Improving off-line accelerated tryptic digestion. Towards fast-lane proteolysis of complex biological samples

Off-line digestion of proteins using immobilized trypsin beads is studied with respect to the format of the digestion reactor, the digestion conditions, the comparison with in-solution digestion and its use in complex biological samples. The use of the filter vial as the most appropriate digestion reactor enables simple, efficient and easy-to-handle off-line digestion of the proteins on trypsin beads. It was shown that complex proteins like bovine serum albumin (BSA) need much longer time (89 min) and elevated temperature (37 degrees C) to be digested to an acceptable level compared to smaller proteins like cytochrome c (5 min, room temperature). Comparing the BSA digestion using immobilized trypsin beads with conventional in-solution digestion (overnight at 37 degrees C), it was shown that comparable results were obtained with respect to sequence coverage (>90%) and amount of missed cleavages (in both cases around 20 peptides with 1 or 2 missed cleavages were detected). However, the digestion using immobilized trypsin beads was considerable less time consuming. Good reproducibility and signal intensities were obtained for the digestion products of BSA in a complex urine sample. In addition to this, peptide products of proteins typically present in urine were identified.     

原子转移自由基聚合修饰银丝固定化酶反应器的制备及在蛋白质组鉴定中的应用

针对传统溶液酶解存在的酶解时间较长、酶自切物干扰以及蛋白酶不能重复使用等缺陷,通过电子转移生成催化剂的原子转移自由基聚合法修饰银丝,并以其为载体制备了一种新型的固定化酶反应器。用质谱考察了银丝固定化酶反应器(SW-Trypsin)的酶解效率、重复性和回收率。结果表明:绒毛状聚合物修饰的SW-Trypsin的酶解效率较高,酶解标准蛋白牛血清白蛋白(BSA)20 min后,肽段的氨基酸序列覆盖率可达93%,高于传统溶液酶解方法酶解16 h所得79%的覆盖率。使用该固定化酶反应器于一个月内8次酶解BSA所得的氨基酸序列覆盖率在89%到97%之间,平均覆盖率为94%,显示出良好的稳定性。另外,该固定化酶反应器酶解马心肌红蛋白(MYO)的回收率为87.67%。最后,用SW-Trypsin酶解腾冲嗜热菌全蛋白20 min,所鉴定到的氨基酸序列覆盖率和蛋白数量与同样条件下溶液酶解16 h的结果接近,且零漏切位点肽段的比例更高。加之容易分离的优点,SW-Trypsin在蛋白质组学的应用中具有良好的前景。     

On-column digestion of proteins in aqueous-organic solvents

Proteolytic digestion is an important step in protein identification by peptide mass mapping and tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS)-based peptide sequencing. Traditional methods of protein digestion require extended incubation times and have difficulty with proteolytically resistant proteins. Here, we describe a method in which a protein solution was combined with a mixed aqueous-organic solution (methanol, isopropanol, or acetonitrile) and passed through a microcolumn containing immobilized trypsin. Myoglobin sequence coverage was high (>85%) in all three solvents, and differences in spectra were seen among the different solution conditions. Notably, methanol-based digestions produced fewer missed cleavages while acetonitrile-based digestions produced the most peptides and the most intense mass spectra. Flow rates through the column were varied from 0.5 to 15 micro L/min, corresponding to column residence times of 78 and 2.6 s, respectively. All flow rates produced high sequence coverage of myoglobin, although, at higher flow rates, more missed cleavages were observed. No significant increase in undigested myoglobin was observed with flow rates up to 15 micro L/min. The described method was applied to the digestion of human transferrin (hTf), a proteolytically resistant protein. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometric (MALDI-TOFMS) analysis detected 42 peptides covering 46% of the hTf sequence. The traditional aqueous method resulted in 12 peptides (8% sequence coverage) only when high concentrations of trypsin were used. Lastly, digestion of low nanomolar myoglobin was shown to produce detectable peptides and resulted in a correct database hit. Thus, we demonstrate a method that is capable of rapid on-line digestion, thereby lending itself to high-throughput identification of proteins.     

