Insights in the laser induced breakdown spectroscopy signal generation underwater using dual pulse excitation — Part II: Plasma emission intensity as a function of interpulse delay

Influence of time delay between two laser pulses on the LIBS (laser induced breakdown spectroscopy) signal inside liquids was investigated and the results are compared with data from literature. Plasma was produced by laser ablation (LA) of aluminum inside water and its emission after the second laser pulse was characterized by spectrally and time resolved detection. Light propagation through the vapor bubble formed by the first laser pulse was studied by measurements of beam scattering and transmission. Optical absorption by the evolving bubble is not significant, but its growth is accompanied by lowering of its refraction index n_b with respect to surrounding liquid; this effect increases defocusing both of the incident beam and of the out-coming plasma radiation. Collection efficiency of the secondary plasma emission rapidly degrades with the cavity growth, but close to its full expansion the LIBS signal partially recovers through Snell's reflections at the liquid–vapor interface, which produce a bright spot close to the bubble center. Such a light redistribution allows detecting of the emission from external plasma volume, otherwise deflected out of the collection system. Except for strong line transitions from the main sample constituents, self-absorbed inside the high-pressure cavity, we observed the highest LIBS signal when sending the second pulse well before the bubble is fully expanded. Transitions of the pressure wave through the focal volume, formed by the first laser pulse and reflected from the cell's walls and sample back-plane, enhances the LIBS signal importantly. The measured lifetime of the secondary plasma rapidly decreases with the bubble expansion. Here, we also discuss the optimization of the optical collection system and some analytical aspects of double-pulse (DP) LIBS inside liquids.     

Efficient plasma and bubble generation underwater by an optimized laser excitation and its application for liquid analyses by laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) measurements were performed on bulk water solutions by applying a double-pulse excitation from a Q-Switched (QS) Nd:YAG laser emitting at 1064 nm. In order to optimize the LIBS signal, laser pulse energies were varied through changing of the QS trigger delays with respect to the flash-lamp trigger. We had noted that reduction of the first pulse energy from 92 mJ to 72 mJ drastically improves the signal, although the second pulse energy was also lowered from 214 mJ to 144 mJ. With lower pulse energies, limit of detection (LOD) for Mg in pure water was reduced for one order of magnitude (34 ppb instead of 210 ppb). In order to explain such a phenomenon, we studied the dynamics of the gas bubble generated after the first laser pulse through measurements of the HeNe laser light scattered on the bubble. The influence of laser energy on underwater bubble and plasma formation and corresponding plasma emission intensity were also studied by photographic technique. From the results obtained, we conclude that the optimal first pulse energy should be kept close to the plasma elongation threshold, in our case about 65 mJ, where the gas bubble has its maximum lateral expansion and the secondary plasma is still well-localized. The importance of a multi-pulse sequence on the LIBS signal was also analyzed, where the pulse sequence after the first QS aperture was produced by operating the laser close to the lasing threshold, with the consequent generation of relaxation oscillations. Low-energy multi-pulses might keep the bubble expansion large prior to the probing pulse, but preventing the formation of secondary weak plasmas in multiple sites, which reduces the LIBS signal. The short interval between the pre-pulses and the probing pulse is another reason for the observed LIBS signal enhancement.     

Elemental chemical analysis of submerged targets by double-pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

Double-pulse laser-induced plasma spectroscopy (DP-LIPS) is applied to submerged targets to investigate its feasibility for elemental analysis. The role of experimental parameters, such as inter-pulse delay and detection time, has been discussed in terms of the dynamics of the laser-induced bubble produced by the first pulse and its confinement effect on the plasma produced by the second laser pulse. The analytical performance of this technique applied to targets in a water environment are discussed. The elemental analysis of submerged copper alloys by DP-LIPS has been compared with conventional (single-pulse) LIBS in air. Theoretical investigation of the plasma dynamics in water bubbles and open air has been performed.     

