Use of the kinetic plot method to analyze commercial high-temperature liquid chromatography systems. II. Practically constrained performance comparison

Using a set of experimentally determined plate height data obtained on three commercial high-temperature HPLC supports, and evaluating their isocratic separation speed potential under the application of a set of instrumental constraints, a qualitative map of the practically achievable critical pair separation speed potential of high-temperature HPLC has been established. The obtained data show that the gain in separation speed is more strongly affected by the instrumental limitations in the high-temperature range than it is for the low temperatures. For the presently considered case of alkylbenzene separations, the potential gain in analysis time that can be obtained by going from T=30 to 120 degrees C in the presence of a typical set of instrumental limitations nevertheless remains of the order of a factor of 2-4. The study also shows that improvements on the instrumentation side (increased detector frequency, pumping flow rate, smaller extra-column volumes, ...) are indispensable to fully benefit from the high temperature advantages for all separations requiring less than 10,000 effective theoretical plates.     

Influence of temperature on peak shape and solvent compatibility: implications for two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Solvent compatibility is a limiting factor for the success of two-dimensional liquid chromatography (2-D LC). In the second dimension, solvent effects can result in overpressures as well as in peak broadening or even distortion. A peak shape study was performed on a one-dimensional high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) system to simulate the impact of peak distorting solvent effects on a reversed-phase second dimension separation operated at high temperatures. This study includes changes in injection volume, solute concentration, column inner diameter, eluent composition and oven temperature. Special attention was given to the influence of high temperatures on the solvent effects. High-temperature HPLC (HT-HPLC) is known to enhance second dimension separations in terms of speed, selectivity and solvent compatibility. The ability to minimise the viscosity contrast between the mobile phases of both dimensions makes HT-HPLC a promising tool to avoid viscosity mismatch effects like (pre-)viscous fingering. In case of our study, viscosity mismatch effects could not be observed. However, our results clearly show that the enhancement in solvent compatibility provided by the application of high temperatures does not include the elimination of solvent strength effects. The additional peak broadening and distortion caused by this effect is a potential error source for data processing in 2-D LC.     

Role of solvent in protein phase behavior: Influence of temperature dependent potential

Among many factors that affect protein phase separation, solvent plays a pivotal role in the possible structuring of the solvent molecules around the protein. The effect of solvent structuring is influenced strongly by temperature because of the relative stability of hydrogen bonding at low temperatures. As a result, quantitative as well as qualitative changes in protein phase separation may be expected with change in temperature. Here, we use a temperature dependent pair potential to examine the effect of water in the phase separation of protein solutions. Using Gibbs ensemble Monte Carlo simulations, we observe both a lower critical solution temperature and an upper critical solution temperature, in good agreement with the experimental observations for a number of proteins and phenomenological, statistical thermodynamic arguments. It is found that the effect of solvent is significant at low temperatures as a result of the highly structured shell of water molecules around the protein molecules. Radial distribution functions also indicate that a thick shell of structured water exists around the protein molecules due to the formation of strong hydrogen bonds when temperature is low. The findings of this study suggest that a simple model with a reasonable physical basis can capture the general phase behavior of some proteins or biopolymers.     

Elevated-temperature ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography using very small polybutadiene-coated nonporous zirconia particles

Capillary columns packed with small diameter particles typically lead to low permeability and long separation times in high-performance liquid chromatography. Ultrahigh pressures (>10,000 p.s.i.; 1 p.s.i. is identical with 6,894.76 Pa) can be used to overcome the limitations that small particles impose. Ultrahigh-pressure liquid chromatography (UHPLC) has demonstrated great potential for high-speed and high-efficiency separations. Decreasing the viscosity of the mobile phase by elevating the temperature could additionally reduce the pressure drop and facilitate the use of longer columns or smaller particles to achieve even higher total plate numbers. For this reason, we investigated the use of elevated temperatures in UHPLC. Water-resistant, flexible heater tape covered with insulation was used to provide the desired heat to the column. Polybutadiene-coated 1 microm nonporous zirconia particles were used because of their chemical stability at elevated temperature. A column efficiency as high as 420,000 plates m(-1) was obtained. The effects of temperature and pressure on the separation of parabens were investigated. Separation of five herbicides was completed in 60 s using 26,000 p.s.i. and 90 degrees C.     

