Large-eddy simulation of a bluff-body stabilised turbulent premixed flame using the transported flame surface density approach

A premixed propane–air flame stabilised on a triangular bluff body in a model jet-engine afterburner configuration is investigated using large-eddy simulation (LES). The reaction rate source term for turbulent premixed combustion is closed using the transported flame surface density (TFSD) model. In this approach, there is no need to assume local equilibrium between the generation and destruction of subgrid FSD, as commonly done in simple algebraic closure models. Instead, the key processes that create and destroy FSD are accounted for explicitly. This allows the model to capture large-scale unsteady flame propagation in the presence of combustion instabilities, or in situations where the flame encounters progressive wrinkling with time. In this study, comprehensive validation of the numerical method is carried out. For the non-reacting flow, good agreement for both the time-averaged and root-mean-square velocity fields are obtained, and the Karman type vortex shedding behaviour seen in the experiment is well represented. For the reacting flow, two mesh configurations are used to investigate the sensitivity of the LES results to the numerical resolution. Profiles for the velocity and temperature fields exhibit good agreement with the experimental data for both the coarse and dense mesh. This demonstrates the capability of LES coupled with the TFSD approach in representing the highly unsteady premixed combustion observed in this configuration. The instantaneous flow pattern and turbulent flame behaviour are discussed, and the differences between the non-reacting and reacting flow are described through visualisation of vortical structures and their interaction with the flame. Lastly, the generation and destruction of FSD are evaluated by examining the individual terms in the FSD transport equation. Localised regions where straining, curvature and propagation are each dominant are observed, highlighting the importance of non-equilibrium effects of FSD generation and destruction in the model afterburner.     

A posteriori testing of the flame surface density transport equation for LES

Flame Surface Density (FSD) models for Large Eddy Simulation (LES) are implemented and tested for a canonical configuration and a practical bluff body stabilised burner, comparing common algebraic closures with a transport equation closure in the context of turbulent premixed combustion. The transported method is expected to yield advantages over algebraic closures, as the equilibrium of subgrid production and destruction of FSD is no longer enforced and resolved processes of strain, propagation and curvature are explicitly accounted for. These advantages might have the potential to improve the ability to capture large-scale unsteady flame propagation in situations with combustion instabilities or situations where the flame encounters progressive wrinkling with time. The initial study of a propagating turbulent flame in wind-tunnel turbulence shows that the Algebraic Flame Surface Density (FSDA) method can predict an excessively wrinkled flame under fine grid conditions, potentially increasing the consumption rate of reactants to artificially higher levels. In contrast, the Flame Surface Density Transport (FSDT) closure predicts a smooth flame front and avoids the formation of artificial flame cusps when the grid is refined. Five FSDA models and the FSDT approach are then applied to the LES of the Volvo Rig. The predicted mean velocities are found to be relatively insensitive to the use of the FSDT and FSDA approaches, whereas temperature predictions exhibit appreciable differences for different formulations. The FSDT approach yields very similar temperature predictions to two of the tested FSDA models, quantitatively capturing the mean temperature. Grid refinement is found to improve the FSDT predictions of the mean flame spread. Overall, the paper demonstrates that the apparently complicated FSD transport equation approach can be implemented and applied to realistic, strongly wrinkled flames with good success, and opens up the field for further work to improve the models and the overall FSDT approach.     

Studies of the flow and turbulence fields in a turbulent pulsed jet flame using LES/PDF

A turbulent piloted jet flame subject to a rapid velocity pulse in its fuel jet inflow is proposed as a new benchmark case for the study of turbulent combustion models. In this work, we perform modelling studies of this turbulent pulsed jet flame and focus on the predictions of its flow and turbulence fields. An advanced modelling strategy combining the large eddy simulation (LES) and the probability density function (PDF) methods is employed to model the turbulent pulsed jet flame. Characteristics of the velocity measurements are analysed to produce a time-dependent inflow condition that can be fed into the simulations. The effect of the uncertainty in the inflow turbulence intensity is investigated and is found to be very small. A method of specifying the inflow turbulence boundary condition for the simulations of the pulsed jet flame is assessed. The strategies for validating LES of statistically transient flames are discussed, and a new framework is developed consisting of different averaging strategies and a bootstrap method for constructing confidence intervals. Parametric studies are performed to examine the sensitivity of the predictions of the flow and turbulence fields to model and numerical parameters. A direct comparison of the predicted and measured time series of the axial velocity demonstrates a satisfactory prediction of the flow and turbulence fields of the pulsed jet flame by the employed modelling methods.     

