Development of silica-based stationary phases for high-performance liquid chromatography

Stationary phases are the basis of the development and application of high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC). In this review we focused on the development of silica-based stationary phases, including the synthesis of silica gel and the application of silica in hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC), reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), chiral separation chromatography, and ion chromatography. New stationary phases, advances in ionic liquid-modified silica, silica-based core-shell materials, and silica-based monolithic columns for HPLC are introduced separately.     

Comparison of zirconia- and silica-based reversed stationary phases for separation of enkephalins

In this study, the separation of biologically active peptides on two zirconia-based phases, polybutadiene (PBD)-ZrO2 and polystyrene (PS)-ZrO2, and a silica-based phase C18 was compared. Basic differences in interactions on both types of phases led to quite different selectivity. The retention characteristics were investigated in detail using a variety of organic modifiers, buffers, and temperatures. These parameters affected retention, separation efficiency, resolution and symmetry of peaks. Separation systems consisting of Discovery PBD-Zr column and mobile phase composed of a mixture of acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 2.0 (45:55, v/v) at 70 degrees C and Discovery PS-Zr with acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 3.5 in the same (v/v) ratio at 40 degrees C were suitable for a good resolution of enkephalin related peptides. Mobile phase composed of acetonitrile and phosphate buffer, pH 5.0 (22:78, v/v) was appropriate for separation of enkephalins on Supelcosil C18 stationary phase.     

Synthesis and characterization of silica-based hyper-crosslinked sulfonate-modified reversed stationary phases

A novel type of silica-based sulfonate-modified reversed phase ((-)SO3-HC-C8) has been synthesized; it is based on a newly developed acid stable "hyper-crosslinked" C8 derivatized reversed phase, denoted HC-C8. The (-)SO3-HC-C8 phases containing controlled amounts of sulfonyl groups were made by sulfonating the aromatic hyper-crosslinked network of the HC-C(8) phase at different temperatures. The (-)SO3-HC-C8 phases are only slightly less hydrophobic than the parent HC-C8 phase. The added sulfonyl groups provide a unique strong cation-exchange selectivity to the hydrophobic hyper-crosslinked substrate as indicated by the very large C coefficient as shown through Snyder's hydrophobic subtraction reversed-phase characterization method. This cation-exchange activity clearly distinguishes the sulfonated phase from all other reversed phases as confirmed by the very high values of Snyder's column comparison function F(s). In addition, as was found in previous studies of silica-based and zirconia-based reversed phases, a strong correlation between the cation-exchange interaction and hydrophobic interaction was observed for these sulfonated phases in studies of the retention of cationic solutes. The overall chromatographic selectivity of these (-)SO3-HC-C8 phases is greatly enhanced by its high hydrophobicity through a "hydrophobically assisted" ion-exchange retention process.     

Selectivity of long chain stationary phases in reversed phase liquid chromatography

A series of commercial monomeric and polymeric C(18), C(27), and C(30) stationary phases were compared with immobilized poly(ethylene-co-acrylic acid) stationary phases synthesized in-house. The columns were characterized on the basis of methylene selectivity, silanol activity, metal activity, pore size, shape selectivity, and the ability to separate tocopherol isomers and carotenoid isomers. Monomeric and polymeric C(30) phases were shown to yield excellent separations of the tocopherol isomers while the polymeric C(30) and polyethylene phases were more appropriate to the separation of carotenoids.     

Liquid chromatography of sugars on silica-based stationary phases

A review is given of sugar analysis by liquid chromatography using silica columns. Aspects covered are column materials and preparation, chemically and physically modified amine columns, octadecy- and unmodified silica columns; eluent composition and elution mechanisms for the different types of columns used; detection methods, RI and UV detectors, visible lights, fluorescence, moving-wire, polarimetric and mass detection; and sample preparation and origin of samples.     

Theory of retention in reversed phase liquid chromatography with ternary mobile phases

The partition model of retention is developed for reversed phase liquid chromatography with multicomponent mobile phases. Simple equations for the retention and selectivity in ternary mobile phases are derived. For the systems in which the ratio of volume fractions of organic modifiers remains fixed, new linear dependences for retention factor and selectivity are proposed. These equations are successfully used to describe experimental data found in the literature. An influence of the nature of organic solvents and proportion in which they are mixed on retention and selectivity is discussed.     

