A new approach for the study of gas-phase ion-ion reactions using electrospray ionization

A simple flow reactor which facilitates the study and application of ion-ion and ion-molecule reactions at near atmospheric pressures is reported. Reactant ions were generated by electrospray ionization and discharge ionization methods, although any ionization sources amenable to atmospheric pressure may be used. Ions of opposite charge are generated in spatially separate ion sources and are swept into capillary inlets where the flows are merged and where reaction(s) can occur. Among the reactions investigated were the partial neutralization of multiply protonated polypeptides and proteins such as melittin, bradykinin, cytochrome c, and myoglobin by reaction with discharge-generated anions, the partial neutralization of multiply charged anions of oligodeoxyadenylic acid (d(pA)₃) by reaction with discharge-generated cations, the partial neutralization of bovine A-chain insulin anions by reaction with myoglobin [M+nH]ⁿ⁺ ions, and the reaction of multiply protonated melittin with discharge-generated cations. The cation-anion reactions generally resulted in a shift to lower charge (higher mass-to-charge ratio) in the products’ charge state distributions and the transfer of solvent molecules to the macromolecule products. Multiply protonated melittin was detected in a less highly solvated state with the positive discharge in operation.     

Decompositions of odd- and even-electron anions derived from deoxy-polyadenylates

Radical anions have been formed via electron transfer from multiply charged 5′-d(AAA)-3′ and 5′-d(AAAA)-3′ anions to CCl₃ ⁺. These ions have been isolated in a quadrupole ion trap operated with helium bath gas at a pressure of 1 mtorr and subjected to resonance excitation (i. e., conventional ion trap collisional activation). Collisional activation of the even-electron species of the same charge state formed directly via electrospray was also performed by using essentially identical conditions. The collisional activation data can be compared directly without ambiguity arising from differences in parent ion internal energies and/or dissociation time frames. Both the odd- and even-electron anions yield extensive sequence-informative fragmentation but show significant differences in the extent of nucleobase loss and in the relative contributions from the various sequence diagnostic dissociation channels. The results of this study indicate that radical anions derived from multiply deprotonated oligo-deoxynucleotides that survive the electron transfer process are stable with respect to fragmentation in the ion trap environment under normal storage conditions and that the unimolecular dissociation behavior of these ions differs from the even-electron anions of the same charge state. These findings suggest, therefore, that odd- and even-electron anions might be used to provide complementary sequence information in cases in which neither ion type provides the full sequence.     

Ion trap collisional activation of disulfide linkage intact and reduced multiply protonated polypeptides.

The presence of disulfide linkages in multiply charged polypeptide ions tends to inhibit the formation of structurally informative product ions under conventional quadrupole ion trap collisional activation conditions. In particular, fragmentation that requires two cleavages (i.e., cleavage of a disulfide linkage and a peptide linkage) is strongly suppressed. Reduction of the disulfide linkage(s) by use of dithiothreitol yields parent ions upon electrospray without this complication. Far richer structural information is revealed by ion trap collisional activation of the disulfide-reduced species than from the native species. These observations are illustrated with doubly protonated native and reduced somatosin, the [M + 5H](5+) ion of native bovine insulin and the [M + 4H](4+) and [M + 3H](3+) ions of the B-chain of bovine insulin produced by reduction of the disulfide linkages in insulin, and the [M + 11H](11+) ion of native chicken lysozyme and the [M + 11H](11+) and [M + 14H](14+) ions of reduced lysozyme. In each case, the product ions produced by ion trap collisional activation were subjected to ion/ion proton transfer reactions to facilitate interpretation of the product ion spectra. These studies clearly suggest that the identification of polypeptides with one or more disulfide linkages via application of ion trap collisional activation to the multiply charged parent ions formed directly by electrospray could be problematic. Means for cleaving the disulfide linkage, such as reduction by dithiothreitol prior to electrospray, are therefore desirable in these cases.     

