Review: Current Development of Immunoassay for Analyzing Veterinary Drug Residue in Foods and Food Products

Veterinary drug residues in foods and food products have been reported to be harmful for consumer health and must not be permitted in food intended for human consumption. These drugs include antibiotics, anthelmintics, beta-receptor agonists, and steroids. Immunoassay is recognized as the most powerful screening technique for a large number of different compounds. Because of the rapidity, sensitivity, and cost-effectiveness of this method, numerous immunoassays have already been developed for screening purposes to reduce sample loading for conventional analysis. In this review, the principles and an overview of advanced immunoassays for various veterinary drugs will be given.     

Analytical methodologies for identifying a polypeptide antibiotic

This article discusses the development of various analytical methods for identification and quantification of residues of antibiotics in meeting international regulatory requirements, and, as an example, overviews the screening, purification, fractionation and analytical assays of bacitracin, a commonly applied polypeptide antibiotic mixture. Attention is focused on the development of chemical methods, as they provide extraordinary performance, in terms of sensitivity and selectivity, for measuring residual levels of the various components of bacitracin in food and other matrices; the non-compound specific biological assay is discussed only briefly. Because of its advantages, state-of-the-art high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) coupled with various detection techniques, in particular mass spectrometry (MS), has recently gained in popularity in confirming and quantifying drug residues. In this article, the authors also outline the latest results on the application of highly sensitive and selective LC-MS in analysis of bacitracin residues in milk and animal tissues. LC-MS is suggested as the technique of choice for confirmation of polar polypeptide antibiotics and the like at trace concentrations.     

食品及环境样品中双酚类物质的前处理及检测方法研究进展

双酚类物质作为一种环境内分泌干扰物,广泛存在于食品包装材料及环境介质中,对生态环境造成污染,也对人体健康产生一定危害。双酚残留是目前重要的食品安全问题,检测食品和环境样品中的双酚类物质的含量对人体健康具有重要的意义。由于残留目标物浓度通常较低,且实际样品存在基质干扰,因此需经一定的样品前处理,并结合仪器分析方法,提高检测效率,增强分析灵敏度与可靠性。常用的前处理分析方法主要有液液萃取、微波辅助萃取、固相萃取、固相微萃取、基质分散固相萃取、QuEChERS等,常用仪器分析方法包括液相色谱法、气相色谱法、毛细管电泳法、酶联免疫吸附测定法、生物传感器法等。该文综述了食品及环境样品中双酚类物质的样品前处理及仪器分析方法,为双酚类化合物的残留监测提供了参考依据。     

Simultaneous determination of 24 sulfonamide residues in meat by ultra-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry

The present study used the liquid extraction pretreatment method and developed an ultra-performance liquid chromatography triple quadrupole tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-MS/MS) for the simultaneous determination of 24 kinds of sulfonamide residues in meat. The meat samples were homogenized, extracted and deproteinized by acetonitrile, defatted by n-hexane, and further liquid-liquid extracted by ethyl acetate. All of 24 sulfonamide residues were simultaneously separated and determined by UPLC-MS/MS within 15 min. The sulfonamide residues were monitored via the ESI(+) ionization method and quantified by six-channel multiple reaction monitoring (MRM). The calibrations were performed in sample matrixes by the isotope dilution method and the interference effect of sample matrixes on the ionization was effectively eliminated. Good linear relationship (R(2)=0.991-0.999) was observed within the concentration range of 0.2-50 microg/kg. Satisfied recoveries (67.8-113.9%) of all the sulfonamides were demonstrated in different standard-spiked levels except sulfanitran (SNT). The analytical category, separation speed, selectivity, sensitivity and repeatability of sulfonamides using UPLC-MS/MS were significantly improved compared to other analytical methods. Quantitative results of 240 meat samples demonstrated that the present method has a convenient operation and good practicability, which can be applied to the quantitative analysis of a large number of samples.     