Atypical silica-based column packings for high-performance liquid chromatography

Column packings widely used for high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) mostly are based on porous silica microspheres with certain pore sizes and pore size distributions. Such materials have the most desirable compromise of properties that provide for effective and reproducible separations over a wide range of operating conditions. To provide desired separation characteristics, several manufacturers specially synthesize the silica particles for these packings. While such column packing materials have general utility for a wide range of needs, special silica-based particles have been synthesized with different physical conformations for special separation goals. This presentation describes some atypical types of silica-based particles with unique separation properties that enlarge the capabilities of HPLC methods.     

Separation of small peptides by electrochromatography on silica-based reversed phases and hydrophobic anion exchange phases

Peptide separations are regarded as a promising application of capillary electrochromatography (CEC) and, at the same time, a suitable model to elucidate its mixed separation mechanism when charged analytes are involved. In this paper, studies on the separation of small peptides (2-4 amino acids) on a Spherisorb octadecyl silane (ODS) phase at acidic pH and on a strong anion exchange (SAX)/C18 mixed mode phase at weakly basic pH are reported. For the ODS phase a comparison of CEC, capillary zone electrophoresis (CZE) and high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) under identical buffer/eluent conditions is presented. The predicted retention factors for CEC under the assumption of simple superposition of HPLC retention and CZE migration matched the measured results for the peptides that had small retention factors in HPLC. For both types of stationary phases, a variation of the acetonitrile content in the mobile phase led to a wide range of retention factors, including negative values when co-electroosmotic migration was dominant. Though both the ODS and the SAX/C18 phase offer unique advantages, the SCX/C18 phase at pH 9 provides more flexibility to alter separation selectivity for the selected peptides.     

Novel ultra stable silica-based stationary phases for reversed phase liquid chromatography--study of a hydrophobically assisted weak acid cation exchange phase

A mixed-mode reversed-phase/weak cation exchange (RP/WCX) phase has been developed by introducing a small amount of carboxylate functionality into a hydrophobic hyper-crosslinked (HC) platform. This silica-based HC platform was designed to form an extensive polystyrene network completely confined to the particle's surface. The fully connected polymer network prevents the loss of bonded phase, which leads to superior hydrolytic stability of the new phase when compared to conventional silica-based phases. Compared to previously introduced HC phases the added carboxylic groups impart a new weak cation exchange selectivity to the base hydrophobic HC platform. The phase thus prepared shows a mixed-mode retention mechanism, allowing for both neutral organic compounds and bases of a wide polarity range to be simultaneously separated on the same phase under the same conditions. In addition, the new phase offers the flexibility that gradients in organic modifier, pH or ionic competitors can be used to affect the separation of a wide range of solutes. Moreover, the inherent weak acid cation exchange groups allow formic and acetic acid buffers to be used as eluents thereby avoiding the mass spectrometric ionization suppression problems concomitant to the use of non-volatile additives such as strong amine modifiers (e.g. triethylamine) or salts (e.g. NaCl) to elute basic solutes from the strong cation exchange phase which was previously developed in this lab. The use of the new phase for achieving strong retention of rather hydrophilic neurotransmitters and drugs of abuse without the need for ion pairing agents is demonstrated.     

Application of silica-based hyper-crosslinked sulfonate-modified reversed stationary phases for separating highly hydrophilic basic compounds

