Growth and surface alloying of Fe on Pt(9 9 7)

The growth of ultra-thin layers of Fe on the vicinal Pt(9 9 7) surface is studied by thermal energy He atom scattering (TEAS) and Auger Electron Spectroscopy (AES) in the temperature range between 175 K and 800 K. We find three distinct regimes of qualitatively different growth type. Below 450 K the formation of a smooth first monolayer, at and above 600 K the onset of bulk alloy formation, and at intermediate temperature 500-550 K the formation of a surface alloy. Monatomic Fe rows are observed to decorate the substrate steps between 175 K and 500 K. The importance of the high step density is discussed with respect to the promotion of smooth layer growth and with respect to the alloying process and its kinetics.     

Characterization of methylidyne on Pt(1 1 1) with infrared spectroscopy

Methylidyne (CH) was prepared on Pt(1 1 1) by three methods: thermal decomposition of diiodomethane (CH₂I₂), ethylene decomposition at temperatures above 450 K, and surface carbon hydrogenation. Methylidyne and its precursors are characterized by reflection absorption infrared spectroscopy (RAIRS). The C-I bond of diiodomethane breaks upon adsorption to produce methylene (CH₂), which decomposes to methylidyne at temperatures above 130 K. Above 200 K, methylidyne is the only hydrocarbon species observed with RAIRS, although reaction channels for the formation of methane (CH₄) and ethylene (C₂H₄) are indicated by temperature programmed desorption (TPD). As is well known from numerous previous studies, ethylene decomposes to ethylidyne (CCH₃) upon exposure to Pt(1 1 1) at 410 K. Upon annealing to 450 K, ethylidyne dissociates through two reaction pathways, dehydrogenation to ethynyl (CCH) and C-C bond scission to methylidyne. Ethylene dehydrogenation on the surface at 750 K and under low ethylene exposures produces surface carbon that can be hydrogenated to methylidyne with C-H and C-D stretch frequencies of 2956 and 2206 cm⁻¹, respectively. Hydrogen co-adsorption on the surface causes these frequencies to shift to higher values. Methylidyne is stable on Pt(1 1 1) to temperatures up to 500 K.     

The temperature dependence of the interaction of NO + CO on Pt{1 0 0}

Infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy together with mass spectrometry has been used to investigate the interaction of NO and CO on Pt{1 0 0}, initially prepared in the reconstructed ‘hex’ phase, under ambient pressures of these gases, in the temperature range 300-500 K. The results allow the local and total coverages of adsorbed CO and NO to be related to the rate of reaction to produce gas phase CO₂, and provide insight into the species present on the surface during the so-called low temperature oscillatory reaction regime of this process. At temperatures below that at which NO dissociation occurs (approximately 390-400 K) adsorption is controlled by the non-reactive displacement of NO by CO and results in a CO-poisoned surface. Above 400 K when significant CO₂ production occurs, the NO coverage increases to produce a surface with NO and CO fully intermixed; the increase in NO coverage is attributed to the higher rate of NO arrival from the gas phase (with a partial pressure ratio of P_NO:P_CO>1) at free surface sites created by NO dissociation and subsequent reaction with CO. The competition between these two processes of non-reactive NO displacement by CO and reactive displacement of CO by NO is proposed to determine the parameter space of the low temperature oscillatory regime. Rapid equilibration between bridged and atop CO species leads to them appearing to exhibit identical reaction behaviour. Particularly at the lowest reaction temperatures (around 400 K), islands of pure CO may coexist on the surface but not participate in the reaction. Under conditions corresponding to the high temperature oscillatory regime, small quantities of absorbed CO, but no NO, are seen on the surface.     

