Solving Blue Light Riddles: New Lessons from Flavin‐binding LOV Photoreceptors

Detection of blue light (BL) via flavin‐binding photoreceptors (Fl‐Blues) has evolved throughout all three domains of life. Although the main BL players, that is light, oxygen and voltage (LOV), blue light sensing using flavins (BLUF) and Cry (cryptochrome) proteins, have been characterized in great detail with respect to structure and function, still several unresolved issues at different levels of complexity remain and novel unexpected findings were reported. Here, we review the most prevailing riddles of LOV‐based photoreceptors, for example: the relevance of water and/or small metabolites for the dynamics of the photocycle; molecular details of light‐to‐signal transduction events; the interplay of BL sensing by LOV domains with other environmental stimuli, such as BL plus oxygen‐mediating photodamage and its impact on microbial lifestyles; the importance of the cell or chromophore redox state in determining the fate of BL‐driven reactions; the evolutionary pathways of LOV‐based BL sensing and associated functions through the diverse phyla. We will discuss major novelties emerged during the last few years on these intriguing aspects of LOV proteins by presenting paradigmatic examples from prokaryotic photosensors that exhibit the largest complexity and richness in associated functions.     

Metagenome-based screening reveals worldwide distribution of LOV-domain proteins

Metagenomes from various environments were screened for sequences homologous to light, oxygen, voltage (LOV)-domain proteins. LOV domains are flavin binding, blue-light (BL)-sensitive photoreceptors present in 10-15% of deposited prokaryotic genomes. The LOV domain has been selected, since BL is an ever present and sometimes harmful environmental factor for microbial communities. The majority of the metagenome material originated from the Sargasso Sea Project and from open-ocean sampling. In total, more than 40 million open reading frames were investigated for LOV-domain sequences. Most sequences were identified from aquatic material, but they were also found in metagenomes from soil and extreme environments, e.g. hypersaline ponds, acidic mine drainage or wastewater treatment facilities. A total of 578 LOV domains was assigned by three criteria: (1) the highly conserved core region, (2) the presence of minimally 14 essential amino acids and (3) a minimal length of 80 amino acids. More than three quarters of these identified genes showed a sequence divergence of more than 20% from database-deposited LOV domains from known organisms, indicating the large variation of this photoreceptor motif. The broad occurrence of LOV domains in metagenomes emphasizes their important physiological role for light-induced signal transduction, stress adaptation and survival mechanisms.     

A Blue Light-inducible Phosphodiesterase Activity in the Cyanobacterium Synechococcus elongatus

A blue light-inducible phosphodiesterase (PDE) activity, specific for the hydrolysis of cyclic di-GMP (c-di-GMP), has been identified in a recombinant protein from Synechococcus elongatus. Blue light (BL) activation is accomplished by a light, oxygen, voltage (LOV) domain, found in plant phototropins and bacterial BL photoreceptors. The genome of S. elongatus contains two genes coding for proteins with LOV domains fused to EAL domains (SL1 and SL2). In both cases, a GGDEF motif is placed in between the LOV and the EAL motifs. Such arrangement is frequently found with diguanylate-cyclase (DGC) functions that form c-di-GMP. Cyclic di-GMP acts as a second messenger molecule regulating biofilm formation in many microbial species. Both enzyme activities modulate the intracellular level of this second messenger, although in most proteins only one of the two enzyme functions is active. Both S. elongatus LOV-GGDEF-EAL proteins were expressed in full length or as truncated proteins. Only the SL2 protein, expressed as a LOV-GGDEF-EAL construct, showed an increase of PDE activity upon BL irradiation, demonstrating this activity for the first time in a LOV-domain protein. Addition of GTP or c-di-GMP did not affect the observed enzymatic activity. In none of the full-length or truncated proteins was a DGC activity detected.     

