Metal-induced supramolecualr chirality in an optically active polythiophene aggregate

Chiral polythiophenes (PTs), in sharp contrast to other optically active polymers, exhibit optical activity in the pi-pi* transition region which is derived from the chirality of the main chain when they self-assemble to form a supramolecular pi-stacked aggregate with intermolecular interactions in a poor solvent or in a film. We now report that the regioregular, optically active PT poly[(R)-3-[4-(4-ethyl-2-oxazolin-2-yl)phenyl]thiophene] (poly-1) exhibits unique split-type induced circular dichroism (ICD) in the pi-pi* transition region of the main chain upon complexation with various metal salts such as trifluoromethanesulfonates of copper(I), copper(II), silver(I), and zinc(II), and iron(II) perchlorate in chloroform, which is a good solvent for poly-1. The appearance of ICD and slight changes in the UV/Vis spectra (no color change), except for the zinc salts, indicated that the chirality may not be induced by chiral pi-stacked aggregates of poly-1, but by the chirality of the main chain, for example, a predominantly one-handed helical structure induced by intermolecular coordination of the oxazoline groups to metal ions. The sign of the Cotton effect depends on the metal salt; most metal salts induced ICDs with similar Cotton-effect patterns, while zinc salts caused an inversion of the signs of the Cotton effect of poly-1 accompanied by a gradual red shift in the absorption of up to 125 nm. The changes in the conformation and the size of the poly-1 aggregates induced by different metal salts were also investigated by (1)H NMR titrations, static light scattering (SLS), atomic force microscopy (AFM), and membrane filtration. On the basis of these results, we propose a possible model for the chiral supramolecular aggregates of poly-1 with metal salts.     

Studies on the interaction of achiral cationic pseudoisocyanine with chiral metal complexes

The effect of chiral metal complexes ([Co(en)(3)]I(3)·H(2)O, cis-[CoBr(NH(3))(en)(2)]Br(2), K[Co(edta)]·2H(2)O and [Ru(phen)(3)](PF(6))(2)) on the polymer-bound J-aggregates in aqueous mixtures of pesudoisocyanine (PIC) iodine and poly(acrylic acid, sodium)(PAAS) have been studied by UV-vis absorption, circular dichroism (CD) and fluorescence spectra. At low concentration, the PIC monomers could self-assemble to form supermolecules by binding to each of the COO(-) groups on the polymer chains through electrostatic interactions. After the addition of chiral metal complexes to the formed PIC-PAAS J-aggregates, we found that only the chiral multiple π-conjugated phenanthroline metal complexes could transfer their metal-centered chiral information to the formed J-aggregates. The chiral J-aggregates showed a characteristic induced circular dichroism (ICD) in the visible region of J-band chromophore, and the ICD signals depend on the absolute configuration, concentration of the chiral multiple π-conjugated metal complexes, as well as temperature. More interestingly, the supramolecular chirality of the polymer supported PIC J-aggregates could be memorized even after the addition of an excess opposite chiral complex enantiomers. This is in sharp contrast to the behavior in the high concentrated NaCl induced PIC-J aggregates, in which the optical rotation of a mixture of two enantiomers varies linearly with their ratio.     

Mechanism of helix induction on a stereoregular Poly((4-carboxyphenyl)acetylene) with chiral amines and memory of the macromolecular helicity assisted by interaction with achiral amines

Cis-transoidal poly((4-carboxyphenyl)acetylene) (poly-1) is an optically inactive polymer but forms an induced one-handed helical structure upon complexation with optically active amines such as (R)-(1-(1-naphthyl)ethyl)amine ((R)-2) in DMSO. The complexes show a characteristic induced circular dichroism (ICD) in the UV-visible region of the polymer backbone. Moreover, the macromolecular helicity of poly-1 induced by (R)-2 can be "memorized" even after complete replacement of (R)-2 by various achiral amines. We now report fully detailed studies on the mechanism of the helicity induction and memory of the helical chirality of poly-1 by means of UV-visible, CD, and infrared spectroscopies. We have found that a one-handed helix is cooperatively induced on poly-1 upon the ion pair formation of the carboxy groups of poly-1 with optically active amines and that the bulkiness of the chiral amines plays a crucial role for inducing an excess of a single-handed helix. On the other hand, the free ion formation was found to be essential for the macromolecular helicity memory of poly-1 after the replacement of the chiral amine by achiral amines, since the intramolecular electrostatic repulsion between the neighboring carboxylate ions of poly-1 significantly contributes to reduce the atropisomerization process of poly-1. On the basis of the mechanism of helicity induction and the memory of the helical chirality drawn from the present studies, we succeeded in creating an almost perfect memory of the induced macromolecular helicity of poly-1 with (R)-2 by using 2-aminoethanol as an achiral chaperoning molecule to assist in maintaining the memory of helical chirality.     

