Investigating changes in high-stakes mathematics examinations: a discursive approach

ABSTRACT

This article focuses on the theoretical-methodological question of how to identify reform-induced changes in school mathematics. The issue arose in our project The Evolution of the Discourse of School Mathematics (EDSM), in which we studied transformations in high-stakes examinations taken by students in England at the end of compulsory schooling. We have adopted a conceptualisation that draws on social semiotics and on a communicational approach, according to which school mathematics can be thought of as a discourse. Methods of comparing examinations of different years developed on the basis of this definition enable identification of subtle disparities that are nevertheless significant enough to make an important difference in students’ vision of mathematics, in their performance and, eventually, in their ability to cope with problems that can benefit from the use of mathematics. In this article, we present these methods and argue that they have wider application for comparative studies of school mathematics.     

Turnaround Students in High School Mathematics: Constructing Identities of Competence Through Mathematical Worlds

This study investigates prospective secondary teachers’ cognitive difficulties and mathematical ideas involved in making connections among representations. We implemented a three-week teaching unit to help prospective secondary mathematics teachers develop understanding of big ideas that are critical to formulating connections among representations, in the context of conic curves. Qualitative analysis of data showed that most undergraduate mathematics majors and minors in this study struggled with variation, the Cartesian Connection, and other affiliated ideas such as graph as a locus of points. Furthermore, they were unable to identify basic metric relations encoded in algebraic expressions such as the distance between points, which further compounded their difficulties in making connections among representations. We argue that mathematics teacher education needs more focus on these ideas so that their graduates can successfully teach these big ideas in their future instruction.     

To what extent are students expected to participate in specialised mathematical discourse? Change over time in school mathematics in England

ABSTRACT

From a discursive perspective, differences in the language in which mathematics questions are posed change the nature of the mathematics with which students are expected to engage. The project The Evolution of the Discourse of School Mathematics (EDSM) analysed the discourse of mathematics examination papers set in the UK between 1980 and 2011. In this article we address the issue of how students over this period have been expected to engage with the specialised discourse of school mathematics. We explain our analytic methods and present some outcomes of the analysis. We identify changes in engagement with algebraic manipulation, proving, relating mathematics to non-mathematical contexts and making connections between specialised mathematical objects. These changes are discussed in the light of public and policy domain debates about ‘standards’ of examinations.     

Measurement as relational,intensive and analogical: Towards a minor mathematics

Minor mathematics refers to the mathematical practices that are often erased by state-sanctioned curricular images of mathematics. We use the idea of a minor mathematics to explore alternative measurement practices. We argue that minor measurement practices have been buried by a ‘major’ settler mathematics, a process of erasure that distributes ‘sensibility’ and formulates conditions of mathematics dis/ability. We emphasize how measuring involves the making and mixing of analogies, and that this involves attending to intensive relationships rather than extensive properties. Our philosophical and historical approach moves from the archeological origins of human measurement activity, to pivotal developments in modern mathematics, to configurations of curriculum. We argue that the project of proliferating multiple mathematics is required in order to disturb narrow (and perhaps white, western, male) images of mathematics—and to open up opportunities for a more pluralist and inclusive school mathematics.     

Using Primary Source Projects to teach undergraduate mathematics content: analysis of instructor implementation and perceptions

ABSTRACT

This study investigates changes in instructor teaching tendencies, instructor’s perception of impact on student learning and dispositions, and methods of implementation of Primary Source Projects (PSPs). PSPs are curricular modules designed to teach core mathematical topics from primary historical sources rather than from standard textbooks. In essence, they are a form of inquiry-based learning that incorporates the history of mathematics through original source texts. We provide an overview of results from two semesters of implementation reports and surveys administered at the beginning and end of the semester by instructors who implemented PSPs in their undergraduate mathematics classes.     

