Retention modelling of electrostatic and adsorption effects of aliphatic and aromatic carboxylic acids in ion-exclusion chromatography

The retention mechanism of aliphatic and aromatic carboxylic acids in ion-exclusion chromatography has been investigated with consideration of simultaneous electrostatic repulsion effects and hydrophobic adsorption effects. A mathematical relationship between the retention factor of the analyte and the mobile-phase composition (sulfuric acid concentration and percentage of methanol), the type of analyte (pK_a and hydrophobicity) and some physical characteristics of the stationary phase has been derived. Thirteen carboxylic acids (comprising mono- and divalent, aliphatic and aromatic acids) were chosen and used to acquire retention data on three different cation-exchange stationary phases (in which the sulfonate functional groups are bound to polystyrene–divinylbenzene, polymethacrylate or silica) using 14 mobile-phase compositions of varying pH and percent methanol. These retention data were used to derive the parameters necessary to solve the retention model using non-linear regression. In this way, a quantitative measure of the effects of adsorption phenomena on analyte retention were obtained. The model was then used to optimise the separation of nine carboxylic acids.     

Qualitative analysis of some carboxylic acids by ion-exclusion chromatography with atmospheric pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometric detection

A simple, selective and sensitive method for the determination of carboxylic acids has been developed. A mixture of formic, acetic, propionic, valeric, isovaleric, isobutyric, and isocaproic acids has been separated on a polymethacrylate-based weak acidic cation-exchange resin (TSK gel OA pak-A) based on an ion-exclusion chromatographic mechanism with detection using UV-photodiode array, conductivity and atmospheric pressure chemical ionization mass spectrometry (APCI-MS). A mobile phase consisting of 0.85 mM benzoic acid in 10% aqueous methanol (pH 3.89) was used to separate the above carboxylic acids in about 40 min. For LC-MS, the APCI interface was used in the negative ionization mode. Linear plots of peak area versus concentration were obtained over the range 1-30 mM (r2=0.9982) and 1-30 mM (r2=0.9958) for conductimetric and MS detection, respectively. The detection limits of the target carboxylic acids calculated at S/N=3 ranged from 0.078 to 2.3 microM for conductimetric and photometric detection and from 0.66 to 3.82 microM for ion-exclusion chromatography-APCI-MS. The reproducibility of retention times was 0.12-0.16% relative standard deviation for ion-exclusion chromatography and 1.21-2.5% for ion-exclusion chromatography-APCI-MS. The method was applied to the determination of carboxylic acids in red wine, white wine, apple vinegar, and Japanese rice wine.     

Vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography of haloacetic acids on a weakly acidic cation-exchange resin

A new and simple approach is described for the determination of the haloacetic acids (such as mono-, di- and trichloroacetic acids) usually found in drinking water as chlorination by-products after disinfection processes and acetic acid. The new approach, termed vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography, is based on an ion-exclusion mechanism but using the sample solution as the mobile phase, pure water as the injected sample, and a weakly acidic cation-exchange resin column (TSKgel OApak-A) as the stationary phase. The addition of sulfuric acid to the mobile phase results in highly sensitive conductivity detection with sharp and well-shaped peaks, leading to excellent and efficient separations. The elution order was sulfuric acid, dichloroacetic acid, monochloroacetic acid, trichloroacetic acid, and acetic acid. The separation of these acids depends on their pKa values. Acids with lower pKa values were eluted earlier than those with higher pKa, except for trichloroacetic acid due to a hydrophobic-adsorption effect occurring as a side-effect of vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography. The detection limits of these acids in the present study with conductivity detection were 3.4 microM for monochloroacetic acid, 0.86 microM for dichloroacetic acid and 0.15 microM for trichloroacetic acid.     

