Underdetermination,Realism, and Theory Appraisal: An Epistemological Reflection on Quantum Mechanics

This paper examines the epistemological significance of the present situation of underdetermination in quantum mechanics. After analyzing this underdetermination at three levels---formal, ontological, and methodological---the paper considers implications for a number of variants of the thesis of scientific realism in fundamental physics and reassesses Lakatos characterization of progress in physical theory in light of the present situation. Next, this paper considers the implications of underdetermination for Weinbergs dream of a final theory. Finally, the paper concludes by suggesting how one might still think of realism and progress in fundamental physics despite the possibility of persistent underdetermination in quantum mechanics.This paper draws from my Ph.D. dissertation, Ontological Commitments and Theory Appraisal in the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics (University of Notre Dame, 1998). It was presented at the James T. Cushing Memorial Conference on Philosophical Issues in Physics, University of Notre Dame, November 2002. My thanks to the participants on that occasion for their comments and questions.     

Asymptotic Completeness for Compton Scattering

Scattering in a model of a massive quantum-mechanical particle, an electron, interacting with massless, relativistic bosons, photons, is studied. The interaction term in the Hamiltonian of our model describes emission and absorption of photons by the electron; but electron-positron pair production is suppressed. An ultraviolet cutoff and an (arbitrarily small, but fixed) infrared cutoff are imposed on the interaction term. In a range of energies where the propagation speed of the dressed electron is strictly smaller than the speed of light, unitarity of the scattering matrix is proven, provided the coupling constant is small enough; (asymptotic completeness of Compton scattering). The proof combines a construction of dressed one–electron states with propagation estimates for the electron and the photons.Dedicated to Freeman Dyson on the occasion of his 80th birthdayWork partially supported by U.S. National Science Foundation grant DMS 01-00160.Acknowledgement. We thank V. Bach for his hospitality at the University of Mainz, where part of this work was done, and we are indebted to Gian Michele Graf for pointing out a serious gap in an earlier version of this paper. We also thank one of the referees for pointing out many typos and some small errors.     

On the relation between weak and strong invariance of differential equations

Some concepts of Lie algebra cohomology are used to systematize the search for differential equations invariant under a given Lie groupG. In particular, it is shown that if a strongly invariant equation exists, then all weakly invariant equations differ from it only by an arbitrary multiplicative factor. If no strongly invariant equation exists, then cohomology theory can be used to simplify the search for weakly invariant equations.     

Perturbed periodic Hamiltonians: Essential Spectrum and exponential decay of eigenfunctions

Spectral properties of – +V(x), whereV(x) lies in a neighbourhood of the periodic case and describes various models of disorder, are studied. We prove the exponential decay of generalized eigenfunctions corresponding to energies in the resolvent set of the unperturbed periodic Hamiltonian, as well as the stability of the essential spectrum for the dislocation disorder in two dimensions.     

Maximal structures of determinate propositions in quantum mechanics

I formulate and answer some questions concerning maximal structures of determinate quantum propositions, i.e., maximal structures of propositions that can be taken as having definite (but perhaps unknown) truth values for a given quantum state. The basic constraint on such structures is the Kochen and Specker no-go hidden-variables theorem, which demonstrates that no value assignment to certain finite sets of observables can preserve the functional relations between commuting observables. The problem I want to consider is how large we can take the set of determinate observables without violating the functional relationship constraint. I show how to construct maximal determinate sublattices of quantum propositions that are unique, subject to certain constraints, and I comment on the relevance of this go theorem for the interpretation of quantum mechanics.     

The Wilson Loop Observables of Chern-Simons Theory on ℝ<Superscript>3</Superscript> in Axial Gauge

We define the Wilson loop observables (WLOs) for pure Chern-Simons models with base manifold M=³ rigorously as infinite dimensional oscillatory integrals by exploiting an axial gauge fixing and applying certain regularization techniques like loop-smearing and framing. The values of the WLOs can be computed explicitly. If the structure group G of the model considered is Abelian one obtains well-known linking number expressions for the WLOs. If G is Non-Abelian one obtains expressions which are similar but not identical to the state sum representations for the Homfly and Kauffman polynomials by Jones and Turaev.     

Analysis of signal-to-noise ratio of the laser Doppler velocimeter

The signal-to-shot-noise ratio of the photocurrent of a laser Doppler anemometer is calculated as a function of the parameters which describe the system. It is found that the S/N is generally a growing function of receiver area, that few large particles are better than many small ones, and that generally the fringe or differential mode configuration is equal to, or better than, the reference beam mode.     

