Influence of Copolymerization on Fragmentation Behavior Using Ziegler‐Natta Catalysts

Summary: A morphological investigation was carried out on different Ziegler‐Natta catalysts during the early stages of propylene homo‐ and propylene‐ethylene copolymerization. For similar polymerization conditions, but dependent on the nature of the catalysts, fragmentation occurs layer‐by‐layer or instantaneously into a large amount of small pieces. However, the incorporation of comonomer ethylene slows down the fragmentation progress. This is believed to be the result of the higher mobility of the just formed propylene‐ethylene copolymer molecules at the active sites.

SEM images of the cross‐sectional morphology of polymer particles from catalyst‐I.     

Ziegler‐Natta/Metallocene Hybrid Catalyst for Ethylene Polymerization

A Ziegler‐Natta/metallocene hybrid catalyst was produced and utilized in the polymerization of ethylene with the aim of producing bimodal polyethylene. The MgCl₂ adduct was prepared by a melt quenching method and Cp₂ZrCl₂ and TiCl₄ catalysts were loaded, respectively, after treating the surface with TiBAl. The polymerization kinetics involved an induction period, followed by fragmentation and expansion of particles. SEM micrographs revealed that the spherical morphology was retained through the initial mild reaction conditions of induction period. The polymers produced showed bimodal molecular weight distribution patterns, suggesting that both components of the hybrid catalyst were active over the support.

     

Modifications of the active sites distribution in the Ziegler‐Natta polymerization of propylene using Lewis acids

Heterogeneous Ziegler‐Natta precatalysts (with phthalate as internal donor) were modified by treatments with various Lewis acids (MCl_n with M = Ga, Sn, Si, and Sb and n = 3, 4, or 5) before their use in the polymerization of propylene. If performed on previously “detitanated” precatalysts, treatments with SnCl₄ and SiCl₄ lead to a slight activation but especially to an increase of the tacticity whereas GaCl₃ and SbCl₅ treatments deactivate the catalyst. The modification method applied to conventional unmodified precatalysts gave similar trends. A significant increase of tacticity (and/or of T_m) and a narrowing of the molecular weight distribution were observed in the case of SnCl₄ and SiCl₄ treatments. © 2010 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 48: 2631–2635, 2010     

Determination of the Catalytic Sites for Ziegler‐Natta Homo‐Polymerization from GPC Data

Deconvolution of the MWD of a polymer produced by multi‐site catalysts into independent Flory modes is the first step in modeling the polymerization process. A new deconvolution procedure for GPC data is developed that does not require an a priori assumption concerning the nature of the discrete distribution and can be used with a continuous distribution. The MWD measured via GPC is a linear function of the individual catalytic sites, but it is numerically ill‐conditioned, preventing direct inversion of the GPC data. Tikhonov regularization has been developed to uniquely invert the MWD. Applying the regularizing method to a polyethylene produced via a Ziegler‐Natta catalyst, seven discrete sites were found, and the kinetic constant ratios were determined for each of these sites.

     

A Simplified Model for Prediction of Molecular Weight Distributions in Ethylene‐Hexene Copolymerization Using Ziegler‐Natta Catalysts

A simplified steady‐state model has been developed to predict molecular weight distributions and average compositions of ethylene‐hexene copolymers produced using heterogeneous Ziegler‐Natta catalysts in gas‐phase reactors. The model uses a simplified reaction scheme to limit the number of parameters that must be estimated. The number of parameters is further reduced by assuming that different types of active sites share common rate constants for some reactions. Estimates of kinetic parameters are obtained using deconvolution analysis of industrial copolymer samples produced using a variety of isothermal steady‐state operating conditions. The parameter estimates should prove useful as initial guesses for future parameter estimation in a non‐isothermal model.

