Rate and product studies in the solvolyses of N,N-dimethylsulfamoyl and 2-propanesulfonyl chlorides

Contrary to earlier suggestions of an S(N)1 pathway for solvolyses of N,N-dimethylsulfamoyl chloride (1), an extended Grunwald-Winstein equation treatment of the specific rates of solvolysis in 32 solvents shows an appreciable sensitivity towards changes in both solvent nucleophilicity and solvent ionizing power. The actual values are very similar to those obtained in earlier studies of the solvolyses of sulfonyl and phosphoryl chlorides, solvolyses which are believed to proceed by an S(N)2 pathway. The observation of similar selectivities in aqueous-alcohol solvents further supports this assignment. In a recent report, an addition-elimination (association-dissociation) pathway was proposed for solvolyses of 2-propanesulfonyl chloride (2). A severe multicollinearity problem has been removed by the addition of several specific rates of solvolysis in fluoroalcohol-containing solvents. The new analyses using the extended Grunwald-Winstein equation lead to sensitivities similar to those for and the previously studied related compounds, and these solvolyses are also best described as following an S(N)2 pathway.     

Application of the NT solvent nucleophilicity scale to attack at phosphorus: solvolyses of N,N,N',N'-tetramethyldiamidophosphorochloridate

The specific rates of solvolysis of N,N,N',N'-tetramethyldiamidophosphorochloridate have been measured at 25.0 degrees C in 31 solvents. Analysis with the extended Grunwald-Winstein equation leads to sensitivities toward changes in solvent nucleophilicity (l) of 1.20 +/- 0.07 and toward changes in solvent ionizing power (m) of 0.69 +/- 0.04. The correlation is improved by omission of the four data points for 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol-ethanol mixtures (F-test value from 155 to 320) with very small reductions in both l and m values. Activation parameters are reported for eight of the solvolyses. The l and m values are very similar to those previously reported for solvolyses of several arenesulfonyl chlorides, consistent with a concerted substitution process. This assignment is supported by a large k(Cl)/k(F) ratio for hydrolysis and a corresponding ratio for hydroxide-assisted hydrolysis of 178. The stereochemistry of nucleophilic attack at tetracoordinate phosphorus(V) is discussed.     

Nucleophilic Participation in the Solvolyses of (Arylthio)methyl Chlorides and Derivatives: Application of Simple and Extended Forms of the Grunwald-Winstein Equations

The specific rates of solvolysis of chloromethyl phenyl sulfide [(phenylthio)methyl chloride] and its p-chloro-derivative have been determined at 0.0 °C in a wide range of hydroxylic solvents, including several containing a fluroalcohol. Treatment in terms of a two-term Grunwald-Winstein equation, incorporating terms based on solvent ionizing power (Y(Cl)) and solvent nucleophilicity (N(T)) suggest a mechanism similar to that for the solvolyses of tert-butyl chloride, involving in the rate-determining step a nucleophilic solvation of the incipient carbocation in an ionization process. A previous suggestion, that a third-term governed by the aromatic ring parameter (I) is required, is shown both for the new and for the previously studied related substrates to be an artifact, resulting from an appreciable degree of multicollinearity between I values and a linear combination of N(T) and Y(Cl) values.     

Rate and product studies with dimethyl phosphorochloridate and phosphorochloridothionate under solvolytic conditions

The specific rates of solvolysis of dimethyl phosphorochloridate and of dimethyl phosphorochloridothionate are very well correlated using the extended Grunwald-Winstein equation, with incorporation of the NT solvent nucleophilicity scale and the YCl solvent ionizing power scale. The sensitivity parameters (l and m) are similar to each other and also similar to previously recorded values for solvolyses of arenesulfonyl chlorides, which were proposed to follow a concerted displacement mechanism. For solvolyses in aqueous ethanol or aqueous methanol the product selectivities (S) are close to unity. For solvolyses in aqueous 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol, the values are too small to accurately measure, showing a very large preference for product formation involving nucleophilic attack by the water component. It is concluded that the chloride and chloridothionate solvolyses, in common with the solvolyses of arenesulfonyl chlorides, follow a concerted displacement mechanism.     