Supramolecular helical assembly of an achiral cyanine dye in an induced helical amphiphilic poly(phenylacetylene) interior in water

A water-soluble amphiphilic poly(phenylacetylene) bearing the bulky aza-18-crown-6-ether pendants forms a one-handed helix induced by l- or d-amino acids and chiral amino alcohols through specific host-guest interactions in water. We now report that such an induced helical poly(phenylacetylene) with a controlled helix sense can selectively trap an achiral benzoxazole cyanine dye among various structurally similar cyanine dyes within its hydrophobic helical cavity inside the polymer in acidic water, resulting in the formation of supramolecular helical aggregates, which exhibit an induced circular dichroism (ICD) in the cyanine dye chromophore region. The supramolecular chirality induced in the cyanine aggregates could be further memorized when the template helical polymer lost its optical activity and further inverted into the opposite helicity. Thereafter, thermal racemization of the helical aggregates slowly took place.     

Interchain-solvent-induced chirality change of 1D helical chains: from achiral to chiral crystallization

Three helical supramolecular stereoisomers of meso-2, Delta-2, and Delta-3 with the formula of cis-[Ni(f-rac-L)][Ni(CN)4] were successfully constructed based on the [Ni(f-rac-L)2+ and [Ni(CN)4]2- building blocks (L = 5,5,7,12,12,14-hexamethyl-1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane). In all three supramolecular stereoisomers, cis-[Ni(f-rac-L)]2+ cations are alternately bridged by [Ni(CN)4]2- anions through two cis (in meso-2 and Delta-2) or trans (in Delta-3) cyano groups to form one-dimensional (1D) helical chains of cis-[Ni(f-rac-L)][Ni(CN)4]. In meso-2, the right/left-handed chirality of the originally formed chain is transferred oppositely to adjacent chains through the interchain hydrogen-bonding interactions of hexameric water clusters, leading to the formation of meso-2 with a central symmetrical space group, P21/n, in which the 1D helical chains are packed in an alternating right- and left-handed chirality. In Delta-2 and Delta-3, the right/left-handed chirality of the original chain is transferred uniformly to adjacent chains through the zipper-like interchain hydrophobic interactions, resulting in the formation of Delta-2 and Delta-3 with chiral space groups of P212121 and P3121, respectively, in which all of the 1D helical chains are arranged in the same right/left-handed chirality.     

Chiral Amplification in Nature: Studying Cell‐Extracted Chiral Carotenoid Microcrystals via the Resonance Raman Optical Activity of Model Systems

Carotenoid microcrystals, extracted from cells of carrot roots and consisting of 95 % of achiral β‐carotene, exhibit a very intense chiroptical (ECD and ROA) signal. The preferential chirality of crystalline aggregates that consist mostly of achiral building blocks is a newly observed phenomenon in nature, and may be related to asymmetric information transfer from the chiral seeds (small amount of α‐carotene or lutein) present in carrot cells. To confirm this hypothesis, we synthesized several model aggregates from various achiral and chiral carotenoids. Because of the sergeant‐and‐soldier behavior, a small number of chiral sergeants (α‐carotene or astaxanthin) force the achiral soldier molecules (β‐ or 11,11′‐[D₂]‐β‐carotene) to jointly form supramolecular assemblies of induced chirality. The chiral amplification observed in these model systems confirmed that chiral microcrystals appearing in nature might consist predominantly of achiral building blocks and their supramolecular chirality might result from the co‐crystallization of chiral and achiral analogues.     

pH-Controlled Supramolecular Self-Assembly of Naphthalenediimide Appended l-Alanine and Ethylenediamine Asymmetric Bolaamphiphile

