The Shapley value for bicooperative games

The aim of the present paper is to study a one-point solution concept for bicooperative games. For these games introduced by Bilbao (Cooperative Games on Combinatorial Structures, 2000) , we define a one-point solution called the Shapley value, since this value can be interpreted in a similar way to the classical Shapley value for cooperative games. The main result of the paper is an axiomatic characterization of this value.     

The Shapley value,the Proper Shapley value,and sharing rules for cooperative ventures

In this note, we discuss two solutions for cooperative transferable utility games, namely the Shapley value and the Proper Shapley value. We characterize positive Proper Shapley values by affine invariance and by an axiom that requires proportional allocation of the surplus according to the individual singleton worths in generalized joint venture games. As a counterpart, we show that affine invariance and an axiom that requires equal allocation of the surplus in generalized joint venture games characterize the Shapley value.     

A dynamic approach to the Shapley value based on associated games

We propose a dynamic process leading to the Shapley value of TU games or any solution satisfying Inessential Game (IG) and Continuity (CONT), based on a modified version of Hamiache's notion of an associated game. The authors are very grateful to William Thomson and two anonymous referees for valuable comments which much improve the paper. They provide better statements and proofs of several major results than the original ones.     

Allocation processes in cooperative games

This paper deals with a temporal aspect of cooperative games. A solution of the game is reached through an allocation process. At each stage of the allocation process of a cooperative game a budget of fixed size is distributed among the players. In the first part of this paper we study a type of process that, at any stage, endows the budget to a player whose contribution to the total welfare, according to some measurements, is maximal. It is shown that the empirical distribution of the budget induced by each process of the family converges to a least square value of the game, one such value being the Shapley value. Other allocation processes presented here converge to the core or to the least core. Received: January 2001/Revised: July 2002 I am grateful to the Associate Editor and to the two anonymous referees of International Journal of Game Theory. This research was partially supported by the Israel Science Foundation, grant no. 178/99     

Partially ordered cooperative games: extended core and Shapley value

In this paper we analyze cooperative games whose characteristic function takes values in a partially ordered linear space. Thus, the classical solution concepts in cooperative game theory have to be revisited and redefined: the core concept, Shapley–Bondareva theorem and the Shapley value are extended for this class of games. The classes of standard, vector-valued and stochastic cooperative games among others are particular cases of this general theory. The research of the authors is partially supported by Spanish DGICYT grant numbers MTM2004-0909, HA2003-0121, HI2003-0189, MTM2007-67433-C02-01, P06-FQM-01366.     

Cooperative grey games and the grey Shapley value

This contribution is located in the common area of operational research and economics, with a close relation and joint future potential with optimization: game theory. We focus on collaborative game theory under uncertainty. This study is on a new class of cooperative games where the set of players is finite and the coalition values are interval grey numbers. An interesting solution concept, the grey Shapley value, is introduced and characterized with the properties of additivity, efficiency, symmetry and dummy player, which are straightforward generalizations of the corresponding properties in the classical cooperative game theory. The paper ends with a conclusion and an outlook to future studies.     

Associated consistency and Shapley value

In this work, a new axiomatization of the Shapley is presented. An associated game is constructed. We define a sequence of games, when the term of order n, in this sequence, is the associated game of the term of order (n−1). We show that the sequence converges and that the limit game is inessential. The solution is obtained using the inessential game axiom, the associated consistency axiom and the continuity axiom. As a by-product, we note that neither the additivity nor the efficiency axioms are needed. Accepted September 2001     

Shapley value for constant-sum games

It is proved that Youngs [4] axiomatization for the Shapley value by marginalism, efficiency, and symmetry is still valid for the Shapley value defined on the class of nonnegative constant-sum games with nonzero worth of grand coalition and on the entire class of constant-sum games as well.The research was supported by NWO (The Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research) grant NL-RF 047-008-010.I am thankful to Theo Driessen, Natalia Naumova and Elena Yanovskaya for interesting discussions and comments. The useful remarks of two anonymous referees are also appreciated.     

