Distribution modeling for reliability analysis: Impact of multiple dependences and probability model selection

Reliability analysis requires modeling of joint probability distribution of uncertain parameters, which can be a challenge since the random variables representing the parameter uncertainties may be correlated. For convenience, a Gaussian data dependence is commonly assumed for correlated random variables. This paper first investigates the effect of multidimensional non-Gaussian data dependences underlying the multivariate probability distribution on reliability results. Using different bivariate copulas in a vine structure, various data dependences can be modeled. The associated copula parameters are identified from available statistical information by moment matching techniques. After the development of the vine copula model for representing the multivariate probability distribution, the reliability involving correlated random variables is evaluated based on the Rosenblatt transformation. The impact of data dependence is significant because a large deviation in failure probability is observed, which emphasizes the need for accurate dependence characterization. A practical method for dependence modeling based on limited data is thus provided. The result demonstrates that the non-Gaussian data dependences can be real in practice, and the reliability can be biased if the Gaussian dependence is used inappropriately. Moreover, the effect of conditioning order on reliability should not be overlooked except that the vine structure contains only one type of copula.     

Construction of asymmetric multivariate copulas

In this paper we introduce two methods for the construction of asymmetric multivariate copulas. The first is connected with products of copulas. The second approach generalises the Archimedean copulas. The resulting copulas are asymmetric and may have more than two parameters in contrast to most of the parametric families of copulas described in the literature. We study the properties of the proposed families of copulas such as the dependence of two components (Kendall’s tau, tail dependence), marginal distributions and the generation of random variates.     

Modelling dependence

A new way of choosing a suitable copula to model dependence is introduced. Instead of relying on a given parametric family of copulas or applying the other extreme of modelling dependence in a nonparametric way, an intermediate approach is proposed, based on a sequence of parametric models containing more and more dependency aspects. In contrast to a similar way of thinking in testing theory, the method here, intended for estimating the copula, often requires a somewhat larger number of steps. One approach is based on exponential families, another on contamination families. An extensive numerical investigation is supplied on a large number of well-known copulas. The method based on contamination families is recommended. A Gaussian start in this approximation looks very promising.     

Validation of positive quadrant dependence

Quadrant dependence is a useful dependence notion of two random variables, widely applied in reliability, insurance and actuarial sciences. The interest in this dependence structure ranges from modeling it, throughout measuring its strength and investigations on how increasing the dependence effects of several reliability and economic indexes, to hypothesis testing on the dependence. In this paper, we focus on testing for positive quadrant dependence. We propose two new tests for verifying positive quadrant dependence. We prove novel results on finite sample behavior of power function of one of the proposed tests as well as evaluate and compare the two new solutions with the best existing ones, via a simulation study. These comparisons demonstrate that the new solutions are slightly weaker in detecting positive quadrant dependence modeled by classical bivariate models and outperform the best existing solutions when some mixtures, regression and heavy-tailed models have to be detected. Finally, the methods introduced in the paper are applied to real life insurance data, to assess the dependence and test them for positive quadrant dependence.     

Efficient algorithms for basket default swap pricing with multivariate Archimedean copulas

We introduce a new importance sampling method for pricing basket default swaps employing exchangeable Archimedean copulas and nested Gumbel copulas. We establish more realistic dependence structures than existing copula models for credit risks in the underlying portfolio, and propose an appropriate density for importance sampling by analyzing multivariate Archimedean copulas. To justify efficiency and accuracy of the proposed algorithms, we present numerical examples and compare them with the crude Monte Carlo simulation, and finally show that our proposed estimators produce considerably smaller variances.     

An order of asymmetry in copulas,and implications for risk management

We study symmetry properties of bivariate copulas. For this, we introduce an order of asymmetry, as well as measures of asymmetry which are monotone in that order. In an empirical study, we illustrate that asymmetric dependence structures do indeed occur in financial market data and discuss its relevance for financial risk management.     

半参数阿基米德Copula的实证研究

半参数阿基米德Copula族的生成元可由现有阿基米德Copula生成元得到,由于有独特的构造方式,该Copula族具有灵活的相关结构,能"自适应"地描述数据中包含的相关结构.外汇市场的实证分析证实了该Copula族在描述相关结构时的灵活性,对选择何种Copula描述金融资产间的相关结构有一定的参考意义.     

