A characterization of the folk rule for multi-source minimal cost spanning tree problems

In this paper we provide an axiomatic characterization of the folk rule for minimum cost spanning tree problems with multiple sources. The properties we need are: cone-wise additivity, cost monotonicity, symmetry, isolated agents, and equal treatment of source costs.     

“Optimistic” weighted Shapley rules in minimum cost spanning tree problems

We introduce optimistic weighted Shapley rules in minimum cost spanning tree problems. We define them as the weighted Shapley values of the optimistic game v⁺ introduced in Bergantiños and Vidal-Puga [Bergantiños, G., Vidal-Puga, J.J., forthcoming. The optimistic TU game in minimum cost spanning tree problems. International Journal of Game Theory. Available from: <http://webs.uvigo.es/gbergant/papers/cstShapley.pdf>]. We prove that they are obligation rules [Tijs, S., Branzei, R., Moretti, S., Norde, H., 2006. Obligation rules for minimum cost spanning tree situations and their monotonicity properties. European Journal of Operational Research 175, 121–134].     

Realizing fair outcomes in minimum cost spanning tree problems through non-cooperative mechanisms

In the context of minimum cost spanning tree problems, we present a bargaining mechanism for connecting all agents to the source and dividing the cost among them. The basic idea is very simple: we ask each agent the part of the cost he is willing to pay for an arc to be constructed. We prove that there exists a unique payoff allocation associated with the subgame perfect Nash equilibria of this bargaining mechanism. Moreover, this payoff allocation coincides with the rule defined in Bergantiños and Vidal-Puga [Bergantiños, G., Vidal-Puga, J.J., 2007a. A fair rule in minimum cost spanning tree problems. Journal of Economic Theory 137, 326–352].     

A characterization of Kruskal sharing rules for minimum cost spanning tree problems

In Tijs et al. (Eur J Oper Res 175:121–134, 2006) a new family of cost allocation rules is introduced in the context of cost spanning tree problems. In this paper we provide the first characterization of this family by means of population monotonicity and a property of additivity.     

A generalization of obligation rules for minimum cost spanning tree problems

Tijs et al. [23] introduce the family of obligation rules for minimum cost spanning tree problems. We give a generalization of such family. We prove that our family coincides with the set of rules satisfying an additivity property and a cost monotonicity property. We also provide two new characterizations for the family of obligation rules using the previous properties. In the first one, we add a property of separability; and in the second one, we add core selection.     

最小费用k度限制树对策

本在Glover—Klingman算法及最小费用支撑树对策的基础上，讨论了最小费用k度限制树对策问题．利用威胁、旁支付理论制订了两种规则，并利用优超、策略等价理论分别给出了在这两种规则下最小费用k度限制树对策核心中的解，从而证明了在这两种规则下其核心非空．     

A GRASP algorithm for the multi-criteria minimum spanning tree problem

This paper proposes a GRASP (Greedy Randomized Adaptive Search Procedure) algorithm for the multi-criteria minimum spanning tree problem, which is NP-hard. In this problem a vector of costs is defined for each edge of the graph and the problem is to find all Pareto optimal or efficient spanning trees (solutions). The algorithm is based on the optimization of different weighted utility functions. In each iteration, a weight vector is defined and a solution is built using a greedy randomized constructive procedure. The found solution is submitted to a local search trying to improve the value of the weighted utility function. We use a drop-and-add neighborhood where the spanning trees are represented by Prufer numbers. In order to find a variety of efficient solutions, we use different weight vectors, which are distributed uniformly on the Pareto frontier. The proposed algorithm is tested on problems with r=2 and 3 criteria. For non-complete graphs with n=10, 20 and 30 nodes, the performance of the algorithm is tested against a complete enumeration. For complete graphs with n=20, 30 and 50 nodes the performance of the algorithm is tested using two types of weighted utility functions. The algorithm is also compared with the multi-criteria version of the Kruskal’s algorithm, which generates supported efficient solutions. This work was funded by the Municipal Town Hall of Campos dos Goytacazes city. The used computer was acquired with resource of CNPq.     

Truth-telling and Nash equilibria in minimum cost spanning tree models

In this paper we consider the minimum cost spanning tree model. We assume that a central planner aims at implementing a minimum cost spanning tree not knowing the true link costs. The central planner sets up a game where agents announce link costs, a tree is chosen and costs are allocated according to the rules of the game. We characterize ways of allocating costs such that true announcements constitute Nash equilibria both in case of full and incomplete information. In particular, we find that the Shapley rule based on the irreducible cost matrix is consistent with truthful announcements while a series of other well-known rules (such as the Bird-rule, Serial Equal Split, and the Proportional rule) are not.     

The optimistic <Emphasis Type="Italic">TU</Emphasis> game in minimum cost spanning tree problems

We associate an optimistic TU game with each minimum cost spanning tree problem. We define the worth of a coalition S as the cost of connecting agents in S to the source assuming that agents in N\S are already connected to the source, and agents in S can connect through agents in N\S. We study the Shapley value of this new game. We thank Hervé Moulin, William Thomson, and two referees for helpful comments. Financial support from the Ministerio de Ciencia y Tecnologia and FEDER through grant SEJ2005-07637-c02-01 is gratefully acknowledged.     

On the prize-collecting generalized minimum spanning tree problem

The prize-collecting generalized minimum spanning tree problem (PC-GMSTP), is a generalization of the generalized minimum spanning tree problem (GMSTP) and belongs to the hard core of -hard problems. We describe an exact exponential time algorithm for the problem, as well we present several mixed integer and integer programming formulations of the PC-GMSTP. Moreover, we establish relationships between the polytopes corresponding to their linear relaxations and present an efficient solution procedure that finds the optimal solution of the PC-GMSTP for graphs with up 240 nodes.     