     

AlR2Cl/MgR2 combinations as universal cocatalysts for Ziegler–Natta,metallocene, and post‐metallocene catalysts

Combinations of dialkylaluminum chlorides and dialkylmagnesium compounds, when used at molar [AlR₂Cl]:[MgR₂] ratios ≥ 2, act as universal cocatalysts for all three presently known types of alkene polymerization catalysts—Ziegler–Natta, metallocene, and post‐metallocene. When these cocatalysts are used with supported Ti‐based Ziegler–Natta catalysts, they produce catalyst systems which are 1.5–2 times more active than the systems utilizing AlR₃ compounds as cocatalysts. Combinations of AlR₂Cl/MgR₂ cocatalysts and various metallocene complexes produce single‐center catalyst systems similar to those formed in the presence of MAO. The same cocatalysts activate numerous post‐metallocene Ti complexes containing bidentate ligands of a different nature and produce multicenter systems of very high activity. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 47: 3271–3285, 2009     

Exploring Reaction Kinetics of a Multi‐Site Ziegler‐Natta Catalyst Using Deconvolution of Molecular Weight Distributions for Ethylene‐Hexene Copolymers

Industrial ethylene‐hexene copolymer samples produced using a supported Ti‐based Ziegler‐Natta catalyst were deconvoluted into five Flory molecular weight distributions (MWDs). Relationships between reactor operating conditions and deconvolution parameters confirmed that temperature and hydrogen and hexene concentrations influenced the MWD. The two sites that produced low‐molecular‐weight polymer responded similarly to changes in reactor operating conditions, as did the three sites that produce high‐molecular‐weight polymer. Increasing hexene concentration resulted in relatively more polymer being produced at the two low‐molecular‐weight sites and less at the high‐molecular‐weight sites. The information obtained will be useful for making simplifying assumptions during kinetic model development.

     

Ethylene polymerization reactions with Ziegler–Natta catalysts. III. Chain-end structures and polymerization mechanism

Ethylene polymerization reactions with many Ziegler–Natta catalysts exhibit a number of features that differentiate them from polymerization reactions of α olefins: (1) a relatively low ethylene reactivity, (2) markedly higher polymerization rates in the presence of α olefins, (3) a high reaction order with respect to ethylene concentration, and (4) a strong reversible rate depression in the presence of hydrogen. A detailed kinetic analysis of ethylene polymerization reactions¹ provided the basis for a new kinetic scheme that postulates the equilibrium formation of Ti C₂H₅ species with the H atom in the methyl group β-agostically coordinated to the Ti atom in an active center. This mechanism predicts several new features of ethylene polymerization reactions, one being that chain initiation via insertion of any α-olefin molecule into the Ti H bond should proceed with an increased probability compared to that via ethylene insertion into the same bond. As a result, a significant fraction of ethylene/α-olefin copolymer chains should contain α-olefin units as the starting units. This article provides experimental data supporting this prediction on the basis of both a detailed structural analysis of co-oligomers formed in ethylene/1-pentene and ethylene/4-methyl-1-pentene copolymerization reactions and a spectroscopic analysis of chain ends in the copolymers. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci A: Polym Chem 37: 4281–4294, 1999     

Hydrogen effects in propylene polymerization reactions with titanium‐based Ziegler–Natta catalysts. II. Mechanism of the chain‐transfer reaction

Hydrogen is a very effective chain‐transfer agent in propylene polymerization reactions with Ti‐based Ziegler–Natta catalysts. However, measurements of the hydrogen concentration effect on the molecular weight of polypropylene prepared with a supported TiCl₄/dibutyl phthalate/MgCl₂ catalyst show a peculiar effect: hydrogen efficiency in the chain transfer significantly decreases with concentration, and at very high concentrations, hydrogen no longer affects the molecular weight of polypropylene. A detailed analysis of kinetic features of chain‐transfer reactions for different types of active centers in the catalyst suggests that chain transfer with hydrogen is not merely the hydrogenolysis reaction of the Ti? C bond in an active center but proceeds with the participation of a coordinated propylene molecule. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 40: 1899–1911, 2002     

Kinetics of ethylene polymerization reactions with chromium oxide catalysts

Principal kinetic data are presented for ethylene homopolymerization and ethylene/1‐hexene copolymerization reactions with two types of chromium oxide catalyst. The reaction rate of the homopolymerization reaction is first order with respect to ethylene concentration (both for gas‐phase and slurry reactions); its effective activation energy is 10.2 kcal/mol (42.8 kJ/mol). The r₁ value for ethylene/1‐hexene copolymerization reactions with the catalysts is ～30, which places these catalysts in terms of efficiency of α‐olefin copolymerization with ethylene between metallocene catalysts (r₁ ～ 20) and Ti‐based Ziegler‐Natta catalysts (r₁ in the 80–120 range). GPC, DSC, and Crystaf data for ethylene/1‐hexene copolymers of different compositions produced with the catalysts show that the reaction products have broad molecular weight and compositional distributions. A combination of kinetic data and structural data for the copolymers provided detailed information about the frequency of chain transfer reactions for several types of active centers present in the catalysts, their copolymerization efficiency, and stability. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 46: 5315–5329, 2008     