Rate and product studies with benzyl and p-nitrobenzyl chloroformates under solvolytic conditions

The specific rates of solvolysis of p-nitrobenzyl chloroformate are well correlated using the extended Grunwald-Winstein equation, with a high sensitivity (l) to changes in solvent nucleophilicity (N(T)) and a moderate sensitivity (m) to changes in solvent ionizing power (Y(Cl)). The values are consistent with a rate-determining association within an association-dissociation pathway. The selectivity values (S) for the attack at the acyl carbon show a modest preference for ethanol over water and a relatively high preference for ethanol over 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol (TFE). The solvolyses of benzyl chloroformate show similar characteristics in solvents of relatively high nucleophilicity and/or low ionizing power. In solvents with considerable fluoro alcohol content, an ionization mechanism, accompanied by loss of carbon dioxide, leads to benzyl chloride, benzyl alcohol, and benzyl alkyl ether. A new correlation now applies, with a much lower l value and somewhat higher m value. The S values for this pathway are close to unity, even in TFE-ethanol mixtures, consistent with the components of the binary solvent capturing a highly reactive carbocation.     

Solvent polarity and organic reactivity in mixed solvents: evidence using a reactive molecular probe to assess the role of preferential solvation in aqueous alcohols

Product selectivities [S = ([ester product]/[acid product]) x ([water]/[alcohol solvent])] are reported for solvolyses of p-methoxybenzoyl chloride (2) in aqueous methanol, ethanol, 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol, n-propyl alcohol, isopropyl alcohol, and tert-butyl alcohol at 25, 35, and 45 degrees C. S values are small and depend significantly on the alcohol cosolvent, varying from 1.3 in methanol to 0.1 in tert-butyl alcohol, but S depends only slightly on the solvent composition, and on the temperature. As S adjusts the product ratios for changes in bulk solvent compositions, it is suggested that preferential solvation by either alcohol or water at the reaction site is not a major factor influencing rates or products. Logarithms of rates of solvolyses of 2 correlate well with Kosower Z values (based on solvatochromism). In contrast, another solvatochromic polarity index, E(T)(30), shows "dispersion" in correlations with the solvent ionizing power parameter, Y(OTs), probably due to aromatic ring and other solvation effects.     

Solvolyses of 2-Deoxy-alpha- and beta-D-Glucopyranosyl 4'-Bromoisoquinolinium Tetrafluoroborates

The solvolyses of 2-deoxy-alpha- and beta-D-glucopyranosyl 4'-bromoisoquinolinium tetrafluoroborates (1 and 2) were monitored in aqueous methanol, ethanol, trifluoroethanol, and binary mixtures of ethanol and trifluoroethanol. The observed rate constants are consistent with the solvolyses of 1 and 2 proceeding via dissociative (D(N) A(N)) transition states. In comparison to the alpha-anomer, solvolysis of the beta-compound gives a greater transition state charge delocalization onto the ring oxygen atom. Analysis of the solvolysis product ratios indicates that the 2-deoxyglucosyl oxacarbenium ion is not solvent-equilibrated in the solvent mixtures studied. In the solvolysis of compound 1, the solvent trifluoroethanol facilitates diffusional separation of the leaving group and, in so doing, promotes the formation of the retained trifluoroethyl glycoside.     

Use of the Simple and Extended Grunwald-Winstein Equations in the Correlation of the Rates of Solvolysis of Highly Hindered Tertiary Alkyl Derivatives

The original Grunwald-Winstein equation (1948) involved the development of a scale of solvent ionizing power (Y). Subsequent work has refined this scale and involved the development of scales of solvent nucleophilicity (N) and a term to correct for deviations when aromatic rings are present, governed by the aromatic ring parameter (I). These three scales, and the sensitivities towards each, can be related to specific rates of solvolysis through linear free energy relationships (LFERs).One important area of application of LFERs has been to the solvolyses of tert-alkyl halides. It has been proposed that the solvolysis of tert-butyl chloride involves a nucleophilic component, although other workers have suggested that the effects observed are related to electrophilic not nucleophilic influences. Takeuchi (1997) studied a compound with two of the methyl groups of tert-butyl chloride replaced by neopentyl groups. For this highly-hindered substrate there was no evidence for nucleophilic participation. Liu (1998) and Takeuchi (2001) have reported concerning the solvolyses of additional significantly-hindered tertiary alkyl chlorides. Liu (2009) has presented a parallel study of bromides. Martins (2008) has considered hindered tertiary alkyl halides, mainly with carbon-carbon multiple bonds as substituents. It was proposed that the hI term was of importance, with the sensitivities (h) sometimes positive and sometimes negative. To explain negative values, it was suggested that the I scale might contain a nucleophilicity component. In this review, we bring together, with analysis and commentary, the work of Takeuchi, Liu, Martins and others concerning the solvolyses of tertiary alkyl halides, with emphasis on the relevance of the three scales that have been developed for use in Grunwald-Winstein correlations.     

