Factors affecting primary ionization in dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure photoionization (DA-APPI) for LC/MS

The sensitivity of dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure photoionization (DA-APPI) for LC/MS is generally reduced at higher solvent flow rates. Theory suggests that quenching of excited-state precursors to the dopant ions, via collisions with vaporized solvent molecules, may be one mechanism responsible for this trend. To ascertain if the primary rate of ionization is affected by quenching, experiments were performed utilizing an ionization detector to determine the primary ion current generated by irradiating vaporized mixtures of toluene dopant and methanol solvent. The results indicate that no loss of primary ion current occurs as the solvent flow is increased, provided the dopant-to-solvent ratio is held constant. Additional primary ion current can always be generated by increasing the dopant flow rate and/or the lamp power. Thus, quenching of excited-state precursors to the dopant ions, leading to a reduction in the primary rate of ionization, is not the mechanism responsible for the observed loss of sensitivity at higher liquid solvent flow rates.     

Electrospray ionization/atmospheric pressure photoionization multimode source for low-flow liquid chromatography/mass spectrometric analysis

Analysis of several polar and non-polar compounds is performed with a newly developed dual electrospray ionization/atmospheric pressure photoionization (ESI/APPI) or ESPI source. Several variables are considered in the source, such as ESI probe heater temperature, solvent flow, dopant effects, repeller plate voltage, source geometry and photon energy (Kr vs. Ar lamp). Direct photoionization resulting in a molecular radical cation [M](*+) dominates at high temperatures (>400 degrees C) and low flow rates (<200 microL/min). Indirect photo-induced chemical ionization (PCI) involving solvent molecules becomes important at lower temperatures and higher solvent flow rates. Indirect PCI is enhanced using an Ar lamp, which yields comparable [M+H](+) signal but poorer [M](*+) signal than the Kr lamp at lower temperatures and higher flow rates. This is in support of our recent finding that the Ar lamp results in a solvent-dependent enhancement of analyte molecules via PCI. Analysis of 12 compounds in methanol under low-flow conditions (10 microL/min) demonstrates that the dual ESPI source performs favorably for most compounds versus the standard ESCI source, and significantly better than ESCI for the analysis of unstable drugs, like flurbiprofen. Several factors contributing to the benefits of the ESPI source are the shared optimal geometry for ESI and APPI sources and soft ionization of APPI versus APCI.     

APPI-MS: Effects of mobile phases and VUV lamps on the detection of PAH compounds

The technique of atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) has several advantages over electrospray ionization (ESI) and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (APCI), including efficient ionization of nonpolar or low charge affinity compounds, reduced susceptibility to ion suppression, high sensitivity, and large linear dynamic range. These benefits are greatest at low flow rates (i.e., 相似文献   

Study of a bisquaternary ammonium salt by atmospheric pressure photoionization mass spectrometry

A comprehensive atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) mass spectrometry investigation of hexamethonium bromide is reported. This bisquaternary ammonium salt is a model system for the investigation of multiply charged species and elucidation of ion formation processes. It has been used to elucidate the physicochemical phenomenon occurring when photoionization is carried out at atmospheric pressure. First, the in-source fragmentations were studied for aqueous solutions of the salt with the photoionization lamp switched off, i.e. under thermospray conditions. It is shown that, in this mode of operation, fragmentations are minor and may be classified into two classes, namely dequaternization and charge separation, arising from the two precursors, M2+ and [M+Br]+. Second, the fragmentation patterns have been monitored in dopant- assisted APPI for different dopants (toluene, toluene-d8, anisole and hexafluorobenzene) at various amounts. At low dopant flow rates, the [M+Br]+ and M2+ ions are still observed. As the flow rate is increased, these precursor ions lose intensity and are finally suppressed for all three dopants. Comparison of toluene and toluene-d8 reveals that H atoms may be transferred from the dopant to the molecular ions, very likely mediated by the solvent. The role of the solvent (water) was also investigated by using heavy water. Apart from the thermospray fragmentations, which are also observed in APPI, several fragmentation pathways appear to be specific to the photoionization process. Photoionization efficiencies are measured by determination of the relative photoionization cross sections with respect to toluene. It is found that, when the ionization efficiencies are taken into account, the depletion of the precursors as a function of the dopant flow rates is the same for all three dopant molecules. This result shows that the precursor ions are depleted by reactions with the photoelectrons released from the dopant. Three additional mechanisms are proposed to account for this effect: electron transfer or H atom transfer from negatively charged water nanodroplets and H atom transfer from the dopant.     

