Combinatorial auctions

Combinatorial auctions are an important class of market mechanisms in which participants are allowed to bid on bundles of multiple heterogeneous items. In this paper, we discuss several complex issues that are encountered in the design of combinatorial auctions. These issues are related to the formulation of the winner determination problem, the expression of combined bids, the design of progressive combinatorial auctions that require less information revelation, and the need for decision support tools to help participants make profitable bidding decisions. For each issue, we survey the existing literature and propose avenues for further research. An earlier version of this paper appeared in 4OR 2, 1–33, 2004.     

Design issues for combinatorial auctions

Combinatorial auctions are an important class of market mechanisms in which participants are allowed to bid on bundles of multiple heterogeneous items. In this paper, we discuss several complex issues that are encountered in the design of combinatorial auctions. These issues are related to the formulation of the winner determination problem, the expression of combined bids, the design of progressive combinatorial auctions that require less information revelation, and the need for decision support tools to help participants make profitable bidding decisions. For each issue, we survey the existing literature and propose avenues for further research.Received: April 2003, Revised: July 2003, AMS classification: 91B26, 90BXX, 90C27All correspondence to:Jawad Abrache     

Monotonicity in asymmetric first-price auctions with affiliation

I study monotonicity of equilibrium strategies in first-price auctions with asymmetric bidders, risk aversion, affiliated types, and interdependent values. Every mixed-strategy equilibrium is shown to be outcome-equivalent to a monotone pure-strategy equilibrium under the “priority rule” for breaking ties. This provides a missing link to establish uniqueness in the “general symmetric model” of Milgrom and Weber (Econometrica 50:1089–1122, 1982). Non-monotone equilibria can exist under the “coin-flip rule” but they are distinguishable: all non-monotone equilibria have positive probability of ties whereas all monotone equilibria have zero probability of ties. This provides a justification for the standard empirical practice of restricting attention to monotone strategies. Hendricks et al. (2003) provide an overview of recent empirical work. For a survey of experimental work, see Kagel and Levin (2002).     

Multi-criteria auctions without full comparability of bids

The emergence of auction mechanisms that support bids characterized by several attributes is one of the most recent evolutions within auction theory. These mechanisms, referred to as multi-attribute, multiple issue or multi-dimensional auctions, are at the intersection between multi-criteria decision and auction theories. The purpose of this paper is to introduce multi-criteria auctions the originality of which is not to require full comparability between bids. We claim that this distinctive feature is of great interest, especially in procurement situations. Furthermore, the existence of potential incomparability between multi-dimensional offers will permit us to manage different bidding niches coexisting within the same bidding space. A theoretical framework based on a general preference structure will be introduced and then referenced to existing approaches such as multi-attribute auctions or new ones such as dominance based multi-criteria auctions or butterfly auctions.     

Comparing the Spanish and the discriminatory auction formats: A discrete model with private information

The Spanish Treasury is the only Treasury in the world that uses a hybrid system of discriminatory and uniform price auctions to sell government debt: winning bidders pay their bid price for each unit if this is lower than the weighted average price of winning bids (WAP), and pay the WAP otherwise. Following Gordy [Gordy, M., 1996. Multiple bids in a multiple-unit common-value auction. Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System], we model the Spanish auction as a common value auction of multiple units with private information, allowing for multiple bids. Numerical analysis shows that bidders spread their bids more in the Spanish than in the discriminatory auction and bid higher for the first unit, and that the expected seller’s revenue is higher in the Spanish than in the discriminatory auction within a reasonable set of parameter values.     

车辆牌照拍卖模型

提出多个相同物品(如车辆牌照)同时密封拍卖的模型，给出对称均衡竞标策略；证明了该拍卖方式与第一价格密封连续拍卖产生相同的预期收益；对估价为均匀分布的拍卖预期收益进行了研究。     

Vickrey–Dutch procurement auction for multiple items

We consider a setting where there is a manufacturer who wants to procure multiple items from a set of suppliers each of whom can supply one or more of these items (bundles). We design an ascending price auction for such a setting which implements the Vickrey–Clarke–Groves outcome and truthful bidding is an ex post Nash equilibrium. Our auction maintains non-linear and non-anonymous prices throughout the auction. This auction has a simple price adjustment step and is easy to implement in practice. As offshoots of this auction, we also suggest other simple auctions (in which truthful bidding is not an equilibrium by suppliers) which may be suitable where incentives to suppliers are not a big concern. Computer simulations of our auction show that it is scalable for the multi-unit case, and has better information revelation properties than its descending auction counterpart.     

收入管理中多数量需求的动态分批拍卖机制研究

分析了可运用于收入管理的定价及分配存量的动态分批拍卖机制,传统拍卖机制假设竞标者是单一需求,与实际情况不相符合.本文研究的模型中一个卖方在有限时间限制T内采用分批拍卖的方式销售商品出售C件产品,每个时期的竞标者有着多数量的产品需求,并对所需求产品有统一的,独立的私有价值.为使得整个拍卖收益最大化,研究了最优的分配方案和每个时期应该出售的最优产品数量kt*(x),并且运用改进的多需求第二价格拍卖模型实现最优分配机制.     

An auction with positive externality and possible application to overtime rules in football,soccer, and chess

We analyze auctions with positive externality, wherein the utility of each player who submitted a losing bid is strictly increasing in the price paid by the winning bidder. Such an auction was recently proposed for determining the starting team and the starting yard line in an overtime period in American football. We analyze the NFL case and also consider other football leagues, as well as tie-breaking by penalty shots in soccer, and overcoming a draw situation in chess.     

