Fredholmness of fringe operators over the bidisk

Let M be an invariant subspace of \(H^2\) over the bidisk. Associated with M, we have the fringe operator \(F^M_z\) on \(M\ominus w M\). For \(A\subset H^2\), let [A] denote the smallest invariant subspace containing A. Assume that \(F^M_z\) is Fredholm. If h is a bounded analytic function on \(\mathbb {D}^2\) satisfying \(h(0,0)\not =0\), then \(F^{[h M]}_z\) is Fredholm and \(\mathrm{ind}\,F^{[h M]}_z=\mathrm{ind}\,F^M_z\).     

Erratum to: Abstract commensurability and quasi-isometry classification of hyperbolic surface group amalgams

A fundamental result by Gromov and Thurston asserts that, if M is a closed hyperbolic n-manifold, then the simplicial volume \(\Vert M\Vert \) of M is equal to \(\mathrm{Vol}(M)/v_n\), where \(v_n\) is a constant depending only on the dimension of M. The same result also holds for complete finite-volume hyperbolic manifolds without boundary, while Jungreis proved that the ratio \(\mathrm{Vol}(M)/\Vert M\Vert \) is strictly smaller than \(v_n\) if M is compact with nonempty geodesic boundary. We prove here a quantitative version of Jungreis’ result for \(n\ge 4\), which bounds from below the ratio \(\Vert M\Vert /\mathrm{Vol}(M)\) in terms of the ratio \(\mathrm{Vol}(\partial M)/\mathrm{Vol}(M)\). As a consequence, we show that, for \(n\ge 4\), a sequence \(\{M_i\}\) of compact hyperbolic n-manifolds with geodesic boundary satisfies \(\lim _i \mathrm{Vol}(M_i)/\Vert M_i\Vert =v_n\) if and only if \(\lim _i \mathrm{Vol}(\partial M_i)/\mathrm{Vol}(M_i)=0\). We also provide estimates of the simplicial volume of hyperbolic manifolds with geodesic boundary in dimension 3.     

An <Emphasis Type="Italic">A</Emphasis>-invariant subspace for bipartite distance-regular graphs with exactly two irreducible <Emphasis Type="Italic">T</Emphasis>-modules with endpoint 2, both thin

Let \(\Gamma \) denote a bipartite distance-regular graph with vertex set X, diameter \(D \ge 4\), and valency \(k \ge 3\). Let \({{\mathbb {C}}}^X\) denote the vector space over \({{\mathbb {C}}}\) consisting of column vectors with entries in \({{\mathbb {C}}}\) and rows indexed by X. For \(z \in X\), let \({{\widehat{z}}}\) denote the vector in \({{\mathbb {C}}}^X\) with a 1 in the z-coordinate, and 0 in all other coordinates. Fix a vertex x of \(\Gamma \) and let \(T = T(x)\) denote the corresponding Terwilliger algebra. Assume that up to isomorphism there exist exactly two irreducible T-modules with endpoint 2, and they both are thin. Fix \(y \in X\) such that \(\partial (x,y)=2\), where \(\partial \) denotes path-length distance. For \(0 \le i,j \le D\) define \(w_{ij}=\sum {{\widehat{z}}}\), where the sum is over all \(z \in X\) such that \(\partial (x,z)=i\) and \(\partial (y,z)=j\). We define \(W=\mathrm{span}\{w_{ij} \mid 0 \le i,j \le D\}\). In this paper we consider the space \(MW=\mathrm{span}\{mw \mid m \in M, w \in W\}\), where M is the Bose–Mesner algebra of \(\Gamma \). We observe that MW is the minimal A-invariant subspace of \({{\mathbb {C}}}^X\) which contains W, where A is the adjacency matrix of \(\Gamma \). We show that \(4D-6 \le \mathrm{dim}(MW) \le 4D-2\). We display a basis for MW for each of these five cases, and we give the action of A on these bases.     

Beatty sequences and prime numbers with restrictions on strongly <Emphasis Type="Italic">q</Emphasis>-additive functions

We estimate exponential sums over a non-homogenous Beatty sequence with restriction on strongly q-additive functions. We then apply our result in a few special cases to obtain an asymptotic formula for the number of primes \(p=\lfloor \alpha n +\beta \rfloor \) and \(f(p)\equiv a (\mathrm{mod\,}b)\), with \(n\ge N \), where \(\alpha \), \(\beta \) are real numbers and f is a strongly q-additive function (for example, the sum of digits function in base q is a strongly q-additive function). We also prove that for any fixed integer \(k\ge 3 \), all sufficiently large \(N\equiv k (\mathrm{mod\,}2) \) could be represented as a sum of k prime numbers from a Beatty sequence with restriction on strongly q-additive functions.     

