Mechanistic study of the Soai autocatalytic reaction informed by kinetic analysis

Detailed kinetic studies of the Soai reaction affirm the basic mechanistic picture previously developed in kinetic, spectroscopic and molecular modelling studies, and also suggest that refinements to the proposed elementary reaction steps must be considered. The alkanol reaction product is driven strongly and without bias towards the formation of homochiral and heterochiral dimers. The reaction is catalyzed by only the homochiral dimers. Consideration of the kinetic profiles from reactions carried out with different initial dialkylzinc concentrations support a proposal for a tetrameric transition state, but further experimental work is required to delineate the nature of this species. The power of reaction calorimetry as a kinetic tool for discerning subtle effects of the shape of the kinetic profile is highlighted. The importance of combining kinetic evidence with spectroscopic and other characterization tools is emphasized.     

One‐Pot Organocatalytic Asymmetric Synthesis of 3‐Nitro‐1,2‐dihydroquinolines by a Dual‐Activation Protocol

Generally, amine‐catalyzed enantioselective transformations rely on chiral enamine or unsaturated iminium intermediates. Herein, we report a protocol involving dual activation by an aromatic iminium and hydrogen‐bonding. An enantioselective aza‐Michael–Henry domino reaction of 2‐aminobenzaldehydes with nitroolefins has been developed through this protocol using primary amine thiourea catalysts to provide a variety of 3‐nitro‐1,2‐dihydroquinolines in moderate yields and with up to 90 % ee. The mechanism for the catalytic enantioselective reaction was confirmed by ESI mass spectrometric detection of the reaction intermediates. The products formed are substructures found in skeletons of important biological and pharmaceutical molecules.     

An Amine‐Catalyzed Enantioselective [3+2] Cycloaddition of Azomethine Ylides and α,β‐Unsaturated Aldehydes: Applications and Mechanistic Implications

The catalytic enantioselective [3+2] cycloaddition between azomethine ylides and α,β‐unsaturated aldehydes catalyzed by α,α‐diphenylprolinol has been studied in detail. In particular, the reaction has been extended to the use of 2‐alkenylidene aminomalonates generated in situ as azomethine ylide precursors. These reactions lead to the formation of pyrrolidines containing a 5‐alkenyl side chain with potential for chemical manipulation. Moreover, a detailed and concise computational study has been carried out to understand the exact nature of the mechanism of this reaction and especially the consequences derived from the incorporation of the chiral secondary amine catalyst on the reaction pathway.     

Enantioselective N‐Heterocyclic Carbene Catalysis by the Umpolung of α,β‐Unsaturated Ketones

N‐Heterocyclic carbene‐catalyzed formation of β‐anionic intermediates from enones has been employed in the enantioselective synthesis of 2‐aryl propionates. The reaction was achievable using a homochiral 4‐MeOC₆H₄ morpholinone catalyst allowing the first example of enantioselective catalysis by umpolung of α,β‐unsaturated ketones. The reaction is high yielding, and shows robustness with reasonable generality. A mechanism is proposed in which the enantiodetermining protonation is achieved using either hexafluoroisopropanol or the formed naphthol product.     

In Situ Mass Spectrometric and Kinetic Investigations of Soai's Asymmetric Autocatalysis

Chemical reactions that lead to a spontaneous symmetry breaking or amplification of the enantiomeric excess are of fundamental interest in explaining the formation of a homochiral world. An outstanding example is Soai's asymmetric autocatalysis, in which small enantiomeric excesses of the added product alcohol are amplified in the reaction of diisopropylzinc and pyrimidine-5-carbaldehydes. The exact mechanism is still in dispute due to complex reaction equilibria and elusive intermediates. In situ high-resolution mass spectrometric measurements, detailed kinetic analyses and doping with in situ reacting reaction mixtures show the transient formation of hemiacetal complexes, which can establish an autocatalytic cycle. We propose a mechanism that explains the autocatalytic amplification involving these hemiacetal complexes. Comprehensive kinetic experiments and modelling of the hemiacetal formation and the Soai reaction allow the precise prediction of the reaction progress, the enantiomeric excess as well as the enantiomeric excess dependent time shift in the induction period. Experimental structural data give insights into the privileged properties of the pyrimidyl units and the formation of diastereomeric structures leading to an efficient amplification of even minimal enantiomeric excesses, respectively.     

