Comparison of one-dimensional and comprehensive two-dimensional separations by gas chromatography

Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) can reveal information on the composition of a sample in a way that cannot be done by one-dimensional GC (1D-GC). GC x GC also offers much greater control of chromatographic selectivity based on molecular structure. However, in spite of more than 15 years of claims of the ability of GC x GC to resolve an overwhelmingly larger number of peaks than 1D-GC, and in spite of the theoretically proven potential of GC x GC to have an order of magnitude larger peak capacity than 1D-GC, the peak capacity of currently practiced GC x GC does not generally exceed the peak capacity attainable from 1D-GC with the same analysis time and the same minimal detectable concentration (MDC). The methodology for comparing the peak capacity of GC x GC to 1D-GC is described. The comparison of the performance of GC x GC to 1D-GC shows that the modulator is the key bottleneck limiting the performance of existing GC x GC. To realize the full potential of GC x GC, duration of injection from a modulator into the second-dimension column should be reduced by an order of magnitude or more. Use of powerful data analysis techniques such as peak deconvolution in both dimensions can further increase resolving power of GC x GC.     

A theoretical basis for parameter selection and instrument design in comprehensive size-exclusion chromatography x liquid chromatography

A novel approach for the selection of the operational parameters (linear velocity, column length) for a comprehensive 2D-LC system is discussed. Starting point for the calculations is a given second dimension ((2)D) separation and a desired peak capacity for the 2D system. Using the theory developed here the optimum settings for the first dimension ((1)D) column can be derived. Theory clearly indicates that the choice of the (1)D conditions is basically limited to just one set of column lengths and linear velocities. The new method is tested on a comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography system which uses size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) followed by reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC). A novel LC/LC interface, using a six-port valve rather than storage loops, joins the two chromatographic dimensions. From a theoretical comparison of continuous low flow and stop-flow operation the latter method was found to be an attractive mode of interfacing. The common idea that stop-flow operation results in additional band broadening is shown to be incorrect. The new interface design operated in the stop-flow mode permits the use of conventional analytical diameter HPLC columns, 7.8mm for SEC and 4.6mm for RPLC. The reversed phase chromatography utilizes a monolithic C-18 modified silica column, which produces fast and efficient analyses. As test samples complex mixtures of peptides were analyzed.     

Using computer modeling to predict and optimize separations for comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography

In order to fully realize the separation power of comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC), a means of predicting and optimizing separations based on operating variables was developed. This approach initially calculates the enthalpy (DeltaH) and entropy (DeltaS) for the target compounds from experimental input data, and then uses this information to simultaneously optimize all column and runtime variables, including stationary phase composition, by comparing the performance of large numbers of simulated separations. This use of computer simulation has been shown to be a useful aid in conventional separations. It becomes almost essential for GC x GC optimization because of the large number of variables involved and their very complex interaction. Agreement between experimental and predicted values of standard test samples (Grob mix) using GC x GC separation shows that this approach is accurate. We believe that this success can be extended to more challenging mixtures resulting in optimizations that are simpler and transferable between GC x GC instruments.     

Molecular size fractionation of soil humic acids using preparative high performance size-exclusion chromatography

High performance size-exclusion chromatography (HPSEC) is useful for the molecular size separation of soil humic acids (HAs), but there is no method available for various HAs with different chemical properties. In this paper the authors propose a new preparative HPSEC method for various soil HAs. Three soil HAs with different chemical properties were fractionated by a Shodex OHpak SB-2004 HQ column with 10mM sodium phosphate buffer (pH 7.0)/acetonitrile (3:1, v/v) as an eluent. The HAs eluted within a reasonable column range time (12-25 min) without peak tailing. Preparative HPSEC chromatograms of these HAs indicated that non-size-exclusion effects were suppressed. The separated fractions were analyzed by HPSEC to determine their apparent molecular weights. These decreased sequentially from fraction 1 to fraction 10, suggesting that the HAs had been separated by their molecular size. The size-separated fractions of the soil HA were mixed to compare them with unfractionated HA. The analytical HPSEC chromatogram of the mixed HA was almost identical to that of the unfractionated HA. It appears that the HAs do not adsorb specifically to the column during preparative HPSEC. Our preparative HPSEC method allows for rapid and reproducible separation of various soil HAs by molecular size.     

