Prediction of folding stability and degradability of thede novo designed protein MB-1 in cow rumen

The authors have recently reported on the design of a protein (MB-1) enriched in methionine, threonine, lysine, and leucine. The protein is intended to be produced by rumen bacteria, in a way that would provide high producing lactating cows with limiting amino acids. In this report, MB-1 stability in the rumen is assessed, i.e., where the protein might be found after cell lysis or after being secreted by rumen bacteria. Current in vitro methods used to predict proteolytic degradability in the rumen were used for MB-1, as well as other natural proteins for comparison. MB-1 was found to be more susceptible to degradation than cytochrome c and ribonuclease A. Data indicate that MB-1 will be rapidly degraded if exposed to the rumen environment without protection. The contribution of folding stability to proteolytic stability was also examined. Rumen liquor components were selected to formulate a solution compatible with constraints of thermal denaturation studies. Denaturation curves show that the natural proteins were folded at rumen temperature. The MB-1 denaturation curves indicated that MB-1 does not unfold in a cooperative transition when heated from 20 to 70‡C. This suggests that MB-1 structure may be progressively modified as temperature increases, and that a continuum of conformations are available to MB-1. At 39‡C, a significant (50%) portion of MB-1 molecules had their tertiary structure unfolded, contributing to proteolytic degradability. Despite the unusual constraints used in MB-1 design (i.e., a maximized content in selected essential amino acids), results show that MB-1 has structural properties similar to previously reportedde novo designed proteins.     

Conformational studies of the robust 2-Cys peroxiredoxin Salmonella typhimurium AhpC by solution phase hydrogen/deuterium (H/D) exchange monitored by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

This is the first comprehensive HX-MS study of a "robust" 2-Cys peroxiredoxin (Prx), namely Salmonella typhimurium AhpC (StAhpC). Prx proteins control intracellular peroxide levels and are abundant antioxidant proteins in eukaryotes, archaea and bacteria. Crystal structural analyses and structure/activity studies of several bacterial and mammalian 2-Cys Prxs have revealed that the activity of 2-Cys Prxs is regulated by redox-dependent oligmerization and a sensitivity of the active site cysteine residue to overoxidation. The propensity to overoxidation is linked to the conformational flexibility of the peroxidatic active site loop. The HX-MS results emphasize the modulation of the conformational motility of the active site loop by disulfide formation. To obtain information on the conformational impact of decamer formation on the active site loop motility, mutants with Thr77 substituted by Ile, a decamer-disrupting mutation or by Val, a decamer-stabilizing mutation, were studied. For the isoleucine mutant, enhanced mobility was observed for regions encompassing the α4 helix located in the dimer-dimer interface and regions surrounding the peroxidatic loop. In contrast, the T77V mutation resulted in an increase in conformational stability in most regions of the protein except for the active site loop and the region encompassing the resolving cysteine.     

Molecular dynamics simulations of bovine cathepsin B and its complex with CA074

To promote our better understanding of the dynamic stability of the bovine cathepsin B structure, which is characterized by an extra disulfide bond at Cys148-Cys252 from the other species, and of the binding stability of CA074 (a cathepsin B-specific inhibitor), molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were performed for the enzyme and its CA074 complex, assuming a system in aqueous solution at 300 K. The MD simulation covering 400 ps indicated that the existence of a Cys148-Cys252 disulfide bond increases the conformational flexibility of the occluding loop, although the conformational stability of the overall structure is little affected. The structural characteristics of the complex elucidated by X-ray analysis were suggested to be also intrinsic and stable in the dynamic state; the hydrogen bonding/electrostatic interactions between the main and side chains of CA074 and the Sn and Sn' subsites of the enzyme were maintained throughout the MD simulation. Furthermore, the simulation made clear that the binding of CA074 significantly restricted the conformational flexibility of the substrate binding region, especially the occluding loop, of cathepsin B. Statistical analyses during the simulation suggest that the selectivity of CA074 for cathepsin B stems from the tight P1'-S1' and P2'-S2' interactions, assisted in particular by double hydrogen bonds between the carboxyl two oxygens of the CA074 C-terminus and the imidazole NH groups of His110 and His111 residues.     