Ion-exclusion chromatographic behavior of aliphatic carboxylic acids and benzenecarboxylic acids on a sulfonated styrene--divinylbenzene co-polymer resin column with sulfuric acid containing various alcohols as eluent

The addition of C1-C7 alcohols (methanol, ethanol, propanol, butanol, heptanol, hexanol and heptanol) to dilute sulfuric acid as eluent in ion-exclusion chromatography using a highly sulfonated styrene-divinylbenzene co-polymer resin (TSKgel SCX) in the H+ form as the stationary phase was carried out for the simultaneous separations of both (a) C1-C7 aliphatic carboxylic acids (formic, acetic, propionic, isobutyric, butyric, isovaleric, valeric, 2-methylvaleric, isocaproic, caproic, 2,2-dimethyl-n-valeric, 2-methylhexanoic, 5-methylhexanoic and heptanoic acids) and (b) benzenecarboxylic acids (pyromellitic, hemimellitic, trimellitic, o-phthalic, m-phthalic, p-phthalic, benzoic and salicylic acids and phenol). Heptanol was the most effective modifier in ion-exclusion chromatography for the improvement of peak shapes and a reduction in retention volumes for higher aliphatic carboxylic acids and benzenecarboxylic acids. Excellent simultaneous separation and relatively highly sensitive conductimetric detection for these C1-C7 aliphatic carboxylic acids were achieved on the TSKgel SCX column (150 x 6 mm I.D.) in 30 min using 0.5 mM sulfuric acid containing 0.025% heptanol as eluent. Excellent simultaneous separation and highly sensitive UV detection at 200 nm for these benzenecarboxylic acids were also achieved on the TSKgel SCX column in 30 min using 5 mM sulfuric acid containing 0.075% heptanol as eluent.     

Vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography of carboxylic acids on a weakly acidic cation-exchange resin

In this preliminary study, a new approach to ion-exclusion chromatography is proposed to overcome the relatively poor conductivity detection response which occurs in ion-exclusion chromatography when acids are added to the eluent in order to improve peak shape. This approach, termed vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography, requires the sample to be used as eluent and a sample of water to be injected onto a weakly acidic cation-exchange column (TSKgel OApak-A). Vacancy peaks for each of the analytes appear at the retention times of these analytes. Highly sensitive conductivity detection is possible and sharp, well-shaped peaks are produced, leading to efficient separations. Retention times were found to be affected by the concentration of the analytes in the eluent, and also by the presence of an organic modifier such as methanol in the eluent. Detection limits for oxalic, formic, acetic, propionic, butyric and valeric acids were 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.3, 0.4 and 0.5 microM, respectively, and linear ranges for some acids extended over two orders of magnitude. Precision values for retention times were 0.21% and for peak areas were <1.90%. The vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography method was found to give detection responses four to 10 times higher than conventional ion-exclusion chromatography using sulfuric acid eluent and two to five times higher than conventional ion-exclusion chromatography using benzoic acid eluent.     

Vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography of inorganic acids on a weakly acidic cation-exchange resin column

Vacancy ion-exclusion chromatography (VIEC) for inorganic acids such as H(2)SO(4), HCl, H(3)PO(4), HNO(3), HI and HF is tested on a polymethacrylate-based weakly acidic cation-exchange resin column in the H(+)-form. That is, mixture of inorganic acids in the mobile phase is adsorbed to the resin phase passing through the separation column, and each vacant peak induced by injecting water is determined. Retention times are dependent on the degrees of retention for each analyte in the resin phase. In VIEC, well-shaped peaks of inorganic acids are produced, leading to efficient separations. However, retention behaviors of inorganic acids were strongly affected by the concentrations of the acids in the mobile phase. Sulfosalicylic acid was mixed with inorganic acids in the mobile phase prior to the introduction of a separation column in order to obtain the well-resolutions in the lower concentrations of the acids. By using this method, the separations of inorganic acids could be achieved in the range of 0.01-1 mM, and the linear ranges could be extended over two-orders of magnitude. This is considered since the protonated carboxylic groups fixed on the resin phase were increased with increasing the acid concentrations in the mobile phase, and the penetration effects for the acids to the resin phase were thus enhanced. The detection limits (S/N=3) were below 1.0 microM for all analyte acids. Precision values for retention times were below 0.32% and for peak area were below 0.91%.     

