Combined bond-polarization basis sets for accurate determination of dissociation energies

Summary The effect of bond functions on the basis set superposition error (BSSE) is investigated at both SCF (self consistent field) and correlated levels for a number of basis sets using the pairwise additive function counterpoise (PAFC), the site-site function counterpoise (SSFC), and the newly proposed successive reaction counterpoise method (SRCP). BSSEs using bond functions are shown to be roughly twice those without bond functions, whereas the latter may still be quite sizeable. The addition of f functions dramatically decreases the bond function BSSE. The results obtained support the empirical decision in our earlier papers to neglect BSSE altogether.     

On basis set superposition error corrected stabilization energies for large n-body clusters

In this contribution, we propose an approximate basis set superposition error (BSSE) correction scheme for the site-site function counterpoise and for the Valiron-Mayer function counterpoise correction of second order to account for the basis set superposition error in clusters with a large number of subunits. The accuracy of the proposed scheme has been investigated for a water cluster series at the CCSD(T), CCSD, MP2, and self-consistent field levels of theory using Dunning's correlation consistent basis sets. The BSSE corrected stabilization energies for a series of water clusters are presented. A study regarding the possible savings with respect to computational resources has been carried out as well as a monitoring of the basis set dependence of the approximate BSSE corrections.     

On the counterpoise correction for the basis set superposition error in large systems

The appropriateness of the use of the counterpoise correction for the basis set superposition error in SCF calculations of the interaction energies for pairs of aliphatic amino acids is analyzed in this paper. Our results show that for this type of molecule where the magnitude of the basis set superposition error can become quite big, the use of the counterpoise method provides interaction energies in good agreement with near Hartree-Fock values. The inaccuracies associated with the counterpoise method are much less important compared with the basis set superposition error itself. It is shown that the use of a well-balanced minimal basis set together with the counterpoise method is a good compromise (quality versus computational cost) for calculating interaction energies in systems involving molecules of biological interest.     

Hydrogen-bonding interaction of 5,6-dihydrouracil with RNA bases: DFT and MP2 studies

5,6-Dihydrouracil (DHU) is a rare pyrimidine base naturally occurring in tRNAs, it differs from the base uracil due to the saturation of the C₅–C₆ bond. This work presents the interaction energies of complexes formation involving DHU bound to the natural RNA bases adenine (A), uracil (U), guanine (G), and cytosine (C). Full geometry optimization has been performed for the studied complexes by B3LYP/6-31+G(d,p) and MP2/6-31+G(d,p) calculations. The interaction energies were corrected for the basis-set superposition error (BSSE), using the full Boys–Bernardi counterpoise correction scheme. We find that the stability order is DHU:G > DHU:A > DHU:C  DHU:U.     

Hydrogen bonding in the urea dimers and adenine–thymine DNA base pair: anharmonic effects in the intermolecular H-bond and intramolecular H-stretching vibrations

The equilibrium structures, binding energies, vibrational harmonic frequencies, and the anharmonic corrections for two different (cyclic and asymmetric) urea dimers and for the adenine–thymine DNA base pair system have been studied using the second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) method and different density functional theory (DFT) exchange–correlation (XC) functionals (BLYP, B3LYP, PBE, HCTH407, KMLYP, and BH and HLYP) with the D95V, D95V**, and D95V++** basis sets. The widely used a posteriori Boys–Bernardi or counterpoise correction scheme for basis set superposition error (BSSE) has been included in the calculations to take into account the BSSE effects during geometry optimization (on structure), on binding energies and on the different levels of approximation used for calculating the vibrational frequencies. The results obtained with the ab initio MP2 method are compared with those calculated with different DFT XC functionals; and finally the suitability of these DFT XC functionals to describe intermolecular hydrogen bonds as well as harmonic frequencies and the anharmonic corrections is assessed and discussed.     

Parameterization of a B3LYP specific correction for non-covalent interactions and basis set superposition error on a gigantic dataset of CCSD(T) quality non-covalent interaction energies