S(N)2 Mechanism for Alcoholysis, Aminolysis, and Hydrolysis of Acetyl Chloride

First-order solvolysis rate constants are reported for solvolyses of acetyl chloride in methanol and MeOD, and in binary aqueous mixtures with acetone, acetonitrile, ethanol, methanol, and trifluoroethanol at 0 degrees C. Product selectivities (S = [MeCOOR]/[MeCOOH] x [water]/[alcohol]) are reported for solvolyses in ethanol/ and methanol/water at 0 degrees C. Solvolyses of acetyl chloride show a high sensitivity to changes in solvent ionizing power, consistent with C-Cl bond cleavage. As the solvent is varied from pure ethanol (or methanol) to water, S values and rate-rate profiles show no evidence for the change in reaction channel observed for solvolyses of benzoyl and trimethylacetyl chlorides. However, using rate ratios in 40% ethanol/water and 97% trifluoroethanol/water (solvents of similar ionizing power but different nucleophilicities) to compare sensitivities to nucleophilic attack, solvolyses of acetyl chloride are over 20-fold more sensitive to nucleophilic attack than benzoyl chloride. The solvent isotope effect of 1.29 (MeOH/MeOD) for acetyl chloride is similar to that for p-methoxybenzoyl chloride (1.22) and is lower than for benzoyl chloride (1.55). Second-order rate constants for aminolyses of acetyl chloride with m-nitroaniline in methanol at 0 degrees C show that acetyl chloride behaves similarly to p-methoxybenzoyl chloride, whereas benzoyl chloride is 40-fold more sensitive to the added amine. The results indicate mechanistic differences between solvolyses of acetyl and benzoyl chlorides, and an S(N)2 mechanism is proposed for solvolyses and aminolyses by m-nitroaniline of acetyl chloride (i.e. these reactions are probably not carbonyl additions, but a strong sensitivity to nucleophilic attack accounts for their high rates).     

Mechanisms of solvolyses of acid chlorides and chloroformates. Chloroacetyl and phenylacetyl chloride as similarity models

[reaction: see text] Rate constants and product selectivities (S = ([ester product]/[acid product]) x ([water]/[alcohol solvent]) are reported for solvolyses of chloroacetyl chloride (3) at -10 degrees C and phenylacetyl chloride (4) at 0 degrees C in ethanol/ and methanol/water mixtures. Additional kinetic data are reported for solvolyses in acetone/water, 2,2,2-trifluoroethanol(TFE)/water, and TFE/ethanol mixtures. Selectivities and solvent effects for 3, including the kinetic solvent isotope effect (KSIE) of 2.18 for methanol, are similar to those for solvolyses of p-nitrobenzoyl chloride (1, Z = NO(2)); rate constants in acetone/water are consistent with a third-order mechanism, and rates and products in ethanol/ and methanol/water mixtures can be explained quantitatively by competing third-order mechanisms in which one molecule of solvent (alcohol or water) acts as a nucleophile and another acts as a general base (an addition/elimination reaction channel). Selectivities increase for 3 as water is added to alcohol. Solvent effects on rate constants for solvolyses of 3 are very similar to those of methyl chloroformate, but acetyl chloride shows a lower KSIE, and a higher sensitivity to solvent-ionizing power, explained by a change to an S(N)2/S(N)1 (ionization) reaction channel. Solvolyses of 4 undergo a change from the addition/elimination channel in ethanol to the ionization channel in aqueous ethanol (<80% v/v alcohol). The reasons for change in reaction channels are discussed in terms of the gas-phase stabilities of acylium ions, calculated using Gaussian 03 (HF/6-31G(d), B3LYP/6-31G(d), and B3LYP/6-311G(d,p) MO theory).     