Determination of the carbohydrate composition and the disulfide bond linkages of bovine lactoperoxidase by mass spectrometry

The extent and distribution of N-glycosylation and the nature of most of the disulfide bond linkages were determined for bovine lactoperoxidase through proteolytic and glycolytic digestions combined with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometric analysis. In addition, 98% of the primary sequence of the protein was confirmed. All five of the asparagines present in sequons were found to be glycosylated, predominantly by high mannose and complex structures. Six disulfide bonds were assigned, including Cys 32-Cys 45, Cys 146-Cys 156, Cys 150-Cys 174, Cys 254-Cys 265, Cys 473-Cys 530 and Cys 571-Cys 596.     

Stability Enhancement of a Dimeric HER2-Specific Affibody Molecule through Sortase A-Catalyzed Head-to-Tail Cyclization

Natural backbone-cyclized proteins have an increased thermostability and resistance towards proteases, characteristics that have sparked interest in head-to-tail cyclization as a method to stability-enhance proteins used in diagnostics and therapeutic applications, for example. In this proof-of principle study, we have produced and investigated a head-to-tail cyclized and HER2-specific Z_HER2:342 Affibody dimer. The sortase A-mediated cyclization reaction is highly efficient (>95%) under optimized conditions, and renders a cyclic Z_HER3:342-dimer with an apparent melting temperature, T_m, of 68 °C, which is 3 °C higher than that of its linear counterpart. Circular dichroism spectra of the linear and cyclic dimers looked very similar in the far-UV range, both before and after thermal unfolding to 90 °C, which suggests that cyclization does not negatively impact the helicity or folding of the cyclic protein. The cyclic dimer had an apparent sub-nanomolar affinity (K_d ~750 pM) to the HER2-receptor, which is a ~150-fold reduction in affinity relative to the linear dimer (K_d ~5 pM), but the anti-HER2 Affibody dimer remained a high-affinity binder even after cyclization. No apparent difference in proteolytic stability was detected in an endopeptidase degradation assay for the cyclic and linear dimers. In contrast, in an exopeptidase degradation assay, the linear dimer was shown to be completely degraded after 5 min, while the cyclic dimer showed no detectable degradation even after 60 min. We further demonstrate that a site-specifically DyLight 594-labeled cyclic dimer shows specific binding to HER2-overexpressing cells. Taken together, the results presented here demonstrate that head-to-tail cyclization can be an effective strategy to increase the stability of an Affibody dimer.     

An experimental approach probing the conformational transitions and energy landscape of antibodies: a glimmer of hope for reviving lost therapeutic candidates using ionic liquid

Understanding protein folding in different environmental conditions is fundamentally important for predicting protein structures and developing innovative antibody formulations. While the thermodynamics and kinetics of folding and unfolding have been extensively studied by computational methods, experimental methods for determining antibody conformational transition pathways are lacking. Motivated to fill this gap, we prepared a series of unique formulations containing a high concentration of a chimeric immunoglobin G4 (IgG4) antibody with different excipients in the presence and absence of the ionic liquid (IL) choline dihydrogen phosphate. We determined the effects of different excipients and IL on protein thermal and structural stability by performing variable temperature circular dichroism and bio-layer interferometry analyses. To further rationalise the observations of conformational changes with temperature, we carried out molecular dynamics simulations on a single antibody binding fragment from IgG4 in the different formulations, at low and high temperatures. We developed a methodology to study the conformational transitions and associated thermodynamics of biomolecules, and we showed IL-induced conformational transitions. We showed that the increased propensity for conformational change was driven by preferential binding of the dihydrogen phosphate anion to the antibody fragment. Finally, we found that a formulation containing IL with sugar, amino acids and surfactant is a promising candidate for stabilising proteins against conformational destabilisation and aggregation. We hope that ultimately, we can help in the quest to understand the molecular basis of the stability of antibodies and protein misfolding phenomena and offer new candidate formulations with the potential to revive lost therapeutic candidates.

Probing the energy landscape and thermodynamics of biomolecules for drug design.     