Design, synthesis and characterization of novel (2S)-2-[7-(2-aminoethyl)-1,3,6,8-tetraoxo-3,6,7,8-tetrahydrobenzo[lmn][3,8]phenanthrolin-2(1H)-yl]propanoic acid ( 1 ) bolaamphiphile, which combine naphthalene diimide (NDI) appended with l -alanine at one end of imide and ethylenediamine at the other end. An l -alanine bearing NDI-based asymmetric bolaamphiphile self-assembled at various pH ranging from 2 to 10 forms a variety of supramolecular nanostructures. The UV-Vis and emission spectroscopic techniques employed for the optical and photophysical properties study of bolaamphiphile 1 at various pH values. It was revealed that the change in pH alters both the optical and photophysical properties of bolaamphiphile 1 . Theoretical calculations used to investigate the electronic properties of the bolaamphiphile 1 . Dynamic light scattering experiments displayed formation of aggregates in solution and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was used to visualize the nanostructures formed on silicon wafers. Furthermore, the X-ray diffraction was used to determine the nanostructure's packing properties i. e. crystalline/amorphous. Experimental circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy results inferred and revealed the induction of chirality into the supramolecular systems, which was shown to be pH dependent. This study clearly demonstrates the manipulation of pH can control/tune chiral supramolecular structures and provide future methods for the development of chiral recognition and catalysis study.     

Main-chain optically active riboflavin polymer for asymmetric catalysis and its vapochromic behavior

A novel optically active polymer consisting of riboflavin units as the main chain (poly-1) was prepared from naturally occurring riboflavin (vitamin B(2)) in three steps. The riboflavin residues of poly-1 were converted to 5-ethylriboflavinium cations (giving poly-2), which could be reversibly transformed into the corresponding 4a-hydroxyriboflavins (giving poly-2OH) through hydroxylation/dehydroxylation reactions. This reversible structural change was accompanied by a visible color change along with significant changes in the absorption and circular dichroism (CD) spectra. The nuclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (NOESY) and CD spectra of poly-2 revealed a supramolecularly twisted helical structure with excess one-handedness through face-to-face stacking of the intermolecular riboflavinium units, as evidenced by the apparent NOE correlations between the interstrand riboflavin units and intense Cotton effects induced in the flavinium chromophore regions. The hydroxylation of poly-2 at the 4a-position proceeded in a diastereoselective fashion via chirality transfer from the induced supramolecular helical chirality assisted by the ribityl pendants, resulting in a 83:17 diastereomeric mixture of poly-2OH. The diastereoselectivity of poly-2 was remarkably higher than that of the corresponding monomeric model (64.5:35.5), indicating amplification of the chirality resulting from the supramolecular chirality induced in the stacked poly-2 backbones. The optically active poly-2 efficiently catalyzed the asymmetric organocatalytic oxidation of sulfides with hydrogen peroxide, yielding optically active sulfoxides with up to 60% enantiomeric excess (ee), whose enantioselectivity was higher than that catalyzed by the monomeric counterpart (30% ee). In addition, upon exposure to primary and secondary amines, poly-2 exhibited unique high-speed vapochromic behavior arising from the formation of 4a-amine adducts in the film.     

Construction of Chiroptical Switch on Silica Nanoparticle Surface via Chiral Self-assembly of Side-chain Azobenzene-containing Polymer

In this contribution, we utilized surface-initiated atom transfer radical polymerization(SI-ATRP) to prepare organic-inorganic hybrid core/shell silica nanoparticles(NPs), where silica particles acted as cores and polymeric shells(PAzo MA*) were attached to silica particles via covalent bond. Subsequently, chiroptical switch was successfully constructed on silica NPs surface taking advantage of supramolecular chiral selfassembly of the grafted side-chain Azo-containing polymer(PAzo MA*). We foun...     