Enantioselective Arylation of N‐Tosylimines by Phenylboronic Acid Catalysed by a Rhodium/Diene Complex: Reaction Mechanism from Density Functional Theory

A DFT study of the reaction mechanism of the rhodium‐catalysed enantioselective arylation of (E)‐N‐propylidene‐4‐methyl‐benzenesulfonamide by phenylboronic acid [Lin et al J. Am. Chem. Soc.­ 2011 , 133, 12394] is reported. The catalyst ([{Rh(OH)(diene)}₂]) includes a chiral diene ligand and the reaction is conducted in 1,4‐dioxane in the presence of drying agents (4 Å molecular sieves). Because phenylboronic acid is in equilibrium with phenylboroxin and water under the reaction conditions, three catalytic cycles are proposed that differ in the way the transmetallation and the release of the product are brought about, depending on the availability of phenylboronic acid, water and boroxin in the reaction medium. Based on computations, a new mechanism for the title reaction is proposed, in which phenylboronic acid plays the double role of “aryl source” and proton donor. This path does not require the presence of adventitious water molecules, in keeping with a reaction conducted in a dry medium. Comparisons with the generally accepted mechanism for arylation of enones proposed by Hayashi and co‐workers (J. Am. Chem. Soc.­ 2002 , 124, 5052) show that the latter mechanism is less favourable and is not expected to operate in the case of the N‐tosylimine substrate considered herein. Finally, the possibility that phenylboroxin is the aryl source has also been investigated, but is not found to be competitive.     

The Brønsted Acid Catalyzed,Enantioselective Vinylogous Mannich Reaction

The first catalytic, enantioselective vinylogous Mannich reaction of acyclic silyl dienolates is reported. A second‐generation 2,2′‐dihydroxy‐1,1′‐binaphthyl (BINOL)‐based phosphoric acid has been developed and further optimized as an enantioselective organocatalyst. Upon protonation of the imines, chiral contact ion pairs are generated in situ and attacked highly diastereoselectively by the nucleophile. γ‐Substituted silyl dienolates that lead to more highly substituted Mannich products with a second stereogenic center in good diastereoselectivity have been employed in these reactions. The reaction path has been elucidated with NMR spectroscopy and mass spectrometry, which suggest that the protic reaction medium found to be optimal in these reactions serves to trap the cationic silicon species as silanol. A crystal structure of a phosphoric acid bound imine was obtained that provides insight into the binding mode and a rationale for the stereochemical course of the reaction.     

The Mechanism of Gold(I)‐Catalyzed Hydroalkoxylation of Alkynes: An Extensive Experimental Study

An extensive experimental study of the mechanism of gold(I)‐catalyzed hydroalkoxylation of internal alkynes has been conducted by using NMR spectroscopy. This study was focused on the organogold intermediates, observations of actual catalytic intermediates in situ, and the reaction kinetics that are involved in this reaction. Based on the experimental results, a complete mechanistic picture was established, including on‐ and off‐cycle processes that explain the role of diaurated species. We have shown that gold‐catalyzed hydroalkoxylation of internal alkynes is a reaction that requires only one gold atom for the catalytic cycle, disproving a recent hypothesis regarding the involvement of cooperative gold catalysis.     

Catalytic Selective Synthesis

Complete control of the product of a catalytic reaction can be achieved on the basis of catalyst structure, even when the reaction conditions are nearly identical. Catalyst‐controlled selectivity is well established for enantioselective catalysis but less formulated for catalytic regio‐, chemo‐, or product‐selective reactions. This Review describes selective transformations of the same starting materials into two or more different products simply by the choice of catalyst. By collecting and highlighting examples of selective catalysis, we hope that the field will be encouraged by the progress that has been made while bringing attention to unmet needs in the design and mechanistic understanding of selective catalysts.     

Regiodivergent Intramolecular Nucleophilic Addition of Ketimines for the Diverse Synthesis of Azacycles

Azacycles such as indoles and tetrahydroquinolines are privileged structures in drug development. Reported here is an unprecedented regiodivergent intramolecular nucleophilic addition reaction of imines as a flexible approach to access N‐functionalized indoles and tetrahydroquinolines, by the control of reaction at the N‐terminus and C‐terminus, respectively. Using ketimines derived from 2‐(2‐nitroethyl)anilines with isatins or α‐ketoesters, the regioselective N‐attack reaction gives N‐functionalized indoles, while the catalytic enantioselective C‐attack reaction affords chiral tetrahydroquinolines featuring an α‐tetrasubstituted stereocenter. Mechanistic studies reveal that hydrogen‐bonding interactions may greatly facilitate such unusual N‐attack reactions of imines. The utility of this protocol is highlighted by the catalytic enantioselective formal synthesis of (?)‐psychotrimine, and the construction of various fused aza‐heterocycles.     

