Enhanced electrophoretic DNA separation in photonic crystal fiber

Joule heating generated by the electrical current in capillary electrophoresis leads to a temperature gradient along the separation channel and consequently affects the separation quality. We describe a method of reducing the Joule heating effect by incorporating photonic crystal fiber into a micro capillary electrophoresis chip. The photonic crystal fiber consists of a bundle of extremely narrow hollow channels, which ideally work as separation columns. Electrophoretic separation of DNA fragments was simultaneously but independently carried out in 54 narrow capillaries with a diameter of 3.7 μm each. The capillary bundle offers more efficient heat dissipation owing to the high surface-to-volume ratio. Under the same electrical field strength, notable improvement in resolution was obtained in the capillary bundle chip.     

Quantification and evaluation of Joule heating in on-chip capillary electrophoresis

We present the use of a novel, picoliter volume interferometer to measure, for the first time, the extent of Joule heating in chip-scale capillary electrophoresis (CE). The simple optical configuration for the on-chip interferometric backscatter detector (OCIBD) consists of an unfocused laser, an unaltered silica chip with a half-cylinder channel and a photodetector. Using OCIBD for millidegree-level noninvasive thermometry, temperature changes associated with Joule heating (2.81 degrees C above ambient) in on-chip CE have been observed in 90 microm wide and 40 microm deep separation channels. The temporal response of Joule heating in isotropically etched channels was exponential, with it taking an excess of 2.7 s to reach equilibrium. Buffer viscosity changes have also been derived from empirical on-chip thermometry data, allowing for the determination of diffusion coefficients for solutes when separated in heated buffers. In addition, OCIBD has allowed the reduction in separation efficiency to be estimated in the absence of laminar flow and due to increased molecular diffusion and lower buffer viscosity. A 7% reduction in separation efficiency was determined for a high current drawing buffer such as Tris-boric acid under an applied field of just 400 V/cm. Results indicate that heating effects in on-chip CE have been underestimated and there is a need to readdress the theoretical model.     

Bundled capillary electrophoresis using microstructured fibres

Joule heating, arising from the electric current passing through the capillary, causes many undesired effects in CE that ultimately result in band broadening. The use of narrow‐bore capillaries helps to solve this problem as smaller cross‐sectional area results in decreased Joule heating and the rate of heat dissipation is increased by the larger surface‐to‐volume ratio. Issues arising from such small capillaries, such as poor detection sensitivity, low loading capacity and high flow‐induced backpressure (complicating capillary loading) can be avoided by using a bundle of small capillaries operating simultaneously that share buffer reservoirs. Microstructured fibres, originally designed as waveguides in the telecommunication industry, are essentially a bundle of parallel ～5 μm id channels that extend the length of a fibre having otherwise similar dimensions to conventional CE capillaries. This work presents the use of microstructured fibres for CZE, taking advantage of their relatively high surface‐to‐volume ratio and the small individual size of each channel to effect highly efficient separations, particularly for dye‐labelled peptides.     

In-line application of electric field in capillary separation systems: Joule heating, pH and conductivity

This study concerns the technique electric field-assisted capillary liquid chromatography. In this technique, an electric field is applied over the separation capillary in order to provide an additional selectivity. In this technique, the electric field is applied in-line in the separation capillary and here the electric current is the factor limiting the magnitude of applied electric field. The influence of Joule heating and other factors on the current in such systems has been investigated. The temperature in the capillary was first measured within a standard CE set-up, as function of effect per unit of length. Then the same cooling system was applied to an in-line set-up, to replicate the conditions between the two systems, and thus the temperature. Thus Joule heating effects could then be calculated within the in-line system. It was found that for systems applying an electric field in line, the direct influence from Joule heating was only relatively small. The pH in the capillary was measured in the in-line set-up using cresol red/TRIS solutions as pH probe. Significant changes in pH were observed and the results suggested that electrolysis of water is the dominant electrode reaction in the in-line system. In summary, the observed conductivity change in in-line systems was found to be mainly due to the pH change by hydrolysis of water, but primarily not due the temperature change in the capillary column.     

Peak dispersion and contributions to plate height in nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis at high electric field strengths: ethanol as background electrolyte solvent

Nonaqueous capillary electrophoretic separations were performed under high electric field strengths (up to 2000 Vcm(-1)) in ethanolic background electrolyte solution and the contributions of different band broadening effects to plate height were evaluated. Under optimum conditions, increasing the field strength will provide faster separations and increased separation efficiency. Decrease in the separation efficiency at high field strengths was, however, observed in a previous study and now in the present paper an attempt is made to quantify various band broadening effects by applying a plate height model, which included the contributions of the injection plug length, diffusion, electromigration dispersion, Joule heating, analyte adsorption to the capillary wall, and detector slit aperture length. Of special interest were the contributions of Joule heating and analyte adsorption to the capillary wall. Poly(glycidylmethacrylate-co-N-vinylpyrrolidone)-coated fused-silica capillaries were used with internal diameters (ID) ranging from 30 to 75 microm. The separation efficiencies obtained experimentally were compared with the theoretically calculated efficiencies and fairly good agreement was observed for the 30 microm ID capillary. Relatively large deviation from the predictions of the model was found for the other capillary diameters especially at higher field strengths. The possible reasons for the deviation were discussed.     

