Mathematics,Applicable versus Pure‐and‐Applied

‘Applicable mathematics’ is based on the idea that mathematics provides a source of models of proposed and postulated states of affairs. The use of the model is essentially to simulate exploration of the possibilities of the situation to which the model relates. Two main areas where this ‘investigation of the implications of possibilities’ is needed are in discussing putative scientific hypotheses and in discussing the implications of proposed or suggested social and technical innovation. Much of what has been customarily called ‘pure mathematics’ can be regarded as second‐order applicable mathematics, i.e. mathematics which adds to and strengthens our over‐all model building capability.

     

Mathematic education in a cultural setting

The paper develops some proposals for curriculum development in mathematics based on an analysis of the intercultural transmission of mathematical knowledge. By introducing a concept of culture which calls for an analysis of individual and social behaviours, we are lead to recognize ‘ethnomathematics’ as a form of structured knowledge and to recognize ‘matheracy’ as a characteristic behaviour of human beings. Upon these two concepts, we introduce a theoretical framework for curriculum development in mathematics.

Curricular space is conceptualized as a three‐dimensional space with components, contents, methods and objectives considered solidarily. This relies upon an epistemology of action, based on an integration of episteme, techne and praxis. This allows for an approach in which theory and practice are in a dialectical relationship. Special reference is made to the problems of mathematical education for culturally differentiated groups, and in particular to the situation in third‐world countries.     

Mathematics capital in the educational field: Bourdieu and beyond

Mathematics education needs a better appreciation of the dominant power structures in the educational field: Bourdieu's theory of capital provides a good starting point. We argue from Bourdieu's perspective that school mathematics provides capital that is finely tuned to generationally reproduce the social structures that serve to keep the powerful in power, while ensuring that less powerful groups are led to accept their own failure in mathematics. Bourdieu's perspective thereby highlights theoretical inadequacies in much mathematics education research, insofar as it presumes a consensus about a ‘what works agenda’ for improving achievement for all. Drawing on one case where we manufactured awkward facts, we illustrate a Bourdieusian interpretation of mathematics capital as reproductive, and the crucial role of its cultural arbitrary. We then criticise the Bourdieusian concept of ‘mathematical capital’ as the value of mathematical competence in practice and propose to extend his tools to include the contradictory ‘use’ and ‘exchange’ values of mathematics instead: we will show how this conceptualisation goes ‘beyond Bourdieu’ and helps explain how teaching-learning might (ideally) produce ‘cultural use value’ in mathematical competence, while still recognising the contradictions teachers and learners face. Finally, we suggest how critical education research generally can benefit from this theoretical framework: (1) in exposing the interest of the dominant classes; but also (2) in researching critical pedagogic alternatives that challenge orthodoxy in educational policy and practice both in mathematics education and more generally.     

To be or not to be constructive,that is not the question

In the early twentieth century, L.E.J. Brouwer pioneered a new philosophy of mathematics, called intuitionism. Intuitionism was revolutionary in many respects but stands out – mathematically speaking – for its challenge of Hilbert’s formalist philosophy of mathematics and rejection of the law of excluded middle from the ‘classical’ logic used in mainstream mathematics. Out of intuitionism grew intuitionistic logic and the associated Brouwer–Heyting–Kolmogorov interpretation by which ‘there exists $x$’ intuitively means ‘an algorithm to compute $x$ is given’. A number of schools of constructive mathematics were developed, inspired by Brouwer’s intuitionism and invariably based on intuitionistic logic, but with varying interpretations of what constitutes an algorithm. This paper deals with the dichotomy between constructive and non-constructive mathematics, or rather the absence of such an ‘excluded middle’. In particular, we challenge the ‘binary’ view that mathematics is either constructive or not. To this end, we identify a part of classical mathematics, namely classical Nonstandard Analysis, and show it inhabits the twilight-zone between the constructive and non-constructive. Intuitively, the predicate ‘$x$ is standard’ typical of Nonstandard Analysis can be interpreted as ‘$x$ is computable’, giving rise to computable (and sometimes constructive) mathematics obtained directly from classical Nonstandard Analysis. Our results formalise Osswald’s longstanding conjecture that classical Nonstandard Analysis is locally constructive. Finally, an alternative explanation of our results is provided by Brouwer’s thesis that logic depends upon mathematics.     