Generation of ion-bound solvent clusters as reactant ions in dopant-assisted APPI and APLI

We provide experimental and theoretical evidence that the primary ionization process in the dopant-assisted varieties of the atmospheric pressure ionization methods atmospheric pressure photoionization and atmospheric pressure laser ionization in typical liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry settings is—as suggested in the literature—dopant radical cation formation. However, instead of direct dopant radical cation–analyte interaction—the broadly accepted subsequent step in the reaction cascade leading to protonated analyte molecules—rapid thermal equilibration with ion source background water or liquid chromatography solvents through dopant ion–molecule cluster formation occurs. Fast intracluster chemistry then leads to almost instantaneous proton-bound water/solvent cluster generation. These clusters interact either directly with analytes by ligand switching or association reactions, respectively, or further downstream in the intermediate-pressure regions in the ion transfer stages of the mass spectrometer via electrical-field-driven collisional decomposition reactions finally leading to the predominantly observed bare protonated analyte molecules [M?+?H]⁺.     

Comparison of atmospheric pressure photoionization and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry for the analysis of UV filters

A comparison was made between the electrospray ionization (ESI) and atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) tandem mass spectrometric (MS/MS) responses of eleven ultraviolet (UV) filters. Four of the target compounds were favourably ionized in negative ion mode, and the other seven compounds in positive ion mode. For nine of the compounds APPI generated a similar response to that of ESI, but the APPI signal‐to‐noise (S/N) ratios were 1.3–60 times higher. The two most polar of the UV filter compounds (PBSA and BP‐4) were more efficiently ionized by ESI, offering higher signal intensities and lower detection limits. APPI was, however, less susceptible to ion suppression than ESI when real samples were injected. In order to optimize the APPI conditions different dopant solvents were examined to enhance the efficiency of the photoionization process. Among the evaluated dopants, toluene was selected as the best compromise. At a toluene flow rate of 10% of the solvent flow rates the ionization response increased by a factor of 40–50 over the use of no dopant for the compounds in positive ion mode and by more than 300 for the compounds in negative ion mode. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Improving the analytical performance of ion mobility spectrometer using a non-radioactive electron source

For the ionization of gas mixtures, several ionization sources can be coupled to an ion mobility spectrometer. Radioactive sources, e.g. beta radiators like ⁶³Ni and ³H, are the most commonly used ionization sources. However, due to legal restrictions radioactive ionization sources are not applicable in certain applications. Non-radioactive alternatives are corona discharge ionization sources or photoionization sources. However, using an electron gun allows regulation of ion production rate, ionization time and recombination time by simply changing the operating parameters, which can be utilized to enhance the analytical performance of ion mobility spectrometers. In this work, the impact of an ionization source parameter variation on the ion mobility spectrum is demonstrated. Increasing the ion production rate, the amount of the generated ions increases leading to higher signal intensity while the noise remains constant. Thus, the signal to noise ratio can be increased, leading to better limits of detection. In a next step, the ion production rate is kept constant while the influence of ionization time on the ion mobility spectrum is investigated. It is shown, that varying the ionization time allows the determination of the reaction rate constants as additional information to the ion mobility. Furthermore, we show the prevention of discrimination processes by using short ionization times combined with an increased ion production rate. Thus, the limit of detection for benzene in presence of toluene is improved. Additionally, it is shown that using ion-ion recombination leads to the detection of the ion species with the highest proton affinity at higher recombination times while the low proton affine ions already recombined. Thus, the measurement of the ion mobility spectra at a defined recombination time allows a suppression of disturbing low proton affine substances.     