Comment on “three-dimensional analysis of laser induced plasmas in single and double pulse configuration”

Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) is an effective technique for real-time chemical analysis of samples in the laboratory and in the field. The performance of LIBS can be significantly improved by replacing the conventional LIBS configuration from single pulse laser to double pulse laser ablation. Corsi et al. showed that by firing two lasers with microsecond order delay can increase LIBS sensitivity [M. Corsi, G. Cristoforetti, M. Giuffrida, M. Hidalgo, S. Legnaioli, V. Palleschi, A. Salvetti, E. Tognoni, C. Vallebona, Three-dimensional analysis of laser induced plasmas in single and double pulse configuration, Spectrochimica Acta, Part B 59 (2004) 723–735] [1]. By studying plume evolution, they attribute this enhancement to the faster plume expansion in double pulse laser ablation. Blast wave theory was used in Corsi's paper to explain the higher expansion speed observed in double pulse laser ablation. However, it is questionable whether the blast wave theorem applies in laser ablation where the shockwave is driven by a vapor plume of mass. We introduce an alternative way to explain the faster plume expansion during double pulse laser through a more general thermodynamic relation.     

Analysis of lead and sulfur in environmental samples by double pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy

In the present work, a model of double pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) spectrometer has been developed and results from two different applications of double pulse LIBS for solving the problems of environmental interest are presented. In one case, laser induced breakdown spectroscopy has been applied to the determination of heavy and toxic metals (lead) in soil samples. In the second case, laser induced breakdown spectroscopy was used in preliminary experiments for the detection of sulfur content in coal, and on the basis of spectral features, ways to improve the sensitivity of laser induced breakdown spectroscopy detection of sulfur are proposed. The detection limit for lead in soil was estimated to be approximately 20 ppm that is lower than the regulatory standards for the presence of lead in soil.     

A comparison of single and double pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy of aluminum samples

Single and double pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) was carried out on aluminum samples in air. In the case of double pulse excitation, experiments were conducted by using the same laser source operated at the same wavelength (1064 nm in most cases here presented). A lowering of the second pulse plasma threshold was observed, together with an overall enhancement in line emission for the investigated time delay between the two pulses (40–60 μs). The laser-induced plasma originated by a single and double pulse was investigated near ignition threshold with the aim to study possible dynamical mechanisms in different regimes. Currently available spectroscopic diagnostics of plasma, such as the line broadening and shift due Stark effects, have been used in the characterization in order to retrieve electron densities, while standard temperature measurements were based on Boltzmann plot. Plasma relevant parameters, such as temperature and electron density, have been measured in the plasma decay on a long time scale, and compared with crater shape (diameter and inferred volume). The comparison of double with single pulse laser excitation was carried out while keeping constant the energy per pulse; the influence of laser energy was investigated as well. Results here obtained suggest that use of the double pulse technique could significantly improve the analytical capabilities of LIBS technique in routine laboratory experiments.     

Depth profiles of ceramic tiles by using orthogonal double‐pulse laser induced breakdown spectrometry

The potential of a double pulse (DP) excitation scheme for in‐depth characterization of ceramic samples using laser induced breakdown spectrometry (LIBS) has been demonstrated. For this purpose, two Q‐switched Nd:YAG lasers in orthogonal configuration were employed, the first one to ablate the sample (1064 nm) and the second one (532 nm) to excite the ablated material. Light emission was collected by a spectrograph and detected by an intensified charge‐coupled device (CCD) detector. Optimal conditions such as relative laser beam positions, laser pulse energies, inter‐pulse separation and CCD delay time were studied. Depth profiles were evaluated on the basis of various elemental compositions in both layers of ceramic samples. The depth resolution with DP configuration was improved by almost twofold as compared to the single‐pulse approach. The reproducibility of the depth profiles is also twice better with double pulse LIBS. Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Amelioration in the Detection of Chlorine Using Electric Field Assisted LIBS

The detection of chlorine and improvement in its detection has remained a challenge despite the use of a single pulse and a dual pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopic technique (LIBS). In this article, we presented an alternate technique for improving the detection of chlorine (Cl) using LIBS in conjunction with an external electric filed. A comparison of the emission intensity enhancement and plasma parameters in the absence and presence of an external field has been also presented. The implication of the presented technique for the detection of Cl is much easier and inexpensive as compared with the dual pulse LIBS.

     

Early stage emission spectroscopy study of metallic titanium plasma induced in air by femtosecond- and nanosecond-laser pulses

In this work the laser induced plasma obtained in air at atmospheric pressure by the interaction of a fs (femtosecond) or a ns (nanosecond) laser pulse with a metallic titanium target has been investigated by optical emission spectroscopy. The temporal evolution of plasma parameters such as electron number density and excitation temperature has been determined in order to highlight the processes involved when the emission spectra are acquired at short time delays from the ablating laser pulse. A survey of elementary processes implicated during plasma formation and expansion of ns- and fs-Laser Induced Plasma has been performed. Departures from equilibrium conditions are even discussed. The dynamic aspects corresponding to ns- and fs-LIP have been investigated by optical time of flight (TOF) and by fast emission imaging. The overall results have been used for clarifying the basic mechanisms occurring during plasma expansion due to either ns or fs laser source when experimental conditions usually used for laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) applications are employed.     

