Effect of liquid oils on the properties of multiple emulsions containing liquid crystals

Recently, many cosmetic researchers have been focused on multiple emulsions due to better performance. Limited application of multiple emulsions has been attributed to their instability, which can be resolved by the presence of liquid crystals. Multiple emulsions containing liquid crystals are affected by various formulation parameters, such as liquid oils. In this paper, the influence of liquid oils on the formation mechanism was studied. Besides, stability, small-angle x-ray scattering (SAXS) spectra analysis, and rheological analysis of the emulsions were investigated as well. The results showed that when the gap of the polarity between inner oils and external liquid oils is greater, the multiple structures were more easily formed. Multiple emulsions containing liquid crystals were superior in stability to multiple emulsions prepared in the same way with liquid oils that did not form liquid crystals. SAXS indicated that the liquid crystal orientation was lamellar. Rheological analysis indicated that the different structure emulsions showed shear-thinning behavior. The presence of liquid crystal decreased the viscosity and resulted in pseudoplastic enhancement. Both the storage modulus (G′) and the loss modulus (G″) of multiple emulsions were slightly higher than those of O/W-type emulsions, implying the existence of multiple structures.     

FORMATION AND APPLICATIONS OF MULTIPLE EMULSIONS

Multiple emulsions, especially water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) type systems, have potential applications for the formulation and processing of foods, drugs, cosmetics, etc, as each dispersed globule in this type of emulsions consists of liquid compartments separated from the same liquid suspending medium by a thin layer of another immiscible liquid components. This article reviews a series of fundamental works on the formation and dispersion state of multiple emulsion systems and integrates advances made in the area of colloid science so as to obtain further insights into the formulation of W/O/W emulsions. The contents are divided into three sections: methods for preparing multiple emulsions in view of the phase diagram of mixed components, dynamic aspects of oil layer in W/O/W emulsions, and stability of this type of emulsions.     

Emulsifying potency of new amino acid-type surfactant (II): stable water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions containing 85 wt% inner water phase

The ternary phase diagram for N-[3-lauryloxy-2-hydroxypropyl]-L-arginine L-glutamate (C12HEA-Glu), a new amino acid-type surfactant, /oleic acid (OA)/water system was established. The liquid crystal and gel complex formations between C12HEA-Glu and OA were applied to a preparation of water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions. Stable W/O emulsions containing liquid paraffin (LP) as the oil and a mixture of C12HEA-Glu and OA as the emulsifier were formed. The preparation of stable W/O emulsions containing 85 wt% water phase was also possible, in which water droplets would be polygonally transformed and closely packed, since the maximum percentage of inner phase is 74% assuming uniformly spherical droplets. Water droplets would be taken into the liquid crystalline phase (or the gel complex) and the immovable water droplets would stabilize the W/O emulsion system. The viscosity of emulsions abruptly increased above the 75 wt% water phase (dispersed phase). The stability of W/O emulsions with a lower weight ratio of OA to C12HEA-Glu and a higher ratio of water phase was greater. This unusual phenomenon may be related to the formation of a liquid crystalline phase between C12HEA-Glu and OA, and the stability of the liquid crystal at a lower ratio of oil (continuous phase). W/O and oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions containing LP were selectively prepared using a mixture of C12HEA-Glu and OA since the desirable hydrophile-lipophile balance (HLB) number for the emulsification was obtainable by mixing the two emulsifiers.     

Multiple emulsion stability: pressure balance and interfacial film strength

The objective of this study was to investigate the significance of inner and outer phase pressure, as well as interfacial film strength on W/O/W multiple emulsion stability using microscopy and long-term stability tests. It was observed that immediately upon applying a coverslip to samples the multiple droplets deformed and there was coalescence of the inner aqueous droplets. Under certain conditions (such as lipophilic surfactant concentration and internal phase osmotic pressure) the destabilized multiple emulsions formed unique metastable structures that had a "dimpled" appearance. The formation of these metastable structures correlated with the real-time instability of the W/O/W multiple emulsions investigated. Multiple emulsion stability also correlated with the interfacial film strength (measured by interfacial elasticity) of the hydrophobic surfactant at the mineral oil/external continuous aqueous phase interface. The formation of the metastable dimpled structures and the long-term stability of the multiple emulsions were dependent on the osmotic pressure of the inner droplets and the Laplace curvature pressure as described by the Walstra Equation (P. Walstra, "Encyclopedia of Emulsion Technology" (P. Becher, Ed.), Vol. 4. Dekker, New York, 1996). It appears that the effect of coverslip pressure on multiple emulsions may be useful as an accelerated stability testing method or for initial formulation screening.     