Isolable chiral aggregates of achiral π-conjugated carboxylic acids

The induced aggregation of achiral building blocks by a chiral species to form chiral aggregates with memorized chirality has been observed for a number of systems. However, chiral memory in isolated aggregates of achiral building blocks remains rare. One possible reason for this discrepancy could be that not much is understood in terms of designing these chiral aggregates. Herein, we report a strategy for creating such isolable chiral aggregates from achiral building blocks that retain chiral memory after the facile physical removal of the chiral templates. This strategy was used for the isolation of chiral homoaggregates of neutral achiral π-conjugated carboxylic acids in pure aqueous solution. Under what we have termed an "interaction-substitution" mechanism, we generated chiral homoaggregates of a variety of π-conjugated carboxylic acids by using carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) as a mediator in acidic aqueous solutions. These aggregates were subsequently isolated from the CMC templates whilst retaining their memorized supramolecular chirality. Circular dichroism (CD) spectra of the aggregates formed in the acidic CMC solution exhibited bisignated exciton-coupled signals of various signs and intensities that were maintained in the isolated pure homoaggregates of the achiral π-conjugated carboxylic acids. The memory of the supramolecular chirality in the isolated aggregates was ascribed to the substitution of COOH/COOH hydrogen-bonding interaction between the carboxylic acid groups within the aggregates for the hydrogen-bonding interactions between the COOH groups of the building blocks and the chiral templates. We expect that this "interaction-substitution" procedure will open up a new route to isolable pure chiral aggregates from achiral species.     

Isolable Chiral Aggregates of Achiral π‐Conjugated Carboxylic Acids

The induced aggregation of achiral building blocks by a chiral species to form chiral aggregates with memorized chirality has been observed for a number of systems. However, chiral memory in isolated aggregates of achiral building blocks remains rare. One possible reason for this discrepancy could be that not much is understood in terms of designing these chiral aggregates. Herein, we report a strategy for creating such isolable chiral aggregates from achiral building blocks that retain chiral memory after the facile physical removal of the chiral templates. This strategy was used for the isolation of chiral homoaggregates of neutral achiral π‐conjugated carboxylic acids in pure aqueous solution. Under what we have termed an “interaction–substitution” mechanism, we generated chiral homoaggregates of a variety of π‐conjugated carboxylic acids by using carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) as a mediator in acidic aqueous solutions. These aggregates were subsequently isolated from the CMC templates whilst retaining their memorized supramolecular chirality. Circular dichroism (CD) spectra of the aggregates formed in the acidic CMC solution exhibited bisignated exciton‐coupled signals of various signs and intensities that were maintained in the isolated pure homoaggregates of the achiral π‐conjugated carboxylic acids. The memory of the supramolecular chirality in the isolated aggregates was ascribed to the substitution of COOH/COOH hydrogen‐bonding interaction between the carboxylic acid groups within the aggregates for the hydrogen‐bonding interactions between the COOH groups of the building blocks and the chiral templates. We expect that this “interaction–substitution” procedure will open up a new route to isolable pure chiral aggregates from achiral species.     

Helical chirality of π‐conjugated main‐chain induced by polymerization of phenylacetylene with chiral bulky pinanyl groups: Effects of the flexible spacer and polymerization catalyst

Three optically active phenylacetylene polymers with chiral bulky pinanyl groups, (?)‐poly[4‐(dimethylpinanylsilyl)phenylacetylene] [(?)‐poly(PSPA)], (+)‐poly{4‐[3‐(10‐pinanyl)tetramethyldisiloxy]phenylacethylene} [(+)‐poly(PDSPA)], and their copolymer [(?)‐copoly(PSPA/PDSPA)], were synthesized. We observed high chirality in the main‐chain chromophore of (?)‐poly(PSPA), due to the presence of a chiral helix, with circular dichroism spectroscopy. In contrast, (+)‐poly(PDSPA),with flexible SiOSi spacers between the chiral pinanyl group and the main chain, had lower chirality. (?)‐Poly(PSPA), with large circular dichroism signals, was prepared by polymerization with a rhodium catalyst and had a highly stereoregular main chain (high cis‐configuration percentage). However, (?)‐poly(PSPA) prepared with a tungsten catalyst had lower chirality and lower stereoregularity in the main chain. A membrane from (?)‐poly(PSPA) showed enantioselective permeability for tryptophan in an aqueous solution. © 2002 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 40: 1689–1697, 2002     

Reversing the Handedness of Self‐Assembled Porous Molecular Networks through the Number of Identical Chiral Centres

