Discovery, characterization, and optimization of an unnatural base pair for expansion of the genetic alphabet

DNA is inherently limited by its four natural nucleotides. Efforts to expand the genetic alphabet, by addition of an unnatural base pair, promise to expand the biotechnological applications available for DNA as well as to be an essential first step toward expansion of the genetic code. We have conducted two independent screens of hydrophobic unnatural nucleotides to identify novel candidate base pairs that are well recognized by a natural DNA polymerase. From a pool of 3600 candidate base pairs, both screens identified the same base pair, dSICS:dMMO2, which we report here. Using a series of related analogues, we performed a detailed structure-activity relationship analysis, which allowed us to identify the essential functional groups on each nucleobase. From the results of these studies, we designed an optimized base pair, d5SICS:dMMO2, which is efficiently and selectively synthesized by Kf within the context of natural DNA.     

Major groove substituents and polymerase recognition of a class of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs

Expansion of the genetic alphabet with an unnatural base pair is a long‐standing goal of synthetic biology. We have developed a class of unnatural base pairs, formed between d 5SICS and analogues of d MMO2 that are efficiently and selectively replicated by the Klenow fragment (Kf) DNA polymerase. In an effort to further characterize and optimize replication, we report the synthesis of five new d MMO2 analogues bearing different substituents designed to be oriented into the developing major groove and an analysis of their insertion opposite d 5SICS by Kf and Thermus aquaticus DNA polymerase I (Taq). We also expand the analysis of the previously optimized pair, d NaM –d 5SICS , to include replication by Taq. Finally, the efficiency and fidelity of PCR amplification of the base pairs by Taq or Deep Vent polymerases was examined. The resulting structure–activity relationship data suggest that the major determinants of efficient replication are the minimization of desolvation effects and the introduction of favorable hydrophobic packing, and that Taq is more sensitive than Kf to structural changes. In addition, we identify an analogue (d NMO1 ) that is a better partner for d 5SICS than any of the previously identified d MMO2 analogues with the exception of d NaM . We also found that d NaM –d 5SICS is replicated by both Kf and Taq with rates approaching those of a natural base pair.     

Efforts toward expansion of the genetic alphabet: structure and replication of unnatural base pairs

Expansion of the genetic alphabet has been a long-time goal of chemical biology. A third DNA base pair that is stable and replicable would have a great number of practical applications and would also lay the foundation for a semisynthetic organism. We have reported that DNA base pairs formed between deoxyribonucleotides with large aromatic, predominantly hydrophobic nucleobase analogues, such as propynylisocarbostyril (dPICS), are stable and efficiently synthesized by DNA polymerases. However, once incorporated into the primer, these analogues inhibit continued primer elongation. More recently, we have found that DNA base pairs formed between nucleobase analogues that have minimal aromatic surface area in addition to little or no hydrogen-bonding potential, such as 3-fluorobenzene (d3FB), are synthesized and extended by DNA polymerases with greatly increased efficiency. Here we show that the rate of synthesis and extension of the self-pair formed between two d3FB analogues is sufficient for in vitro DNA replication. To better understand the origins of efficient replication, we examined the structure of DNA duplexes containing either the d3FB or dPICS self-pairs. We find that the large aromatic rings of dPICS pair in an intercalative manner within duplex DNA, while the d3FB nucleobases interact in an edge-on manner, much closer in structure to natural base pairs. We also synthesized duplexes containing the 5-methyl-substituted derivatives of d3FB (d5Me3FB) paired opposite d3FB or the unsubstituted analogue (dBEN). In all, the data suggest that the structure, electrostatics, and dynamics can all contribute to the extension of unnatural primer termini. The results also help explain the replication properties of many previously examined unnatural base pairs and should help design unnatural base pairs that are better replicated.     