Teaching Children to be Mathematicians Versus Teaching About Mathematics

The important difference between the work of a child in an elementary mathematics class and that of a mathematician is not in the subject matter (old fashioned numbers versus groups or categories or whatever) but in the fact that the mathematician is creatively engaged in the pursuit of a personally meaningful project. In this respect a child's work in an art class is often close to that of a grown‐up artist. The paper presents the results of some mathematical research guided by the goal of producing mathematical concepts and topics to close this gap. The prime example used here is ‘Turtle Geometry’, which is concerned with programming a moving point to generate geometric forms. By embodying the moving point as a ‘cybernetic turtle’ controlled by an actual computer, the constructive aspects of the theory come out sufficiently to capture the minds and imaginations of almost all the elementary school children with whom we have worked—including some at the lowest levels of previous mathematical performance.

     

‘New mathematics’ and teaching

Inside the scientific world it is not always understood that the mood of mathematics, which is a product and a part of culture, can change with time. This is partly why many have been surprised by the coming of the so‐called new mathematics.

In the truly creative mathematical mind two opposite tendencies coexist: the logical and the imaginative. Apparently it seems that new mathematics can be reduced to a purely logical machinery. In fact it contains as much imaginative contributions as classical mathematics. But it is difficult to show simultaneously the logical sequence of propositions and the clumsy progression of research itself. Mathematical exposition does not always follow the ‘ most natural slopes’ of the mind. Unfamiliar presentations often give an impression of ‘ abstraction ‘, more familiar ones an impression of concreteness ‘.

So it appears that difficulties with new mathematics are mostly of psychological origin. Misuses of it can easily raise up intolerance reactions and emotional blocks. Perhaps insisting upon the fact that, here as elsewhere, it is important to be able to guess, to realize that intuition and imagination are essential, could help to make new mathematics better understood, more useful and more able to be considered as a unifing element among sciences.     

An Experiment in Teaching College Mathematics†

Kac has observed that the ideal preparation in mathematics, especially for non‐mathematicians, should focus not on acquiring skills but on acquiring certain attitudes. We administered a special attitude questionnaire to a sample of graduate students in mathematics and undergraduate speech majors. We found significant differences on 10 of 27 items on this test. We then administered this test to a mixed group of undergraduates at the beginning and at the end of a special experimental mathematics ‘course’ designed to modify and shape attitudes. We found changes in attitudes in the intended direction. The primary aims of the experimental course were to:

1. Get students without any prior acquaintance with mathematics or a fear thereof to approach their studies more analytically.

2. Acquire orientation to and acquaintance with 25‐75 basic concepts and methods covering sets, algebra, logic, computers, analysis, probability, math‐statistics and topology in an over‐all map of how they logically fit together and how they relate to problems of modern life.

3. Read, with appreciation, mathematical literature previously incomprehensible to them. These aims were met.

     

To what extent are students expected to participate in specialised mathematical discourse? Change over time in school mathematics in England

ABSTRACT

From a discursive perspective, differences in the language in which mathematics questions are posed change the nature of the mathematics with which students are expected to engage. The project The Evolution of the Discourse of School Mathematics (EDSM) analysed the discourse of mathematics examination papers set in the UK between 1980 and 2011. In this article we address the issue of how students over this period have been expected to engage with the specialised discourse of school mathematics. We explain our analytic methods and present some outcomes of the analysis. We identify changes in engagement with algebraic manipulation, proving, relating mathematics to non-mathematical contexts and making connections between specialised mathematical objects. These changes are discussed in the light of public and policy domain debates about ‘standards’ of examinations.     

