Recent developments in DNS of turbulent combustion

The simulation of turbulent flames fully resolving the smallest flow scales and the thinnest reaction zones goes along with specific requirements, which are discussed from dimensionless numbers useful to introduce the generic context in which direct numerical simulation (DNS) of turbulent flames is performed. Starting from this basis, the evolution of the DNS landscape over the past five years is reviewed. It is found that the flow geometries, the focus of the studies and the overall motivations for performing DNS have broadened, making DNS a standard tool in numerical turbulent combustion. Along these lines, the emerging DNS of laboratory burners for turbulent flame modeling development is discussed and illustrated from DNS imbedded in Large Eddy Simulation (LES) and flow resolved simulation of bluff-body flames. The literature shows that DNS generated databases constitute a fantastic playground for developing and testing a large spectrum of promising machine learning methods for the control and the optimisation of combustion systems, including novel numerical approaches based on the training of neural networks and which can be evaluated in DNS free from sub-model artefacts. The so-called quasi-DNS is also progressively entering the optimisation loop of combustion systems, with the application of techniques to downsize real combustion devices in order to perform fully resolved simulations of their complex geometries. An example of such study leading to the improvement of an incinerator efficiency is reported. Finally, numbers are given relative to the carbon footprint of the generation of DNS databases, motivating the crucial need for community building around database sharing.     

Stratified turbulent Bunsen flames: flame surface analysis and flame surface density modelling

In this paper it is investigated whether the Flame Surface Density (FSD) model, developed for turbulent premixed combustion, is also applicable to stratified flames. Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) of turbulent stratified Bunsen flames have been carried out, using the Flamelet Generated Manifold (FGM) reduction method for reaction kinetics. Before examining the suitability of the FSD model, flame surfaces are characterized in terms of thickness, curvature and stratification.

All flames are in the Thin Reaction Zones regime, and the maximum equivalence ratio range covers 0.1?φ?1.3. For all flames, local flame thicknesses correspond very well to those observed in stretchless, steady premixed flamelets. Extracted curvature radii and mixing length scales are significantly larger than the flame thickness, implying that the stratified flames all burn in a premixed mode. The remaining challenge is accounting for the large variation in (subfilter) mass burning rate.

In this contribution, the FSD model is proven to be applicable for Large Eddy Simulations (LES) of stratified flames for the equivalence ratio range 0.1?φ?1.3. Subfilter mass burning rate variations are taken into account by a subfilter Probability Density Function (PDF) for the mixture fraction, on which the mass burning rate directly depends. A priori analysis point out that for small stratifications (0.4?φ?1.0), the replacement of the subfilter PDF (obtained from DNS data) by the corresponding Dirac function is appropriate. Integration of the Dirac function with the mass burning rate m=m(φ), can then adequately model the filtered mass burning rate obtained from filtered DNS data. For a larger stratification (0.1?φ?1.3), and filter widths up to ten flame thicknesses, a β-function for the subfilter PDF yields substantially better predictions than a Dirac function. Finally, inclusion of a simple algebraic model for the FSD resulted only in small additional deviations from DNS data, thereby rendering this approach promising for application in LES.     

Modelling of turbulent scalar flux in turbulent premixed flames based on DNS databases

A transport equation for scalar flux in turbulent premixed flames was modelled on the basis of DNS databases. Fully developed turbulent premixed flames were obtained for three different density ratios of flames with a single-step irreversible reaction, while the turbulent intensity was comparable to the laminar burning velocity. These DNS databases showed that the countergradient diffusion was dominant in the flame region. Analyses of the Favre-averaged transport equation for turbulent scalar flux proved that the pressure related terms and the velocity–reaction rate correlation term played important roles on the countergradient diffusion, while the mean velocity gradient term, the mean progress variable gradient term and dissipation terms suppressed it. Based on these analyses, modelling of the combustion-related terms was discussed. The mean pressure gradient term and the fluctuating pressure term were modelled by scaling, and these models were in good agreement with DNS databases. The dissipation terms and the velocity–reaction rate correlation term were also modelled, and these models mimicked DNS well.     

