Capacitated lot sizing and scheduling with parallel machines and shared buffers: A case study in a packaging company

The aim of this work is to propose a solution approach for a capacitated lot sizing and scheduling real problem with parallel machines and shared buffers, arising in a packaging company producing yoghurt. The problem has been formulated as a hybrid Continuous Set-up and Capacitated Lot Sizing Problem (CSLP–CLSP). A new effective two stage optimisation heuristic based on the decomposition of the problem into a lot sizing problem and a scheduling problem has been developed. An assignment of mixture to buffers is made in the first stage, and therefore the corresponding orders are scheduled on the production lines by performing a local search. Computational tests have been performed on the real data provided by the company. The heuristic exhibits near-optimal solutions, all obtained in a very short computational time.     

Equivalence classes of problem instances for a continuous-time lot sizing and scheduling problem

In the context of a single machine, multi-item, continuous-time lot sizing and scheduling problem with a production rate alternating between the two values zero and full production rate, this paper identifies classes of equivalent problem instances which differ from one another in the way in which demand is represented. Each class contains an instance with a continuous cumulated demand function, and may contain demand functions with very different shapes, including functions with discontinuities. When approaching the problem (in order to solve it numerically, or to prove analytical results etc.), it therefore becomes possible to select, from many different representations, the problem instance which best meets the requirements of the applied method.     

Economic lot scheduling with uncontrolled co-production

The aim of this paper is to analyze the effects of uncontrolled co-production on the production planning and lot scheduling of multiple products. Co-production occurs when a proportion of a certain production comes out as another product. This is typical in the process industry where quality and process specifications can lead to diversified products. We assume that there is no demand substitution and each product has its own market. Furthermore, we assume that co-production cannot be controlled due to technical and/or cost considerations. We introduce two models that extend the common cycle economic lot scheduling (ELSP) setting to include uncontrolled co-production. In the first model we do not allow for shortages and derive the optimal cycle time expression. In the second model, we allow for planned backorders and characterize the optimal solution in closed form. We provide a numerical study to gain insight about co-production. It seems that the cycle time increases with co-production rate and utilization of the system. The effect of co-production on long-term average cost does not exhibit a certain characteristic.     

A scheduling policy for adjusting economic lot quantities to a feasible solution

A heuristic scheduling policy is introduced for a multi-item, single-machine production facility. The scheduling policy uses the presumed optimal order quantities derived from solving an Economic Lot Size Problem and checks that the quantities obtain a feasible production schedule according to current inventory levels and expected demand rates. If not, the scheduling policy modifies the order quantities to achieve a possible solution without shortages. The scheduling policy is inspired by modification of the similar heuristic Dynamic Cycle Lengths Policy by Leachman and Gascon from 1988, 1991. The main characteristics of this scheduling policy are successive batches of the same item are treated explicitly, due to that it is quite possible that one item be manufactured several times before one other item is manufactured once more; the batches are ordered in increasing run-out time; if the existing situation creates stock-outs with ordinary order quantities, then the order quantities are decreased with a common scaling factor to try to prevent inventory shortages; in case the decrease of the order quantities changes expected run-out times, the batches are reordered after new run-out times; no filling up to an explicit inventory level is done, the filling up is done by the desirable order quantity; to prevent possible excess inventory the policy suggests time periods where no production should be performed. The scheduling policy contains no economical evaluation; this is supposed to be done when the order quantities are calculated, the policy prevents shortages and excess inventory. A numerical example illustrates the suggested scheduling policy. Finally, it is discussed as to how the policy can also take into account stochastic behaviour of the demand rates and compensate the schedule by applying appropriate safety times.     

Solution approaches for the soft drink integrated production lot sizing and scheduling problem

In this paper we present a mixed integer programming model that integrates production lot sizing and scheduling decisions of beverage plants with sequence-dependent setup costs and times. The model considers that the industrial process produces soft drink bottles in different flavours and sizes, and it is carried out in two production stages: liquid preparation (stage I) and bottling (stage II). The model also takes into account that the production bottleneck may alternate between stages I and II, and a synchronisation of the production between these stages is required. A relaxation approach and several strategies of the relax-and-fix heuristic are proposed to solve the model. Computational tests with instances generated based on real data from a Brazilian soft drink plant are also presented. The results show that the solution approaches are capable of producing better solutions than those used by the company.     

The use of genetic algorithms to solve the economic lot size scheduling problem

The purpose of this paper is to investigate the use genetic algorithms (GAs) for solving the Economic Lot Size Scheduling Problem (ELSP). The ELSP is formulated using the Basic Period (BP) approach which results in a problem having one continuous decision variable and a number of integer decision variables equal to the number of products being produced. This formulation is ideally suited for using GAs. The GA is tested on Bomberger's classical problem. The resulting solutions were better than those obtained using an iterative dynamic programming (DP) approach. The total cost of GA solutions to the problem with utilization up to 65% were within 3.4% of the lower bound. The GA also performed well for higher utilization yielding solutions within 13.87% of the lower bound for utilization up to 86%. The GA was tested on a 30-item problem and good solutions were obtained. The results of the GA under different binary representations, crossover methods, and initialization methods are compared to identify the best settings. The results indicate that for this particular problem, binary representation works better than Gray coding, 2-point crossover is best, and an infeasible starting population is better than feasible.     

