Studies of the binding mechanism between aptamers and thrombin by circular dichroism, surface plasmon resonance and isothermal titration calorimetry

Thrombin, a multifunctional serine protease, has both procoagulant and anticoagulant functions in human blood. Thrombin has two electropositive exosites. One is the fibrinogen-binding site and the other is the heparin-binding site. Over the past decade, two thrombin-binding aptamers (15-mer and 29-mer) were reported by SELEX technique. Recently, many studies examined the interactions between the 15-mer aptamer and thrombin extensively, but the data on the difference of these two aptamers binding to thrombin are still lacking and worth investigating for fundamental understanding. In the present study, we combined conformational data from circular dichroism (CD), kinetics and thermodynamics information from surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) to compare the binding mechanism between the two aptamers with thrombin. Special attentions were paid to the formation of G-quadruplex and the effects of ions on the aptamer conformation on the binding and the kinetics discrimination between specific and nonspecific interactions of the binding. The results indicated reasonably that the 15-mer aptamer bound to fibrinogen-binding site of thrombin using a G-quadruplex structure and was dominated by electrostatic interactions, while the 29-mer aptamer bound to heparin-binding site thrombin using a duplex structure and was driven mainly by hydrophobic effects.     

Characterizing the interaction between aptamers and human IgE by use of surface plasmon resonance

Human immunoglobulin E (hIgE) is such an important protein, because of its involvement in allergic disease, that it is of significance to study the interactions between it and its recognizing elements. In this report an analytical strategy based on surface plasmon resonance (SPR) was developed to probe the pattern of interaction between hIgE and its recognizing molecules, including aptamers and antibodies. The affinity constants of hIgE for the antibody and the aptamer were compared first; the aptamer has more affinity than the antibody for human IgE. To study their pattern of interaction, three different binding approaches, including adding the antibody and the streptavidin-coupled aptamer to the sensing surface, were designed. The results showed that hIgE captured on the sensing surface could form a multivalent complex with the aptamer. An ELISA-like assay using the aptamer as both capture and detection probes was then developed. This work highlights an SPR method for characterizing the interaction between the protein and aptamers that is useful for study of biomolecular interaction patterns and binding properties. Figure Schematic diagram of the use of surface plasmon resonance for detection of the pattern of interaction of human IgE with its DNA aptamer and antibody     

Arginine-modified DNA aptamers that show enantioselective recognition of the dicarboxylic acid moiety of glutamic acid

We have screened glutamic acid-binding aptamers from a modified DNA pool containing arginine residues using the method of systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment (SELEX). Thirty-one modified DNA molecules were obtained from the enriched pool after the 17th round of selection, and their binding affinities for the target were evaluated by binding assays using affinity gels. Three modified DNA molecules having higher affinity were sequenced and we determined their affinity and specificity for the target by surface plasmon resonance (SPR) measurements. The SPR studies indicated that two of these three aptamers distinguished the dicarboxylic acid moiety of the D-isomer from that of the L-isomer; however, the third aptamer did not show enantioselectivity.     

Binding kinetics of human cellular prion detection by DNA aptamers immobilized on a conducting polypyrrole

We developed a biosensor based on the surface plasmon resonance (SPR) method for the study of the binding kinetics and detection of human cellular prions (PrP^C) using DNA aptamers as bioreceptors. The biosensor was formed by immobilization of various biotinylated DNA aptamers on a surface of conducting polypyrrole modified by streptavidin. We demonstrated that PrP^C interaction with DNA aptamers could be followed by measuring the variation of the resonance angle. This was studied using DNA aptamers of various configurations, including conventional single-stranded aptamers that contained a rigid double-stranded supporting part and aptamer dimers containing two binding sites. The kinetic constants determined by the SPR method suggest strong interaction of PrP^C with various DNA aptamers depending on their configuration. SPR aptasensors have a high selectivity to PrP^C and were regenerable by a brief wash in 0.1 M NaOH. The best limit of detection (4 nM) has been achieved with this biosensor based on DNA aptamers with one binding site but containing a double-stranded supporting part.

