A quantitative analysis of children's splitting operations and fraction schemes

Teaching experiments with pairs of children have generated several hypotheses about students’ construction of fractions. For example, Steffe (2004) hypothesized that robust conceptions of improper fractions depends on the development of a splitting operation. Results from teaching experiments that rely on scheme theory and Steffe's hierarchy of fraction schemes imply additional hypotheses, such as the idea that the schemes do indeed form a hierarchy. Our study constitutes the first attempt to test these hypotheses and substantiate Steffe's claims using quantitative methods. We analyze data from 84 students’ performances on written tests, in order to measure students’ development of the splitting operation and construction of fraction schemes. Our findings align with many of the hypotheses implied by teaching experiments and, additionally, suggest that students’ construction of a partitive fraction scheme facilitates the development of splitting.     

Mathematics teachers’ conceptions about modelling activities and its reflection on their beliefs about mathematics

The current study examines whether the engagement of mathematics teachers in modelling activities and subsequent changes in their conceptions about these activities affect their beliefs about mathematics. The sample comprised 52 mathematics teachers working in small groups in four modelling activities. The data were collected from teachers' Reports about features of each activity, interviews and questionnaires on teachers' beliefs about mathematics. The findings indicated changes in teachers' conceptions about the modelling activities. Most teachers referred to the first activity as a mathematical problem but emphasized only the mathematical notions or the mathematical operations in the modelling process; changes in their conceptions were gradual. Most of the teachers referred to the fourth activity as a mathematical problem and emphasized features of the whole modelling process. The results of the interviews indicated that changes in the teachers' conceptions can be attributed to structure of the activities, group discussions, solution paths and elicited models. These changes about modelling activities were reflected in teachers' beliefs about mathematics. The quantitative findings indicated that the teachers developed more constructive beliefs about mathematics after engagement in the modelling activities and that the difference was significant, however there was no significant difference regarding changes in their traditional beliefs.     

Accurate and Inaccurate Conceptions About Osmosis That Accompanied Meaningful Problem Solving

This study focused on the knowledge of six outstanding science students who solved an osmosis problem meaningfully. That is, they used appropriate and substantially accurate conceptual knowledge to generate an answer. Three generated a correct answer; three, an incorrect answer. This paper identifies both the accurate and inaccurate conceptions about osmosis of each correct and incorrect solver. The investigation consisted of a presolving clinical interview, think-aloud solving of the problem, and retrospective report of the solving. Of the 12 accurate conceptions identified here, two were especially important in enabling these solvers to generate a correct answer. Of the 8 inaccurate conceptions, either of 2 blocked a correct answer. Four, however, accompanied (and could therefore be concealed by) a correct answer. Teachers could use this information to make a meaningful solving of this problem accessible to more students and to identify more effectively students' inaccurate conceptions about osmosis.     

Making sense of instruction on fractions when a student lacks necessary fractional schemes: The case of Tim

This paper critically examines the discrepancies among the pre-requisite fractional concepts assumed by a curricular unit on operations with fractions, the teacher's assumptions about those concepts and a particular student's understanding of fractions. The paper focuses on the case of one student (Tim) in the teacher's 6th grade class who was interviewed by one of the authors once a week during the teaching of the unit. The teaching materials and the teacher's instruction were based on the assumption that students understood the concept of a unit fraction as being one of several equal parts of a given whole. The teacher neither emphasized the need for equal parts nor the part-to-whole relation. The teacher's reasonable assumptions about her students’ understanding of fractions were severely challenged by the cognitive constructs that Tim exhibited during his first two interviews. When she viewed tapes of the class instruction and the interviews with Tim she realized Tim lacked essential constructs to make sense of her instruction. She subsequently made adjustments in her instruction, making effective use of more appropriate representations based on tasks from the unit that we modified and used with Tim in our interviews. These adjustments helped Tim to construct partitioning operations and an appropriate unit fractional scheme. This study illustrates the importance of coming to understand a student's mathematical activity in terms of possible conceptual schemes and modifying instructional strategies to build on those schemes. The coordinated design of the research study facilitated these instructional modifications.     

Investigating Elementary Teachers' Conceptions of Animal Classification

Numerous studies have been conducted regarding alternative conceptions about animal diversity and classification, many of which have used a cross‐age approach to investigate how students' conceptions change over time. None of these studies, however, have investigated teachers' conceptions of animal classification. This study was intended to augment the findings of past research by exploring the conceptions that elementary teachers possess about animal classification. Using interviews and written items, we documented teachers' conceptions about animal classification and compared them with student conceptions identified in previous research studies. Many of the teachers' conceptions observed in this study were similar to students' conceptions in that they were often too limited or too general compared with scientifically accepted conceptions. Also, the teachers in this study frequently used “non‐defining” characteristics, such as locomotion and habitat, to classify animals. As a result, several misclassifications were observed in the teachers' responses to the written items. Notably, the results of our study demonstrate that teachers often have the same alternative conceptions about animal classification as students. We explore some possible explanations for these alternative conceptions and discuss the instructional implications of the findings.     