Shapley mappings and the cumulative value for n-person games with fuzzy coalitions

In this paper we prove existence and uniqueness of the so-called Shapley mapping, which is a solution concept for a class of n-person games with fuzzy coalitions whose elements are defined by the specific structure of their characteristic functions. The Shapley mapping, when it exists, associates to each fuzzy coalition in the game an allocation of the coalitional worth satisfying the efficiency, the symmetry, and the null-player conditions. It determines a “cumulative value” that is the “sum” of all coalitional allocations for whose computation we provide an explicit formula.     

Axiomatizations of the Shapley value for games on augmenting systems

This paper deals with cooperative games in which only certain coalitions are allowed to form. There have been previous models developed to confront the problem of unallowable coalitions. Games restricted by a communication graph were introduced by Myerson and Owen. In their model, the feasible coalitions are those that induce connected subgraphs. Another type of model is introduced in Gilles, Owen and van den Brink. In their model, the possibilities of coalition formation are determined by the positions of the players in a so-called permission structure. Faigle proposed another model for cooperative games defined on lattice structures. We introduce a combinatorial structure called augmenting system which is a generalization of the antimatroid structure and the system of connected subgraphs of a graph. In this framework, the Shapley value of games on augmenting systems is introduced and two axiomatizations of this value are showed.     

On the Asymmetric Shapley Value for Cooperative Games

We discover an interesting relationship between the Shapley value and the asymmetric Shapley value.AMS Subject Classification (2000): Primary 91A06, 91A12, 91B12, 91B74, Secondary 91A80     

The Shapley value for the probability game

The main goal of this paper is to introduce the probability game. On one hand, we analyze the Shapley value by providing an axiomatic characterization. We propose the so-called independent fairness property, meaning that for any two players, the player with larger individual value gets a larger portion of the total benefit. On the other, we use the Shapley value for studying the profitability of merging two agents.     

Transversality of the Shapley value

A few applications of the Shapley value are described. The main choice criterion is to look at quite diversified fields, to appreciate how wide is the terrain that has been explored and colonized using this and related tools. The title is inspired by a tutorial that one of the authors planned to deliver at the 7th meeting on Game Theory and Practice (Montreal, 2007), but was unable to do it for personal reasons. Thanks to Georges Zaccour whose invitation sparked the present survey.     

The Shapley value for arbitrary families of coalitions

We address the problem of finding a suitable definition of a value similar to that of Shapley’s, when the games are defined on a subfamily of coalitions with no structure. We present two frameworks: one based on the familiar efficiency, linearity and null player axioms, and the other on linearity and the behavior on unanimity games. We give several properties and examples in each case, and give necessary and sufficient conditions on the family of coalitions for the approaches to coincide.     

The Harsanyi value for nontransferable utility games with restricted cooperation

A nontransferable utility (NTU) game assigns a set of feasible pay-off vectors to each coalition. In this article, we study NTU games in situations in which there are restrictions on coalition formation. These restrictions will be modelled through interior structures, which extend some of the structures considered in the literature on transferable utility games for modelling restricted cooperation, such as permission structures or antimatroids. The Harsanyi value for NTU games is extended to the set of NTU games with interior structure.     

Matrix approach to dual similar associated consistency for the Shapley value

In terms of the similarity of matrices, by combining the dual operator and the linear mapping with respect to Hamiache’s associated game on the game space, the Shapley value for TU-games is axiomatized as the unique value verifying dual similar associated consistency, continuity, and the inessential game property.     

Linear and symmetric allocation methods for partially defined cooperative games

A partially defined cooperative game is a coalition function form game in which some of the coalitional worths are not known. An application would be cost allocation of a joint project among so many players that the determination of all coalitional worths is prohibitive. This paper generalizes the concept of the Shapley value for cooperative games to the class of partially defined cooperative games. Several allocation method characterization theorems are given utilizing linearity, symmetry, formulation independence, subsidy freedom, and monotonicity properties. Whether a value exists or is unique depends crucially on the class of games under consideration. Received June 1996/Revised August 2001