The dissimilar twins - a comparative, site-selective in situ study of CO adsorption and desorption on Pt(3 2 2) and Pt(3 5 5)

The adsorption and desorption of CO on stepped Pt(3 2 2) = Pt(S)-[5(1 1 1) × (1 0 0)] and Pt(3 5 5) = Pt(S)-[5(1 1 1) × (1 1 1)] were investigated using in situ high-resolution X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy at BESSY II, which allows to clearly distinguish between different step and terrace adsorption sites. For the two surfaces, with the same nominal terrace width of five atomic rows, but different step orientation, significant differences are observed. While for Pt(3 5 5) CO adsorption at steps only occurs at on-top sites, on Pt(3 2 2) both step on-top and bridge sites are occupied, albeit with a significantly lower coverage (0.07 vs. 0.13 ML at 200 K). On both surfaces terrace sites are only occupied when the step sites are almost saturated confirming the enhanced binding energy at step sites. CO adsorbed at the (1 1 1) steps on Pt(3 5 5) is more strongly bound than on the (1 0 0) steps on Pt(3 2 2), which is attributed to the different electronic and geometric structure of the steps. The relative occupation of terrace and step sites at a given coverage remains the same between 120 and 290 K on Pt(3 5 5) K, but shows major changes on Pt(3 2 2), between step on-top and bridge sites as well as terrace on-top and bridge sites. On Pt(3 5 5) a smaller CO terrace coverage is found (0.36 vs. 0.40 ML on Pt(3 2 2) at 200 K), mainly due to the lower occupation of terrace bridge sites. For Pt(3 2 2), an ordered adsorbate phase is deduced from a c(4 × 2)-like LEED pattern, which indicates adsorbate order beyond the extension of a single terrace. A model for this structure is proposed.     

Surface (electro-)chemistry on Pt(1 1 1) modified by a Pseudomorphic Pd monolayer

The formic acid and methanol oxidation reaction are studied on Pt(1 1 1) modified by a pseudomorphic Pd monolayer (denoted hereafter as the Pt(1 1 1)-Pd_1 ML system) in 0.1 M HClO₄ solution. The results are compared to the bare Pt(1 1 1) surface. The nature of adsorbed intermediates (CO_ad) and the electrocatalytic properties (the onset of CO₂ formation) were studied by FTIR spectroscopy. The results show that Pd has a unique catalytic activity for HCOOH oxidation, with Pd surface atoms being about four times more active than Pt surface atoms at 0.4 V. FTIR spectra reveal that on Pt atoms adsorbed CO is produced from dehydration of HCOOH, whereas no CO adsorbed on Pd can be detected although a high production rate of CO₂ is observed at low potentials. This indicates that the reaction can proceed on Pd at low potentials without the typical “poison” formation. In contrast to its high activity for formic acid oxidation, the Pd film is completely inactive for methanol oxidation. The FTIR spectra show that neither adsorbed CO is formed on the Pd sites nor significant amounts of CO₂ are produced during the electrooxidation of methanol.     

Search for adsorption potential energy minima of NO on Pt(9 9 7) at 11 K

We observed four kinds of adsorbed NO molecules on Pt(9 9 7) at 11 K using infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRAS). The peaks at 1690, 1484 and 1615 cm⁻¹ are assigned to the N-O stretching modes of the on-top site and the hollow site on the terrace and the bridge site at the step, respectively. The 1385 cm⁻¹ peak is observed below ∼70 K. We assign the 1385 cm⁻¹ peak to the hollow site of the (1 1 1) microfacet at the step or the lower-terrace hollow site nearest to the step. By heating, site-to-site hopping to the more stable site occurs and the relative stability of four adsorption sites can be determined.     

CO adsorption on epitaxially grown Pt layers on Ru(0 0 0 1)

The adsorption of CO on epitaxially grown Pt films of variable thickness has been studied using infrared-absorption spectroscopy, scanning tunnelling microscopy and thermal desorption spectroscopy. Depending on the number of pseudomorphic Pt layers (N_Pt = 1-4) the internal and external CO stretching modes (ν_C-O and ν_Pt-CO, respectively) display characteristic frequency shifts due to the vanishing influence of the underlying Ru(0 0 0 1) substrate and Pt/Ru interface. For thicker layers (N_Pt ? 5) when this influence has become negligible, the compressive stress within the Pt film is gradually relieved, leading to a dislocation network. The structural heterogeneity during the ongoing relaxation process of the Pt film is reflected in the ν_C-O line shape; no line broadening is observed for either pseudomorphic or very thick films (N_Pt ? 15). For N_Pt ? 3 the adsorption of CO on Pt/Ru(0 0 0 1) films closely resembles CO on Pt(1 1 1), with residual deviations in line position and desorption temperatures gradually converging to zero.     