Force-induced insulin dimer dissociation: a molecular dynamics study

Understanding the forces and dynamics of insulin dissociation is critical for devising formulations for the treatment of insulin-dependent diabetes. In earlier work, we applied AFM-based force spectroscopy to covalently tethered and oriented insulin monomers to assess the effect of molecular orientation on insulin-insulin binding forces. We report here on steered molecular dynamics simulations of the insulin dissociation force spectroscopy experiment. Consistent with our experiments, our simulation results suggest that insulin dimer dissociation occurs near the limit of extensibility of the B-chain. We have also found that the forced dissociation of the insulin dimer is a rate-dependent process, involving significant conformational changes to the monomer(s). The insulin dimer dissociation pathway also depends on the relative strength of the inter-monomer interactions across the antiparallel beta-sheet interface and the intra-monomer interactions of residues A1 and A30 with the insulin B-chain. Our simulation results strongly support the design of bioactive insulin analogues that involves altering hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic interactions across the beta-sheet dimer interface.     

Folding and self-association of atTic20 in lipid membranes: implications for understanding protein transport across the inner envelope membrane of chloroplasts

Background

We have previously shown that the P. gingivalis HmuY hemophore-like protein binds heme and scavenges heme from host hemoproteins to further deliver it to the cognate heme receptor HmuR. The aim of this study was to characterize structural features of HmuY variants in the presence and absence of heme with respect to roles of tryptophan residues in conformational stability.

Results

HmuY possesses tryptophan residues at positions 51 and 73, which are conserved in HmuY homologs present in a variety of bacteria, and a tryptophan residue at position 161, which has been found only in HmuY identified in P. gingivalis strains. We expressed and purified the wildtype HmuY and its protein variants with single tryptophan residues replaced by alanine or tyrosine residues. All HmuY variants were subjected to thermal denaturation and fluorescence spectroscopy analyses. Replacement of the most buried W161 only moderately affects protein stability. The most profound effect of the lack of a large hydrophobic side chain in respect to thermal stability is observed for W73. Also replacement of the W51 exposed on the surface results in the greatest loss of protein stability and even the large aromatic side chain of a tyrosine residue has little potential to substitute this tryptophan residue. Heme binding leads to different exposure of the tryptophan residue at position 51 to the surface of the protein. Differences in structural stability of HmuY variants suggest the change of the tertiary structure of the protein upon heme binding.

Conclusions

Here we demonstrate differential roles of tryptophan residues in the protein conformational stability. We also propose different conformations of apo- and holoHmuY caused by tertiary changes which allow heme binding to the protein.     

Structural and oxygen binding properties of dimeric horse myoglobin

Myoglobin (Mb) stores dioxygen in muscles, and is a fundamental model protein widely used in molecular design. The presence of dimeric Mb has been known for more than forty years, but its structural and oxygen binding properties remain unknown. From an X-ray crystallographic analysis at 1.05 ? resolution, we found that dimeric metMb exhibits a domain-swapped structure with two extended α-helices. Each new long α-helix is formed by the E and F helices and the EF-loop of the original monomer, and as a result the proximal and distal histidines of the heme originate from different protomers. The heme orientation in the dimer was in the normal mode as in the monomer, but regulated faster from the reverse to normal orientation. The dimer possessed the oxygen binding property, although it exhibited a slightly higher oxygen binding affinity (～1.4 fold) compared to the monomer and showed no cooperativity for oxygen binding. The oxygen binding rate constant (k(on)) of the dimer ((14.0 ± 0.7) × 10(6) M(-1) s(-1)) was similar to that of the monomer, whereas the oxygen dissociation rate constant (k(off)) of the dimer (8 ± 1 s(-1)) was smaller than that of the monomer (12 ± 1 s(-1)). We attribute the similar k(on) values to their active site structures being similar, whereas the faster regulation of the heme orientation and the smaller k(off) in the dimer are presumably due to the slight change in the active site structure and/or more rigid structure compared to the monomer. These results show that domain swapping may be a new tool for protein engineering.     