Solution Structure,Mechanism of Replication,and Optimization of an Unnatural Base Pair

As part of an ongoing effort to expand the genetic alphabet for in vitro and eventual in vivo applications, we have synthesized a wide variety of predominantly hydrophobic unnatural base pairs and evaluated their replication in DNA. Collectively, the results have led us to propose that these base pairs, which lack stabilizing edge‐on interactions, are replicated by means of a unique intercalative mechanism. Here, we report the synthesis and characterization of three novel derivatives of the nucleotide analogue d MMO2 , which forms an unnatural base pair with the nucleotide analogue d 5SICS . Replacing the para‐methyl substituent of d MMO2 with an annulated furan ring (yielding d FMO ) has a dramatically negative effect on replication, while replacing it with a methoxy (d DMO ) or with a thiomethyl group (d TMO ) improves replication in both steady‐state assays and during PCR amplification. Thus, d TMO –d 5SICS , and especially d DMO –d 5SICS , represent significant progress toward the expansion of the genetic alphabet. To elucidate the structure–activity relationships governing unnatural base pair replication, we determined the solution structure of duplex DNA containing the parental d MMO2 –d 5SICS pair, and also used this structure to generate models of the derivative base pairs. The results strongly support the intercalative mechanism of replication, reveal a surprisingly high level of specificity that may be achieved by optimizing packing interactions, and should prove invaluable for the further optimization of the unnatural base pair.     

Optimization of unnatural base pair packing for polymerase recognition

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we have been examining the ability of predominately hydrophobic nucleobase analogues to pair in duplex DNA and during polymerase-mediated replication. We previously reported the synthesis and thermal stability of unnatural base pairs formed between nucleotides bearing simple methyl-substituted phenyl ring nucleobase analogues. Several of these pairs are virtually as stable and selective as natural base pairs in the same sequence context. Here, we report the characterization of polymerase-mediated replication of the same unnatural base pairs. We find that every facet of replication, including correct and incorrect base pair synthesis, as well as continued primer extension beyond the unnatural base pair, is sensitive to the specific methyl substitution pattern of the nucleobase analogue. The results demonstrate that neither hydrogen bonding nor large aromatic surface area is required for polymerase recognition, and that interstrand interactions between small aromatic rings may be optimized for replication. Combined with our previous results, these studies suggest that appropriately derivatized phenyl nucleobase analogues represent a promising approach toward developing a third base pair and expanding the genetic alphabet.     

Structural Basis for Expansion of the Genetic Alphabet with an Artificial Nucleobase Pair

Hydrophobic artificial nucleobase pairs without the ability to pair through hydrogen bonds are promising candidates to expand the genetic alphabet. The most successful nucleobase surrogates show little similarity to each other and their natural counterparts. It is thus puzzling how these unnatural molecules are processed by DNA polymerases that have evolved to efficiently work with the natural building blocks. Here, we report structural insight into the insertion of one of the most promising hydrophobic unnatural base pairs, the dDs–dPx pair, into a DNA strand by a DNA polymerase. We solved a crystal structure of KlenTaq DNA polymerase with a modified template/primer duplex bound to the unnatural triphosphate. The ternary complex shows that the artificial pair adopts a planar structure just like a natural nucleobase pair, and identifies features that might hint at the mechanisms accounting for the lower incorporation efficiency observed when processing the unnatural substrates.     

Unnatural Cytosine Bases Recognized as Thymines by DNA Polymerases by the Formation of the Watson–Crick Geometry

The emergence of unnatural DNA bases provides opportunities to demystify the mechanisms by which DNA polymerases faithfully decode chemical information on the template. It was previously shown that two unnatural cytosine bases (termed “M‐fC” and “I‐fC”), which are chemical labeling adducts of the epigenetic base 5‐formylcytosine, can induce C‐to‐T transition during DNA amplification. However, how DNA polymerases recognize such unnatural cytosine bases remains enigmatic. Herein, crystal structures of unnatural cytosine bases pairing to dA/dG in the KlenTaq polymerase‐host–guest complex system and pairing to dATP in the KlenTaq polymerase active site were determined. Both M‐fC and I‐fC base pair with dA/dATP, but not with dG, in a Watson–Crick geometry. This study reveals that the formation of the Watson–Crick geometry, which may be enabled by the A‐rule, is important for the recognition of unnatural cytosines.     