Representational disfluency in algebra: evidence from student gestures and speech

In this investigation, we analyzed US middle school students’ (grades 6–8) gestures and speech during interviews to understand students’ reasoning while interpreting quantitative patterns represented by Cartesian graphs. We studied students’ representational fluency, defined as their abilities to work within and translate among representations. While students translated across representations to address task demands, they also translated to a different representation when reaching an impasse, where the initial representation could not be used to answer a task. During these impasse events, which we call representational disfluencies, three categories of behavior were observed. Some students perceived the graph to be bounded by its physical and numerical limits, and these students were categorized as physically grounded. A second, related, disfluency was categorized as spatially grounded. Students who were classified as spatially grounded exhibited a bounded view of the graph that limited their ability to make far predictions until they physically altered the spatial configuration of the graph by rescaling or extending the axes. Finally, students who recovered from one or more of these disfluencies by translating the quantitative information to alternative but equivalent representations (i.e., exhibiting representational fluency), while retaining the connection back to the linear pattern as graphed, were categorized as interpretatively grounded. Understanding the causes and varieties of representational fluency and disfluency contributes directly to our understanding of mathematics knowledge, learning and adaptive forms of reasoning. These findings also provide implications for mathematics instruction and assessment.     

Time for telling stories: narrative thinking with dynamic geometry

In his work on human cognition, Bruner (The culture of education, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 1996) distinguishes between narrative and paradigmatic modes of thinking. While the latter is closely associated with mathematics, Bruner’s writings suggest that the former contributes non-trivially to the learning of mathematics. In this paper, we argue that the very nature of dynamic mathematical representations—being intrinsically temporal, occurring over time—offer very different opportunities for narrative thinking than do the static diagrams and pictures traditionally available to learners. Using examples from our research, we analyse these opportunities both in terms of their potential for enhancing understanding and for their relation to the kind of paradigmatic thinking that usually constitutes mathematical knowledge.     

When time is an implicit variable: An investigation of students’ ways of understanding graphing tasks

In this study, we investigate students’ ways of understanding graphing tasks involving quantitative relationships in which time functions as an implicit variable. Through task-based interviews of students ages 14–16 in a summer mathematics program, we observe a variety of ways of understanding, including thematic or visual association, pointwise thinking, and reasoning parametrically about changes in the two variables to be graphed. We argue that, rather than comprising a hierarchy, these ways of understanding complement one another in helping students discover an invariant relationship between two dynamically varying quantities, and develop a graph of the relationship that captures this invariance. From these ways of understanding, we conjecture several mathematical meanings for graphing that may account for students’ behavior when graphing quantitative relationships.     

Effectively coaching middle school teachers: A case for teacher and student learning

In this paper we report findings from a two-year, large-scale research project that describes the work of middle school mathematics specialists (also referred to as mathematics coaches or instructional coaches) who served in 10 school districts. We use mixed methods to describe how mathematics specialists spent their time supporting teachers and how these supports contributed to meaningful changes that teachers made in their instructional practices. We also report results that correlate student achievement scores with whether or not teachers were highly engaged with the mathematics specialists. We coordinate these quantitative results with findings from several case studies to illustrate the qualitatively different ways that mathematics specialists supported teachers’ ongoing work with their students. We also account for why some teachers participated more fully than others. Importantly, because mathematics specialists’ work was situated in different school settings with different demands, resources and administrative supports, these constraints and affordances contributed in part to how they could effectively support teachers’ work with their students.     

Changing students’ beliefs about the relevance of mathematics in an advanced secondary mathematics class

ABSTRACT

This study shows that using authentic contexts for learning differential equations in a differentiation-by-interest setting can enhance students’ beliefs about the relevance of mathematics. The students in this study were studying advanced mathematics (wiskunde D) at upper secondary school in the Netherlands. These students are often not aware of the relevance of the mathematics they have to learn in school. More insights into the application of mathematics in other sciences can be beneficial for these students in terms of preparation for their future study and career. A course differentiating by student interest with new context-rich curriculum materials was developed in order to enhance students’ beliefs about the relevance of mathematics. The intervention aimed at teaching differential equations through guided small-group tasks in scientific, medical or economical contexts. The results show that students’ beliefs about the relevance of mathematics improved, and they appreciated experiencing how the mathematics was applied in real-life situations.     