Conceptions of mathematics and student identity: implications for engineering education

Lecturers of first-year mathematics often have reason to believe that students enter university studies with naïve conceptions of mathematics and that more mature conceptions need to be developed in the classroom. Students’ conceptions of the nature and role of mathematics in current and future studies as well as future career are pedagogically important as they can impact on student learning and have the potential to influence how and what we teach. As part of ongoing longitudinal research into the experience of a cohort of students registered at the author's institution, students’ conceptions of mathematics were determined using a coding scheme developed elsewhere. In this article, I discuss how the cohort of students choosing to study engineering exhibits a view of mathematics as conceptual skill and as problem-solving, coherent with an accurate understanding of the role of mathematics in engineering. Parallel investigation shows, however, that the students do not embody designated identities as engineers.     

An Integrated Research on Children's Construction of Meaningful,Symbolic, Partitioning-related Conceptions and the Teacher's Role in Fostering That Learning

A teaching experiment was conducted with two fourth graders to study the co-emergence of teaching and children's construction of fraction knowledge. The children's learning, i.e., modifications in their fraction schemes, was fostered through working on tasks in a computer microworld. The children advanced from thinking about a unit fraction as one of several equal parts in a whole (the equipartitioning scheme) to operating with a unit fraction as a symbolized, iterable part the magnitude of which is based on the numerosity of the partitioned whole (the partitive fraction scheme). The paper interweaves an analysis of children's construction of partitioning-related symbolic conceptions of fractions with an analysis of the teaching—planning and using tasks—that fosters such an advancement by introducing fraction words and numerals in the context of the children's partitioning activities.     

Elementary Preservice Teachers’ Transitional Conceptions of Partitive Division with Proper-Fraction Divisors

An understanding of partitive division is foundational for numerous other mathematics topics, including unit rate, slope, and probability. However, research has shown that learners tend to have a limited understanding of partitive division when the divisor is a proper fraction. To extend research on conceptions of partitive division in this study, we used Moschkovich’s (1999) transitional conceptions perspective to examine how conceptions of partitive division evolve. This article reports on preservice teachers’ (PSTs) conceptions of partitive division with proper-fraction divisors before and after they explored partitive division in a mathematics content course for elementary teachers (N = 17). Our analysis of pre- and post-interviews revealed an initial transitional conception and two levels of refinement of their conceptions. Furthermore, we identified two perturbations that PSTs experienced during refinement of their conceptions. By identifying ordered levels of refinement and associated perturbations, this exploratory study extends the transitional conceptions perspective. Furthermore, this study adds new insights into the conceptual complexities that the partitive model for division of fractions presents to PSTs (and to learners in general) and suggests new hypotheses about ways that conceptions of partitive division undergo refinement.     

Pre-service elementary teachers’ strategies for tiling and relating area units

It has been established that preservice elementary school teachers (PSTs) often employ procedural methods when solving measurement problems without conceptual understanding or flexibility, but a significant gap exists in the literature identifying why. Through the lens of discrete and continuous interpretations of area, this study extends the research base by describing strategies PSTs use to tile a two-dimensional space with varying size tiles and what these strategies imply about PSTs’ conceptions of area measurement. These strategies and implied conceptions enable further discussion on the multiple purposes of the area model as an illustrative measure for mathematics throughout the elementary school curriculum.     

Investigating the transformation of a secondary teacher’s knowledge of trigonometric functions

Shulman (1987) defined pedagogical content knowledge as the knowledge required to transform subject-matter knowledge into curricular material and pedagogical representations. This paper presents the results of an exploratory case study that examined a secondary teacher’s knowledge of sine and cosine values in both clinical and professional settings to discern the characteristics of mathematical schemes that facilitate their transformation into learning artifacts and experiences for students. My analysis revealed that the teacher’s knowledge of sine and cosine values consisted of uncoordinated quantitative and arithmetic schemes and that he was cognizant only of the behavioral proficiencies these schemes enable, not the mental actions and conceptual operations they entail. Based on these findings, I hypothesize that the extent to which a teacher is consciously aware of the mental activity that comprises their mathematical conceptions influences their capacity to transform their mathematical knowledge into curricular material and pedagogical representations to effectively support students’ conceptual learning.     

Web‐Based Instruction on Preservice Teachers' Knowledge of Fraction Operations

This study determines whether web‐based instruction (WBI) represents an improved method for helping preservice teachers learn procedural and conceptual knowledge of fractions.. The purpose was to compare the effectiveness of web‐based instruction (WBI) with the traditional lecture in mathematics content and methods for the elementary school course. The results of this study suggest that the use of WBI in learning fractions is more effective. When compared with the traditional instruction, the WBI treatment results were significantly more effective for procedural and conceptual knowledge of fraction operations.     

Students’ conceptions of mathematics as sensible: Towards the SCOMAS framework

In this article I describe the development of a framework for considering students’ conceptions about the sensible nature of mathematics. I begin by using extant literature on conceptions of mathematics to develop a framework of action-oriented indicators that students’ conceive of mathematics as sensible. I then use classroom data to modify and illustrate the framework. The result is a coding framework, grounded in the literature, which can be used to assess the enacted conceptions of mathematics as sensible of a group of students. This work also provides a conceptual framework, grounded in classroom data, of the dimensions of these conceptions.     