Thermal and photochemical solvolysis of (E)- and (Z)-2-phenyl-1-propenyl(phenyl)iodonium tetrafluoroborate: benzenium and primary vinylic cation intermediates

The thermal and photochemical solvolysis of the two stereoisomeric 2-phenyl-1-propenyl(phenyl)iodonium tetrafluoroborates has been investigated in alcoholic solvents of varying nucleophilicity. The product profiles and rates of product formation in the thermal reaction are all compatible with a mechanism involving cleavage of the vinylic C-I bond assisted by the group in the trans position (methyl or phenyl), always leading to rearranged products. Depending on the nucleophilicity of the solvent, the primarily formed cations may or may not further rearrange to more stable isomers. The less reactive Z compound also yields some unrearranged vinyl ether product in the more nucleophilic solvents via an in-plane S(N)2 mechanism. The mechanism of the photolysis involves direct, unassisted cleavage of the vinylic, and aromatic, C-I bond in an S(N)1 mechanism. This produces a primary vinyl cation, which is partially trapped prior to rearrangement in methanol. The unrearranged vinyl ethers are mainly formed with retention of configuration via a lambda3-iodonium/solvent complex in an S(N)i mechanism. Thermal and photochemical solvolyses of iodonium salts are complementary techniques for the generation of different cation intermediates from the same substrate.     

Structural effects on the solvolytic reactivity of carboxylic and sulfonic acid chlorides. Comparisons with gas-phase data for cation formation

Kinetic data for solvolyses of 28 acid chlorides in 97% w/w trifluoroethanol (TFE)-water spanning over 10 (9) in rate constant at 25 degrees C are obtained directly or by short extrapolation from published values. G3 calculations of the energy required for cation formation in the gas phase are validated from proton affinities and from other experimental data. G3 calculations of heterolytic bond dissociation enthalpies (HBDEs) for formation of cations from acid chlorides in the gas phase show the following trends when compared with the solvolysis rate constants: (i) electron-rich sulfonyl chlorides and most carboxylic acid chlorides, including thione derivatives, give a satisfactory linear correlation with a significant negative slope; (ii) most sulfonyl chlorides and some chloroformates and thio derivatives have higher HBDEs and fit another correlation with a small, negative slope. A significant deviation is observed for the acyl series (RCOCl), for which both solvolysis rates and HBDEs increase in the order R = Bu ( t ) < Pr ( i ) < Et < Me. The deviation may be explained either by a prior hydration mechanism or preferably by electrostatic effects on the formation of small cations. The above results of structural effects support independent evidence from solvent effects that cationic ionization reaction pathways (with nucleophilic solvent assistance or S N2 character) are involved in the solvolyses of acid chlorides.     

Additivity rules using similarity models for chemical reactivity: calculation and interpretation of electrofugality and nucleofugality

A recently proposed, multi-parameter correlation: log k (25 degrees C)=s(f) (Ef + Nf), where Ef is electrofugality and Nf is nucleofugality, for the substituent and solvent effects on the rate constants for solvolyses of benzhydryl and substituted benzhydryl substrates, is re-evaluated. A new formula (Ef=log k (RCl/EtOH/25 degrees C) -1.87), where RCl/EtOH refers to ethanolysis of chlorides, reproduces published values of Ef satisfactorily, avoids multi-parameter optimisations and provides additional values of Ef. From the formula for Ef, it is shown that the term (sfxEf) is compatible with the Hammett-Brown (rho+sigma+) equation for substituent effects. However, the previously published values of N(f) do not accurately account for solvent and leaving group effects (e.g. nucleofuge Cl or X), even for benzhydryl solvolyses; alternatively, if the more exact, two-parameter term, (sfxNf) is used, calculated effects are less accurate. A new formula (Nf=6.14 + log k(BX/any solvent/25 degrees C)), where BX refers to solvolysis of the parent benzhydryl as electrofuge, defines improved Nf values for benzhydryl substrates. The new formulae for Ef and Nf are consistent with an assumption that sf=1.00(,) and so improved correlations for benzhydryl substrates can be obtained from the additive formula: log k(RX/any solvent/25 degrees C)=(Ef + Nf). Possible extensions of this approach are also discussed.     