两种记分函数下多属性拍卖投标均衡策略

以拍卖人期望收益最大化为机制设计目标,讨论两种不同偏好的记分函数条件下,最高得分密封投标拍卖和连续完全信息多属性英式拍卖中,卖者的最优投标策略和买者的最优拍卖设计问题,主要结论是:1)无论选择哪种拍卖方式和记分函数,拍卖人均有动机隐瞒自己的真实偏好,除非竞价人是同质的或参与人数足够多.2)竞价人最优属性策略qi*与拍卖...     

Revenue deficiency under second-price auctions in a supply-chain setting

Consider a firm, called the buyer, that satisfies its demand over two periods by assigning both demands to a supplier via a second-price procurement auction; call this the Standard auction. In the hope of lowering its purchase cost, the firm is considering an alternative procedure in which it will also allow bids on each period individually, where there can be either one or two winners covering the two demands; call this the Multiple Winner auction. Choosing the Multiple Winner auction over the Standard auction can in fact result in a higher cost to the buyer. We provide a bound on how much greater the buyer’s cost can be in the Multiple Winner auction and show that this bound is tight. We then sharpen this bound for two scenarios that can arise when the buyer announces his demands close to the beginning of the demand horizon. Under a monotonicity condition, we achieve a further sharpening of the bound in one of the scenarios. Finally, this monotonicity condition allows us to generalize this bound to the T-period case in which bids are allowed on any subset of period demands.     

Design of planar articulated mechanisms using branch and bound

This paper considers an optimization model and a solution method for the design of two-dimensional mechanical mechanisms. The mechanism design problem is modeled as a nonconvex mixed integer program which allows the optimal topology and geometry of the mechanism to be determined simultaneously. The underlying mechanical analysis model is based on a truss representation allowing for large displacements. For mechanisms undergoing large displacements elastic stability is of major concern. We derive conditions, modeled by nonlinear matrix inequalities, which guarantee that a stable equilibrium is found and that buckling is prevented. The feasible set of the design problem is described by nonlinear differentiable and non-differentiable constraints as well as nonlinear matrix inequalities.To solve the mechanism design problem a branch and bound method based on convex relaxations is developed. To guarantee convergence of the method, two different types of convex relaxations are derived. The relaxations are strengthened by adding valid inequalities to the feasible set and by solving bound contraction sub-problems. Encouraging computational results indicate that the branch and bound method can reliably solve mechanism design problems of realistic size to global optimality.     

A double-sided multiunit combinatorial auction for substitutes: Theory and algorithms

Combinatorial exchanges have existed for a long time in securities markets. In these auctions buyers and sellers can place orders on combinations, or bundles of different securities. These orders are conjunctive: they are matched only if the full bundle is available. On business-to-business (B2B) exchanges, buyers have the choice to receive the same product with different attributes; for instance the same product can be produced by different sellers. A buyer indicates his preference by submitting a disjunctive order, where he specifies the quantity he wants of each particular good and what limit price he is willing to pay for each good, thus providing a subjective valuation of each attribute. Only the goods with the best prices will be traded. This article considers a doubled-sided multiunit combinatorial auction for substitutes, that is, a uniform price auction where buyers and sellers place both types of orders, conjunctive (AND orders) and disjunctive (XOR orders). We show that linear competitive prices exist. We also propose an algorithm to clear the market, which is particularly efficient when the number of traders is large, and the goods are divisible.     

Approximations and auctions for scheduling batches on related machines

We consider the scheduling of groups of identical jobs on related machines with sequence independent setup times. We provide a 2-approximation algorithm for minimizing the makespan. The second result is a truthful, polynomial time, randomized mechanism for the batch scheduling problem with a deterministic approximation guarantee of 4.     

Trade reduction vs. multi-stage: A comparison of double auction design approaches

With the growth of electronic markets, designing double auction mechanisms that are applicable to emerging market structures has become an important research topic. In this paper, we investigate two truthful double auction design approaches, the Trade Reduction Approach and the Multi-Stage Design Approach, and compare their resulting mechanisms in various exchange environments. We find that comparing with the Trade Reduction Approach, the Multi-Stage Design Approach offers mechanisms applicable to more complicated exchange environments. Furthermore, for the known trade reduction mechanisms, we prove that the corresponding mechanisms under the multi-stage design approach are superior in terms of both social efficiency and individual payoffs, in each exchange environment of interest. Our computational tests show that the mechanisms under the multi-stage design approach achieve very high efficiency in various scenarios.     

Using bid data for the management of sequential,multi-unit,online auctions with uniformly distributed bidder valuations

Internet auctions for consumers’ goods are an increasingly popular selling venue. We have observed that many sellers, instead of offering their entire inventory in a single auction, split it into sequential auctions of smaller lots, thereby reducing the negative market impact of larger lots. Information technology also makes it possible to collect and analyze detailed bid data from online auctions. In this paper, we develop and test a new model of sequential online auctions to explore the potential benefits of using real bid data from earlier auctions to improve the management of future auctions. Assuming a typical truth-revealing auction model, we quantify the effect of the lot size on the closing price and derive a closed-form solution for the problem of allocating inventory across multiple auctions when bidder valuation distributions are known. We also develop a decision methodology for allocating inventory across multiple auctions that dynamically incorporates the results of previous auctions as feedback into the management of subsequent auctions, and updating the lot size and number of auctions. We demonstrate how information signals from previous auctions can be used to update the auctioneer’s beliefs about the customers’ valuation distribution, and then to significantly increase the seller’s profit potential. We use several examples to reveal the benefits of using detailed transaction data for the management of sequential, multi-unit, online auctions and we demonstrate how these benefits are influenced by the inventory holding costs, the number of bidders, and the dispersion of consumers’ valuations.