Improved formulation of W/O/W multiple emulsion for insulin encapsulation. Influence of the chemical structure of insulin

W/O/W multiple emulsions are systems of potential interest in the oral administration of insulin. Although it has been shown that a single oral administration of insulin-loaded W/O/W multiple emulsion to diabetic rats led to the significant decrease of blood glucose levels (Silva Cunha et al., 1998, Int J Pharm 169:33), repeated administrations displayed unpleasant side effects such as diarrhoea and steatosis. These unwanted effects were attributed to the high oil concentration used for their preparation. In the present study, attention was focused on the reduction of oil concentration in the formulation of these systems and on the encapsulation of two different insulins. The physical properties and stability of the multiple emulsions over long periods of time were assessed by conductivity measurements, and granulometric and microscopic analyses. The encapsulation in the inner aqueous phase of two insulins, Umulin and Humalog, differing only by the transposition of one amino acid, had non-negligible effects on the formation and stability of W/O/W multiple emulsions. Both insulins were shown to improve the formation of the multiple emulsions. Circular dichroism studies and surface tension measurements evidenced the contribution of insulin conformation and surface properties in multiple emulsion formation and stability.     

Role of liquid crystal in the emulsification of a gel emulsion with high internal phase fraction

A gel emulsion with high internal oil phase volume fraction was formed via an inversion process induced by a water–oil ratio change. The process involved the formation of intermediate multiple emulsions prior to inversion. The multiple emulsions contain a liquid crystal formed by the surfactant with water; this was both predicted by the equilibrium phase diagram as well as observed using polarization microscopy. These multiple emulsions were more stable compared to alternative multiple emulsions prepared in the same way with a surfactant that does not form liquid crystals. While the formation of a stable intermediate multiple emulsion may not be a necessary condition for the inversion to occur, the transitional presence of a liquid crystal proved to be a significant factor in the stabilization of the intermediate multiple emulsions. The resulting gel emulsion contained a small fraction of the liquid crystal according to the phase diagram, and it exhibited excellent stability.     

W/O/W多重乳液中水传递的控制

建立了简化的W/O/W(水/油/水)多重乳液乳珠模型——统计平均半径模型, 预测出当W/O/W多重乳液内水相水滴之间以及内外水相之间均达到水传递平衡时的内外水相中盐的浓度, 从而实现对水传递的控制, 以维持W/O/W多重乳液的稳定. 按理论预测制备出了不同稳定态的W/O/W多重乳液, 利用差分扫描量热仪(DSC)检测了多重乳液中水的传递过程, 确定体系在实验状态下的稳定程度, 实验结果与理论预测基本吻合.     

Influence of composition on the encapsulation properties of P/O/W multiple emulsions for Vitamin C

Abstract

The aim of this work was to study the encapsulation properties of polyols-in-oil-in-water (P/O/W) multiple emulsions for Vitamin C (Vc). The influence of formulation factors, including the concentration of lipophilic emulsifier, hydrophilic emulsifier, salt and glycerol had been investigated. The results indicated that the encapsulation stability could be improved by increasing the lipophilic emulsifier concentration which could strengthen the interfacial film. In contrast, the excess of hydrophilic emulsifier destabilized the emulsion. The presence of glycerol in the outer aqueous phase accelerated the phase transfer, thus reduced the encapsulation rate. The addition of salt in inner polyols phase had little effect on encapsulation rate while markedly affected the morphology and stability of this system. P/O/W multiple emulsions showed better encapsulation stability than the W/O/W multiple emulsions as the former’s encapsulation rate could remain more than 75% after 2?weeks while the latter only remained less than 60%. Meanwhile, the P/O/W emulsions exhibited higher storage modulus (G’), bigger loss modulus (G’’) and broaden linear viscoelastic regions than W/O/W emulsions.     

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in multiple W/O/W emulsions

Multiple water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) emulsions offer a huge potential as encapsulation systems in different food, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical applications. Because of their complex structure, however, it is difficult to characterize these systems. Typical measurement techniques to determine the size and stability of the inner water droplets encapsulated in the oil droplets show limitations and inaccuracies. Determining the total amount of water in the inner droplets is most often done by indirect methods to date. We describe an analytical method based on differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) for characterizing the total amount of encapsulated water droplets and their stability in W/O/W multiple emulsions. It uses the possibility to directly determine the latent heat of freezing of water droplets of the same size and composition as in the multiple emulsions. The amount of water in the inner droplets of a W/O/W emulsion can thus be calculated very accurately. It is shown that this method enables furthermore detecting multi-modalities in the size distribution of inner water droplets in W/O/W emulsions. Changes in droplet size distribution of the inner droplets occurring during the second emulsification step of processing or during storage can be detected. DSC thus offers a powerful tool to characterize the structure of multiple W/O/W emulsions.     