Turbulent flame visualization using direct numerical simulation

Combustion phenomena are of high scientific and technological interest, in particular for energy generation and transportation systems. Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) have become an essential and well established research tool to investigate the structure of turbulent flames, since they do not rely on any approximate turbulence models. In this work two complementary DNS codes are employed to investigate different types of fuels and flame configurations. The code is π³ is a 3-dimensional DNS code using a low-Mach number approximation. Chemistry is described through a tabulation, using two coordinates to enter a database constructed for example with 29 species and 141 reactions for methane combustion. It is used here to investigate the growth of a turbulent premixed flame in a methane-air mixture (Case 1). The second code,Sider is an explicit three-dimensional DNS code solving the fully compressible reactive Navier-Stokes equations, where the chemical processes are computed using a complete reaction scheme, taking into account accurate diffusion properties. It is used here to compute a hydrogen/air turbulent diffusion flame (Case 2), considering 9 chemical species and 38 chemical reactions.     

The impact of dilatation,scrambling, and pressure transport in turbulent premixed flames

Premixed turbulent flames feature strong interactions between chemical reactions and turbulence that affect scalar and turbulence statistics. The focus of the present work is on clarifying the impact of pressure dilatation/flamelet scrambling effects with a comprehensive second-moment closure used for evaluation purposes. Model extensions that take into account flamelet orientation and molecular diffusion are derived. Isothermal pressure transport is included with an additional variable density contribution derived for the flamelet regime of combustion. Full closure is assessed by comparisons with Direct Numerical Simulations (DNSs) of statistically ‘steady’ fully developed premixed turbulent planar flames at different expansion ratios. Subsequently, the prediction of lean premixed turbulent methane–air flames featuring fractal grid generated turbulence in an opposed jet geometry is considered. The overall agreement shows that ‘dilatation’ effects contribute to counter-gradient transport and can also increase the turbulent kinetic energy significantly. Levels of anisotropy are broadly consistent with the DNS data and key aspects of opposed jet flames are well predicted. However, it is also shown that complications arise due to interactions between the imposed pressure gradient and combustion and that redistribution is affected along with the scalar flux at the leading edge. The latter is strongly affected by the reaction rate closure and, potentially, by pressure transport. Overall, the derived models offer significant improvements and can readily be applied to the modelling of premixed turbulent flames at practical rates of heat release.     

How fast can we burn, 2.0

We review the state of the art in measurements and simulations of the behavior of premixed laminar and turbulent flames, subject to differential diffusion, stretch and curvature. The first part of the paper reviews the behavior of premixed laminar flames subject to flow stretch, and how it affects the accuracy of measurements of unstrained laminar flame speeds in stretched and spherically propagating flames. We then examine how flow field stretch and differential diffusion interact with flame propagation, promoting or suppressing the onset of thermodiffusive instabilities. Secondly, we survey the methodology for and results of measurements of turbulent flame speeds in the light of theory, and identify issues of consistency in the definition of mean flame speeds, and their corresponding mean areas. Data for methane at a single operating condition are compared for a range of turbulent conditions, showing that fundamental issues that have yet to be resolved for Bunsen and spherically propagating flames. Finally, we consider how the laminar flame scale response of flames to flow perturbations interacting with differential diffusion leads to very different outcomes to the overall sensitivity of the burning rate to turbulence, according to numerical simulations (DNS). The paper concludes with opportunities for future measurements and model development, including the perennial recommendation for robust archival databases of experimental and DNS results for future testing of models.     

