HORSE HEART CYTOCHROME c AS AN ELECTRON ACCEPTOR FROM CHLOROPHYLL TRIPLET IN NEGATIVELY CHARGED LIPID BILAYER VESICLES*

Abstract— Cytochrome c has been shown to bind via electrostatic interactions to egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles which contain 5–30 mol percent of negatively-charged surfactant (dihexadecylphosphate) in a low ionic strength medium. Under these conditions the oxidized cytochrome can function as a direct one-electron acceptor from membrane-bound triplet state chlorophyll to produce chlorophyll cation radical and reduced cytochrome. Kinetic experiments using laser flash photolysis have demonstrated that triplet quenching and the yield of electron transfer products increase, and product lifetime decreases, with an increase in the magnitude of the negative charge on the vesicles, and with a decrease in the ionic strength of the medium. Both triplet quenching and product formation rates and yields showed saturation behavior as the cytochrome concentration was increased, and reached limiting values at 20–30 μM cytochrome when the vesicle contained 20 mol percent of the negatively-charged surfactant. This behavior is interpreted in terms of saturation of the vesicle surface binding sites. Under optimum conditions in this system, approximately 20% of the chlorophyll triplet molecules could be converted to electron transfer products which had a halftime for the reverse reaction of approximately 1.5 ms.     

SPINACH PLASTOCYANIN AS AN ELECTRON ACCEPTOR FROM MEMBRANE-BOUND CHLOROPHYLL TRIPLET STATE IN POSITIVELY CHARGED LIPID BILAYER VESICLES*

Spinach plastocyanin is bound to egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles containing 5–25 mole percent dioctadecyldimethylammonium chloride (DODAC) via electrostatic interactions in a 50 mM betaine medium (pH=6.5). This was demonstrated by both gel filtration experiments and kinetic results using laser flash photolysis. Under those conditions, oxidized plastocyanin can function as a direct electron acceptor from membrane-bound triplet chlorophyll to produce chlorophyll cation radical and reduced plastocyanin. The fraction of chlorophyll triplet which is quenched by oxidized plastocyanin increases, and the yield of electron transfer products also increases, with an increase in the magnitude of the positive charge on the vesicles. Product decay and rise halftimes decrease with an increase in the mole percent of DODAC⁺ incorporated into egg phosphatidylcholine vesicles. However, both of these halftimes are independent of oxidized plastocyanin concentration. Even though ～50% of the Chi triplets were quenched, no electron transfer product formation was observed in 5 mM phosphate buffer (pH=7.0). Under similar conditions in betaine, approximately 13% of the Chi triplets could be converted into products.     

QUINONES AS MEDIATORS OF ELECTRON TRANSFER FROM MEMBRANE-BOUND CHLOROPHYLL TO CYTOCHROME c IN THE AQUEOUS PHASE IN LIPID BILAYER VESICLES: SYNERGISTIC ENHANCEMENT OF CYTOCHROME c REDUCTION BY LIPOPHILIC/ HYDROPHILIC QUINONE PAIRS

Laser flash photolysis has been used to determine the kinetics of cytochrome c reduction by chlorophyll triplet state in negatively-charged lipid bilayer vesicles, as mediated by quinones. Large synergistic enhancements in the yield of reduced cytochrome were obtained using a pair of quinones, one of which was lipophilic (e.g. benzoquinone, 2,6-di-f-butylbenzoquinone) and the other of which was hydrophilic (e.g. l,2-naphthoquinone-4-sulfonate). The mechanism was shown to involve initial quenching of the triplet by the membrane-associated quinone to form chlorophyll cation radical and quinone anion radical. An interquinone electron transfer process followed this reaction, which occurred at the membrane-water interface, and greatly facilitated electron transport from within the bilayer to the aqueous phase. This process formed the basis of the synergistic effect. Cytochrome c reduction occurred in the water phase by reaction with the anion radical of the hydrophilic quinone. Finally, the reduced cytochrome was reoxidized by a slow reaction with chlorophyll cation radical. Under the most favorable conditions, we estimate that the quantum yield of conversion of triplet quenching events to reduction of cytochrome approached unity. The lifetime of the reduced protein and oxidized chlorophyll could be as long as 140 ms, under the best conditions. This system has properties which are thus quite favorable for solar energy conversion in a biomimetic process.     