Estimates for coefficients of certain <Emphasis Type="Italic">L</Emphasis>-functions

Let \(\pi _{\varphi }\) (or \(\pi _{\psi }\)) be an automorphic cuspidal representation of \(\text {GL}_{2} (\mathbb {A}_{\mathbb {Q}})\) associated to a primitive Maass cusp form \(\varphi \) (or \(\psi \)), and \(\mathrm{sym}^j \pi _{\varphi }\) be the jth symmetric power lift of \(\pi _{\varphi }\). Let \(a_{\mathrm{sym}^j \pi _{\varphi }}(n)\) denote the nth Dirichlet series coefficient of the principal L-function associated to \(\mathrm{sym}^j \pi _{\varphi }\). In this paper, we study first moments of Dirichlet series coefficients of automorphic representations \(\mathrm{sym}^3 \pi _{\varphi }\) of \(\text {GL}_{4}(\mathbb {A}_{\mathbb {Q}})\), and \(\pi _{\psi }\otimes \mathrm{sym}^2 \pi _{\varphi }\) of \(\text {GL}_{6}(\mathbb {A}_{\mathbb {Q}})\). For \(3 \le j \le 8\), estimates for \(|a_{\mathrm{sym}^j \pi _{\varphi }}(n)|\) on average over a short interval have also been established.     

Corona problem with data in ideal spaces of sequences

Let E be a Banach lattice on \({\mathbb {Z}}\) with order continuous norm. We show that for any function \(f = \{f_j\}_{j \in {\mathbb {Z}}}\) from the Hardy space \(\mathrm H_{\infty }\left( E \right) \) such that \(\delta \leqslant \Vert f (z)\Vert _E \leqslant 1\) for all z from the unit disk \({\mathbb {D}}\) there exists some solution \(g = \{g_j\}_{j \in {\mathbb {Z}}} \in \mathrm H_{\infty }\left( E' \right) \), \(\Vert g\Vert _{\mathrm H_{\infty }\left( E' \right) } \leqslant C_\delta \) of the Bézout equation \(\sum _j f_j g_j = 1\), also known as the vector-valued corona problem with data in \(\mathrm H_{\infty }\left( E \right) \).     

Couplings of Brownian Motions of Deterministic Distance in Model Spaces of Constant Curvature

We consider the model space \(\mathbb {M}^{n}_{K}\) of constant curvature K and dimension \(n\ge 1\) (Euclidean space for \(K=0\), sphere for \(K>0\) and hyperbolic space for \(K<0\)), and we show that given a function \(\rho :[0,\infty )\rightarrow [0, \infty )\) with \(\rho (0)=\mathrm {dist}(x,y)\) there exists a coadapted coupling (X(t), Y(t)) of Brownian motions on \(\mathbb {M}^{n}_{K}\) starting at (x, y) such that \(\rho (t)=\mathrm {dist}(X(t),Y(t))\) for every \(t\ge 0\) if and only if \(\rho \) is continuous and satisfies for almost every \(t\ge 0\) the differential inequality

$$\begin{aligned} -(n-1)\sqrt{K}\tan \left( \tfrac{\sqrt{K}\rho (t)}{2}\right) \le \rho '(t)\le -(n-1)\sqrt{K}\tan \left( \tfrac{\sqrt{K}\rho (t)}{2}\right) +\tfrac{2(n-1)\sqrt{K}}{\sin (\sqrt{K}\rho (t))}. \end{aligned}$$

In other words, we characterize all coadapted couplings of Brownian motions on the model space \(\mathbb {M}^{n}_{K}\) for which the distance between the processes is deterministic. In addition, the construction of the coupling is explicit for every choice of \(\rho \) satisfying the above hypotheses.