Evaluation of the thermal effect on separation selectivity in anion-exchange processes using superheated water ion-exchange chromatography

The thermal effect on retention and separation selectivity of inorganic anions and aromatic sulfonate ions in anion-exchange chromatography is studied on a quaternized styrene-divinylbenzene copolymer anion-exchange column in the temperature range of 40-120 °C using superheated water chromatography. The selectivity coefficient for a pair of identically charged anions approaches unity as temperature increases provided the ions have the same effective size, such that the retention of an analyte ion decreases with an increase in temperature when the analyte ion has stronger affinity for the ion-exchanger than that of the eluent counterion, whereas it increases when it has weaker affinity. The change in anion-exchange selectivity with temperature observed with superheated water chromatography has been discussed on the basis of the effect of temperature on hydration of the ions. At elevated temperatures, especially in superheated water, the electrostatic interaction or association of the ions with the fixed ion in the resin phase becomes a predominant factor resulting in a different separation selectivity from that obtained at ambient temperature.     

Minimum analysis time in capillary gas chromatography vacuum- versus atmospheric-outlet column operation

Previous studies on open tubular column operation at vacuum outlet vs. atmospheric outlet pressures focused on comparisons of given columns, or comparisons of columns with the same inner diameters. It was demonstrated that, for a given separation problem, vacuum outlet operation of columns with a constant i. d. always yields the shortest analysis times (under minimum plate height conditions). In this paper, the comparison of vacuum vs. atmospheric outlet operation is broadened to columns with different dimensions. A general equation for the gain in speed of analysis by vacuum outlet operation of any column, as compared to atmospheric outlet operation of all possible open tubular columns with the same maximum plate number is presented. The resulting equation is further evaluated for thin film columns of different dimensions. It appears that vacuum outlet operation is beneficial only, in terms of speed of analysis, if low maximum plate numbers are required. The gain in speed of analysis is more pronounced for wide-bore than for narrow-bore columns.     

Enrichment of 13C by chemical exchange between CO2and amine carbamate in nonaqueous solvents

Enrichment of ¹³C by chemical exchange between CO₂ and amine carbamate in nonaqueous solvents has been mathematically modelled in two ways. The height equivalent to a theoretical plate and steady-state separation, based on the two models, have been obtained. If only the isotopic exchange between CO₂ gas and amine carbamate is considered, the model can estimate the process performance for pressures close to the atmospheric one and room temperature. For process analysis at pressures higher than the atmospheric one and lower temperatures, a two-step model has been used. Using the two models the effects of pressure have been studied.     

Grafting of styrene into pre-irradiated fluoropolymer films: Influence of base material and irradiation temperature

In this study, the influence of irradiation temperature on mechanical properties of three fluoropolymers and on grafting of styrene into the polymers by the pre-irradiation method was investigated. Electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy and infrared spectroscopy were used to characterize the irradiated polymers regarding trapped radical species and changes in the chemical structure, respectively. For poly(tetrafluoroethylene-co-perfluoropropyl vinyl ether) (PFA) the irradiation temperature was found to be an important factor for tensile strength and elongation at break of the pre-irradiated film. No strong effect of irradiation temperature on the mechanical properties was noticed for poly(tetrafluoroethylene-co-ethylene) (ETFE); however the yield of grafting drops at high irradiation temperatures. Finally, mechanical properties of poly(tetrafluoroethylene) (PTFE) were found to be dramatically altered, even if the film was irradiated at elevated temperature.     

Experimental problems and recent results in polymer melt rheometry

Recent developments helped to solve some experimental problems in polymer melt rheometry: By a stability test one can find out whether under test conditions the individual polymer melt is sufficiently long stable. For melts with long relaxation times, an incomplete creep-test followed by recovery is proposed to determine the linear viscoelastic material functions. In a cone-and-plate rheometer, a very constant heating system and the separation of the plate into a central disk and an outer ring allow us to measure the two normal stress differences in viscometric flows also at higher temperatures. For a commercial LCP, a special sample preparation technique is reported. Melt elongation followed by recovery in combination with morphological studies are presented for a polymer blend (PMMA/PS). From the combination of recovery after melt extension and morphology the interface tension between the melts of PS and PMMA can be determined.     