PPh3‐Catalyzed Reactions of Alkyl Propiolates with N‐Tosylimines: A Facile Synthesis of Alkyl 2‐[aryl(tosylimino)methyl]acrylate and an Insight into the Reaction Mechanism

A new PPh₃‐catalyzed synthesis of alkyl 2‐[aryl(tosylimino)methyl]acrylates from propiolate and N‐tosylimine has been developed. Deuterium‐labelling experiments show that the reaction mechanism involves several hydrogen‐transfer processes, which are not the turnover‐limiting step and strongly rely on the nature of the reaction media. The stable phosphonium–enamine zwitterion, which was proven to play an important role in the catalytic cycle, has been isolated and characterised by X‐ray analysis.     

Mechanistic Investigations into the Enantioselective Conia‐Ene Reaction Catalyzed by Cinchona‐Derived Amino Urea Pre‐Catalysts and CuI

The enantioselective Conia‐ene cyclization of alkyne‐tethered β‐ketoesters is efficiently catalyzed by the combination of cinchona‐derived amino‐urea pre‐catalysts and copper(I) salts. The reaction scope is broad and a series of substrates can be efficiently cyclized with high yields and enantioselectivities. Herein, we present a detailed mechanistic study based on experimental considerations and quantum mechanical calculations. Several variables, such as the nature of the organic pre‐catalyst and the metal‐ion source, have been thoroughly investigated. Kinetic studies, as well as kinetic isotope effects and deuterium labeling experiments have been used to gain further insights into the mechanism and prove the cooperative nature of the catalytic system. Our studies suggest that the rate‐limiting step for the reaction involves the β‐ketoester deprotonation and that the active species responsible for the enantiodeterming step is monomeric in amino‐urea pre‐catalyst. Computational studies provide a quantitative understanding of the observed stereoinduction and identify hydrogen bonding from the urea group as a crucial factor in determining the observed enantioselectivity.     

Room‐Temperature Guerbet Reaction with Unprecedented Catalytic Efficiency and Enantioselectivity

We report herein an unprecedented highly efficient Guerbet‐type reaction at room temperature (catalytic TON up to >6000). This β‐alkylation of secondary methyl carbinols with primary alcohols has significant advantage of delivering higher‐order secondary alcohols in an economical, redox‐neutral fashion. In addition, the first enantioselective Guerbet reaction has also been achieved using a commercially available chiral ruthenium complex to deliver secondary alcohols with moderate yield and up to 92 % ee. In both reactions, the use of a traceless ketone promoter proved to be beneficial for the catalytic efficiency.     

Mechanistic Study of the Rhodium‐Catalyzed [3+2+2] Carbocyclization of Alkenylidenecyclopropanes with Alkynes

A systematic theoretical study has been performed on the recently reported Rh^I‐catalyzed [3+2+2] carbocyclization reactions between alkenylidenecyclopropanes (ACPs) and alkynes. With the aid of theoretical calculations, two possible mechanisms, that is, alkene‐carbometalation‐first and alkyne‐carbometalation‐first mechanisms, are examined in this study. In the oxidative addition step, the possibility of reaction on either the distal or proximal C? C bond of the cyclopropane group has been evaluated. The calculations indicate that the alkene‐activation‐first mechanism is more favored for the overall catalytic cycle. This mechanism involves four steps, that is, oxidative addition of the distal (rather than the proximal) C? C bond of cyclopropane group, alkene carbometalation, alkyne carbometalation, and reductive elimination. The rate‐determining step in the overall catalytic cycle is the carbometalation of the alkyne (i.e., the alkyne‐insertion step) and this step also determines the regioselectivity. Finally, the origin of the regioselectivity is determined by the steric effect (i.e., the steric crowding between the electron‐withdrawing group on alkyne and other ligands on the rhodium center) in the alkyne‐insertion step.     

Mechanistic Origin of Chemoselectivity in Thiolate‐Catalyzed Tishchenko Reactions

The thiolate‐catalyzed Tishchenko reaction has shown high chemoselectivity for the formation of double aromatic‐substituted esters. In the present study, the detailed reaction mechanism and, in particular, the origin of the observed high chemoselectivity, have been studied with DFT calculations. The catalytic cycle mainly consisted of three steps: 1,2‐addition, hydride transfer, and acyl transfer steps. The calculation results reproduce the experimental observations that 4‐chlorobenzaldehyde acts as the hydrogen donor (carbonyl part in the ester product), while 2‐methoxybenzaldehyde acts as the hydrogen acceptor (alcohol part in the product). The two main factors are responsible for such chemoselectivity: 1) in the rate‐determining hydride transfer step, the para‐chloride substituent facilitates the hydride‐donating process by weakening the steric hindrance, and 2) the ortho‐methoxy substituent facilitates the hydride‐accepting process by stabilizing the magnesium center (by compensating for the electron deficiency).     