Surface plasmon resonance imaging for affinity analysis of aptamer–protein interactions with PDMS microfluidic chips

We report on the use of PDMS multichannels for affinity studies of DNA aptamer–human Immunoglobulin E (IgE) interactions by surface plasmon resonance imaging (SPRi). The sensing surface was prepared with thiol-terminated aptamers through a self-assembling process in the PDMS channels defined on a gold substrate. Cysteamine was codeposited with the thiol aptamers to promote proper spatial arrangement of the aptamers and thus maintain their optimal binding efficiencies. Four aptamers with different nucleic acid sequences were studied to test their interaction affinity toward IgE, and the results confirmed that aptamer I (5′-SH-GGG GCA CGT TTA TCC GTC CCT CCT AGT GGC GTG CCC C-3′) has the strongest binding affinity. Control experiments were conducted with a PEG-functionalized surface and IgG was used to replace IgE in order to verify the selective binding of aptamer I to the IgE molecules. A linear concentration-dependent relationship between IgE and aptamer I was obtained, and a 2-nM detection limit was achieved. SPRi data were further analyzed by global fitting, and the dissociation constant of aptamer I–IgE complex was found to be 2.7 × 10⁻⁷ M, which agrees relatively well with the values reported in the literature. Aptamer affinity screening by SPR imaging demonstrates marked advantages over competing methods because it does not require labeling, can be used in real-time, and is potentially high-throughput. The ability to provide both qualitative and quantitative results on a multichannel chip further establishes SPRi as a powerful tool for the study of biological interactions in a multiplexed format. Figure The SPRi sensograms and thier global fits for aptamer I and IgE interactions. Insert in the difference image obtained with the PDMS microchannel flow cell for aptamer IV, III, and I (from left to right     

Novel application of fluorescence coupled capillary electrophoresis to resolve the interaction between the G‐quadruplex aptamer and thrombin

The dynamic binding status between the thrombin and its G‐quadruplex aptamers and the stability of its interaction partners were probed using our previously established fluorescence‐coupled capillary electrophoresis method. A 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer was chosen as a model to study its binding affinity with the thrombin ligand. First, the effects of the cations on the formation of G‐quadruplex from unstructured 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer were examined. Second, the rapid binding kinetics between the thrombin and 6‐carboxyfluorescein labeled G‐quadruplex aptamer was measured. Third, the stability of G‐quadruplex aptamer–thrombin complex was also examined in the presence of the interfering species. Remarkably, it was found that the complementary strand of 29‐nucleic acid thrombin binding aptamer could compete with G‐quadruplex aptamer and thus disassociated the G‐quadruplex structure into an unstructured aptamer. These data suggest that our in‐house established fluorescence‐coupled capillary electrophoresis assay could be applied to binding studies of the G‐quadruplex aptamers, thrombin, and their ligands, while overcoming the complicated and costly approaches currently available.     

Supramolecular Fluorescence Resonance Energy Transfer in Nucleobase‐Modified Fluorogenic RNA Aptamers

RNA aptamers form compact tertiary structures and bind their ligands in specific binding sites. Fluorescence‐based strategies reveal information on structure and dynamics of RNA aptamers. Herein, we report the incorporation of the universal emissive nucleobase analog 4‐cyanoindole into the fluorogenic RNA aptamer Chili, and its application as a donor for supramolecular FRET to the bound ligands DMHBI⁺ or DMHBO⁺. The photophysical properties of the new nucleobase–ligand‐FRET pair revealed structural restraints for the overall RNA aptamer organization and identified nucleotide positions suitable for FRET‐based readout of ligand binding. This strategy is generally suitable for binding‐site mapping and may also be applied for responsive aptamer devices.     

Streptavidin binding bifunctional aptamers and their interaction with low molecular weight ligands

This paper describes the measurement of the binding affinities of two bifunctional RNA aptamers to their respective ligands. The aptamers comprise either a theophylline or malachite green binding sequence fused to a streptavidin binding sequence. These bifunctional aptamers are shown to bind simultaneously to both the small ligand and to streptavidin whether in free solution or on gold surfaces. Binding isotherms for both interactions were measured by different physiochemical techniques: surface plasmon resonance, fluorescence spectroscopy and dynamic light scattering. Both qualitatively and quantitatively there is little difference in binding affinities between the bifunctional aptamers and their monofunctional components. The respective K_d values for streptavidin binding in the monofunctional aptamer and in the theophylline bifunctional aptamer were 12 nM and 65 nM, respectively whilst the K_d values for theophylline binding in the monofunctional aptamer and the streptavidin bifunctional aptamer were 300 nM and 120 nM. These results are consistent with treating each aptamer sequence as a module that can be combined with others without significant loss of function. This allows for the use of streptavidin based immobilization strategies without either the cost of biotinylated dNTPs or the variable yields associated with the chemical biotinylation of RNA.     

