Supported lipid bilayers at skeletonized surfaces for the study of transmembrane proteins

Skeletonized zirconium phosphonate surfaces are used to support planar lipid bilayers and are shown to be viable substrates for studying transmembrane proteins. The skeletonized surfaces provide space between the bilayer and the solid support to enable protein insertion and avoid denaturation. The skeletonized zirconium octadecylphosphonate surfaces were prepared using Langmuir-Blodgett techniques by mixing octadecanol with octadecylphosphonic acid. After zirconation of the transferred monolayer, rinsing the coating with organic solvent removes the octadecanol, leaving holes in the film ranging from ～50 to ～500 nm in diameter, depending on the octadecanol content. Upon subsequent deposition of a lipid bilayer, either by vesicle fusion or by Langmuir-Blodgett/Langmuir-Schaefer techniques, the lipid assemblies span the holes providing reservoirs beneath the bilayer. The viability of the supported bilayers as model membranes for transmembrane proteins was demonstrated by examining two approaches for incorporating the proteins. The BK channel protein inserts directly into a preformed bilayer on the skeletonized surface, in contrast to a bilayer on a nonskeletonized film, for which the protein associates only weakly. As a second approach, the integrin α(5)β(1) was reconstituted in lipid vesicles, and its inclusion in supported bilayers on the skeletonized surface was achieved by vesicle fusion. The integrin retains its ability to recognize the extracellular matrix protein fibronectin when supported on the skeletonized film, again in contrast to the response if the bilayer is supported on a nonskeletonized film.     

Solid-supported block copolymer membranes through interfacial adsorption of charged block copolymer vesicles

The properties of amphiphilic block copolymer membranes can be tailored within a wide range of physical parameters. This makes them promising candidates for the development of new (bio)sensors based on solid-supported biomimetic membranes. Here we investigated the interfacial adsorption of polyelectrolyte vesicles on three different model substrates to find the optimum conditions for formation of planar membranes. The polymer vesicles were made from amphiphilic ABA triblock copolymers with short, positively charged poly(2,2-dimethylaminoethyl methacrylate) (PDMAEMA) end blocks and a hydrophobic poly( n-butyl methacrylate) (PBMA) middle block. We observed reorganization of the amphiphilic copolymer chains from vesicular structures into a 1.5+/-0.04 nm thick layer on the hydrophobic HOPG surface. However, this film starts disrupting and dewetting upon drying. In contrast, adsorption of the vesicles on the negatively charged SiO2 and mica substrates induced vesicle fusion and formation of planar, supported block copolymer films. This process seems to be controlled by the surface charge density of the substrate and concentration of the block copolymers in solution. The thickness of the copolymer membrane on mica was comparable to the thickness of phospholipid bilayers.     

Composition and asymmetry in supported membranes formed by vesicle fusion

The structure and formation of supported membranes at silica surfaces by vesicle fusion was investigated by neutron reflectivity and quartz crystal microbalance (QCM-D) measurements. The structure of equimolar phospholipid mixtures of DLPC-DPPC, DMPC-DPPC, and DOPC-DPPC depends intricately on the vesicle deposition conditions. The supported bilayer membranes exhibit varying degrees of compositional asymmetry between the monolayer leaflets, which can be modified by the deposition temperature as well as the salt concentration of the vesicle solution. The total lipid composition of the supported bilayers differs from the composition of the vesicles in solution, and the monolayer proximal to the silica surface is always enriched in DPPC compared to the distal monolayer. The results, which show unambiguougsly that some exchange and rearrangement of lipids occur during vesicle deposition, can be rationalized by considering the effects of salt screening and temperature on the rates of lipid exchange, rearrangement, and vesicle adsorption, but there is also an intricate dependence on the lipid-lipid interactions. Thus, although both symmetric and asymmetric supported bilayers can be prepared from vesicles, the optimal conditions are sensitive to the lipid composition of the system.     