Ethylene polymerization and ethylene/hexene copolymerization with vanadium(III) catalysts bearing heteroatom‐containing salicylaldiminato ligands

A series of novel vanadium(III) complexes bearing heteroatom‐containing group‐substituted salicylaldiminato ligands [RN?CH(ArO)]VCl₂(THF)₂ (Ar = C₆H₄, R = C₃H₂NS, 2a ; C₇H₄NS, 2c ; C₇H₅N₂, 2d ; Ar = C₆H₂tBu₂ (2,4), R = C₃H₂NS, 2b ) have been synthesized and characterized. Structure of complex 2c was further confirmed by X‐ray crystallographic analysis. The complexes were investigated as the catalysts for ethylene polymerization in the presence of Et₂AlCl. Complexes 2a–d exhibited high catalytic activities (up to 22.8 kg polyethylene/mmol_V h bar), and affording polymer with unimodal molecular weight distributions at 25–70 °C in the first 5‐min polymerization, whereas produced bimodal molecular weight distribution polymers at 70 °C when polymerization time prolonged to 30 min. The catalyst structure plays an important role in controlling the molecular weight and molecular weight distribution of the resultant polymers produced in 30 min polymerization. In addition, ethylene/hexene copolymerizations with catalysts 2a–d were also explored in the presence of Et₂AlCl, which leads to the high molecular weight and unimodal distributions copolymers with high comonomer incorporation. Catalytic activity, comonomer incorporation, and polymer molecular weight can be controlled over a wide range by the variation of catalyst structure and the reaction parameters, such as comonomer feed concentration, polymerization time, and polymerization reaction temperature. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 47: 3573–3582, 2009     

Ethylene polymerization reactions with Ziegler–Natta catalysts. II. Ethylene polymerization reactions in the presence of deuterium

Ethylene polymerization reactions with many Ziegler–Natta catalysts exhibit several features which differentiate them from polymerization reactions of α-olefins: a relatively low ethylene reactivity, higher polymerization rates in the presence of α-olefins, a high reaction order with respect to ethylene concentration, and strong reversible rate depression in the presence of hydrogen. A detailed kinetic analysis of ethylene polymerization reactions (see ref. 1 ) provided the basis for a new reaction scheme which explains all these features by postulating the equilibrium formation of a Ti C₂H₅ species with the H atom in the methyl group β-agostically coordinated to the Ti atom in an active center. This mechanism predicts that the β-agostically stabilized Ti C₂H₅ groups can decompose in the β-hydride elimination reaction with expulsion of ethylene and the formation of a Ti H bond even in the absence of hydrogen in the reaction medium. If D₂ is used as a chain transfer agent instead of H₂, the mechanism predicts the formation of deuterated ethylene molecules, which copolymerize with protioethylene. To prove this prediction, several ethylene homopolymerization reactions were carried out with a supported Ziegler–Natta titanium-based catalyst in the presence of large amounts of D₂. Analysis of gaseous reaction products and polymers confirmed the formation of several types of deuterated ethylene molecules and protio/deuterioethylene copolymers, respectively. In contrast, a metallocene catalyst, Cp₂ZrCl₂ MAO, does not exhibit these kinetic features. In the presence of deuterium, it produces only DCH₂ CH₂ (CH₂ CH₂)_x CH₂ CH₂D molecules. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci A: Polym Chem 37: 4273–4280, 1999     

Ethylene polymerization reactions with Ziegler–Natta catalysts. I. Ethylene polymerization kinetics and kinetic mechanism