Effect of the Solvent Flow Rate on the Ionization Efficiency in Atmospheric Pressure Photoionization-Mass Spectrometry

In the novel atmospheric pressure photoionization-mass spectrometry the ionization efficiency has been observed to decrease when the solvent flow rate is increased. The effect of the flow rate on the ionization efficiency was studied by comparing the behavior of two analytes, one of which is ionized through charge exchange, the other through proton transfer. Additional information about the ion loss mechanisms was obtained by comparing results obtained with two different APPI ion sources: a Sciex prototype and the Agilent/Syagen APPI source. In addition to the measurements done by using the mass analyzer, the total ion current in the ion source was obtained by measuring the currents of the ions arriving at curtain/end plate and orifice/capillary of the two mass spectrometers. The total ion current measurements showed a significant decrease at high solvent flow rates. Loss of dopant radical cations was thought to be the reason for the signal decrease of the analytes formed through charge exchange. Analytes formed through proton transfer were not as seriously ected by the high solvent flow rates, but some saturation of their signal was nevertheless observed. Loss of photons through absorption by solvent vapor is another mechanism that can be held responsible for a reduction of the total number of ions produced by the APPI source.     

The unexpected formation of [M − H]+ species during MALDI and dopant‐free APPI MS analysis of novel antineoplastic curcumin analogues

Unusual ionization behavior was observed with novel antineoplastic curcumin analogues during the positive ion mode of matrix‐assisted laser desorption ionization (MALDI) and dopant‐free atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI). The tested compounds produced an unusual significant peak designated as [M ? H]⁺ ion along with the expected [M + H]⁺ species. In contrast, electrospray ionization, atmospheric pressure chemical ionization and the dopant‐mediated APPI (dopant‐APPI) showed only the expected [M + H]⁺ peak. The [M ? H]⁺ ion was detected with all evaluated curcumin analogues including phosphoramidates, secondary amines, amides and mixed amines/amides. Our experiments revealed that photon energy triggers the ionization of the curcumin analogues even in the absence of any ionization enhancer such as matrix, solvent or dopant. The possible mechanisms for the formation of both [M ? H]⁺ and [M + H]⁺ ions are discussed in this paper. In particular, three proposed mechanisms for the formation of [M ? H]⁺ were evaluated. The first mechanism involves the loss of H₂ from the protonated [M + H]⁺ species. The other two mechanisms include hydrogen transfer from the analyte radical cation or hydride abstraction from the neutral analyte molecule. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Fragmentation induced in atmospheric pressure photoionization of peptides

In this work, the fragmentation of peptides under atmospheric pressure photoionization conditions is investigated. Intensive fragmentations into b/y- and c-sequence ions are reported. Abundance of these c-ions appeared to be related to the quantity of dopant infused and to the disappearance of the doubly protonated peptide ion. A careful analysis of the role of the dopant indicates that the fragmentations are not dependent on the nature of the dopant but on their ionization efficiencies. This result shows that the fragmentation arises from the reaction of the protonated peptide with photoelectrons released upon ionization of the dopant in an electron capture dissociation/electron transfer dissociation (ECD/ETD) type mechanism. Experiments with peptides bearing a single proton indicate that additional mechanisms are involved. H-atom transfer reactions are suggested to be responsible for the fragmentations as well. Those atoms could arise either from the dopant ions or from negatively charged solvent nanodroplets. This is the first report of an ECD/ETD mechanism in a dense medium and at atmospheric pressure.     

A dopant introduction device for atmospheric pressure photoionization with liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry

This technical note describes in detail the fabrication, operation and characterization of a pneumatically driven dopant introduction device, with a solvent reservoir capacity of 300 mL. Dopant flow rates and stability for this device are governed by the simple regulation of gas pressure rather than the progression of a stepper motor and syringe diameter, as is the case for typical infusion pumps. The device has the potential to provide days or even weeks of continuous, uninterrupted dopant flow at rates commonly adopted for atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) experiments without the need to replenish the dopant supply. Although not a refined instrumental design, this device was developed as an alternative cost-effective means of introducing stable dopant flow to an APPI source. The device was designed such that all components would be commercially available and easily procurable from common scientific part vendors. Figures and suggested part numbers are provided to allow those interested to fabricate similar devices to suit their individual experimental needs. Device characterization was performed while monitoring such factors as flow rate calibration, overall flow stability and reproducibility. In addition, a standard mixture of three polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons was employed as a model sample for a typical reversed-phase liquid chromatography/atmospheric pressure photoionization mass spectrometry (LC/APPI-MS) application in order to demonstrate device performance.     