Pulse chirp effects in ultrafast laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy

When compared to many other sensitive methods for material detection, such as inductively coupled mass spectroscopy and thermal ionization mass spectroscopy, laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) typically exhibits a lower signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), resulting in higher detection limits. Increasing the SNR of LIBS would improve the ability to characterize the sample composition with increased accuracy and speed and reduce the amount of material needed to perform analysis. We have been investigating the effect of simple ultrashort laser pulse shaping on the SNR of LIBS. Our goal is to control the dynamics of the ionization and recombination processes in the laser-produced plasma to favorably affect the SNR associated with the line emission from the plasma. Pulse shaping is performed using an acousto-optic programmable dispersive filter. An adaptive learning algorithm is being developed to automate the pulse shape optimization process for maximization of LIBS SNR in nuclear security-relevant material characterization scenarios. We report a 27 % increase of the SNR for non-gated LIBS measurements of uranium by utilizing simple pulse shaping limited exclusively to excess quadratic spectral phase of the laser pulse.     

Resonance fluorescence spectroscopy in laser-induced cavitation bubbles

Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) in liquids using a double-pulse Q-switched Nd:YAG laser system has provided reliable results that give trace detection limits in water. Resonant laser excitation has been added to enhance detection sensitivity. A primary laser pulse (at 532 nm), transmitted via an optical fiber, induces a cavitation bubble and shockwave at a target immersed in a 10 mg l⁻¹–100 mg l⁻¹ indium (In) water suspension. The low-pressure rear of the shockwave induces bubble expansion and a resulting reduction in cavity pressure as it extends away from the target. Shortly before the maximum diameter is expected, a secondary laser pulse (also at 532 nm) is fed into the bubble in order to reduce quenching processes. The plasma field generated is then resonantly excited by a fiber-guided dye laser beam to increase detection selectivity. The resulting resonance fluorescence emission is optically detected and processed by an intensified optical multichannel analyzer system.      

Double pulse laser ablation and plasma: Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy signal enhancement

A review of recent results of the studies of double laser pulse plasma and ablation for laser induced breakdown spectroscopy applications is presented. The double pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy configuration was suggested with the aim of overcoming the sensitivity shortcomings of the conventional single pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy technique. Several configurations have been suggested for the realization of the double pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy technique: collinear, orthogonal pre-spark, orthogonal pre-heating and dual pulse crossed beam modes. In addition, combinations of laser pulses with different wavelengths, different energies and durations were studied, thus providing flexibility in the choice of wavelength, pulse width, energy and pulse sequence. The double pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy approach provides a significant enhancement in the intensity of laser induced breakdown spectroscopy emission lines up to two orders of magnitude greater than a conventional single pulse laser induced breakdown spectroscopy. The double pulse technique leads to a better coupling of the laser beam with the plasma plume and target material, thus providing a more temporally effective energy delivery to the plasma and target. The experimental results demonstrate that the maximum effect is obtained at some optimum separation delay time between pulses. The optimum value of the interpulse delay depends on several factors, such as the target material, the energy level of excited states responsible for the emission, and the type of enhancement process considered. Depending on the specified parameter, the enhancement effects were observed on different time scales ranging from the picosecond time level (e.g., ion yield, ablation mass) up to the hundred microsecond level (e.g., increased emission intensity for laser induced breakdown spectroscopy of submerged metal target in water). Several suggestions have been proposed to explain the mechanism of double pulse enhancement.     

Calibration Measurements in laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy using nanosecond and picosecond lasers

The influence of laser pulse duration on laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) calibration curves is investigated in the present work. Two Nd:YAG lasers providing pulses of 35 ps and 5 ns, respectively, both operating at 1064 nm, have been used to create plasmas on aluminium, manganese, iron, and silicon targets and on prepared stoichiometric samples of these metals in a matrix. The time-resolved, space-averaged plasma temperatures have been deduced using Boltzmann plots, while the electron number density has been determined from the broadening of spectral lines. The effect of laser pulse duration on the plasma characteristics is discussed, and comparisons are made with previously reported data measured under similar experimental conditions. The optimum experimental conditions (i.e., time delay, gate width, laser energy) have been determined for reliable use of LIBS for quantitative analysis for both pulse durations. For each of the metals of interest, calibration curves have been constructed for concentrations ranging up to 2%.     