Tandem mass spectrometry of half-generation PAMAM dendrimer anions

Ions derived from negative electrospray ionization of polyamidoamine (PAMAM) dendrimer generation 0.5 were subjected to ion trap tandem mass spectrometry. Ion/ion proton transfer reactions were used to manipulate the charge states of PAMAM precursor ions to form lower charge states from those initially formed by electrospray, as well as to facilitate the interpretation of the product ion mass spectra. Most of the products derived from dendrimer precursor ions could be rationalized by retro-Michael decomposition reactions. The dominant fragmentation channels are highly dependent on the composition of the counter-ions, which in this case are restricted to different numbers of sodium ions and protons, and whether the precursor ion is multiply charged or singly charged. An interpretation is given that is consistent with all of the observations made with the various anions associated with this study. The nature of the structural information that can be obtained via ion trap tandem mass spectrometry of the dendrimers is dependent on the types of precursor ions subjected to study. The tandem mass spectrometry data also provided information about the structure of faulty synthesis products present in the PAMAM dendrimer sample.     

Manipulation of charge states of biopolymer ions by atmospheric pressure ion/molecule reactions implemented in an extractive electrospray ionization source

A home-made extractive electrospray ionization source is coupled to an linear quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer to investigate ion/molecule reactions of biopolymers at ambient pressure. Multiply charged biopolymers such as peptides and proteins generated in an electrospray are easily reduced to a low charge state by the atmospheric pressure ion/molecule reactions occurring between the multiply charged ions and a strong basic reagent sprayed in neutral form into the electrospray plume. The charge state of the biopolymer ions can be manipulated by controlling the amount of the basic reagent. The production of biopolymer ions with low charge states results in a substantial improvement of sensitivity and reduced spectral congestion in ESI-MS. This is of importance for biopolymer mixture analysis and could have promising applications in proteomics.     

Mutual storage mode ion/ion reactions in a hybrid linear ion trap

Ion/ion proton transfer reactions involving mutual storage of both ion polarities in a linear ion trap (LIT) that comprises part of a hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion trap mass spectrometer have been effected. Mutual ion storage in the x- and y-dimensions arises from the normal operation of the oscillating quadrupole field of the quadrupole array, while storage in the z-dimension is enabled by applying unbalanced radio-frequency amplitudes to opposing sets of rods of the array. Efficient trapping (>90%) is achieved for thermalized ions over periods of several seconds. Reactions were demonstrated for multiply charged protein/peptide cations formed by electrospray with anions derived from glow discharge ionization of perfluoro(methyldecalin) (PMD) introduced from the side of the LIT rod array. Doubly and singly charged protein ions are readily formed via ion/ion reactions. The parameters that affect ion/ion reactions are discussed, including the degree of RF unbalance on the LIT rods, vacuum pressure, nature of the buffer gas, reaction time, anion abundance, and the low mass cutoff for ion/ion reaction. The present system has a demonstrated upper mass-to-charge ratio limit of at least 33,000. The system also has high flexibility with respect to defining MS(n) experiments involving both collision-induced dissociation (CID) and ion/ion reactions. Experiments are demonstrated involving beam-type CID in the pressurized collision quadrupole (Q2) followed by ion/ion reactions involving the product ions in the LIT. Ion parking experiments are also demonstrated using the mutual storage ion/ion reaction mode in the LIT, with a parking efficiency over 60%.     

Targeted ion parking for the quantitation of biotherapeutic proteins: Concepts and preliminary data

Targeted ion parking (or TIPing) is the first quantitative application of ion/ion reactions for mass spectrometry. In TIPing, intact biotherapeutic proteins are electrosprayed as intact molecules (no digestion) and, as expected, many multiply protonated species are produced (e.g., (M + 7H)⁷⁺, (M + 8H)⁸⁺, etc.). Several of these multiply charged species are selectively isolated using a quadrupole mass analyzer and then contained in a linear ion trap. The protein ions are then subjected to a proton-transfer reaction with a reagent anion. The ions undergo sequential charge reduction (e.g., to (M + 6H)⁶⁺) during a defined reaction period. Applying a low-amplitude waveform to the trap during this reaction time stops the ion/ion reaction at a chosen (and predicted) charge state for the protein. This funnels the analyte ions into a single channel with relatively high efficiency (>-50% of reactant ion signal is converted into product ion signal) that can be used for quantitation. In TIPing, the target protein’s molecular weight and charge state distribution are the only prerequisite knowledge required. This information can be acquired experimentally or can be easily predicted based upon amino acid sequences. Preliminary data for a biotherapeutic protein, a domain antibody, were collected using TIPing coupled online with liquid chromatography (LC-TIPing). The LC-TIPing data demonstrate a linear response for samples from 10–1000 ng/mL extracted from a complex plasma sample, demonstrating the analytical potential for TIPing.     