Aromatic-aromatic interactions in proteins: beyond the dimer

Aromatic residues are key widespread elements of protein structures and have been shown to be important for structure stability, folding, protein-protein recognition, and ligand binding. The interactions of pairs of aromatic residues (aromatic dimers) have been extensively studied in protein structures. Isolated aromatic molecules tend to form higher order clusters, like trimers, tetramers, and pentamers, that adopt particular well-defined structures. Taking this into account, we have surveyed protein structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank in order to find clusters of aromatic residues in proteins larger than dimers and characterized them. Our results show that larger clusters are found in one of every two unique proteins crystallized so far, that the clusters are built adopting the same trimer motifs found for benzene clusters in vacuum, and that they are clearly nonlocal brining primary structure distant sites together. We extensively analyze the trimers and tetramers conformations and found two main cluster types: a symmetric cluster and an extended ladder. Finally, using calmodulin as a test case, we show aromatic clsuters possible role in folding and protein-protein interactions. All together, our study highlights the relevance of aromatic clusters beyond the dimer in protein function, stability, and ligand recognition.     

Characterization of specific protein association by 15N CPMG relaxation dispersion NMR: the GB1(A34F) monomer-dimer equilibrium

The Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) transverse relaxation dispersion NMR experiment is a powerful means for detecting and characterizing conformational exchange. This experiment reports the exchange of chemical shifts and therefore can monitor all chemical exchange phenomena, not only intramolecular conformational exchange. Here, we report a CPMG transverse relaxation dispersion study for the monomer-dimer equilibrium of the GB1 point mutant, Ala-34-Phe (GB1(A34F)). This variant exists predominantly as a side-by-side dimer at high concentration (>1 mM). We demonstrate that the dispersion experiment is exceptionally valuable for studying association equilibria since it is extremely sensitive to the minor population in the equilibrium. Twenty-eight individual amide sites in the GB1(A34F) dimer protein were monitored via a 2D (15)N-(1)H HSQC spectroscopy, and all relaxation-derived data are consistent with predominantly an exchange process between dimer and monomer species.     

Why does the silica-binding protein “Si-tag” bind strongly to silica surfaces? Implications of conformational adaptation of the intrinsically disordered polypeptide to solid surfaces

We recently reported that the bacterial 50S ribosomal protein L2 binds strongly to silica surfaces even in the presence of high salt concentrations, detergents, and denaturants such as 8 M urea. We designated L2 as Si-tag, a fusion tag for immobilizing functional proteins on silica materials. Here we discuss the remarkable properties of the Si-tag polypeptide in order to understand the mechanism underlying this binding. Experimental and theoretical studies have shown that the 60-aa N-terminal region and the 71-aa C-terminal region, both of which are rich in positively charged residues, lack a well-defined three-dimensional structure under physiological conditions. This lack of a stable tertiary structure suggests that Si-tag belongs to a family of intrinsically disordered (ID) proteins that exist as dynamic ensembles of rapidly fluctuating structures in aqueous solution. Because of its inherent flexibility, Si-tag could form a large intermolecular interface and optimize its structure for surface interactions by conformational adaptation at the binding interface. Such conformational adaptation occurring concomitantly with binding is common to many ID proteins and is called "coupled folding and binding". Through this conformational adaptation, Si-tag could optimize the interactions between its positively charged side chains and ionized surface silanol groups and between its apolar side chains and hydrophobic surface siloxane sites. The cumulative contribution of these contacts would significantly strengthen the binding of Si-tag, resulting in strong, virtually irreversible binding. Our study suggests that flexible ID proteins have tremendous potential for connecting biomolecules to inorganic materials.     

Protein secondary structure and stability determined by combining exoproteolysis and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

In the post-genomic era, several projects focused on the massive experimental resolution of the three-dimensional structures of all the proteins of different organisms have been initiated. Simultaneously, significant progress has been made in the ab initio prediction of protein three-dimensional structure. One of the keys to the success of such a prediction is the use of local information (i.e. secondary structure). Here we describe a new limited proteolysis methodology, based on the use of unspecific exoproteases coupled with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS), to map quickly secondary structure elements of a protein from both ends, the N- and C-termini. We show that the proteolytic patterns (mass spectra series) obtained can be interpreted in the light of the conformation and local stability of the analyzed proteins, a direct correlation being observed between the predicted and the experimentally derived protein secondary structure. Further, this methodology can be easily applied to check rapidly the folding state of a protein and characterize mutational effects on protein conformation and stability. Moreover, given global stability information, this methodology allows one to locate the protein regions of increased or decreased conformational stability. All of this can be done with a small fraction of the amount of protein required by most of the other methods for conformational analysis. Thus limited exoproteolysis, together with MALDI-TOF MS, can be a useful tool to achieve quickly the elucidation of protein structure and stability.     