ZERO FIELD OPTICAL DETECTION OF MAGNETIC RESONANCE OF TRIPLET STATE OF CHLOROPHYLL a IN LIPID BILAYER VESICLES

Abstract The zero-field ODMR of triplet state of chlorophyll a incorporated in phosphatidylcholine (PC) vesicles (Chi a : PC = 1:100) has been carried out. The zero-field ODMR frequencies and intersystem crossing rate constants have been measured at various fluorescence wavelengths. The ODMR data suggest that the chlorophyll is present in mono- and biligated species. The nature of the ligand and the role of the medium (phospholipid) are also discussed.     

CHLOROPHYLL PHOTOSENSITIZED ELECTRON TRANSFER REACTIONS IN LIPID BILAYER VESICLES: VECTORIAL ELECTRON TRANSFER ACROSS THE BILAYER FROM REDUCED CYTOCHROME c IN THE INNER COMPARTMENT TO OXIDIZED FERREDOXIN IN THE OUTER COMPARTMENT

A negatively charged large unilamellar vesicle system containing a membrane-bound photo-sensitizer (chlorophyll, Chi), a reduced redox protein [cytochrome c, cyt c(red)] in the inner aqueous compartment, an oxidized redox protein [ferredoxin, Fd(ox)] in the outer aqueous compartment, and propylene diquat (PDQ²⁺) as a mediator, was investigated using both flash and steady-state photolysis techniques. The results demonstrate that the light-generated triplet state of Chi (³Chl) was initially quenched by PDQ²⁺ at the outer membrane surface to form Chi cation radical (Chl⁺) and the reduced diquat (PDQ⁺). This was succeeded by a biphasic recombination between Chi⁺ and PDQ⁺. The slow phase of the recombination process, which represents reverse electron transfer between Chl⁺ and those PDQ⁺ molecules which escaped from the membrane surface, could be suppressed effectively both by the reduction of Chl^ in the inner monolayer of the vesicles by cyt c(red), and by the reoxidation of PDQ⁺ by Fd(ox) in the outer aqueous compartment. These reactions lead to the permanent accumulation of oxidized and reduced product proteins, i.e. cyt c(ox) in the inner compartment and Fd(red) in the outer compartment. The yields of such accumulation were 11%, based on the ³Chl quenched, and 1.4%, based on absorbed quanta, under the conditions used in the present study. This system mimics one of the key events in natural photosynthesis and results in an appreciable storage of electromagnetic energy in the reaction products.     

CHLOROPHYLL PHOTOSENSITIZED ELECTRON TRANSFER REACTIONS IN LIPID VESICLES:ENHANCEMENT IN YIELD OF VECTORIAL ELECTRON TRANSFER ACROSS THE BILAYER FROM REDUCED CYTOCHROME c TO OXIDIZED FERREDOXIN BY ADDITION OF VALINOMYCIN PLUS POTASSIUM ION

Chlorophyll photosensitized electron transfer across a vesicle bilayer from reduced cytochrome c in the inner compartment to oxidized ferredoxin in the outer compartment, using propylene diquat as a mediator, has been investigated using both steady-state and laser flash photolysis methods. One of the factors limiting the quantum yield is the transmembrane potential, which is formed during sample preparation and is increased by the electron transfer process across the membrane bilayer. This limitation can be diminished by the incorporation of valinomycin into the bilayer in the presence of potassium ion. The overall quantum yield can be approximately doubled (up to a total of 22% based on the chlorophyll triplet which is quenched, and 2.8% based on the absorbed quanta) by valinomycin addition. Another quantum yield limitation arises from the accumulation of oxidized cytochrome c in the inner aqueous compartment, which is formed as a consequence of the transbilayer electron transport process and can quench triplet chlorophyll on the inner side of the vesicle. The chlorophyll cation radical generated in this way can participate in the electron exchange equilibrium between chlorophyll molecules located within the bilayer, and thus inhibit electron flow from inside to outside. This acts to limit the extent of cytochrome c oxidation to less than or equal to 50% of the original amount.     

VECTORIAL ELECTRON TRANSPORT ACROSS LIPID VESICLE MEMBRANES DRIVE BY TWO PHOTOREACTIONS. II. PHOTOCHEMICAL REGENERATION OF REDUCED CYTOCHROME c BY FLAVIN TRIPLET STATE AND ETHYLENEDIAMINETETRAACETIC ACID IN THE INNER COMPARTMENT AND REDUCTION OF FERREDOXIN BY CHLOROPHYLL TRIPLET STATE IN THE OUTER COMPARTMENT