The separation and determination of hydrophilic basic compounds are of great importance in many fields including clinical and biological research, pharmaceutical development and forensic analysis. However, the most widely used analytical separation technique in these disciplines, reversed-phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), usually does not provide sufficient retention for several important classes of highly hydrophilic basic compounds including catecholamines, many drug metabolites and many drugs of abuse. Commonly eluents having little or no organic modifier and/or strong ion pairing agents must be used to achieve sufficient retention and separation. Use of highly aqueous eluents can lead to column failure by dewetting, resulting in poor retention, low selectivity and irreproducibility and slow recovery of performance. The use of a strong ion pairing agent to increase retention renders the separation incompatible with mass spectrometric detection and complicates preparative separations. This paper describes the successful applications of a novel type of silica-based, hyper-crosslinked, sulfonate-modified reversed stationary phase, denoted as (-)SO(3)-HC-C(8)-L, for the separation of highly hydrophilic cations and related compounds by a hydrophobically assisted cation-exchange mechanism. Compared to conventional reversed-phases, the (-)SO(3)-HC-C(8)-L phase showed significantly improved retention and separation selectivity for hydrophilic amines. Concurrently, due to the presence of both cation-exchange and reversed-phase retention mechanisms and the high acid stability of hyper-crosslinked phases, the separation can be optimized by changing the type or concentration of ionic additive or organic modifier, and by varying the column temperature. In addition, gradients generated by programming the concentration of either the ionic additive or the organic modifier can be applied to reduce the analysis time without compromising resolution. Furthermore, remarkably different chromatographic selectivities, especially toward cationic solutes, were observed upon comparing the (-)SO(3)-HC-C(8)-L phase with conventional reversed-phases. We believe that the combination of these two types of stationary phases will be very useful in two-dimensional liquid chromatography.     

Optimization of St John's Wort flavonoid separation by reversed phase liquid chromatography on a silica-based monolithic column

Summary An optimization procedure for the separation of flavonoids from St John's Wort by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography on monolithic stationary phase is described. Three-component mobile phase systems are studied using experimental design methodology. The starting experimental domain is a triangle, each vertex of which is a pure component. From preliminary isocratic experiments, truncations in the domain are performed leading to a quadrilateral shape working domain with no symmetry. To cope with both separation and analysis time, desirability functions are used. Optimal conditions are finally given by binary systems and the four flavonoids are separated in less than seven minutes.     

An improved optimization procedure for the selection of mixed mobile phases in reversed phase liquid chromatography

Summary The stepwise procedure described previously [1] for the selection of optimal mobile phase compositions in reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC) is improved in two ways. The optimization criterion is modified to account for variations in analysis time. The iterative approach to the optimal solvent composition makes a more efficient use of previous data. An example illustrates the resulting gain in speed and accuracy.Presented at the 14th International Symposium on Chromatography London, September, 1982     

High-performance anion-exchange chromatography of proteins using aza-ether bonded silica-based phases

The use of wide-pore silica-based hydrophilic aza-ether bonded phases for the chromatographic separation of proteins under anion-exchange conditions was studied. Polyether silanes containing terminal morpholine or piperazine derivatives are synthesized for attachment to the silica surface and provide a flexible approach to bonded phase design. In one instance, a quaternized amine support may be prepared by further derivatization of the methylpiperazine bonded phase. The supports provide high-performance anion-exchange chromatographic separations of proteins using gradients of increasing salt content, e.g., to 1.0 M sodium acetate at pH 7.0. The salt type and concentration can be varied to control protein retention while the buffer system used at pH 7.0 exerts a minimal influence on the separation. The anion exchangers may be reproducibly prepared and exhibit chromatographic retention stability at pH 7.5 for at least 2 months of operation. Acceptable capacity for protein on the bonded phase is demonstrated with high recovery of solute mass. The flexibility in anion exchanger design provides a probe of bonded ligand hydrophobic effects which can contribute in an undefined and deleterious manner to the desired ion-exchange separation. Taken together, these results provide a greater insight into the operating characteristics of anion exchangers, especially with regard to competing retention mechanisms.     

Cation-exchange liquid chromatography of choline and acetylcholine on free shielded silanols of silica-based reversed-phase stationary phases.