离子对电色谱法分离机理的理论探讨

离子对电色谱是离子对高效液相色谱与电泳模式的复合体，兼具两种方法的特点；作者基于计量模型的基本假设，并考虑溶质在电色谱过程中的输运机制，通过对溶质在柱过程中涉及的多种平衡过程进行考察，得到了可以说明溶质迁移速率随离子对试剂浓度和各种相互作用之间关系的理论表达式；以中性溶质和简单带电溶质为例，对理论迁移方程进行简化，结果表明带电溶质在离子对电色谱中的迁移过程中同时受色谱机理、离子对作用和电泳分离机理的影响，因此离子对电色谱对样品溶质应有更好的选择性，且适宜于快速分离。     

Can the speed of sound be used for detecting critical states of fluid mixtures?

The phenomenology of sound speeds in fluid mixtures is examined near and across critical lines. Using literature data for binary and ternary mixtures, it is shown that the ultrasound speed along an isotherm-isopleth passes through a minimum value in the form of an angular (or V-shaped) point at critical states. The relation between critical and pseudo-critical coordinates is discussed. For nonazeotropic fixed-composition fluid mixtures, pseudo-critical temperatures and pressures are found to be lower than the corresponding critical temperatures and pressures. The analysis shows that unstable pseudo-critical states cannot be detected using acoustic methods. The thermodynamic link between sound speeds and isochoric heat capacities is formulated and discussed in terms of p-Vm-T derivatives capable of being calculated using cubic equations of state. Based on the Griffiths-Wheeler theory of critical phenomena, a new specific link between critical sound speeds and critical isochoric heat capacities is deduced in terms of the rate of change of critical pressures and critical temperatures along the p-T projection of the critical locus of binary fluid mixtures. It is shown that the latter link can be used to obtain estimates of critical isochoric heat capacities from the experimental determination of critical speeds of sound. The applicability domain of the new link does not include binary systems at compositions along the critical line for which the rate of change in pressure with temperature changes sign. The new equation is combined with thermodynamic data to provide approximate numerical estimates for the speed of sound in two mixtures of carbon dioxide and ethane at different temperatures along their critical isochores. A clear decrease in the sound speed is found at critical points. A similar behavior is suggested by available critical heat capacity data for several binary fluid mixtures. Using an acoustic technique, the critical temperature and pressure were determined for three different mixtures of methane and propane, and compared with literature data obtained using conventional methods. It is concluded that acoustic-based techniques are reliable to determine, for the most part, critical surfaces of fluid mixtures. The remaining few cases where the present analysis cannot be applied could be tested by the thermodynamic calculation of critical sound speeds using crossover equations of state in conjunction with experimentally determined critical isochoric heat capacities.     

DNA sequencing of close to 1000 bases in 40 minutes by capillary electrophoresis using dimethyl sulfoxide and urea as denaturants in replaceable linear polyacrylamide solutions

The goal of this work was to reduce the capillary electrophoresis (CE) separation time of DNA sequencing fragments with linear polyacrylamide solutions while maintaining the previously achieved long read lengths of 1000 bases. Separation speed can be increased while maintaining long read lengths by reducing the separation matrix viscosity and/or raising the column temperature. As urea is a major contributor to the separation buffer viscosity, reducing its concentration is desirable both for increase in the separation speed and easier solution replacement from the capillary. However, at urea concentrations below 6 M, the denaturing capacity of the separation buffer is not sufficient for accurate base-calling. To restore the denaturing properties of the buffer, a small amount of an organic solvent was added to the formulation. We found that a mixture of 2 M urea with 5% v/w of dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) resulted in 975 bases being sequenced at 70 degrees C in 40 min with 98.5% accuracy. To achieve this result, the software was modified to perform base-calling at a peak resolution as low as 0.24. It is also demonstrated that the products of thermal decomposition of urea had a deleterious effect on the separation performance at temperatures above 70 degrees C. With total replacement of urea with DMSO, at a concentration of 5% v/w in the same linear polyacrylamide (LPA)-containing buffer, it was possible to increase the column temperature up to 90 degrees C. At this temperature, up to 951 bases with 98.5% accuracy could be read in only 32 min of separation. However, with DMSO alone, some groups of C-terminated peaks remained compressed, and column temperature at this level cannot at present be utilized with existing commercial instrumentation.     