Minor groove hydrogen bonds and the replication of unnatural base pairs

As part of an effort to expand the genetic alphabet, we examined the synthesis of DNA with six different unnatural nucleotides bearing methoxy-derivatized nucleobase analogues. Different nucleobase substitution patterns were used to systematically alter the nucleobase electronics, sterics, and hydrogen-bonding potential. We determined the ability of the Klenow fragment of E. coli DNA polymerase I to synthesize and extend the different unnatural base pairs and mispairs under steady-state conditions. Unlike other hydrogen-bond acceptors examined in the past, the methoxy groups do not facilitate mispairing, implying that they are not recognized by any of the hydrogen-bond donors of the natural nucleobases; however, they do facilitate replication. The more efficient replication results largely from an increase in the rate of extension of primers terminating at the unnatural base pair and, interestingly, requires that the methoxy group be at the ortho position where it is positioned in the developing minor groove and can form a functionally important hydrogen bond with the polymerase. Thus, ortho methoxy groups should be generally useful for the effort to expand the genetic alphabet.     

The effect of minor-groove hydrogen-bond acceptors and donors on the stability and replication of four unnatural base pairs

The stability and replication of DNA containing self-pairs formed between unnatural nucleotides bearing benzofuran, benzothiophene, indole, and benzotriazole nucleobases are reported. These nucleobase analogues are based on a similar scaffold but have different hydrogen-bond donor/acceptor groups that are expected to be oriented in the duplex minor groove. The unnatural base pairs do not appear to induce major structural distortions and are accommodated within the constraints of a B-form duplex. The differences between these unnatural base pairs are manifest only in the polymerase-mediated extension step, not in base-pair stability or synthesis. The benzotriazole self-pair is extended with an efficiency that is only 200-fold less than a correct natural base pair. The data are discussed in terms of available polymerase crystal structures and imply that further modifications may result in unnatural base pairs that can be both efficiently synthesized and extended, resulting in an expanded genetic alphabet.     

A new unnatural base pair system between fluorophore and quencher base analogues for nucleic acid-based imaging technology

In the development of orthogonal extra base pairs for expanding the genetic alphabet, we created novel, unnatural base pairs between fluorophore and quencher nucleobase analogues. We found that the nucleobase analogue, 2-nitropyrrole (denoted by Pn), and its 4-substitutions, such as 2-nitro-4-propynylpyrrole (Px) and 4-[3-(6-aminohexanamido)-1-propynyl]-2-nitropyrrole (NH(2)-hx-Px), act as fluorescence quenchers. The Pn and Px bases specifically pair with their pairing partner, 7-(2,2'-bithien-5-yl)imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Dss), which is strongly fluorescent. Thus, these unnatural Dss-Pn and Dss-Px base pairs function as reporter-quencher base pairs, and are complementarily incorporated into DNA by polymerase reactions as a third base pair in combination with the natural A-T and G-C pairs. Due to the static contact quenching, the Pn and Px quencher bases significantly decreased the fluorescence intensity of Dss by the unnatural base pairings in DNA duplexes. In addition, the Dss-Px pair exhibited high efficiency and selectivity in PCR amplification. Thus, this new unnatural base pair system would be suitable for detection methods of target nucleic acid sequences, and here we demonstrated the applications of the Dss-Pn and Dss-Px pairs as molecular beacons and in real-time PCR. The genetic alphabet expansion system with the replicable, unnatural fluorophore-quencher base pair will be a useful tool for sensing and diagnostic applications, as well as an imaging tool for basic research.     

Site‐Specifically Arraying Small Molecules or Proteins on DNA Using An Expanded Genetic Alphabet

A class of replicable unnatural DNA base pairs formed between d 5SICS and either d MMO2 , d DMO , or d NaM were developed. To explore the use of these pairs to produce site‐specifically labeled DNA, the synthesis of a variety of derivatives bearing propynyl groups, an analysis of their polymerase‐mediated replication, and subsequent site‐specific modification of the amplified DNA by Click chemistry is reported. With the d 5SICS scaffold a propynyl ether linker is accommodated better than its aliphatic analogue, but not as well as the protected propargyl amine linker explored previously. It was also found that with the d MMO2 and d DMO analogues, the d MMO2 position para to the glycosidic linkage is best suited for linker attachment and that although aliphatic and ether‐based linkers are similarly accommodated, the direct attachment of an ethynyl group to the nucleobase core is most well tolerated. To demonstrate the utility of these analogues, a variety of them were used to site‐selectively attach a biotin tag to the amplified DNA. Finally, we use d 5SICS^CO –d NaM to couple one or two proteins to amplified DNA, with the double labeled product visualized by atomic force microscopy. The ability to encode the spatial relationships of arrayed molecules in PCR amplifiable DNA should have important applications, ranging from SELEX with functionalities not naturally present in DNA to the production, and perhaps “evolution” of nanomaterials.     