On-line capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry using dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure photoionization: setup and system performance

The on-line coupling of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and mass spectrometry (MS) via atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) is demonstrated. To achieve CE-APPI-MS, an adapted coaxial sheath-flow interface was combined with an ion-trap mass spectrometer equipped with an APPI source originally designed for liquid chromatography-MS. Effective photoionization of test compounds was accomplished after optimization of several interface and MS parameters, and of the composition and flow rate of the sheath liquid. Further enhancement of the ionization efficiency could be achieved by adding a dopant, such as acetone or toluene, to the sheath liquid to aid indirect ionization. Acetone significantly increased the ionization of the polar test compounds by proton transfer, while toluene was more useful for the enhanced formation of molecular ions from nonpolar compounds. The effect of several common CE background electrolytes (BGEs) on the APPI-MS response of the analytes was also studied. It appeared that in contrast with electrospray ionization, nonvolatile BGEs do not cause suppression of analyte signals using APPI. Therefore, in CE-APPI-MS, a variety of buffers can be chosen, which obviously is a great advantage during method development. Remarkably, also sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) did not affect the photoionization of the test compounds, indicating a strong potential of APPI for the on-line coupling of micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) and MS.     

A Simultaneous,Laser-Excited Fluorescence,Photoacoustic, and Two-Photon Photoionization Detector for Liquid Chromatography

Abstract

A laser-excited windowless flow cell has been developed for simultaneous fluorescence, photoacoustic, and two-photon photoionization detection of aromatic compounds in HPLC eluents. Sensitive three-mode detection of acridine, naphthalene, 7,8-benzoflavone, N-ethylcarbazole, and anthracene in 70/30 V/V acetonitrile/water is demonstrated with conservative detection limits in the nanogram range and below.     

Effect of ionization suppression by trace impurities in mobile phase water on the accuracy of quantification by high‐performance liquid chromatography/mass spectrometry

The high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) column is capable of enrichment/pre‐concentration of trace impurities in the mobile phase during the column equilibration, prior to sample injection and elution. These impurities elute during gradient elution and result in significant chromatographic peaks. Three types of purified water were tested for their impurity levels, and hence their performances as mobile phase, in HPLC followed by total ion current (TIC) mode of MS. Two types of HPLC‐grade water produced 3–4 significant peaks in solvent blanks while LC/MS‐grade water produced no peaks (although peaks were produced by LC/MS‐grade water also after a few days of standing). None of the three waters produced peaks in HPLC followed by UV‐Vis detection. These peaks, if co‐eluted with analyte, are capable of suppressing or enhancing the analyte signal in a MS detector. As it is not common practice to run solvent blanks in TIC mode, when quantification is commonly carried out using single ion monitoring (SIM) or single or multiple reaction monitoring (SRM or MRM), the effect of co‐eluting impurities on the analyte signal and hence on the accuracy of the results is often unknown to the analyst. Running solvent blanks in TIC mode, regardless of the MS mode used for quantification, is essential in order to detect this problem and to take subsequent precautions. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Design and evaluation of a dopant‐delivery system for an orthogonal atmospheric‐pressure photoionization source and its performance in the analysis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons

Atmospheric‐pressure photoionization (APPI) mass spectrometry benefits from the addition of an ionization‐enhancing dopant such as benzene. A passive dopant‐delivery system has therefore been designed for use with the orthogonal APPI source within a commercial liquid chromatographic instrument with mass spectrometric detector. By providing the dopant in the gas phase, the newly designed equipment avoids mixing problems and other difficulties associated with liquid dopant addition. The system is a simple and durable design that can reliably deliver virtually any dopant with sufficient vapor pressure in the temperature range of 20 to 120°C. At the optimum dopant flow rate (10% of the mobile phase flow rate) for high‐performance liquid chromatography with narrow‐bore (2.1 mm) columns, the system allows for uninterrupted routine analysis for up to two weeks. The performance of the device has been evaluated with benzene as dopant and with a test mixture consisting of four polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH): naphthalene, 9H‐fluorene, anthracene, and phenanthrene. All four PAH can be detected with an excellent signal‐to‐noise ratio in the scanning mode and a limit of detection down to 0.42 ng on column (51 pg in single‐ion monitoring mode). The concentration calibration curves are linear over a range of three orders of magnitude, with correlation coefficients greater than 0.99. The utilization of benzene as dopant not only increases the sensitivity significantly – 20‐fold, compared with dopant‐free operation – but the low m/z values of the background ions observed also allow for the effective quantitative and qualitative analysis of PAH. Copyright © 2010 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

The Ionization Mechanisms in Direct and Dopant-Assisted Atmospheric Pressure Photoionization and Atmospheric Pressure Laser Ionization

A novel, gas-tight API interface for gas chromatography–mass spectrometry was used to study the ionization mechanism in direct and dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure photoionization (APPI) and atmospheric pressure laser ionization (APLI). Eight analytes (ethylbenzene, bromobenzene, naphthalene, anthracene, benzaldehyde, pyridine, quinolone, and acridine) with varying ionization energies (IEs) and proton affinities (PAs), and four common APPI dopants (toluene, acetone, anisole, and chlorobenzene) were chosen. All the studied compounds were ionized by direct APPI, forming mainly molecular ions. Addition of dopants suppressed the signal of the analytes with IEs above the IE of the dopant. For compounds with suitable IEs or Pas, the dopants increased the ionization efficiency as the analytes could be ionized through dopant-mediated gas-phase reactions, such as charge exchange, proton transfer, and other rather unexpected reactions, such as formation of [M?+?77]⁺ in the presence of chlorobenzene. Experiments with deuterated toluene as the dopant verified that in case of proton transfer, the proton originated from the dopant instead of proton-bound solvent clusters, as in conventional open or non-tight APPI sources. In direct APLI using a 266 nm laser, a narrower range of compounds was ionized than in direct APPI, because of exceedingly high IEs or unfavorable two-photon absorption cross-sections. Introduction of dopants in the APLI system changed the ionization mechanism to similar dopant-mediated gas-phase reactions with the dopant as in APPI, which produced mainly ions of the same form as in APPI, and ionized a wider range of analytes than direct APLI. Graphical Abstract

?     

Negative ion-atmospheric pressure photoionization-mass spectrometry

The ionization mechanism in the novel atmospheric pressure photoionization mass spectrometry (APPI-MS) in negative ion mode was studied thoroughly by the analysis of seven compounds in 17 solvent systems. The compounds possessed either gas-phase acidity or positive electron affinity, whereas the solvent systems had different polarities and gas-phase acidities and some of them positive electron affinities. The analytes that possessed gas-phase acidity formed deprotonated ions in proton transfer; in addition, fragments and solvent adducts were observed. The compounds of positive electron affinity formed negative molecular ions by electron capture or charge exchange and substitution products of form [M - X + O](-) by substitution reactions. The efficiency of deprotonation was decreased if the solvent used possessed higher gas-phase acidity than the analyte. Solvents of positive electron affinity captured thermal electrons and deteriorated the ionization of all the analytes. Also, the proportion of substitution products was affected by the solvent. Finally, the performances of negative ion APPI and negative ion APCI were compared. The sensitivity for the studied compounds was better in APPI, but the formation of substitution products was lower in APCI.     