Economic lot sizing: The capacity reservation model

Capacity reservation contracts allow a consumer to purchase up to a certain capacity at a unit price lower than that of the spot market, while the consumer’s excess orders are realized at the spot price. In this paper, we consider a lot sizing problem where the consumer places orders following a capacity reservation contract. In particular, we study the general problem and the polynomial time solvable special cases of the problem and propose corresponding algorithms for them.     

Augmenting the lot sizing order quantity when demand is probabilistic

In this paper we consider a single item, discrete time, lot sizing situation where demand is random and its parameters (e.g., mean and standard deviation) can change with time. For the appealing criterion of minimizing expected total relevant costs per unit time until the moment of the next replenishment we develop two heuristic ways of selecting an appropriate augmentation quantity beyond the expected total demand through to the planned (deterministic) time of the next replenishment. The results of a set of numerical experiments show that augmentation is important, particularly when orders occur frequently (i.e., the fixed cost of a replenishment is low relative to the costs of carrying one period of demand in stock) and the coefficient of variability of demand is relatively low, but also under other specified circumstances. The heuristic procedures are also shown to perform very favourably against a hindsight, baseline (s, S) policy, especially for larger levels of non-stationarity.     

Multi-level lot sizing and job shop scheduling with compressible process times: A cutting plane approach

This paper proposes an integer linear programming formulation for a simultaneous lot sizing and scheduling problem in a job shop environment. Among others, one of our realistic assumptions is dealing with flexible machines which enable the production manager to change their working speeds. Then, a number of valid inequalities are developed based on problem structures. As the valid inequalities can help in reducing the non-optimal parts of the solution space, they are dealt with as some cutting planes. The proposed cutting planes are used to solve the problem in (i) cut-and-branch, and (ii) branch-and-cut approaches. The performance of each cutting plane is investigated with CPLEX 12.2 on a set of randomly-generated test data. Then, some performance criteria are identified and the proposed cutting planes are ranked by TOPSIS method.     

Planning for demand failure: A dynamic lot size model for clinical trial supply chains

This paper examines the optimal production lot size decisions for clinical trial supply chains. One unique aspect of clinical trial supply chains is the risk of failure, meaning that the investigational drug is proven unsafe or ineffective during human testing and the trial is halted. Upon failure, any unused inventory is essentially wasted and needs to be destroyed. To avoid waste, manufacturers could produce small lot sizes. However, high production setup costs lead manufacturers to opt for large lot sizes and few setups. To optimally balance this tradeoff of waste and destruction versus production inefficiency, this paper generalizes the Wagner-Whitin model (W-W model) to incorporate the risk of failure. We show that this stochastic model, referred to as the failure-risk model, is equivalent to the deterministic W-W model if one adjusts the cost parameters properly to reflect failure and destruction costs. We find that increasing failure rates lead to reduced lot sizes and that properly incorporating the risk of failure into clinical trial drug production can lead to substantial cost savings as compared to the W-W model without the properly adjusted parameters.     

Pricing,relaxing and fixing under lot sizing and scheduling

We present a novel mathematical model and a mathematical programming based approach to deliver superior quality solutions for the single machine capacitated lot sizing and scheduling problem with sequence-dependent setup times and costs. The formulation explores the idea of scheduling products based on the selection of known production sequences. The model is the basis of a matheuristic, which embeds pricing principles within construction and improvement MIP-based heuristics. A partial exploration of distinct neighborhood structures avoids local entrapment and is conducted on a rule-based neighbor selection principle. We compare the performance of this approach to other heuristics proposed in the literature. The computational study carried out on different sets of benchmark instances shows the ability of the matheuristic to cope with several model extensions while maintaining a very effective search. Although the techniques described were developed in the context of the problem studied, the method is applicable to other lot sizing problems or even to problems outside this domain.     

Pattern scheduling

A pattern is a sequence of disjoint intervals on a circle together with fixed distances between these intervals. The intervals may be interpreted as tasks of a job which is produced perio-dically on one machine. How shouldr patterns be moved relative to each other to minimize the maximum overlapping of intervals (machines needed)? An enumerative procedure for solving this problem is given.     

Inventory replenishment model: lot sizing versus just-in-time delivery

Motivated by a practical industrial problem where a manufacturer stipulates a minimum order from each buyer but where a local dealer promises the buyer a just-in-time delivery with a slightly higher unit cost, this paper uses a dynamic lot-sizing model with a stepwise cargo cost function and a minimum order amount constraint to help the buyer select the supplier with minimum total cost.     