We have attempted to mimic natural photosynthesis with regard to the photogeneration of a powerful reductant, using a negatively charged lipid bilayer vesicle system incorporating two photoreactions sensitized by a flavin analog (flavin mononucleotide [FMN]) and chlorophyll (chl) in their respective triplet states. Ethylenediamine-tetraacetic acid (EDTA) in the inner aqueous compartment was used as a sacrificial electron donor to the FMN triplet, and ferredoxin in the outer aqueous compartment served as the final electron acceptor (mediated via triplet electron transfer chain in this multicomponent system to be elucidated. By itself, EDTA does not function as an effective donor to membran-bound oxidized chl (chl^+.), which is formed by electron transfer from triplet chl to the viologen follwed by transbilayer electron migration. This is a consequence of electrostatic repulsive interactions with the negatively charged membrane. This limitation is avoided when FMN is used as a photomediator between EDTA and chl^+.. The overall reaction is dramatically increased in rate by enclosing cytochrom c together with EDTA and FMN in the inner compartment. The rate constant of the key step in the reaction, i.e. elctron transfer from reduced cytochrome c, generated via photoreduction by the FMN/EDTA system, to chl^+. is increased 20-fold over that obtained with cytochrome c alone as the elctron donor. One of the important constraints that limited the net electron transfer across the bilayer to 50% of the added cytochrome, i.e. inhibition by oxidized cytochrome c formed in the inner compartment, is avoided by the inclusion of the second photoreaction in this system, thus allowing photoreduction of all of the added ferredoxin to be achieved. This system provides a model for a photochemical energy storage process that utilizes two photorections operating in series resulting in electron flow across a lipid bilayer membrane.     

VECTORIAL ELECTRON TRANSPORT ACROSS LIPID VESICLE MEMBRANES DRIVEN BY TWO PHOTOREACTIONS. I. ETHYLENEDIAMINETETRAACETIC ACID AS AN ELECTRON DONOR via FLAVIN TRIPLET STATE IN THE INNER COMPARTMENT AND CYTOCHROME c AS AN ELECTRON ACCEPTOR FROM CHLOROPHYLL TRIPLET STATE IN THE OUTER COMPARTMENT

Negatively charged vesicle suspensions containing chlorophyll a (chl) dissolved in the lipid bilayer, flavin mononucleotide (FMN) and/or ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) enclosed in the inner compartment as electron sources and oxidized cytochrome c (cyt c[ox]) in the outer compartment as an electron acceptor have been studied using laser flash photolysis and steady-state irradiation methods. Cytochrome c initially quenches the chl triplet state (³chl) generating the chlorophyll cation radical (chi⁺′) in the membrane. Reverse electron transfer from cyt c(red) to chl^+. subsequently occurs in a kinetically biphasic reaction, with rate constants of 430 pT 30 and 21.9 pT 1.7 s^?1 for the fast and slow phases, respectively. In the absence of FMN, reduction of chl⁺′ by EDTA in the inner compartment can be observed during steady-state irradiation but not in a laser flash photolysis experiment. This is due to a low reaction yield, which is probably limited by the repulsive electrostatic interaction between EDTA and the negatively charged membrane. When FMN was enclosed together with EDTA in the inner Compartment, the reaction yield of vectorial electron transfer across the bilayer from EDTA to cyt c(oX) was increased by a factor of six during steadystate white light irradiation. Laser flash photolysis and steady-state irradiation experiments using red and blue light excitation have demonstrated that the enhancement mechanism involves the formation of fully reduced FMN by blue light-sensitized photooxidation of EDTA via the flavin triplet state, occumng simultaneously with red lightsensitized electron transfer to cyt c via the chlorophyll triplet state.     

ELECTRON TRANSFER REACTIONS OCCURRING UPON LASER FLASH PHOTOLYSIS OF PHOSPHOLIPID BILAYER SYSTEMS CONTAINING CHLOROPHYLL,BENZOQUINONE AND CYTOCHROME c-I. NEGATIVELY-CHARGED VESICLES*

Abstract— In negatively-charged lipid bilayer vesicles prepared in deionized water from egg phosphatidylcholine and 25 mol % of α-eleostearic acid, and containing chlorophyll a, benzoquinone, and cytochrome c, primary electron transfer after a laser flash occurred principally from chlorophyll triplet to benzoquinone, and to a smaller extent from chlorophyll triplet to oxidized cytochrome c. Several secondary electron transfer reactions occurred subsequent to this. The most rapid of these was electron transfer from reduced cytochrome c, which was bound to the outer surface of the negatively-charged vesicle, to chlorophyll cation radical (k= 3.9 times 10³ s^-1). Subsequent to this, the cation radical was reduced by benzoquinone anion radical (k= 1.6 times 10² s^-1>) and bound oxidized cytochrome c was reduced by the remaining anion radical which was expelled into the aqueous phase by the negative charge on the vesicle surface. This latter reaction occurred at the membrane-solution interface with an observed rate constant (k= 60 s^-1) two orders of magnitude smaller than cytochrome oxidation. Net reduced cytochrome c was produced in this process. The reduced cytochrome c was slowly reoxidized by benzoquinone (k= 17 s^-1) and the system was returned to its original state. When the vesicle system was made slightly basic by adding tris(hydroxymethyl)aminomethane, the rates of both the reverse electron transfer between chlorophyll cation radical and benzoquinone anion radical (k= 5 times 10² s^-1) and the oxidation of reduced cytochrome c by chlorophyll cation radical (k= 9.4 times 10³ s^-1) were accelerated. The rate of reduction of oxidized cytochrome c by benzoquinone anion radical remained approximately the same.     