DNA sequencing with hydrophilic and hydrophobic polymers at elevated column temperatures

Read length in DNA sequencing by capillary electrophoresis at elevated temperatures is shown to be greatly affected by the extent of hydrophobicity of the polymer separation matrix. At column temperatures of up to 80 degrees C, hydrophilic linear polyacrylamide (LPA) provides superior read length and separation speed compared to poly(N,N-dimethylacrylamide) (PDMA) and a 70:30 copolymer of N,N-dimethylacrylamide and N,N-diethylacrylamide (PDEA30). DNA-polymer and polymer intramolecular interactions are presumed to be a major cause of band broadening and the subsequent loss of separation efficiency with the more hydrophobic polymers at higher column temperatures. With LPA, these interactions were reduced, and a read length of 1000 bases at an optimum temperature of 70 degrees -75 degrees C was achieved in less than 59 min. By comparison, PDMA produced a read length of roughly 800 bases at 50 degrees C, which was close to the read length attained in LPA at the same temperature; however, the migration time was approximately 20% longer, mainly because of the higher polymer concentration required. At 60 degrees C, the maximum read length was 850 bases for PDMA, while at higher temperatures, read lengths for this polymer were substantially lower. With the copolymer DEA30, read length was 650 bases at the optimum temperature of 50 degrees C. Molecular masses of these polymers were determined by tandem gel permeation chromatography-multiangle laser light scattering method (GPC-MALLS). The results indicate that for long read, rapid DNA sequencing and analysis, hydrophilic polymers such as LPA provide the best overall performance.     

Corresponding-states laws for protein solutions

The solvent around protein molecules in solutions is structured and this structuring introduces a repulsion in the intermolecular interaction potential at intermediate separations. We use Monte Carlo simulations with isotropic, pair-additive systems interacting with such potentials. We test if the liquid-liquid and liquid-solid phase lines in model protein solutions can be predicted from universal curves and a pair of experimentally determined parameters, as done for atomic and colloid materials using several laws of corresponding states. As predictors, we test three properties at the critical point for liquid-liquid separation: temperature, as in the original van der Waals law, the second virial coefficient, and a modified second virial coefficient, all paired with the critical volume fraction. We find that the van der Waals law is best obeyed and appears more general than its original formulation: A single universal curve describes all tested nonconformal isotropic pair-additive systems. Published experimental data for the liquid-liquid equilibrium for several proteins at various conditions follow a single van der Waals curve. For the solid-liquid equilibrium, we find that no single system property serves as its predictor. We go beyond corresponding-states correlations and put forth semiempirical laws, which allow prediction of the critical temperature and volume fraction solely based on the range of attraction of the intermolecular interaction potential.     

High temperature liquid chromatography of intact proteins using organic polymer monoliths and alternative solvent systems

Alternative approaches to conventional acetonitrile gradient methods for reversed-phase liquid chromatographic analysis of intact proteins have been investigated using commercial poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) monolithic columns (Dionex ProSwift™ RP-2H and RP-4H). Alternative solvents to acetonitrile (2-propanol and methanol) coupled with elevated temperatures demonstrated complementary approaches to adjusting separation selectivity and reducing organic solvent consumption. Measurements of peak area at increasing isothermal temperature intervals indicated that only minor (<5%) decreases in detectable protein recovery occurred between 40 and 100 °C on the timescale of separation (2–5 min). The reduced viscosity of a 2-propanol/water eluent at elevated temperatures permitted coupling of three columns to increase peak production (peaks/min) by 16.5%. Finally, narrow-bore (1 mm i.d.) columns were found to provide a more suitable avenue to fast, high temperature (up to 140 °C) separations.     

Characterization of Ethylene methyl methacrylate and Ethylene butylacrylate Copolymers with Interactive Liquid Chromatography

Summary: Copolymers of ethylene with methyl methacrylate (EMMA) and butyl acrylate (EBA), which are of different average chemical composition and block lengths according to NMR analysis, were analyzed by size exclusion chromatography (SEC), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), Crystallization Analysis Fractionation (CRYSTAF), and high performance liquid chromatography at high temperature (HT-HPLC). With CRYSTAF and DSC crystallizing fractions were detected only in some samples. HT-HPLC fractionated all the samples irrespective of their crystallinity. Homopolymers, PMMA and PE were also found in the copolymer samples of EMMA. EMMA and EBA were separated in HPLC according to the content of polar comonomer. A linear correlation between the MMA content and elution volume could not be established due to the presence of homopolymers as admixtures. In such a case the average chemical composition obtained by NMR does not correspond to the real chemical composition of the copolymers. Unlike EMMA the EBA samples eluted in single peaks, which was used for evaluation of their chemical composition distribution. The comparison of results obtained by fractionation via CRYSTAF and HT-HPLC clearly demonstrates the advantages of the chromatographic approach to study the chemical heterogeneity of olefin based copolymers.     