Scanning tunnelling microscope observations at the 1‐phenyloctane/graphite interface reveal how chiral structural information at the molecular level is transferred and expressed structurally at the 2D supramolecular level for a porous system. The chirality of self‐assembled molecular networks formed by chiral dehydrobenzo[12]annulene (cDBA) derivatives having three chiral chains and three achiral chains, alternatingly, is compared with those of cDBAs having six chiral chains reported previously. While for all cDBAs homochiral surfaces are formed, their handedness is not simply a reflection of the absolute configuration of the stereogenic centres. Both the number of stereogenic centres as well as the length of the achiral chains determine the supramolecular handedness, providing a deep insight into the supramolecular chirality induction mechanisms at play. Moreover, these cDBAs act to induce chirality in porous networks formed by achiral DBAs.     

Alignment and Dynamic Inversion of Planar Chirality in Pillar[n]arenes

Pillar[n]arenes are symmetrical macrocyclic compounds composed of benzene panels with para-methylene linkages. Each panel usually exhibits planar chirality and prefers chirality-aligned states. Because of this feature, pillar[n]arenes are attractive scaffolds for chiroptical materials that are easy to prepare and optically resolve and show intense circular dichroism (CD) signals. In addition, rotation of the panels endows the chirality of pillar[n]arenes with a dynamic nature. The chirality in tubular oligomers and supramolecular assemblies sometimes show time- and procedure-dependent alignment phenomena. Furthermore, the CD signals of some pillar[n]arenes respond to the addition of chiral guests when their dynamic chirality is coupled with host–guest properties. By using diastereomeric pillar[n]arenes with additional chiral structures, the response can also be caused by achiral guests and changes of the environment, providing molecular sensors.     

Noncovalent Chirality Sensing Ensembles for the Detection and Reaction Monitoring of Amino Acids,Peptides, Proteins,and Aromatic Drugs

Ternary complexes between the macrocyclic host cucurbit[8]uril, dicationic dyes, and chiral aromatic analytes afford strong induced circular dichroism (ICD) signals in the near‐UV and visible regions. This allows for chirality sensing and peptide‐sequence recognition in water at low micromolar analyte concentrations. The reversible and noncovalent mode of binding ensures an immediate response to concentration changes, which allows the real‐time monitoring of chemical reactions. The introduced supramolecular method is likely to find applications in bioanalytical chemistry, especially enzyme assays, for drug‐related analytical applications, and for continuous monitoring of enantioselective reactions, particularly asymmetric catalysis.     

Chiral Supramolecular Multiblock Copolymerization Accompanying Chirality Transfer in Heterostructures via Living Chain Growth

We report the unique synthesis of chiral supramolecular tri- and penta-BCPs with controllable chirality using kinetically adjusted seeded supramolecular copolymerization in THF and DMSO (99 : 1, v/v). Tetraphenylethylene (d - and l -TPE) derivatives bearing d - and l -alanine side chains formed thermodynamically favored chiral products via a kinetically trapped in monomeric state with a long lag phase. In contrast, achiral TPE-G containing glycine moieties did not form a supramolecular polymer owing to the energy barrier in its kinetically trapped state. We show that the copolymerization of the metastable states of TPE-G not only enables the generation of supramolecular BCPs by the seeded living growth method, but also transfers chirality at the seed ends. This research demonstrates the generation of chiral supramolecular tri- and penta-BCPs with B-A-B, A-B-A-B-A, and C-B-A-B-C block patterns accompanying chirality transfer via seeded living polymerization.     

Lamellar‐Twisting‐Induced Circular Dichroism of Chromophore Moieties in Banded Spherulites with Evolution of Homochirality

Banded spherulites are formed by crystallization of a chiral polymer that is end‐capped with chromophore. Induced circular dichroism (ICD) of the chromophore can be found in the crystallized chiral polymers, giving exclusive optical response of the ICD. The ICD signals are presumed to be driven by the lamellar twisting in the crystalline spherulites, and the exclusive optical activity is attributed to the chirality transfer from molecular level to macroscopic level. To verify the suggested mechanism, the sense of the lamellar twisting in the crystalline spherulite is determined using PLM for the comparison with the ICD signals of the chromophore in the electron circular dichroism spectrum. The conformational chirality of the chiral polymer is determined by the vibrational circular dichroism spectrum. On the basis of the chiroptical results, evolution of homochirality from helical polymer chains (conformational chirality) to lamellar twisting in the banded spherulite (hierachical chirality) is suggested.     

