Best cooperative partner selection and input resource reallocation using DEA

Reallocation of input resources (RIR) is a process by which certain decision making units (DMUs) reallocate resources among themselves; a process that occurs frequently in many enterprises. In this paper, a new data envelopment analysis (DEA) approach is developed to select the best cooperative partner DMU. Context-dependent DEA is used to identify the different levels of best-practice frontiers. Two DEA-based models are established for two cooperative scenarios, namely, resources pooling only and best-practice sharing. A cooperative method is applied to determine how to reallocate the input resources, and Shapley value is used to estimate the revenue changes that the various DMUs should expect after RIR. Two different situations with different objectives are considered. One objective is to maximize total revenue for the partnership, while the other is to maximize the Shapley value. The proposed approaches are illustrated with two examples.     

On centralized resource utilization and its reallocation by using DEA

The standard DEA model allows different DMU units to set their own priorities for the inputs and outputs that form part of the efficiency assessment. In the case of a centralized organization with many outlets, such as an education authority that is responsible for many schools, it may be more sensible to operate in the most efficient way, but under a common set of priorities for all DMUs. The algorithm that is used to do this, the centralized resource allocation model, does just this. We show that the centralized resource allocation model can be substantially simplified and we interpret the simplifications and show how the model works using real data of Spanish public schools. Apart from finding the best way to reallocate resource among the schools, it is shown that the most desirable operating unit is found to be a by-product of the estimation. This is useful information when planning new schools.     

Network DEA efficiency in input–output models: With an application to OECD countries

We undertake network efficiency analysis within an input–output model that allows us to assess potential technical efficiency gains by comparing technologies corresponding to different economies. Input–output tables represent a network where different sectoral nodes use primary inputs (endowments) to produce intermediate input and outputs (according to sectoral technologies), and satisfy final demand (preferences). Within the input–output framework it is possible to optimize primary inputs allocation, intermediate production and final demand production by way of non-parametric data envelopment analysis (DEA) techniques. DEA allows us to model the different subtechnologies corresponding to alternative production processes, to assess efficient resource allocation among them, and to determine potential output gains if inefficiencies were dealt with. The proposed model optimizes the underlying multi-stage technologies that the input–output system comprises identifying the best practice economies. The model is applied to a set of OECD countries.     

Extended utility and DEA models without explicit input

In this paper, we discuss the relationship between multi-attribute utility theory and data envelopment analysis (DEA) models without explicit inputs (DEA-WEI), including dual models and some theoretical analysis of DEA-WEI models. We then propose generic DEA-WEI models with quadratic utility terms. Finally, we provide illustrative examples to show that DEA-WEI with suitable quadratic utility terms are able to reflect some value judgments that the standard DEA models cannot.     

A new chance-constrained DEA model with birandom input and output data

The purpose of conventional Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is to evaluate the performance of a set of firms or Decision-Making Units using deterministic input and output data. However, the input and output data in the real-life performance evaluation problems are often stochastic. The stochastic input and output data in DEA can be represented with random variables. Several methods have been proposed to deal with the random input and output data in DEA. In this paper, we propose a new chance-constrained DEA model with birandom input and output data. A super-efficiency model with birandom constraints is formulated and a non-linear deterministic equivalent model is obtained to solve the super-efficiency model. The non-linear model is converted into a model with quadratic constraints to solve the non-linear deterministic model. Furthermore, a sensitivity analysis is performed to assess the robustness of the proposed super-efficiency model. Finally, two numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the applicability of the proposed chance-constrained DEA model and sensitivity analysis.     

DEA production games with fuzzy output prices

In DEA production models the technology is assumed to be implicit in the input-output data given by a set of recorded observations. DEA production games assess the benefits to different firms of pooling their resources and sharing their technology. The crisp version of this type of problems has been studied in the literature and methods to obtain stable solutions have been proposed. However, no solution approach exists when there is uncertainty in the unit output prices, a situation that can clearly occur in practice. This paper extends DEA production games to the case of fuzzy unit output prices. In that scenario the total revenue is uncertain and therefore the corresponding allocation among the players is also necessarily uncertain. A core-like solution concept is introduced for these fuzzy games, the Preference Least Core. The computational burden of obtaining allocations of the fuzzy total profit reached through cooperation that belong to the preference least core is high. However, the results presented in the paper permit us to compute the fuzzy total revenue obtained by the grand coalition and a fuzzy allocation in the preference least core by solving a single linear programming model. The application of the proposed approach is illustrated with the analysis of two cooperative production situations originated by data sets from the literature.     