An assessment of large eddy simulations of premixed flames propagating past repeated obstacles

This paper presents an assessment of Large Eddy Simulations (LES) in calculating the structure of turbulent premixed flames propagating past solid obstacles. One objective of the present study is to evaluate the LES simulations and identify the drawbacks in accounting the chemical reaction rate. Another objective is to analyse the flame structure and to calculate flame speed, generated overpressure at different time intervals following ignition of a stoichiometric propane/air mixture. The combustion chamber has built-in repeated solid obstructions to enhance the turbulence level and hence increase the flame propagating speed. Various numerical tests have also been carried out to determine the regimes of combustion at different stages of the flame propagation. These have been identified from the calculated results for the flow and flame characteristic parameters. It is found that the flame lies within the ‘thin reaction zone’ regime which supports the use of the laminar flamelet approach for modelling turbulent premixed flames. A submodel to calculate the model coefficient in the algebraic flame surface density model is implemented and examined. It is found that the LES predictions are slightly improved owing to the calculation of model coefficient by using submodel. Results are presented and discussed in this paper are for the flame structure, position, speed, generated pressure and the regimes of combustion during all stages of flame propagation from ignition to venting. The calculated results are validated against available experimental data.     

Large eddy simulation of turbulent combustion systems

This paper reviews recent and ongoing work on numerical models for turbulent combustion systems based on a classical LES approach. The work is confined to single-phase reacting flows. First, important physico-chemical features of combustion-LES are discussed along with several aspects of overall LES models. Subsequently, some numerical issues, in particular questions associated with the reliability of LES results, are outlined. The details of chemistry, its reduction, and tabulation are not addressed here. Second, two illustrative applications dealing with non-premixed and premixed flame configurations are presented. The results show that combustion-LES is able to provide predictions very close to measured data for configurations where the flow is governed by large turbulent structures. To meet the future demands, new key challenges in specific modelling areas are suggested, and opportunities for advancements in combustion-LES techniques are highlighted. From a predictive point of view, the main target must be to provide a reliable method to aid combustion safety studies and the design of combustion systems of practical importance.     

A fractal flame-wrinkling large eddy simulation model for premixed turbulent combustion

Combustion plays an important role in a wide variety of industrial applications, such as gas-turbines, furnaces, spark-ignition engines, and various air-breathing engines. The ability to predict and understand the behavior of reacting flows in practical devices is fundamental to improved combustors with higher efficiency and reduced levels of emissions. At present, large eddy simulation is considered the most promising approach for premixed combustion modeling since the large-scale energy containing flow structures are resolved on the grid. However, the typically thin reaction zone cannot be resolved. To overcome this difficulty flamelet models, in which the reaction is assumed to take place in thin layers, wrinkled by the turbulence can sometimes be used. In these models, the turbulent flame speed can be represented as the product of the laminar flame speed, S_u, corrected for the effects of stretch (strain and curvature) and the flame-wrinkling, Ξ. In this study, we propose to model Ξ using fractal theory. This model requires sub-models for the fractal dimension, and the inner and outer cut-offs—the latter being set by the grid. A model is proposed for the inner cut-off, whereas an empirical parameterization is used to provide the fractal dimension. The proposed model is applied to flame kernel growth in homogeneous isotropic turbulence in a fan-stirred bomb and to a lean premixed flame in a plane symmetric dump combustor. Good qualitative and quantitative agreement with experimental data were obtained for the proposed model in both cases. Comparison with other well-known turbulent flame speed closure models shows that the proposed model behaves at least as good, or even better, than the reference models.     