HPLC separation of triacylglycerol positional isomers on a polymeric ODS column

A polymeric ODS column was applied to the resolution of triacylglycerol positional isomers (TAG-PI), i.e. 1,3-dioleoyl-2-palmitoyl-glycerol (OPO) and 1,2-dioleoyl-3-palmitoyl-rac-glycerol (OOP), with a recycle HPLC system. To investigate the ODS column species and the column temperatures for the resolution of a TAG-PI pair, a mixture of OPO and OOP was subjected to an HPLC system equipped with a non-endcapped polymeric, endcapped monomeric, endcapped intermediate, or non-endcapped monomeric ODS column at three different column temperatures (40, 25, or 10 degrees C). Only the non-endcapped polymeric ODS column achieved the separation of OPO and OOP, and the lowest column temperature (10 degrees C) showed the best resolution for them. The other pair of TAG-PI, a mixture of 1,3-dipalmitoyl-2-oleoyl-glycerol (POP) and 1,2-dipalmitoyl-3-oleoyl-rac-glycerol (PPO) was also subjected to the system equipped with a non-endcapped polymeric or monomeric ODS column at five different column temperatures (40, 32, 25, 17, and 10 degrees C). Thus, POP and PPO were also separated on only the non-endcapped polymeric ODS column at 25 degrees C. However, no clear peak appeared at 10 degrees C. These results would indicate that the polymeric ODS stationary phase has an ability to recognize the structural differences between TAG-PI pairs. Also, the column temperature is a very important factor for separating the TAG-PI pair, and the optimal temperature would relate to the solubility of TAG-PI in the mobile phase. Furthermore, the recycle HPLC system provided measurements for the separation and analysis of TAG-PI pairs.     

Temperature effects in γ-initiated polymerization of styrene. II

Experimental data are presented for the γ-initiated polymerization of commercial styrene at a series of temperatures above ambient. Examination of the early stages of polymerization (up to 10% conversion) has led to the following conclusions. For this system, there exists a critical temperature (109°C) above which the rate of polymerization is independent of dose rate, over a wide range of γ-intensities. This dose rate independence is ascribed to a “limiting rate of initiation,” characteristic of the intensity range. A consequence of this is that at a given temperature above the critical temperature the degree of polymerization is also dose rate-independent. The above phenomena can be expected in any vinyl monomer where the monomer is fairly active and produces relatively stable radicals. Experimental procedure is described, and kinetic analysis presented to substantiate the conclusions.     

Temperature effects on resolution in ion mobility spectrometry

The separation efficiency of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) may be measured in terms of either resolving power, based on a single-peak definition, or peak-to-peak resolution, based on the separation of pairs of adjacent peaks. Usually resolving power decreases with temperature. However, the experimental results show that the peak-to-peak resolution may be increased in some cases. Negative ion mobility spectra of halide ions are better resolved at elevated temperatures. In addition, the peaks corresponding to protonated monomer of amylacetate and the proton-bound dimer of ethylacetate are well separated at 100 °C while they fully overlap at 18 °C. This paper focuses on the effect of temperature on peak-to-peak resolution. It was also observed that in some cases peak-to-peak resolution decreases with temperature. Examples are the spectra of cyclohexanone and methyl-iso-butyl ketone (MIBK) as well as dimethyl methyl phosphonate (DMMP) and MIBK. The increase or decrease in resolution at elevated temperatures has been attributed to the changes in separation factor (α) which is governed by the different hydration and clustering tendency of ions.     

On-line high-performance liquid chromatography/mass spectrometric investigation of amyloid-beta peptide variants found in Alzheimer's disease

Abeta peptides are the major components of amyloid deposits in Alzheimer's disease. The presence of N-terminally truncated Abeta variants in amyloid may be a critical factor in Alzheimer's disease pathogenesis. These Abeta variants are less soluble and more amyloidogenic than full-length Abeta, making their separation, purification and identification difficult. High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) at elevated temperatures, coupled to electrospray ionization (ES) mass spectrometry (MS), enables rapid separation and identification of N-terminally truncated Abeta variants. This methodology provides a potential tool for exploring the importance of these Abeta variants in both the pathogenesis and diagnosis of Alzheimer's disease.