The irreducible Core of a minimum cost spanning tree game

It is a known result that for a minimum cost spanning tree (mcst) game a Core allocation can be deduced directly from a mcst in the underlying network. To determine this Core allocation one only needs to determine a mcst in the network and it is not necessary to calculate the coalition values of the corresponding mcst game. In this paper we will deduce other Core allocations directly from the network, without determining the corresponding mcst game itself: we use an idea of Bird (cf. [4]) to present two procedures that determine a part of the Core (called the Irreducible Core) from the network.     

The complexity of a minimum reload cost diameter problem

We consider the minimum diameter spanning tree problem under the reload cost model which has been introduced by Wirth and Steffan [H.-C. Wirth, J. Steffan, Reload cost problems: Minimum diameter spanning tree, Discrete Appl. Math. 113 (2001) 73-85]. In this model an undirected edge-coloured graph G is given, together with a nonnegative symmetrical integer matrix R specifying the costs of changing from a colour to another one. The reload cost of a path in G arises at its internal nodes, when passing from the colour of one incident edge to the colour of the other. We prove that, unless P=NP, the problem of finding a spanning tree of G having a minimum diameter with respect to reload costs, when restricted to graphs with maximum degree 4, cannot be approximated within any constant α<2 if the reload costs are unrestricted, and cannot be approximated within any constant β<5/3 if the reload costs satisfy the triangle inequality. This solves a problem left open by Wirth and Steffan [H.-C. Wirth, J. Steffan, Reload cost problems: minimum diameter spanning tree, Discrete Appl. Math. 113 (2001) 73-85].     

Interactive decision making for uncertain minimum spanning tree problems with total importance based on a risk-management approach

This paper deals with a minimum spanning tree problem where each edge cost includes uncertainty and importance measure. In risk management to avoid adverse impacts derived from uncertainty, a d-confidence interval for the total cost derived from robustness is introduced. Then, by maximizing the considerable region as well as minimizing the cost-importance ratio, a biobjective minimum spanning tree problem is proposed. Furthermore, in order to satisfy the objects of the decision maker and to solve the proposed model in mathematical programming, fuzzy goals for the objects are introduced as satisfaction functions, and an exact solution algorithm is developed using interactive decision making and deterministic equivalent transformations. Numerical examples are provided to compare our proposed model with some previous models.     

On the core of cost-revenue games: Minimum cost spanning tree games with revenues

In this paper, we analyze cost sharing problems arising from a general service by explicitly taking into account the generated revenues. To this cost-revenue sharing problem, we associate a cooperative game with transferable utility, called cost-revenue game. By considering cooperation among the agents using the general service, the value of a coalition is defined as the maximum net revenues that the coalition may obtain by means of cooperation. As a result, a coalition may profit from not allowing all its members to get the service that generates the revenues. We focus on the study of the core of cost-revenue games. Under the assumption that cooperation among the members of the grand coalition grants the use of the service under consideration to all its members, it is shown that a cost-revenue game has a nonempty core for any vector of revenues if, and only if, the dual game of the cost game has a large core. Using this result, we investigate minimum cost spanning tree games with revenues. We show that if every connection cost can take only two values (low or high cost), then, the corresponding minimum cost spanning tree game with revenues has a nonempty core. Furthermore, we provide an example of a minimum cost spanning tree game with revenues with an empty core where every connection cost can take only one of three values (low, medium, or high cost).     

The minimum spanning strong subdigraph problem is fixed parameter tractable

A digraph D is strong if it contains a directed path from x to y for every choice of vertices x,y in D. We consider the problem (MSSS) of finding the minimum number of arcs in a spanning strong subdigraph of a strong digraph. It is easy to see that every strong digraph D on n vertices contains a spanning strong subdigraph on at most 2n−2 arcs. By reformulating the MSSS problem into the equivalent problem of finding the largest positive integer k≤n−2 so that D contains a spanning strong subdigraph with at most 2n−2−k arcs, we obtain a problem which we prove is fixed parameter tractable. Namely, we prove that there exists an O(f(k)n^c) algorithm for deciding whether a given strong digraph D on n vertices contains a spanning strong subdigraph with at most 2n−2−k arcs.We furthermore prove that if k≥1 and D has no cut vertex then it has a kernel of order at most (2k−1)². We finally discuss related problems and conjectures.     

Choquet-based optimisation in multiobjective shortest path and spanning tree problems

This paper is devoted to the search of Choquet-optimal solutions in finite graph problems with multiple objectives. The Choquet integral is one of the most sophisticated preference models used in decision theory for aggregating preferences on multiple objectives. We first present a condition on preferences (name hereafter preference for interior points) that characterizes preferences favouring compromise solutions, a natural attitude in various contexts such as multicriteria optimisation, robust optimisation and optimisation with multiple agents. Within Choquet expected utility theory, this condition amounts to using a submodular capacity and a convex utility function. Under these assumptions, we focus on the fast determination of Choquet-optimal paths and spanning trees. After investigating the complexity of these problems, we introduce a lower bound for the Choquet integral, computable in polynomial time. Then, we propose different algorithms using this bound, either based on a controlled enumeration of solutions (ranking approach) or an implicit enumeration scheme (branch and bound). Finally, we provide numerical experiments that show the actual efficiency of the algorithms on multiple instances of different sizes.