Initial inter-phase transport of compounds in a model emulsion system

Three-phase geranyl acetate emulsions stabilized by a non-ionic surfactant, Laureth 4, were prepared with a constant weight fraction of a lamellar liquid crystal and varied aqueous to oil phase weight ratios according to the phase diagram. The appearance and micrographs of the drop pattern versus time were recorded. As expected, emulsions with the lower values of the water to oil (W/O) ratio appeared to be of the W/O variety while the two more stable emulsions with the highest W/O ratio appeared as oil to water (O/W). Considering the surfactant exclusive solubility in the oil, this result was unexpected and the emulsions were investigated as to their structure. Unpredictably, all the emulsions were of the O/W kind; including the highest ratio of oil to water. The reason for this unanticipated outcome was the lamellar liquid crystal being dispersed into the aqueous phase at the slightest perturbation.     

Stability versus phase ratios of geranyl acetate three-phase emulsions

Three-phase geranyl acetate emulsions stabilized by a non-ionic surfactant, Laureth 4, were prepared with a constant weight fraction of a lamellar liquid crystal and varied aqueous to oil phase weight ratios according to the phase diagram. The appearance and micrographs of the drop pattern versus time were recorded. As expected, emulsions with the lower values of the water to oil (W/O) ratio appeared to be of the W/O variety while the two more stable emulsions with the highest W/O ratio appeared as oil to water (O/W). Considering the surfactant exclusive solubility in the oil, this result was unexpected and the emulsions were investigated as to their structure. Unpredictably, all the emulsions were of the O/W kind; including the highest ratio of oil to water. The reason for this unanticipated outcome was the lamellar liquid crystal being dispersed into the aqueous phase at the slightest perturbation.     

Fat crystals and water-in-oil emulsion stability

Products such as cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, and crude oil often exist as water-in-oil (W/O) emulsions during their processing or in final form. In many cases, their dispersed aqueous phase is encased in a crystal network and/or by interfacially-adsorbed (‘Pickering’) particles [paraffins, triacylglycerols, polymers, etc.] that promote emulsion kinetic stability by hindering droplet–droplet contact, coalescence and macroscopic phase separation. In processed foods, important questions remain regarding whether a continuous phase fat crystal network or Pickering crystal provides better stabilization. This review explores the following factors related to crystal-stabilized W/O emulsions: i) the key properties dictating fat crystal spatial distribution (at the interface or in the continuous phase); ii) how temperature and freeze–thaw emulsion destabilization are intimately linked with fat crystal spatial distribution, and; iii) why oil-soluble surfactant interactions with the continuous oil phase influence fat crystal wettability and emulsifier efficacy. It is shown that these parameters strongly govern W/O emulsion formation and stability.     

Effects of compositions on the stability of polyols-in-oil-in-water (P/O/W) multiple emulsions

Polyols-in-oil-in-water (P/O/W) multiple emulsions were successfully prepared by using polyols as inner aqueous phase to avoid instabilities caused by water. The influence of polyols, oils and emulsifiers on the morphology and stability of P/O/W multiple emulsions were studied and the stability mechanisms of this new kind of multiple emulsions were also explored. Glycerol that has the worst solubility in oil phase contributed to the formation of stable inner droplets which agree with the Ostwald Ripening theory. Mineral oil worked well with the system proving that oils possessing similar solubility parameters with the hydrophobic group of emulsifiers benefited for system stability. Several typical surfactants had been investigated in this article, and it turned out that emulsifiers Cetyl PEG/PPG-10/1 Dimethicone and the block copolymer Poloxamer 407 were suitable for the P/O/W system. The stability of the system affected by different compositions was evaluated based on microscopic observation and rheological measurements. The novel multiple emulsions will provide enlightening recommendations for future investigations and applications in cosmetic, food and pharmaceuticals, including drug delivery and the encapsulation of hydrophilic actives and actives that are soluble in polyols.     