Distorted Mix Method for constructing copulas with tail dependence

This paper introduces a method for constructing copula functions by combining the ideas of distortion and convex sum, named Distorted Mix Method. The method mixes different copulas with distorted margins to construct new copula functions, and it enables us to model the dependence structure of risks by handling the central and tail parts separately. By applying the method we can modify the tail dependence of a given copula to any desired level measured by tail dependence function and tail dependence coefficients of marginal distributions. As an application, a tight bound for asymptotic Value-at-Risk of order statistics is obtained by using the method. An empirical study shows that copulas constructed by this method fit the empirical data of SPX 500 Index and FTSE 100 Index very well in both central and tail parts.     

A generalized beta copula with applications in modeling multivariate long-tailed data

This work proposes a new copula class that we call the MGB2 copula. The new copula originates from extracting the dependence function of the multivariate GB2 distribution (MGB2) whose marginals follow the univariate generalized beta distribution of the second kind (GB2). The MGB2 copula can capture non-elliptical and asymmetric dependencies among marginal coordinates and provides a simple formulation for multi-dimensional applications. This new class features positive tail dependence in the upper tail and tail independence in the lower tail. Furthermore, it includes some well-known copula classes, such as the Gaussian copula, as special or limiting cases.To illustrate the usefulness of the MGB2 copula, we build a trivariate MGB2 copula model of bodily injury liability closed claims. Extended GB2 distributions are chosen to accommodate the right-skewness and the long-tailedness of the outcome variables. For the regression component, location parameters with continuous predictors are introduced using a nonlinear additive function. For comparison purposes, we also consider the Gumbel and t copulas, alternatives that capture the upper tail dependence. The paper introduces a conditional plot graphical tool for assessing the validation of the MGB2 copula. Quantitative and graphical assessment of the goodness of fit demonstrate the advantages of the MGB2 copula over the other copulas.     

Tail negative dependence and its applications for aggregate loss modeling

Tail order of copulas can be used to describe the strength of dependence in the tails of a joint distribution. When the value of tail order is larger than the dimension, it may lead to tail negative dependence. First, we prove results on conditions that lead to tail negative dependence for Archimedean copulas. Using the conditions, we construct new parametric copula families that possess upper tail negative dependence. Among them, a copula based on a scale mixture with a generalized gamma random variable (GGS copula) is useful for modeling asymmetric tail negative dependence. We propose mixed copula regression based on the GGS copula for aggregate loss modeling of a medical expenditure panel survey dataset. For this dataset, we find that there exists upper tail negative dependence between loss frequency and loss severity, and the introduction of tail negative dependence structures significantly improves the aggregate loss modeling.     

Approximation of bivariate copulas by patched bivariate Fréchet copulas

Bivariate Fréchet (BF) copulas characterize dependence as a mixture of three simple structures: comonotonicity, independence and countermonotonicity. They are easily interpretable but have limitations when used as approximations to general dependence structures. To improve the approximation property of the BF copulas and keep the advantage of easy interpretation, we develop a new copula approximation scheme by using BF copulas locally and patching the local pieces together. Error bounds and a probabilistic interpretation of this approximation scheme are developed. The new approximation scheme is compared with several existing copula approximations, including shuffle of min, checkmin, checkerboard and Bernstein approximations and exhibits better performance, especially in characterizing the local dependence. The utility of the new approximation scheme in insurance and finance is illustrated in the computation of the rainbow option prices and stop-loss premiums.     

A class of multivariate copulas with bivariate Fréchet marginal copulas

In this paper, we present a class of multivariate copulas whose two-dimensional marginals belong to the family of bivariate Fréchet copulas. The coordinates of a random vector distributed as one of these copulas are conditionally independent. We prove that these multivariate copulas are uniquely determined by their two-dimensional marginal copulas. Some other properties for these multivariate copulas are discussed as well. Two applications of these copulas in actuarial science are given.     

A practical non-parametric copula algorithm for system reliability with correlations

System reliability analysis involving correlated random variables is challenging because the failure probability cannot be uniquely determined under the given probability information. This paper proposes a system reliability evaluation method based on non-parametric copulas. The approximated joint probability distribution satisfying the constraints specified by correlations has the maximal relative entropy with respect to the joint probability distribution of independent random variables. Thus the reliability evaluation is unbiased from the perspective of information theory. The estimation of the non-parametric copula parameters from Pearson linear correlation, Spearman rank correlation, and Kendall rank correlation are provided, respectively. The approximated maximum entropy distribution is then integrated with the first and second order system reliability method. Four examples are adopted to illustrate the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed method. It is found that traditional system reliability method encodes excessive dependence information for correlated random variables and the estimated failure probability can be significantly biased.     