Lipid bilayer deposition and patterning via air bubble collapse

We report a new method for forming patterned lipid bilayers on solid substrates. In bubble collapse deposition (BCD), an air bubble is first "inked" with a monolayer of phospholipid molecules and then touched to the surface of a thermally oxidized silicon wafer and the air is slowly withdrawn. As the bubble shrinks, the lipid monolayer pressure increases. Once the monolayer exceeds the collapse pressure, it folds back on itself, depositing a stable lipid bilayer on the surface. These bilayer disks have lateral diffusion coefficients consistent with high quality supported bilayers. By sequentially depositing bilayers in overlapping areas, fluid connections between bilayers of different compositions are formed. Performing vesicle rupture on the open substrate surrounding this bilayer patch results in a fluid but spatially isolated bilayer. Very little intermixing was observed between the vesicle rupture and bubble-deposited bilayers.     

Surface-dependent transitions during self-assembly of phospholipid membranes on mica, silica, and glass

Formation of supported membranes by exposure of solid surfaces to phospholipid vesicles is a much-used technique in membrane research. Freshly cleaved mica, because of its superior flatness, is a preferred support, and we used ellipsometry to study membrane formation kinetics on mica. Neutral dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (DOPC) and negatively charged dioleoyl-phosphatidylserine/dioleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (20% DOPS/80% DOPC) vesicles were prepared by sonication. Results were compared with membrane formation on silica and glass, and the influence of stirring, buffer, and calcium was assessed. Without calcium, DOPC vesicles had a low affinity (Kd approximately 30 microM) for mica, and DOPS/DOPC vesicles hardly adsorbed. Addition of calcium promptly caused condensation of the adhering vesicles, with either loss of excess lipid or rapid additional lipid adsorption up to full surface coverage. Vesicle-mica interactions dominate the adsorption process, but vesicle-vesicle interactions also seem to be required for the condensation process. Membranes on mica proved unstable in Tris-HCl buffer. For glass, transport-limited adsorption of DOPC and DOPS/DOPC vesicles with immediate condensation into bilayers was observed, with and without calcium. For silica, vesicle adsorption was also rapid, even in the absence of calcium, but the transition to condensed layers required a critical surface coverage of about 50% of bilayer mass, indicating vesicle-vesicle interaction. For all three surfaces, additional adsorption of DOPC (but not DOPS/DOPC) vesicles to condensed membranes was observed. DOPC membranes on mica were rapidly degraded by phospholipase A2 (PLA2), which pleads against the role of membrane defects as initial PLA2 targets. During degradation, layer thickness remained unchanged while layer density decreased, in accordance with recent atomic force microscopy measurements of gel-phase phospholipid degradation by PLA2.     

Study of frictional properties of a phospholipid bilayer in a liquid environment with lateral force microscopy as a function of NaCl concentration

Friction properties of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC)-supported planar bilayers deposited on mica were tested in a liquid environment by lateral force microscopy. The presence of these bilayers was detected by imaging and force measurements with atomic force microscopy. To test how the presence of NaCl affects the frictional properties of the phospholipid bilayers, four DMPC bilayers were prepared on mica in saline media ranging from 0 to 0.1 M NaCl. Changes in the lateral vs vertical force curves were recorded as a function of NaCl concentration and related to structural changes induced in the DMPC bilayer by electrolyte ions. Three friction regimes were observed as the vertical force exerted by the tip on the bilayer increased. To relate the friction response to the structure of the DMPC bilayer, topographic images were recorded at the same time as friction data. Ions in solution screened charges present in DMPC polar heads, leading to more compact bilayers. As a consequence, the vertical force at which the bilayer broke during friction experiments increased with NaCl concentration. In addition, the topographic images showed that low-NaCl-concentration bilayers recover more easily due to the low cohesion between phospholipid molecules.     