Joule heating and determination of temperature in capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography columns

This article reviews the progress that has taken place in the past decade on the topic of estimation of Joule heating and temperature inside an open or packed capillary in electro-driven separation techniques of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and capillary electrochromatography (CEC), respectively. Developments in theoretical modeling of the heat transfer in the capillary systems have focused on attempts to apply the existing models on newer techniques such as CEC and chip-based CE. However, the advent of novel analytical tools such as pulsed magnetic field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), NMR thermometry, and Raman spectroscopy, have led to a revolution in the area of experimental estimation of Joule heating and temperature inside the capillary via the various noninvasive techniques. This review attempts to capture the major findings that have been reported in the past decade.     

Rapid fabrication of poly(dimethylsiloxane)-based microchip capillary electrophoresis devices using CO2 laser ablation

The use of CO(2) laser ablation for the patterning of capillary electrophoresis (CE) microchannels in poly(dimethylsiloxane)(PDMS) is described. Low-cost polymer devices were produced using a relatively inexpensive CO(2) laser system that facilitated rapid patterning and ablation of microchannels. Device designs were created using a commercially available software package. The effects of PDMS thickness, laser focusing, power, and speed on the resulting channel dimensions were investigated. Using optimized settings, the smallest channels that could be produced averaged 33 microm in depth (11.1% RSD, N= 6) and 110 microm in width (5.7% RSD, N= 6). The use of a PDMS substrate allowed reversible sealing of microchip components at room temperature without the need for cleanroom facilities. Using a layer of pre-cured polymer, devices were designed, ablated, and assembled within minutes. The final devices were used for microchip CE separation and detection of the fluorescently labeled neurotransmitters aspartate and glutamate.     

Protein tryptic digests analyzed by carrier ampholyte-based capillary electrophoresis coupled to ESI-MS

In this study, narrow pH cuts of carrier ampholytes have been used as buffers in CE for the analysis of protein tryptic digests. Their low conductivity allows very efficient separations under high electric field strength without inducing any significant Joule heating. In this study, the capabilities of narrow pH cuts of carrier ampholytes for the separation of protein tryptic digests have been assessed. Three proteins of different molecular masses have been studied: cytochrome C (horse heart), beta-lactoglobulin B (bovine) and human transferrin. Efficient, rapid and repeatable separations of the peptides resulting from the tryptic digestion have been achieved in this buffer. Moreover, the feasibility of the coupling of carrier ampholyte-based capillary electrophoresis with ESI-MS has been demonstrated through the study of the cytochrome C tryptic digest.     

Efficiency studies in nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis

Nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis (NACE) is a relatively new area with several advantages that include enhanced efficiency and improved detection sensitivity. The goal of this study was to investigate the influence of NACE compared to aqueous CE on the separation efficiency of oligosaccharides. The applied voltage and buffer concentration were optimized for the aqueous and nonaqueous buffer media to minimize the band broadening effects of Joule heating and electrophoretic dispersion. At the optimized conditions a 1.5-fold enhancement in efficiency was obtained with the nonaqueous buffer medium.     

Nonaqueous capillary electrophoresis with alcoholic background electrolytes: separation efficiency under high electrical field strengths

The effect of high voltage on capillary electrophoresis (CE) separations of anionic analytes in nonaqueous separation media was investigated. Methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, and 1-butanol were tested as background electrolyte (BGE) solvents. Experiments were carried out with a laboratory-built CE instrument suitable for high-voltage separations. Potentials up to 60 kV were applied with reversed polarity to generate unusually high field strengths (e.g. 2000 Vcm-1) and so achieve fast and efficient separations. Highest separation efficiencies were obtained with propanol as BGE solvent, and the dependency of the efficiency on the separation voltage was more or less linear. With the other alcohols, separation efficiency decreased or remained roughly constant with increasing absolute voltage. The separation efficiencies are discussed in terms of longitudinal diffusion, Joule heating, and analyte interaction with the capillary wall. Capillary preconditioning had a varied effect on the separations in the different BGEs as the BGE and the conditioning process affected the electroosmotic flow (EOF) velocity and direction.     