How is cultural influence manifested in the formation of mathematics textbooks? A comparative case study of resource book series between Shanghai and England

Focusing on issues about the development of mathematics textbooks from a cultural perspective, this study examined a widely-used curriculum resource series, One Lesson One Exercise, published in China, and its adapted English series, published in the UK, to explore how cultural influence is manifested in the two series of resource books. For the study we established a conceptual framework classifying culture into six types in relation to people’s beliefs, values and ways of interacting about them, for data collection and analysis. The results indicate that there exist considerable differences between the Chinese and the English series that are related to cultural factors. It appears that, to a large extent, culture plays an essential role in the development of mathematics textbooks. Concerning the different types of culture, the results show that most adaptations between the Chinese series and the English series are related to ‘ways of behaving and customs’ and ‘artifacts, flora and fauna’, followed by ‘identities’ and ‘geography’, and the least are related to ‘organisations’ and ‘history’. Based on the study, we argue that the relevance and importance of culture to the development of mathematics textbooks must not be underestimated, and more research in this direction is needed.     

Development of an attitude-towards-using-mathematics scale for high-school students and an analysis of student attitudes

ABSTRACT

This research has been carried out in two stages and has two main objectives. The first aim of the study is to develop a Likert-type scale which is used to determine the attitudes towards the use of mathematics in real life. The second aim is to examine the attitudes of high school students about the use of mathematics in real life according to different variables used in the developed scale. The research was carried out according to the correlational research method, and the participants comprise the sample of 340 and 356 students for the scale development and implementation stages of the study, respectively. As a result of the research, a structure consisting of 23 items and three sub-factors was determined for the scale. In the second stage of the study, it was observed that the student attitudes were at the level corresponding to the ‘undecided’ option of the scale, and they differed significantly according to gender and grade level variables. In addition, it was found that there was a positive and significant relationship between the students’ attitudes towards the use of mathematics and their mathematics achievement.     

Variations on a theme: introducing new representations of fraction into two classrooms

Abstract

The interplay between generalisations and particular instances—examples—is an essential feature of mathematics teaching and learning. In this paper, we bring together our experiences of personal and classroom mathematics activity, and demonstrate that examples do not always fulfil their intended purpose (to point to generalisations). A distinction is drawn between ‘empirical’ and ‘structural’ generalisation, and the role of generic examples is discussed as a means of supporting the second of these qualities of generalisation.     

‘The unplanned impact of mathematics’ and its implications for research funding: a discussion-led educational activity

‘The unplanned impact of mathematics’ refers to mathematics which has an impact that was not planned by its originator, either as pure maths that finds an application or applied maths that finds an unexpected one. This aspect of mathematics has serious implications when increasingly researchers are asked to predict the impact of their research before it is funded and research quality is measured partly by its short term impact.

A session on this topic has been used in a UK undergraduate mathematics module that aims to consider topics in the history of mathematics and examine how maths interacts with wider society. First, this introduced the ‘unplanned impact’ concept through historical examples. Second, it provoked discussion of the concept through a fictionalized blog comments discussion thread giving different views on the development and utility of mathematics. Finally, a mock research funding activity encouraged a pragmatic view of how research funding is planned and funded.

The unplanned impact concept and the structure and content of the taught session are described.     

The Erlanger Programm of Felix Klein: Reflections on its place in the history of mathematics

The commonly held view that Klein's Erlanger Programm was one of the most significant and influential works for the history of mathematics during the half-century following its publication in 1872 is questioned on the grounds that insufficient attention has been paid to the complex web of related mathematical activities of the period. By sketching some of these that are connected with Lie and his school, we present a first approximation to a more informed assessment of the place of the Erlanger Programm in the history of mathematics.     