Numerical simulation of turbulent combustion: Scientific challenges

Predictive simulation of engine combustion is key to understanding the underlying complicated physicochemical processes, improving engine performance, and reducing pollutant emissions. Critical issues as turbulence modeling, turbulence-chemistry interaction, and accommodation of detailed chemical kinetics in complex flows remain challenging and essential for high-fidelity combustion simulation. This paper reviews the current status of the state-of-the-art large eddy simulation (LES)/prob-ability density function (PDF)/detailed chemistry approach that can address the three challenging modelling issues. PDF as a subgrid model for LES is formulated and the hybrid mesh-particle method for LES/PDF simulations is described. Then the development need in micro-mixing models for the PDF simulations of turbulent premixed combustion is identified. Finally the different acceleration methods for detailed chemistry are reviewed and a combined strategy is proposed for further development.     

Three-dimensional direct simulations and structure of expanding turbulent methane flames

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are ideally suited to investigate in detail turbulent reacting flows in simple geometries. For an increasing number of applications, detailed models must be employed to describe the chemical processes with sufficient accuracy. Despite the huge cost of such simulations, recent progress has allowed the direct numerical simulation of turbulent premixed flames while employing complete reaction schemes. We briefly describe our own developments in this field and use the resulting DNS code to investigate more extensively the structure of premixed methane flames expanding in a three-dimensional turbulent velocity field, initially homogeneous and isotropic. This situation typifies, for example, the initial flame development after spark ignition in a gas turbine or an internal combustion engine. First investigation steps have been carried out at low turbulence levels on this same configuration in the past Symposium, and we build on top of these former results. Here, a considerably higher Reynolds number is considered, the simulation has been repeated twice in to limit the possibility of spurious, very specific results, and several complementary post-processing steps are carried out. Characteristic features concerning the observed combustion regime are presented. We then investigate in a quantitative manner the evolution of flame surface area, global stretch-rate, flame front curvature, flame thickness, and correlation between thickness and curvature. The possibility of obtaining reliable information on flame front curvature from two-dimensional slices is checked by comparison with the exact procedure.     

Capturing multi-regime combustion in turbulent flames with a virtual chemistry approach

Multiple flame regimes are encountered in industrial combustion chambers, where premixed, stratified and non-premixed flame regions may coexist. To obtain a predictive tool for pollutant formation predictions, chemical flame modeling must take into account the influence of such complex flame structure. The objective of this article is to apply and compare two reduced chemistry models on both laminar and turbulent multi-regime flame configurations in order to analyze their capabilities in predicting flame structure and CO formation. The challenged approaches are (i) a premixed flamelet-based tabulated chemistry method, whose thermochemical variables are parameterized by a mixture fraction and a progress variable, and (ii) a virtual chemical scheme which has been optimized to retrieve the properties of canonical premixed and non-premixed 1-D laminar flames. The methods are first applied to compute a series of laminar partially-premixed methane-air counterflow flames. Results are compared to detailed chemistry simulations. Both approaches reproduced the thermal flame structure but only the virtual chemistry captures the CO formation in all ranges of equivalence ratio from stoichiometry premixed flame to pure non-premixed flame. Finally, the two chemical models combined with the Thickened Flame model for LES are challenged on a piloted turbulent jet flame with inhomogeneous inlet, the Sydney inhomogeneous burner. Mean and RMS of temperature and CO mass fraction radial profiles are compared to available experimental data. Scatter data in mixture fraction space and Wasserstein metric of numerical and experimental data are also studied. The analyses confirm again that the virtual chemistry approach is able to account for the impact of multi-regime turbulent combustion on the CO formation.     