Kinetics of ethylene homopolymerization reactions and ethylene/1-hexene copolymerization reactions using a supported Ziegler–Natta catalyst was carried out over a broad range of reaction conditions. The kinetic data were analyzed using a concept of multicenter catalysis with different centers that respond differently to changes in reaction parameters. The catalyst contains five types of active centers that differ in the molecular weights of material they produce and in their copolymerization ability. In ethylene homopolymerization reactions, each active center has a high reaction order with respect to ethylene concentration, close to the second order. In ethylene/α-olefin copolymerization reactions, the centers that have poor copolymerization ability retain this high reaction order, whereas the centers that have good copolymerization ability change the reaction order to the first order. Hydrogen depresses activity of each type of center in the homopolymerization reactions in a reversible manner; however, the centers that copolymerize ethylene and α-olefins well are not depressed if an α-olefin is present in the reaction medium. Introduction of an α-olefin significantly increases activity of those centers, which are effective in copolymerizing it with ethylene but does not affect the centers that copolymerize ethylene and α-olefins poorly. To explain these kinetic features, a new reaction scheme is proposed. It is based on a hypothesis that the Ti—C₂H₅ bond in active centers has low reactivity due to the equilibrium formation of a Ti—C₂H₅ species with the H atom in the methyl group β-agostically coordinated to the Ti atom in an active center. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. J Polym Sci A: Polym Chem 37: 4255–4272, 1999     

Organic nanoparticles as fragmentable support for Ziegler–Natta catalysts

A fragmentable support material for Ziegler–Natta catalysts is presented based on micrometer‐sized aggregates of polystyrene nanoparticles. Hydroxyl anchoring groups are introduced by copolymerization of hydroxymethylstyrene in emulsion process to immobilize the catalysts. The catalytic activity in ethylene slurry polymerizations is found to be directly correlated to the hydroxyl group content of the supports. Furthermore, the fragmentation behavior of dye‐labeled support aggregates into the initial nanoparticles is demonstrated using laser scanning confocal fluorescence microscopy as a nondestructive method. These supported catalysts fulfill two important design criteria, high fragmentability and high catalyst loading, and produce high‐density polyethylene with medium molecular weight distributions (MWDs = 3–4). These values lie between those obtained using single‐site metallocene‐based (narrow MWD < 3) or inorganic supported multi‐site Ziegler–Natta‐based (broad MWD = 4–12) polymerizations without the need of blending. © 2014 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Polym. Sci., Part A: Polym. Chem. 2015 , 53, 15–22     

Parameter Estimation in a Simplified MWD Model for HDPE Produced by a Ziegler‐Natta Catalyst

A simplified steady‐state model to predict MWDs of ethylene/butene and ethylene/hexene copolymers produced industrially using heterogeneous Z‐N catalysts is developed. Estimability analysis is used to guide model simplification and to determine which parameters can be estimated using the available data. Scaling of response variables and parameters using information about their uncertainties ensures that appropriate results are obtained from the estimability analysis. Parameter estimates are obtained to provide good predictions of the measured MWDs. Although the parameter values obtained are specific to the Z‐N catalyst of our industrial sponsor, the method should be useful for parameter estimation and model simplification in other catalytic polymerization systems.

     

A Simplified Comprehensive Kinetic Scheme for Modeling of Ethylene/1‐butene Copolymerization Using Ziegler‐Natta Catalysts

A simplified kinetic scheme of eythylene/α‐olefin copolymerization has been developed by adding reactions responsible for the unusual kinetic behavior to a general mechanism. The estimation of rate constants has been simplified by making physically meaningful initial guesses. Rate constants affecting yield, MWD and comonomer content have been estimated separately. Experiments were designed to investigate the effects of each rate constant independently. The obtained rate constants show that the sites which are responsible for formation of short chains with higher 1‐butene content are more active at the beginning of polymerization, while the sites which are responsible for formation of longer chains with lower 1‐butene units are more active at the final stages of polymerization.

     

Hydrogen effects in propylene polymerization reactions with titanium‐based Ziegler–Natta catalysts. I. Chemical mechanism of catalyst activation

The hydrogen activation effect in propylene polymerization reactions with Ti‐based Ziegler–Natta catalysts is usually explained by hydrogenolysis of dormant active centers formed after secondary insertion of a propylene molecule into the growing polymer chain. This article proposes a different mechanism for the hydrogen activation effect due to hydrogenolysis of the Ti? iso‐C₃H₇ group. This group can be formed in two reactions: (1) after secondary propylene insertion into the Ti? H bond (which is generated after β‐hydrogen elimination in the growing polymer chain or after chain transfer with hydrogen), and (2) in the chain transfer with propylene if a propylene molecule is coordinated to the Ti atom in the secondary orientation. The Ti? CH(CH₃)₂ species is relatively stable, possibly because of the β‐agostic interaction between the H atom of one of its CH₃ groups and the Ti atom. The validity of this mechanism was demonstrated in a gas chromatography study of oligomers formed in ethylene/α‐olefin copolymerization reactions with δ‐TiCl₃/AlEt₃ and TiCl₄/dibutyl phthalate/MgCl₂–AlEt₃ catalysts. A quantitative analysis of gas chromatography data for ethylene/propylene co‐oligomers showed that the probability of secondary propylene insertion into the Ti? H bond was only 3–4 times lower than the probability of primary insertion. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 40: 1353–1365, 2002     