Evaluation of different electrolyte systems and on-line preconcentrations for the analysis of haloacetic acids by capillary zone electrophoresis

The separation of various carboxylic acids was performed on a polymethacrylate-based weakly acidic cation-exchange resin (TSKgel OApak-A) using ion-exclusion chromatography under the acidic elution conditions. When a diluted sulfuric acid solution was used as the eluent, highly sensitive conductimetric detection of carboxylic acids was achieved without increasing the background conductance of the eluent. This method was more sensitive than using benzoic acid eluent and enabled a good resolution of dicarboxylic as well as monocarboxylic acids. The addition of 5–20% methanol to the eluent considerably reduced the retention times of carboxylic acids with hydrophobic nature.     

Ethylammonium formate as an organic solvent replacement for ion-pair reversed-phase liquid chromatography

Ethylammonium formate (EAF), an inexpensive and easily synthesized room-temperature ionic liquid, acts like a conventional organic solvent for reversed-phase liquid chromatography (LC). In this report, the use of standard ion-pair reagents with this ionic liquid LC mobile phase and a polystyrene-divinylbenzene PRP-1 column is explored. Starting with the column equilibrated with a methanol mobile phase, the required equilibration time of the column by the EAF ion-pair mobile phase is determined by the plate number profile. Chromatograms of six aromatic carboxylic acids, with either methanol or EAF as the mobile phase, at room temperature (in the absence of an ion-pairing agent) lack resolution with significant peak overlap of nitro-substituted benzoic acids. The addition of 30mM tetrabutylammonium ion to the EAF or methanol mobile phase provides baseline resolution for all peaks in approximately 10 min. Analogous studies using a mixture of four aromatic amines, including protonated tyramine, diphenhydramine, and neutral nitroanilines in the absence or presence of 30mM sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) in the mobile phase are similar to those for the aromatic acids, indicating baseline resolution with only the ion-pair reagent. Raising the column temperature to 55 degrees C improves the plate count by a factor of approximately 1.2 when using the EAF mobile phase. The retention factor profiles for either the carboxylic acids or the amines, as a function of the organic modifier percentage or ion-pair reagent concentration, are similar for both EAF and methanol. The polymerized acyl monoglycinate surfactant, poly(sodium-N-undecenoyl glycinate), is used for the first time as an LC ion-interaction reagent and is about as effective as SDS for the resolution of organic amines.     

Non-suppressed conductivity and indirect UV detection of carboxylic acids in environmental samples by ion-exclusion chromatography using 2,6-pyridinedicarboxylic acidic eluent

2,6-Pyridinedicarboxylic acid (PDCA) was evaluated as an eluent for indirect UV and non-suppressed conductivity detection of carboxylic acids in ion-exclusion chromatography. The effect of PDCA concentration on the separation and detection sensitivity was investigated. The reasonable resolutions between carboxylic acids were achieved using 1 mM PDCA eluent. Detection limits were 1.0-7.0 microM for conductivity detection and 8-30 microM for UV detection. Compared to the eluent containing 1 mM sulfuric acid, the method offers a high resolution and high detection sensitivity for both detectors due to its high molar absorptivity and low background conductance. The proposed method was demonstrated to be useful for the determination of carboxylic acids in environmental samples with direct sample injection.     

Single-Run Separation and Determination of Aliphatic and Aromatic Carboxylic Acids in Wine and Human Urine Samples by Ion-Exclusion Chromatography

This work is focused on developing a new chromatographic method with UV detection for the separation and determination of thirty-two carboxylic aliphatic and/or aromatic acids in a single run. Ion-exclusion chromatography with a silica based, modified with C18, analytical column Alltech Prevail? organic acid 5 µm (150 mm × 4.6 mm I.D) was used for the solving of this problem. The developed method was based on ion-exclusion and/or hydrophobic interaction chromatographic separation mechanism. The effect of the concentrations of phosphate buffer and its pH as well as the column temperatures on the retention of the test acids has been investigated. Gradient elution of the mobile phase composed of aqueous phosphate buffer and methanol was used to achieve a required separation of carboxylic acids within 45 min. All measurements were done at 220 nm. Column temperature was set at 25 ± 0.1 °C. The LOD values for organic acids range from 0.002–2.224 mg L^?1. The repeatability of the procedure developed is characterized by the RSD, which varied between 0.52 and 2.85 % for the peak area. The proposed method was successfully applied for the determination of aliphatic and aromatic acids in dry white wine and human urine samples.     