A Base‐Free Neutral Phase‐Transfer Reaction System

Although phase‐transfer reactions catalyzed by using quaternary ammonium salts are generally believed to require base additives, we discovered that, even without any base additives, conjugate additions of 3‐substituted oxindoles to nitroolefins proceeded smoothly in the presence of lipophilic quaternary ammonium bromide under water–organic biphasic conditions. The mechanism of this novel base‐free neutral phase‐transfer reaction system is investigated and the assumed catalytic cycle is presented together with interesting effects of water and lipophilicity of the phase‐transfer catalyst. The base‐free neutral phase‐transfer reaction system can be applied to highly enantioselective conjugate addition and aldol reactions under the influence of chiral bifunctional ammonium bromides as key catalysts. The structure of the chiral ammonium enolate intermediate is discussed based on the single‐crystal X‐ray structures of relevant ammonium salts and the importance of bifunctional design of catalyst is clearly explained in the model of intermediate.     

Mechanism-based chemical understanding of chiral symmetry breaking in the Soai reaction. A combined probabilistic and deterministic description of chemical reactions

The experimentally observed distribution of enantiomers in the Soai reaction is interpreted in this Article on the basis of a chemical mechanism using a newly developed stochastic kinetic method, accelerated Monte Carlo simulation combined with deterministic continuation and symmetrization. The method is in principle suitable for handling large mechanisms with realistic particle numbers and could be useful for any case where the kinetics of a process shows inherent random fluctuations. The mechanism shows how a slow initial reaction combined with efficient and highly enantioselective autocatalysis can give rise to chiral symmetry breaking under completely nonchiral external conditions.     

Catalytic Enantioselective Synthesis of C1‐ and C2‐Symmetric Spirobiindanones through Counterion‐Directed Enolate C‐Acylation

A catalytic enantioselective route to C₁‐ and C₂‐symmetric 2,2′‐spirobiindanones has been realized through an intramolecular enolate C‐acylation. This reaction employs a chiral ammonium counterion to direct the acylation of an in situ generated ketone enolate with a pentafluorophenyl ester. This reaction constitutes the first example of a direct catalytic enantioselective C‐acylation of a ketone and provides an efficient and highly enantioselective route to axially chiral spirobiindanediones. These products can be diastereoselectively derivatized, offering access to a range of functionalized spirocyclic architectures.     

Palladium‐Catalyzed Enantioselective Thiocarbonylation of Styrenes

A highly enantioselective thiocarbonylation of styrenes with CO and thiols has been achieved by Pd catalysis, providing highly enantioenriched thioesters in good to excellent yields. Key to the successful execution of this reaction is the use of a chiral sulfoxide‐(P‐dialkyl)‐phosphine (SOP) ligands. This thiocarbonylation proceeds smoothly under mild reaction conditions (1 atm CO and 0 °C) and displays broad substrate scope. Also demonstrated is that this transformation can be conducted using surrogates of CO, greatly increasing the safety aspects of running the reaction. The generality and utility of the method is manifested by its application to the synthetic transformations of thioester products and the direct acylation of cysteine‐containing dipeptides. A primary mechanism was investigated and a plausible catalytic cycle was proposed.     

Frank Model and Spontaneous Emergence of Chirality in Closed Systems

In a closed system an irreversible enantioselective autocatalysis coupled to a mutual inhibition reaction, corresponding to a fast and low exergonic formation of the heterochiral dimer which reverts to the monomers in the final reaction work‐up, yields absolute asymmetric synthesis even in the absence of chiral polarizations. This is due to the very high chiral amplifications of the initial small statistical deviations from the ideal racemic composition. Moreover, this system is sensitive to very small chiral polarizations (energy differences between transition states below the mJ mol^?1 range). This behaviour can also be observed in reversible exergonic reactions, because the racemization time scale is substantially longer than that of the transformation of the initial reagents. The effect of the presence of other reactions likely to occur (i.e. non‐catalytic transformations, non‐enantioselective catalysis and homodimer formation) is discussed. Even if these decrease the sensitivity of the network in several chemical scenarios, the emergence of kinetically controlled spontaneous symmetry breaking is not hindered. These features, together with the response of the system to a sequential reaction procedure, suggest that a similar type of network is at the heart of the Soai reaction.