Characterization of an Unusual LOV Domain Protein in the α-Proteobacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides

The facultatively phototrophic purple bacterium Rhodobacter sphaeroides 2.4.1 harbors a LOV (light, oxygen and voltage) domain protein, which shows a particular structure. LOV domains perceive blue light by a noncovalently bound flavin and transmit the signal to various coupled output domains. Proteins, that harbor a LOV core, function e.g. as phototropins or circadian clock regulators. Jα helices, which act as linker between the LOV core and the output domain, were shown to be involved in the light-dependent activation of the output domain. Like PpSB2 from Pseudomonas putida , the LOV domain protein of R. sphaeroides is not coupled to an effector domain and harbors an extended C-terminal α helix. We expressed the R. sphaeroides LOV domain recombinantly in Escherichia  coli . The protein binds an FMN as a cofactor and shows a photocycle typical for LOV domain containing proteins. In R. sphaeroides , we detected the protein as well in the cytoplasm as in the membrane fraction, which was not reported for other bacterial LOV domain proteins.     

Tryptophan Fluorescence in the Bacillus subtilis Phototropin‐related Protein YtvA as a Marker of Interdomain Interaction¶

The Bacillus subtilis protein YtvA, related to plant phototropins (phot), binds flavin mononucleotide (FMN) within the N‐terminal light, oxygen and voltage (LOV) domain. The blue light‐triggered photocycle of YtvA and phot involves the reversible formation of a covalent photoadduct between FMN and a cysteine (cys) residue. YtvA contains a single tryptophan, W103, localized on the LOV domain and conserved in all phot‐LOV domains. In this study, we show that the fluorescence parameters of W103 in YtvA‐LOV are markedly different from those observed in the full‐length YtvA. The fluorescence quantum yields are ca 0.03 and 0.08, respectively. In YtvA‐LOV, the maximum is redshifted (ca 345 vs 335 nm) and the average fluorescence lifetime shorter (2.7 vs 4.7 ns). These data indicate that W103 is located in a site of tight contact between the two domains of YtvA. In the FMN‐cys adduct, selective excitation of W103 at 295 nm results in minimal changes of the fluorescence parameters with respect to the dark state. On 280 nm excitation, however, there is a detectable decrease in the fluorescence emitted from tyrosines, with concomitant increase in W103 fluorescence. This effect is reversible in the dark and might arise from a light‐regulated energy transfer process from a yet unidentified tyrosine to W103.     

Three putative photosensory light, oxygen or voltage (LOV) domains with distinct biochemical properties from the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

Light, oxygen or voltage (LOV) domains function as blue-light sensors in the phototropin family of photoreceptors found in plants, algae and bacteria. We detected putative LOV domains (Alr3170-LOV, All2875-LOV and Alr1229-LOV) in the genome of a filamentous cyanobacterium, Anabaena sp. PCC 7120. These cyanobacterial LOV domains are closely clustered with the known LOV domains. Alr3170-LOV and A112875-LOV carry the conserved cysteine residue unique to the photoactive LOV, whereas Alr1229-LOV does not. We expressed these three LOV domains in Escherichia coli and purified them. In fact, Alr3170-LOV and A112875-LOV that are conserved in Nostoc punctiforme, a related species, bound flavin mononucleotide and showed spectral changes unique to known LOV domains on illumination with blue light. Alr3170-LOV was completely photoreduced and dark reversion was slow, whereas A112875-LOV was slowly photoreduced and dark reversion was rapid. For comparison, AvA112875-LOV in a closely related A. variabilis was also studied as a homolog of A112875-LOV. Finally, we observed that Alr1229-LOV that is not conserved in N. punctiforme showed no flavin binding.     

The LOV2 domain of phototropin: a reversible photochromic switch

Light, oxygen, or voltage (LOV) domains constitute a new class of photoreceptor proteins that are sensitive to blue light through a noncovalently bound flavin chromophore. Blue-light absorption by the LOV2 domain initiates a photochemical reaction that results in formation of a long-lived covalent adduct between a cysteine and the flavin cofactor. We have applied ultrafast spectroscopy on the photoaccumulated covalent adduct state of LOV2 and find that, upon absorption of a near-UV photon by the adduct state, the covalent bond between the flavin and the cysteine is broken and the blue-light-sensitive ground state is regained on an ultrafast time scale of 100 ps. We thus demonstrate that the LOV2 domain is a reversible photochromic switch, which can be activated by blue light and deactivated by near-UV light.     

