Fast Capillary Gas Chromatography: Comparison of Different Approaches

Savings in analysis time in capillary GC have always been an important issue for chromatographers since the introduction of capillary columns by Golay in 1958. In laboratories where gas chromatographic techniques are routinely applied as an analytical technique, every reduction of analysis time, without significant loss of resolution, can be translated into a higher sample throughput and hence reduce the laboratory operating costs. In this contribution, three different approaches for obtaining fast GC separations are investigated. First, a narrow-bore column is used under conventional GC operating conditions. Secondly, the same narrow-bore column is used under typical fast GC conditions. Here, a high oven temperature programming rate is used. The third approach uses a recent new development in GC instrumentation: Flash-2D-GC. Here the column is placed inside a metal tube, which is resistively heated. With this system, a temperature programming rate of 100°/s is possible. The results obtained with each of these three approaches are compared with results obtained on a column with conventional dimensions. This comparison takes retention times as well as plate numbers and resolution into consideration.     

Fast temperature programming in routine analysis of multiple pesticide residues in food matrices

Flash gas chromatographic (GC) analysis of 15 organophosphorus pesticides commonly occurring in food crops was performed using the Thermedics Detection EZ Flash upgrade kit installed in the oven of a HP 5890 Series II Plus gas chromatograph. The temperature program and splitless time period were the main parameters to be optimized. In the first set of experiments wheat matrix-matched standards were analyzed both by: (i) the flash GC technique (resistive heating of a 5 m capillary column), and (ii) the conventional GC technique (moderate oven temperature programming of a 30 m capillary column). Using the flash GC technique, the analysis time was reduced by a factor of more than 10 compared to the conventional GC technique. Dramatically improved detectability of analytes was achieved due to much narrower peak widths. The flash GC technique was compared with another approach to faster GC analysis employing a 5 m column and fast temperature programming with a conventional GC oven. In comparison with this alternative, in the case of flash GC significantly better retention time repeatability was observed. The other superiority of resistive heating is very rapid cooling down (i.e., equilibration to the initial conditions) which contributes to the increased sample throughput.     

Effects of variation in modulator temperature during cryogenic modulation in comprehensive two‐dimensional gas chromatography

Many modulation systems in comprehensive 2D GC (GC×GC) are based on cryogenic methods. High trapping temperatures in these systems can result in ineffective trapping of the more volatile compounds, whilst temperatures that are too low can prevent efficient remobilisation of some compounds. To better understand the trapping and release of compounds over a wide range of volatilities, we have investigated a number of different constant temperature modulator settings, and have also examined a constant temperature differential between the cryo‐trap and the chromatographic oven. These investigations have led us to modify the temperature regulation capabilities of the longitudinally modulated cryogenic system (LMCS). In contrast to the current system, where the user sets a constant temperature for the cooling chamber, the user now sets the temperature difference between the cryo‐trap and the chromatographic oven. In this configuration, the cooling chamber temperature increases during the chromatographic run, tracking the oven temperature ramp. This produces more efficient, volatility‐dependent modulation, and increases the range of volatile compounds that can be analysed under optimal trap‐and‐release conditions within a single analytical run. This system also reduces cryogenic fluid consumption.     

Fast GC analysis of major volatile compounds in distilled alcoholic beverages: Optimisation of injection and chromatographic conditions

The principal secondary flavour compounds in distilled spirits can be successfully quantified by split injection to a 0.15 mm internal diameter (I.D.) capillary column. Initial conditions for split ratio, gas velocity, initial oven temperature and oven ramp rate are given by method translation from a similar method on a standard 0.25 mm internal diameter column with the same phase. These parameters were then investigated in an experimental design comprising a series of experiments in which the responses were the resolution of two critical peak pairs, the analysis time and the limit of quantification (LOQ) of the eight major compounds. The LOQ is the concentration corresponding to a signal 10 times greater than the noise. The experiments were replicated at two different concentration levels, which encompassed the natural levels of the compounds of interest found in distilled spirits. From the chemometric evaluation of these data, a validated model was constructed, which allowed the prediction of conditions for optimum chromatographic analysis. Three additional concentration levels were then added to the model to establish linearity, repeatability and sensitivity. Modern gas chromatographic hardware allows the use of these narrow-bore capillary columns for routine use without operational difficulties. Major advantages are a substantial decrease in analysis time allowing high throughput processing of samples.     