A vast number of non-covalent interaction energies at the counterpoise corrected CCSD(T) level have been collected from the literature to build a diverse new dataset. The whole dataset, which consists of 2027 CCSD(T) energies, includes most of the published data at this level. A large subset of the data was then used to train a novel, B3LYP specific, empirical correction scheme for non-covalent interactions and basis set superposition error (abbreviated as B3LYP-MM). Results obtained with our new correction scheme were directly compared to benchmark results obtained with B3LYP-D3(1) and M06-2X(2) (two popular density functions designed specifically to accurately model non-covalent interactions). For non-covalent complexes dominated by dispersion or dipole-dipole interactions all three tested methods give accurate results with the medium size aug-cc-pVDZ(3-6) basis set with MUE's of 0.27 (B3LYP-MM), 0.32 (B3LYP-D3) and 0.47 kcal/mol (M06-2X) (with explicit counterpoise corrections). These results validate both B3LYP-D3 and M06-2X for interactions of this type using a much larger data set than was presented in prior work. However, our new dispersion correction scheme shows some clear advantages for dispersion and dipole-dipole dominated complexes with the small LACVP* basis set, which is very popular in use due to its low associated computational cost: The MUE for B3LYP-MM with the LACVP* basis set for this subset of complexes (without explicit counterpoise corrections) is only 0.28 kcal/mol, compared to 0.65 kcal/mol for M06-2X or 1.16 kcal/mol for B3LYP-D3. Additionally, our new correction scheme also shows major improvements in accuracy for hydrogen-bonded systems and for systems involving ionic interactions, for example cation-π interactions. Compared to B3LYP-D3 and M06-2X, we also find that our new B3LYP-MM correction scheme gives results of higher or equal accuracy for a large dataset of conformer energies of di- and tripeptides, sugars, and cysteine.     

Can extrapolation to the basis set limit be an alternative to the counterpoise correction? A study on the helium dimer

Configuration interaction and coupled cluster calculations are reported for He₂ using various orbital basis sets of the d-aug-AVXZ type, with the results being extrapolated to the one electron basis set limit both with counterpoise and without counterpoise correction. A generalized uniform singlet- and triplet-pair extrapolation scheme has been utilized for such a purpose. Using appropriate corrections to mimic full configuration interaction, the energies were predicted in excellent agreement with the best available estimates. The results also suggest that extrapolation to the complete basis set limit may be a general alternative to the counterpoise correction that yields a more accurate potential energy while being more economical.     

On the basis set superposition error in supermolecular calculations of interaction-induced electric properties: many-body components

In the present paper we analyze basis set superposition error (BSSE) removal methods from many-body components of interaction-induced electric properties. The Valiron–Mayer function counterpoise (VMFC), site–site function counterpoise (SSFC) and TB methods have been employed in order to obtain the incremental optical components of linear hydrogen fluoride clusters (HF)n, where n = {3,4}. Following Mierzwicki and Latajka, who have performed similar calculations for the interaction energy, we compare those three methods of eliminating BSSE using several Dunning’s correlation consistent basis sets.     

Møller-Plesset perturbation energies and distances for HeC(20) extrapolated to the complete basis set limit

The potential energy surface for the C₂₀–He interaction is extrapolated for three representative cuts to the complete basis set limit using second‐order Møller–Plesset perturbation calculations with correlation consistent basis sets up to the doubly augmented variety. The results both with and without counterpoise correction show consistency with each other, supporting that extrapolation without such a correction provides a reliable scheme to elude the basis‐set‐superposition error. Converged attributes are obtained for the C₂₀– He interaction, which are used to predict the fullerene dimer ones. Time requirements show that the method can be drastically more economical than the counterpoise procedure and even competitive with Kohn‐Sham density functional theory for the title system. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Comput Chem, 2009     

Dressed Second-order Epstein–Nesbet Perturbation Theory and Consequences of Orbital Delocalization for the BSSE Correction in Dimer Systems (in Honor of J.-P. Malrieu)

The dressed diagonal approximation to the self-consistent – size consistent CI, corrected for off-diagonal Fock matrix elements in localized orbitals is developed and applied to the ammoniac dimer system. A quite correct correlation energy can be obtained for this system, with a significantly reduced dependence of the results on the choice of the localization procedure. When calculating an interaction energy, the choice of the monomer orbitals and the application of the Boys–Bernardi counterpoise procedure shows in this case an unusual behavior: the correlation energy does not increase with the size of the atomic basis sets. Nevertheless a reasonable potential curve can be obtained.     

Analysis of the interaction energy in the Cu+-H2O and Cl−-H2O systems,with CP corrections to the BSSE of the separate terms,and MC simulations of the aqueous systems with and without CP corrections

The interaction energyE of the systems Cu⁺-H₂O and Cl^–-H₂O has been computed over a wide range of distances and orientations with the MINI-1 basis set in the SCF approximation. The interaction energy has been decomposed according to the Kitaura-Morokuma scheme, with and without counterpoise (CP) corrections to the basis set superposition error. The importance of this correction is analysed by its effect upon Monte Carlo calculations of the Cu⁺-water and Cl^–-water systems, using two-body potentials without and with CP corrections. The effect of CP corrections on theE analysis is similar to that found in other systems of analogous composition (of the general type ion plus neutral ligands), but with significant differences in the details. The effect of the CP corrections to the interaction potential, and then on the results of the Monte Carlo simulations, is small for the Cu⁺ ion, but remarkable for the Cl^– ion.     