在线柱后衍生-高效液相色谱-荧光检测法同时测定牛肉中16种磺胺类药物残留

在考察了荧光胺、邻苯二甲醛、异硫氰酸荧光素和2,3-萘二醛等对磺胺类药物衍生效果的基础上,建立了采用改良QuEChERS方法进行样品前处理,荧光胺在线柱后衍生,高效液相色谱-荧光检测法测定牛肉中16种磺胺残留量的方法。牛肉样品经1%(v/v)乙酸乙腈溶液提取,改良QuEChERS方法净化后取上清液进样,与荧光胺柱后在线衍生,荧光检测器检测。实验结果表明,16种磺胺类药物在0.024~2.533 mg/L范围内线性关系良好,相关系数(r)大于0.992,检出限为1.6~8.2 μg/kg,平均加标回收率范围为66.6%~109.5%,相对标准偏差为0.9%~9.9%。该方法快速简便、灵敏度高、净化效果好,可用于牛肉中16种磺胺类药物的快速测定。     

Biosensor assay of sulfadiazine and sulfamethazine residues in pork

Biosensor-based immunochemical screening assays for the detection of sulfadiazine (SDZ) and sulfamethazine (SMT) in muscle extract from pigs were developed. Samples were extracted with aqueous buffer and then centrifuged. This simple and straightforward preparation allowed up to 40 samples to be processed and analysed in 1 d. The limits of detection for the assays were found to be 5.6 ng g-1 for SDZ and 7.4 ng g-1 for SMT. These figures were well below the European and US legal limits for sulfonamides (100 ng g-1). The precision (RSD) between runs was < 8% and the recovery was between 91 and 98%. The validation proved the assays to be accurate and the analysis of routine field samples showed good correlation with an established TLC screening procedure. No false negative or positive results were obtained with blank and spiked samples. The influence of cross-reacting metabolites on immunoassays was demonstrated by testing incurred tissue samples, collected from sulfonamide treated pigs after only a short withdrawal period. The quantitative results obtained by biosensor analysis were a combination of parent sulfonamide plus N4-acetyl metabolite while the HPLC method used for confirmatory analysis detected only the parent sulfonamide. This gave rise to some false positive results and highlighted the need to use real samples in evaluating any assay thoroughly. False negative results were not obtained.     

Application of matrix solid-phase dispersion and high-performance liquid chromatography for determination of sulfonamides in honey

A novel method for simultaneous determination of 8 sulfonamide residues (sulfathiazole, sulfapyridine, sulfadiazine, sulfamerazine, sulfamonome-thoxine, sulfachloropyridazine, sulfamethoxazole, and sulfadimethoxine) in honey samples by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) has been developed on the basis of precolumn derivatization with 9-fluorenylmethyl-chloroformate (FMOC-Cl). Sulfonamide residues in honey samples were extracted and purified by matrix solid-phase dispersion with C18 as the solid support. The residues were derivatized by FMOC-CI, and the FMOC-sulfonamide derivatives were further purified by solid-phase extraction with silica gel as the solid support prior to HPLC analysis. The average recoveries for most sulfonamide compounds at different spiking levels (from 10 to 250 microg/kg) were > 70% with relative standard deviations < 16%, and their limits of detection were 4.0 microg/kg. The established analytical method has high sensitivity and repeatability and can be applicable for determining the sulfonamide residues in various honey matrixes.     

Receptor-Based Screening Assays: New Perspectives in Anti-Doping Control

The so-called “growth promoters”, steroid hormones and β-agonists, are currently controlled by using hyphenated analytical methods (chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry) or, sometimes for screening purposes, on immunoassays. These methods are often too specific to allow an effective multianalyte control. To develop more efficient assays, the use of hormonal receptors as detection tools (receptor-based binding assays and cell-based assays) is proposed. Receptor-based assays represent useful tools in screening of hormonal residues in food, but they could also be applied in doping control (to detect “new” hormonal substances). Furthermore, these assays could be used to monitor the human exposure to endocrine disruptors.     

Immunobiosensor--an alternative to enzyme immunoassay screening for residues of two sulfonamides in pigs.

A rapid immunoassay using an optical biosensor (BIAcore) for determining the presence of sulfamethazine (SMT) residues in pig bile was developed. The assay was used in a routine screening laboratory alongside a previously described biosensor method for sulfadiazine (SDZ). Sulfonamide bile concentrations, determined by enzyme immunoassay (EIA), have already been shown suitable for use in predicting the extent of sulfonamide accumulation in kidney. The ability of immunobiosensor based bile screening to predict violative tissue residues (greater than the maximum residue limit; MRL) was compared with results achieved using two conventional EIAs for two of these drug residues (SMT and SDZ). Analysis of 2081 samples for both sulphonamide residues, over an 8 month period, showed the false positive prediction rate of biosensor analysis to be 0.14% and 0.34% for SMT and SDZ, respectively, compared with false positive rates of 1.54% and 1.44% by EIA. Biosensor analysis showed no false negative predictions for either SMT or SDZ while EIA showed a false negative prediction rate of 0.14% for SMT and 0.24% for SDZ. The present study has clearly demonstrated that immunobiosensor assays can be developed for veterinary drug residue screening programmes. These methods have the potential for generating faster and more reliable results than conventional immunoassay methods.     

