From the principle of bijection to the isomorphism of structures: an analysis of some teaching paradigms in discrete mathematics

This paper is concerned with the teaching of Discrete Mathematics to university undergraduate students. Two to three decades ago this course became a requirement for math and computer science students in most universities world wide. Today this course is taken by students in many other disciplines as well. The paper begins with a discussion of a few topics that we feel should be included in the syllabus for any course in Discrete Mathematics, independent of the audience. We then discuss several potential models for teaching the course, depending upon the interests and mathematical background of the audience. We also investigate various educational links with other components of the curriculum, consider pedagogical issues associated with the teaching of discrete mathematics, and discuss some logistical and psychological difficulties that must be overcome. A special emphasis is placed on the role of textbooks.     

模糊数学精品课程建设与实践

模糊数学课程是我校各专业研究生的一门重要的公共基础课,实施模糊数学核心课程建设,对于深化教学改革、提高教学质量以及培养研究生的实践能力和创新能力起着极其重要的作用,从模糊数学课程性质、目的和任务人手,较详细地阐述了模糊数学课程的教学内容、体系,教学模式和手段等系列改革以及模糊数学课程建设中取得的显著成效。     

Journey toward Teaching Mathematics through Problem Solving

Teaching mathematics through problem solving is a challenge for teachers who learned mathematics by doing exercises. How do teachers develop their own problem solving abilities as well as their abilities to teach mathematics through problem solving? A group of teachers began the journey of learning to teach through problem solving while taking a Teaching Elementary School Mathematics graduate course. This course was designed to engage teachers in problem solving during class meetings and required them to do problem solving action research in their classrooms. Although challenged by the course problem solving work, teachers became more comfortable with the mathematics and recognized the importance of group work while problem solving. As they worked with their students, teachers were more confident in their students' abilities to be successful problem solvers. For some teachers, a strong problem solving foundation was established. For others, the foundation was more tentative.     

An Experiment in Teaching College Mathematics†

Kac has observed that the ideal preparation in mathematics, especially for non‐mathematicians, should focus not on acquiring skills but on acquiring certain attitudes. We administered a special attitude questionnaire to a sample of graduate students in mathematics and undergraduate speech majors. We found significant differences on 10 of 27 items on this test. We then administered this test to a mixed group of undergraduates at the beginning and at the end of a special experimental mathematics ‘course’ designed to modify and shape attitudes. We found changes in attitudes in the intended direction. The primary aims of the experimental course were to:

1. Get students without any prior acquaintance with mathematics or a fear thereof to approach their studies more analytically.

2. Acquire orientation to and acquaintance with 25‐75 basic concepts and methods covering sets, algebra, logic, computers, analysis, probability, math‐statistics and topology in an over‐all map of how they logically fit together and how they relate to problems of modern life.

3. Read, with appreciation, mathematical literature previously incomprehensible to them. These aims were met.

     

Mathematical Sociology: Some Educational and Organizational Problems of an Emergent Sub‐Discipline

Three major areas of mathematical sociology are critically reviewed: analysis of measurement, statistical analysis and model building. Next, some social problems, created by the introduction of mathematics into sociology, are discussed. These include the emergence of inflated expectations for mathematical sociology which are subsequently disappointed, and the potential status threat which mathematical sociology poses for non‐mathematical sociologists. Examples of mathematical applications in the construction of causal models, population projection and the analysis of stability in social groups are discussed. Following this, the role of mathematics in the education of undergraduate sociology majors is considered. Neither mathematics nor statistics should be required of such persons, but they should be encouraged to acquire a mathematical background if interested. Statistics should, however, be required of sociology graduate students. The graduate training of mathematical sociologists should emphasize research over course work. An apprenticeship relationship with a faculty member working in mathematical sociology is highly desirable for these students. A substantive specialty is also useful since it enables mathematical sociologists to stay in contact with mainstream sociology. Emphasis is placed on the function of present research in legitimating future expanded mathematical education of sociologists.     