Practical fast gas chromatography for contract laboratory program pesticide analyses

An approach to shortening the analysis time for practical fast gas chromatography (GC) by using Method Translator software, which can be downloaded free from the Internet, is presented. This software simplifies the process of optimizing temperature programming while changing column dimensions, carrier gas type, and flow. Basic chromatographic theory is employed in a practical manner for adjusting column dimensions for optimal performance. In addition, electronic pneumatic control and high oven ramp rates make it easier to achieve fast analysis times without reproducibility problems. This practical approach is demonstrated using Contract Laboratory Program pesticide analytes. The factors found to be most important in decreasing the analysis time without a loss of performance are utilization of GC columns having smaller diameters and substitution of hydrogen for helium as the carrier gas.     

Gas chromatography with ballistic heating and ultrafast cooling of column

An overview of the existing methods for minimization of the analysis time in gas chromatography (GC) is presented and a new system for fast temperature programming and very fast cooling down is evaluated. In this study, a system of coaxial tubes, a heating/cooling module (HC-M), was developed and studied with a capillary column placed inside the HC-M. The module itself was heated by a GC oven and cooled down by an external cooling medium. The HC-M was heated at rates of up to 330 °C min⁻¹ and cooled at the rate of 6000 °C min⁻¹. The GC system was prepared for the next run within a few seconds. The HC-M permits good separation reproducibility, comparable with that of a conventional GC, expressed in terms of relative retention times and peak areas of analytes reproducibilities. The HC-M can be used within any commercial gas chromatograph.     

Peak pattern variations related to comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography acquisition

Identifying compounds of interest for peaks in data generated by comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) is a critical analytical task. Manually identifying compounds is tedious and time-consuming. An alternative is to use pattern matching. Pattern matching identifies compounds by matching previously observed patterns with known peaks to newly observed patterns with unidentified peaks. The fundamental difficulty of pattern matching comes from peak pattern distortions that are caused by differences in data acquisition conditions. This paper investigates peak pattern variations related to varying oven temperature ramp rate and inlet gas pressure and evaluates two types of affine transformations for matching peak patterns. The experimental results suggest that, over the experimental ranges, the changes in temperature ramp rate generate non-linear pattern variations and changes in gas pressure generate nearly linear pattern variations. The results indicate the affine transformations can largely remove the pattern variations and can be used for applications such as pattern matching and normalizing retention times to retention indices.     

Fast GC with a Small Volume Column Oven and Low Power Heater

A new apparatus for fast gas chromatography separations is described. It consists of a small volume oven containing a coiled fused silica capillary column that is heated by a flow of hot air. The oven can be heated at rates of 10 °C s^?1 with a 300 W heater. Benchmark studies at various temperature programming rates are described. Retention time relative standard deviations increase with increasing heating rate, but are at most about 1% when an 8 °C s^?1 heating rate is employed. The small size of the column oven makes it possible for it to be attached to a commercial GC instrument through an opening provided for installation of a second injector.     

A direct resistively heated gas chromatography column with heating and sensing on the same nickel element

Nickel clad or nickel wired fused silica column bundles were constructed and evaluated. The nickel sheathing or wire functions not only as the heating element for direct resistive heat, but also as the temperature sensor, since nickel has a large resistive temperature coefficient. With this method the temperature controller is able to apply power and measure the temperature simultaneously on the same nickel element, which can effectively avoid the temperature overshoot caused by any delayed response of the sensor to the heating element. This approach also eliminates the cool spot where a separate sensor touches the column. There are some other advantages to the column bundle structure: (1) the column can be heated quickly because of the direct heating and the column's low mass, shortening analysis time. We demonstrate a maximum heating rate of 13 °C/s (800 °C/min). (2) Cooling time is also short, increasing sample throughput. The column drops from 360 °C to 40 °C is less than 1 min. (3) Power consumption is very low – 1.7 W/m (8.5 W total) for a 5 m column and 0.69 W/m (10.4 W total) for a 15 m column when they are kept at 200 °C isothermally. With temperature programming, the power consumption for a 5 m column is less then 70 W for an 800 °C/min ramp to 350 °C. (4) The column bundle is small, with a diameter of only about 2.25 in. All these advantages make the column bundle ideal for fast GC analysis or portable instruments. Column efficiencies and retention time repeatability have been evaluated and compared with the conventional oven heating method in this study. For isothermal conditions, the column efficiencies are measured by effective theoretical plate number. It was found that the plate number with resistive heat is always less than with oven heat, due to uneven heat in the column bundle. However, the loss is not significant – an average of about 1.5% for the nickel clad column and 4.5% for the nickel wired column. Separation numbers are used for the comparison with temperature programming, with results similar to those observed for isothermal conditions. Retention time repeatability for direct heat were 0.010% RSD for isotheral and 0.037% RSD for temperature programming, which is similar to those obtained by oven heat. Applications have been demonstrated, including diesel and PAH analysis.     