CO adsorption on the Pt(1 1 1) surface: a comparison of a gradient corrected functional and a hybrid functional

The adsorption of CO on the Pt(1 1 1) surface in a pattern has been studied with the gradient corrected functional of Perdew and Wang and the B3LYP hybrid functional. A slab which is periodic in two dimensions is used to model the system. The Perdew-Wang functional incorrectly gives the fcc site as the most favorable adsorption site, in accord with a set of previous studies. The B3LYP functional gives the top site as the preferred site. This confirms results from cluster studies where it was suggested that the different splitting, dependent on the functional, between highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbital, could be the reason for this change of the adsorption site. This is supported by an analysis based on the projected density of states and the Mulliken population.     

Adsorption behavior and reaction properties of NO and CO on Rh(1 1 1)

Reactions between NO and CO on Rh(1 1 1) surfaces were investigated using infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and temperature-programmed desorption. NO adsorbed on the fcc, atop, and hcp sites in that order, whereas CO adsorbed initially on the atop sites and then on the hollow (fcc + hcp) sites. The results of experiments with NO exposure on CO-preadsorbed Rh(1 1 1) surfaces indicated that the adsorption of NO on the hcp sites was inhibited by preadsorption of CO on the atop sites, and NO adsorption on the atop and fcc sites was inhibited by CO preadsorbed on each type of site, which indicates that NO and CO competitively adsorbed on Rh(1 1 1). From a Rh(1 1 1) surface with coadsorbed NO and CO, N₂ was produced from the dissociation of fcc-NO, and CO₂ was formed by the reaction of adsorbed CO with atomic oxygen from dissociated fcc-NO. The CO₂ production increased remarkably in the presence of hollow-CO. Coverage of fcc-NO and hollow-CO on Rh(1 1 1) depended on the composition ratio of the NO/CO gas mixture, and a gas mixture with NO/CO ? 1/2 was required for the co-existence of fcc-NO and hollow-CO at 273 K.     

RAIRS studies of CO adsorption on Pd/CeO2−x(1 1 1)/Pt(1 1 1)

Reflection absorption infrared spectroscopy (RAIRS) has been used to investigate the adsorption of CO on CeO_2−x-supported Pd nanoparticles at room temperature. The results show that when CeO_2−x is initially grown on Pt(1 1 1), a small proportion of the surface remains as bare Pt sites. However, when Pd is deposited onto CeO_2−x/Pt(1 1 1), most of the Pd grows directly on top of the CeO_2−x(1 1 1). RAIR spectra of CO adsorption on 1 ML Pd/CeO_2−x/Pt(1 1 1) show a broad CO-Pd band, which is inconsistent with a single crystal Pd surface. However, the 5 ML and 10 ML Pd/CeO_2−x/Pt(1 1 1) spectra show vibrational bands consistent with the presence of Pd(1 1 1) and (1 0 0) faces, suggesting the growth of Pd nanostructures with well defined facets.     

Morphological change of D2O layers on Ru(0 0 0 1) probed with He atom scattering

The morphological change of D₂O layers on a Ru(0 0 0 1) surface has been investigated on the basis of He atom scattering. With the increase of D₂O exposure on Ru(0 0 0 1) at 111 K, the intensity of a specularly reflected He beam continuously decreases up to the exposure of 1.0 L (Langmuir). At the D₂O coverage of 1.0 adsorbed layer (∼1.5 L), which is characterized by temperature-programmed desorption measurements, the formation of the (√3 × √3)R30° superstructure as a result of the diffusion of D₂O on the surface was confirmed by He atom diffraction. With the further increase of D₂O exposure, at 2-3 adsorbed layers, the disordered structure was found to be on the surface at 111 K. The morphological change of the disordered layers was observed during annealing, and discussed in detail.     