Communication: efficient counterpoise corrections by a perturbative approach

We investigate the use of Hartree-Fock and density functional perturbative corrections for estimating the counterpoise correction (CPC) for interaction energies at the self-consistent field level. We test our approach using several popular basis sets on the S22 set of weakly bound systems, which can exhibit large basis set superposition errors. Our results show that the perturbative approaches typically recover over 95% of the CPC and can be up to twelve times faster to compute than the conventional methods and therefore provide an attractive alternative to calculating CPCs in the conventional way.     

Towards a “Chemical” Hamiltonian

An analysis of the LCAO Hamiltonian is performed in terms of a “mixed” formulation of the second quantization for nonorthogonal orbitals, compressing the different interactions to one- and two-center terms as far as possible by performing appropriate projections. For this purpose an operator of atomic charge is also introduced, the expectation values of which are the Mulliken gross atomic populations on the individual atoms. The LCAO Hamiltonian is decomposed into terms having different physical meaning and significance: (i) sum of effective atomic Hamiltonians; (ii) the electrostatic interactions in the point-charge approximation; (iii) the electrostatic effects connected with the deviation of the actual charge distribution from the pointlike one; (iv) two-center overlap effects; (v) finite basis (“counterpoise”) correction terms related to the individual atoms; and (vi) similar finite basis correction terms with respect to the two-center interactions. Only terms of types (i) to (iv), containing no three- or four-center integrals, are considered as having physical significance. Based on the analysis of the Hamiltonian, an energy partitioning scheme is developed, and explicit expressions are given for one- and two-center (and basis extension) components of the SCF energy. The approach is also applied to the problem of intermolecular interactions, and an explicit formula is given permitting calculation of the “counterpoise” part of the supermolecule energy by properly taking into account that it depends not only on the extension of the basis, but also on the occupation of the additional orbitals in the intervening molecule—a factor completely overlooked in the usual scheme of calculations.     

On the calculations of interaction energies and induced electric properties within the polarizable continuum model

In this work we investigate the influence of a polarizable environment on the interaction energies and the interaction-induced (excess) static electric dipole properties for the selected model hydrogen-bonded complexes. The excess properties were estimated for water and hydrogen fluoride dimers using the supermolecular approach and assuming the polarizable continuum model (PCM) as a representation of the polarizable environment. We analyze in this context the performance of the counterpoise correction and the consequences of various possible monomer cavity choices. The polarizable environment reduces the absolute magnitudes of interaction energies and interaction-induced dipole moments, whereas an increase is observed for the absolute magnitudes of induced polarizabilities and first hyperpolarizabilities. Our results indicate that the use of either monomeric (MC) or dimeric (DC) cavities in calculations of monomer properties does not change qualitatively the resultant excess properties. We conclude that the DC scheme is more consistent with the definition of the interaction energy and consequently also the interaction-induced property, whereas the MC scheme corresponds to the definition of stabilization energy. Our results indicate also a good performance of the counterpoise correction scheme for the self-consistent methods in the case of all studied properties.     

The effect of methylation on the hydrogen-bonding and stacking interaction of nucleic acid bases

Methylated nucleosides play an important role in DNA/RNA function, and may affect republication by interrupting the base-pairing and base-stacking. In order to investigate the effect of methylation on the interaction between nucleic acid bases, this work presents the hydrogen-bonding and stacking interactions between 5-methylcytosine and guanine (G), cytosine (C) and G, 1-methyladenine and thymine (T), as well as adenine and T. Geometry optimization and potential energy surface scan have been performed for the involved complexes by MP2 calculations. The interaction energies, which were corrected for the basis-set superposition error by the full Boys–Bernardi counterpoise correction scheme, were used to evaluate the interaction intensity of these nucleic acid bases. The atoms in molecules theory and natural bond orbital analysis have been performed to study the hydrogen bonds in these complexes. The result shows that the methyl substitute contributes the stability to these complexes because it enhances either the hydrogen bonding or the staking interaction between nucleic acid bases studied.     