Direct numerical simulation of a statistically stationary,turbulent reacting flow

An inhomogeneous, non-premixed, stationary, turbulent, reacting model flow that is accessible to direct numerical simulation (DNS) is described for investigating the effects of mixing on reaction and for testing mixing models. The mixture-fraction-progress-variable approach of Bilger is used, with a model, finite-rate, reversible, single-step thermochemistry, yielding non-trivial stationary solutions corresponding to stable reaction and also allowing local extinction to occur. There is a uniform mean gradient in the mixture fraction, which gives rise to stationarity as well as a flame brush. A range of reaction zone thicknesses and Damkohler numbers are examined, yielding a broad spectrum of behaviour, including thick and thin flames, local extinction and near equilibrium. Based on direct numerical simulations, results from the conditional moment closure (CMC) and the quasi-equilibrium distributed reaction (QEDR) model are evaluated. Large intermittency in the scalar dissipation leads to local extinction in the DNS. In regions of the flow where local extinction is not present, CMC and QEDR based on the local scalar dissipation give good agreement with the DNS.M This article features multimedia enhancements available from the supplemental page in the online journal.     

The effect of timescale variation in multiple mapping conditioning mixing of PDF calculations for Sandia Flame series D–F

A stochastic implementation of the multiple mapping conditioning (MMC) model has been used for the modelling of turbulence–chemistry interactions in a series of turbulent jet diffusion flames with varying degrees of local extinction (Sandia Flames D–F). The mapping function approximates the cumulative probability distribution of mixture fraction and the corresponding variance can be controlled by a standard implementation of the scalar mixing timescale. The conditional fluctuations are controlled by a minor dissipation timescale, τ_min. The results show a clear dependence of the conditional fluctuations on the choice of the minor timescale, and the appropriate value for turbulent jet flames is similar to values determined in related direct numerical simulation (DNS) studies of homogeneous turbulent reacting flows. The predictions of means and variances of temperature and species mass fractions are very good for all flames, indicating an appropriate modelling of the conditional variances. Further sensitivity studies with respect to particle number density demonstrate a relative insensitivity of the results to the particle number in the numerical solution procedure. Good results can be obtained with as few as 10 particles per cell, allowing for a computationally inexpensive implementation of a Monte Carlo/probability density function (PDF) method.     

Turbulent scalar fluxes in H2-air premixed flames at low and high Karlovitz numbers

The statistical behaviour and closure of sub-grid scalar fluxes in the context of turbulent premixed combustion have been assessed based on an a priori analysis of a detailed chemistry Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) database consisting of three hydrogen-air flames spanning the corrugated flamelets (CF), thin reaction zones (TRZ) and broken reaction zones (BRZ) regimes of premixed turbulent combustion. The sub-grid scalar fluxes have been extracted by explicit filtering of DNS data. It has been found that the conventional gradient hypothesis model is not appropriate for the closure of sub-grid scalar flux for any scalar in the context of a multispecies system. However, the predictions of the conventional gradient hypothesis exhibit a greater level of qualitative agreement with DNS data for the flame representing the BRZ regime. The aforementioned behaviour has been analysed in terms of the properties of the invariants of the anisotropy tensor in the Lumley triangle. The flames in the CF and TRZ regimes are characterised by a pronounced two-dimensional anisotropy due to strong heat release whereas a three-dimensional and more isotropic behaviour is observed for the flame located in the BRZ regime. Two sub-grid scalar flux models which are capable of predicting counter-gradient transport have been considered for a priori DNS assessment of multispecies systems and have been analysed in terms of both qualitative and quantitative agreements. By combining the latter two sub-grid scalar flux closures, a new modelling strategy is suggested where one model is responsible for properly predicting the conditional mean accurately and the other model is responsible for the correlations between model and unclosed term. Detailed physical explanations for the observed behaviour and an assessment of existing modelling assumptions have been provided. Finally, the classical Bray–Moss–Libby theory for the scalar flux closure has been extended to address multispecies transport in the context of large eddy simulations.     