Carbon monoxide adsorption on Co deposited Pt(1 0 0)-hex: IRRAS and LEED investigations

Infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS) was used to investigate carbon monoxide (CO) adsorption on Pt(1 0 0) surfaces deposited with Co layers with different thicknesses. Pt(1 0 0) surfaces cleaned in ultrahigh vacuum showed surface reconstruction, i.e., Pt(1 0 0)-hex: two absorption bands ascribable to adsorbed CO on the 1 × 1 surface and hex domains emerge at 2086 and 2074 cm⁻¹, respectively, after 1.0 L CO exposure. Deposition of a 0.3-nm-thick-Co layer on Pt(1 0 0)-hex at 333 K changes the low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) pattern from hex to p(1 × 1), indicating that the deposited Co lifts the reconstruction. The IRRAS spectrum for 1.0-L-CO-exposed Co_0.3 nm/Pt(1 0 0)-hex fabricated at 333 K yields a single absorption band at 2059 cm⁻¹. For Co_0.3 nm/Pt(1 0 0)-hex fabricated at 693 K, the LEED pattern shows a less-contrasted hex and the pattern remains nearly unchanged even after CO exposure of 11 L, although only 1.0 L CO exposure to Pt(1 0 0)-hex lifts the surface reconstruction. A Co_0.3 nm/Pt(1 0 0)-hex surface fabricated at 753 K exhibits an absorption band at 2077 cm⁻¹, which is considered to originate from CO adsorbed on the Pt-enriched surface alloy. Co_0.3 nm/Pt(1 0 0)-hex surfaces fabricated above 773 K show a clear hex-reconstructed LEED pattern, and the frequencies of the adsorbed CO bands are comparable to those of Pt(1 0 0)-hex, indicating that the deposited Co atoms are diffused near the surface region. The outermost surface of the 3.0-nm-thick-Co-deposited Pt(1 0 0)-hex is composed of Pt-Co alloy domains even at a deposition temperature of 873 K. Based on the LEED and IRRAS results, the outermost surface structures of Co_x/Pt(1 0 0)-hex are discussed.     

Adsorption states of NO on the Pt(1 1 1) step surface

Using infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRAS) and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM), we investigated the adsorption states of NO on the Pt(9 9 7) step surface. At 90 K, we observe three N-O stretching modes at 1490 cm⁻¹, 1631 cm⁻¹ and 1700 cm⁻¹ at 0.2 ML. The 1490 cm⁻¹ and 1700 cm⁻¹ peaks are assigned to NO molecules at fcc-hollow and on-top sites of the terrace, respectively. The 1631 cm⁻¹ peak is assigned to the step NO species. In the present STM results, we observed that NO molecules were adsorbed at the bridge sites of the step as well as fcc-hollow and on-top sites of the terrace. To help with our assignments, density functional theory calculations were also performed. The calculated results indicate that a bridge site of the step is the most stable adsorption site for NO, and its stretching frequency is 1607 cm⁻¹. The interactions between NO species at different sites on Pt(9 9 7) are also discussed.     

Collision-induced diffusion and vacancy migration in alkanethiol monolayers on Au(1 1 1)

Scanning tunneling microscopy is used to characterize the collision-induced migration of molecules within well-ordered octanethiol and nonanethiol self-assembled monolayers. A seeded molecular beam is used to create xenon atoms with a kinetic energy of 1.3 eV, and collisions with these atoms cause measurable changes in alkanethiol monolayer surface structure. Migration rates are calculated and compared for molecules in close-packed domains, at domain-boundary defects, and along the perimeter of vacancy-island defects. The number of nearest-neighbor molecules (within the 5 Å lattice distance) is strongly predictive of molecular stability with respect to xenon bombardment, and the overall dependence of stability on nearest neighbors is well fit by a simple exponential curve. The incident direction of the molecular beam is not observed to influence the direction of molecular motion; however, in some cases, migration correlates strongly to surface lattice directions. Finally, there is no evidence that substrate restructuring or gold-atom diffusion accompanies alkanethiol migration under these non-equilibrium conditions.     

Adsorption of gas-phase oxygen atoms on Pt(1 0 0)-hex-R0.7°: Evidence of a metastable chemisorbed phase