Dual Adsorber-Capillary Column System for Gas Chromatographic Analysis of Air Samples

Abstract

An interface which allows thermal desorption and subsequent capillary gas chromatographic analysis of air samples is described. A small solid-sorbent trap is positioned between the sampling tube and capillary column. A sample thermally released from the sampling tube is transferred by a carrier gas at high flow rate to the trap and retained. From there it is again thermally released and transferred to the capillary column by carrier gas at a low flow rate, as required by capillary GC. The transfer and injection steps are effected by means of externally placed solenoid valves. The performance of the system depends on the desorption temperature and time allowed for transfer of the sample between the two adsorbers and the column. These parameters are programmable and can be changed to suit the requirements of a particular analysis. The system allows the analysis of sub-parts-per-billion concentrations of organic compounds in a comparatively simple and reproducible manner. Operation of the system does not require cryogenic cooling of either the trap or the GC oven. Chromatograms of a variety of air samples are presented and discussed.     

Jet‐Cooled Thermal Modulator for Comprehensive Multidimensional Gas Chromatography

A jet of cool gas is used to locally cool a section of modulator tube in the presence of the stirred oven bath of a GC×GC instrument. Local cooling decouples the temperature of the modulator tube from that of the first dimension column, which was 100 meters long. Overall resolution of the GC×GC experiment was improved as a result. Another consequence of the jet‐cooled thermal modulation structure is the elimination of moving parts in the GC oven. By pulsing cold and hot jets of gas onto a modulator tube with solenoid valves, two stage thermal modulation can be obtained without the complexity of moving parts in the vicinity of the capillary columns.     

Analysis of polymer additives in high-temperature liquid chromatography

A high-temperature liquid chromatographic technique is employed for the separation of commercially available polymer additives to enhance the resolution and speed. Separation efficiencies and elution behaviors for seven phthalate plasticizers and five antioxidants are evaluated at elevated column temperatures and with a thermal gradient. Diamondbond C18 (octadecylsilica), Zirchrom PS (zirconia-based polystyrene), and Zirchrom PBD (zirconia-based polybutadiene) columns are selected for the study because of their thermal stability. The temperature programming is controlled with a column oven in conjunction with an independent mobile phase preheater and a post-column effluent cooling assembly. Van't Hoff plots show that the reverse-phase liquid chromatography mechanism is maintained over a wide range of column temperatures. A 1% increase of acetonitrile in the mobile phase is estimated to have a comparable effect as a 7-7.5 degrees C column temperature increase on the retention time changes.     

At-column heating and a resistively heated, liquid-cooled thermal modulator for a low-resource bench-top GC x GC

A transportable GC x GC instrument is under development for on-site applications that would benefit from the enhanced resolution and powers of detection, which can be achieved by this method. In the present study, a low-resource GC x GC instrument using an electrically heated and liquid-cooled single-stage thermal modulator that requires no cryogenic materials is evaluated. The instrument also uses at-column heating, thus eliminating the need for a convection oven to house the two columns. The stainless-steel modulator tube is coated with PDMS, which can be heated to 350 degrees C for sample injection into the second-dimension column. The modulator is cooled to -30 degrees C by a 100 mL/min flow of PEG by means of a commercial liquid chiller and a small recirculating pump. Resistive heating of the modulator tube is provided by a programmable power supply, which uses a voltage program that results in increasing modulator temperature during an analysis. This, together with more rapid cooling by the use of a liquid cooling medium, results in reduced solute breakthrough following each heating cycle as the modulator cools to a temperature where quantitative trapping resumes. As a result, modulated peak widths at half-height of less than 40 ms are observed. Design and performance details are presented along with chromatograms of gasoline and an essential oil sample.     