Formation and properties of reverse micellar cubic liquid crystals and derived emulsions

The structure of the reverse micellar cubic (I2) liquid crystal and the adjacent micellar phase in amphiphilic block copolymer/water/oil systems has been studied by small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), rheometry, and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). Upon addition of water to the copolymer/oil mixture, spherical micelles are formed and grow in size until a disorder-order transition takes place, which is related to a sudden increase in the viscosity and shear modulus. The transition is driven by the packing of the spherical micelles into a Fd3m cubic lattice. The single-phase I2 liquid crystals show gel-like behavior and elastic moduli higher than 104 Pa, as determined by oscillatory measurements. Further addition of water induces phase separation, and it is found that reverse water-in-oil emulsions with high internal phase ratio and stabilized by I2 liquid crystals can be prepared in the two-phase region. Contrary to liquid-liquid emulsions, both the elastic modulus and the viscosity decrease with the fraction of dispersed water, due to a decrease in the crystalline fraction in the sample, although the reverse emulsions remain gel-like even at high volume fractions of the dispersed phase. A temperature induced order-disorder transition can be detected by calorimetry and rheometry. Upon heating the I2 liquid crystals, two thermal events associated with small enthalpy values were detected: one endothermic, related to the "melting" of the liquid crystal, and the other exothermic, attributed to phase separation. The melting of the liquid crystal is associated with a sudden drop in viscosity and shear moduli. Results are relevant for understanding the formation of cubic-phase-based reverse emulsions and for their application as templates for the synthesis of structured materials.     

Synthesis and characterization of PEO-PCL-PEO triblock copolymers: effects of the PCL chain length on the physical property of W(1)/O/W(2) multiple emulsions

A series of poly(ethylene glycol)-block-poly(epsilon-caprolactone)-block-poly(ethylene glycol) (PEO-PCL-PEO) triblock copolymers were prepared and then used for the investigation of the effects of the ratio of epsilon-caprolactone to poly(ethylene glycol) (i.e., [CL]/[EO]) on the physical properties of water-in-oil-in-water (W(1)/O/W(2)) multiple emulsions containing a model reagent, ascorbic acid-2-glucoside (AA2G). In the synthesis, the [CL]/[EO] was varied from 0.11 to 0.31. The molecular weights and compositions of PEO-PCL-PEO were determined by GPC and (1)H NMR analyses. Thermal behavior and crystal formation were studied by DSC, XRD, FT-IR, and polarized optical microscopy (POM). Aggregate behavior of PEO-PCL-PEO was confirmed by DLS, UV, and (1)H NMR. Morphology and relative stiffness of the W(1)/O/W(2) multiple emulsions in the presence of PEO-PCL-PEO were studied by confocal laser scanning microscopy (CLSM) and rheometer. Variation in the [CL]/[EO] significantly affects the crystalline temperature and spherulite morphology of PEO-PCL-PEO. As the [CL]/[EO] increases, the CMCs of PEO-PCL-PEO decreases and the slope of aggregate size reduction against the copolymer concentration becomes steeper except for the lowest [CL]/[EO] value of PEO-PCL-PEO (i.e., P-222). P-222 significantly increases the viscosity of continuous (W(2)) phase, which implies the copolymer would exist in the W(2) phase. On the other hand, the triblock copolymers with relatively high [CL]/[EO] ratios mainly contribute to the size reduction of multiple emulsions and the formation of a firm wall structure. The particle size of the multiple emulsion decreases and the elastic modulus increased as [CL]/[EO] increases, confirmed by microscopic and rheometric analyses.     

Relationship between rheological properties and one-step W/O/W multiple emulsion formation

Formation of a normal (not temporary) W/O/W multiple emulsion via the one-step method as a result of the simultaneous occurrence of catastrophic and transitional phase inversion processes has been recently reported. Critical features of this process include the emulsification temperature (corresponding to the ultralow surface tension point), the use of a specific nonionic surfactant blend and the surfactant blend/oil phase ratio, and the addition of the surfactant blend to the oil phase. The purpose of this study was to investigate physicochemical properties in an effort to gain a mechanistic understanding of the formation of these emulsions. Bulk, surface, and interfacial rheological properties of adsorbed nonionic surfactant (CremophorRH40 and Span80) films were investigated under conditions known to affect W/O/W emulsion formation. Bulk viscosity results demonstrated that CremophorRH40 has a higher mobility in oil compared than in water, explaining the significance of the solvent phase. In addition, the bulk viscosity profile of aqueous solutions containing CremophorRH40 indicated a phase transition at around 78 ± 2 °C, which is in agreement with cubic phase formation in the Winsor III region. The similarity in the interfacial elasticity values of CremophorRH40 and Span80 indicated that canola oil has a major effect on surface activity, showing the significance of vegetable oil. The highest interfacial shear elasticity and viscosity were observed when both surfactants were added to the oil phase, indicating the importance of the microstructural arrangement. CremophorRH40/Span80 complexes tended to desorb from the solution/solution interface with increasing temperature, indicating surfactant phase formation as is theoretically predicted in the Winsor III region. Together these interfacial and bulk rheology data demonstrate that one-step W/O/W emulsions form as a result of the simultaneous occurrence of phase-transition processes in the Winsor III region and explain the critical formulation and processing parameters necessary to achieve the formation of these normal W/O/W emulsions.     