We utilized temperature programmed desorption (TPD) and low energy electron diffraction (LEED) to study the chemisorption of gas-phase oxygen atoms on Pt(1 0 0)-hex-R0.7° at 450 K and 573 K, and find that the types and relative populations of oxygen phases that develop are highly dependent on the surface temperature during adsorption. At both temperatures, oxygen atoms initially adsorb on defects associated with the surface reconstruction. Increasing the coverage to about 0.32 ML (monolayers) at 573 K causes deconstruction and population of a phase with apparent (3 × 1) symmetry that desorbs in a single feature centered at about 672 K. Saturating at 0.63 ML leads to the formation of an additional “complex” ordered phase that desorbs in a sharp feature exhibiting autocatalytic behavior as it shifts from approximately 631 K to 642 K. Uptake at 450 K also initiates deconstruction, but in this case two desorption maxima at about 652 K and 672 K grow simultaneously with increasing coverage to about 0.32 ML. The feature at 672 K is associated with the disordered (3 × 1) phase, while the feature at 652 K has not been previously reported. We attribute this new feature to desorption from disordered arrangements of high oxygen concentrations on (1 × 1) surface regions. As the coverage increases to about 0.51 ML, small amounts of the complex phase grow, while this “high-concentration” (1 × 1) and the (3 × 1) phases continue to develop. We conclude that the complex phase is energetically preferred over the high-concentration (1 × 1) phase, but kinetic barriers hinder its formation at 450 K, causing oxygen to become trapped in the high-concentration (1 × 1) phase. Therefore, the high-concentration (1 × 1) phase is metastable relative to the complex phase. Lastly, above about 0.51 ML, further adsorption at 450 K promotes the growth of Pt oxide islands as detailed in a future investigation.     

Effect of surface steps on sputtering and surface defect formation: molecular-dynamics study of 5 keV Xe bombardment of Pt(1 1 1) at glancing incidence angles

Using molecular-dynamics simulation, we study sputtering and defect formation induced by 5 keV Xe⁺ ion impact on a Pt(1 1 1) surface at oblique and glancing incidence angles. Impact on a terrace produces yield maxima at ?=60-65° incidence angle towards the surface normal. Beyond 75-80°, no damage is produced due to projectile ion reflection. Impact on a dense-packed step, however, produces defects in sizeable numbers up to glancing incidence, ?=85°. The dependence of the yields on the incidence angle and distance of the impact point of the projectile to the step are discussed.     

Infrared reflection absorption study of carbon monoxide adsorption on Cu(1 0 0)-c(2 × 2)-Pd surfaces formed by palladium vacuum-depositions at various temperatures

Using infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRRAS) and temperature programmed desorption (TPD), we investigated carbon monoxide (CO) adsorption and desorption behaviors on atomic checkerboard structures of Cu and Pd formed by Pd vacuum deposition at various temperatures of Cu(1 0 0). The 0.15-nm-thick Pd deposition onto a clean Cu(1 0 0) surface at room temperature (RT) showed a clear c(2 × 2) low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) pattern, i.e. Cu(1 0 0)-c(2 × 2)-Pd. The RT-CO exposure to the c(2 × 2) surfaces resulted in IRRAS absorption caused by CO adsorbed on the on-top sites of Pd. The LEED patterns of the Pd-deposited Cu(1 0 0) at higher substrate temperatures revealed less-contrasted c(2 × 2) patterns. The IRRAS intensities of the linearly bonded CO bands on 373-K-, 473-K-, and 673-K-deposited c(2 × 2) surfaces are, respectively, 25%, 22%, and 10% less intense than those on the RT-deposited surface, indicating that Pd coverages at the outermost c(2 × 2) surfaces decrease with increasing deposition temperature. In the initial stage of the 90-K-CO exposure to the RT surface, the band attributable to CO bonded to the Pd emerged at 2067 cm⁻¹ and shifted to higher frequencies with increasing CO exposure. At saturation coverage, the band was located at 2093 cm⁻¹. In contrast, two distinct bands around 2090 cm⁻¹ were apparent on the spectrum of the 473-K-deposited surface: the CO saturation spectrum was dominated by an apparent single absorption at 2090 cm⁻¹ for the 673-K-deposited surface. The TPD spectra of the surfaces showed peaks at around 200 and 300 K, which were ascribable respectively to Cu-CO and Pd-CO. Taking into account the TPD and IRRAS results, we discuss the adsorption-desorption behaviors of CO on the ordered checkerboard structures.     