Turbulence/flame/wall interactions in non-premixed inclined slot-jet flames impinging at a wall using direct numerical simulation

In the present work, three-dimensional turbulent non-premixed oblique slot-jet flames impinging at a wall were investigated using direct numerical simulation (DNS). Two cases are considered with the Damköhler number (Da) of case A being twice that of case B. A 17 species and 73-step mechanism for methane combustion was employed in the simulations. It was found that flame extinction in case B is more prominent compared to case A. Reignition in the lower branch of combustion for case A occurs when the scalar dissipation rate relaxes, while no reignition occurs in the lower branch for case B due to excessive scalar dissipation rate. A method was proposed to identify the flame quenching edges of turbulent non-premixed flames in wall-bounded flows based on the intersections of mixture fraction and OH mass fraction iso-surfaces. The flame/wall interactions were examined in terms of the quenching distance and the wall heat flux along the quenching edges. There is essentially no flame/wall interaction in case B due to the extinction caused by excessive turbulent mixing. In contrast, significant interactions between flames and the wall are observed in case A. The quenching distance is found to be negatively correlated with wall heat flux as previously reported in turbulent premixed flames. The influence of chemical reactions and wall on flow topologies was identified. The FS/U and FC/U topologies are found near flame edges, and the NNN/U topology appears when reignition occurs. The vortex-dominant topologies, FC/U and FS/S, play an increasingly important role as the jet turbulence develops.     

Conditional velocity statistics in the double scalar mixing layer – A mapping closure approach

In this work we use 3D direct numerical simulations (DNS) to investigate the average velocity conditioned on a conserved scalar in a double scalar mixing layer (DSML). The DSML is a canonical multistream flow designed as a model problem for the extensively studied piloted diffusion flames. The conditional mean velocity appears as an unclosed term in advanced Eulerian models of turbulent non-premixed combustion, like the conditional moment closure and transported probability density function (PDF) methods. Here it accounts for inhomogeneous effects that have been found significant in flames with relatively low Damköhler numbers. Today there are only a few simple models available for the conditional mean velocity and these are discussed with reference to the DNS results. We find that both the linear model of Kutznetzov and the Li and Bilger model are unsuitable for multi stream flows, whereas the gradient diffusion model of Pope shows very close agreement with DNS over the whole range of the DSML. The gradient diffusion model relies on a model for the conserved scalar PDF and here we have used a presumed mapping function PDF, that is known to give an excellent representation of the DNS. A new model for the conditional mean velocity is suggested by arguing that the Gaussian reference field represents the velocity field, a statement that is evidenced by a near perfect agreement with DNS. The model still suffers from an inconsistency with the unconditional flux of conserved scalar variance, though, and a strategy for developing fully consistent models is suggested.     

Modeling curvature effects in turbulent autoigniting non-premixed flames using tabulated chemistry

Turbulent flames are intrinsically curved. In the presence of preferential diffusion, curvature effects either enhance or suppress molecular diffusion, depending on the diffusivity of the species and the direction of the flame curvature. When a tabulated chemistry type of modeling is employed, curvature-preferential diffusion interactions have to be taken into consideration in the construction of manifolds. In this study, we employ multistage stage flamelet generated manifolds (MuSt-FGM) method to model autoigniting non-premixed turbulent flames with preferential diffusion effects included. The conditions for the modeled flame are in MILD combustion regime. To model the above-mentioned curvature-preferential diffusion interactions, a new mixture fraction which has a non-unity Lewis number is defined and used as a new control variable in the manifold generation. 1D curved flames are simulated to create the necessary flamelets. The resulting MuSt-FGM tables are used in the simulation of 1D laminar flames, and then also applied to turbulent flames using 2D direct numerical simulations (DNS). It was observed that when the curvature effects are included in the manifold, the MuSt-FGM results agree well with the detailed chemistry results; whereas the results become unsatisfactory when the curvature effects are ignored.     