Experimental studies of the 13C NMR of iodoalkynes in Lewis-basic solvents

The (13)C NMR spectra of two different iodoalkynes, 1-iodo-1-hexyne (1) and diiodoethyne (2), exhibit a strong solvent dependence. Comparisons of the data with several common empirical models, including Gutmann's Donor numbers, Reichardt's E(N)(T), and Taft and Kamlet's beta and pi, demonstrate that this solvent effect arises from a specific acid-base interaction. Solvent basicity measures such as Donor numbers and beta values correlate well with the alpha-carbon chemical shift of 1, but polarity measures such as E(N)(T) and pi do not correlate. The similarity of the solvent effect for 1 and 2 suggests that carbon-carbon bond polarization may not play a role in the change in chemical shift, as previously hypothesized.     

Correlation of the rates of solvolysis of the S-Ethyldibenzothiophenium Ion

The specific rates of solvolysis of S-ethyldibenzothiophenium trifluoromethanesulfonate have been found to give a good linear correlation with the previously determined specific rates of solvolysis of the triethyloxonium ion, and hence with the solvent nucleophilicity scale established from the triethyloxonium ion study. A value for the sensitivity to changes in solvent nucleophilicity ( 1 ) of greater than unity (1.15) is in accord with reactivity-selectivity considerations.     

Ab initio study of the SN1Ar and SN2Ar reactions of benzenediazonium ion with water. On the conception of "unimolecular dediazoniation" in solvolysis reactions

The nucleophilic substitution of N2 in benzenediazonium ion 1 by one H2O molecule to form protonated phenol 2 has been studied with ab initio (RHF, MP2, QCISD(T)//MP2) and hybrid density functional (B3LYP) methods. Three mechanisms were considered: (a) the unimolecular process SN1Ar with steps 1 --> Ph+ + N2 and Ph+ + H2O --> 2, (b) the bimolecular process SN2Ar with precoordination 1 + H2O --> 1 x H2O, SN reaction 1 x H2O --> [TS]++ --> 2 x N2 and dissociation of the postcoordination complex 2 x N2 --> 2 + N2, and (c) the direct bimolecular process SN2Ar that bypasses precoordination and involves just the SN reaction 1 + H2O --> [TS]++ --> 2 + N2. The SN2Ar reactions proceed by way of a Cs symmetric SN2Ar transition state structure that is rather loose, contains essentially a phenyl cation weakly bound to N2 and OH2, and is analogous to the transition state structures of front-side nucleophilic replacement at saturated centers. In solvolysis reactions, all of these processes follow first-order kinetics, and the electronic relaxation is essentially the same. It is argued that "unimolecular dediazoniations" have to proceed by way of SN2Ar transition state structures because strict SN1Ar reactions cannot be realized in solvolyses, despite the fact that the Gibbs free energy profile favors the strict SN1Ar process over the SN2Ar reaction by 6.7 kcal/mol. It is further argued that the direct SN2Ar process is the best model for the solvolysis reaction for dynamic reasons, and its Gibbs free energy of activation is 19.3 kcal/mol and remains higher than the SN1Ar value. Even though the SN1Ar and SN2Ar models provide activation enthalpies and SKIE values that closely match the experimental data, the analysis leads us to the unavoidable conclusion that this agreement is fortuitous. While the experiments do show that the solvent effect on the activation energy is about the same for all solvents, they do not show the absence of a solvent effect. The ab initio results presented here suggest that the solvent effect on the direct SN2Ar dediazoniation is approximately 12 kcal/mol, and computation of solvent effects with the isodensity polarized continuum model (IPCM) support this conclusion.     

Is the tert-butyl chloride solvolysis the most misunderstood reaction in organic chemistry? Evidence against nucleophilic solvent participation in the tert-butyl chloride transition state and for increased hydrogen bond donation to the 1-adamantyl chloride solvolysis transition state.