Interaction between chemisorbed N2 and Li promoter atoms: A comparison between the stepped Ru(1 0 9) and the atomically smooth Ru(0 0 1) surfaces

We present a direct side-by-side comparison of the interaction of Li atoms and N₂ molecules on the atomically stepped Ru(1 0 9) single crystal surface and on the atomically smooth Ru(0 0 1) single crystal surface using infrared reflection absorption spectroscopy (IRAS) and temperature programmed desorption (TPD). At low adsorbate coverages there is spectroscopic evidence for the formation of a Li_x(N₂)_y complex on the Ru(1 0 9) surface, whereas no such complex is observed on the Ru(0 0 1) surface. This complex is due to local interactions between an adsorbed Li atom and N₂ adsorbed on the atomic steps of Ru(1 0 9). The short range interaction near the atomic steps is characterized by the development of several highly red-shifted ν(N₂) modes in the region of ∼2130 cm⁻¹ in the IR spectra. Adsorbed N₂ molecules on both Ru(1 0 9) and Ru(0 0 1) also are influenced by the long range electrostatic field produced by Li adsorbate atoms, causing a red shift in the uncomplexed N₂ species, which monotonically increases as the Li coverage in increased. On the Ru(0 0 1) surface, small coverages of N₂ influenced by the long range effect of Li are initially chemisorbed parallel to the surface resulting in the absence of infrared activity. In addition we have also found that Li does not cause N-N bond scission on Ru(0 0 1) below 250 K.     

Oxidation of Pt(1 0 0)-hex-R0.7° by gas-phase oxygen atoms

We utilized temperature programmed desorption (TPD), X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), electron energy loss spectroscopy (ELS), and low energy electron diffraction (LEED) to investigate the oxidation of Pt(1 0 0)-hex-R0.7° at 450 K. Using an oxygen atom beam, we generated atomic oxygen coverages as high as 3.6 ML (monolayers) on Pt(1 0 0) in ultrahigh vacuum (UHV), almost 6 times the maximum coverage obtainable by dissociatively adsorbing O₂. The results show that oxidation occurs through the development of several chemisorbed phases prior to oxide growth above about 1 ML. A weakly bound oxygen state that populates as the coverage increases from approximately 0.50 ML to 1 ML appears to serve as a necessary precursor to Pt oxide growth. We find that increasing the coverage above about 1 ML causes Pt oxide particle growth and significant surface disordering. Decomposition of the Pt oxide particles produces explosive O₂ desorption characterized by a shift of the primary TPD feature to higher temperatures and a dramatic increase in the maximum desorption rate with increasing coverage. Based on thermodynamic considerations, we show that the thermal stability of the surface Pt oxide on Pt single crystal surfaces significantly exceeds that of bulk PtO₂. Furthermore, we attribute the high stability and the acceleratory decomposition rates of the surface oxide to large kinetic barriers that must be overcome during oxide formation and decomposition. Lastly, we present evidence that structurally similar oxides develop on both Pt(1 1 1) and Pt(1 0 0), therefore concluding that the properties of the surface Pt oxide are largely insensitive to the initial structure of the Pt single crystal surface.     

Mass and lattice effects in trapping: Ar, Kr, and Xe on Pt(1 1 1), Pd(1 1 1), and Ni(1 1 1)

The trapping probabilities of argon, krypton, and xenon on Pd(1 1 1) and Ni(1 1 1) have been investigated using supersonic molecular beam techniques. The trapping probability of argon exhibits normal incident energy in a similar fashion on both Pd(1 1 1) and Pt(1 1 1) because the mass of argon is significantly less than the surface mass of either Pd or Pt. In contrast, dynamic corrugation in the gas-surface potential is observed for krypton trapping on Pt(1 1 1) and Pd(1 1 1), resulting in a decreased angular dependence of the trapping probability compared to argon. For xenon trapping on Pd significant lattice deformation during the gas-surface collision appears to give rise to total energy scaling. The trapping probability of xenon on Pd(1 1 1) remains high at unusually high incident kinetic energies due to the overall enhanced energy transfer from the incident atom to the lattice. Trapping probabilities of Ar, Kr, and Xe are significantly lower on Ni(1 1 1) than on either Pt(1 1 1) or Pd(1 1 1) despite the lower surface mass of the Ni atoms. This result is attributed to the lower binding energy of the rare gases on Ni(1 1 1) and the higher Debye temperature of Ni. The energy scaling of Ar trapping on Ni(1 1 1) is determined by static corrugation, but the energy scaling for Kr and Xe on Ni(1 1 1) may involve the effects of dynamic corrugation. In the latter cases, the greater stiffness of the nickel lattice decreases the dynamic corrugation relative to Pt(1 1 1) and Pd(1 1 1).