Novel Thermostable Flavin‐binding Fluorescent Proteins from Thermophilic Organisms

Flavin‐binding fluorescent proteins (FbFPs) are small, oxygen‐independent in vivo reporters, derived from Light Oxygen Voltage (LOV) domains of photoreceptors. Here, we investigated the thermostability of existing, as well as novel FbFPs, whose genes were identified in genome sequences of various thermophilic bacteria as well as metagenomic libraries from hot springs in the Yellowstone National Park. Detailed in vitro analyses revealed that two of those fluorescent reporter proteins were highly thermostable, exhibiting melting temperatures above 75°C.     

Characterization of the Blue–Light‐Activated Adenylyl Cyclase mPAC by Flash Photolysis and FTIR Spectroscopy

The recently discovered photo‐activated adenylyl cyclase (mPAC from Microcoleus chthonoplastes) is the first PAC that owes a light‐, oxygen‐ and voltage‐sensitive (LOV) domain for blue‐light sensing. The photoreaction of the mPAC receptor was studied by time‐resolved UV/vis and light‐induced Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) absorption difference spectroscopy. The photocycle comprises of the typical triplet state LOV₇₁₅ and the thio‐adduct state LOV₃₉₀. While the adduct state decays with a time constant of 8 s, the lifetime of the triplet state is with 656 ns significantly shorter than in all other reported LOV domains. The light‐induced FTIR difference spectrum shows the typical bands of the LOV₃₉₀ and LOV₄₅₀ intermediates. The negative S‐H stretching vibration at 2573 cm^?1 is asymmetric suggesting two rotamer configurations of the protonated side chain of C194. A positive band at 3632 cm^?1 is observed, which is assigned to an internal water molecule. In contrast to other LOV domains, mPAC exhibits a second positive feature at 3674 cm^?1 which is due to the O‐H stretch of a second intrinsic water molecule and the side chain of Y476. We conclude that the latter might be involved in the dimerization of the cyclase domain which is crucial for ATP binding.     

Old chromophores, new photoactivation paradigms, trendy applications: flavins in blue light-sensing photoreceptors

The knowledge on the mechanisms by which blue light (BL) is sensed by diverse and numerous organisms, and of the physiological responses elicited by the BL photoreceptors, has grown remarkably during the last two decades. The basis for this "blue revival" was set by the identification and molecular characterization of long sought plant BL sensors, employing flavins as chromophores, chiefly cryptochromes and phototropins. The latter photosensors are the foundation members of the so-called light, oxygen, voltage (LOV)-protein family, largely spread among archaea, bacteria, fungi and plants. The accumulation of sequenced microbial genomes during the last years has added the BLUF (Blue Light sensing Using FAD) family to the BL photoreceptors and yielded the opportunity for intense "genome mining," which has presented to us the intriguing wealth of BL sensing in prokaryotes. In this contribution we provide an update of flavin-based BL sensors of the LOV and BLUF type, from prokaryotic microorganisms, with special emphasis to their light-activation pathways and molecular signal-transduction mechanisms. Rather than being a fully comprehensive review, this research collects the most recent discoveries and aims to unveil and compare signaling pathways and mechanisms of BL sensors.     

Functional Characterization of a LOV‐Histidine Kinase Photoreceptor from Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri

The blue‐light (BL) absorbing protein Xcc‐LOV from Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri is composed of a LOV‐domain, a histidine kinase (HK) and a response regulator. Spectroscopic characterization of Xcc‐LOV identified intermediates and kinetics of the protein's photocycle. Measurements of steady state and time‐resolved fluorescence allowed determination of quantum yields for triplet (Φ_T = 0.68 ± 0.03) and photoproduct formation (Φ₃₉₀ = 0.46 ± 0.05). The lifetime for triplet decay was determined as τ_T = 2.4–2.8 μs. Fluorescence of tryptophan and tyrosine residues was unchanged upon light‐to‐dark conversion, emphasizing the absence of significant conformational changes. Photochemistry was blocked upon cysteine C76 (C76S) mutation, causing a seven‐fold longer lifetime of the triplet state (τ_T = 16–18.5 μs). Optoacoustic spectroscopy yielded the energy content of the triplet state. Interestingly, Xcc‐LOV did not undergo the volume contraction reported for other LOV domains within the observation time window, although the back‐conversion into the dark state was accompanied by a volume expansion. A radioactivity‐based enzyme function assay revealed a larger HK activity in the lit than in the dark state. The C76S mutant showed a still lower enzyme function, indicating the dark state activity being corrupted by a remaining portion of the long‐lived lit state.     