CHLOROPHYLL PHOTOSENSITIZED ELECTRON TRANSFER REACTIONS IN LIPID BILAYER VESICLES: GENERATION OF PROTON GRADIENTS ACROSS THE BILAYER COUPLED TO QUINONE REDUCTION AND HYDROQUINONE OXIDATION

Abstract— A chlorophyll-containing small unilamellar lipid bilayer vesicle system with a sulfonated quinone molecule (MQS) in one aqueous compartment and a sulfonated hydroquinone molecule (H₂QS) in the other has been investigated, using laser flash photolysis and steady-state irradiation, as a means of storing light energy in the form of a proton gradient across the lipid bilayer. Under optimal conditions, an efficiency of 39% based on the chlorophyll triplet state quenched has been achieved for vectorial electron transfer across the bilayer; this corresponds to a quantum yield of 23% based on absorbed photons. As a consequence of irradiation by a single laser flash, 0.2 μ M of protons were taken up by quinone reduction (MQS → H₂MQS) in the outer compartment. The same number of protons were released in the inner compartment by hydroquinone oxidation (H₂QS → QS). Since the volume occupied by the vesicles was only 1/1000 of the total volume of the sample, the local concentration of protons in the inner compartment was 1000 times larger ( i.e. ≅ 200 μ M ), resulting in the generation of an appreciable proton gradient across the bilayer.     

ELECTRON TRANSFER REACTIONS OCCURRING UPON LASER FLASH PHOTOLYSIS OF PHOSPHOLIPID BILAYER SYSTEMS CONTAINING CHLOROPHYLL,BENZOQUINONE AND CYTOCHROME c-II. ELECTRICALLY NEUTRAL AND POSITIVELY-CHARGED VESICLES*

Abstract— The primary and secondary electron transfer reactions which occurred upon laser flash photolysis of electrically neutral and positively-charged lipid bilayer vesicles containing chlorophyll, benzoquinone and cytochrome c were determined by time-resolved difference spectral and kinetic measurements, and compared with previous results obtained with negatively-charged vesicles (Y. Fang and G. Tollin, Photochem. Photobiol. 1988). The extent to which oxidized cytochrome c could function as an electron acceptor from triplet state chlorophyll, and reduced cytochrome c could act as an electron donor to chlorophyll cation radical, decreased from negatively-charged to electrically neutral to positively-charged vesicles, in agreement with expectations based on changes in the ability of cytochrome c to bind to the bilayer. In all three types of vesicles, cytochrome c reduction by benzoquinone anion radical occurred in the aqueous phase.     

CHLOROPHYLL PHOTOSENSITIZED ELECTRON TRANSFER IN PHOSPHOLIPID BILAYER VESICLE SYSTEMS: SECONDARY OXIDATION OF REDUCED VIOLOGEN ACCEPTORS BY Ru(NH3)63+

Abstract— The kinetics of the oxidation of a homologous series of 4,4'-di(n-alkyl)-bipyridinium (viologen) radicals by Ru(NH₃)₆³⁺ in vesicle suspensions was studied using laser flash photolysis. The viologen radicals were produced photochemically in the bilayer membrane phase of the vesicles by electron transfer from the triplet state of chlorophyll-α. At high concentrations of Ru(NH₃)₆³⁺, the rate of oxidation of the viologen radicals in the aqueous phase was limited by the rate at which the radicals diffused from the membrane to the aqueous phase. The exit rate constant decreased from 2 × 10⁵ s⁻¹ for the methyl viologen radical to 4 × 10³ s⁻¹ for the pentyl viologen radical. Both the exit rate constants and the calculated values for the equilibrium association constants of the viologen radicals were unexpectedly insensitive to the length of their alkyl substituents. This, as well as other data, suggests that the radicals that diffused into the aqueous phase tended to remain associated with the membrane-water interface.