Top-down tandem mass spectrometry of tRNA via ion trap collision-induced dissociation

Transfer RNA is a class of highly modified and structured non-coding RNA molecules generally comprised of 74–95 nucleotides. In this study, tandem mass spectrometry of intact multiply charged tRNA anions of roughly 25 kDa in mass has been demonstrated using a quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer adapted for ion/ion reaction studies. The sample proved to be a mixture of tRNA molecules. The mass of the most abundant component of the mixture was not consistent with that of the nominal identity of the tRNA from the supplier, viz., tRNA^phe; rather, the mass was consistent with tRNA^Phe bearing an incomplete 3′-terminus. Multiply-charged anions from the major components were isolated in the gas phase and subjected to ion trap collision-induced dissociation without subsequent ion/ion reactions. Abundant fragments from the 5′- and 3′-termini of the molecule could be used to identify the major component as tRNA^phe-3′adenosine (without 3′-phosphorylation). Roughly 15% of the primary sequence of the intact tRNA was unambiguously reflected in the product ion spectrum. The existence of a possible tRNA^Phe variant and the intact tRNA^Phe was also supported by ion trap CID data. The multiply-charged fragment ions derived from tRNA^Phe-3′adenosine were further charge-reduced to mostly singly- and doubly-charged species via proton transfer ion/ion reactions with benzoquinoline cations. The resulting reduction in spectral overlap and charge state ambiguity simplified interpretation of the product ion spectrum and allowed for the identification of product ions from roughly 60% of the sequence.     

Loss of charged versus neutral heme from gaseous holomyoglobin ions.

The dissociation of holomyoglobin ions ranging in charge state from +10 to +2 has been studied using collisional activation in a quadrupole ion trap. Collisional activation times and amplitudes were varied to investigate the effects of these variables on dissociation of the heme group from the holoprotein. The onset of neutral heme loss occurs at a lower activation amplitude than loss of charged heme. For solutions of ferri-myoglobin, charged heme loss was prominent for +10 to +4 holomyoglobin ions, while neutral heme loss product was found to be dominant for charge states +3 and +2. For any given charge state, activation of holomyoglobin ions from a solution containing primarily ferro-myoglobin yielded significantly more abundant neutral heme loss products than was observed for activation of ions from solutions containing primarily ferri-myoglobin. The relative concentrations of the two oxidation states were shown to be affected by redox chemistry within the nano-electrospray emitter used in this work. Results from a double activation experiment revealed that the precursor ions of a given charge state contained a mixture of two populations, with ferro-myoglobin giving rise to neutral heme loss upon dissociation and ferri-myoglobin yielding charged heme. No evidence for electron transfer upon collisional activation of ferri-myoglobin ions was observed. Furthermore, little or no evidence for electron transfer associated with ion/ion reactions with anions derived from perfluoro-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane was observed. Definitive results could not be drawn for the lowest precursor ion charge states (+3 and +2) due to low dissociation efficiencies.     

Transmission mode ion/ion proton transfer reactions in a linear ion trap

A new method is described for effecting ion/ion proton transfer reactions that involves storage of analyte ions while oppositely charged ions are transmitted through the stored ion population. In this approach, the products are captured and stored in the linear ion trap for subsequent mass analysis. Charge reduction of multiply charged protein ions is used as an example to illustrate the analytical usefulness of this method. In another variation of the transmission mode ion/ion reaction approach, two charge inversion experiments, implemented by passing analyte ions through a population of multiply charged reagent ions in a LIT, are also demonstrated. A pulsed dual ion source approach coupled with a hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion trap instrument was used to demonstrate these two methods. The results for ion/ion reactions implemented using these so-called "transmission mode" experiments were comparable to those acquired using the more conventional mutual storage mode, both in terms of efficiency and information content of the spectra. An advantage of transmission mode experiments compared with mutual storage mode experiments is that they do not require any specialized measures to be taken to enable the simultaneous storage of oppositely charged ions.     