On-line characterization of gaseous and particulate organic analytes using atmospheric pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometry

A modified atmospheric pressure chemical ionization ion source is applied for direct analysis of volatile or low volatile organic compounds in air. The method is based on the direct introduction of the analytes in the gas phase and/or particle phase into the ion source of a commercial ion-trap mass spectrometer. Two methods are employed for the production of primary ions at atmospheric pressure, photoionization and corona discharge. It is shown that in the presence of a dopant, photoionization can be a highly efficient ionization method also for real-time analysis with detection limits for selected analytes in the lower ppt-range. Using corona discharge for the production of primary ions, which is instrumentally easier since no additional chemicals have to be added to the sample flow, we demonstrate the analytical potential of on-line atmospheric pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometry for reaction monitoring experiments. To do so, an atmospherically relevant gas phase reaction is carried out in a 500 l reaction chamber and gaseous and particulate compounds are monitored in the positive and negative ion mode of the mass spectrometer.     

Factors influencing the analytical performance of an atmospheric sampling glow discharge ionization source as revealed via ionization dynamics modeling

A kinetic model is developed for the dynamic events occurring within an atmospheric sampling glow discharge that affect its performance as an ion source for analytical mass spectrometry. The differential equations incorporate secondary electron generation and thermalization, reagent and analyte ion formation via electron capture and ion-molecule reactions, ion loss via recombination processes, diffusion, and ion-molecule reactions with matrix components, and the sampling and pumping parameters of the source. Because the ion source has a flow-through configuration, the number densities of selected species can be estimated by applying the steady-state assumption. However, understanding of its operation is aided by knowledge of the dynamic behavior, so numerical methods are applied to examine the time dependence of those species as well. As in other plasma ionization sources, the ionization efficiency is essentially determined by the ratio of the relevant ion formation and recombination rates. Although thermal electron and positive reagent ion number densities are comparable, the electron capture/ion-molecule reaction rate coefficient ratio is normally quite large and the ion-electron recombination rate coefficient is about an order of magnitude greater than that for ion-ion recombination. Consequently, the efficiency for negative analyte ion formation via electron capture is generally superior to that for positive analyte ion generation via ion-molecule reaction. However, the efficiency for positive analyte ion formation should be equal to or better than that for negative analyte ions when both ionization processes occur via ion-molecule reaction processes (with comparable rate coefficients), since the negative reagent ion density is considerably less than that for positive reagent ions. Furthermore, the particularly high number densities of thermal electrons and reagent ions leads to a large dynamic range of linear response for the source. Simulation results also suggest that analyte ion number densities might be enhanced by modification of the standard physical and operating parameters of the source.     

Charge Exchange Reaction in Dopant-Assisted Atmospheric Pressure Chemical Ionization and Atmospheric Pressure Photoionization

The efficiencies of charge exchange reaction in dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure chemical ionization (DA-APCI) and dopant-assisted atmospheric pressure photoionization (DA-APPI) mass spectrometry (MS) were compared by flow injection analysis. Fourteen individual compounds and a commercial mixture of 16 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons were chosen as model analytes to cover a wide range of polarities, gas-phase ionization energies, and proton affinities. Chlorobenzene was used as the dopant, and methanol/water (80/20) as the solvent. In both techniques, analytes formed the same ions (radical cations, protonated molecules, and/or fragments). However, in DA-APCI, the relative efficiency of charge exchange versus proton transfer was lower than in DA-APPI. This is suggested to be because in DA-APCI both dopant and solvent clusters can be ionized, and the formed reagent ions can react with the analytes via competing charge exchange and proton transfer reactions. In DA-APPI, on the other hand, the main reagents are dopant-derived radical cations, which favor ionization of analytes via charge exchange. The efficiency of charge exchange in both DA-APPI and DA-APCI was shown to depend heavily on the solvent flow rate, with best efficiency seen at lowest flow rates studied (0.05 and 0.1 mL/min). Both DA-APCI and DA-APPI showed the radical cation of chlorobenzene at 0.05–0.1 mL/min flow rate, but at increasing flow rate, the abundance of chlorobenzene M^+. decreased and reagent ion populations deriving from different gas-phase chemistry were recorded. The formation of these reagent ions explains the decreasing ionization efficiency and the differences in charge exchange between the techniques.

Open image in new window

Graphical Abstract ?