Autophosphorylation, electrophoretic mobility and immunoreaction of oat phototropin 1 under UV and blue Light

Phototropins are UV-A/blue light photoreceptors containing two flavin mononucleotide (FMN)-binding domains, light, oxygen and voltage (LOV)1 and LOV2, of which LOV2 is more sensitive toward light and more important for the physiological response compared with LOV1. Some physiological responses are plant phototropism, chloroplast migration and stomatal opening. Oat phototropin 1 together with light-dependent autophosphorylation shows a reduced electrophoretic mobility and reduced immunoreaction against a heterologous antiserum; both effects were suggested to be caused by phosphorylation at the same sites (M. Salomon, E. Knieb, T. von Zeppelin and W. Rudiger [2003] Biochemistry 42, 4217-4225). In this study, we show that both effects can be separated from each other: at low temperature, reduced immunoreaction preceded the mobility shift, and irradiation with UV-C light led to the mobility shift without the loss of immunoreactivity. We demonstrated that UV-C light at 280 nm, which does not match any absorption maximum of FMN, leads to autophosphorylation of phototropin. It is hypothesized that UV-C light causes differential activation of the LOV domains via energy transfer from aromatic amino acids.     

Quantum Mechanics/Molecular Mechanics Study on the Photoreactions of Dark‐ and Light‐Adapted States of a Blue‐Light YtvA LOV Photoreceptor

The dark‐ and light‐adapted states of YtvA LOV domains exhibit distinct excited‐state behavior. We have employed high‐level QM(MS‐CASPT2)/MM calculations to study the photochemical reactions of the dark‐ and light‐adapted states. The photoreaction from the dark‐adapted state starts with an S₁→T₁ intersystem crossing followed by a triplet‐state hydrogen transfer from the thiol to the flavin moiety that produces a diradical intermediate, and a subsequent internal conversion that triggers a barrierless C−S bond formation in the S₀ state. The energy profiles for these transformations are different for the four conformers of the dark‐adapted state considered. The photochemistry of the light‐adapted state does not involve the triplet state: photoexcitation to the S₁ state triggers C−S bond cleavage followed by recombination in the S₀ state; both these processes are essentially barrierless and thus ultrafast. The present work offers new mechanistic insights into the photoresponse of flavin‐containing blue‐light photoreceptors.     

Indication for a radical intermediate preceding the signaling state in the LOV domain photocycle

The blue light photoreceptor phototropin mediates crucial processes in plants leading to optimization of photosynthesis. Phototropin comprises two flavin mononucleotide-binding LOV (light-, oxygen-, or voltage-sensitive) domains. The LOV domains undergo a photocycle upon illumination, in which two intermediates have been detected by UV/Vis spectroscopy. The triplet excited state of flavin is formed and decays within a few microseconds into a photoadduct with an adjacent cysteine, which represents the signaling state of the LOV domain. For bond formation of the photoadduct, several reaction pathways have been proposed, but evidence for an intermediate at ambient conditions has not been found. Here, we performed nanosecond time-resolved UV/Vis spectroscopy on the phototropin-LOV1 domain from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. We designed a flow cell which was used to efficiently replace the sample after each photoexcitation because the cycling time is in the order of hundreds of seconds. The comparison of difference spectra of the wild type with those of the C57S mutant that produces only the triplet excited state revealed the existence of an additional intermediate between the triplet and the adduct state. This intermediate exhibits spectral properties similar to a neutral flavin radical. This finding supports a reaction mechanism involving a neutral radical pair.     

Absorption and emission spectroscopic characterisation of combined wildtype LOV1-LOV2 domain of phot from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