Pulsed dual electrospray ionization for In/In reactions

A pulsed dual electrospray ionization source has been developed to generate positive and negative ions for subsequent ion/ion reaction experiments. The two sprayers, typically a nano-electrospray emitter for analytes and an electrospray emitter for reagents, are positioned in a parallel fashion close to the sampling orifice of a triple quadrupole/linear ion trap tandem mass spectrometer (Sciex Q TRAP). The potentials applied to each sprayer are alternately pulsed so that ions of opposite polarity are generated separately in time. Ion/ion reactions take place after ions of each polarity are sequentially injected into a high-pressure linear ion trap, where axial trapping is effected by applying an auxiliary radio frequency voltage to the end lenses. The pulsed dual electrospray source allows optimization of each sprayer and can be readily coupled to any spray interface with no need for instrument modifications, provided the potentials required to transmit the ion polarity of interest can be alternated in synchrony with the emitter potentials. Ion/ion reaction examples such as charge reduction of multiply charged protein ions, charge inversion of peptides ions, and protein-protein complex formation are given to illustrate capabilities of the pulsed dual electrospray source in the study of gas-phase ion/ion chemistry.     

Effects of ion/ion proton transfer reactions on conformation of gas-phase cytochrome <Emphasis Type="Italic">c</Emphasis> ions

Positive ions from cytochrome c are studied in a 3-D ion trap/ion mobility (IM)/quadrupole-time-of-flight (TOF) instrument with three independent ion sources. The IM separation allows measurement of the cross section of the ions. Ion/ion reactions in the 3-D ion trap that remove protons cause the cytochrome c ions to refold gently without other degradation of protein structure, i.e., fragmentation or loss of heme group or metal ion. The conformation(s) of the product ions generated by ion/ion reactions in a given charge state are similar regardless of whether the cytochrome c ions are originally in +8 or +9 charge states. In the lower charge states (+1 to +5) cytochrome c ions made by the ion/ion reaction yield a single IM peak with cross section of ～1110 to 1180 Ų, even if the original +8 ion started with multiple conformations. The conformation expands slightly when the charge state is reduced from +5 to +1. For product ions in the +6 to +8 charge states, ions created from higher charge states (+9 to +16) by ion/ion reaction produce more compact conformation(s) in somewhat higher abundances compared with those produced directly by the electrospray ionization (ESI) source. For ions in intermediate charge states that have a variety of resolvable conformers, the voltage used to inject the ions into the drift tube, and the voltage and duration of the pulse that extracts ions from the ion trap, can affect the observed abundances of various conformers.     

Tandem Mass Spectrometry of Small,Multiply Charged Oligonucleotides

Multiply charged anions derived from electrospray ionization of the sodium salts of various small oligonucleotides (n = 4?8) have been subjected to tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) in a quadrupole ion trap. All ions were observed to dissociate with high efficiencies even under conditions not ordinarily conducive for the observance of high MS/MS efficiency. Large fractions of the total product ion signal could be attributed to single-cleavage reactions with the parent ion charge shared among the two product ions in various combinations. In every case, the most facile reaction was observed to be the loss of the adenine anion. This reaction was then observed to be followed by cleavage of the 3′ C–O bond of phosphodiester linkage of the sugar from which the adenine had been lost.     

