to the Expression of Uncertainties in Measurements (GUM); and ·*when possible, traceability of the certified value to the SI units, using appropriately validated and/or primary methods, must be ensured. k₀-NAA, i.e. neutron activation analysis with k₀ standardization, is one of the analytical techniques implemented at the Reference Material Unit of IRMM; it meets the first two requirements.     

Improvement of the traceability of reference materials certified for purity: evaluation of a semi-preparative high-performance liquid chromatography approach

A semi-preparative high-performance liquid chromatography process was evaluated as a tool to quantitatively determine the purity or percentage mass fraction content (% m/m) of organic compounds. The method is simple and does not require the identification and subsequent quantitation of organic-related structure impurities. A protocol was developed and tested on four reference materials certified for purity from 95% m/m to 99.3% m/m. Comparing the purity results of each certified reference material using the new approach with their respective certified values showed no significant analytical bias. Semi-preparative high-performance liquid chromatography has proved the potential to be a primary method directly traceable to mass with an uncertainty statement written down also in terms of mass with expanding uncertainty ranging from 0.8% to 1.3% m/m compared to 0.3 to 2.0% m/m for the certified purity values at the 95% confidence interval.     

Determination of trace elements in sediment reference materials by monochromatic X-ray excitation X-ray fluorescence spectrometry.

A new reliable analytical method, "Monochromatic X-ray Excitation X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry", has been proposed. For validating the method, trace elements in sediment certified reference materials were determined. In the method X-ray fluorescence spectra are measured for specimens and pure metals; in addition the mass-attenuation coefficients of the specimens for various X-ray wavelengths are also measured. The data are analyzed by the fundamental parameter method and the uncertainty of the analysis is evaluated. The obtained results were in satisfactory agreement with the certified values within their uncertainties. This method will be applicable to the certification of reference materials, in the field of which reliable results with uncertainty statements are required.     

Development of a certified reference material for the content of nitroimidazole parent drugs and hydroxy metabolites in pork meat

Nitroimidazoles have been applied in the past to poultry and pigs to treat protozoan diseases and to combat bacterial infections, but due to adverse health effects their use in food-producing animals has meanwhile been banned in the EU. The request for a certified reference material in a representative matrix was stipulated by the responsible Community Reference Laboratory and is underpinned by the need to improve the accuracy and comparability of measurement data and to establish metrological traceability of analytical results. The Institute for Reference Materials and Measurements (IRMM) has responded to this demand by developing and producing a new certified matrix reference material, ERM-BB124. This incurred lyophilised pork meat material was certified according to ISO guides 34 and 35 for the mass fractions of six nitroimidazole compounds. Processing of the frozen muscle tissue to the final material was accomplished by application of cutting, freeze-drying, mixing and milling techniques. Homogeneity and stability measurements were performed using liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. The relative standard uncertainty due to possible heterogeneity showed to be below 1.8% for all analytes. Potential degradation during transport and storage was assessed by isochronous stability studies. No significant instability was detected at a storage temperature of −20 °C for a shelf-life of 2 years. The certified mass fraction values were assigned upon evaluation of the data acquired in an international laboratory inter-comparison involving 12 expert laboratories using different sample preparation procedures, but exclusively LC-MS/MS methods. Relative standard uncertainty contributions for the characterisation (between-lab variation of mean values) were found to be between 1.6 and 4.8%. Certified values for five analytes were in the range of 0.7 to 6.2 μg kg⁻¹, with expanded relative uncertainties ranging between 7 and 14%. Dimetridazole could be certified as “<0.25 μg kg⁻¹ with a probability of 95%”. All values are traceable to the International System of Units (SI). The material is intended to be used for method validation purposes (including trueness estimation) and for method performance assessment.     