Multiscale combustion and turbulence

Multiscale physics is the interaction of different physical processes occurring at largely separated scales. In combustion, many elementary reactions combine to only a few, but still have separated time scales. In flames, owing to the presence of diffusion, time scales manifest themselves as length scales, i.e. thicknesses of reaction layers embedded within each other. For premixed flames there results a single velocity scale, the laminar burning velocity, which in turn defines a flame thickness and a flame time as global length and time scales, respectively. The laminar burning velocity represents the simplest microscale model to be used at a premixed combustion interface.While combustion is a multiscale process, this is not so evident for turbulence. Based on the picture of a cascade process traditional turbulent closure approximations treat turbulence as a single-scale problem. Attempts to model turbulent combustion in the same way by using methods developed for non-reacting turbulent flows therefore must fail, because they ignore the multiscale nature of combustion.There is, however, a long tradition and much progress in multiscale modeling of combustion, both on the macroscale as well as on the microscale level. Unfortunately much of that work is conceived only in its particular context, not as part of a multiscale approach. For instance, papers in the TURBULENT FLAMES Colloquium and the FIRE RESEARCH Colloquium at this and at previous Combustion Symposia often take the viewpoint of macroscale modeling only, while REACTION KINETICS and LAMINAR FLAMES concentrate on microscale aspects. What seems to be needed is a more explicit reference to the needs of models developed in the other parts of the community. Furthermore, research is needed to develop suitable definitions of the interface between macroscale and microscale models.     

Flame growth and wrinkling in a turbulent flow

High-speed planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF) and 3-D large eddy simulations (LES) are used to study turbulent flame kernel growth, wrinkling and the formation of separated flame pockets in methane/air mixtures. Turbulence was effected by a set of rotary fans situated in a cylindrical enclosure. Flame wrinkling was followed on sequential 2-D OH images captured at kHz repetition rates. Under stoichiometric conditions and low turbulence levels the flame kernel remains singly connected and close to spherical in shape. By increasing turbulence or reducing the stoichiometry of the mixture the formation of separated pockets could be observed and studied. The mechanisms behind these phenomena are investigated qualitatively by LES of a level-set G-equation describing the flame surface propagation in turbulent flows. Received: 12 April 2000 / Revised version: 26 June 2000 / Published online: 5 October 2000     

Effects of subgrid scale and combustion modelling on flame structure of a turbulent premixed flame within LES and tabulated chemistry framework

The effects of combustion and SubGrid Scale (SGS) modelling on the overall flame characteristics of a turbulent premixed flame are investigated. This is achieved in terms of mean flow statistics, variances and flame surfaces. In particular, the chemical flame structure is analysed and compared. The Artificially Thickened Flame (ATF) approach coupled with the Flamelet Generated Manifolds (FGMs) and Filtered TAbulated Chemistry for LES (F-TACLES) approaches are used for this investigation. A Germano like procedure for dynamical calculation of SGS wrinkling is used which ensures the conservation of the total flame surface for both models. It turns out that using the dynamic SGS wrinkling model improves the results. Although the results of both combustion models in terms of statistics, mean and variances show very good agreement, the resolved flame surfaces hide different dynamic behaviour.     

Partially premixed flamelet in LES of acetone spray flames

An effective partially premixed flamelet model for large eddy simulation (LES) of turbulent spray combustion is formulated. Different flame regimes are identified with a flame index defined by budget terms in a 2-D multi-phase flamelet formulation, and the application in LES of partially pre-vaporized spray flames shows a favorable agreement with experiments. Simulations demonstrate that, compared to the conventional single-regime flamelets, the present partially premixed flamelet formulation shows its ability in capturing the subgrid regime transitions, yielding a well prediction of peak gas temperature and the downstream flame spreading. A propagating premixed flame front is found coupled with a trailing diffusion burning through the spray evaporation, and the spray effect on regime discrimination is manifested with transport budget analysis. A two-phase regime indicator is then proposed, by which the evaporation-dictated regime is properly described. Its intended use will rely on both gas and spray flamelet structures.     