Evaluation of sample injection precision in respect to sensitivity in capillary electrophoresis using various injection modes

A comparative study was conducted to assess the injection precision in capillary electrophoresis for cationic analytes (arecoline, codeine, papaverine). The precision was measured in respect to methods sensitivity in various injection modes in capillary electrophoresis: standard hydrodynamic injection (3.45 kPa for 6 s), large volume sample stacking (3.45 kPa for 40 s), and field‐amplified sample injection (10 kV for 65 s). All measurements were conducted for aqueous solutions of standards to minimize the errors linked to the sample preparation step. The methods were submitted to precision assessment at three concentration levels: at the limit of quantification, three‐fold and ten‐fold of limit of quantification. The results were compared to those from high‐performance liquid chromatography as a reference technique. The field‐amplified sample injection method was shown to provide greatest sensitivity (quantification limits down to 4 ng/mL for all three tested compounds) but the lowest precision. High‐performance liquid chromatography was established as the most reliable technique (coefficient of variation in all intraday experiments was below 1%). It was also shown that with a use of large volume sample injection technique, similar sensitivity as in high‐performance liquid chromatography can be easily reached.     

Screening and analytical confirmation of sulfonamide residues in milk by capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry

A new methodology is proposed to automate the monitoring of sulfonamide residues in milk samples. It combines a screening unit for the total amount of sulfonamide with capillary electrophoresis-mass spectrometry (CE-MS) equipment for processing the samples containing a detectable level of sulfonamide. The screening unit consists of continuous-flow system (CFS) to precipitate the proteins connected on-line to the CE-MS equipment, in which a common characteristic ion of all sulfonamides was monitored with the MS detector by flushing the sample through the capillary. The confirmatory method is based on the purification and preconcentration of sulfonamides in a CFS unit and posterior analysis by CE-MS. The sample treatment unit was also on-line connected to the CE-MS equipment. In order to increase sensitivity, the flow rate of the sheath liquid was diminished from 0.5 to 0.2 microL.min(-1) by increasing the content in water from 0 to 50% and the formic acid from 0.5 to 1.5% in this liquid and by applying an overimposed pressure of 5 mbar during the electrophoretic separation. The method allowed the analysis of 30 samples per hour.     

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay and colloidal gold immunoassay for ochratoxin A: investigation of analytical conditions and sample matrix on assay performance

A polyclonal antibody against ochratoxin A (OTA) was produced from rabbits immunized with the OTA–BSA conjugate. A competitive direct enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (cdELISA) and a membrane-base colloidal gold immunoassay in flow-through format were developed for the rapid detection of OTA in various food matrices. In the cdELISA, the concentration causing 50% inhibition was 0.07 ng mL⁻¹, and the effects of different chemical conditions (ionic strength, pH value, and organic solvent) were studied. The sensitivity of the assay was higher than those previously reported. A simple, rapid, and efficient extraction method was developed and 74–110% recoveries of spiked samples were obtained. Fifty percent methanol extracts of some food samples such as barley, wheat, oat, corn, rice, and raisins could be analyzed directly by immunoassay after dilution in PBS; grape juice and beer samples could be analyzed directly after dilution with PBS; for coffee samples, a more complex method was used to remove the matrix effect effectively. Membrane-based colloidal gold immunoassays had a visual detection limit of 1.0 ng mL⁻¹ for OTA with a detection time of less than 10 min. For the validation of the cdELISA and membrane-based colloidal gold immunoassay, samples were analyzed by high-performance liquid chromatography. The correlation between data obtained using the microwell assay and HPLC was good (R ² = 0.984). The developed immunoassay methods are suitable for the rapid quantitative or qualitative determination of OTA in food samples.     