Validation of the uncertainty evaluation for the determination of metals in solid samples by atomic spectrometry

 Every analytical result should be expressed with some indication of its quality. The uncertainty as defined by Eurachem ("parameter associated with the result of a measurement that characterises the dispersion of the values that could reasonably be attributed to the, . . ., quantity subjected to measurement") is a good tool to accomplish this goal in quantitative analysis. Eurachem has produced a guide to the estimation of the uncertainty attached to an analytical result. Indeed, the estimation of the total uncertainty by using uncertainty propagation laws is components-dependent. The estimation of some of those components is based on subjective criteria. The identification of the uncertainty sources and of their importance, for the same method, can vary from analyst to analyst. It is important to develop tools which will support each choice and approximation. In this work, the comparison of an estimated uncertainty with an experimentally assessed one, through a variance test, is performed. This approach is applied to the determination by atomic absorption of manganese in digested samples of lettuce leaves. The total uncertainty estimation is calculated assuming 100% digestion efficiency with negligible uncertainty. This assumption was tested. Received: 3 November 1997 · Accepted: 2 January 1998     

Efficiency of decomposition procedures for the determination of some elements in soils by atomic spectroscopic methods

Nine decomposition procedures for soil samples, such as via acid mixtures and fusion in open systems and microwave and autoclave dissolution (in closed systems under elevated temperature and pressure) were assessed using certified soil reference materials. The determination of various elements in solutions was performed by FAAS and ICP-OES and the results were compared with certified values and with direct current arc OES analysis. Received: 3 March 1997 / Revised: 30 May 1997 / Accepted: 3 June 1997     

Creatinine determination in urine from the point of view of reference values

In this paper, the creation of a certified reference material for urinary creatinine is described. We used the Jaffe method and HPLC method for establishment of the certified value. Homogeneity tests are also described. We obtained material with sufficient homogeneity, stability, and with certified value (expanded uncertainty, k=2 for CI 95%) (7.77±0.27) mmol·L⁻¹. This material was consequently used for the interlaboratory comparison (EQA Czech Republic for clinical chemistry). Twenty-nine percent of the participants obtained measurement results within the interval of the certified value ± expanded uncertainty, while 85% of the participants obtained values inside the interval of the certified value ± target measurement uncertainty. Direct use of the certified reference materials for method evaluation in EQA programs means a significant advance for monitoring and documentation traceability of results in routine measurements.     

Uncertainties of mercury determinations in biological materials using an atomic absorption spectrometer – AMA 254

 The method is based on catalysed ignition of a sample portion in a flow of oxygen, capture of mercury by an amalgamator and measurement of the mercury vapour's absorbance after thermic release from the amalgamator. Three powdered food samples, a certified reference material (CRM) human hair and a reference material (RM) urine (liquid) were measured in the first range of the instrument (the possible contents determined according to our measurement procedure were 0.0003–0.5 ppm). The calibration function used was a line passing through the origin. The combined standard uncertainties of the mercury determinations were computed from uncertainty components of five quantities: absorbance of the sample, absorbance of the sample blank, slope of the calibration line, correction factor of the abscissa axis, and mass or volume of the sample. The most important uncertainty component is the uncertainty of the sample absorbance measurement which amounts to 52% of the determination uncertainty at the minimum (RM urine) and about 90% at the maximum (in our laboratory homogenized powdered food samples; analysis of variance showed their homogeneity to be insufficient). The results of the CRM and RM analyses do not indicate a significant systematic error for this determination. The relative expanded uncertainty (coefficient was 2) of the determination increases from 9 to 13% for the insufficiently homogenized samples with decreasing mercury content (range of 0.004–0.03 ppm); higher homogeneity of samples results in a decrease of the expanded uncertainty, e.g. 4.6% for the liquid sample (RM urine). Received: 26 April 1999 / Accepted: 30 August 1999     

Uncertainty calculation and implementation of the static volumetric method for the preparation of NO and SO2 standard gas mixtures

 The European Reference Laboratory of Air Pollution implements the static volumetric method for the preparation of nitrogen monoxide and sulphur dioxide reference standard gas mixtures. According to the new ISO guide for the expression of uncertainty, the uncertainty of these standards is up to 0.8% for nitrogen monoxide in the range 100 to 600 ppbv, and up to 0.4% for sulphur dioxide in the range 200 to 400 ppbv. The values presented in the present paper suggest that there is a 95% probability of the true value lying within the interval specified. To attain such low uncertainty values, the standard procedure for the implementation of the static volumetric method must be rigorously followed, and instruments must be carefully maintained. Received: 26 June 1997 · Accepted: 23 August 1997