The input to and output from risk evaluation models

The work which has been done on analytic approaches to the evaluation of the risk in major capital investment opportunities suggests the following hypotheses: (a) The distributions of NPV and IRR which are output from risk evaluation models are often approximately normal. (b) The only important features of the distributions of the variables which are input to risk evaluation models are their means and standard deviations. The research which is described in this paper tests these hypotheses using five risk simulation case studies.     

Using a group support system to aid input–output identification in DEA

In data envelopment analysis (DEA), operating units are compared on their outputs relative to their inputs. The identification of an appropriate input–output set is of decisive significance if assessment of the relative performance of the units is not to be biased. This paper reports on a novel approach used for identifying a suitable input–output set for assessing central administrative services at universities. A computer-supported group support system was used with an advisory board to enable the analysts to extract information pertaining to the boundaries of the unit of assessment and the corresponding input–output variables. The approach provides for a more comprehensive and less inhibited discussion of input–output variables to inform the DEA model.     

A generalized DEA model for inputs/outputs estimation

In this paper we discuss the question: among a group of decision making units (DMUs), if a DMU changes some of its input (output) levels, to what extent should the unit change outputs (inputs) such that its efficiency index remains unchanged? In order to solve this question we propose a solving method based on Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) and Multiple Objective Linear Programming (MOLP). In our suggested method, the increase of some inputs (outputs) and the decrease due to some of the other inputs (outputs) are taken into account at the same time, while the other offered methods do not consider the increase and the decrease of the various inputs (outputs) simultaneously. Furthermore, existing models employ a MOLP for the inefficient DMUs and a linear programming for weakly efficient DMUs, while we propose a MOLP which estimates input/output levels, regardless of the efficiency or inefficiency of the DMU. On the other hand, we show that the current models may fail in a special case, whereas our model overcomes this flaw. Our method is immediately applicable to solve practical problems.     

Specification and estimation of primal production models

While estimating production technology in a primal framework production function, input and output distance functions and input requirement functions are widely used in the empirical literature. This paper shows that these popular primal based models are algebraically equivalent in the sense that they can be derived from the same underlying transformation (production possibility) function. By assuming that producers maximize profit, we show that in all cases, except one, the use of ordinary least squares (OLS) gives inconsistent estimates irrespective of whether the production, input distance and input requirement functions are used. Based on several specifications of the production and input distance function models, we conclude that one can estimate the input elasticities and returns to scale consistently using instruments on only one regressor. No instruments are needed if either it is assumed that producers know the technology entirely (including the so-called error term) or a system approach is used. We used Norwegian timber harvesting data to illustrate workings of various model specifications.     

A new approach for technical efficiency estimation in multiple output production

The nonparametric technique of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) has been used to measure technical efficiency. This approach has proven useful because, unlike regression analyses, it allows multiple outputs and does not require a priori functional form specification. DEA does, however, require correct model specification; inclusion of inappropriate variables or omission of relevant variables leads to distortions. The purpose of this paper is to develop an alternative methodology based on canonical correlation to measure technical efficiency for multiple output production correspondences. Using simulated data, the new methodology is compared with DEA. The results indicate that the canonical regression approach outperforms DEA in most cases.     

Centralized resource allocation DEA models based on revenue efficiency under limited information

In this paper, we extend the centralized DEA models by Lozano et al (2011) to allocate resources based on revenue efficiency across a set of DMUs under a centralized decision-making environment. The aim is to allocate resources so as to maximize the total output revenue produced by all the DMUs under limited information. To uncover the sources of total revenue increase from the centralized resource allocation model, we further decompose the aggregate revenue efficiency into three components: the aggregate output-oriented technical efficiency, the aggregate output allocative efficiency and the aggregate revenue re-allocative efficiency. Finally, two empirical data sets are presented to show that our proposed approach is not only an efficient tool to allocate the resources among the DMUs based on the revenue efficiency but additionally provides the central DM with guidance on how to identify the weak areas where more effort should be devoted to improve the total outputs.     