Test strip enzyme immunoassays and the fast screening of nortestosterone and clenbuterol residues in urine samples at the parts per billion level

The preliminary results of an investigation into the development of "on-site" test strip enzyme immunoassays for the screening of urine samples for the presence of growth promoters, such as 17 beta, 19-nortestosterone and clenbuterol at the parts per billion level are described. Urine samples, enzyme-labelled analyte and a nitrocellulose test strip, containing immobilized antibodies, are incubated together, after which the strip is placed in a chromogen-containing substrate solution for colour reaction. Using prefabricated strips, the tests can be performed in 45-60 min. A similar assay was worked out using a dot-blotting device, allowing the test to be performed in 20-50 min. The tests are simple and easy to perform outside the laboratory. Urine samples identified positive by gas chromatography mass spectrometry were also found to be positive with these test strips and, so far, no false-positive results have been encountered. With standard additions to blank urine samples, positive samples could be distinguished above the 5 ng ml level. However, samples from treated calves contain one or more metabolites of the parent compound, which increase the sensitivity of the assays. Although the tests described can be improved and still have to be evaluated further by analysing more urine samples, the preliminary results are very promising and give a lead to further research into the applicability of such "on-site" tests in residue analysis.     

Fast antimicrobial screen test (FAST): improved screen test for detecting antimicrobial residues in meat tissue

The Fast Antimicrobial Screen Test (FAST) is a simple and quick screening test developed to detect antibiotic and sulfonamide residues in food animal carcasses in slaughter establishments. This microbial inhibition test detects antimicrobials that are allowed to be used in food animals. It has the ability to detect these antimicrobials at or above the allowable limit in carcass kidney fluids in 6 h. Laboratory evaluations show that the lower limit of detection (LLD) of FAST and the Calf Antibiotic and Sulfa Test (CAST) for antibiotics tested was the same, but the LLD for sulfonamides of FAST was lower than the LLD of CAST. Compared with the Swab Test on Premises (STOP) developed in 1977, the LLD's of FAST for both antibiotics and sulfonamides were significantly better. Under field conditions, the sensitivity of FAST and CAST to antibiotic and sulfonamide residues in animal kidneys was not significantly different, but the time required by FAST was significantly lower than CAST (6 versus 18 h). Compared with the STOP, the sensitivity and the range of detection by FAST for all antimicrobials were significantly higher and the testing time was lower (18 versus 6 h).     

Determination of acidic herbicides in fruits and vegetables using liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS)

The use of quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged and safe method followed by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) was found to be the best combination for multiresidue determination of eight acidic herbicides in fruits and vegetables in terms of high recovery, short time of analysis, low cost and safety. Recent few articles were published for determination of different classes of acidic herbicides in single multiresidue method. In the present study, mass spectrophotometric conditions were individually optimised for eight acidic herbicides, namely 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetic acid, bentazone, bromoxynil, fluazifop, fluroxypyr, imazethapyr, ioxynil and triclopyr to achieve maximum sensitivity and selectivity in multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode allowing simultaneous identification and quantification in a single run. Identity confirmation and quantitation were attained by using negative electrospray ionisation LC-MS/MS (ESI?) in MRM mode. Due to LC-MS/MS signal suppression, determination of pesticide residues was based on matrix-matched standard calculations. Most of the evaluated compounds showed a recovery ranging from 81% to 113% with relative standard deviations less than 16 % indicating acceptable precision. The precision and accuracy of the method were determined from recovery experiments on six replicates of spiked blank strawberry and green beans samples at 0.01, 0.05 and 0.1 mg/kg. The developed assay was linear over concentration range of 0.01–0.5 µg/mL, with correlation coefficient greater than 0.99 at the limit of quantitation 0.01 µg/mL. The proposed assay was successfully applied for the analysis of the studied acidic herbicides residues in two proficiency test samples. This wide scope assay protocol is applicable for monitoring acidic herbicides residues in fruits and vegetables by national regulatory authorities and accredited labs in order to help ensuring the safety of such widely used food products.     