Poly(dimethylsiloxane)-coated sensor devices for the formation of supported lipid bilayers and the subsequent study of membrane interactions

The development of smooth hydrophilic surfaces that act as substrates for supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) is important for membrane studies in biology and biotechnology. In this article, it is shown that thin films of poly(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS) formed on a sensor surface can be used as a substrate for the deposition of reproducible and homogeneous zwitterionic SLBs by the direct fusion of vesicles. Poly(dimethylsiloxane) solution (1% w/v) was spin coated on Love acoustic wave and surface plasmon resonance devices to form a thin PDMS layer. Acoustic, fluorescence, and contact angle measurements were used for the optimization of the PDMS film properties as a function of plasma etching time; parameters of interest involve the thickness and hydrophilicity of the film and the ability to induce the formation of homogeneous SLBs without adsorbed vesicles. The application of PDMS-coated sensor devices to the study membrane of interactions was demonstrated during the acoustic and fluorescence detection of the binding of melittin and defensin Crp4 peptides to model supported lipid bilayers.     

Role of nanomechanical properties in the tribological performance of phospholipid biomimetic surfaces

The role of phospholipid bilayers in controlling and reducing frictional forces between biological surfaces is investigated by three complementary experiments: friction forces are measured using a homemade tribometer, mechanical resistance to indentation is measured by AFM, and lipid bilayer degradation is controlled in situ during friction testing using fluorescence microscopy. DPPC lipid bilayers in the solid phase generate friction coefficients as low as 0.002 (comparable to that found for cartilage) that are stable through time. DOPC bilayers formed by the vesicle fusion method or the adsorption of mixed micelles generate higher friction coefficients. These coefficients increased through time, during which the bilayers degraded. The friction coefficient is correlated with the force needed to penetrate the bilayer with the AFM tip. With only one bilayer in the contact region, the friction increased to a similar value of about 0.08 for the DPPC and DOPC. Our study therefore shows that good mechanical stability of the bilayers is essential and suggests that the low friction coefficient is ensured by the hydration layers between adjacent lipid bilayers.     

Direct measurement of forces between a colloidal particle and a phospholipid bilayer

Colloidal interaction forces between a silica particle and a solid-supported Langmuir-Schaefer phospholipid bilayer were directly measured using a gradient optical trap and evanescent wave light scattering. A small custom-built Langmuir trough was integrated with an optical trapping microscope to allow force measurements on a single particle within the subphase of the trough after the dip of the substrate was completed. The novel method allows the force measurements to be conducted without transferring the substratum across an air/water interface. The fluctuating particle position near the bilayer was tracked by evanescent wave light scattering to determine the deflection due to surface forces, and the relaxation time of particle fluctuations was measured to simultaneously determine the viscous forces. Measured equilibrium and viscous force-distance profiles of silica microspheres with diameters of 1 and 5 microm on bilayers of dipalmitoyl phosphatidyl choline (DPPC) were markedly different than force-distance on bare mica and DPPC monolayers under the same electrolyte conditions.     

A class of supported membranes: formation of fluid phospholipid bilayers on photonic band gap colloidal crystals

We report the formation of a new class of supported membranes consisting of a fluid phospholipid bilayer coupled directly to a broadly tunable colloidal crystal with a well-defined photonic band gap. For nanoscale colloidal crystals exhibiting a band gap at the optical frequencies, substrate-induced vesicle fusion gives rise to a surface bilayer riding onto the crystal surface. The bilayer is two-dimensionally continuous, spanning multiple beads with lateral mobilities which reflect the coupling between the bilayer topography and the curvature of the supporting colloidal surface. In contrast, the spreading of vesicles on micrometer scale colloidal crystals results in the formation of bilayers wrapping individual colloidal beads. We show that simple UV photolithography of colloidal crystals produces binary patterns of crystal wettabilities, photonic stopbands, and corresponding patterns of lipid mono- and bilayer morphologies. We envisage that these approaches will be exploitable for the development of optical transduction assays and microarrays for many membrane-mediated processes, including transport and receptor-ligand interactions.     

Polymer cushions functionalized with lipid molecules

This Letter reports a novel approach to the fabrication of a biomimicking surface by modification of an end-functionalizable smooth polymer cushion constructed via chemoselective ligation with a phospholipid-like molecule containing oxyamine groups. The mobility of a phospholipid bilayer formed by vesicle fusion on the phospholipid-like molecule terminated polymer film was characterized by fluorescence recovery after bleaching. Platelet adhesion, as one measure of biocompatibility of the film was also studied and compared to other surfaces such as polyethylene or poly(dimethylsiloxane). The results show that the end-functionalized smooth polymer cushion has potential as a biocompatible platform to reconstitute membrane proteins.     