Despite theoretical calculations to the contrary, it has been argued that the 1-adamantyl cation is more stable than the tert-butyl cation in media of high dielectric constant. This argument has been utilized to suggest that the higher rate of solvolysis of tert-butyl chloride in aqueous ethanol is evidence for nucleophilic solvent participation in this classic reaction. Further, in "more highly ionizing" solvents, the rate of 1-adamantyl chloride is nearly the same as that of tert-butyl chloride, which is interpreted as a manifestation of the relative stabilities of the cations. However, the evidence cited does not explain the increased sensitivity of the rate of solvolysis of 1-adamantyl chloride over tert-butyl chloride to solvents which are better able to donate hydrogen bonds. The hypothesis developed here is that 1-adamantyl chloride solvolysis is assisted by hydrogen bond donation departing chloride ion to a greater extent than that of tert-butyl chloride solvolysis, most likely due to lessened steric interactions in a developing pyramidal cation. This hypothesis is supported by multiparameter solvent effect factor analyses utilizing the KOMPH2 equation which, in addition, quantifies the important role of ground-state destabilization due to strong solvent-solvent interactions. An important result from the good correlation of free energies of transfer of the tert-butyl chloride solvolysis transition state is that there is no change in mechanism, and, in particular, no nucleophilic participation even in non-hydroxylic basic solvents. The equation is also applied to the case of dimethylsulfonium ion solvolyses where the tert-butyl salt reacts substantially faster than the 1-adamantyl salt in ethanol and the gas phase. The decreased rate of the former in hydrogen bond donating solvents relative to the gas phase is as yet unclear. Solvent N values that were generated to characterize solvent nucleophilicity are shown not to be correlated by measures of solvent basicity but rather by the negative of measures of solvent hydrogen bond donor ability.     

Rate and Product Studies in the Solvolyses of Two Cyclic Phosphorochloridate Esters

Kinetic and product studies of the solvolyses of acyclic phosphorochloridates are extended to two cyclic diesters, 2-chloro-1,3,2-dioxaphospholane-2-oxide (1) and 2-chloro-5,5-dimethyl-1,3,2-dioxaphosphorinane-2-oxide (2). Slightly faster solvolyses are observed for 1 than for the acyclic dimethyl phosphorochloridate (3), and 2 solvolyzes somewhat slower than 3. An extended Grunwald–Winstein equation treatment shows similar sensitivities to changes in solvent nucleophilicity and solvent ionizing power for 1, 2, and 3, and a concerted S_N2 attack is proposed in each case. Product studies for the solvolyses of 2 in aqueous alcohols are presented.

     

Kinetics of the reactions of halide anions with carbocations: quantitative energy profiles for s(n)1 reactions

Rate constants for the reactions of Laser flash photolytically generated benzhydrylium ions (diarylcarbenium ions) with halide ions have been determined in various solvents, including neat and aqueous acetonitrile as well as some alcohols. Substitution of the rate constants into the correlation equation log k = s(N + E) yields the nucleophilicity parameters N for the halide ions in different solvents. Linear correlations with negative slopes are found between the nucleophilicity parameters N for Cl(-) and Br(-) in different solvents and the solvent ionizing powers Y of the corresponding solvents. Increasing halide solvation reduces the rates of carbocation/chloride combinations by approximately half as much as it increases the rates of ionizations of benzhydryl chlorides. Comparison of the solvent dependent nucleophilicity parameters N of halide anions and the nucleophilicity parameters N(1) for solvents yields a quantitative prediction of common ion rate depression, as demonstrated by the analysis of a variety of literature reported mass-law constants alpha. Combination of the rate constants for the reactions of benzhydrylium ions with halide ions (k(-)()(1)) reported in this work with the ionization constants of benzhydryl halides (k(1)) and the recently reported rate constants for the reactions of benzhydrylium ions with solvents (k(2)) yields complete quantitative free energy profiles for solvolysis reactions. The applicability of Hammond's postulate for interpreting solvolysis reactions can thus be examined quantitatively.     

Photochemical generation of six- and five-membered cyclic vinyl cations

The photochemical solvolyses of 4-tert-butylcyclohex-1-enyl(phenyl)iodonium tetrafluoroborate (1) and cyclopent-1-enyl(phenyl)iodonium tetrafluoroborate (2) in methanol yield vinylic ethers and vinylic cycloalkenyliodobenzenes and cycloalkenylbenzene, which are the trapping products of the geometrically destabilized C6-ring and C5-ring vinyl cation with the solvent and with the leaving group iodobenzene. Iodonium salt 2 also yields an allylic ether and allylic cyclopentenyliodobenzenes and cyclopentenylbenzene, which are the trapping products of the C5-ring allylic cation produced from the C5-ring vinyl cation by a hydride shift in a typical carbocationic rearrangement.