Role of steric effects in protein-directed enediyne cycloaromatization of neocarzinostatin

The antibiotic neocarzinostatin comprises a carrier protein with a well-defined cavity for accommodating an active enediyne chromophore. The protein has two disulfides, one (Cys(37)-Cys(47)) lies on the cavity bottom and the other (Cys(88)-Cys(93)) in a constrained short loop. When the chromophore is not bound to the protein, a thiol-induced cycloaromatization of the enediyne into a tetrahydroindacene derivative is responsible for the potent antitumor activity. When it is protein-bound, the protein diverts the cycloaromatization pathway to form a distinct hydroxyisochromene-type product. How the protein directs the enediyne chemistry is an interesting puzzle, and various suggestions have been proposed in the past. We screened more than fifty thiols and manipulated conditions to locate reaction features and search for factors that could influence the protein directing strength. Thiol- and oxygen-concentration-dependence studies suggested that disulfides, which maintain the steric rigidity of the protein, could play a key role in diverting the cycloaromatization pathway. For direct proofs, we made mutations at each of the two disulfides by replacing sulfur atoms with oxygen. Circular dichroism and two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy studies suggested that the mutations changed neither the protein conformation nor the ligand interactions. Analyses of the thiol-induced cycloaromatization revealed that rupture of Cys(37)-Cys(47) made the protein almost completely lose its chemical directing ability, whereas rupture of Cys(88)-Cys(93) had only a minor influence. The results demonstrated that the steric rigidity of the binding cavity, but not necessary the whole protein, played an important role in the protein-directed mechanism.     

Determination of the conformation of 2-hydroxy- and 2-aminobenzoic acid dimers using 13C NMR and density functional theory/natural bond order analysis: the central importance of the carboxylic acid carbon

The 13C chemical shift for the carboxylic acid carbon provides a powerful diagnostic probe to determine the preferred isomeric dimer structures of benzoic acid derivatives undergoing intra- and intermolecular H-bonding in the gas, solution and crystalline phases. We have employed hybrid density functional calculations and natural bond orbital analysis to elucidate the electronic origins of the observed 13C shieldings and their relationship to isomeric stability. We find that delocalizing interactions from the carbonyl oxygen lone pairs (nO) into vicinal carbon-oxygen and carbon-carbon antibonds (sigmaCO*,sigmaCC*) make critical contributions to the 13C shieldings, and these nO --> sigmaCO*, nO --> sigmaCC* interactions are in turn sensitive to the intramolecular interactions that dictate dimer structure and stability. The carboxyl carbon atom can thus serve as a useful detector of subtle structural and conformational features in this pharmacologically important class of carboxylic acid interactions.     

Comparison of bovine and porcine beta-lactoglobulin: a mass spectrometric analysis

Nano-electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (nano-ESI-MS) is applied to comparison of bovine and porcine beta-lactoglobulin (BLG and PLG). The conformational and oligomeric properties of the two proteins under different solvent and experimental conditions are analyzed. The pH-dependence of dimerization is described for the pH range 2-11. The results indicate maximal dimer accumulation at pH 6 for BLG and pH 4 for PLG, as well as a lower stability of the PLG dimer at pH 4 compared to BLG at pH 6. Conformational stability appears to be higher for BLG at acidic pH, but higher for PLG at basic pH. The higher stability of BLG at low pH is revealed by means of either chemical or thermal denaturation. Equilibrium folding intermediates of both proteins are detected. Finally, conditions are found that promote dissociation of the BLG dimer at pH 6 into folded monomers.     