溶质在动态改性氧化锆液相色谱柱上的保留行为

分别采用硬脂酸、环糊精和十二烷基磺酸钠动态改性自制的ZrO2微球,研究了流动相中甲醇和改性剂浓度对苯酚及苯甲酸的衍生物、苯胺衍生物及芳香烃类化合物的色谱保留行为的影响。中性及碱性化合物的保留时间较短,色谱峰对称;酸性化合物保留时间较长,色谱峰拖尾较严重。改性氧化锆表现出反相色谱性能。     

离子排斥色谱用于厌氧消化处理水中脂肪族羧酸的分析（英文）

The analysis of seven aliphatic carboxylic acids(formic,acetic,propionic,iso-butyric,n-butyric,iso-valeric and n-valeric acid) in anaerobic digestion process waters for biogas production was examined by ion-exclusion chromatography with dilute acidic eluents(benzoic acid,perfluorobutyric acid(PFBA) and sulfuric acid) and non-suppressed conductivity/ultraviolet(UV) detection.The columns used were a styrene/divinylbenzene-based strongly acidic cation-exchange resin column(TSKgel SCX) and a polymethacrylate-based weakly acidic cation-exchange resin column(TSKgel Super IC-A/C).Good separation was performed on the TSKgel SCX in shorter retention times.For the TSKgel Super IC-A/C,peak shape of the acids was sharp and symmetrical in spite of longer retention times.In addition,the mutual separation of the acids was good except for iso-and n-butyric acids.The better separation and good detection was achieved by using the two columns(TSKgel SCX and TSKgel Super IC-A/C connected in series),lower concentrations of PFBA and sulfuric acid as eluents,non-suppressed conductivity detection and UV detection at 210 nm.This analysis was applied to anaerobic digestion process waters.The chromatograms with conductivity detection were relatively simpler compared with those of UV detection.The use of two columns with different selectivities for the aliphatic carboxylic acids and the two detection modes was effective for the determination and identification of the analytes in anaerobic digestion process waters containing complex matrices.     

Determination of some aliphatic carboxylic acids in anaerobic digestion process waters by ion-exclusion chromatography with conductimetric detection on a weakly acidic cation-exchange resin column

The determination of seven aliphatic carboxylic acids, formic, acetic, propionic, isobutyric, n-butyric, isovaleric and n-valeric acids in anaerobic digestion process waters was examined using ion-exclusion chromatography with conductimetric detection. The analysis of these biologically important carboxylic acids is necessary as a measure for evaluating and controlling the process. The ion-exclusion chromatography system employed consisted of polymethacrylate-based weakly acidic cation-exchange resin columns (TSKgel OApak-A or TSKgel Super IC-A/C). weakly acidic eluent (benzoic acid), and conductimetric detection. Particle size and cation-exchange capacity were 5 microm and 0.1 meq./ml for TSKgel OApak-A and 3 microm and 0.2 meq./ml for TSKgel Super IC-A/C, respectively. A dilute eluent (1.0-2.0 mM) of benzoic acid was effective for the high resolution and highly conductimetric detection of the carboxylic acids. The good separation of isobutyric and n-butyric acids was performed using the TSKgel Super IC-A/C column (150 mm x 6.0 mm i.d. x 2). The simple and good chromatograms were obtained by the optimized ion-exclusion chromatography conditions for real samples from mesophilic anaerobic digestors, thus the aliphatic carboxylic acids were successfully determined without any interferences.     