Helical rosette nanotubes with tunable chiroptical properties

On the basis of transmission electron microscopy (TEM), dynamic light scattering (DLS), small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), and circular dichroism (CD) studies, compound 1 was shown to exist mainly in two states: (a) At high concentration (> or =1 mM, in methanol), 1 undergoes hierarchical self-assembly to generate rosette nanotubes with approximately 4 nm diameter and a concentration-dependent hydrodynamic radius in the range 10-100 nm. Under these conditions, addition of a chiral amino acid promoter (L-Ala), that binds to the crown ether moiety of 1 via electrostatic interactions, promotes a rapid transition (k(0) approximately equal 0.48 s(-1), for [1] = 0.046 mM, [L-Ala] = 2.8 mM) from racemic to chiral rosette nanotubes with predefined helicities as indicated by the resulting induced circular dichroism (ICD). (b) At low concentration (< or =0.04 mM, in methanol), 1 exists mainly in a nonassembled state as shown by TEM and DLS. Addition of L-Ala in this case triggers a relatively slow (k(0) approximately equal 0.07 s(-1) for [1] = 0.04 mM, [L-Ala] = 2.4 mM) sequence of supramolecular reactions leading to the hierarchical self-assembly of rosette nanotubes with predefined helicities. Under both conditions a and b, the kinetic data unveiled the intrinsic ability of the rosette nanotubes to promote their own formation (autocatalysis). The degree of chiral induction was found to depend dramatically upon the chemical structure of the promoter. This process appears also to follow an all-or-none response, as the vast majority of the crown ether sites must be occupied with a promoter for a complete transition to chiral nanotubes to take place. Finally, both supramolecular pathways a and b offer an efficient approach for the preparation of helical rosette nanotubes with tunable chiroptical properties and may also be viewed as a process by which a predefined set of physical and chemical properties that characterizes a molecular promoter is expressed at the macromolecular level.     

Solvent-induced switching of the macromolecular helicity of poly[(4-carboxyphenyl)acetylene] induced by a single chiral amino alcohol

Cis–transoidal poly[(4-carboxyphenyl)acetylene] (poly- 1 ) complexed with optically active amines and amino alcohols showed an induced circular dichroism (ICD) in the ultraviolet–visible region because of a predominantly one-handed helix formation in water and in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). The Cotton effect signs of the poly- 1 /chiral amino alcohol complexes were inverted in the presence of water, whereas the ICD pattern of the poly- 1 /chiral amine complexes showed no change, regardless of the water content. These results demonstrated that the helix sense of poly- 1 induced by optically active amino alcohols through noncovalent acid–base interactions could be switched by changes in the solvent ratio in the DMSO–water mixtures. © 2003 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Polym Sci Part A: Polym Chem 41: 3625–3631, 2003     

Optically active supramolecular complexes of water-soluble achiral polythiophenes and folic acid: spectroscopic studies and sensing applications

Optically active supramolecular complexes of water-soluble achiral polythiophene (PT) derivatives, PMTPA or PMTEA (Chart 1), and folic acid have been prepared; and the complex formation processes have been studied by absorption, emission, and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopies. The complexes exhibited unique split-type induced CDs in the pi-pi* transition region of PTs, indicating that the molecular chirality of the glutamic acid moiety in folic acid was expressed in PT backbones. The influences of temperature, solvent composition, and the structures of the inducing molecules on the chirality induction to PTs were also investigated, and a possible mechanism for the formation of chiral superstructures was proposed. Furthermore, it was found that, upon addition of folic acid into aqueous solution of PTs (PMTPA or PMTEA), a dramatic color change from yellow to purple along with the emission quenching of PT derivatives was observed. PMTEA, having one fewer carbon in the hydrophobic side chain relative to PMTPA, showed better selectivity toward folic acid sensing over ATP because of its higher solubility in water and the appropriate hydrophilic/hydrophobic balance in the complex. Therefore, it can be applied as a colorimetric and fluorescent probe for detecting folic acid with high selectivity and sensitivity. Besides naked-eye detection of folic acid, the detection limit can be extended to be 10 (-8) M by using fluorometry and PMTEA as the probing molecule.