Variations on a theme: introducing new representations of fraction into two classrooms

Abstract

The interplay between generalisations and particular instances—examples—is an essential feature of mathematics teaching and learning. In this paper, we bring together our experiences of personal and classroom mathematics activity, and demonstrate that examples do not always fulfil their intended purpose (to point to generalisations). A distinction is drawn between ‘empirical’ and ‘structural’ generalisation, and the role of generic examples is discussed as a means of supporting the second of these qualities of generalisation.     

Re-sourcing teachers’ work and interactions: a collective perspective on resources, their use and transformation

This paper reviews the literature on the theme of mathematics teachers’ work and interactions with resources, taking a particular perspective, the so-called ‘collective perspective’ on resources, their use and transformation. The review is presented under three headings: (1) theoretical frameworks commonly used in this area of research; (2) teachers’ interactions with resources in terms of their design and use; and (3) teachers’ interactions with resources in terms of teacher learning and professional development. From the literature, and the collection of papers in this issue, we argue that the collective dimensions play an important role in mathematics teachers’ work with resources and in their professional learning/development. Further empirical investigations are likely to be needed on: how teachers may work in collectives and with resources, and in which ways ‘productive’ collectives may form and work together; which roles particular resources can play in these delicate constellations and how particular resources may support teachers in their work and learning; and which kinds of resources offer opportunities for community building.     

Professional Development Strategically Connecting Mathematics and Science: The Impact on Teachers' Confidence and Practice

The press to integrate mathematics and science comes from researchers, business leaders, and educators, yet research that examines ways to support teachers in relating these disciplines is scant. Using research on science and mathematics professional development, we designed a professional development project to help elementary teachers improve their teaching of mathematics and science by strategically connecting these disciplines. The purposes of this study are: (a) to identify changes in teachers' confidence and practice after participating in the professional development and (b) to identify different ways to connect mathematics and science during the professional development. We use a Likert‐scale survey to assess changes in teachers' confidence related to teaching mathematics and science. In addition, we report on a thematic analysis of teachers' written responses to open‐ended questions that probed teachers' perceived changes in practice. We analyze field notes from observations of project workshops to document different types of opportunities for connecting mathematics and science. We conclude with implications for future professional development that connects mathematics and science in meaningful ways, as well as suggestions for future research.     

Relationships between emotional dispositions and mathematics achievement moderated by instructional practices: analysis of TIMSS 2015

ABSTRACT

This research is a secondary analysis with Korean students’ data collected in the TIMSS 2015 to describe the moderation effects of instructional practices on the relationships between students’ emotional dispositions toward mathematics and mathematics achievement. From the TIMSS 2015 database, we collected mathematics achievement scores, a student-level contextual scale for students’ emotional disposition, and teacher-level contextual scales representing teachers’ instructional practices. We applied hierarchical linear modelling to construct multilevel models. The findings showed that the achievement gap between emotional dispositions – like and dislike – became smaller when teachers more frequently implemented certain instructional practices like asking students to complete challenging exercises, decide their own problem-solving procedures, and express their ideas in class. Students who disliked mathematics were likely to have higher scores as their teachers implemented each of those practices more frequently. Findings provide important implications to teachers regarding: It is important to encourage students to reason through instructional practices like asking them to decide their own problem-solving procedures and to solve challenging problems.     

Mathematics teachers’ views about the limited utility of real analysis: A transport model hypothesis

In the United States and elsewhere, prospective teachers of secondary mathematics are usually required to complete numerous advanced mathematics courses before obtaining certification. However, several research studies suggest that teachers’ experiences in these advanced mathematics courses have little influence on their pedagogical practice and efficacy. To understand this phenomenon, we presented 14 secondary mathematics teachers with four statements and proofs in real analysis that related to secondary content and asked the participants to discuss whether these proofs could inform their teaching of secondary mathematics. In analyzing participants’ remarks, we propose that many teachers view the utility of real analysis in secondary school mathematics teaching using a transport model, where the perceived importance of a real analysis explanation is dependent upon the teacher’s ability to transport that explanation directly into their instruction in a secondary mathematics classroom. Consequently, their perceived value of a real analysis course in their teacher preparation is inherently limited. We discuss implications of the transport model on secondary mathematics teacher education.     