A novel method for identification and relative quantification of N-terminal peptides using metal-element-chelated tags coupled with mass spectrometry

By means of the reaction between a DOTA-NHS-ester bifunctional reagent and N-terminal peptides of proteins,and then chelation of lanthanide metal ions as tags,we established a novel method for the identification of N-terminal peptides of proteins and their relative quantification using metal-element-chelated tags coupled with mass spectrometry.The experimental results indicate that metal elements are able to completely label N-terminal peptides at the protein level.The N-terminal peptides are enriched as the peptides digested with trypsin are selectively eliminated by isothiocyanate-coupled silica beads.We successfully identified the N-terminal peptides of 158 proteins of Thermoanaerobacter tengcongensis incubated at 55 and 75°C,among which N-terminal peptides of 24 proteins are partially acetylated.Moreover,metal-element tags with high molecule weights make it convenient for N-terminal peptides consisting of less than 6 amino acids to be identified;these make up 55percent of the identified proteins.Finally,we developed a general approach for the relative quantification of proteins based on N-terminal peptides.We adopted lysozyme and ribonuclease B as model proteins;the correlation coefficients(R2)of the standard curves for the quantitative method were 0.9994 and 0.9997,respectively,with each concentration ratio ranging from0.1 to 10 and both relative standard derivations(RSD)measured at less than 5%.In T.tengcongensis at two incubation temperatures,80 proteins possess quantitative information.In addition,compared with the proteins of T.tengcongensis incubated at 55°C,in T.tengcongensis incubated at 75°C,7 proteins upregulate whereas 16 proteins downregulate,and most differential proteins are related to protein synthesis.     

Peptide map procedure using immobilized protease cartridges in tandem for disulfide linkage identification of neu differentiation factor epidermal growth factor domain

Immobilized proteolytic enzyme cartridges were used to rapidly digest neu differentiation factor EGF domain in order to obtain improved peptide maps useful for assignment of disulfide linkages. The procedure described here involves an on-line digestion of proteins using immobilized trypsin and endoproteinase Glu-C cartridges connected in series, followed by on-line RP-HPLC separation of the peptides. The entire process can be automated using a commercially available workstation; and the total time required for both proteolytic digestion and the HPLC separation can be shortened to within 1 h. Using these immobilized columns, we demonstrated that disulfide structure assignment of the EGF domains of recombinant human neu differentiation factor can be performed by isolation of individual disulfide-containing peptides followed by assignment of disulfide linkages with prompt fragmentation of peptides using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. The use of immobilized protease cartridges in tandem eliminates undesirable digestion artifacts associated with longer digestion time and higher protease-to-substrate ratio and results in the development of a reproducible and high quality peptide map.     

Immobilization of enzyme on detonation nanodiamond for highly efficient proteolysis

Immobilization of enzyme on detonation nanodiamond (dND, 3-10 nm) and its application for efficient proteolysis have been demonstrated. By evaluation of the Michaelis constant (K_m) and maximum velocity (V_max) of immobilized enzyme, its activity was not impaired significantly by immobilization. And enzyme immobilized on dNDs exhibited much better thermal and chemical stabilities than its free counterpart and maintained high activity even after 10 times reuse. The efficient proteolysis by trypsin immobilized on dNDs (dND-trypsin) is demonstrated with the digestion of myoglobin (or other model protein) in a short time (5 min). Large numbers of identified peptides obtained by dNDs-trypsin enable a higher degree of sequence coverage and more positive identification of proteins than those obtained by in-solution digestion and the commercial immobilized trypsin beads, respectively. Moreover, immobilization of peptide-N-glycosidase F (PNGase F) on dNDs was realized and resulted in faster sequential glycosidase digestion of glycopeptides in less than 10 min.     