Can a Six‐Letter Alphabet Increase the Likelihood of Photochemical Assault to the Genetic Code?

In 2014, two unnatural nucleosides, d5SICS and dNaM, were shown to selectively base pair and replicate with high fidelity in a modified strain of E. coli, thus effectively expanding its genetic alphabet from four to six letters. More recently, a significant reduction in cell proliferation was reported in cells cultured with d5SICS, and putatively with dNaM, upon exposure to brief periods of near‐visible radiation. The photosensitizing properties of the lowest‐energy excited triplet state of both d5SICS and dNaM were implicated in their cytotoxicity. Importantly, however, the excited‐state mechanisms by which near‐visible excitation populates the triplet states of d5SICS and dNaM are currently unknown. In this study, steady‐state and time‐resolved spectroscopies are combined with quantum‐chemical calculations in order to reveal the excited‐state relaxation mechanisms leading to efficient population of the triplet states in these unnatural nucleosides in solution. It is shown that excitation of d5SICS or dNaM with near‐visible light leads overwhelmingly to ultrafast population of their triplet states on the femtosecond time scale. The results presented in this work lend strong support to the proposal that photoexcitation of these unnatural nucleosides can accelerate oxidatively generated damage to DNA and other biomolecules within the cellular environment.     

An efficient unnatural base pair for PCR amplification

Expansion of the genetic alphabet by an unnatural base pair system provides a powerful tool for modern biotechnology. As an alternative to previous unnatural base pairs, we have developed a new pair between 7-(2-thienyl)imidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (Ds) and 2-nitropyrrole (Pn), which functions in DNA amplification. Pn more selectively pairs with Ds in replication than another previously reported pairing partner, pyrrole-2-carbaldehyde (Pa). The nitro group of Pn efficiently prevented the mispairing with A. High efficiency and selectivity of the Ds-Pn pair in PCR amplification were achieved by using a substrate mixture of the gamma-amidotriphosphate of Ds and the usual triphosphates of Pn and the natural bases, with Vent DNA polymerase as a 3' to 5' exonuclease-proficient polymerase. After 20 cycles of PCR, the total mutation rate of the Ds-Pn site in an amplified DNA fragment was approximately 1%. PCR amplification of DNA fragments containing the unnatural Ds-Pn pair would be useful for expanded genetic systems in DNA-based biotechnology.     

Polymerase evolution: efforts toward expansion of the genetic code

Genetic information is encoded by, but potentially not limited to, a four-letter alphabet. A variety of predominantly hydrophobic nucleobase analogues that form self-pairs in DNA have been examined as third base pair candidates. For example, the PICS self-pair is both stable in duplex DNA and synthesized by some wild-type polymerases with reasonable efficiency. These efforts to expand the genetic code are expected to be facilitated by optimizing both the unnatural nucleobase analogues and the polymerases that replicate them. Here, we report the use of an activity-based selection system to evolve a DNA polymerase that more efficiently replicates DNA containing the PICS self-pair. The selection system is based on the co-display on phage of DNA polymerase libraries and a DNA substrate containing the self-pair. Only polymerases that accept the unnatural substrate incorporate a biotin-dUTP to the attached primer and may then be isolated on a streptavidin solid support. A mutant of Sf polymerase, P2, was evolved which both inserts dPICSTP opposite dPICS in the template and extends the unnatural primer terminus by incorporation of the next correct natural dNTP, where the parental enzyme catalyzes neither step at detectable rates. P2 was found to be a triple mutant of Sf, with the mutations F598I, I614F, and Q489H. The evolved properties of P2, as well as the observed mutations, are consistent with an increased affinity for the DNA primer-template containing the self-pair.     

An efficiently extended class of unnatural base pairs

A third DNA base pair, which is synthesized efficiently and selectively, would have wide ranging applications from synthetic organisms to nucleic acids biotechnology. Hydrophobic unnatural nucleobases offer a promising route to such a pair, but are often limited by inefficient extension, defined as synthesis immediately following the unnatural pair. Here, we describe a simple screen which enables the characterization of large numbers of previously uncharacterized hetero base pairs. From this screen, we identified a class of unnatural base pairs which are extended more efficiently than any unnatural base pair reported to date. Screening, when complemented by further kinetic analysis, can improve the understanding of the determinants of efficient extension as well as identify viable hetero base pairs.     