The ground state of the Bose gas

The mathematical formalism describing the Bose gas at zero temperature is analysed with the aid of methods that have recently been successful in relativistic quantum field theory. First the spectrum conditions for an infinitely extended system are given and the algebra of observables and the algebra of field operators are defined. General properties of states over these algebras are discussed and theorems are given which connect the linked cluster property, translation invariance and the purity of the states. It is proved that pure states over the algebra of observables have the property of factorisable off-diagonal long range order. The class of quasi free states is defined and of these states those which are translation invariant and possess the linked cluster property are analysed. It is shown that this class of states contains a subclass of pure states of the Bogoliubov type and a subclass of states which are mixtures of non-translationally invariant pure states. The applications of these quasi free states to the interacting Bose gas are summarized.     

Sampling in holography of diffused objects or with diffused illumination

Differentiation between a diffused hologram and a specular hologram is determined by criteria of the wavelength and the relief of the object. In a hologram where the object beam is diffused (due to diffused object illumination, or because the object surface is reflecting diffusively), every part in the holographic plane contains information about the whole object, but from a different angle of view. In a specular hologram, the recording is somewhere between the image recording and the diffused holography. The latter part is contributed mainly by the edges of the object.This paper describes properties of sampled diffused holograms in terms of resolution,S/N (contrast), angle of view, power spectrum and the ability of determination of the object.Different sampling functions are compared and experimentally examined, while the total diffracting areas are preserved constant.It was found that when the sampling areas were distributed over the entire plane and the observation distance was preserved, the resolution, the angle of view and the ability of determination of the object was close to the unsampled hologram. At the same conditions theS/N and the power spectrum were reduced.It seems that these techniques of sampling may be applied for multiplexing, subtracting and correlating between two adjacent recordings.     

Crossing relations derived from (Extended) Relativity

Recently, Special Relativity has been straightforwardly extended to Superluminal inertial frames and faster-than-light objects. The Extended Relativity theory not only allowed building up a self-consistent classical theory of tachyons, but reveals itself useful also for the understanding of standard (subluminal) physics, i.e. of usual particles. In this paper, it is shown that Extended Relativity allows: (i) deriving the usual Crossing Relations of elementary particle (high-energy) physics; and (ii) deriving the CPT-covariance theorem as a particular case of G-covariance (i.e., covariance under the new group of Generalised Lorentz transformations, both subluminal and Superluminal).In this framework, the Analyticity postulate is unnecessary: it is better substituted by the G-covariance requirement.Moreover, new crossing-type relations are predicted on the basis of mere Extended Relativity. They may well serve as a test for relativistic covariance of force fields like strong interactions and, particularly, weak interactions, and possible new interaction fields (whicha priori are not relativistically covariant).     

Rational forms for twistings of enveloping algebras of simple Lie algebras

We give rational forms for twistings of classical enveloping algebras. We also remark a link with the generalized formalism of Gurevich, Manin, and Cartier.     

Integrable hierarchy underlying topological Landau-Ginzburg models of D-type

A universal integrable hierarchy underlying topological Landau-Ginzburg models of D-type is presented. Like the dispersionless Toda hierarchy, the new hierarchy has two distinct (positive and negative) sets of flows. Special solutions corresponding to topological Landau-Ginzburg models of D-type are characterized by a Riemann-Hilbert problem, which can be converted into a generalized hodograph transformation. This construction gives an embedding of the finite-dimensional small phase space of these models into the full space of flows of this hierarchy. One of flat coordinates in the small phase space turns out to be identical to the first negative time variable of the hierarchy, whereas the others belong to the positive flows.     