Exploring conformational preferences of proteins: ionic liquid effects on the energy landscape of avidin

In this work we experimentally investigate solvent and temperature induced conformational transitions of proteins and examine the role of ion–protein interactions in determining the conformational preferences of avidin, a homotetrameric glycoprotein, in choline-based ionic liquid (IL) solutions. Avidin was modified by surface cationisation and the addition of anionic surfactants, and the structural, thermal, and conformational stabilities of native and modified avidin were examined using dynamic light scattering, differential scanning calorimetry, and thermogravimetric analysis experiments. The protein-surfactant nanoconjugates showed higher thermostability behaviour compared to unmodified avidin, demonstrating distinct conformational ensembles. Small-angle X-ray scattering data showed that with increasing IL concentration, avidin became more compact, interpreted in the context of molecular confinement. To experimentally determine the detailed effects of IL on the energy landscape of avidin, differential scanning fluorimetry and variable temperature circular dichroism spectroscopy were performed. We show that different IL solutions can influence avidin conformation and thermal stability, and we provide insight into the effects of ILs on the folding pathways and thermodynamics of proteins. To further study the effects of ILs on avidin binding and correlate thermostability with conformational heterogeneity, we conducted a binding study. We found the ILs examined inhibited ligand binding in native avidin while enhancing binding in the modified protein, indicating ILs can influence the conformational stability of the distinct proteins differently. Significantly, this work presents a systematic strategy to explore protein conformational space and experimentally detect and characterise ‘invisible’ rare conformations using ILs.

Revealing solvent and temperature induced conformational transitions of proteins and the role of ion–protein interactions in determining the conformational preferences of avidin in ionic liquids.     

Conformational analysis of the eight-membered ring of the oxidized cysteinyl-cysteine unit implicated in nicotinic acetylcholine receptor ligand recognition.

Nicotinic acetylcholine receptors (nAChRs) are membrane-bound, pentameric ligand-gated ion channels associated with a variety of human disorders such as Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, schizophrenia, and pain. Most known nAChRs contain an unusual eight-membered disulfide-containing cysteinyl-cysteine ring, ox-[Cys-Cys], as does the soluble acetylcholine binding protein (AChBP) found in the snail Lymnaea stagnalis. The cysteinyl-cysteine ring is located in a region implicated in ligand binding, and conformational changes involving this ring may be important for modulation of nAChR function. We have studied the preferred conformations of Ac-ox-[Cys-Cys]-NH2 by NMR in water and computationally by Monte Carlo simulations using the OPLS-AA force field and GB/SA water model. ox-[Cys-Cys] adopts four distinct low-energy conformers at slightly above 0 degrees C in water. Two populations are dependent on the peptide omega2 dihedral angle, with the trans amide favored over the cis amide by a ratio of ca. 60:40. Two ox-[Cys-Cys] conformers with a cis amide bond (C+ and C-) differ from each other primarily by variation of the chi3 dihedral angle, which defines the orientation of the helicity about the S-S bond (+/- 90 degrees ). Two trans amide conformers have the same S-S helicity (chi3 approximately -90 degrees ), but are distinguished by a backbone rotation about phi2 and psi1 (T- and T'-). The ratio of T-/T'-/C+/C- is 47:15:29:9. The orientation of the pendant moieties from the eight-membered ring is more compact for the major trans conformer (T-) than for the extended conformations adopted by T'-, C+, and C-. These conformational preferences are also observed in tetrapeptide and undecapeptide fragments of the human alpha7 subtype of the nAChR that contains the ox-[Cys-Cys] unit. Conformer T- is nearly identical to the conformation seen in the X-ray structure of ox-[Cys(187)-Cys(188)] found in the unliganded AChBP, and is a Type VIII beta-turn.     

Kinetic barriers and ordering of non-covalently bound states

Binding of a dimer of a glycopeptide antibiotic to two molecules of a ligand that are bound to a membrane surface (by a hydrocarbon anchor) has been investigated. This binding on a surface is cooperatively enhanced (surface enhancement) relative to the binding in solution, because the former occurs intramolecularly on a template. Previously a correlation between surface enhancement and thermodynamic stability of the dimer in free solution (Kdimsol) was hypothesised. However, we found that two weakly dimerising antibiotics (vancomycin and ristocetin A) with similar Kdimsol give very different surface enhancements. We propose a model to explain the data correlating surface enhancement to the kinetic barrier to dissociation of the dimer. The surface enhancement of binding can be expected to increase with increasing tightness of the non-covalent interactions formed at the dimer interface. The effect should be found in general where cooperativity is exercised within an organised template (e.g., DNA duplexes and proteins).