MODs vs. NPs: Vying for the Future of Printed Electronics

This Minireview compares two distinct ink types, namely metal-organic decomposition (MOD) and nanoparticle (NP) formulations, for use in the printing of some of the most conductive elements: silver, copper and aluminium. Printing of highly conductive features has found purpose across a broad array of electronics and as processing times and temperatures reduce, the avenues of application expand to low-cost flexible substrates, materials for wearable devices and beyond. Printing techniques such as screen, aerosol jet and inkjet printing are scalable, solution-based processes that historically have employed NP formulations to achieve low resistivity coatings printed at high resolution. Since the turn of the century, the rise in MOD inks has vastly extended the range of potentially applicable compounds that can be printed, whilst simultaneously addressing shelf life and sintering issues. A brief introduction to the field and requirements of an ink will be presented followed by a detailed discussion of a wide array of synthetic routes to both MOD and NP inks. Unindustrialized materials will be discussed, with the challenges and outlook considered for the market leaders: silver and copper, in comparison with the emerging field of aluminium inks.     

Applicability of surface-enhanced resonance Raman scattering for the direct discrimination of ballpoint pen inks

In situ surface-enhanced resonance Raman spectroscopy (SERRS) with excitation at 685 nm is suitable for the direct discrimination of blue and black ballpoint pen inks on paper. For black inks, shorter excitation wavelengths can also be used. For blue inks, SERRS at 514.5 and 457.9 nm does not provide adequate discriminative power. At these excitation wavelengths, the SERRS signals of the Methyl Violet derivatives present in inks easily dominate the overall spectrum because of resonance enhancement and preferential interaction with silver sol particles. At 685 nm, this problem is not encountered as the Methyl Violet derivatives do not show resonance enhancement, while other components may still exhibit resonance. Thirteen blue and thirteen black ink lines were examined. For the blue and black inks, on the basis of the 685 nm SERR spectra, eight and six groups of spectra, respectively, could be distinguished. This discrimination largely agrees with information from thin layer chromatography (TLC) experiments, although some differences in group compositions are found. The in situ SERR spectra show good repeatability with regard to the Raman frequencies, band shapes and relative intensities of the spectral bands. However, absolute intensities cannot be used for discrimination purposes.     

Disposable electrochemical paper-based devices fully fabricated by screen-printing technique

This work presents a novel method for the full fabrication of electrochemical paper-based cells by screen-printing technology. Firstly, a mixture of ultraviolet curable inks was used for patterning hydrophobic barriers into chromatography paper. Afterwards three-electrode systems were coupled for electrochemical detection by printing successively carbon and silver/silver chloride inks over the hydrophilic areas. The resulting electrochemical cells were characterized by cyclic voltammetry in different redox systems and used for amperometric detection of ferricyanide.     

Chemically Induced Sintering of Nanoparticles

We have observed solid‐state growth of pre‐existing silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) upon exposure to trace (ppb) concentrations of reactive gases at room temperature. The consequent change in localized surface plasmon resonances alters the visible absorbance of dried, printed sensor spots made from inks of 10 nm‐AgNPs and provides a novel mechanism for trace detection and dosimetry of reactive gases. Colorimetric sensor arrays based on these AgNP inks offer dosimetric identification of acidic and oxidizing gases and other reactive vapors with limits of detection below ppb levels for 1 h exposures. For an array of AgNP inks with various capping agents, a unique color response pattern is observed for each specific analyte. Excellent discrimination among 11 reactive gases was demonstrated using standard chemometric methods. The chemically induced sintering of NPs paves the way for novel solid‐state sensors for the ultrasensitive detection of reactive gases and their application to the monitoring of trace airborne pollutants.     

Differentiation of selected blue writing inks by surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy

Raman spectroscopy and surface enhanced Raman spectroscopy were used to examine 14 blue inks obtained from commercially available stationery. Standard colouring agents in the inks: β-phase of phtalocyanine blue PB15 and some homologues of the methyl violet class, were identified. Surface enhanced Raman spectra were recorded on a firm heterostructure of silver/nanocrystalline diamond/silicon constituting an active substrate providing the possibility to write directly on the surface. Based on the differences in traditional and surface enhanced Raman spectra, two inks were identified unambiguously, the remaining inks were categorised into three groups exhibiting common spectral features. Despite their similarity, surface enhanced Raman spectra exhibited soft variations enabling discrimination of the inks, thus proving the usefulness of the method.     