GRASP heuristic with path-relinking for the multi-plant capacitated lot sizing problem

This paper addresses the independent multi-plant, multi-period, and multi-item capacitated lot sizing problem where transfers between the plants are allowed. This is an NP-hard combinatorial optimization problem and few solution methods have been proposed to solve it. We develop a GRASP (Greedy Randomized Adaptive Search Procedure) heuristic as well as a path-relinking intensification procedure to find cost-effective solutions for this problem. In addition, the proposed heuristics is used to solve some instances of the capacitated lot sizing problem with parallel machines. The results of the computational tests show that the proposed heuristics outperform other heuristics previously described in the literature. The results are confirmed by statistical tests.     

Effects of imperfect products on lot sizing with work in process inventory

The economic production quantity (EPQ) is one of the most widely known inventory control models that can be regarded as the generalized form of the Economic Order Quantity. However, the model is built on an unrealistic assumption that all the produced items need to be of perfect quality. Also, the introduction of work in process, WIP, as part of the inventory has been of lesser concern in developing inventory models. This paper attempts to develop the economic production quantity considering work in process inventory and manufacturing imperfect products that may be either reworkable or non-reworkable. The non-reworkable imperfect products are sold at a reduced price. This paper introduces a new model for this problem.     

Economic lot sizing problem with inventory bounds

This paper studies a economic lot sizing (ELS) problem with both upper and lower inventory bounds. Bounded ELS models address inventory control problems with time-varying inventory capacity and safety stock constraints. An O(n²) algorithm is found by using net cumulative demand (NCD) to measure the amount of replenishment requested to fulfill the cumulative demand till the end of the planning horizon. An O(n) algorithm is found for the special case, the bounded ELS problem with non-increasing marginal production cost.     

An integrated model for lot sizing with supplier selection and quantity discounts

Good inventory management is essential for a firm to be cost competitive and to acquire decent profit in the market, and how to achieve an outstanding inventory management has been a popular topic in both the academic field and in real practice for decades. As the production environment getting increasingly complex, various kinds of mathematical models have been developed, such as linear programming, nonlinear programming, mixed integer programming, geometric programming, gradient-based nonlinear programming and dynamic programming, to name a few. However, when the problem becomes NP-hard, heuristics tools may be necessary to solve the problem. In this paper, a mixed integer programming (MIP) model is constructed first to solve the lot-sizing problem with multiple suppliers, multiple periods and quantity discounts. An efficient Genetic Algorithm (GA) is proposed next to tackle the problem when it becomes too complicated. The objectives are to minimize total costs, where the costs include ordering cost, holding cost, purchase cost and transportation cost, under the requirement that no inventory shortage is allowed in the system, and to determine an appropriate inventory level for each planning period. The results demonstrate that the proposed GA model is an effective and accurate tool for determining the replenishment for a manufacturer for multi-periods.     

Balancing capacity and lot sizes

In many companies there is an on-going discussion about capacity, capacity utilization and capital tied up in inventories. However, traditional models such as the EOQ model only include capacity considerations in the set-up cost, or in the cost of a replenishment order. This implies e.g. that they do not consider the set-up time as a capacity constraint. Furthermore, in these models the set-up cost is usually treated as a constant, even though the opportunity cost for capacity in general is dependent upon the capacity utilization.The purpose of this paper is to derive an analytical model for the balancing of capacity and lot sizes. The model includes costs for capacity, work-in-process (queueing, set-up, and processing time), and finished goods inventory. The total costs are minimized with respect to capacity. Then, the corresponding, recommended lot sizes are determined. The model was tested with data from a Swedish manufacturing company. The results turned out to coincide with experiences of the company in many important respects. The model offers production management an opportunity to discuss the relationship between capacity, work-in-process, and lot sizes.     

Economic lot sizes and vehicle scheduling

In this paper a relationship between the vehicle scheduling problem and the dynamic lot size problem is considered. For the latter problem we assume that order quantities for different products can be determined separately. Demand is known over our n-period production planning horizon. For a certain product our task is to decide for each period if it should be produced or not. If it is produced, what is its economic lot size? Our aim here is to minimize the combined set-up and inventory holding costs. The optimal solution of this problem is given by the well-known Wagner-Whitin dynamic lot size algorithm. Also many heuristics for solving this problem have been presented. In this article we point out the analogy of the dynamic lot size problem to a certain vehicle scheduling problem. For solving vehicle scheduling problems the heuristic algorithm developed by Clark and Wright in very often used. Applying this algorithm to the equivalent vehicle scheduling problem we obtain by analogy a simple heuristic algorithm for the dynamic lot size problem. Numerical results indicate that computation time is reduced by about 50% compared to the Wagner-Whitin algorithm. The average cost appears to be approximately 0.8% higher than optimum.