Use of beta-cyclodextrin bonded phase with s-triazine moiety in the spacer for separation of aromatic carboxylic acid isomers by high-performance liquid chromatography

The separation and retention behavior of five aromatic carboxylic acid isomers was investigated by means of high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using a β-cyclodextrin bonded phase with s-triazine ring in the spacer. The influence of mobile phase pH on the retention was examined. The presence of s-triazine moiety in the spacer enhances greatly the selectivity of the isomers of aromatic carboxylic acids. Baseline separations of the five aromatic carboxylic acid isomers were achieved. In particular, the isomers of toluic, aminobenzoic, nitrobenzoic and hydroxybenzoic acid were successfully and effectively separated. The chromatographic results indicate that, in addition to inclusion complexation, π-π interaction and hydrogen bonding interaction between the bonded phase and analytes play significant roles in the retention of these acid isomers. Different elution orders were observed for these acidic solutes with different substituents. Possible retention mechanisms are discussed.     

Characterization of the properties of stationary phases for liquid chromatography in aqueous mobile phases using aromatic sulphonic acids as the test compounds

We investigated the effects of the concentration of naphthalene sulphonic acids (NSAs) as anionic test compounds in the injected sample and of the salt additives to the mobile phase on ion-exclusion. The retention behaviour of NSAs sensitively reflects even minor changes in the ionic and hydrophobic interactions and can be useful for predicting the effects of the stationary phases in reversed-phase chromatography of polar and ionic compounds, both small ones and biopolymers, e.g., oligonucleotides. We studied chromatographic properties of several stationary phases intended for separations in aqueous mobile phases: a C18 column end-capped with polar hydrophilic groups, a densely bonded C8 column doubly end-capped with short alkyl groups, a short alkyl stationary phase designed to keep full pore accessibility in highly-aqueous mobile phases and a Bidentate column with “bridged” C18 groups attached to the silica hydride support. The chemistry and pore structure of various types of column packing materials and of the salt additives to the mobile phase affect the proportion of the pore volume non-accessible to anions due to ion-exclusion and consequently the peak asymmetry and hydrophobic selectivity in reversed-phase chromatography of organic acids. We also addressed the problems connected with the determination of column hold-up volume in aqueous mobile phases. The accessibility of the stationary phase for anionic compounds in contact with the sample zone is affected by ion-exclusion due to repulsive interactions with the negatively charged surface in the pores of the stationary phase. The accessible part of the stationary phase increases and consequently the migration velocity along the column decreases with increasing concentration of the sample in the zone moving along the column. Because of a limited access to the stationary phase, its capacity can be easily overloaded. The combination of the column overload and ion-exclusion effects may result in fronting or tailing peak asymmetry. To explain this behaviour, we proposed a modified Langmuir model, respecting the variation of the column capacity due to the effects of sample concentration on ion-exclusion.     

单柱离子色谱法测定一价阳离子的流动相研究

对单柱离子色谱法测定一价阳离子的流动相进行了系统研究，阐述了一价阳离子的保留行为和电导检测行为与流动相之间的关系，分别对无机酸（硝酸）、有机酸（柠檬酸）和芳香碱（苯胺）为流动相测定一价阳离子进行了讨论，其中有机酸和无机酸是较为适宜的流动相。     

Separation of Aliphatic and Aromatic Carboxylic Acids by Conventional and Ultra High-Performance Ion-Exclusion Chromatography