Sampling techniques for SFC using peak focusing by pressure and/or temperature programming

In analogy to the focusing effective in capillary GC, performed with temperature programming but also with sectional cooling of the column inlet as in multidimensional capillary GC, peak focusing can easily be attained in SFC by adjustment of the mobile phase pressure as well as the column temperature. This may be of practical use in connection with sampling techniques giving poor, i.e. broad and unsymmetrical, peak shapes. Such disturbances may occur, for example, in time controlled valve sampling over longer switching times. Generally, all other negative influences on peak shape can be suppressed or compensated by trapping within the column inlet. Special trapping devices and “retention gaps” may also be coupled to the column inlet in order to create narrow starting plug widths. Positive pressure (density) and negative temperature programs give rise to peak compression besides the increase of peak capacity of the separation.     

Large-volume programmed-temperature vaporiser injection for fast gas chromatography with electron capture and mass spectrometric detection of polybrominated diphenyl ethers

A large volume injection fast-GC-MS method has been developed, optimized and evaluated for the determination of polybrominated diphenyl ethers, including the decabrominated diphenyl ether (BDE-209). The programmed-temperature vaporiser injection parameters, temperature programming of the GC oven, and the physical dimensions of the narrow bore GC column were investigated to find the optimal operating conditions for the analysis. Depending on parameter settings the yield of the PBDEs and particularly BDE-209, varies significantly. Volumes up to 125 microl were successfully injected and a fast GC separation was performed, with retention times as short as 6.4 min for the last eluting compound, BDE-209. In a pilot study an air sample, collected at an electronics dismantling facility, was analyzed. Low-resolution mass spectrometry in electron capture negative ion mode was used for detection. Nine BDE congeners, including BDE-209, were identified and quantified.     

Temperature requirements for thermal modulation in comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography

Temperature requirements for trapping and release of compounds in a cryogenic gas loop-type GC x GC modulator were determined. Maximum trapping temperatures on the uncoated, deactivated modulator capillary were determined for compounds from C4 (bp -0.5 degrees C) to C40 (bp 522 degrees C). The liquid-nitrogen cooled gas flow rate was reduced from a high of 15.5 to 1.5 SLPM over the range to achieve the required trapping temperature. Excessive cold jet flow rates caused irreversible trapping and peak tailing for semi-volatile compounds above C26. Alternate cold jet coolants were investigated. An ice water-cooled jet was able to trap compounds with boiling points from C18 (bp 316 degrees C) to C40 and a room temperature air-cooled jet was able to trap compounds from C20 (bp 344 degrees C) to C40. The hot jet produced launch temperatures approximately 40 degrees C hotter than the elution temperature with heating time constants of 8 to 27 ms. Modulated compound peaks were symmetrical with half-height peak widths of 43 to 56 ms for compounds with little second column retention, and 70 to 75 ms for compounds with more second column retention. The liquid nitrogen-cooled loop modulator with gas flow programming was used to produce a GC x GC chromatogram for a crude oil that contained compounds from C7 to C47.     

Direct thermal desorption of semivolatile organic compounds from diffusion denuders and gas chromatographic analysis for trace concentration measurement

A novel method for collection and analysis of vapor-phase semivolatile organic compounds (SOCs) in ambient air is presented. The method utilizes thermal desorption of SOCs trapped in diffusion denuders coupled with cryogenic preconcentration on Tenax-TA and analysis by high resolution gas chromatography (GC)-electron-capture detection (ECD). The sampling and analysis methods employ custom-fabricated multicapillary diffusion denuders, a hot gas spike (HGS) apparatus to load known quantities of thermally stable standards into diffusion denuders prior to sample collection, a custom-fabricated oven to thermally desorb SOCs from the diffusion denuder, and a programmable temperature vaporization (PTV) inlet containing a liner packed with Tenax-TA for effective preconcentration of the analytes and water management. High flow rates into the PTV inlet of 750mLmin(-1)during thermal desorption are ca. a factor of ten greater than typically used. To improve resolution and retention time stability, the thermal desorption and PTV inlet programming procedure includes three steps to prevent water from entering the analytic column while effectively transferring the analytes into the GC system. The instrumentation and procedures provide virtually complete and consistent transfer of analytes collected from ambient air into the GC evidenced by recovery of seven replicates of four internal standards of 90.7+/-4.0-120+/-23% (mean+/-95% confidence interval, CI). Retention time based compound identification is facilitated by low retention time variability with an average 95% CI of 0.024min for sixteen replicates of eight standards. Procedure details and performance metrics as well as ambient sampling results are presented.     