Numerical analysis of the thermal effect on electroosmotic flow and electrokinetic mass transport in microchannels

Joule heating is present in electrokinetically driven flow and mass transport in microfluidic systems. Nowadays, there is a trend of replacing costly glass-based microfluidic systems by the disposable, cheap polymer-based microfluidic systems. Due to poor thermal conductivity of polymer materials, the thermal management of the polymer-based microfluidic systems may become a problem. In this study, numerical analysis is presented for transient temperature development due to Joule heating and its effect on the electroosmotic flow (EOF) and mass species transport in microchannels. The proposed model includes the coupling Poisson-Boltzmann (P-B) equation, the modified Navier-Stokes (N-S) equations, the conjugate energy equation, and the mass species transport equation. The results show that the time development for both the electroosmotic flow field and the Joule heating induced temperature field are less than 1 s. The Joule heating induced temperature field is strongly dependent on channel size, electrolyte concentration, and applied electric field strength. The simulations reveal that the presence of the Joule heating can result in significantly different characteristics of the electroosmotic flow and electrokinetic mass transport in microchannels.     

Effect of Joule heating on efficiency and performance for microchip-based and capillary-based electrophoretic separation systems: a closer look

An attempt is made to revisit the main theoretical considerations concerning temperature effects ("Joule heating") in electro-driven separation systems, in particular lab-on-a-chip systems. Measurements of efficiencies in microfabricated devices under different Joule heating conditions are evaluated and compared to both theoretical models and measurements performed on conventional capillary systems. The widely accepted notion that planar microdevices are less susceptible to Joule heating effects is largely confirmed. The heat dissipation from a nonthermostatically controlled glass microdevice was found to be comparable to that from a liquid-cooled-fused silica capillary. Using typically dimensioned glass and glass/silicon microdevices, the experimental results indicate that 5-10 times higher electric field strengths can be applied than on conventional capillaries, before detrimental effects on the separation efficiency occur. The main influence of Joule heating on efficiency is via the establishment of a radial temperature profile across the lumen of the capillary or channel. An overall temperature increase of the buffer solution has only little influence on the quality of the separation. Still, active temperature control (cooling, thermostatting) can help prevent boiling of the buffer and increase the reproducibility of the results.     

Influence of moderate Joule heating on electroosmotic flow velocity, retention, and efficiency in capillary electrochromatography

The influence of Joule heating on electroosmotic flow velocity, the retention factor of neutral analytes, and separation efficiency in capillary electrochromatography was investigated theoretically and experimentally. A plot of electrical current against the applied electrical field strength was used to evaluate the Joule heating effect. When the mobile phase concentration of Tris buffer exceeded 5.0 mM in the studied capillary electrochromatography systems using particulate and monolithic columns (with an accompanying power level of heat dissipation higher than 0.35 W/m), the Joule heating effect became clearly noticeable. Theoretical models for describing the variation of electroosmotic flow velocity with increasing applied field strength and the change of retention factors for neutral analytes with electrical field strength at higher Tris buffer concentrations were analyzed to explain consequences of Joule heating in capillary electrochromatography. Qualitative agreement between experimental data and implications of the theoretical model analysis was observed. The decrease of separation efficiency in capillary electrochromatography with macroporous octadecylsilica particles at high buffer concentration can be also attributed to Joule heating mainly via the increased axial diffusion of the analyte molecules and dispersion of solute bands by a nonuniform electroosmotic flow profile over the column cross-section. However, within a moderate temperature range, the contribution of the macroscopic velocity profile in the column arising from radial temperature gradients is insignificant.     

High Electric Field Strengths in Micellar Electrokinetic Capillary Electrophoresis with Ionic Liquids as Modifiers

Abstract

In this study, a method for the separation and determination of basic analytes in aqueous capillary electrophoresis (CE) was developed based on high electric field strengths and ionic liquids (ILs). The resulting electric field strengths ranged from 500 to 1000 V/cm. Trishydroxymethylaminomethane (Tris) and sodium cholate (SC) were used as main electrolytes. The ionic liquids 1‐ethyl‐3‐methylimidazoium tetrafluoroborate (1E‐3MI‐TFB) and 1‐butyl‐3‐methylimidazoium tetrafluoroborate (1B‐3MI‐TFB) were used as modifiers to improve the separation efficiency and selectivity. It was shown that increasing the applied electric field strengths not only caused short analysis time, but also did not induce excessive Joule heating in the capillary when ionic liquids were used as modifiers. The susceptibility to high electric field of separation efficiency in capillary electrophoresis, with the effect of ionic liquids, was subsequently discussed, and the developed method was used to analyze three model analytes in Sinacalia tangutica. The accurate results illustrated that high electric field strength with the ionic liquids was feasible in CE.     