Comprehensive two-dimensional separations of complex mixtures using reversed-phase reversed-phase liquid chromatography

A comprehensive two-dimensional reversed-phase reversed-phase liquid chromatographic system for the separation of a complex mixture of oligostyrenes was developed using results from a previous theoretical assessment of the informational similarity, percent synentropy, orthogonality and peak capacity of hypothetically coupled systems. The degree of sample attribute order in the first separation dimension was also used in the development of the experimental two-dimensional system. A C18(methanol)/CCZ(acetonitrile) two-dimensional system was chosen for the comprehensive analysis of the oligostyrene mixtures because this system had the lowest solute crowding, highest orthogonality and was observed to have order with respect to a sample attribute in the first separation dimension. The separations achieved were in full agreement with the results from information theory and (a geometric approach to) factor analysis assessments. High sampling rates in the first liquid chromatographic dimension were shown to be impossible or inefficient when the peak capacity and separation time of the second dimension was high or when the aim of the exercise was to isolate individual sample constituents in high yield.     

Columns and optimum gradient conditions for fast second-dimension separations in comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography

Gradient elution provides significantly higher peak capacity in comparison to the isocratic elution mode, hence it is very useful in online comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography (LC). We compared suitability of five commercial core-shell columns and one monolithic column for fast gradients in the second LC dimension, where the time of separation is strictly limited by the fraction cycle time. In two-dimensional reversed-phase systems with partially correlated retention, the resolution, the peak capacity, and the regularity of coverage of the second-dimension retention space can be improved by appropriate adjusting the gradient time and the gradient range to suit the sample properties. We developed a new strategy for adjusting the gradient mobile phase composition range in the second-dimension, employing the retention data of representative sample standards characterizing the sample properties, which can be calibrated using the reference alkylbenzene series. Optimized second-dimension gradients with single-step or segmented profiles covering two or more fraction ranges, employed for the separation of subsequent fractions from the first-dimension, improve significantly the resolution, the separation time, and the regularity of coverage of the two-dimensional retention plane. The approach was applied to the two-dimensional comprehensive separation of phenolic acids and flavonoid compounds occurring as natural antioxidants.     

Optimization of two-dimensional gradient liquid chromatography separations

An almost orthogonal comprehensive two-dimensional liquid chromatography was developed for the separation of phenolic and flavone natural antioxidants by using combinations of a polyethylene glycol silica micro-column in the first dimension and a porous-shell fused-core C18 column in the second dimension, both in the reversed-phase mode. System orthogonality was improved using parallel gradients of acetonitrile in buffered mobile phase. A new approach was proposed to optimize matching segmented gradient profiles in the two dimensions. An algorithm was developed for automatic corrections of the shifts in retention in the second dimension induced by the parallel two-dimensional gradient operation technique. Using the porous-shell C18 column in the second dimension at elevated temperature (60 degrees C) and high pressure (480 bar) with optimized segmented profiles of the parallel gradients in the two dimensions, the overall separation time for comprehensive LC x LC was reduced to 30 min.     

The evolution of comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC)

For a technology little over a decade old, comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) has quickly reached the status of one of the most powerful analytical tools for volatile organic compounds. At the heart of any GC x GC system is an interface, which physically connects the primary and the secondary columns and acts to preserve the separation obtained in the first dimension (first column) while allowing additional separation in the second dimension. The paper presents a review of the technology, including fundamental principles of the technique, data processing and interpretation and a timeline of inventive contributions to interface design. In addition, applications of the technique are presented, with a more detailed discussion of selected examples.     

Transfer-volume effects in two-dimensional chromatography: adsorption-phenomena in second-dimension size-exclusion chromatography

Gradient-elution LC × LC is a valuable technique for the characterization of complex biological samples as well as for synthetic polymers. Breakthrough and viscous fingering may yield misleading information on the sample characteristics or deteriorate separation. In LC × SEC another phenomenon may jeopardize the separation. If the analytes adsorb on the SEC column under the injection-plug conditions, peak splitting may occur. In LC × LC the effluent from the first column is the sample solvent for the analytes injected into the second dimension. If a gradient-elution LC × SEC setup is used (i.e. if reversed-phase gradient-elution LC is coupled to organic SEC and if normal-phase gradient-elution LC is coupled to SEC with a polar solvent), the percentage of weak solvent may be significant, especially at short analysis times. In this case adsorption in the first-dimension-effluent zone on the second-dimension SEC column can become an issue and two peaks--the first eluting in size-exclusion mode and the second undergoing adsorption--can be obtained. The work presented in this paper documents peak splitting in LC × SEC of polymers. The adsorption of the polymer on the size-exclusion column was proven in one-dimensional isocratic runs. The observed effects were modeled and visualized through simulation. Studies on the influence of the transfer volume were carried out. Keeping the transfer volume as small as possible helped to minimize peak splitting due to adsorption.     