Metal Extracts as Precursors for the Production of Metal Powders and Coatings via the Extraction-Pyrolytic Method

The extraction of copper, silver, bismuth, and nickel with carboxylic acids thus providing concentrated metal-containing organic solutions and their crystalline salts has been studied. Micron- and submicron-sized metal powders have been obtained via reduction of these metals carboxylates by heating in benzyl alcohol or ethylene glycol. The synthesis of aspherical silver nanoparticles has been achieved by the reduction of a liquid extract of silver neodecanoate in benzyl alcohol. The possibility of the use of concentrated silver-containing solutions as inks for obtaining of electroconductive images has been demonstrated.     

Conducting polymer-silver composites

Preparations of hybrid composites composed of two conducting components, a conducting polymer and silver, are reviewed. They are produced mainly by the oxidation of aniline or pyrrole with silver ions. In another approach, polyaniline or polypyrrole are used for the reduction of silver ions to metallic silver. Other synthetic approaches are also reviewed. Products of oxidation of aniline derivatives, including phenylenediamines, are considered. Morphology of both the conducting polymers and the silver in composites displays a rich variety. Conductivity of the composites seldom exceeds 1000 S cm^?1 and seems to be controlled by percolation. Interfacial effects are also discussed. Potential applications of hybrid composites are outlined; they are likely to extend especially to conducting inks, printed electronics, noble-metal recovery, antimicrobial materials, catalysts, and sensors.     

Flexible Glass‐based Amperometric Sensors for Hydrogen Peroxide

The development of flexible sensors could enable significant advances in clinical diagnosis, defense, and environmental monitoring. Flexible glass provides the flexibility and possesses stable chemical and physical properties. Here, we show that carbon graphite and silver/silver chloride inks can be printed onto flexible glass to construct amperometric sensors, and the sensors show sensitive and rapid detections of hydrogen peroxide. We anticipate that these results could provide exciting avenues for fundamental studies of flexible electronics and flexible bioelectronics, as well as a variety of applications in fields ranging from medical diagnosis to defense.     

Ink‐Jet Printing of Metallic Nanoparticles and Microemulsions

Summary: Two types of ink‐jet inks are presented: ink containing an aqueous dispersion of silver nanoparticles and an oil‐in‐water microemulsion‐based ink. The metallic ink contains nanoparticles of silver, which are formed in the presence of an ionic polymeric stabilizer. Sintering of the printed image obtained with the use of such silver‐based inks at temperatures as low as 300 °C results in formation of patterns possessing noticeable conductivity. The microemulsion inks are based on a thermodynamically stable microemulsion, in which the dispersed oil phase is a volatile solvent containing a water‐insoluble colorant. After contact of the jetted ink droplets with a substrate, nanodroplets of the microemulsion are converted into nanoparticles of the solubilized colorant. In some cases, it was found that the evaporation of microemulsion ink droplets leads to formation of rings composed of ordered nanoparticles.

Scheme of ink‐jet printing of an oil‐in‐water microemulsion followed by conversion of the nanodroplets into nanoparticles, caused by quick evaporation of the solvent within the microemulsion droplets. Therefore, the ink behaves as a dye‐based ink prior to printing, but after printing it behaves like a pigment‐based ink.     

Breaking the Size Limitation of Directly-Synthesized PbS Quantum Dot Inks Toward Efficient Short-wavelength Infrared Optoelectronic Applications

PbS quantum dots (QDs) are promising building blocks for solution-processed short-wavelength infrared (SWIR) devices. The recently developed direct synthesis of semi-conductive PbS QD inks has substantially simplified the preparation processing and reduced the material cost, while facing the challenge to synthesize large-size QDs with absorption covering the SWIR region. Herein, we for the first time realize a low-cost, scalable synthesis of SWIR PbS QD inks after an extensive investigation of the reaction kinetics. Finally, based on these PbS SWIR QD inks, the solar cell demonstrates a record-high power conversion efficiency (PCE) of 1.44 % through an 1100 nm cutoff silicon filter and the photodetector device shows a low dark current density of 2×10⁻⁶ A cm⁻² at −0.8 V reverse bias with a high external quantum efficiency (EQE) of 70 % at ≈1300 nm. Our results realize the direct synthesis of low-cost and scalable SWIR QD inks and may accelerate the industrialization of consumer SWIR technologies.     