The impact of instructor pedagogy on college calculus students’ attitude toward mathematics

College calculus teaches students important mathematical concepts and skills. The course also has a substantial impact on students’ attitude toward mathematics, affecting their career aspirations and desires to take more mathematics. This national US study of 3103 students at 123 colleges and universities tracks changes in students’ attitudes toward mathematics during a ‘mainstream’ calculus course while controlling for student backgrounds. The attitude measure combines students’ self-ratings of their mathematics confidence, interest in, and enjoyment of mathematics. Three major kinds of instructor pedagogy, identified through the factor analysis of 61 student-reported variables, are investigated for impact on student attitude as follows: (1) instructors who employ generally accepted ‘good teaching’ practices (e.g. clarity in presentation and answering questions, useful homework, fair exams, help outside of class) are found to have the most positive impact, particularly with students who began with a weaker initial attitude. (2) Use of educational ‘technology’ (e.g. graphing calculators, for demonstrations, in homework), on average, is found to have no impact on attitudes, except when used by graduate student instructors, which negatively affects students’ attitudes towards mathematics. (3) ‘Ambitious teaching’ (e.g. group work, word problems, ‘flipped’ reading, student explanations of thinking) has a small negative impact on student attitudes, while being a relatively more constructive influence only on students who already enjoyed a positive attitude toward mathematics and in classrooms with a large number of students. This study provides support for efforts to improve calculus teaching through the training of faculty and graduate students to use traditional ‘good teaching’ practices through professional development workshops and courses. As currently implemented, technology and ambitious pedagogical practices, while no doubt effective in certain classrooms, do not appear to have a reliable, positive impact on student attitudes toward mathematics.     

Computer‐enhanced algebra resources: their effects on achievement and attitudes [1]

Findings from this study indicate that the use of computer-enhanced resources throughout an entire algebra course had no significant effect on algebra achievement, attitudes toward mathematics, and attitudes toward the instructional setting. Differences in ability did have a significant effect upon algebra achievement but did not significantly affect attitudes toward mathematics and the instructional setting. During the study, high- and average-ability students had a significant improvement in their attitudes toward computers. High-ability students were more reluctant to accept computers in the algebra course than average-ability students. An important finding of this study is that computer-related assignments can be given weekly throughout an entire course in second-year algebra without taking time and topics from the algebra content.     

Reading mathematics for understanding—From novice to expert

As students progress through the college mathematics curriculum, enter graduate school and eventually become practicing mathematicians, reading mathematics textbooks and journal articles appears to become easier and leads to increased proficiency and understanding. This study was designed to begin to understand how mathematically more advanced readers read for understanding in mathematical exposition as it appears in textbooks compared to first-year undergraduate students. Three faculty members and three graduate students participated in this study and read from a first-year graduate textbook in an area of mathematics unfamiliar to each of them. The observed reading strategies of these more mathematically advanced readers are compared to observed reading strategies of first-year undergraduate students from an earlier study. The reading methods of the faculty level mathematicians were all quite similar and were markedly different from those that have been identified for undergraduate students, as well as from those used by the graduate students in this study. A Mathematics Reading Framework is proposed based on this study and previous research documenting the strategies that first-year undergraduate students use for reading exposition in their mathematics textbooks.     

Discrete mathematics in primary and secondary schools in the United States

This article provides a status report on discrete mathematics in America's schools, including an overview of publications and programs that have had major impact. It discusses why discrete mathematics should be introduced in the schools and the authors' efforts to advocate, facilitate, and support the adoption of discrete mathematics topics in the schools. Their perspective is that discrete mathematics should be viewed not only as a collection of new and interesting mathematical topics, but, more importantly, as a vehicle for providing teachers with a new way to think about traditional mathematical topics and new strategies for engaging their students in the study of mathematics.     