     

Idempotent and <Emphasis Type="Italic">p</Emphasis>-potent quadratic functions: distribution of nonlinearity and co-dimension

The Walsh transform \(\widehat{Q}\) of a quadratic function \(Q:{\mathbb F}_{p^n}\rightarrow {\mathbb F}_p\) satisfies \(|\widehat{Q}(b)| \in \{0,p^{\frac{n+s}{2}}\}\) for all \(b\in {\mathbb F}_{p^n}\), where \(0\le s\le n-1\) is an integer depending on Q. In this article, we study the following three classes of quadratic functions of wide interest. The class \(\mathcal {C}_1\) is defined for arbitrary n as \(\mathcal {C}_1 = \{Q(x) = \mathrm{Tr_n}(\sum _{i=1}^{\lfloor (n-1)/2\rfloor }a_ix^{2^i+1})\;:\; a_i \in {\mathbb F}_2\}\), and the larger class \(\mathcal {C}_2\) is defined for even n as \(\mathcal {C}_2 = \{Q(x) = \mathrm{Tr_n}(\sum _{i=1}^{(n/2)-1}a_ix^{2^i+1}) + \mathrm{Tr_{n/2}}(a_{n/2}x^{2^{n/2}+1}) \;:\; a_i \in {\mathbb F}_2\}\). For an odd prime p, the subclass \(\mathcal {D}\) of all p-ary quadratic functions is defined as \(\mathcal {D} = \{Q(x) = \mathrm{Tr_n}(\sum _{i=0}^{\lfloor n/2\rfloor }a_ix^{p^i+1})\;:\; a_i \in {\mathbb F}_p\}\). We determine the generating function for the distribution of the parameter s for \(\mathcal {C}_1, \mathcal {C}_2\) and \(\mathcal {D}\). As a consequence we completely describe the distribution of the nonlinearity for the rotation symmetric quadratic Boolean functions, and in the case \(p > 2\), the distribution of the co-dimension for the rotation symmetric quadratic p-ary functions, which have been attracting considerable attention recently. Our results also facilitate obtaining closed formulas for the number of such quadratic functions with prescribed s for small values of s, and hence extend earlier results on this topic. We also present the complete weight distribution of the subcodes of the second order Reed–Muller codes corresponding to \(\mathcal {C}_1\) and \(\mathcal {C}_2\) in terms of a generating function.     

Generic Vopěnka’s Principle,remarkable cardinals,and the weak Proper Forcing Axiom

We introduce and study the first-order Generic Vopěnka’s Principle, which states that for every definable proper class of structures \(\mathcal {C}\) of the same type, there exist \(B\ne A\) in \(\mathcal {C}\) such that B elementarily embeds into A in some set-forcing extension. We show that, for \(n\ge 1\), the Generic Vopěnka’s Principle fragment for \(\Pi _n\)-definable classes is equiconsistent with a proper class of n-remarkable cardinals. The n-remarkable cardinals hierarchy for \(n\in \omega \), which we introduce here, is a natural generic analogue for the \(C^{(n)}\)-extendible cardinals that Bagaria used to calibrate the strength of the first-order Vopěnka’s Principle in Bagaria (Arch Math Logic 51(3–4):213–240, 2012). Expanding on the theme of studying set theoretic properties which assert the existence of elementary embeddings in some set-forcing extension, we introduce and study the weak Proper Forcing Axiom, \(\mathrm{wPFA}\). The axiom \(\mathrm{wPFA}\) states that for every transitive model \(\mathcal M\) in the language of set theory with some \(\omega _1\)-many additional relations, if it is forced by a proper forcing \(\mathbb P\) that \(\mathcal M\) satisfies some \(\Sigma _1\)-property, then V has a transitive model \(\bar{\mathcal M}\), satisfying the same \(\Sigma _1\)-property, and in some set-forcing extension there is an elementary embedding from \(\bar{\mathcal M}\) into \(\mathcal M\). This is a weakening of a formulation of \(\mathrm{PFA}\) due to Claverie and Schindler (J Symb Logic 77(2):475–498, 2012), which asserts that the embedding from \(\bar{\mathcal M}\) to \(\mathcal M\) exists in V. We show that \(\mathrm{wPFA}\) is equiconsistent with a remarkable cardinal. Furthermore, the axiom \(\mathrm{wPFA}\) implies \(\mathrm{PFA}_{\aleph _2}\), the Proper Forcing Axiom for antichains of size at most \(\omega _2\), but it is consistent with \(\square _\kappa \) for all \(\kappa \ge \omega _2\), and therefore does not imply \(\mathrm{PFA}_{\aleph _3}\).     