Preparation and characterization of Ce-doped and Zr-doped sol–gel inks of titanium alkoxide

Inks of titanium diisopropoxide bisacetylacetonate ([(CH₃)₂CHO]₂Ti(C₅H₇O₂)₂) are suitable for the fabrication of photonic bandgap materials by direct ink writing (DIW). Using this method we are able to obtain micro-periodic titania (TiO₂) structures with high refractive index by calcining the structures built with those inks. Calcining at high temperatures causes titania grain growth and surface roughness of the structure, which has an influence over its optical properties. In order to inhibit the grain growth of titania nanocrystals when the structures are calcined, we have synthesized using the sol–gel technique titanium diisopropoxide bisacetylacetonate inks doped with Cerium (III) nitrate hexahydrate (Ce(NO₃)₃·6H₂O) and Zirconyl nitrate hydrate (ZrO(NO₃)₂·xH₂O). The grain growth process of titania powders derived from the calcined doped sol–gel inks during various heat-treatment programs has been investigated by the X-ray line-broadening analysis. It was demonstrated how the dopants reduce the grain growth of the rutile phase after heat treatment. The influence of the dopants on the rheological behaviour of doped inks were studied and compared with the undoped. The flow and oscillation curves as a function of time demonstrate that doped inks have the same rheological behaviour than undoped inks. Thermogravimetric analysis also proves that doped inks keep the same mass loss after calcination than undoped inks. These results show how doped inks can be applied for DIW in the same conditions than undoped inks with a significant reduction of titania grain growth.     

Development and validation of an HPLC method for the determination of endocrine disruptors bisphenol A and benzophenone in thermochromic printing inks

The endocrine disruptors bisphenol A (BPA) and benzophenone (BFN) could be important ingredients in thermochromic printing inks in significant amounts. Due to patent protection and use of the inks, manufacturers are not obliged to state their precise chemical composition. These substances in increasingly used thermochromic printing inks present a hazard for human health and environment in the case of inappropriate application and waste disposal. In this work we enabled identification of the inks that contain these hazardous substances by developing a new method for the analysis of BPA and BFN in thermochromic printing inks. The method is based on the reversed-phase liquid chromatography (LC) with UV detection at 226 and 254?nm. Ultrasound-assisted sample extraction in methanol was proven to be the most suitable and effective among several other solvents. The method was completely validated with satisfactory results. The specificity of the method was proven by the additional LC–tandem mass spectrometry analysis. A representative group of 15 ink samples from various manufacturers, curing and printing modes was analyzed. BPA was found in three samples with mass fractions of about 2% while BFN was found in two samples with mass fractions of 0.34 and 0.66%.     

A multi-analytical approach for the characterization of powders from the Pompeii archaeological site

Nine black powders found in Pompeii houses in three different types of bronze vessels (cylindrical theca atramentaria, unguentaries, and aryballoi) were characterized in order to assess a correspondence between the composition and the type of vessel and, possibly, to verify if these powders were inks or not. For the compositional characterization, a multi-analytical approach was adopted, which involved the use of scanning electron microscopy-energy dispersive X-ray, Fourier-transformed infrared spectroscopy, Raman, X-ray diffraction, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis, gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (GC/MS), and pyrolysis GC/MS. Powders contained in cylindrical theca atramentaria form a homogeneous group, and their organic and inorganic compositions suggest that they were writing inks, while powders contained in unguentaries and aryballoi could have had several different uses, including writing inks and cosmetics. Furthermore, the composition profile of the powders found in cylindrical cases shows that, at 79?AD: , in Pompeii, carbon-based inks were still used for writing, and iron gall inks had not been introduced yet.     