Developing conceptions of statistics by designing measures of distribution

Students often learn procedures for measuring, but rarely do they grapple with the foundational conceptual problem of generating and validating coordination between a measure and the phenomenon being measured. Coordinating measures with phenomenon involves developing an appreciation of the objects and relations in each as well as establishing their mutual correspondence. We supported students?? developing conceptions of statistics by positioning them to design measures of center and of variability for distributions that they had generated through repeated measure of a length. After students invented and explored the viability of their measures individually, they participated in a public (whole-class conversation) forum featuring justification and reflection about the viability of their designed measures. We illustrate how individual invention enticed students to attend to, and to make explicit, characteristics of distribution not initially noticed or known only tacitly. Conceptions of statistics and of relevant characteristics of distribution were further expanded as students justified and argued about the utility and prospective generalization of particular inventions. Teachers supported student learning by highlighting prospective relations between characteristics of measures and characteristics of distribution as they emerged during the course of activity in each setting.     

A conceptual pathway to confidence intervals

Finding ways for the majority of students to better understand conventional normal theory-based statistical inference seems to be an intractable problem area for researchers. In this paper we propose a conceptual pathway for developing confidence interval ideas for the one-sample situation only from an intuitive sense to bootstrapping for students from about age 14 to first-year university. We make the case that conceptual development should start early; that probability and statistical instruction should change so that both orientate students towards interconnected stochastic conceptions; and that the use of visual imagery has the potential to stimulate students towards such a perspective. We analyse our conceptual pathway based on a theoretical framework for a stochastic conception of statistical inference based on imagery and some research evidence. Our analysis suggests that the pathway has the potential for students to become conversant with the concepts underpinning inference, to view statistics probabilistically and to integrate concepts into a coherent comprehension of inference.     

Pre-service Teachers’ Developing Conceptions about the Nature and Pedagogy of Mathematical Modeling in the Context of a Mathematical Modeling Course

Adopting a multitiered design-based research perspective, this study examines pre-service secondary mathematics teachers’ developing conceptions about (a) the nature of mathematical modeling in simulations of “real life” problem solving, and (b) pedagogical principles and strategies needed to teach mathematics through modeling. Unlike other studies that have focused on single-topic and lesson-sized research sites, a course-sized research site was used in this study. Having been through several iterations over three teaching semesters, the 15-week long course was implemented with 25 pre-service secondary mathematics teachers. Findings revealed that pre-service teachers developed ideas about the nature of mathematical modeling involving what mathematical modeling is, the relationship between mathematical modeling and meaningful understanding, and the nature of mathematical modeling tasks. They also realized the changing roles of teachers during modeling implementations and diversity in students’ ways of thinking. The researchers’ conceptual development, on the other hand, involved realizing the critical aspect of the “teacher role” played by the instructor during modeling implementations, and the need for more experience of modeling implementations for pre-service teachers.     

From “everything changes” to “for high numbers, it changes just a bit”

This paper presents theoretical notions developed in a design research study for investigating the development of students?? conceptions within a learning environment for grade 6. The study was designed to give opportunities to learn about random data showing patterns in the long run while being haphazard in the short term. By an in-depth analysis, we have investigated the microprocesses of constructing meanings of short-term and long-term behaviour and of attempting to relate them to each other. We have identified different patterns of microprocesses such as negotiating the scope of applicability in terms of situational or stochastic contexts. These patterns can??as empirically grounded theoretical notions??refine the conceptual change approach by providing tools for describing students?? learning trajectories and potential obstacles in stochastics.     

Teacher and students’ joint production of a reversible fraction conception

Within a constructivist perspective, I conducted a teaching experiment with two fourth graders to study how a teacher and students can jointly produce the reversible fraction conception. Ongoing and retrospective analysis of the data revealed the non-trivial process by which students can abstract multiplicative reasoning about fractions. The study articulates a conception in a developmental sequence of iteration-based fraction conceptions and the teacher’s role in fostering such a conception in students.     

What do mathematicians mean by proof? A comparative-judgement study of students’ and mathematicians’ views

We present a study in which mathematicians and undergraduate students were asked to explain in writing what mathematicians mean by proof. The 175 responses were evaluated using comparative judgement: mathematicians compared pairs of responses and their judgements were used to construct a scaled rank order. We provide evidence establishing the reliability, divergent validity and content validity of this approach to investigating individuals’ written conceptions of mathematical proof. In doing so, we compare the quality of student and mathematician responses and identify which features the judges collectively valued. Substantively, our findings reveal that despite the variety of views in the literature, mathematicians broadly agree on what people should say when asked what mathematicians mean by proof. Methodologically, we provide evidence that comparative judgement could have an important role to play in investigating conceptions of mathematical ideas, and conjecture that similar methods could be productive in evaluating individuals’ more general (mathematical) beliefs.