Pre- and in-service teachers’ perceived value of an experimental real analysis course for teachers

Prospective secondary mathematics teachers are usually required to complete several university advanced mathematics courses before being certified to teach secondary mathematics. However, teachers usually do not find these courses to be valuable for their teaching. We designed an experimental real analysis course with the goal of making real analysis content useful and relevant to teaching. Our approach was to ground the real analysis content in pedagogical situations that problematized a secondary mathematics topic, where the nuances of teaching secondary mathematics could be informed by the real analysis that was covered. The experimental course was implemented in a graduate teacher education programme with 32 pre- and in-service teachers (PISTs). After the course, we conducted focus group interviews with 20 of these PISTs to get feedback on how the course was valuable to their teaching practice. Many PISTs found the course to be valuable for teaching secondary mathematics, as well as for their understanding of secondary mathematics and real analysis.     

Interesting Science and Mathematics Graduate Students in Secondary Teaching

State and national initiatives attempt to increase the quantity and quality of secondary mathematics and science teachers. Research suggests that if one could appeal to something inside of people or about the process of teaching and learning itself, then one might draw current mathematics and science graduate students into secondary teaching. This study placed eight mathematics and science graduate students in secondary schools for ten hours a week. Pre‐ and post‐measures of their interest level in becoming secondary teachers were made. Overall, graduate students decreased in their desire to become secondary teachers. The main reasons were (1) fellows wanted to work with higher‐level mathematics and science; (2) fellows felt students were not behaved and unmotivated; (3) fellows did not view being a teacher as a career, but only as a job; and (4) fellows felt school systems had to do too many things that fellows did not want to do.     

Problems and Possibilities with Teaching Introductory Statistics to Social Scientists

As undergraduates, many social scientists take only one introductory course in statistics, and this paper concentrates mainly on the various issues involved in teaching such a course. Among the topics discussed are: the aims of the course; the problem of students’ varying mathematical backgrounds and abilities, and in particular the very low level of mathematics of a significant number of them; the question of a common course for all social sciences, and the differing needs of the various subjects; who should teach introductory statistics; the problem of developing students’ motivation to study statistics; the use of practical work; the possibilities of the computer; the utility of programmed texts and teaching machines. The intention of the paper is to provide a framework for the seminar by a broad review of the topics, a number of which are discussed in detail in subsequent sessions.     

Introducing Differential Calculus

In this paper we discuss three ways of introducing calculus all based on concepts which students would either already know or which can be introduced without much difficulty at this stage of their mathematical training. The aim of this paper is to persuade teachers of mathematics that topics in ‘higher mathematics’, specifically calculus, can and should be presented to students in terms of concepts with which they are familiar.     

The effectiveness of resources created by students as partners in explaining the relevance of mathematics in engineering education

First-year engineering students often struggle to see the relevance of theoretical mathematical concepts for their future studies and professional careers. This is an issue, as students who do not see relevance in fundamental parts of their studies may disengage from these parts and focus their efforts on other subjects they think will be more useful to them. In this study, we surveyed engineering students enrolled in a first-year mathematics subject on their perceptions of the relevance of the individual mathematical topics taught. Surveys were administered at the start of semester when some of these topics were unknown to them, and again at the end of semester when students had not only studied all these topics but also watched a set of animated videos. These videos had been produced by higher-year students to explain where they had seen applications of the mathematical concepts presented in the first year. We notice differences between the perceived relevance of topics for future study and for professional careers, with relevance to study rated higher than relevance to careers. We also find that the animations are seen as helpful in understanding the relevance of first-year mathematics. The majority of students indicated that lecturers with students as partners should work collaboratively to produce future videos.     

Students’ experiences with mathematics teaching and learning: listening to unheard voices

This study documents students’ views about the nature of mathematics, the mathematics learning process and factors within the classroom that are perceived to impact upon the learning of mathematics. The participants were senior secondary school students. Qualitative and quantitative methods were used to understand the students’ views about their experiences with mathematics learning and mathematics classroom environment. Interviews of students and mathematics lesson observations were analysed to understand how students view their mathematics classes. A questionnaire was used to solicit students’ views with regards to teaching approaches in mathematics classes. The results suggest that students consider learning and understanding mathematics to mean being successful in getting the correct answers. Students reported that in the majority of cases, the teaching of mathematics was lecture-oriented. Mathematics language was considered a barrier in learning some topics in mathematics. The use of informal language was also evident during mathematics class lessons.     