Detitanation of MgCl2‐supported Ziegler‐Natta catalysts for the study of active sites organization

Thermal treatments under vacuum of conventional supported Ziegler‐Natta precatalysts (MgCl₂/TiCl₄/Dibutylphthalate) were conducted to gradually remove titanium to modify the active sites distribution. Only limited detitanations of precatalysts were achieved paying attention not to chemically alter the internal donor (T < 150 °C). Used in combination with the required cocatalyst and external donor in the propylene slurry polymerization, the modified precatalysts exhibited a drop of activity versus decreasing titanium content but the distributed polymer properties are almost not affected (a slight narrowing of molecular weight distribution was observed). After a titanium chloride secondary impregnation (possibly done in presence of an additional Lewis base), activity resumed but polymer properties are once again unchanged. These findings highlight the difficulty to separate the different families of active sites and lead us to propose a cluster organization of titanium active sites. Active sites are composed of titanium clusters having a size distribution at the precatalyst surface, possessing a critical operating size and operating collectively in polymerization. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 46: 5461–5470, 2008     

Multi‐center nature of heterogeneous Ziegler–Natta catalysts: TREF confirmation

A new approach to detailed Tref analysis of ethylene/α‐olefin copolymers prepared with multi‐center polymerization catalysts is developed. It is based on resolution of complex Tref curves into elemental components described with the Lorentz distribution function. This approach was applied to the study of a series of ethylene/1‐butene copolymers prepared with a supported Ti‐based catalyst. The analysis showed that the copolymers, which, on average, contain from 6.5 to 3.5 mol % of 1‐butene, consist of seven discrete components with different compositions, ranging from a completely amorphous material with a 1‐butene content of > 15–20 mol %, to two highly crystalline components with 1‐butene contents < 1 mol %. A comparison of these Tref results with the data on the molecular weight distribution of the copolymers (based on resolution of their GPC curves) shows that Tref and GPC data provide complimentary information on the properties of active centers in the catalysts in terms of the molecular weights of the material they produce and their ability to copolymerize α‐olefins with ethylene. Tref analysis of copolymers produced at different reaction times showed that the active centers responsible for the formation of various Tref components differ in the rates of their formation and in stability. The centers that produce copolymer molecules with a high 1‐butene content are formed rapidly but decay rapidly as well whereas the centers producing copolymer molecules with a low 1‐butene content are formed more slowly but are more stable. © 2005 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 43: 4351–4362, 2005     

Effects of external donors and hydrogen concentration on oligomer formation and chain end distribution in propylene polymerization with Ziegler‐Natta catalysts

The effect of type and concentration of external donor and hydrogen concentration on oligomer formation and chain end distribution were studied. Bulk polymerization of propylene was carried out with two different Ziegler‐Natta catalysts at 70 °C, one a novel self‐supported catalyst (A) and the other a conventional MgCl₂‐supported catalyst (B) with triethyl aluminum as cocatalyst. The external donors used were dicyclopentyl dimethoxy silane (DCP) and cyclohexylmethyl dimethoxy silane (CHM). The oligomer amount was shown to be strongly dependent on the molecular weight of the polymer. Catalyst A gave approximately 50 % lower oligomer content than catalyst B due to narrower molecular weight distribution in case of catalyst A. More n‐Bu‐terminated chain ends were found for catalyst A indicating more frequent 2,1 insertions. Catalyst A also gave more vinylidene‐terminated oligomers, suggesting that chain transfer to monomer, responsible for the vinylidene chain ends, was a more important chain termination mechanism for this catalyst, especially at low hydrogen concentration. Low site selectivity, due to low external donor concentration or use of a weak external donor (CHM), was also found to increase formation of vinylidene‐terminated oligomers. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 48: 351–358, 2010