Measuring K‐8 Teachers' Perceptions of Discourse Use in Their Mathematics Classes

This article documents the development and use of a survey instrument designed to measure K‐8 mathematics teachers ‘perceptions about discourse in mathematics classes. In particular, the 5‐point Likert‐type survey sought to address teachers ‘perceptions of their use of dialogic (dialogue to construct new meaning), univocal (conveying information), and general discourse in their mathematics classes. Factor analysis revealed three reliable factors that were compatible with the original constructs, these include: dialogic discourse (α₃= .67), univocal discourse (α₁= .83), and general discourse (α₂= .68). These results suggest a framework that could be used to uncover K‐8 teachers' perceptions of their use of discourse in mathematics instruction, especially if there is interest in tendencies toward univocal or dialogic discourse. In addition to research implications, the survey could be used to inform the design and implementation of teacher professional development that focuses on discourse in mathematics instruction.     

Aims and Objectives in the Teaching of Mathematics to non‐Mathematicians∗

After a discussion on what is a non‐mathematician and what is an applied mathematician, aims that have been variously suggested are presented and discussed. Attention is drawn to the importance of an understanding of model building and of mathematics as the language of science, and this leads to a plea for co‐operation between the mathematician and the non‐mathematician. Reference is made to the relevance of the ‘New Mathematics’ and to the demand for mathematical rigour, and the paper closes with a brief discussion of the importance of detailed objectives.

     

‘Re’-presenting qualitative data from multilingual mathematics classrooms

In this paper I consider what it means to ‘re’-present qualitative data from multilingual mathematics classrooms. I draw from a recent study that focused on language practices in multilingual mathematics classrooms to explore the different levels involved in the ‘re’-presentation of multilingual data. The purpose of the paper is not to discuss the details of the study but to use data from the study to raise the awareness of the conceptual underpinnings of data re-presentation in mathematics education research. I use the data to show one perspective to ‘re’-presentation of multilingual data. The main argument of the paper is that ‘re’-presentation of multilingual data is not just talk written down, it is inevitably a process of selection and is informed by theory, research questions, tools of analysis and the purposes of re-presenting the data.     

Mathematics,Science of Possibility ‐‐ A Critical Review

This paper supports the view that search for the applicative standpoint in mathematical education has yet to be sufficiently exploited. Mathematical propositions are considered to have both an ‘internal’ and ‘external’ role and thus a system of ‘potential models’ is evolved. Despite the stress on the applicative nature of the subject it is argued in conclusion that the position in the body of the paper is compatible with the synthetic apriority of mathematics.

     

Measurement as relational,intensive and analogical: Towards a minor mathematics

Minor mathematics refers to the mathematical practices that are often erased by state-sanctioned curricular images of mathematics. We use the idea of a minor mathematics to explore alternative measurement practices. We argue that minor measurement practices have been buried by a ‘major’ settler mathematics, a process of erasure that distributes ‘sensibility’ and formulates conditions of mathematics dis/ability. We emphasize how measuring involves the making and mixing of analogies, and that this involves attending to intensive relationships rather than extensive properties. Our philosophical and historical approach moves from the archeological origins of human measurement activity, to pivotal developments in modern mathematics, to configurations of curriculum. We argue that the project of proliferating multiple mathematics is required in order to disturb narrow (and perhaps white, western, male) images of mathematics—and to open up opportunities for a more pluralist and inclusive school mathematics.     

The Role of Heuristic Proof in Mathematics Teaching

With the great emphasis now being placed on the importance of ‘rigour’ in new mathematics programmes, many educators have been led to disparage intuition as the vitally important tool that it is in developing mathematical insights. Increasingly one sees evidence, even in technical schools, of pupils actually being discouraged from arriving at mathematical perceptions through unorthodox (and uncontrollable!) channels of analogy involving considerable divergent thinking or through consideration of physical models with which they are familiar.

As a mathematician, this pre‐occupation with ‘purism’ greatly disturbs the author. Mathematicians do not create through the formal apparatus ‐‐ they only apply formalism after ‘guessing’ results intuitionally. We have become overconcerned with the way the package is wrapped and less concerned with what is in it. Especially, the role of heuristic argument is widely misunderstood and misused in schools and colleges. The author hopes that this article will help to rectify this sorry state of affairs.