Proteolytic enzyme-immobilization techniques for MS-based protein analysis

Protein digestion utilizing proteases (e.g., trypsin, Lys C and other proteolytic enzymes) is one of the key sample-preparation steps in contemporary proteomics, followed by liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (MS). Tryptic digestion is traditionally performed in aqueous solutions, usually applying the enzyme and the sample in a 50:1 protein-to-protease ratio. Long digestion times (up to 24 h), auto-digestion sub-products and poor enzyme-to-substrate ratio are common issues with liquid-phase protein-digestion processes. The use of enzymes immobilized onto solid supports can minimize these problems by increasing enzyme-to-substrate ratios, significantly speeding up digestion times and reducing autolysis. The other main goal of protease immobilization is to obtain rugged, efficient enzyme reactors.In this article, we review the most important proteolytic enzyme-immobilization techniques with the main emphasis on fabrication of trypsin microreactors and nanoreactors and their utilization in bottom-up proteomics. We also discuss data reportedly obtained using the various immobilization protocols with respect to enzyme activity and MS-sequence coverage.     

新型亲水聚合物修饰硅胶颗粒固定化酶的制备及在蛋白质组鉴定中的应用

采用原子转移自由基聚合法制备了亲水聚合物修饰的硅胶颗粒作为一种新型固定化酶载体,在实现胰蛋白酶高密度固定的同时,显著降低了载体材料非特异性吸附导致的样品损失。因此,该固定化酶材料兼具高酶解效率和高回收率的特性。以标准蛋白质牛血清白蛋白(BSA)为样本,使用该固定化酶1 min即可完成酶解,鉴定到肽段对BSA的氨基酸序列覆盖率可达90%以上。该固定化酶材料成功应用于酵母菌全蛋白质复杂样本的酶解,从3 min酶解产物中鉴定到666个蛋白质,超过同样条件下溶液酶解12 h的鉴定结果。     

赖氨酸C端内切酶/胰蛋白酶顺序酶切在蛋白质组学样本制备中的评估

采用胰蛋白酶(Trypsin)单独酶切与不同酶量的赖氨酸C端内切酶(Lys-C/trypsin)顺序酶切两种方法,对293T细胞全蛋白样本进行酶解消化,系统评估Lys-C/trypsin顺序酶切与Trypsin单一酶切在蛋白质组学样本制备中的差别.实验结果表明,Lys-C/trypsin顺序酶切不仅能显著提高肽段和蛋白质的鉴定数目,同时降低遗漏K酶切位点的数目及比例,而且得到的肽段长度有利于质谱鉴定,蛋白质覆盖率明显提升.通过对酶的用量进行优化对比,最终确定了Lys-C/trypsin顺序酶切时酶的合理用量.本研究结果对提高蛋白质组学样本的制备质量以及蛋白质的序列鉴定覆盖度具有指导意义.     

Assessment of microwave-assisted enzymatic digestion by measuring glycated hemoglobin A1c by mass spectrometry

Enzymatic digestion of proteins and analysis of the resulting peptides by mass spectrometry is an established approach in proteomics and in clinical and environmental chemistry. The long digestion times of several hours prevent the fast turnover of samples and results. Qualitative applications showed that microwave radiation profoundly shortens enzymatic digestion. However, its usefulness for quantitative applications had not been assessed. In this study, the microwave-assisted enzymatic digestion of hemoglobin at different temperatures, buffer concentrations, and digestion times was assessed and compared with conventional digestion for the proteolytic enzymes trypsin and Glu-C. A microwave-assisted enzymatic digestion method optimized for digestion time and temperature was applied for the analysis of glycated hemoglobin HbA1c and compared with a reference method. Using trypsin, complete digestion was obtained at 50 degrees C within 20 min. Under these conditions, the digestion efficiency was 20% higher than with conventional trypsin digestion. These effects were not observed with Glu-C as enzyme, probably because of the decreased stability of Glu-C at elevated temperatures in comparison with the trypsin used. The comparison of the optimized microwave-assisted digestion method using trypsin with the reference method for HbA1c using Glu-C gave a close correlation in the results (R2: 0.996). A significant bias of 0.33% HbA1c was observed, with higher values obtained with the microwave-assisted tryptic digest; this finding might have resulted from the use of a different enzyme. This study showed that microwave-assisted enzymatic digestion can substantially reduce digestion times to minutes and can be used in qualitative as well as quantitative applications.     