From Archimedean to Liouville copulas

We use a recent characterization of the d-dimensional Archimedean copulas as the survival copulas of d-dimensional simplex distributions (McNeil and Nešlehová (2009) [1]) to construct new Archimedean copula families, and to examine the relationship between their dependence properties and the radial parts of the corresponding simplex distributions. In particular, a new formula for Kendall’s tau is derived and a new dependence ordering for non-negative random variables is introduced which generalises the Laplace transform order. We then generalise the Archimedean copulas to obtain Liouville copulas, which are the survival copulas of Liouville distributions and which are non-exchangeable in general. We derive a formula for Kendall’s tau of Liouville copulas in terms of the radial parts of the corresponding Liouville distributions.     

Asymmetric extreme interdependence in emerging equity markets

We assess the extent of integration between stock markets during stressful periods using the concept of copulas. Our methodology consists of fitting copulas to simultaneous exceedances of high thresholds, and computing copula‐based measures of interdependence and contagion. Using 21 pairs of emerging stock markets daily returns, we investigate if dependence increases with crisis, and analyse the chances of both markets crashing together. Dependence at joint positive and negative extreme returns levels may differ. This type of asymmetry is captured by the upper and lower tail dependence coefficients. Propagation of crisis may be faster in one direction, and this feature is captured by asymmetric copulas. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Discussion of “Copulas: Tales and facts”, by Thomas Mikosch

As Prof. Mikosch correctly points out, there exists very little sound statistical theory on modelling dependence using copulas. In this contribution, an open problem is presented concerning the efficient estimation of the parameter of a copula when no parametric assumptions are made regarding the marginal distributions.     

基于双参数Copula沪港股市的相关性分析

通过双参数Copula分析上证指数和恒生指数的尾部相关性,并与单参数Copula及混合Copula进行比较分析,参数估计使用半参数估计法,结果表明:与单参数Clayton Copula、Gumbel-Hougaard Copula以及由两者组成的混合Copula相比,双参数BB1 Copula对数据具有更好的拟合效果;且通过分析发现两股市的上尾相关性大于下尾相关性.     

Estimating standard errors in regular vine copula models

We describe a new algorithm for the computation of the score function and observed information in regular vine (R-vine) copula models. R-vine copulas are constructed hierarchically from bivariate copulas as building blocks only, and the algorithm exploits this hierarchical nature for subsequent computation of log-likelihood derivatives. This allows to routinely estimate standard errors of parameter estimates, and overcomes reliability and accuracy issues associated with numerical differentiation in multidimensional models. Results obtained using the proposed methods are discussed in the context of the asymptotic efficiency of different estimation methods and of an application to exchange rate data.     

Tail order and intermediate tail dependence of multivariate copulas

In order to study copula families that have tail patterns and tail asymmetry different from multivariate Gaussian and t copulas, we introduce the concepts of tail order and tail order functions. These provide an integrated way to study both tail dependence and intermediate tail dependence. Some fundamental properties of tail order and tail order functions are obtained. For the multivariate Archimedean copula, we relate the tail heaviness of a positive random variable to the tail behavior of the Archimedean copula constructed from the Laplace transform of the random variable, and extend the results of Charpentier and Segers [7] [A. Charpentier, J. Segers, Tails of multivariate Archimedean copulas, Journal of Multivariate Analysis 100 (7) (2009) 1521–1537] for upper tails of Archimedean copulas. In addition, a new one-parameter Archimedean copula family based on the Laplace transform of the inverse Gamma distribution is proposed; it possesses patterns of upper and lower tails not seen in commonly used copula families. Finally, tail orders are studied for copulas constructed from mixtures of max-infinitely divisible copulas.     

Lower tail dependence for Archimedean copulas: Characterizations and pitfalls

Tail dependence copulas provide a natural perspective from which one can study the dependence in the tail of a multivariate distribution. For Archimedean copulas with continuously differentiable generators, regular variation of the generator near the origin is known to be closely connected to convergence of the lower tail dependence copulas to the Clayton copula. In this paper, these characterizations are refined and extended to the case of generators which are not necessarily continuously differentiable. Moreover, a counterexample is constructed showing that even if the generator of a strict Archimedean copula is continuously differentiable and slowly varying at the origin, then the lower tail dependence copulas still do not need to converge to the independent copula.