Approximations to complete basis set-extrapolated, highly correlated non-covalent interaction energies

The first-principles calculation of non-covalent (particularly dispersion) interactions between molecules is a considerable challenge. In this work we studied the binding energies for ten small non-covalently bonded dimers with several combinations of correlation methods (MP2, coupled-cluster single double, coupled-cluster single double (triple) (CCSD(T))), correlation-consistent basis sets (aug-cc-pVXZ, X = D, T, Q), two-point complete basis set energy extrapolations, and counterpoise corrections. For this work, complete basis set results were estimated from averaged counterpoise and non-counterpoise-corrected CCSD(T) binding energies obtained from extrapolations with aug-cc-pVQZ and aug-cc-pVTZ basis sets. It is demonstrated that, in almost all cases, binding energies converge more rapidly to the basis set limit by averaging the counterpoise and non-counterpoise corrected values than by using either counterpoise or non-counterpoise methods alone. Examination of the effect of basis set size and electron correlation shows that the triples contribution to the CCSD(T) binding energies is fairly constant with the basis set size, with a slight underestimation with CCSD(T)∕aug-cc-pVDZ compared to the value at the (estimated) complete basis set limit, and that contributions to the binding energies obtained by MP2 generally overestimate the analogous CCSD(T) contributions. Taking these factors together, we conclude that the binding energies for non-covalently bonded systems can be accurately determined using a composite method that combines CCSD(T)∕aug-cc-pVDZ with energy corrections obtained using basis set extrapolated MP2 (utilizing aug-cc-pVQZ and aug-cc-pVTZ basis sets), if all of the components are obtained by averaging the counterpoise and non-counterpoise energies. With such an approach, binding energies for the set of ten dimers are predicted with a mean absolute deviation of 0.02 kcal/mol, a maximum absolute deviation of 0.05 kcal/mol, and a mean percent absolute deviation of only 1.7%, relative to the (estimated) complete basis set CCSD(T) results. Use of this composite approach to an additional set of eight dimers gave binding energies to within 1% of previously published high-level data. It is also shown that binding within parallel and parallel-crossed conformations of naphthalene dimer is predicted by the composite approach to be 9% greater than that previously reported in the literature. The ability of some recently developed dispersion-corrected density-functional theory methods to predict the binding energies of the set of ten small dimers was also examined.     

Improved SCF interaction energy decomposition scheme corrected for basis set superposition effect

A modified scheme for SCF interaction energy decomposition has been proposed where the nonphysical basis set superposition error (BSSE ) has been corrected by means of the counterpoise method. A new procedure to separate the exchange and induction energy terms free of nonphysical BSSE has been tested in the case of the H₂O dimer. The first order BSSE appears to be non-negligible for strong hydrogen bonded complexes. In addition the scheme allows separation of the long-controversial charge-transfer contribution within the induction term, which has been considerably overestimated in previous studies.     

A polarizable dipole–dipole interaction model for evaluation of the interaction energies for NH···OC and CH···OC hydrogen‐bonded complexes

In this article, a polarizable dipole–dipole interaction model is established to estimate the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances and the interaction energies for hydrogen‐bonded complexes containing peptide amides and nucleic acid bases. We regard the chemical bonds N? H, C?O, and C? H as bond dipoles. The magnitude of the bond dipole moment varies according to its environment. We apply this polarizable dipole–dipole interaction model to a series of hydrogen‐bonded complexes containing the N? H···O?C and C? H···O?C hydrogen bonds, such as simple amide‐amide dimers, base‐base dimers, peptide‐base dimers, and β‐sheet models. We find that a simple two‐term function, only containing the permanent dipole–dipole interactions and the van der Waals interactions, can produce the equilibrium hydrogen bond distances compared favorably with those produced by the MP2/6‐31G(d) method, whereas the high‐quality counterpoise‐corrected (CP‐corrected) MP2/aug‐cc‐pVTZ interaction energies for the hydrogen‐bonded complexes can be well‐reproduced by a four‐term function which involves the permanent dipole–dipole interactions, the van der Waals interactions, the polarization contributions, and a corrected term. Based on the calculation results obtained from this polarizable dipole–dipole interaction model, the natures of the hydrogen bonding interactions in these hydrogen‐bonded complexes are further discussed. © 2013 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.     

Relative strength of hydrogen bond interaction in alcohol–water complexes

Hydrogen binding energies are calculated for the different isomers of 1:1 complexes of methanol, ethanol and water using ab initio methods from MP2 to CCSD(T). Zero-point energy vibration and counterpoise corrections are considered and electron correlation effects are analyzed. In methanol–water and ethanol–water the most stable heterodimer is the one where the water plays the role of proton donor. In methanol–ethanol the two isomers have essentially the same energy and no favorite heterodimer could be discerned. The interplay between the relative binding energy is briefly discussed in conjunction with the incomplete mixing of alcohol–water systems.