Complete classification of pseudo <Emphasis Type="Italic">H</Emphasis>-type Lie algebras: I

Let \({\mathscr {N}}\) be a 2-step nilpotent Lie algebra endowed with a non-degenerate scalar product \(\langle .\,,.\rangle \), and let \({\mathscr {N}}=V\oplus _{\perp }Z\), where Z is the centre of the Lie algebra and V its orthogonal complement. We study classification of the Lie algebras for which the space V arises as a representation space of the Clifford algebra \({{\mathrm{{\mathrm{Cl}}}}}({\mathbb {R}}^{r,s})\), and the representation map \(J:{{\mathrm{{\mathrm{Cl}}}}}({\mathbb {R}}^{r,s})\rightarrow {{\mathrm{End}}}(V)\) is related to the Lie algebra structure by \(\langle J_zv,w\rangle =\langle z,[v,w]\rangle \) for all \(z\in {\mathbb {R}}^{r,s}\) and \(v,w\in V\). The classification depends on parameters r and s and is completed for the Clifford modules V having minimal possible dimension, that are not necessary irreducible. We find necessary conditions for the existence of a Lie algebra isomorphism according to the range of the integer parameters \(0\le r,s<\infty \). We present a constructive proof for the isomorphism maps for isomorphic Lie algebras and determine the class of non-isomorphic Lie algebras.     

Largest initial segments pointwise fixed by automorphisms of models of set theory

Given a model \(\mathcal {M}\) of set theory, and a nontrivial automorphism j of \(\mathcal {M}\), let \(\mathcal {I}_{\mathrm {fix}}(j)\) be the submodel of \(\mathcal {M}\) whose universe consists of elements m of \(\mathcal {M}\) such that \(j(x)=x\) for every x in the transitive closure of m (where the transitive closure of m is computed within \(\mathcal {M}\)). Here we study the class \(\mathcal {C}\) of structures of the form \(\mathcal {I}_{\mathrm {fix}}(j)\), where the ambient model \(\mathcal {M}\) satisfies a frugal yet robust fragment of \(\mathrm {ZFC}\) known as \(\mathrm {MOST}\), and \(j(m)=m\) whenever m is a finite ordinal in the sense of \(\mathcal {M}.\) Our main achievement is the calculation of the theory of \(\mathcal {C}\) as precisely \(\mathrm {MOST+\Delta }_{0}^{\mathcal {P}}\)-\(\mathrm {Collection}\). The following theorems encapsulate our principal results: Theorem A. Every structure in \(\mathcal {C}\) satisfies \(\mathrm {MOST+\Delta }_{0}^{\mathcal {P}}\)-\(\mathrm { Collection}\). Theorem B. Each of the following three conditions is sufficient for a countable structure \(\mathcal {N}\) to be in \(\mathcal {C}\):(a) \(\mathcal {N}\) is a transitive model of \(\mathrm {MOST+\Delta }_{0}^{\mathcal {P}}\)-\(\mathrm {Collection}\).(b) \(\mathcal {N}\) is a recursively saturated model of \(\mathrm {MOST+\Delta }_{0}^{\mathcal {P}}\)-\(\mathrm {Collection}\).(c) \(\mathcal {N}\) is a model of \(\mathrm {ZFC}\). Theorem C. Suppose \(\mathcal {M}\) is a countable recursively saturated model of \(\mathrm {ZFC}\) and I is a proper initial segment of \(\mathrm {Ord}^{\mathcal {M}}\) that is closed under exponentiation and contains \(\omega ^\mathcal {M}\) . There is a group embedding \(j\longmapsto \check{j}\) from \(\mathrm {Aut}(\mathbb {Q})\) into \(\mathrm {Aut}(\mathcal {M})\) such that I is the longest initial segment of \(\mathrm {Ord}^{\mathcal {M}}\) that is pointwise fixed by \(\check{j}\) for every nontrivial \(j\in \mathrm {Aut}(\mathbb {Q}).\) In Theorem C, \(\mathrm {Aut}(X)\) is the group of automorphisms of the structure X, and \(\mathbb {Q}\) is the ordered set of rationals.     

Quasi-classical generalized CRF structures

In an earlier paper, we studied manifolds M endowed with a generalized F structure \(\Phi \in \mathrm{End}(TM\oplus T^*M)\), skew-symmetric with respect to the pairing metric, such that \(\Phi ^3+\Phi =0\). Furthermore, if \(\Phi \) is integrable (in some well-defined sense), \(\Phi \) is a generalized CRF structure. In the present paper, we study quasi-classical generalized F and CRF structures, which may be seen as a generalization of the holomorphic Poisson structures (it is well known that the latter may also be defined via generalized geometry). The structures that we study are equivalent to a pair of tensor fields \((A\in \mathrm{End}(TM),\pi \in \wedge ^2TM)\), where \(A^3+A=0\) and some relations between A and \(\pi \) hold. We establish the integrability conditions in terms of \((A,\pi )\). They include the facts that A is a classical CRF structure, \(\pi \) is a Poisson bivector field and \(\mathrm{im}\,A\) is a (non)holonomic Poisson submanifold of \((M,\pi )\). We discuss the case where either \(\mathrm{ker}\,A\) or \(\mathrm{im}\,A\) is tangent to a foliation and, in particular, the case of almost contact manifolds. Finally, we show that the dual bundle of \(\mathrm{im}\,A\) inherits a Lie algebroid structure and we briefly discuss the Poisson cohomology of \(\pi \), including an associated spectral sequence and a Dolbeault type grading.     