Influence of ionic strength, pH and aptamer configuration for binding affinity to thrombin

We used the methods of electrochemical indicators and the quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) for detection of thrombin-aptamer interactions. We analyzed how the method of immobilization of aptamer to a solid support, the aptamer configuration as well as variation in ionic strength and pH will affect the binding of thrombin to the aptamer. The immobilization of aptamer by means of avidin-biotin technology revealed best results in sensitivity in comparison with immobilization utilizing dendrimers of first generation and in comparison with chemisorption of aptamer to a gold surface. Linear and molecular beacon aptamers of similar structure of binding site revealed similar binding properties to thrombin. Increased concentration of NaCl resulted in weakening of the binding of thrombin to the aptamers, probably due to shielding effect of Na(+) ions. The binding of the thrombin to the aptamer depends on electrolyte pH, which is presumably connected with maintaining the three dimensional aptamer configuration, optimal for binding the protein.     

Surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy study of interfacial binding of thrombin to antithrombin DNA aptamers

We have applied surface plasmon resonance (SPR) spectroscopy, in combination with one-step direct binding, competition, and sandwiched assay schemes, to study thrombin binding to its DNA aptamers, with the aim to further the understanding of their interfacial binding characteristics. Using a 15-mer aptamer that binds thrombin primarily at the fibrinogen-recognition exosite as a model, we have demonstrated that introducing a DNA spacer in the aptamer enhances thrombin-binding capacity and stability, as similarly reported for hydrocarbon linkers. The bindings are aptamer surface coverage and salt concentration dependent. When free aptamers or DNA sequences complementary to the immobilized aptamer are applied after the formation of thrombin/aptamer complexes, bound thrombin is displaced to a certain extent, depending on the stability of the complexes formed under different conditions. When the 29-mer aptamer (specific to thrombin's heparin-binding exosite) is immobilized on the surface, its affinity to thrombin appears to be lower than the immobilized 15-mer aptamer, although the 29-mer aptamer is known to have a higher affinity in the solution phase. These findings underline the importance of aptamers' ability to fold into intermolecular structures and their accessibility for target capture. Using a sandwiched assay scheme followed by an additional signaling step involving biotin-streptavidin chemistry, we have observed the simultaneous binding of the 15- and 29-mer aptamers to thrombin protein at different exosites and have found that one aptamer depletes thrombin's affinity to the other when they bind together. We believe that these findings are invaluable for developing DNA aptamer-based biochips and biosensors.     

Finding the Optimal Surface Density of Aptamer Monolayers by SPR Imaging Detection‐based Aptamer Microarrays

Surface plasmon resonance imaging (SPRi) by enabling label‐free, real time assessment of biomolecular interactions in multiplexed manner is one of the methods of choice for high throughput characterization of large pools of DNA aptamer candidates following in vitro selection. Moreover, with major advances in in situ amplification methods SPRi became also a viable detection platform for aptamer microarrays. In case of aptamer microarrays, commonly prepared by microspotting, the direct assessment of the surface density of aptamer probes, which is essential for both kinetic and sensing measurements is not possible. Therefore, here we introduce a methodology for simple, one‐step determination of surface densities of thiol labelled aptamer monolayers microspotted on gold SPRi chips. Based on this methodology we investigated in detail the effect of the surface density of aptamers on target binding through two aptamer‐target systems, i. e. human immunoglobulin E (hIgE) and six histidine tag 6xHis‐tag. We found that the surface density of the aptamers is indeed critical and shows a sharp maximum in terms of target binding efficiency, which is largely determined by the size of the target. The optimal aptamer surface densities determined, the immobilization chemistry (shared by many detection platforms, e. g., electrochemical, surface acoustic) and the trends identified may be used for rapid rational optimization of aptamer‐target assays.     

RNA aptamers that bind flavin and nicotinamide redox cofactors

RNA molecules that specifically bind riboflavin (Rb) and beta-nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMN) have been isolated by in vitro selection. A simple structural motif containing intramolecular G-quartets was found to bind tightly to oxidized riboflavin (Kd = 1-5 micromolar). DNA versions of the consensus sequence also bind, but with weaker affinity. DMS protection experiments show that the quartet structure of these aptamers is stabilized by interaction with the flavin. As a measure of their redox specificity, the aptamers do not show significant differential binding between oxidized and reduced forms of a 5-deazariboflavin derivative that is a close structural analog of riboflavin. In contrast to the lack of redox specificity of the riboflavin aptamers, RNAs selected for binding to the nicotinamide portion of NAD discriminate between NAD and NADH in solution by over an order of magnitude. A mutagenized pool based on one of the NMN aptamer sequences was used to reselect for NMN binding. Comparison of the reselected sequences led to the identification of the binding region of the aptamer. A complex secondary structure containing two interacting stem-loops is proposed for the minimal NMN-binding RNA. The same mutagenized pool was used to select for increased discrimination between NMN and NMNH. From these reselected sequences, a mutation within the binding region was identified that increases specificity for NMN. These experiments show that RNA can bind these cofactors with low micromolar affinity and, in the case of nicotinamide cofactors, can discriminate between the two redox states. These cofactor binding motifs may provide a framework for generating new ribozymes that catalyze redox reactions similar to those found in basic metabolic pathways.     