Immobilization of trypsin on graphene oxide for microwave-assisted on-plate proteolysis combined with MALDI-MS analysis

With an ultra-high surface area and abundant functional groups, graphene oxide (GO) provides an ideal substrate for the immobilization of trypsin. We demonstrated that trypsin could be immobilized on GO sheets assisted by polymers as molecular spacers to maintain the activity of the enzyme. And with the trypsin-linked GO as the enzyme immobilization probe, a novel microwave-assisted on-plate digestion method has been developed with subsequent analysis by MALDI-MS. The feasibility and performance of the digestion approach were demonstrated by the proteolysis of standard proteins. The results show that this novel approach substantially accelerated proteolysis and reduced the time required for traditional procedures involving on-plate enzymatic digestion and sample preparation prior to MALDI-MS analysis. The novel digestion approach is simple and efficient, offering great promise for high throughput protein identification.     

Increasing phosphoproteomic coverage through sequential digestion by complementary proteases

Protein phosphorylation is a reversible post-translational modification known to regulate protein function, subcellular localization, complex formation, and protein degradation. Detailed phosphoproteomic information is critical to kinomic studies of signal transduction and for elucidation of cancer biomarkers, such as in non-small-cell lung adenocarcinoma, where phosphorylation is commonly dysregulated. However, the collection and analysis of phosphorylation data remains a difficult problem. The low concentrations of phosphopeptides in complex biological mixtures as well as challenges inherent in their chemical nature have limited phosphoproteomic characterization and some phosphorylation sites are inaccessible by traditional workflows. We developed a sequential digestion method using complementary proteases, Glu-C and trypsin, to increase phosphoproteomic coverage and supplement traditional approaches. The sequential digestion method is more productive than workflows utilizing only Glu-C and we evaluated the orthogonality of the sequential digestion method relative to replicate trypsin-based analyses. Finally, we demonstrate the ability of the sequential digestion method to access new regions of the phosphoproteome by comparison to existing public phosphoproteomic databases. Our approach increases coverage of the human lung cancer phosphoproteome by accessing both new phosphoproteins and novel phosphorylation site information.     

依赖色谱保留时间的智能化选择反应监测质谱方法的建立及其初步应用

建立了依赖色谱保留时间的智能化选择反应监测质谱方法,并与非依赖色谱保留时间的智能化选择反应监测质谱分析方法对不同体系(牛血清白蛋白酶切物、6种标准蛋白质混合物酶切物、腾冲嗜热菌蛋白提取液酶切物)的分析结果进行了系统比较。结果表明,引入色谱保留时间后的智能化选择反应监测质谱方法能够显著提高肽段及蛋白质的鉴定量,并且在复杂体系（如腾冲嗜热菌蛋白提取液酶切物）中效果尤为明显,鉴定到的肽段及蛋白质的覆盖率可分别达到目标肽段和蛋白质数量的89.62%和92.41%,并且灵敏度高、重复性好,能够实现对质荷比相同但保留时间有差异的肽段的准确鉴定。该方法将在复杂生物样本目标蛋白质组高通量、高灵敏度的鉴定、验证和确认中发挥独特作用。     

Improved in-gel approaches to generate peptide maps of integral membrane proteins with matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry

This paper reports studies of in-gel digestion procedures to generate MALDI-MS peptide maps of integral membrane proteins. The methods were developed for the membrane domain of the mannitol permease of E. coli. In-gel digestion of this domain with trypsin, followed by extraction of the peptides from the gel, yields only 44% sequence coverage. Since lysines and arginines are seldomly found in the membrane-spanning regions, complete tryptic cleavage will generate large hydrophobic fragments, many of which are poorly soluble and most likely contribute to the low sequence coverage. Addition of the detergent octyl-beta-glucopyranoside (OBG), at 0.1% concentration, to the extraction solvent increases the total number of peptides detected to at least 85% of the total protein sequence. OBG facilitates the recovery of hydrophobic peptides when they are SpeedVac dried during the extraction procedure. Many of the newly recovered peptides are partial cleavage products. This seems to be advantageous since it generates hydrophobic fragments with a hydrophilic solubilizing part. In-gel CNBr cleavage resulted in 5-10-fold more intense spectra, 83% sequence coverage, fully cleaved fragments and no effect of OBG. In contrast to tryptic cleavage sites, the CNBr cleavage sites are found in transmembrane segments; cleavage at these sites generates smaller hydrophobic fragments, which are more soluble and do not need OBG. With the results of both cleavages, a complete sequence coverage of the membrane domain of the mannitol permease of E. coli is obtained without the necessity of using HPLC separation. The protocols were applied to two other integral membrane proteins, which confirmed the general applicability of CNBr cleavage and the observed effects of OBG in peptide recovery after tryptic digestion.     

Implications of partial tryptic digestion in organic-aqueous solvent systems for bottom-up proteome analysis

For bottom-up MS, the digestion step is critical and is typically performed with trypsin. Solvent-assisted digestion in 80% acetonitrile has previously been shown to improve protein sequence coverage at shorter digestion times. This has been attributed to enhanced enzyme digestion efficiency in this solvent. However, our results demonstrate that tryptic digestion in 80% acetonitrile is less efficient than that of conventional (aqueous) digestion. This is a consequence of decreased enzyme activity beyond ∼40% acetonitrile, increased enzyme autolysis and lower protein solubility in 80% acetonitrile. We observe multiple missed cleavages and reduced concentration of fully cleaved digestion products. Nonetheless we confirm, through room temperature solvent-assisted digestion, a consistent improvement in protein sequence coverage when analyzed by mass spectrometry. These results are explained through the increased number of unique digestion products available for detection. Thus, while solvent-assisted digestion has clear merits for proteome analysis, one should be aware of the inefficiency of protein digestion though this protocol, particularly with absolute protein quantitation experiments.     

Characterization of femtomole levels of proteins in solution using rapid proteolysis and nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry

A method for the rapid proteolytic digestion of low picomole to low femtomole amounts of proteins in solution using a capillary immobilized protease column is presented. Dilute protein samples are passed through a “μ-digestion” column packed with Poroszyme^? immobilized trypsin for generation of proteolytic fragments in less than 10 min. After digestion, nanoelectrospray ionization mass spectrometry (NanoES) is used to generate a peptide map, and peptides of interest are subjected to MS/MS from the same sample. By digesting only 100 fmol of the protein src kinase and 30 fmol of the protein lck kinase with a tryptic μ-digestion column, we obtained sufficient data from NanoES-MS and MS/MS to unambiguously identify both proteins using database searching. This approach was also used to locate a phosphorylation site on lck kinase starting with only 300 fmol of protein. The method was successfully used to identify an E. coli cold shock protein in a fraction collected from a two-dimensional HPLC separation of an E. coli cell lysate. The μ-digestion column was found to be less susceptible to adsorptive losses than solution digests, thus allowing for digestion and enhanced recovery of peptides from even low fmol amounts of protein in solution.     