Application of high-performance liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry for analysis and quality control of Radix Astragali and its preparations

A high-performance liquid chromatography coupled with electrospray ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (HPLC-ESI-TOF-MS) method has been developed for qualitative and quantitative analysis of isoflavonoids and saponins, as well as for the quality control of Radix Astragali and its preparations. The selectivity, reproducibility and sensitivity are compared with HPLC with diode array detection (DAD) and evaporative light scattering detection (ELSD). Limits of detection and quantification fell in ranges of 9-40 and 23-103 ng/mL for 13 analytes with a injection of 10 microL samples, and all calibration curves showed good linear regression (r(2)>0.9938) within the test range. The assay was successfully utilized to analyze the 13 marker components in 20 samples of Radix Astragali products. The quantitative results demonstrated that samples from different localities and manufacturers showed different quality. Advantages, in comparison with conventional HPLC-DAD-ELSD, are that reliable identification of target compounds could be achieved by accurate mass measurements (<3 ppm) along with characteristic retention time, extracted ions chromatograms using a narrow mass window for quantification ensure that the chromatographic peaks are free from background or co-elutes interference, and the great enhancement in selectivity and sensitivity allows identification and quantification of low levels of constituents in complex Radix Astragali matrixes.     

Development of a simple and rapid HPLC‐MS/MS method for quantification of streptomycin in mice and its application to plasma pharmacokinetic studies

Streptomycin was the first discovered aminoglycoside antibiotic. It has been widely applied in veterinary medicine for the prevention and treatment of bacterial infection. However, the current detection methods are not satisfactory in terms of sensitivity and sample process, which makes them unsuitable for a pharmacokinetic study. A high‐performance liquid chromatography–mass spectrometric method employing positive electrospray ionization was developed and validated for the determination of streptomycin concentration in mice plasma. A simple protein precipitation method was utilized to extract streptomycin as well as the internal standard (kanamycin) from mouse plasma. This assay method was validated in terms of specificity, sensitivity, precision, accuracy and recovery. This method was applied to a pharmacokinetic study in mice following intramuscular administration of 200 mg/kg streptomycin. The lower limit of quantification of the developed assay method for streptomycin was 10 ng/mL. The intra‐day and inter‐day precision was evaluated with the coefficient of variations <14.3%, whereas the mean accuracy ranged from 87.0 to 105.0%. The samples were stable under the experimental conditions. The present method provides a robust, fast and sensitive analytical approach for the quantification of streptomycin in mouse plasma and has been successfully applied to a pharmacokinetic study in mice.     

Improving the sensitivity of liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry analysis of hexabromocyclododecanes by chlorine adduct generation

It is well documented and experimentally confirmed that hexabromocyclododecanes (HBCDs) tend to associate with several anions forming different adducts that can affect the sensitivity and the accuracy of the determinations. In the present work, two different approaches for HBCD determination have been optimised and characterised based on their repeatability and intermediate precision, linear calibration ranges, sensitivity, limits of detection and quantification and application to commercial food samples. Both methods involve the use of a triple quadrupole mass spectrometer coupled to a liquid chromatograph and the addition of different ammonium salts to the mobile phase, i.e. ammonium chloride or ammonium acetate, in order to encourage (Cl method) or try to inhibit (Ac method), respectively, the formation of the chlorine adducts of the molecular ion. Precision of the two methods investigated was similar and both approaches presented a comparable behaviour for the analysis of food samples. However, the Cl method showed higher sensitivity and the limits of detection (0.23–0.41 pg on column) and quantification (0.77–1.35 pg on column) were up to 14 times lower than those obtained applying the Ac method. All these facts make the Cl method the best choice for the quantification of HBCDs in food samples with low concentration levels.     

A quantitative method for the detection of sulfonamide residues in meat and milk samples with a high-performance thin-layer chromatographic method.

Sulfonamides are widely used in veterinary medicine for prophylactic purposes and for the treatment of various infections of food-producing animals. This means that residues of these drugs and their possible metabolites may occur in food of animal origin. In Belgium, a zero tolerance level for sulfonamides in edible animal tissues has been set. In order to check this zero level on a routine basis, a rapid and sensitive method has to be available. For this purpose, a quantitative high-performance thin-layer chromatographic (HPTLC) method for the detection of sulfonamide residues in animal tissue and milk samples has been developed. The sample preparation consists of a liquid extraction followed by a solid phase extraction (SPE) on disposable columns for the meat samples and a matrix solid phase dispersion (MSPD) for the milk samples. A three-multiple development chromatographic system is used for the separation and a derivatization with fluorescamine decreases the minimal detectable quantity per spot from 1.42 to 0.32 ng. The limit of quantification is 4 micrograms/kg for milk and meat samples.