Creation of lipid partitions by deposition of amphipathic viral peptides

Phospholipid vesicles exhibit a natural characteristic to fuse and reform into a continuous single bilayer membrane on hydrophilic solid substrates such as glass, mica, and silica. The resulting solid-supported bilayer mimics physiological tendencies such as lipid flip-flop and lateral mobility. The lateral mobility of fluorescently labeled lipids fused into solid-supported bilayers is found to change upon deposition on the membrane surface of an amphipathic alpha-helical peptide (AH) derived from the hepatitis C virus (HCV) NS5A protein. The binding of the AH peptide to a phospholipid bilayer, with the helical axis parallel to the bilayer, leads to immobilization of the bilayer. We used AFM to better understand the mechanistic details of this specific interaction, and determined that the diminished fluidity of the bilayer is due to membrane thinning. Utilizing this specific interaction between AH peptides and lipid molecules, we demonstrate a novel process for the creation of lipid partition by employing AH peptides as agents to immobilize lipid molecules, thus creating a patterned solid support with partition-defined areas of freely mobile lipid bilayers. This architecture could have a wide range of applications in novel sensing, biotechnology, high-throughput screening, and biomimetic strategies.     

Fluorophore-encapsulated solid-supported bilayer vesicles: a method for studying membrane permeation processes

This letter describes a new method for studying the interaction of the membrane-lysing enzyme phospholipase A(2) (PLA(2)) with phospholipid bilayers by simultaneous measurements of enzyme binding and vesicle lysis using surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and permeabilization using surface plasmon field-enhanced fluorescence spectroscopy (SPFS). The PLA(2) inhibitor dimethyl-eicosadienoic acid was incorporated into the surface-bound vesicles and support bilayer in order to study its role in preventing PLA(2)-mediated vesicle lysis. This methodology has a generic applicability for the study of a range of membrane-disrupting agents.     

Ordering transitions in nematic liquid crystals induced by vesicles captured through ligand-receptor interactions

We report that phospholipid vesicles incorporating ligands, when captured from solution onto surfaces presenting receptors for these ligands, can trigger surface-induced orientational ordering transitions in nematic phases of 4'-pentyl-4-cyanobiphenyl (5CB). Specifically, whereas avidin-functionalized surfaces incubated against vesicles composed of 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DOPC) were observed to cause the liquid crystal (LC) to adopt a parallel orientation at the surface, the same surfaces incubated against biotinylated vesicles (DOPC and 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-(biotinyl) (biotin-DOPE)) caused the homeotropic (perpendicular) ordering of the LC. The use of a combination of atomic force microscopy (AFM), ellipsometry and quantitative fluorimetry, performed as a function of vesicle composition and vesicle concentration in solution, revealed the capture of intact vesicles containing 1% biotin-DOPE from buffer at the avidin-functionalized surfaces. Subsequent exposure to water prior to contact with the LC, however, resulted in the rupture of the majority of vesicles into interfacial multilayer assemblies with a maximum phospholipid loading set by random close packing of the intact vesicles initially captured on the surface (5.1 ± 0.2 phospholipid molecules/nm(2)). At high concentrations of biotinylated lipid (>10% biotin-DOPE) in the vesicles, the limiting lipid loading was measured to be 4.0 ± 0.3 phospholipid molecules/nm(2), consistent with the maximum phospholipid loading set by the spontaneous formation of a bilayer during incubation with the biotinylated vesicles. We measured the homeotropic ordering of the LC on the surfaces independently of the initial morphology of the phospholipid assembly captured on the surface (intact vesicle, planar multilayer). We interpret this result to infer the reorganization of the phospholipid bilayers either prior to or upon contact with the LCs such that interactions of the acyl chains of the phospholipid and the LC dominate the ordering of the LC, a conclusion that is further supported by quantitative measurements of the orientation of the LC as a function of the phospholipid surface density (>1.8 molecules/nm(2) is required to cause the homeotropic ordering of the LC). These results and others presented herein provide fundamental insights into the interactions of phospholipid-decorated interfaces with LCs and thereby provide guidance for the design of surfaces on which phospholipid assemblies captured through ligand-receptor recognition can be reported via ordering transitions in LCs.     