LES studies of the flow in a swirl gas combustor

Environmental and other practical concerns have led to the development of compact gas turbine combustors burning lean mixtures leading to potentially low CO and NO_x emissions. The compact design requires efficient atomization and mixing together with a compact premixed flame. Associated with these requirements are higher temperatures, increased heat transfer, and thermal load, thus increasing the danger of combustion instabilities (causing performance deterioration and excessive mechanical loads), and possible off-design operation. Numerical simulations of reacting flows are well suited to address these issues. To this end, large eddy simulation (LES) is particularly promising. The philosophy behind LES is to explicitly simulate the large scales of the flow and the thermochemistry, affected by boundary conditions whilst modeling only the small scales, including the interaction between the flow and the combustion processes. Here, we examine the flow and the flame in a model gas turbine combustor (General Electric’s lean premixed dry low NO_x LM6000) to evaluate the potential of LES for design studies of engineering applications and to study the effects of the combustor confinement geometry on the flow and on the flame dynamics. Two LES models, a Monotone Integrated LES model with 1 and 2 step Ahrrenius chemistry, and a fractal flame-wrinkling LES model coupled to a conventional one-equation eddy-viscosity subgrid model, are used. Reasonable agreement is found when comparing predictions with experimental data and with other LES computations of the same case. Furthermore, the combustor confinement geometry is found to strongly affect the vortical flow, and hence also the flame and its dynamics.     

Comparative analysis of methods for heat losses in turbulent premixed flames using physically-derived reduced-order manifolds

Heat losses have the potential to substantially modify turbulent combustion processes, especially the formation of pollutants such as nitrogen oxides. The chemistry governing these species is strongly temperature sensitive, making heat losses critical for an accurate prediction. To account for the effects of heat loss in large eddy simulation (LES) using a precomputed reduced-order manifold approach, thermochemical states must be precomputed not only for adiabatic conditions but also over a range of reduced enthalpy states. However, there are a number of methods for producing reduced enthalpy states, which invoke different implicit assumptions. In this work, a set of a priori and a posteriori LES studies have been performed for turbulent premixed flames considering heat losses within a precomputed reduced-order manifold approach to determine the sensitivity to the method by which reduced enthalpy states are generated. Two general approaches are explored for generating these reduced enthalpy states and are compared in detail to assess any effects on turbulent flame structure and emissions. In the first approach, the enthalpy is reduced at the boundary of the one-dimensional (1D) premixed flame solution, resulting in a single enthalpy deficit for a single premixed flame solution. In the second approach, a variable heat loss source term is introduced into the 1D flame solutions by mimicking a real heat loss to reduce the post-flame enthalpy. The two approaches are compared in methane–air piloted turbulent premixed planar jet flames with different diluents that maintain a constant adiabatic flame temperature but experience different radiation heat losses. Both a priori and a posteriori results, as well as a chemical pathway analysis, indicate that the manner by which the heat loss is accounted for in the manifold is of secondary importance compared to other model uncertainties such as the chemical mechanism, except in situations where heat loss is unphysically fast compared to the flame time scale. A new theoretical framework to explain this insensitivity is also proposed, and its validity is briefly assessed.     

湍流对多孔介质内预混火焰影响的初步研究

当气流速度较大时,多孔介质内预混燃烧的模拟需要考虑湍流的影响,本文利用简化的k-ε双方程湍流反应流模型对多孔介质内的预混火焰进行了数值模拟.结果表明,湍流大大加强了气流的组分和能世扩散,计算得到的火焰传播速度、CO及NO的排放量都与实验值符合得比较好,与层流模型相比,湍流模型能够改善计算结果.     

Direct numerical simulations of turbulent flame expansion in fine sprays

Direct Numerical Simulations of expanding flame kernels following localized ignition in decaying turbulence with the fuel in the form of a fine mist have been performed to identify the effects of the spray parameters on the possibility of self-sustained combustion. Simulations show that the flame kernel may quench due to fuel starvation in the gaseous phase if the droplets are large or if their number is insufficient to result in significant heat release to allow for self-sustained flame propagation for the given turbulent environment. The reaction proceeds in a large range of equivalence ratios due to the random location of the droplets relative to the igniter location that causes a wide range of mixture fractions to develop through pre-evaporation in the unreacted gas and through evaporation in the preheat zone of the propagating flame. The resulting flame exhibits both premixed and non-premixed characteristics.     