Interface for coupling nonaqueous wide-bore capillary electrophoresis with mass spectrometry

A liquid-junction-type interface where a thin spraying capillary is inserted inside the separation capillary was constructed for coupling nonaqueous wide-bore capillary electrophoresis (CE) to mass spectrometry (MS). The robust structure of the interface provided fairly easy capillary handling. The study was carried out with uncoated CE capillaries of 200 and 320 microm inner diameter (ID). 1-Propanol-acetonitrile (80:20 v/v) with acetate electrolyte provided a low conducting medium for CE and good spraying conditions for electrospray ionization (ESI) without sheath-flow and drying gas. Methamphetamine, alprenolol, and levorphanol served as model compounds. Approximate detection limits with the 200 microm ID capillary were 35-265 ng/mL.     

Parametric investigation on the effect of channel topologies on electrophoretic separations

This paper presents a systematic study that illustrates the importance of the topologies of microchannels on electrokinetically based separation. Using theoretical and numerical analyses, we designed and showed that topologies that significantly increased the surface-to-volume ratio of the channel can provide dramatic improvement in the ability of the channel both to dissipate the heat generated by Joule heating and to reduce the axial dispersion associated with the siphoning effect. The incremental benefit and tradeoff of geometric complexity was also evaluated. The improvement offered by topographically patterned channels, such as finned structures, is especially pertinent in the development of preparative or semi-preparative scale electrokinetically driven separations, such as capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography, in which large cross sections of channels are required to achieve the needed volumetric throughput.     

Capillary Electrophoresis of Water-Soluble Vitamins: An Undergraduate Experiment

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) is a relatively new analytical separation technique that is not usually introduced in the undergraduate analytical chemistry curriculum. The techniques growing popularity in research, industrial, and commercial laboratories, however, should be a reason to consider its introduction at this level. Here, we describe an exercise utilizing capillary zone electrophoresis and micellar electrokinetic chromatography. This exercise provides a suitable introduction to capillary electrophoresis and illustrates the mechanism for the separation of ionized and nonionized water-soluble vitamins (B1, B2 phosphate, B3 niacinamide, and B12). Joule heating can also be easily introduced as part of the exercise.     

Tryptic digest mapping by gradient capillary electrochromatography

A high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) system complemented with T-split, capillary detection cell and a high voltage power supply was used for peptide mapping by gradient electrochromatography and nanoliquid chromatography (nano-LC). With capillary columns of 100 microm ID, 6 cm packed with octadecylated 1.5 microm silica particles, the typical analysis time was approximately 10-15 min. The resolution of a tryptic digest of cytochrome c obtained by electrochromatography at 100 kV/m was superior compared to the analysis by nano-LC. Bubble formation caused by Joule heating at currents up to 100 microA was successfully suppressed by using a resistor capillary of 25 microm ID connected to the outlet of the packed column.     

Electrochromatography with a 2.7 mm inner diameter monolithic column

Monolithic columns of 2.7 mm I.D. have been prepared and used in electrochromatography (EC) separation. Although capillary electrochromatography (CEC) has higher separation efficiency, it displays some shortcomings, such as limited sample loadability and restricted concentration detectability etc. In this paper, we investigate the feasibility of EC separation with millimeter diameter monolithic columns. By using a designed preparation method of monolithic column packed with about 150 microm quartz sand, the effect of Joule heating can be reduced, and the processes of frit making and column packing can be avoided. The concentration detectability of the EC is improved comparing with that of CEC. Moreover, the separation efficiency of 52,000 plates/m was achieved with a 70 mm length and 2.7 mm I.D. monolithic column.     

Joule heating in packed capillaries used in capillary electrochromatography

Effective heat dissipation is critical for reproducible and efficient separations in electrically driven separation systems. Flow rate, retention kinetics, and analyte diffusion rates are some of the characteristics that are affected by variation in the temperature of the mobile phase inside the column. In this study, we examine the issue of Joule heating in packed capillary columns used in capillary electrochromatography (CEC). As almost all commonly used CEC packings are poor thermal conductors, it is assumed that the packing particles do not conduct heat and heat transfer is solely through the mobile phase flowing through the system. The electrical conductivity of various mobile phases was measured at different temperatures by a conductivity meter and the temperature coefficient for each mobile phase was calculated. This was followed by measurement of the electrical current at several applied voltages to calculate the conductivity of the solution within the column as a function of the applied voltage. An overall increase in the conductivity is attributed to Joule heating within the column, while a constant conductivity means good heat dissipation. A plot of conductivity versus applied voltage was used as the indicator of poor heat dissipation. Using theories that have been proposed earlier for modeling of Joule heating effects in capillary electrophoresis (CE), we estimated the temperature within CEC columns. Under mobile and stationary phase conditions typically used in CEC, heat dissipation was found to be not always efficient. Elevated temperatures within the columns in excess of 23 degrees C above ambient temperature were calculated for packed columns, and about 35 degrees C for an open column, under a given set of conditions. The results agree with recently published experimental findings with nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) thermometry, and Raman spectroscopic measurements.