The Hilbert Series of the Face Ring of a Flag Complex

 It is shown that the Hilbert series of the face ring of a clique complex (equivalently, flag complex) of a graph G is, up to a factor, just a specialization of , the subgraph polynomial of the complement of G. We also find a simple relationship between the size of a minimum vertex cover of a graph G and its subgraph polynomial. This yields a formula for the h-vector of the flag complex in terms of those two invariants of . Some computational issues are addressed and a recursive formula for the Hilbert series is given based on an algorithm of Bayer and Stillman. Received: December 10, 1999 Acknowledgments. I would like to thank Rick Wilson and the mathematics department of the California Institute of Technology for their kind hospitality, and Richard Stanley for pointing out an error in an earlier draft.     

Compensations in the Shapley value and the compensation solutions for graph games

We consider an alternative expression of the Shapley value that reveals a system of compensations: each player receives an equal share of the worth of each coalition he belongs to, and has to compensate an equal share of the worth of any coalition he does not belong to. We give a representation in terms of formation of the grand coalition according to an ordering of the players and define the corresponding compensation vector. Then, we generalize this idea to cooperative games with a communication graph in order to construct new allocation rules called the compensation solutions. Firstly, we consider cooperative games with arbitrary graphs and construct rooted spanning trees (see Demange, J Political Econ 112:754–778, 2004) instead of orderings of the players by using the classical algorithms DFS and BFS. If the graph is complete, we show that the compensation solutions associated with DFS and BFS coincide with the Shapley value and the equal surplus division respectively. Secondly, we consider cooperative games with a forest (cycle-free graph) and all its rooted spanning trees. The compensation solution is characterized by component efficiency and relative fairness. The latter axiom takes into account the relative position of a player with respect to his component in the communication graph.     

Mathematics in engineering programs: what teachers with different academic and professional backgrounds bring to the table. An institutional analysis

ABSTRACT

In this paper, we examine how differences in the academic and professional backgrounds of engineering teachers shape their personal relationship to the use of mathematics in engineering practices, and whether these differences affect some of their practices. The analyses herein are based on an institutional perspective and employ Chevallard's anthropological theory of the didactic (ATD). We interviewed two teachers in an engineering programme to identify specific elements of their practice that could be attributable to the mobilisation of knowledge and skills derived from their distinct academic backgrounds and experience. The results indicate that the teachers mobilise different tasks, techniques, and technologies in many of their practices, and that they take different approaches to using mathematics and applying rigour.     

Visage—Visualization of algorithms in discrete mathematics

Which route should the garbage collectors' truck take? Just a simple question, but also the starting point of an exciting mathematics class. The only “hardware” you need is a city map, given on a sheet of paper or on the computer screen. Then lively discussions will take place in the classroom on how to find an optimal routing for the truck. The aim of this activity is to develop an algorithm that constructs Eulerian tours in graphs and to learn about graphs and their properties. This teaching sequence, and those stemming from discrete mathematics, in particular combinatorial optimization, are ideal for training problem solving skills and modeling—general competencies that, influenced by the German National Standards, are finding their way into curricula. In this article, we investigate how computers can help in providing individual teaching tools for students. Within the Visage project we focus on electronic activities that can enhance explorations with graphs and guide studients even if the teacher is not available—without taking away freedom and creativity. The software package is embedded into a standard DGS, and it offers many pre-built and teacher-customizable tools in the area of graph algorithms. Until now, there are no complete didactical concepts for teaching graph algorithms, in particular using new media. We see a huge potential in our methods, and the topic is highly requested on part of the teachers, as it introduces a modern and highly relevant part of mathematics into the curriculum.