Effects of Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities on turbulent premixed flames in a curved rectangular duct

Large-eddy simulations are used to demonstrate the effects of Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities (RTIs) on constant-pressure, turbulent premixed flames stabilized in a curved rectangular duct. A splitter plate of constant radius separates a reactant and pilot stream such that the flame stabilizes in the mixing layer between the two streams. Centrifugal acceleration due to the duct curvature induces the RTI, increasing the mixing of the higher-density reactant stream with the lower-density pilot stream. In both non-reacting and reacting flows, the resulting mixing layer thickness grows at rates comparable to those in unconfined RTIs until the flame occupies approximately half of the duct, at which point the duct walls limit the growth rate. The conservative equations are modified with artificial body forces to negate the centrifugal effect (and the RTI) to isolate the impact of the curved geometry. A comparison between the flames with and without the RTI shows that the RTI increases the turbulent flame speed primarily through increased flame surface area. The RTI also increases the range of local flame stretches and curvatures. The increased turbulent flame speed and growth rates due to RTI suggest a viable mechanism to increase turbulent flame speed in gas turbine engines though the application of flow path curvature.     

Turbulent scalar flux transport in head-on quenching of turbulent premixed flames: a direct numerical simulations approach to assess models for Reynolds averaged Navier Stokes simulations

The statistical behaviour and the modelling of turbulent scalar flux transport have been analysed using a direct numerical simulation (DNS) database of head-on quenching of statistically planar turbulent premixed flames by an isothermal wall. A range of different values of Damköhler, Karlovitz numbers and Lewis numbers has been considered for this analysis. The magnitudes of the turbulent transport and mean velocity gradient terms in the turbulent scalar flux transport equation remain small in comparison to the pressure gradient, molecular dissipation and reaction-velocity fluctuation correlation terms in the turbulent scalar flux transport equation when the flame is away from the wall but the magnitudes of all these terms diminish and assume comparable values during flame quenching before vanishing altogether. It has been found that the existing models for the turbulent transport, pressure gradient, molecular dissipation and reaction-velocity fluctuation correlation terms in the turbulent scalar flux transport equation do not adequately address the respective behaviours extracted from DNS data in the near-wall region during flame quenching. Existing models for transport equation-based closures of turbulent scalar flux have been modified in such a manner that these models provide satisfactory prediction both near to and away from the wall.     

湍流分层燃烧的直接数值模拟和小火焰模型研究

湍流分层燃烧广泛应用于工业燃烧装置,但是目前还比较缺乏适用于湍流分层燃烧的高精度数值模型。本文利用直接数值模拟数据库,对高Karlovitz数分层射流火焰的小火焰模型表现进行了先验性评估。考虑了两种小火焰模型,一种是基于自由传播层流预混火焰的小火焰模型M1,另一种是基于分层对冲小火焰的小火焰模型M2。研究发现M1和M2在c-Z空间的结果与直接数值模拟在定性上是一致的。在物理空间,M2对过程变量反应速率脉动值的预测结果要优于M1.     

Three-dimensional direct simulations and structure of expanding turbulent methane flames

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) are ideally suited to investigate in detail turbulent reacting flows in simple geometries. For an increasing number of applications, detailed models must be employed to describe the chemical processes with sufficient accuracy. Despite the huge cost of such simulations, recent progress has allowed the direct numerical simulation of turbulent premixed flames while employing complete reaction schemes. We briefly describe our own developments in this field and use the resulting DNS code to investigate more extensively the structure of premixed methane flames expanding in a three-dimensional turbulent velocity field, initially homogeneous and isotropic. This situation typifies, for example, the initial flame development after spark ignition in a gas turbine or an internal combustion engine. First investigation steps have been carried out at low turbulence levels on this same configuration in the past Symposium, and we build on top of these former results. Here, a considerably higher Reynolds number is considered, the simulation has been repeated twice in to limit the possibility of spurious, very specific results, and several complementary post-processing steps are carried out. Characteristic features concerning the observed combustion regime are presented. We then investigate in a quantitative manner the evolution of flame surface area, global stretch-rate, flame front curvature, flame thickness, and correlation between thickness and curvature. The possibility of obtaining reliable information on flame front curvature from two-dimensional slices is checked by comparison with the exact procedure.     