A one-step process for oil-in-water-in-oil double emulsion formation using a single surfactant

A one-step double emulsification protocol using one surfactant was developed for oil-in-water-in-oil (O(1)/W/O(2)) double emulsions. Two n-alkane oils and three different surfactants were studied, with focus placed on a formulation containing mineral oil, glycerol monoleate (GMO) and deionized water. Phenomenologically, double emulsion formation and stability originate from the combined actions of phase inversion and interfacial charging of the oil/water interface during high shear homogenization. Based on the extent of double emulsion formation and stability, a critical emulsification zone dependent on the weight ratios of GMO to water was identified. Within this critical zone, enhanced O(1)/W/O(2) emulsion formation occurred at higher pH and lower salt concentrations, demonstrating the key role of interfacial charging on double emulsification. Overall, this novel approach provides a novel platform for the development of double emulsions with simple compositions and processing requirements.     

Screening of the effect of surface energy of microchannels on microfluidic emulsification

We report the results of a systematic study of the effect of the surface energy of the walls of microchannels on emulsification in parallel flow-focusing microfluidic devices. We investigated the formation of water-in-oil (W/O) and oil-in-water (O/W) emulsions and found that the stability of microfluidic emulsification depends critically on the preferential wetting of the walls of the microfluidic device by the continuous phase. The condition for stable operation of the device is, however, different than that of complete wetting of the walls by the continuous phase at equilibrium. We found that W/O emulsions form when the advancing contact angle of water on the channel wall exceeds theta approximately 92 degrees. This result is unexpected because at equilibrium even for theta < 92 degrees the microchannels would be completely wet by the organic phase. The criterion for the formation of W/O emulsions (theta > 92 degrees) is thus more stringent than the equilibrium conditions. Conversely, we observed the stable formation of O/W emulsions for theta < 92 degrees, that is, when the nonequilibrium transition to complete wetting by oil takes place. These results underlie the importance of pinning and the kinetic wetting effects in microfluidic emulsification. The results suggest that the use of parallel devices can facilitate fast screening of physicochemical conditions for emulsification.     

A New System of Multiple Emulsions with Lamellar Gel Phases from Vegetable Oil

Emulsions are excellent pharmaceutical vehicles used in both the pharmacy and cosmetic industries. Vegetable oils have several effects/benefits on skin and can be used in emulsions to release principal active components for cosmetic purposes. Herein, multiple W/O/W emulsions were formulated in a one-step emulsification method, and the resulting anisotropic structures were characterized by x-ray diffraction measurements. The multiple emulsions obtained were stable and maintained their anisotropic structures over 2 years. WAXS (wide-angle x-ray scattering) measurements of these emulsions suggested that the carbon chains of the surfactant around the globules are disposed in a gel network phase. Furthermore, SAXS (small-angle x-ray scattering) measurements indicated that the surfactant is organized in lamellar layers around the globules. Thus, for the first time, we demonstrated that stable lamellar gel phase multiple emulsions can be made from vegetable oils. In addition to having the advantage of being prepared in one step, these emulsions have desirable characteristics that can be used in the cosmetic industry as natural active principles with low surfactant concentration and the unique features of multiple emulsions with gel phases.     

Fat crystals: A tool to inhibit molecular transport in W/O/W double emulsions

Water-in-oil-in-water (W/O/W) double emulsions are a promising technology for encapsulation applications of water soluble compounds with respect to functional food systems. Yet molecular transport through the oil phase is a well-known problem for liquid oil-based double emulsions. The influence of network crystallization in the oil phase of W/O/W globules was evaluated by NMR and laser light scattering experiments on both a liquid oil-based double emulsion and a solid fat-based double emulsion. Water transport was assessed by low-resolution NMR diffusometry and by an osmotically induced swelling or shrinking experiment, whereas manganese ion permeation was followed by means of T₂-relaxometry. The solid fat-based W/O/W globules contained a crystal network with about 80% solid fat. This W/O/W emulsion showed a reduced molecular water exchange and a slower manganese ion influx in the considered time frame, whereas its globule size remained stable under the applied osmotic gradients. The reduced permeability of the oil phase is assumed to be caused by the increased tortuosity of the diffusive path imposed by the crystal network. This solid network also provided mechanical strength to the W/O/W globules to counteract the applied osmotic forces.