Arrest of Rolling Circle Amplification by Protein‐Binding DNA Aptamers

Certain DNA polymerases, such as ?29 DNA polymerase, can isothermally copy the sequence of a circular template round by round in a process known as rolling circle amplification (RCA), which results in super‐long single‐stranded (ss) DNA molecules made of tandem repeats. The power of RCA reflects the high processivity and the strand‐displacement ability of these polymerases. In this work, the ability of ?29DNAP to carry out RCA over circular templates containing a protein‐binding DNA aptamer sequence was investigated. It was found that protein–aptamer interactions can prevent this DNA polymerase from reading through the aptameric domain. This finding indicates that protein‐binding DNA aptamers can form highly stable complexes with their targets in solution. This novel observation was exploited by translating RCA arrest into a simple and convenient colorimetric assay for the detection of specific protein targets, which continues to showcase the versatility of aptamers as molecular recognition elements for biosensing applications.     

Peptide aptamer libraries

Peptide aptamers are molecules that bind to protein targets and are able to interfere with their functions. In the past, important achievements have been made using such peptide aptamers in different approaches and for various purposes. Peptide aptamers are comprised of a variable peptide region of 8 to 20 amino acids in length, which is displayed by a scaffold protein. An overview of the numerous scaffold proteins that have been investigated for their suitability to present peptide aptamers will be given. To identify peptide aptamers efficiently and specifically binding to a predetermined target, two eukaryotic systems have been used in multiple studies: a modified version of the Gal4 yeast-two-hybrid system and the optimized LexA interaction trap system. The two yeast systems are compared and the design of high-complexity peptide aptamer libraries for these systems is described. Although the yeast-two-hybrid system is based on intracellular interactions mammalian screens, performed in cell culture experiments, are sometimes preferred or required. We will give an overview of the mammalian selection systems available, which are based on the expression of peptide aptamers in retroviral or lentiviral vectors. We will show that the isolation and use of peptide aptamers as inhibitors of individual signaling components represents a new challenge for drug development.     

Structural basis for specific, high-affinity tetracycline binding by an in vitro evolved aptamer and artificial riboswitch

The tetracycline aptamer is an in vitro selected RNA that binds to the antibiotic with the highest known affinity of an artificial RNA for a small molecule (Kd approximately 0.8 nM). It is one of few aptamers known to be capable of modulating gene expression in vivo. The 2.2 A resolution cocrystal structure of the aptamer reveals a pseudoknot-like fold formed by tertiary interactions between an 11 nucleotide loop and the minor groove of an irregular helix. Tetracycline binds within this interface as a magnesium ion chelate. The structure, together with previous biochemical and biophysical data, indicates that the aptamer undergoes localized folding concomitant with tetracycline binding. The three-helix junction, h-shaped architecture of this artificial RNA is more complex than those of most aptamers and is reminiscent of the structures of some natural riboswitches.     

Structural basis of DNA folding and recognition in an AMP-DNA aptamer complex: distinct architectures but common recognition motifs for DNA and RNA aptamers complexed to AMP