An absorption and emission spectroscopic characterisation of the combined wild-type LOV1-LOV2 domain string (abbreviated LOV1/2) of phot from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is carried out at pH 8. A LOV1/2-MBP fusion protein (MBP=maltose binding protein) and LOV1/2 with a His-tag at the C-terminus (LOV1/2-His) expressed in an Escherichia coli strain are investigated. Blue-light photo-excitation generates a non-fluorescent intermediate photoproduct (flavin-C(4a)-cysteinyl adduct with absorption peak at 390 nm). The photo-cycle dynamics is studied by dark-state absorption and fluorescence measurement, by following the temporal absorption and emission changes under blue and violet light exposure, and by measuring the temporal absorption and fluorescence recovery after light exposure. The fluorescence quantum yield, phi(F), of the dark adapted samples is phi(F)(LOV1/2-His) approximately 0.15 and phi(F)(LOV1/2-MBP) approximately 0.17. A bi-exponential absorption recovery after light exposure with a fast (in the several 10-s range) and a slow component (in the near 10-min range) are resolved. The quantum yield of photo-adduct formation, phi(Ad), is extracted from excitation intensity dependent absorption measurements. It decreases somewhat with rising excitation intensity. The behaviour of the combined wildtype LOV1-LOV2 double domains is compared with the behaviour of the separate LOV1 and LOV2 domains.     

Expressed Sequence Tag Analysis of the Dinoflagellate Lingulodinium polyedrum During Dark Phase¶

To collect information on gene expression during the dark period in the luminous dinoflagellate Lingulodinium polyedrum, normalized complementary DNA (cDNA) libraries were constructed from cells collected during the first hour of night phase in a 12:12 h light‐dark cycle. A total of 4324 5′‐end sequence tags were isolated. The sequences were grouped into 2111 independent expressed sequence tags (EST) from which 433 groups were established by similarity searches of the public nonredundant protein database. Homology analysis of the total sequences indicated that the luminous dinoflagellate is more similar to land plants and animals (vertebrates and invertebrates) than to prokaryotes or algae. We also isolated three bioluminescence‐related (luciferase and two luciferinbinding proteins [LBP]) and 37 photosynthesis‐related genes. Interestingly, two kinds of LBP genes occur in multiple copies in the genome, in contrast to the single luciferase gene. These cDNA clones and EST sequence data should provide a powerful resource for future genome‐wide functional analyses for uncharacterized genes.     

Selective Photoreceptor Gene Knock‐out Reveals a Regulatory Role for the Growth Behavior of Pseudomonas syringae

The plant pathogen Pseudomonas syringae (Ps) is a well‐established model organism for bacterial infection of plants. The genome sequences of two pathovars, pv. syringae and pv. tomato, revealed one gene encoding a blue and two genes encoding red/far red light‐sensing photoreceptors. Continuing former molecular characterization of the photoreceptor proteins, we here report selective photoreceptor gene disruption for pv. tomato aiming at identification of potentially regulatory functions of these photoreceptors. Transformation of Ps cells with linear DNA constructs yielded interposon mutations of the corresponding genes. Cell growth studies of the generated photoreceptor knock‐out mutants revealed their role in light‐dependent regulation of cell growth and motility. Disruption of the blue‐light (BL) receptor gene caused a growth deregulation, in line with an observed increased virulence of this mutant (Moriconi et al., Plant J., 2013, 76, 322). Bacterial phytochrome‐1 (BphP1) deletion mutant caused unaltered cell growth, but a stronger swarming capacity. Inactivation of its ortholog, BphP2, however, caused reduced growth and remarkably altered dendritic swarming behavior. Combined knock‐out of both bacteriophytochromes reproduced the swarming pattern observed for the BphP2 mutant alone. A triple knock‐out mutant showed a growth rate between that of the BL (deregulation) and the phytochrome‐2 mutant (growth reduction).     

Light‐Regulated Tetracycline Binding to the Tet Repressor

Elucidation of the signal‐transmission pathways between distant sites within proteins is of great importance in medical and bioengineering sciences. The use of optical methods to redesign protein functions is emerging as a general approach for the control of biological systems with high spatiotemporal precision. Here we report the detailed thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of novel chimeric light‐regulated Tet repressor (TetR) switches in which light modulates the TetR function. Light absorbed by flavin mononucleotide (FMN) generates a signal that is transmitted to As‐LOV and YtvA‐LOV fused TetR proteins (LOV=light–oxygen–voltage), in which it alters the binding to tetracycline, the TetR ligand. The engineering of light‐sensing protein modules with TetR is a valuable tool that deepens our understanding of the mechanism of signal transmission within proteins. In addition, the light‐regulated changes of drug binding that we describe here suggest that engineered light‐sensitive proteins may be used for the development of novel therapeutic strategies.