AFM studies of solid-supported lipid bilayers formed at a Au(111) electrode surface using vesicle fusion and a combination of Langmuir-Blodgett and Langmuir-Schaefer techniques

Atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been used to characterize the formation of a phospholipid bilayer composed of 1,2-dimyristyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC) at a Au(111) electrode surface. The bilayer was formed by one of two methods: fusion of lamellar vesicles or by the combination of Langmuir-Blodgett (LB) and Langmuir-Schaefer (LS) deposition. Results indicate that phospholipid vesicles rapidly adsorb and fuse to form a film at the electrode surface. The resulting film undergoes a very slow structural transformation until a characteristic corrugated phase is formed. Force-distance curve measurements reveal that the thickness of the corrugated phase is consistent with the thickness of a bilayer lipid membrane. The formation of the corrugated phase may be explained by considering the elastic properties of the film and taking into account spontaneous curvature induced by the asymmetric environment of the bilayer, in which one side faces the gold substrate and the other side faces the solution. The effect of temperature and electrode potential on the stability of the corrugated phase has also been described.     

Sub-100 nm patterning of supported bilayers by nanoshaving lithography

Sub-100 nm wide supported phospholipid bilayers (SLBs) were patterned on a planar borosilicate substrate by AFM-based nanoshaving lithography. First, a bovine serum albumin monolayer was coated on the glass and then selectively removed in long strips by an AFM tip. The width of vacant strips could be controlled down to 15 nm. Bilayer lines could be formed within the vacant strips by vesicle fusion. It was found that stable bilayers formed by this method had a lower size limit of approximately 55 nm in width. This size limit stems from a balance between a favorable bilayer adhesion energy and an unfavorable bilayer edge energy.     

Groove-spanning behavior of lipid membranes on microfabricated silicon substrates

We report on a spreading behavior of phospholipid membranes that arise from a lump of phospholipid (a lipid source) on topographically patterned substrates immersed in an aqueous solution. Microgrooves with well-defined shapes were prepared on Si111 surfaces by anisotropic etching in an alkaline solution. A spreading front that consists of membrane lobes and a single lipid bilayer was observed on the patterned silicon substrates by utilizing fluorescence interference contrast (FLIC) microscopy. FLIC images indicate that the membrane lobes span the microgrooves, while the underlying single lipid bilayer spread along the surface of the microgrooves. In fact, fluorescent polystyrene nanoparticles could be encapsulated in the microgrooves that were completely covered with the membrane lobes. The groove-spanning behavior of membrane lobes is discussed in terms of a balance between adhesion and bending energies of lipid bilayers.     

Vesicle and bilayer formation of diphytanoylphosphatidylcholine (DPhPC) and diphytanoylphosphatidylethanolamine (DPhPE) mixtures and their bilayers' electrical stability

Lipid bilayers are of interest in applications where a cell membrane mimicking environment is desired. The performance of the lipid bilayer is largely dependent on the physical and chemical properties of the component lipids. Lipid bilayers consisting of phytanoyl lipids have proven to be appropriate choices since they exhibit high mechanical and chemical stability. In addition, such bilayers have high electrical resistances. Two different phytanoyl lipids, 1,2-diphytanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DPhPC) and 1,2-diphytanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine (DPhPE), and various combinations of the two have been investigated with respect to their behavior in aqueous solutions, their interactions with solid surfaces, and their electrical stability. Dynamic light scattering, nuclear magnetic resonance diffusion, and cryogenic transmission electron microscopy measurements showed that pure DPhPC as well as mixtures of DPhPC and DPhPE consisting of greater than 50% (mol%) DPhPC formed unilamellar vesicles. If the total lipid concentration was greater than 0.15g/l, then the vesicles formed solid-supported bilayers on plasma-treated gold and silica surfaces by the process of spontaneous vesicle adsorption and rupture, as determined by quartz crystal microbalance with dissipation monitoring and atomic force microscopy. The solid-supported bilayers exhibited a high degree of viscoelasticity, probably an effect of relatively high amounts of imbibed water or incomplete vesicle fusion. Lipid compositions consisting of greater than 50% DPhPE formed small flower-like vesicular structures along with discrete liquid crystalline structures, as evidenced by cryogenic transmission electron microscopy. Furthermore, electrophysiology measurements were performed on bilayers using the tip-dip methodology and the bilayers' capacity to retain its electrical resistance towards an applied potential across the bilayer was evaluated as a function of lipid composition. It was shown that the lipid ratio significantly affected the bilayer's electrical stability, with pure DPhPE having the highest stability followed by 3DPhPC:7DPhPE and 7DPhPC:3DPhPE in decreasing order. The bilayer consisting of 5DPhPC:5DPhPE had the lowest stability towards the applied electrical potential.     