Free anionic functions present on the surface of reversed-phase packing materials were used for the selective cation-exchange preconcentration and separation of the neurotransmitters choline and acetylcholine from a biological matrix. The cation-exchange behaviour of different reversed-phase packing materials in the neat aqueous mobile phase, the properties of an end-capped column, the dependence of capacity factors and peak shape on the concentration of counter ions, ionic strength, pH and the addition of acetonitrile and optimum conditions for enzymatic conversion of solutes to hydrogen peroxide were studied. The studied reversed-phase columns exhibit better pH stability and longer lifetimes than normal silica-based cation exchangers. Acetylcholine is an effective and sensitive test sample for the measurement of adsorption on silica support. A large sample volume was injected onto a precolumn inserted instead of an injection valve and after injection the solutes were focused and separated on an analytical column with a mobile phase containing tetramethylammonium perchlorate as the counter ion.     

The study of reversed phases by inverse gas chromatography

Summary The surface properties of three silica-based reversed phases have been studied by inverse gas chromatography. Theoretical deduction indicates that there is a linear relationship between the molar deformation polarisation of the test solute (P_D) and the dispersive interaction energy between the solute and the C18 and non-bonded silica surfaces. The specific interaction energy between the solute molecule and the silica surface (-G^SP) can be measured as the vertical distance between the solute experimental retention data point (RTl_nV_N) and the n-alkane RTl_nV_N vs P_D calibration line. From multiple regression analysis of-G^SP data with proton acceptor solubility parameter {ie290-1} and orientation solubility parameter {ie290-2} as variants, two coefficients can be obtained related to the influence of the residual silanol groups and the trace metal impurities.     

Fluorocarbon stationary phases for liquid chromatography applications

This article presents an overview on fluorocarbon stationary phases for liquid chromatography (LC) applications. Fluorocarbons developed as alternative reverse phases have revealed previously unknown separation mechanisms and special utilities. Solvophobicity and fluorophilicity of the fluorinated phases provide enhanced selectivity for organofluorine compounds. The dual normal- and reverse-phase characteristics make fluorinated phases suitable for analysis of polar pharmaceutical and biological samples such as proteins, peptides, nucleotides, steroids, and alkaloids. Fluorinated phases for other applications including supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), micellar electrokinetic liquid chromatography (MEKC), ion chromatography (IC), open tubular electrochromatography (OTEC), and liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS) are also highlighted.     

Ionic liquid stationary phases for gas chromatography

This article provides a summary of the development of ionic liquids as stationary phases for gas chromatography beginning with early work on packed columns that established details of the retention mechanism and established working methods to characterize selectivity differences compared with molecular stationary phases through the modern development of multi-centered cation and cross-linked ionic liquids for high-temperature applications in capillary gas chromatography. Since there are many reviews on ionic liquids dealing with all aspects of their chemical and physical properties, the emphasis in this article is placed on the role of gas chromatography played in the design of ionic liquids of low melting point, high thermal stability, high viscosity, and variable selectivity for separations. Ionic liquids provide unprecedented opportunities for extending the selectivity range and temperature-operating range of columns for gas chromatography, an area of separation science that has otherwise been almost stagnant for over a decade.     

The effect of chain length of bonded organic phases in reversed phase high performance liquid chromatography

Summary Bonded hydrocarbon phases have been prepared by the reaction of organotrichlorosilanes with silica (Lichrosorb Si-100, 10 m, Merck) using conditions for maximum coverage. Alkyl phases, CH₃ (CH₂)_n-With n=7, 10, 12, 14, 17 and 20 and arylakyl phases, Ph (CH₂)_n—with n=0,2,4,6 were investigated. In reverse phase chromatography using water/methanol phases a linear relationship was between the capacity ratios k and the amount of coverage, independent of chain length. The selectivity, however, depends on the chain length of the bonded phase and molecular structure of the solute, whereas for halogenated benzene derivatives the selectivity is constant, and changing the mobile phase composition shows only a minor effect. The selectivity of 4,4-dibromodiphenyl in relation to the benzene derivatives is strongly influenced by the chain length and solvent composition. The utilization of chemically bonded organic long chain phases with maximum coverage makes it possible to reduce the water content in the water/methanol phase increasing the efficiency and loading capacity. The extent of maximum coverage was slightly dependent on the chain length and showed only a 10% decrease from n-octyl-to heneicosyl phase. Treatment of the bonded organic phase with TMCS was not effective with long chain materials, but further reaction occurred with bonded phenyl phase, which could be shown by IR-analysis.