Spectroscopic and shadowgraphic analysis of laser induced plasmas in the orthogonal double pulse pre-ablation configuration

This work focuses on the study of the plumes obtained in the double pulse orthogonal Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS) in the pre-ablation configuration using both spectroscopic and shadowgraphic approaches. Single and double pulse LIBS experiments were carried out on a brass sample in air. Both the distance of the air plasma from the target surface and the interpulse delay were varied (respectively in the range 0.1–4.2 mm and up to 50 μs) revealing a significant variation of the plasma emission and of the plume-shock wave dynamical expansion in different cases. The intensity of both atomic and ionized zinc lines was measured in all the cases, allowing the calculation of the spatially averaged temperature and electron density and an estimation of the ablated mass. The line intensities and the thermodynamic parameters obtained by the spectroscopic measurements were discussed bearing in mind the dynamical expansion characteristics obtained from the shadowgraphic approach. All the data seem to be consistent with the model previously proposed for the double pulse collinear configuration where the line enhancement is mainly attributed to the ambient gas rarefaction produced by the first laser pulse, which causes a less effective shielding of the second laser pulse.     

Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy methodology for the analysis of copper-based-alloys used in ancient artworks

In this paper Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy has been applied for determining the elemental composition of a set of ancient bronze artworks coming from archaeological site of Minervino Murge — Southern of Italy (dated around VII b.C.). Before carrying on the analysis of the archaeological samples, the characterization of the analytical technique has been accomplished by investigating the trueness of the typical assumptions adopted in LIBS, such as Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium, congruent ablation and plasma homogeneity. With this purpose, two different laser pulse durations, 7 ns and 350 fs, have been used. We have focused our attention on LIBS analysis of bronze standards by considering and discussing the bases of both methodology and analytical approach to be followed for the analysis of ancient copper-based-alloy samples. Unexpectedly, regardless from the laser pulse duration, the LIBS technique has shown, by considering an adequate approach on the emitting plasma features, that its peculiarities are anyway preserved so that a fast analysis of ancient copper-based-alloys can be achieved. After verifying the suitability of the methodology, it has been possible to fulfill the typical assumptions considered for the LIBS calibration curves method and use it for ancient bronze artworks analysis.     

Double pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy of explosives: Initial study towards improved discrimination

Detecting trace explosive residues at standoff distances in real-time is a difficult problem. One method ideally suited for real-time standoff detection is laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS). However, atmospheric oxygen and nitrogen contributes to the LIBS signal from the oxygen- and nitrogen-containing explosive compounds, complicating the discrimination of explosives from other organic materials. While bathing the sample in an inert gas will remove atmospheric oxygen and nitrogen interference, it cannot practically be applied for standoff LIBS. Alternatively, we have investigated the potential of double pulse LIBS to improve the discrimination of explosives by diminishing the contribution of atmospheric oxygen and nitrogen to the LIBS signal. These initial studies compare the close-contact (< 1 m) LIBS spectra of explosives using single pulse LIBS in argon with double pulse LIBS in atmosphere. We have demonstrated improved discrimination of an explosive and an organic interferent using double pulse LIBS to reduce the air entrained in the analytical plasma.     

Double pulse laser ablation and laser induced breakdown spectroscopy: A modeling investigation

A numerical model, describing laser–solid interaction (i.e., metal target heating, melting and vaporization), vapor plume expansion, plasma formation and laser–plasma interaction, is applied to describe the effects of double pulse (DP) laser ablation and laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS). Because the model is limited to plume expansion times in the order of (a few) 100 ns in order to produce realistic results, the interpulse delay times are varied between 10 and 100 ns, and the results are compared to the behavior of a single pulse (SP) with the same total energy. It is found that the surface temperature at the maximum is a bit lower in the DP configuration, because of the lower irradiance of one laser pulse, but it remains high during a longer time, because it rises again upon the second laser pulse. Consequently, the target remains for a longer time in the molten state, which suggests that laser ablation in the DP configuration might be more efficient, through the mechanism of splashing of the molten target. The total laser absorption in the plasma is also calculated to be clearly lower in the DP configuration, so that more laser energy can reach the target and give rise to laser ablation. Finally, it is observed that the plume expansion dynamics is characterized by two separate waves, the first one originating from the first laser pulse, and the second (higher) one as a result of the second laser pulse. Initially, the plasma temperature and electron density are somewhat lower than in the SP case, due to the lower energy of one laser pulse. However, they rise again upon the second laser pulse, and after 200 ns, they are therefore somewhat higher than in the SP case. This is especially true for the longer interpulse delay times, and it is expected that these trends will be continued for longer delay times in the μs-range, which are most typically used in DP LIBS, resulting in more intense emission intensities.     