Studying the effect of microwave heating on the digestion process and identification of proteins

The impact of microwave irradiation on the in‐solution digestion processes and the detection limit of proteins are systematically studied. Kinetic processes of many peptides produced through the trypsin digestion of various proteins under microwave heating at 50°C were investigated with MALDI‐MS. This study also examines the detection limits and digestion completeness of individual proteins under microwave heating at 50°C and at different time intervals (1, 5 and 30 min) using LC‐MS. We conclude that if the peptides without missed cleavage dictate the detection limit, conventional digestion will lead to a better detection limit. The detection limit may not differ between the microwave and conventional heating if the peptides with missed cleavage sites and strong intensity are formed at the very early stage (i.e., less than 1 min) and are not further digested throughout the entire digestion process. The digestion of Escherichia coli lysate was compared under conventional and short time (microwave) conditions. The number of proteins identified under conventional heating exceeded that obtained from microwave heating over heating periods less than 5 min. The overall results show that the microwave‐assisted digestion is not complete. Although the sequence coverage might be better, the detection limit might be worse than that under conventional heating.     

Use of different proteases working in acidic conditions to improve sequence coverage and resolution in hydrogen/deuterium exchange of large proteins

The combination of hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry has been widely used in structural biology, providing views on protein structure and protein dynamics. One of the constraints is to use proteases working at low pH and low temperature to limit back-exchange during proteolysis. Although pepsin works in these conditions and is currently used in such experiments, sequence coverage is not always complete especially for large proteins, and the spatial resolution of the exchange rate is limited by the size of the resulting peptides. In this study we tried two other proteases, protease type XIII from Aspergillus saitoi and protease type XVIII from Rhizhopus species. The penicillin-binding protein X (PBP-2X*), a 77-kDa protein, was selected as a model. Like pepsin, neither of these proteases is really specific, but we found very good reproducibility in the digestion pattern. Compared with using pepsin alone, combining the results of the three independent proteolyses increased the coverage for the peptide mapping, thus avoiding missing some potentially interesting regions of the protein. Furthermore, we obtained a better spatial resolution for deuterium incorporation data, specifying accurately the deuterated regions.     

固定化胰蛋白酶整体小柱的制备及其用于微量蛋白质的快速酶解

发展了一种光引发聚合法制备固定化胰蛋白酶整体小柱的方法,以用于微量蛋白质的快速酶解。整体小柱由功能单体4-戊烯酸琥珀酰亚胺酯、甲基丙烯酸羟乙酯,交联剂季戊四醇三丙烯酸酯和三元致孔剂二甲基亚砜、N,N-二甲基甲酰胺、十二醇在20 μL的移液器吸头尖端原位聚合而成。形成整体柱后,胰蛋白酶分子通过氨基与琥珀酰亚胺酯反应实现固定化。系统研究了聚合溶液中活性酯含量与柱床体积对胰蛋白酶固载量的影响,评价了固定化酶整体小柱对标准蛋白细胞色素C和牛血清白蛋白的酶解效率,以及整体小柱的稳定性和重复性。结果表明,在离心辅助下,酶解过程可在10 min内完成,批次间具有良好的重复性。最后将固定化酶整体小柱应用于1×10⁵个人急性早幼粒白血病（NB4）细胞与人急性T细胞白血病（Jurkat T）细胞的快速酶解,经纳升级液相色谱与高分辨质谱联用分析后鉴定得到2489个和2572个蛋白质。相比于溶液状态下的酶解,分别提高了2.2%和6.1%的蛋白鉴定数量,展现了其在蛋白组学研究中的应用潜力。     

免疫亲和质谱法研究β2-微球蛋白抗原表位

采用免疫亲和分离与质谱分析相结合的方法, 对β2-微球蛋白抗原表位进行了系统研究. 完整的抗原分子和已固定在载体(CNBr-activated Sepharose beads)上的单克隆抗体发生免疫亲和反应后, 用Endoproteinase Glu-C, Trypsin, Aminopeptidase M和carboxypeptidase Y四种不同的蛋白酶依次酶解抗原分子, 并采用基质辅助激光解析电离飞行时间质谱(MALDI-TOF-MS)技术对与抗体连接受保护而未发生水解的肽段进行了研究. 结果表明: β2-微球蛋白抗原表位位于整个蛋白分子氨基酸序列的61～67位, 即为SFYLLYY. 通过合成肽段的分析, 证明了SFYLLYY即为抗原表位, 与亲和质谱方法分析结果一致.