Gas-phase proton transfer reactions involving multiply charged cytochrome c ions and water under thermal conditions

Investigations of gas-phase proton transfer reactions have been performed on protein molecular ions generated by electrospray ionization (ESI). Their reactions were studied in a heated capillary inlet/reactor prior to expansion into a quadrupole mass spectrometer. Results from investigations involving protonated horse heart cytochrome c and H, O suggest that Coulombit effects can lower reaction barriers as well as aid in entropically driven reactions. For example, the charge state distribution observed by a quadrupole mass spectrometer for multiply protonated cytochrome c without the addition of any reactive gas ranges from 9+ to 19+ , with the [M + 15H]¹⁵⁺ ion being the most intense peak. With the addition of H₂O (proton affinity approximately 170.3±2 kcal/mol) to the capillary reactor at 120°C, the charge state distribution shifts to a lower charge, ranging from 13+ to less than 9+. Under the same conditions with argon (proton affinity approximately 100 kcal/mol) as the reactive gas, no shift in the charge state distribution is observed. The results demonstrate that proton transfer to water can occur for highly protonated molecular ions, a process that would be expected to be highly endothermic for singly protonated molecules (for which Coulombic destabilization is not significant). The results imply that the charge state distribution from ESI is somewhat dependent upon the mechanism and speed of the droplet evaporation/ion desolvation process, which may vary substantially with the ESI/mass spectrometry interface design.     

Effect of varying counterions on the sensitivity of electrohydrodynamic and fast atom bombardment mass spectrometry

The abundance of ion pairs (CA⁺) relative to that of doubly charged ions (C²⁺) in electrohydrodynamic (EH) mass spectra of a series of anions with a common dication in glycerol was found to increase in the order acetate < nitrite < chloride < bromide ≈ nitrate < iodide < perchlorate. Correlation with enthalpies of hydration for the anions suggests that this trend reflects the solution chemistry of ion association. These spectra also reveal that solvation rather than interactions with the extracting field is more important in determining the overall EH mass spectrometric sensitivity to doubly charged ions. Therefore, the use of anions that promote more extensive ion pairing enhances the overall sensitivity to multiply charged ions that otherwise interact strongly with the solvent, but reduces sensitivity to singly charged ions. These observations hold in fast atom bombardment mass spectrometry, surviving the invasive effects of the primary beam.     

"Dueling" ESI: instrumentation to study ion/ion reactions of electrospray-generated cations and anions

Novel instrumentation has been developed which allows for the sequential injection and subsequent reaction of oppositely-charged ions generated via electrospray ionization (ESI) in a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. The instrument uses a DC turning quadrupole to sequentially direct the two ion polarities into the ion trap from ESI sources which are situated 90 degrees from the axial (z) dimension of the trap, and 180 degrees from one another. This arrangement significantly expands the range of ionic reactants amenable to study over previously-used instrumentation. For example, ion/ion reactions of multiply-charged positive ions with multiply-charged negative ions can be studied. Also, reactions of multiply-charged ions with singly-charged ions of opposite polarity that could not be generated by previously used ionization methods, or that could not be efficiently injected through the ion trap ring electrode, can be studied with the new instrument. This capability allows, for example, the charge state manipulation of negatively-charged precursor and product ions derived from proteins and oligonucleotides via proton transfer reactions with singly-charged cations generated by ESI.     

Synthesis of multi-unit protein hetero-complexes in the gas phase via ion-ion chemistry

The synthesis of protein hetero-complex ions via ion-ion reactions in the gas phase is demonstrated in a quadrupole ion trap. Bovine cytochrome c cations and bovine ubiquitin anions are used as reactant species in the stepwise construction of complexes containing as many as six protein sub-units. For any set of reactants, a series of competitive and consecutive reactions is possible. The yield of complex ions for any given sequence of reactions is primarily limited by the presence of competitive reactions. Proton transfer represents the most important competitive reaction that adversely affects protein complex synthesis. In the present data, proton transfer takes place most extensively in the first step of complex synthesis, when single protein sub-units are subjected to reaction with one another. Proton transfer is found to be less extensive when one of the reactants is a protein complex. The generation of hexameric hetero-complexes containing two cytochrome c molecules and four ubiquitin molecules is demonstrated with two different synthesis approaches. The first involved the initial reaction of several charge states of cytochrome c and several charges states of ubiquitin. The sequence of reactions in this example illustrates the array of possible competitive and consecutive reactions associated with even a relatively simple set of multiply charged reactants. The second approach involved the initial reaction of the 9(+) charge state of cytochrome c and the 5(-) charge state of ubiquitin. The latter approach highlights the utility of the multi-stage mass spectrometric (MS(n)) capabilities of the ion trap in defining reactant ion identities (i.e. charge states and polarities) so that synthesis reactions can be directed along a particular set of pathways.     