On input/output stabilization of singular integrodifferential systems

In this paper we consider a class of systems described by singular integrodifferential equations. This type of systems appear, for example, in the modeling of certain aeroelastic control problems. We study these systems in frequency domain framework and show the existence of finite-dimensional stabilizing controllers. An algorithmic procedure is outlined for the construction of such controllers. In order to illustrate the numerical aspects of this algorithm, we present an example involving the classical Theodorsen model of an airfoil, which fits in the class of systems considered here.This work was supported in part by the National Science Foundation under Grants DMS-8907019 and MSS-9203418.     

A generalized DEA model for centralized resource allocation

In this paper, we introduced a new generalized centralized resource allocation model which extends Lozano and Villa’s and Asmild et al.’s models to a more general case. In order to uncover the sources of such total input contraction in the generalized centralized resource allocation model, we applied the structural efficiency to further decompose it into three components: the aggregate technical efficiency, the aggregate allocative efficiency and re-transferable efficiency components. The proposed models are not only flexible enough for the central decision-maker to adjust the inputs and outputs to achieve the total input contraction but also identify the sources of such total input contraction, thereby giving rise to an important interpretation and understanding of the generalized centralized resource allocation model. Finally, an empirical example is used to illustrate the approach.     

Computation of efficient targets in DEA models with production trade-offs and weight restrictions

Recently new models of data envelopment analysis (DEA) were introduced that incorporate production trade-offs between inputs and outputs or based on them weight restrictions. In this paper, we develop a computational procedure suitable for the practical application of such models. We show that the standard two-stage optimisation procedure used in DEA to test the full efficiency of units and identify their efficient targets may work incorrectly in the new models. The modified procedure consists of three stages: the first evaluates the radial efficiency of the unit, the second identifies its efficient target, and the third its reference set of efficient peers. Each stage requires solving one linear program for each unit.     

DEA models for supply chain efficiency evaluation

An appropriate performance measurement system is an important requirement for the effective management of a supply chain. Two hurdles are present in measuring the performance of a supply chain and its members. One is the existence of multiple measures that characterize the performance of chain members, and for which data must be acquired; the other is the existence of conflicts between the members of the chain with respect to specific measures. Conventional data envelopment analysis (DEA) cannot be employed directly to measure the performance of supply chain and its members, because of the existence of the intermediate measures connecting the supply chain members. In this paper it is shown that a supply chain can be deemed as efficient while its members may be inefficient in DEA-terms. The current study develops several DEA-based approaches for characterizing and measuring supply chain efficiency when intermediate measures are incorporated into the performance evaluation. The models are illustrated in a seller-buyer supply chain context, when the relationship between the seller and buyer is treated first as one of leader-follower, and second as one that is cooperative. In the leader-follower structure, the leader is first evaluated, and then the follower is evaluated using information related to the leader's efficiency. In the cooperative structure, the joint efficiency which is modelled as the average of the seller's and buyer's efficiency scores is maximized, and both supply chain members are evaluated simultaneously. Non-linear programming problems are developed to solve these new supply chain efficiency models. It is shown that these DEA-based non-linear programs can be treated as parametric linear programming problems, and best solutions can be obtained via a heuristic technique. The approaches are demonstrated with a numerical example.     

Buffers with correlated input and output interruptions

The letter considers a discrete buffered system with one randomly interrupted output channel and stochastic interruptions of the arrival stream which are correlated to the output interruptions. The behaviour of this buffer system is studied, and in particular the influence of the correlation is derived.     

Mixing DEA and FDH models together

New formulations of data envelopment analysis (DEA) and free disposal hull (FDH) models in a unified linear framework are proposed. One of the main objectives of this paper is to derive meaningful economic interpretations of the dual models in the price space. In particular, we introduce a new formulation of the returns to scale assumption with a straightforward economic interpretation. This framework allows for mixing DEA and FDH models together in a more general framework.