Behavior of polysaccharide assemblies in field-flow fractionation and size-exclusion chromatography

Asymmetric flow field-flow fractionation (AsFlFFF) and high-performance size-exclusion chromatography (HPSEC) are techniques for separating and characterizing macromolecules; until now the latter is more utilized for analyzing polysaccharides. The demand for characterizing complex, high-molar-mass polysaccharides has raised interest in the use of AsFlFFF in analyzing polymeric carbohydrates in addition to HPSEC. In this paper, we compare the behavior of arabinoxylan aggregates present in aqueous solution in AsFlFFF and HPSEC and their effect on the obtained molecular characteristics (molar mass averages and size). Although the amount of aggregates in aqueous arabinoxylan solutions may be low, their role needs to be understood to avoid erroneous interpretations of AsFlFFF and HPSEC data. When these two separation systems were compared, AsFlFFF seemed to possess more separation power for the differentiation of aggregates from individual chains than HPSEC. To our knowledge, this is the first report on the characterization of xylans with AsFlFFF.     

Recent advancements in comprehensive two-dimensional separations with chemometrics

Comprehensive two-dimensional (2D) separations provide the analyst with a tremendous amount of complex data. In order to glean useful information from this complex data, advancements in commercially available software that implement chemometrics are currently available and continue to evolve. Future advancements will no doubt involve commercializing (or adapting) specialized, in-house chemometric techniques that are currently found only in the hands of technical experts and researchers in industry, government, and academia. In order to make timely advancements, future commercialization of novel chemometric techniques should involve collaborations among instrument software manufacturers, professional programmers, technical experts, and researchers. During the last decade, this field has seen a steady advancement from single analyte target analysis to comprehensive non-target analysis of entire multidimensional sample profiles (involving sample classification and/or data mining for discovery-based sample comparisons). The advancements in instrumentation and chemometric software tools have a tremendous impact in various applications: fuels, food, environmental, pharmaceuticals, metabolomics, etc. Most of the development has been for software to apply with gas chromatography-based instrumentation, such as comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC x GC) and comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography with time-of-flight mass spectrometry (GC x GC-TOF-MS). More recently there have been notable advancements in liquid-phase instrumentation as well.     

Modulation-induced error in comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic separations

There is a fundamental difference between data collected in comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatographic (GCxGC) separations and data collected by one-dimensional GC techniques (or heart-cut GC techniques). This difference can be ascribed to the fact that GCxGC generates multiple sub-peaks for each analyte, as opposed to other GC techniques that generate only a single chromatographic peak for each analyte. In order to calculate the total signal for the analyte, the most commonly used approach is to consider the cumulative area that results from the integration of each sub-peak. Alternately, the data may be considered using higher order techniques such as the generalized rank annihilation method (GRAM). Regardless of the approach, the potential errors are expected to be greater for trace analytes where the sub-peaks are close to the limit of detection (LOD). This error is also expected to be compounded with phase-induced error, a phenomenon foreign to the measurement of single peaks. Here these sources of error are investigated for the first time using both the traditional integration-based approach and GRAM analysis. The use of simulated data permits the sources of error to be controlled and independently evaluated in a manner not possible with real data. The results of this study show that the error introduced by the modulation process is at worst 1% for analyte signals with a base peak height of 10xLOD and either approach to quantitation is used. Errors due to phase shifting are shown to be of greater concern, especially for trace analytes with only one or two visible sub-peaks. In this case, the error could be as great as 6.4% for symmetrical peaks when a conventional integration approach is used. This is contrasted by GRAM which provides a much more precise result, at worst 1.8% and 0.6% when the modulation ratio (MR) is 1.5 or 3.0, respectively for symmetrical peaks. The data show that for analyses demanding high precision, a MR of 3 should be targeted as a minimum, especially if multivariate techniques are to be used so as to maintain data density in the primary dimension. For rapid screening techniques where precision is not as critical lower MR values can be tolerated. When integration is used, if there are 4-5 visible sub-peaks included for a symmetrical peak at MR=3.0, the data will be reasonably free from phase-shift-induced errors or a negative bias. At MR=1.5, at least 3 sub-peaks must be included for a symmetrical peak. The proposed guidelines should be equally relevant to LCxLC and other similar techniques.     