A General One‐Pot Strategy for the Synthesis of High‐Performance Transparent‐Conducting‐Oxide Nanocrystal Inks for All‐Solution‐Processed Devices

For all‐solution‐processed (ASP) devices, transparent conducting oxide (TCO) nanocrystal (NC) inks are anticipated as the next‐generation electrodes to replace both those synthesized by sputtering techniques and those consisting of rare metals, but a universal and one‐pot method to prepare these inks is still lacking. A universal one‐pot strategy is now described; through simply heating a mixture of metal–organic precursors a wide range of TCO NC inks, which can be assembled into high‐performance electrodes for use in ASP optoelectronics, were synthesized. This method can be used for various oxide NC inks with yields as high as 10 g. The formed NCs are of high crystallinity, uniform morphology, monodispersity, and high ink stability and feature effective doping. Therefore, the inks can be readily assembled into films with a surface roughness of 1.6 nm. Typically, a sheet resistance of 110 Ω sq^?1 can be achieved with a transmittance of 88 %, which is the best performance for TCO NC ink‐based electrodes described to date. These electrodes can thus drive a polymer light‐emitting diode (PLED) with a luminance of 2200 cd m^?2 at 100 mA cm^?2.     

Solvent replacement (decane → hexane) in concentrated silver organosols stabilized with sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate

The structure-related properties of silver nanoparticles synthesized in reverse micellar solutions of sodium bis(2-ethylhexyl) sulfosuccinate (AOT) have been studied in the processes of electrophoretic concentraton of nanoparticles, drying of concentrates, and redispersion in n-hexane and n-decane. It has been shown that the dispersity of nanoparticles and stability of organosols to aggregation remain preserved upon the replacement of a low-volatile solvent (decane) by a high-volatile solvent (hexane). The developed procedures enable one to easily regulate important technological characteristics of metal-based inkjet “nanoinks,” such as concentration and size of particles, as well as viscosity and drying rate of the inks.     

裂解气相色谱法分析蓝色中性笔字迹的书写墨水种类及墨迹随书写时间的变化规律

中性笔是当前比较流行的一种书写工具,其墨水多采用颜料作为色料成分,很难用水和有机溶剂进行提取,故无法利用分析圆珠笔油墨和水性笔墨水所采用的气相色谱或高效液相色谱等方法进行检验。目前在法庭科学领域内还没有一种有效的方法用于分析中性笔字迹的书写墨水。采用裂解气相色谱法分析了蓝色中性笔字迹的书写墨水,根据色谱峰的个数和保留时间将收集的65个样品分成3类,其中大部分样品属于具有铜酞菁颜料主要色谱峰的第二大类。色谱峰的保留时间和峰面积比值的分析结果表明所建立的分析方法重现性好且稳定。在此基础上,对蓝色中性笔墨迹随书写时间的变化规律进行了初步研究,得出了老化曲线。     

Scalable Preparation of Photochromic Composite Foils with Excellent Reversibility for Light Printing

Photochromic inks for repeatable light‐printed media have attracted increasing attention owing to the fact that they may be widely applied to reduce the consumption of papers and plastics and conserve the environment. Therefore, it is of practical significance to develop convenient photochromic inks with a low cost and on a large scale. In this study, a simple one‐step hydrothermal route was used to prepare tungsten trioxide (WO₃) nanoparticles, which were further used to make photochromic inks and transparent photochromic films. The obtained transparent photochromic film could rapidly respond to UV light within tens of seconds, then return to its initial state, with different recovery times at different temperatures, and also exhibit good reversible coloration–bleaching effect. A typical polyethylene terephthalate (PET) foil coated with the photochromic ink could also be repeatedly printed with various patterns and displayed excellent rewritable performance over tens of cycles. This study proposes a simple method for widespread applications of WO₃‐based photochromic inks.     

In silico engineering of tailored ink-binding ability at molecular printboards.

Molecular recognition between guest ink molecules and beta-cyclodextrin (beta-CD) cavities at self-assembled monolayers provides a molecular printboard for nanopatterning applications. We recently used molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to describe the specificity of ink-printboard binding and here extend the simulations to include charged cyclodextrin hosts, necessary to broaden the chemistry of molecular printboards and bind charged inks such as the ferrocenium cation. Shifting to high pH, or alternatively grafting a charged sidearm onto beta-CD, created three distinct types of anionic beta-CD cavity and we used electronic structure calculations and MD simulations to measure host-guest charge transfer and binding strengths. We find that steric recognition of uncharged organic molecules is retained at the charged printboards, and that improved guest-host electrostatic contacts can strengthen binding of larger inks while penalising small inks, enhancing the level of discrimination. A prudent choice of complementary host-guest shape and charge states thus provides a means of tuning both ink binding strength and specificity at molecular printboards.