Extending the range of compounds amenable for gas chromatography-mass spectrometric analysis

Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) suffers from a major limitation in that an expanding number of thermally labile or low volatility compounds of interest are not amenable for analysis. We found that the elution temperatures of compounds from GC can be significantly lowered by reducing the column length, increasing the carrier gas flow rate, reducing the capillary column film thickness and lowering the temperature programming rate. Pyrene is eluted at 287 degrees C in standard GC-MS with a 30 m x 0.25 mm I.D. column with 1-microm DB5ms film and 1-ml/min He column flow rate. In contrast, pyrene is eluted at 79 degrees C in our "Supersonic GC-MS" system using a 1 m x 0.25 mm I.D. column with 0.1-microm DB5ms film and 100-ml/min He column flow rate. A simple model has been invoked to explain the significantly (up to 208 degrees C) lower elution temperatures observed. According to this model, every halving of the temperature programming rate, or number of separation plates (either through increased flow rate or due to reduced column length), results in approximately 20 degrees C lower elution temperature. These considerably lower elution temperatures enable the analysis of an extended range of thermally labile and low volatility compounds, that otherwise could not be analyzed by standard GC-MS. We demonstrate the analysis of large polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) such as decacyclene with ten fused rings, well above the current GC limit of PAHs with six rings. Even a metalloporphirin such as magnesiumoctaethylporphin was easily analyzed with elution temperatures below 300 degrees C. Furthermore, a range of thermally labile compounds were analyzed including carbamates such as methomyl, aldicarb, aldicarbsulfone and oxamyl, explosives such as pentaerythritol tetranitrate, Tetryl and HMX, and drugs such as reserpine (608 a.m.u.). Supersonic GC-MS was used, based on the coupling of a supersonic molecular beam (SMB) inlet and ion sources with a bench-top Agilent 6890 GC plus 5972 MSD. The Supersonic GC-MS provides enhanced molecular ion without any ion source related peak tailing. Thus, the lower GC separation power involved in the analysis of thermally labile and low volatility compounds is compensated by increased separation power of the MS gained from the enhanced molecular ion. Several implications of these findings are discussed, including our conclusion that slower chromatography leads to better analysis of thermally labile compounds.     

Interpretative optimization and artificial neural network modeling of the gas chromatographic separation of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

An interpretative strategy (factorial design experimentation+total resolution analysis+chromatogram simulation) was employed to optimize the separation of 16 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) (naphthalene, acenaphthylene, acenaphthene, fluorene, phenanthrene, anthracene, fluoranthene, pyrene, chrysene, benzo(a)anthracene, benzo(k)fluoranthene, benzo(b)fluoranthene, benzo(a)pyrene, indeno(1,2,3-c,d)pyrene, dibenzo(a,h)anthracene, benzo(g,h,i)perylene) in temperature-programmed gas chromatography (GC). Also, the retention behavior of PAHs in the same GC system was studied by a feed-forward artificial neural network (ANN). GC separation was investigated as a function of one (linear temperature ramp) or two (linear temperature ramp+the final hold temperature) variables. The applied interpretative approach resulted in rather good agreement between the measured and the predicted retention times for PAHs in both one and two variable modeling. The ANN model, strongly affected by the number of input experiments, was shown to be less effective for one variable used, but quite successful when two input variables were used. All PAHs, including difficult to separate peak pairs (benzo(k)fluoranthene/benzo(b)fluoranthene and indeno(1,2,3-c,d)pyrene/dibenzo(a,h)anthracene), were separated in a standard (5% phenyl-95% dimethylpolysiloxane) capillary column at an optimum temperature ramp of 8.0 degrees C/min and final hold temperature in the range of 260-320 degrees C.     

Optimizing capillary column backflush to improve cycle time and reduce column contamination

Interest in decreasing cycle times in capillary GC analyses has driven much of the instrumental developments of the last decade. Recent developments in GC instrumentation now make it reasonable to consider backflushing capillary columns on a routine basis. Significant reduction in analysis and total cycle times (typically 15–50% depending on the application) are readily achieved for analyses that currently require an extended temperature program and bakeout period to remove retained sample components and column contaminants. Setup and optimization of backflush conditions are relatively straight forward as long as some basic concepts are well understood. The parameters affecting capillary column backflushing are described. Examples are shown that help visualize what happens during backflush. The relationship between oven ramp rate and flow turns out to be an important variable that dictates minimum backflush times in temperature programmed CGC. Backflush times corresponding to 2–5 void volumes in the reversed direction are usually sufficient for backflushing, if performed after each temperature programmed run.