Factors determining the deriving force of DNA formation: geometrical differences of base pairs, dehydration of bases, and the arginine assisting

The mechanism of the fidelity synthesis of DNA associated with the process of dGTP combination to the DNA template was explored. The exclusion of water molecules from the hydrated DNA bases can amplify the energy difference between the correct and incorrect base pairs, but the effect of the water molecules on the Gibbs free energy of formation is dependent on the binding sites for the water molecules. The water detachment from the incoming dNTP is not the only factor but the first step for the successful replication of DNA. The second step is the selection of the DNA polymerase on the DNA base pair through the comparison between the correct DNA base and the incorrect DNA base. The bonding of the Arg668 with the incoming dNTP can enlarge the Gibbs free energies of formation of the base pairs, especially the correct base pairs, thus increasing the driving force of DNA formation. When the DNA base of the primer terminus is correct, the extension of the guanine and the adenine is quicker than that of the cytosine and the thymine because of the hydrogen bonding fork formation of Arg668 with the minor groove of the primer terminus and the ring oxygen of the deoxyribose moiety of the incoming dNTP. Because of the geometry differences of the incorrect base pairs with the correct base pairs, the effect from the DNA polymerase is smaller on the incorrect base pair than on the correct base pair, and the extension of a mispair is slower than that of a correct base pair. This decreases the extension rate of the base pair and thus allows proofreading exonuclease activity to excise the incorrect base pair. Arg668 cannot prevent the extension of the GT mispair, as well as the GC correct base pair, and GA and GG mispairs. This may be attributed to the small geometry difference between the GT base pair and the correct AT base pair.     

Faithful PCR Amplification of an Unnatural Base‐Pair Analogue with Four Hydrogen Bonds

In vitro replication of an unnatural imidazopyridopyridine:naphthyridine base pair, (i.e., ImN^N:NaO^O), having four hydrogen bonds was investigated. Kinetic studies of single‐nucleotide insertion revealed that ImN^N and NaO^O were recognized as complementary bases by an exonuclease‐deficient Klenow fragment with higher specificity and efficiency than two previously described pairs (ImN^O:NaO^N and ImO^N:NaN^O) because of higher thermal and thermodynamic stabilities and the DAAD:ADDA (D=donor, A=acceptor) hydrogen‐bonding pattern of the ImN^N:NaO^O pair. Faithful polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification of a DNA fragment containing the ImN^N:NaO^O pair was achieved by using DNA polymerases possessing 3′→5′ exonuclease activity (≈99.5 % per doubling).     

Replication Experiments with Nucleotide Base Analogues

The principles governing the replication fidelity of genomes are not fully understood yet. Watson and Crick's base-pairing principle for matched deoxyribonucleotide (DNA) bases can explain why the guanine–cytosine and adenine-thymine base pairs are approximately one hundred times more stable thermodynamically than mismatched combinations. In vitro, DNA polymerases reduce the number of mismatched base pairs to about 10^?6 per Watson–Crick base pair. Replication fidelity can further be enhanced to a mutation probability of 10^?10or less in vivo if optimal conditions for DNA synthesis are provided by polymerase–assisting proteins and DNA-repairing enzymes. The precise reasons for the formation of mismatched base pairs (mispairs), which are responsible for a substantial part of DNA mutations, are still in debate. Although it is agreed that a template-directed “reading” of the hydrogen-substitution pattern in the heterocyclic bases is crucial for proper base pairing during DNA synthesis, it is not clear which type of “misreading” leads to mispairs. Misreading may be due to a non-Watson–Crick base pairing as well as to a change in the hydrogen-substitution pattern, leading to Watson-Crick-like mispairs. The surprising discovery of the selective and quantitative DNA-polymerase-catalyzed formation of a pyridine-pyrimidine base pair (involving a nucleotide base analogue) indicated that rare tautomeric forms in template DNA strands can lead to Watson-Crick-like mispairings that are hardly recognized by the polymerase's proofreading activity. This reveals new pathways for substitution mutations (replication-dependent DNA point mutations) and suggests a new type of mutagen in vivo.