An Outlook in Teaching and Research in Mathematics in Educational Institutions

The present paper outlines some basic principles upon which an outlook in teaching and research in mathematics in educational institutions can be developed. Defining applied mathematics, the author analyses the basic topics of mathematics which permeate throughout the wider fields and diversified aspects of this branch of mathematical science.

For the institutions of learning, a course curriculum has been proposed which will gradually motivate, orient and prepare individuals through the process of learning to understand the methods and techniques, so as to apply them to physical problems. This has been illustrated in the fields of fluid dynamics and aerodynamics through the analysis of complex function theory and differential equations.

Because of the frustrating situations prevailing amongst students and teachers in the institutions of learning in the present day, a critical analysis has been made to identify the respective roles of the academicians and administrators, and with a view to improving the situation, some remedy has been suggested regarding teaching and research in educational institutions.     

Technological Aids in the Teaching of Mathematics∗

In learning mathematics a relationship needs to be known as a detail and this also needs to be understood relative to the over‐all pattern and structure of mathematics. For some users of mathematics, techniques can be developed for presenting formulae sequentially so that they are available for term‐by‐term substitution, but the needs of creative mathematical thinkers are not met in this way. Present human resources are one mathematics graduate per 500 secondary school pupils and one mathematics graduate per 1300 students in further education. There is a pressing need to supplement these teaching resources by aids made available by educational technology, and also for research into suitable student terminals. Sequentially presented material is already available but there is a great need for visual material which can be presented synoptically. It is suggested that a steering team could mobilize many units where there are mathematicians and audio‐visual facilities to provide a large library of linking sequences to be available at computer‐controlled student terminals, relating each formula or relationship to other aspects of mathematics so that its place in the whole structure of mathematics is presented. Examples are given. There is also a need to devote some resources to the study of the effectiveness of particular diagrams and the order of presentation of visual materials since some current researches indicate these may be critical factors.

     

Seeking mathematics success for college students: a randomized field trial of an adapted approach

Many students enter the Canadian college system with insufficient mathematical ability and leave the system with little improvement. Those students who enter with poor mathematics ability typically take a developmental mathematics course as their first and possibly only mathematics course. The educational experiences that comprise a developmental mathematics course vary widely and are, too often, ineffective at improving students’ ability. This trend is concerning, since low mathematics ability is known to be related to lower rates of success in subsequent courses. To date, little attention has been paid to the selection of an instructional approach to consistently apply across developmental mathematics courses. Prior research suggests that an appropriate instructional method would involve explicit instruction and practising mathematical procedures linked to a mathematical concept. This study reports on a randomized field trial of a developmental mathematics approach at a college in Ontario, Canada. The new approach is an adaptation of the JUMP Math program, an explicit instruction method designed for primary and secondary school curriculae, to the college learning environment. In this study, a subset of courses was assigned to JUMP Math and the remainder was taught in the same style as in the previous years. We found consistent, modest improvement in the JUMP Math sections compared to the non-JUMP sections, after accounting for potential covariates. The findings from this randomized field trial, along with prior research on effective education for developmental mathematics students, suggest that JUMP Math is a promising way to improve college student outcomes.     

Investigating and ordering Quadrilaterals and their analogies in space—problem fields with various aspects

Problem fields with one or two generating problems and possibilities of varying existing problems give a good chance for self-activities of students and can be used for reaching different general aims. In this paper some topics concerning quadrilaterals will be presented. I hope they will animate teachers for more problem orientation in mathematics education. First we will reflect about different types of convex and non-convex quadrilaterals and possibilities of ordering them. Then we focus on middle-quadrilaterals and types of quadrilaterals with special middle-quadrilaterals as well as their logical ordering. Finally we investigate the analogies in space to the parallelogram and its sub-types and order them in the “house of parallelepipeds”.