Surface topology investigation for ancient coinage assessment using optical interferometry

In order to demonstrate the capabilities of white-light interferometry depth profiling (WLI-DP) for ancient coinage assessment, we investigated a series of notorious 1786 gold coins, bearing Louis XVIs horned effigy, and allegedly minted in Strasbourg. Scanning electron microscopy as well as WLI-DP observations unambiguously indicate that both previously differentiated single- and double-horned varieties originated from a unique minting tool. Moreover, from topological measurements, we infer that single-horned coins, rather than wearing out into double-horned coins, proceeded from the latter variety during minting by progressive failure of an already altered die. Whereas present observations do not exclude initial forgery, they suggest that protrusions resulted from progressive incidental in-service die deterioration. PACS 81.70.Fy; 07.60.Ly; 61.16.Bg; 81.40.Pq     

The many faces of a character

We prove an identity between three infinite families of polynomials which are defined in terms of bosonic, fermionic, and one-dimensional configuration sums. In the limit where the polynomials become infinite series, they give different-looking expressions for the characters of the two integrable representations of the affine su(2) algebra at level one. We conjecture yet another fermionic sum representation for the polynomials which is constructed directly from the Bethe-ansatz solution of the Heisenberg spin chain.     

Faux-boolean algebras,classical probability,and determinism

It is possible to define, for any quantum system, an algebra of definite-valued events—those events that are definitely occurrent or non-occurrent. It is shown that two different sets of constraints on the algebra of definite-valued events are each equivalent to the definition of that set as a certain pseudo-Boolean algebra.     

A note on a paper by Atkin and Bastin

The paper A Homological Foundation for Scale Problems in Physics (Atkin & Bastin, 1970) is criticised on account of several inconsistencies in the argument. Possible applications of the general ideas used are then discussed in the context of a quantum logic type of framework.     

Ultrageneralised complex analysis

The zero rest mass Euclidean Dirac equations in 2 (4) dimensions may be regarded as square roots of the second order harmonic equation, and give rise to the crucial integral theorem and integral formula of complex (quaternionic) analysis. Recently discovered 2rth root equations for the 2rth order harmonic equations are here shown to give rise to a similar integral theorem and integral formula.     

Long-lived fluorescence probes for studying lipid dynamics: A review

A great many studies have focused on the heterogeneous packing of lipids in the bilayer matrix. However, less attention has been directed toward the temporal aspects of these lipid-lipid interactions. Studies of lipid packing fluctuations, or gel-fluid exchange, using fluorescence probe methodologies have been limited. This limitation arises from thesubmicrosecond time scale over which the fluctuations are expected to occur. Traditionally, dynamic studies of lipid bilayers have been restricted to the nanosecond time regime, and the submicrosecond time window has not been explored in any great depth by fluorescence methods, although persistent lipid dynamics has been evident. Probes with long fluorescence lifetimes (several hundred nanoseconds) have the potential to expand this important time window, providing information on gel-fluid exchange rates and insights into how important biological effectors such as proteins, cholesterol, and anesthetics affect or modulate these fluctuations. Using the long-lived fluorescence probe coronene, combined with time-resolved fluorescence methods geared toward microheterogeneity, we present a view of bilayer dynamics in an alternate time domain. Fluorescence probes are expected to inhabit an equilibrium between fluid and gel environments. Some probes remain in their respective environments throughout their excited-state lifetime, while others reside in surroundings that will change (i.e., melt). Long-lived fluorescence membrane probes can provide direct estimates of submicrosecond lipid fluctuation or melt rates. Simple Landau modeling leads to adistribution of melt rates and provides an attractive alternative to a simplercompartmental model where a unique lipid fluctuation of gel-fluid exchange rate is measured. Thedistribution model is probe independent (defined by thermodynamic quantities) and can be applied generally to the rotational motions of fluorescence probes embedded in the lipid bilayer.Abbreviations DMPC l--dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine - DPH 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene - DPPC l--dipalmitoylphospha-tidylcholine - DSC differential scanning calorimetry - EA fluorescence emission anisotropy - LUV large unilamellar vesicles - SUV small unilamellar vesicles - T_c lipid phase transition temperature     

Current controlled negative resistance phenomenon in SbPbSe system

Thin film Al/Sb₂Pb₁Se₇/Al metal-glass-metal sandwiched structures prepared using thermal evaporation technique have been studied. The I–V measurements showed that the devices switched from high resistance OFF state to a low resistance ON state when a particular voltage appeared across it. The OFF state I–V characteristics showed non-ohmic behaviour while in the ON state the devices displayed purely linear characteristics. The switching voltage (V _th) was found to depend on film thickness and temperature of the device. A linear relation between V_th and temperature was observed.     

Dual pairs of quantum spaces

We discuss the notion of metric dual pair corresponding to the algebraic condition in Alain Connes' definition of noncommutative Poincaré duality. We show that the DeRham complex of a metric dual pair is the homomorphic image of a skew tensor product, this leading to a natural definition of biconnections.