On the density of images of the power maps in Lie groups

Let G be a connected Lie group. In this paper, we study the density of the images of individual power maps \(P_k:G\rightarrow G:g\mapsto g^k\). We give criteria for the density of \(P_k(G)\) in terms of regular elements, as well as Cartan subgroups. In fact, we prove that if \(\mathrm{Reg}(G)\) is the set of regular elements of G, then \(P_k(G)\cap \mathrm{Reg}(G)\) is closed in \(\mathrm{Reg}(G)\). On the other hand, the weak exponentiality of G turns out to be equivalent to the density of all the power maps \(P_k\). In linear Lie groups, weak exponentiality reduces to the density of \(P_2(G)\). We also prove that the density of the image of \(P_k\) for G implies the same for any connected full rank subgroup.     

On height isotopy classes of embeddings in the plane of a Morse function of a circle

Let \(\mathrm{SM}_{2n}(S^1,\mathbb {R})\) be a set of stable Morse functions of an oriented circle such that the number of singular points is \(2n\in \mathbb {N}\) and the order of singular values satisfies the particular condition. For an orthogonal projection \(\pi :\mathbb {R}^2\rightarrow \mathbb {R}\), let \({\tilde{f}}_0\) and \({\tilde{f}}_1:S^1\rightarrow \mathbb {R}^2\) be embedding lifts of f. If there is an ambient isotopy \(\tilde{\varphi }_t:\mathbb {R}^2\rightarrow \mathbb {R}^2\) \((t\in [0,1])\) such that \({\pi \circ \tilde{\varphi }}_t(y_1,y_2)=y_1\) and \(\tilde{\varphi }_1\circ {\tilde{f}}_0={\tilde{f}}_1\), we say that \({\tilde{f}}_0\) and \({\tilde{f}}_1\) are height isotopic. We define a function \(I:\mathrm{SM}_{2n}(S^1,\mathbb {R})\rightarrow \mathbb {N}\) as follows: I(f) is the number of height isotopy classes of embeddings such that each rotation number is one. In this paper, we determine the maximal value of the function I equals the n-th Baxter number and the minimal value equals \(2^{n-1}\).     

Finite 2-Geodesic Transitive Abelian Cayley Graphs

In this paper, we first give a classification of the family of 2-geodesic transitive abelian Cayley graphs. Let \(\Gamma \) be such a graph which is not 2-arc transitive. It is shown that one of the following holds: (1) \(\Gamma \cong \mathrm{K}_{m[b]}\) for some \(m\ge 3\) and \(b\ge 2\); (2) \(\Gamma \) is a normal Cayley graph of an elementary abelian group; (3) \(\Gamma \) is a cover of Cayley graph \(\Gamma _K\) of an abelian group T / K, where either \(\Gamma _K\) is complete arc transitive or \(\Gamma _K\) is 2-geodesic transitive of girth 3, and A / K acts primitively on \(V(\Gamma _K)\) of type Affine or Product Action. Second, we completely determine the family of 2-geodesic transitive circulants.     

Polynomially peripheral range-preserving maps between Banach algebras

Let A and B be two Banach function algebras and p a two variable polynomial \(p(z,w)=zw+az+bw+c\), (\(a,b,c\in {\mathbb {C}}\)). We characterize the general form of a surjection \(T: A \longrightarrow B\) which satisfies \(\mathrm{Ran}_\pi (p(Tf,Tg))\cap \mathrm{Ran}_\pi (p(f,g))\ne \emptyset , (f,g\in A\) and \(c\ne ab)\), where \(\mathrm{Ran}_\pi (f)\) is the peripheral range of f.     