Amino acid analysis by using comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography

The separation characteristics of alkylchloroformate-derivatised amino acids (AAs) by using comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography (GC×GC) is reported. The use of a low-polarity/polar column set did not provide as good a separation performance as that achieved with a polar/non-polar column set, where the latter appeared to provide less correlation over the separation space. The degree of component correlation in each column set was estimated by using the correlation coefficient (r²; for ¹t_R and ²t_R data) with the low-polarity/polar and polar/low-polarity sets returning correlation coefficients of 0.86, and 0.00 respectively, under the respective conditions employed for the experiments. The 1.5-m non-polar ²D column (0.1-mm ID; 0.1-m film thickness) gave peak halfwidths of the order of 50–80 ms. Linearity of detection was good, over a three order of magnitude concentration range, with typical lower detection limit of ca. 0.01 mg L^–1, compared with 0.5 mg L^–1 for normal GC operation with splitless injection. The method was demonstrated for analysis of AAs in a range of food and beverage products, including wine, beer and honey. The major AA in these samples was proline. The Heineken beer sample had a relatively more complex and more abundant AA content compared with the other beer sample. The wine and honey samples also gave a range of AA compounds. Repetition of the sample preparation/analysis procedure for the honey sample gave acceptable reproducibility for individual AAs.     

Comparison of polymer resolution in thermal field-flow fractionation and size-exclusion chromatography

A comparison of the resolving power of themal field-flow fractionation (thermal FFF) and size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) has been made by the experimental operation of a high-resolution system from each category. For the experimental systems used, the measured resolution for thermal FFF was found to be higher than that for SEC for three different binary polymer mixtures. Only for a single low-molecular-weight mixture falling outside the optimal operating range of thermal FFF did SEC show better resolution. The experimental resolution values were broken down into selectivity and column efficiency parameters. While selectivity was easily obtained, column efficiency required a correction for polydispersity effects. With the polydispersity correction made on the basis of thermal FFF data, true resolution values were calculated to replace the apparent or experimental resolution levels. Overall, the corrected resolution values showed that thermal FFF had a significant advantage over SEC. Prospects for future advances in these two techniques are discussed.     

Simultaneous chromatography and electrophoresis: two-dimensional planar separations

Single-dimension separations are routinely coupled in series to achieve two-dimensional separations, yet little has been done to simultaneously exploit multiple dimensions during separation. In this work, simultaneous chromatography and electrophoresis is introduced and evaluated for its potential to achieve two-dimensional separations. In simultaneous chromatography and electrophoresis, chromatography occurs via capillary action while an orthogonal electric field concurrently promotes electrophoresis in a second dimension. A novel apparatus with a dual solvent reservoir was designed to apply the concurrent electric field. Various compounds were used to characterize the apparatus and technique, i.e., vitamins, amino acids, and dyes. Improved separation is reported with equivalent analysis times in comparison to planar chromatography alone. The feasibility of simultaneously employing chromatography and electrophoresis in two dimensions is discussed.

High-performance liquid chromatography fractionation using a silver-modified column followed by two-dimensional comprehensive gas chromatography for detailed group-type characterization of oils and oil pollutions

Successful remediation of oil-contaminated soils relies on a sound preceding characterization of the oil chemical composition and physicochemical properties. Comprehensive two-dimensional gas chromatography with flame ionization detection (GCxGC/FID) is known to be very suitable for the analysis of complex samples such as petroleum hydrocarbons. However, in spite of the high-separation power offered by GCxGC, it fails to completely separate certain hydrocarbon groups in petroleum hydrocarbon mixtures. This hampers a detailed chemical composition assessment which can lead to wrong conclusions on the behaviour of the oil in soil systems, e.g. biological degradability and water solubility. This paper describes a high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) system with a silver-modified column as a prefractionation step to GCxGC to improve chemical identification. With HPLC, the petroleum hydrocarbons were baseline separated into a saturated fraction (including alkanes and cycloalkanes) and an unsaturated fraction (including alkenes, aromatic hydrocarbons and heterocyclic components). Each fraction eluted in a small time window limiting the dilution caused by HPLC. The two fractions were collected and quantitatively analyzed with GCxGC/FID. Cold splitless injection of 4 microl was adopted to compensate the dilution caused by the prefractionation step. With oil-spiked soil samples, a good reproducibility was obtained (RSD=3.5%; n=7) and the recovery was satisfactory (87.7%).     

Observation of Ficoll charge using size-exclusion chromatography

The retention volumes of Ficoll samples of varying molecular weight were determined on porous glass and Superose columns, and compared with those of Pullulan. The retention of Ficoll is pH- and ionic strength-dependent, indicating that it bears a weak negative charge at moderate pH. Comparisons were made with similar charge repulsion effects for proteins on Superose to provide an estimate of the extent of charge on Ficoll, with the conclusion that only a few charges exist per molecule at neutral pH.