Evaluation of laser induced breakdown spectroscopy for the determination of macronutrients in plant materials

Laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) has become an analytical tool for the direct analysis of a large variety of materials in order to provide qualitative and/or quantitative information. However, there is a lack of information for LIBS analysis of agricultural and environmental samples. In this work a LIBS system has been evaluated for the determination of macronutrients (P, K, Ca, Mg) in pellets of vegetal reference materials. An experimental setup was designed by using a Nd:YAG laser operating at 1064 nm and an Echelle spectrometer with ICCD detector. The plasma temperature was estimated by Boltzmann plots and instrumental parameters such as delay time, lens-to-sample distance and pulse energy were evaluated. Certified reference materials as well as reference materials were used for analytical calibrations of P, K, Ca, and Mg. Most results of the direct analysis of plant samples by LIBS were in reasonable agreement with those obtained by ICP OES after wet acid decomposition.     

Quantitative analysis of arsenic in mine tailing soils using double pulse-laser induced breakdown spectroscopy

A double pulse-laser induced breakdown spectroscopy (DP-LIBS) was used to determine arsenic (As) concentration in 16 soil samples collected from 5 different mine tailing sites in Korea. We showed that the use of double pulse laser led to enhancements of signal intensity (by 13% on average) and signal-to-noise ratio of As emission lines (by 165% on average) with smaller relative standard deviation compared to single pulse laser approach. We believe this occurred because the second laser pulse in the rarefied atmosphere produced by the first pulse led to the increase of plasma temperature and populations of exited levels. An internal standardization method using a Fe emission line provided a better correlation and sensitivity between As concentration and the DP-LIBS signal than any other elements used. The Fe was known as one of the major components in current soil samples, and its concentration varied not substantially. The As concentration determined by the DP-LIBS was compared with that obtained by atomic absorption spectrometry (AAS) to evaluate the current LIBS system. They are correlated with a correlation coefficient of 0.94. The As concentration by the DP-LIBS was underestimated in the high concentration range (>1000 mg-As/kg). The loss of sensitivity that occurred at high concentrations could be explained by self-absorption in the generated plasma.     

The influence of laser-particle interaction in laser induced breakdown spectroscopy and laser ablation inductively coupled plasma spectrometry

Particles produced by previous laser shots may have significant influence on the analytical signal in laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) and laser ablation inductively coupled plasma (LA-ICP) spectrometry if they remain close to the position of laser sampling. The effects of these particles on the laser-induced breakdown event are demonstrated in several ways. LIBS-experiments were conducted in an ablation cell at atmospheric conditions in argon or air applying a dual-pulse arrangement with orthogonal pre-pulse, i.e., plasma breakdown in a gas generated by a focussed laser beam parallel and close to the sample surface followed by a delayed crossing laser pulse in orthogonal direction which actually ablates material from the sample and produces the LIBS plasma. The optical emission of the LIBS plasma as well as the absorption of the pre-pulse laser was measured. In the presence of particles in the focus of the pre-pulse laser, the plasma breakdown is affected and more energy of the pre-pulse laser is absorbed than without particles. As a result, the analyte line emission from the LIBS plasma of the second laser is enhanced. It is assumed that the enhancement is not only due to an increase of mass ablated by the second laser but also to better atomization and excitation conditions favored by a reduced gas density in the pre-pulse plasma. Higher laser pulse frequencies increase the probability of particle-laser interaction and, therefore, reduce the shot-to-shot line intensity variation as compared to lower particle loadings in the cell. Additional experiments using an aerosol chamber were performed to further quantify the laser absorption by the plasma in dependence on time both with and without the presence of particles. The overall implication of laser-particle interactions for LIBS and LA-ICP-MS/OES are discussed.