An ion trap-ion mobility-time of flight mass spectrometer with three ion sources for ion/ion reactions

This instrument combines the capabilities of ion/ion reactions with ion mobility (IM) and time-of-flight (TOF) measurements for conformation studies and top-down analysis of large biomolecules. Ubiquitin ions from either of two electrospray ionization (ESI) sources are stored in a three dimensional (3D) ion trap (IT) and reacted with negative ions from atmospheric sampling glow discharge ionization (ASGDI). The proton transfer reaction products are then separated by IM and analyzed via a TOF mass analyzer. In this way, ubiquitin +7 ions are converted to lower charge states down to +1; the ions in lower charge states tend to be in compact conformations with cross sections down to ～880 Ų. The duration and magnitude of the ion ejection pulse on the IT exit and the entrance voltage on the IM drift tube can affect the measured distribution of conformers for ubiquitin +7 and +6. Alternatively, protein ions are fragmented by collision-induced dissociation (CID) in the IT, followed by ion/ion reactions to reduce the charge states of the CID product ions, thus simplifying assignment of charge states and fragments using the mobility-resolved tandem mass spectrum. Instrument characteristics and the use of a new ion trap controller and software modifications to control the entire instrument are described.     

FT-ICRMS distinguishes the mechanism of the charge state reduction for multiply charged protein cations admixed with redox reagents in ESI

Recently, we reported on a phenomenon in which multiply charged protein cations produced by electrospray ionization could be reduced to lower and narrower charge state distributions when admixed with reducing reagents 1,4-benzoquinone or quinhydrone. Circular dichroism spectra of the proteins indicated that secondary and tertiary structural changes upon addition of these reducing reagents were negligible, thus eliminating conformational effects as playing a role in the charge reduction mechanism. Furthermore, the extent of charge state reduction did not correspond with gas-phase basicities of the redox reagents, suggesting that solution-phase, and not gas-phase, behavior dominates the observed charge state reduction. The relatively low resolution of the triple quadrupole employed did not make it possible to distinguish isotopic distributions of the multiply charged cations in order to determine whether the observed phenomenon was the result of proton-transfer reactions between the multiply charged cations and the reducing reagent or because of electron transfer from the reducing reagent to the protein cations. Here, high-resolution ESI-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry of several peptide amides in the presence of a redox reagent show isotopic distributions that are consistent only with the proton-transfer mechanism.     

Ion-ion proton transfer reactions of bio-ions involving noncovalent interactions: Holomyoglobin

Multiply protonated horse skeletal muscle holomyoglobin and apomyoglobin have been subjected to ion-ion proton transfer reactions with anions derived from perfluoro-1,3-dimethylcyclohexane in a quadrupole ion trap operated with helium as a bath gas at 1 mtorr. Neither the apomyoglobin nor holomyoglobin ions show any sign of fragmentation associated with charge state reduction to the 1 + charge state. This is particularly noteworthy for the holomyoglobin ions, which retain the noncovalently bound heme group. For example, no sign of heme loss is associated with charge state reduction from the 9 + charge state of holomyoglobin to the 1 + charge state despite the eight consecutive highly exothermic proton transfer reactions required to bring about this charge change. This result is consistent with calculations that show the combination of long ion lifetime and the high ion-helium collision rate relative to the ion-ion collision rate makes fragmentation unlikely for high mass ions in the ion trap environment even for noncovalently bound complexes of moderate binding strength. The ion-ion proton transfer rates for holo- and apomyoglobin ions of the same charge state also were observed to be indistinguishable, which supports the expectation that ion-ion proton transfer rates are insensitive to ion structure and are determined primarily by the attractive Coulomb field.