A priori analysis of sub-grid variance of a reactive scalar using DNS data of high Ka flames

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) of low and high Karlovitz number (Ka) flames are analysed to investigate the behaviour of the reactive scalar sub-grid scale (SGS) variance in premixed combustion under a wide range of combustion conditions (regimes). An order of magnitude analysis is performed to assess the importance of various terms in the variance evolution equation and the analysis is validated using the DNS results. This analysis sheds light on the relative behaviour among turbulent transport and production, scalar dissipation and chemical processes involved in the evolution of the SGS variance at different Ka. The common expectation is that the variance equation shifts from a reaction-dissipation balance at low Ka to a production–dissipation balance at high Ka with diminishing reaction contribution. However, in large eddy simulation (LES), a high Ka alone does not make the reaction term negligible, as the relative importance of the reaction term has a concurrent increase with filter size. The filter size can be relatively large compared with the Kolmogorov length scale in practical LES of high Ka flames, and as a consequence a reaction–production–dissipation balance may prevail in the variance equation even in a high Ka configuration, and this possibility is quantified using the DNS analysis in this work. This has implications from modelling perspectives, and therefore two commonly used closures in LES for the SGS scalar dissipation rate are investigated a priori to estimate the importance of the above balance in LES modelling. The results are explained to highlight the interplay among turbulence, chemistry and dissipation processes as a function of Ka.     

Experimental measurements of geometric properties of turbulent stratified flames

Combustion under stratified conditions is common in many systems. However, relatively little is known about the structure and dynamics of turbulent stratified flames. Two-dimensional imaging diagnostics are applied to premixed and stratified V-flames at a mean equivalence ratio of 0.77, and low turbulent intensity, within the corrugated flame range. The present results show that stratification affects the mean turbulent flame speed, structure and geometric properties. Stratification increases the flame surface density above the premixed flame levels in all cases, with a maximum reached at intermediate levels of stratification. The flame surface density (FSD) of stratified flames is higher than that of premixed flames at the same mean equivalence ratio. Under the present conditions, the FSD peaks at a stratification ratio around 3.0. The FSD curves for stratified flames are further skewed towards the product side. The distribution of flame curvature in stratified flames is broader and more symmetric relative to premixed flames, indicating an additional mechanism of curvature generation, which is not necessarily due to cusping. These experiments indicate that flame stratification affects the intrinsic behaviour of turbulent flames and suggest that models may need to be revised in the light of the current evidence.     

Characteristic boundary conditions for direct simulations of turbulent counterflow flames

Improved Navier–Stokes characteristic boundary conditions (NSCBC) are formulated for the direct numerical simulations (DNS) of laminar and turbulent counterflow flame configurations with a compressible flow formulation. The new boundary scheme properly accounts for multi-dimensional flow effects and provides nonreflecting inflow and outflow conditions that maintain the mean imposed velocity and pressure, while substantially eliminating spurious acoustic wave reflections. Applications to various counterflow configurations demonstrate that the proposed boundary conditions yield accurate and robust solutions over a wide range of flow and scalar variables, allowing high fidelity in detailed numerical studies of turbulent counterflow flames.     

Controlled detonation initiation in hypersonic flow

Experimental evidence of controlled detonation initiation and propagation in a hypersonic flow of premixed hydrogen-air is presented. This controlled detonation initiation is created in a hypersonic facility capable of producing a Mach 5 flow of hydrogen-air. Flow diagnostics such as high-speed schlieren and OH* chemiluminescence results show that a flame deflagration-to-detonation transition occurs as a combined result of turbulent flame acceleration and shock-focusing. The experimental results define three new distinct regimes in a Mach 5 premixed flow: deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT), unsteady compressible turbulent flames, and shock-induced combustion. A two-dimensional implicit-LES (ILES) simulation, which solves the compressible, reactive Navier-Stokes equations on an adapting grid is conducted to provide additional insight into the local physical mechanism of detonation transition and propagation.