Linear sets in the projective line over the endomorphism ring of a finite field

Let \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,E)\) be the projective line over the endomorphism ring \( E={{\mathrm{End}}}_q({\mathbb F}_{q^t})\) of the \({\mathbb F}_q\)-vector space \({\mathbb F}_{q^t}\). As is well known, there is a bijection \(\varPsi :{{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,E)\rightarrow {\mathcal G}_{2t,t,q}\) with the Grassmannian of the \((t-1)\)-subspaces in \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(2t-1,q)\). In this paper along with any \({\mathbb F}_q\)-linear set L of rank t in \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,q^t)\), determined by a \((t-1)\)-dimensional subspace \(T^\varPsi \) of \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(2t-1,q)\), a subset \(L_T\) of \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,E)\) is investigated. Some properties of linear sets are expressed in terms of the projective line over the ring E. In particular, the attention is focused on the relationship between \(L_T\) and the set \(L'_T\), corresponding via \(\varPsi \) to a collection of pairwise skew \((t-1)\)-dimensional subspaces, with \(T\in L'_T\), each of which determine L. This leads among other things to a characterization of the linear sets of pseudoregulus type. It is proved that a scattered linear set L related to \(T\in {{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,E)\) is of pseudoregulus type if and only if there exists a projectivity \(\varphi \) of \({{\mathrm{{PG}}}}(1,E)\) such that \(L_T^\varphi =L'_T\).     

On the Diophantine equation $$X^{2N}+2^{2\alpha }5^{2\beta }{p}^{2\gamma } = Z^5$$

We prove that for each prime p, positive integer \(\alpha \), and non-negative integers \(\beta \) and \(\gamma \), the Diophantine equation \(X^{2N} + 2^{2\alpha }5^{2\beta }{p}^{2\gamma } = Z^5\) has no solution with N, X, \(Z\in \mathbb {Z}^+\), \(N > 1\), and \(\gcd (X,Z) = 1\).     

Analytic sets and extension of holomorphic maps of positive codimension

Let D, \(D'\) be arbitrary domains in \({\mathbb C}^n\) and \({\mathbb C}^N\) respectively, \(1<n\le N\), both possibly unbounded and \(M \subseteq \partial D\), \(M'\subseteq \partial D'\) be open pieces of the boundaries. Suppose that \(\partial D\) is smooth real-analytic and minimal in an open neighborhood of \({\bar{M}}\) and \(\partial D'\) is smooth real-algebraic and minimal in an open neighborhood of \({\bar{M}'}\). Let \(f: D\rightarrow D'\) be a holomorphic mapping such that the cluster set \(\mathrm{cl}_{f}(M)\) does not intersect \(D'\). It is proved that if the cluster set \(\mathrm{cl}_{f}(p)\) of some point \(p\in M\) contains some point \(q\in M'\) and the graph of f extends as an analytic set to a neighborhood of \((p, q)\in {\mathbb {C}}^n \times {\mathbb C}^N\), then f extends as a holomorphic map to a dense subset of some neighborhood of p. If in addition, \(M =\partial D\), \(M'=\partial D'\) and \(M'\) is compact, then f extends holomorphically across an open dense subset of \(\partial D\).     

Comparison of graphs associated to a commutative Artinian ring

Let R be a commutative ring with \(1\ne 0\) and the additive group \(R^+\). Several graphs on R have been introduced by many authors, among zero-divisor graph \(\Gamma _1(R)\), co-maximal graph \(\Gamma _2(R)\), annihilator graph AG(R), total graph \( T(\Gamma (R))\), cozero-divisors graph \(\Gamma _\mathrm{c}(R)\), equivalence classes graph \(\Gamma _\mathrm{E}(R)\) and the Cayley graph \(\mathrm{Cay}(R^+ ,Z^*(R))\). Shekarriz et al. (J. Commun. Algebra, 40 (2012) 2798–2807) gave some conditions under which total graph is isomorphic to \(\mathrm{Cay}(R^+ ,Z^*(R))\). Badawi (J. Commun. Algebra, 42 (2014) 108–121) showed that when R is a reduced ring, the annihilator graph is identical to the zero-divisor graph if and only if R has exactly two minimal prime ideals. The purpose of this paper is comparison of graphs associated to a commutative Artinian ring. Among the results, we prove that for a commutative finite ring R with \(|\mathrm{Max}(R)|=n \ge 3\), \( \Gamma _1(R) \simeq \Gamma _2(R)\) if and only if \(R\simeq \mathbb {Z}^n_2\); if and only if \(\Gamma _1(R) \simeq \Gamma _\mathrm{E}(R)\). Also the annihilator graph is identical to the cozero-divisor graph if and only if R is a Frobenius ring.