A facile approach for assembling lipid bilayer membranes on template-stripped gold

Lipid vesicles are designed with functional chemical groups to promote vesicle fusion on template-stripped gold (TS Au) surfaces that does not spontaneously occur on unfunctionalized Au surfaces. Three types of vesicles were exposed to TS Au surfaces: (1) vesicles composed of only 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) lipids; (2) vesicles composed of lipid mixtures of 2.5 mol % of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-poly(ethylene glycol)-2000-N-[3-(2-pyridyldithio)propionate] (DSPE-PEG-PDP) and 97.5 mol % of POPC; and (3) vesicles composed of 2.5 mol % of 1,2-distearoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphoethanolamine-N-[methoxy(poly(ethylene glycol))-2000] (DSPE-PEG) and 97.5 mol % POPC. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) topography and force spectroscopy measurements acquired in a fluid environment confirmed tethered lipid bilayer membrane (tLBM) formation only for vesicles composed of 2.5 mol % DSPE-PEG-PDP/97.5 mol % POPC, thus indicating that the sulfur-containing PDP group is necessary to achieve tLBM formation on TS Au via Au-thiolate bonds. Analysis of force-distance curves for 2.5 mol % DSPE-PEG-PDP/97.5 mol % POPC tLBMs on TS Au yielded a breakthrough distance of 4.8 ± 0.4 nm, which is about 1.7 nm thicker than that of POPC lipid bilayer membrane formed on mica. Thus, the PEG group serves as a spacer layer between the tLBM and the TS Au surface. Fluorescence microscopy results indicate that these tLBMs also have greater mechanical stability than solid-supported lipid bilayer membranes made from the same vesicles on mica. The described process for assembling stable tLBMs on Au surfaces is compatible with microdispensing used in array fabrication.     

Model cell membranes: Techniques to form complex biomimetic supported lipid bilayers via vesicle fusion

Vesicle fusion has long provided an easy and reliable method to form supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) from simple, zwitterionic vesicles on siliceous substrates. However, for complex compositions, such as vesicles with high cholesterol content and multiple lipid types, the energy barrier for the vesicle-to-bilayer transition is increased or the required vesicle–vesicle and vesicle–substrate interactions are insufficient for vesicle fusion. Thus, for vesicle compositions that more accurately mimic native membranes, vesicle fusion often fails to form SLBs. In this paper, we review three approaches to overcome these barriers to form complex, biomimetic SLBs via vesicle fusion: (i) optimization of experimental conditions (e.g., temperature, buffer ionic strength, osmotic stress, cation valency, and buffer pH), (ii) α-helical (AH) peptide-induced vesicle fusion, and (iii) bilayer edge-induced vesicle fusion. AH peptide-induced vesicle fusion can form complex SLBs on multiple substrate types without the use of additional equipment. Bilayer edge-induced vesicle fusion uses microfluidics to form SLBs from vesicles with complex composition, including vesicles derived from native cell membranes. Collectively, this review introduces vesicle fusion techniques that can be generalized for many biomimetic vesicle compositions and many substrate types, and thus will aid efforts to reliably create complex SLB platforms on a range of substrates.