Evolution and scaling of the peak flame surface density in spherical turbulent premixed flames subjected to decaying isotropic turbulence

The peak flame surface density within the turbulent flame brush is central to turbulent premixed combustion models in the flamelet regime. This work investigates the evolution of the peak surface density in spherically expanding turbulent premixed flames with the help of direct numerical simulations at various values of the Reynolds and Karlovitz number. The flames propagate in decaying isotropic turbulence inside a closed vessel. The effects of turbulent transport, transport due to mean velocity gradient, and flame stretch on the peak surface density are identified and characterized with an analysis based on the transport equation for the flame surface density function. The three mechanisms are governed by distinct flow time scales; turbulent transport by the eddy turnover time, mean transport by a time scale related to the pressure rise in the closed chamber, and flame stretch by the Kolmogorov time scale. Appropriate scaling of the terms is proposed and shown to collapse the data despite variations in the dimensionless groups. Overall, the transport terms lead to a reduction in the peak value of the surface density, while flame stretch has the opposite effect. In the present configuration, a small imbalance between the two leads to an exponential decay of the peak surface density in time. The dimensionless decay rate is found to be consistent with the evolution of the wrinkling scale as defined in the Bray-Moss-Libby model.     

Temporal evolution of flame stretch due to turbulence and the hydrodynamic instability

The temporal evolution of the strain rate on a turbulent premixed flame was measured experimentally using cinema-stereoscopic particle image velocimetry. Turbulence strains a flame due to velocity gradients associated both directly with the turbulence and those caused by the hydrodynamic instability, which are initiated by the turbulence. The development of flame wrinkles caused by both of these mechanisms was observed. Wrinkles generated by the turbulence formed around vortical structures, which passed through the flame and were attenuated. After the turbulent structures had passed, the hydrodynamic instability flow pattern developed and caused additional strain. The hydrodynamic instability also caused the growth of small flame front perturbations into large wrinkles. In the moderately turbulent flame investigated, it was found that the evolution of the strain rate caused by turbulence–flame interactions followed a common pattern involving three temporal regimes. In the first, the turbulence exerted extensive (positive) strain on the flame, creating a wrinkle that had negative curvature (concave towards the reactants). This was followed by a transition period, leading into the third regime in which the flow pattern and strain rate were dominated by the hydrodynamic instability mechanism. It was also found that the magnitudes of the strain rate in the first and third regimes were similar. Hence, the hydrodynamic instability mechanism caused significant strain on a flame and should be included in turbulent combustion models.     

A numerical study of auto-ignition in turbulent lifted flames issuing into a vitiated co-flow

This paper presents a numerical study of auto-ignition in simple jets of a hydrogen–nitrogen mixture issuing into a vitiated co-flowing stream. The stabilization region of these flames is complex and, depending on the flow conditions, may undergo a transition from auto-ignition to premixed flame propagation. The objective of this paper is to develop numerical indicators for identifying such behavior, first in well-known simple test cases and then in the lifted turbulent flames. The calculations employ a composition probability density function (PDF) approach coupled to the commercial CFD code, FLUENT. The in-situ-adaptive tabulation (ISAT) method is used to implement detailed chemical kinetics. A simple k–ε turbulence model is used for turbulence along with a low Reynolds number model close to the solid walls of the fuel pipe.

The first indicator is based on an analysis of the species transport with respect to the budget of convection, diffusion and chemical reaction terms. This is a powerful tool for investigating aspects of turbulent combustion that would otherwise be prohibitive or impossible to examine experimentally. Reaction balanced by convection with minimal axial diffusion is taken as an indicator of auto-ignition while a diffusive–reactive balance, preceded by a convective–diffusive balanced pre-heat zone, is representative of a premixed flame. The second indicator is the relative location of the onset of creation of certain radical species such as HO₂ ahead of the flame zone. The buildup of HO₂ prior to the creation of H, O and OH is taken as another indicator of autoignition.

The paper first confirms the relevance of these indicators with respect to two simple test cases representing clear auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation. Three turbulent lifted flames are then investigated and the presence of auto-ignition is identified. These numerical tools are essential in providing valuable insights into the stabilization behaviour of these flames, and the demarcation between processes of auto-ignition and premixed flame propagation.