Background: Structural studies by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) of RNA and DNA aptamer complexes identified through in vitro selection and amplification have provided a wealth of information on RNA and DNA tertiary structure and molecular recognition in solution. The RNA and DNA aptamers that target ATP (and AMP)' with micromolar affinity exhibit distinct binding site sequences and secondary structures. We report below on the tertiary structure of the AMP-DNA aptamer complex in solution and compare it with the previously reported tertiary structure of the AMP-RNA aptamer complex in solution.Results: The solution structure of the AMP-DNA aptamer complex shows, surprisingly, that two AMP molecules are intercalated at adjacent sites within a rectangular widened minor groove. Complex formation involves adaptive binding where the asymmetric internal bubble of the free DNA aptamer zippers up through formation of a continuous six-base mismatch segment which includes a pair of adjacent three-base platforms. The AMP molecules pair through their Watson-Crick edges with the minor groove edges of guanine residues. These recognition G·A mismatches are flanked by sheared G·A and reversed Hoogsteen G·G mismatch pairs.Conclusions: The AMP-DNA aptamer and AMP-RNA aptamer complexes have distinct tertiary structures and binding stoichiometries. Nevertheless, both complexes have similar structural features and recognition alignments in their binding pockets. Specifically, AMP targets both DNA and RNA aptamers by intercalating between purine bases and through identical G·A mismatch formation. The recognition G·A mismatch stacks with a reversed Hoogsteen G·G mismatch in one direction and with an adenine base in the other direction in both complexes. It is striking that DNA and RNA aptamers selected independently from libraries of 10¹⁴ molecules in each case utilize identical mismatch alignments for molecular recognition with micromolar affinity within binding-site pockets containing common structural elements.     

Label free,highly sensitive and selective recognition of small molecule using gold surface confined aptamers

A highly sensitive and selective small molecule detection platform has been developed using aptamers immobilized on electrode surface. In our system, two aptamers were used – one of which is for ATP recognition and the other is for signal produce. We designed two probes L1 (containing ATP aptamer and a part of hemin aptamer) and L2 (containing the complementary strand of ATP aptamer and the rest of hemin aptamer) and immobilized L1 on electrode surface. L2 was used to hybridize to L1 and form L1–L2 duplex which brought the two parts of hemin aptamer into close proximity. Then hemin can be captured by this duplex and detected by electrochemical methods. When we introduced ATP into the system, the ATP binding destroyed the duplex and L2 diffused into the solution. As a result, hemin cannot be captured to bring electrochemical signal.     

Aptamers selected for higher-affinity binding are not more specific for the target ligand

Previous study of eleven different in vitro-selected RNA aptamers that bind guanosine triphosphate (GTP) with K(d)s ranging from 8 microM to 9 nM showed that more information is required to specify the structures of the higher-affinity aptamers. We are interested in understanding how the more complex aptamers achieve higher affinities for the ligand. In vitro selection produces structural solutions to a functional problem that are are as simple as possible in terms of the information content needed to define them. It has long been assumed that the simplest way to improve the affinity of an aptamer is to increase the shape and functional group complementarity of the RNA binding pocket for the ligand. This argument underlies the hypothesis that selection for higher-affinity aptamers automatically leads to structures that bind more specifically to the target molecule. Here, we examined the binding specificities of the eleven GTP aptamers by carrying out competition binding studies with sixteen different chemical analogues of GTP. The aptamers have distinct patterns of specificity, implying that each RNA is a structurally unique solution to the problem of GTP binding. However, these experiments failed to provide evidence that higher-affinity aptamers bind more specifically to GTP. We suggest that the simplest way to improve aptamer K(d)s may be to increase the stability of the RNA tertiary structure with additional intramolecular RNA-RNA interactions; increasingly specific ligand binding may emerge only in response to direct selection for specificity.     

Probing the structure of DNA aptamers with a classic heterocycle

DNA aptamers are synthetic, single-stranded DNA oligonucleotides selected by SELEX methods for their binding with specific ligands. Here we present ethidium binding results for three related DNA aptamers (PDB code: 1OLD, 1DB6, and 2ARG)that bind L-argininamide (L-Arm). The ligand bound form of each aptamer's structure has been reported and each are found to be composed primarily of two domains consisting of a stem helical region and a loop domain that forms a binding pocket for the cognate ligand. Previous thermodynamic experiments demonstrated that the DNA aptamer 1OLD undergoes a large conformational ordering upon binding to L-Arm. Here we extend those linkage binding studies by examining the binding of the heterocyclic intercalator ethidium to each of the three aptamers by fluorescence and absorption spectrophotometric titrations. Our results reveal that ethidium binds to each aptamer with DeltaG degree's in the range of -8.7 to -9.4 kcal/mol. The stoichiometry of binding is 2:1 for each aptamer and is quantitatively diminished in the presence of L-Arm as is the overall fluorescence intensity of ethidium. Together, these results demonstrate that a portion of the bound ethidium is excluded from the aptamer in the presence of a saturating amount of L-Arm. These results demonstrate the utility of ethidium and related compounds for the probing of non-conventional DNA structures and reveal an interesting fundamental thermodynamic linkage in DNA aptamers. Results are discussed in the context of the thermodynamic stability and structure of each of the aptamers examined.