An ion-exclusion chromatography (IELC) comparison between a conventional ion-exchange column and an ultra high-performance liquid chromatography (UHPLC) dynamically surfactant modified C18 column for the separation of an aliphatic carboxylic acid and two aromatic carboxylic acids is presented. Professional software is used to optimize the conventional IELC separation conditions for acetylsalicylic acid and the hydrolysis products: salicylic acid and acetic acid. Four different variables are simultaneously optimized including H₂SO₄ concentration, pH, flow rate, and sample injection volume. Thirty different runs are suggested by the software. The resolutions and the time of each run are calculated and feed back to the software to predict the optimum conditions. Derringer’s desirability functions are used to evaluate the test conditions and those with the highest desirability value are utilized to separate acetylsalicylic acid, salicylic acid, and acetic acid. These conditions include using a 0.35 mM H₂SO₄ (pH 3.93) eluent at a flow rate of 1 mL min^?1 and an injection volume of 72 μL. To decrease the run time and improve the performance, a UHPLC C18 column is used after dynamic modification with sodium dodecyl sulfate. Using pure water as a mobile phase, a shorter analysis time and better resolution are achieved. In addition, the elution order is different from the IELC method which indicates the contribution of the reversed-phase mode to the separation mechanism.     

Dynamic coating ion-exchange chromatography of cations on an octadecyl-bonded silica stationary phase

It was found that common cations (Na+, NH4+, K+, Mg2+ and Ca2+) could be strongly retained on an ODS stationary phase when aqueous solutions of carboxylic acids were used as eluents. The chromatographic conditions used in this work were the same as in common cation-exchange chromatography on a cation-exchange resin and the retention behavior of the above-mentioned cations on the ODS column was quite similar to that on a cation-exchange column. The retention behavior and mechanism have been investigated using a number of carboxylic acids as eluents. The retention mechanism of the cations in these experiments was considered to be a dynamic coating ion-exchange mechanism. The carboxylic acids in the mobile phase were coated onto the surface of the ODS stationary phase and formed a dynamic carboxylic acid functional layer which could act like the functional group layer of a carboxylic group cation exchanger.     

Separation and Retention Behavior of Aromatic Carboxylic Acid Isomers by High‐Performance‐Liquid‐Chromatography Using β‐Cyclodextrin Bonded Phase with Diamine‐s‐Triazine Moiety

A β‐cyclodextrin (β‐CD) bonded phase with diamine‐s‐triazine moiety was prepared. The separation and retention behavior of the isomers of five aromatic carboxylic acids, including toluic acid, aminobenzoic acid, nitrobenzoic acid, hydroxybenzoic acid, and naphthoic acid were investigated by a high‐performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using the β‐CD bonded phase prepared. The influence of mobile phase pH in the range of 2.7‐3.6 on the retention of these analytes was examined. The isomers of the aromatic carboxylic acids, with the exception of nitrobenzoic acid, were optimally and effectively separated at pH 2.7, while the three isomers of nitrobenzoic acid could be well separated at pH 3.3. Compared with the chromatographic results obtained previously on the amine‐s‐triazine‐β‐CD bonded phase, the retention factors of the isomers of aromatic carboxylic acid on the diamine‐s‐triazine‐β‐CD bonded phase increase to a relatively much greater extent. Thus, the functionality of the spacer arm of the bonded phase playing an important role in the retention of aromatic carboxylic acid isomers is demonstrated. The results also imply that the hydrogen‐bonding interaction and the mechanism of anion exchange sorption as well may contribute significantly to the retention mechanisms.     

Why robust background electrolytes containing multivalent ionic species can fail in capillary zone electrophoresis

Previous models for the retention behaviour of carboxylic acids in ion-exclusion chromatography are applicable only when the degree of ionisation of the analyte is constant over the entire chromatographic peak. When solutions of sulfuric acid are used as eluents, this condition applies only when the eluent concentration is considerably higher than that of the analyte. Since it is common for dilute solutions of sulfuric acid to be used as eluents, a retention model which accounts for unbuffered eluents has been developed. This model also considers the effects on retention of hydrophobic adsorption of the undissociated and dissociated forms of the analyte onto the stationary phase substrate, as well as the effects of organic solvents added to the eluent. The derivation of this model is presented and it has been evaluated using a comprehensive set of retention data obtained using three different sulfonated stationary phases over a range of eluent conditions. The adsorption coefficients calculated from the model are in accordance with expected trends and showed that both the undissociated and dissociated forms of the analyte acids were retained by hydrophobic adsorption effects, although this adsorption was much stronger for the undissociated analytes.